Added: 8 months ago
From: BberiBubbles5
Views: 327,686
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (511)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Honestly, after watching all versions: IU hit the low notes perfectly. Hyorin hit the high notes perfectly. Insooni's version was pure perfection. Just my opinion tho.

  • เพราะจังเลยครับ

    i don't understand what she sing . but i can feel her heart .

  • I like iu version but when it's comes to high note i prefer Hyorin i love her husky voice ^_^ ♥

  • omg.. i have GOOSE bumps.. o.o SO AMAZHING!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • what is this for?

  • goosebumps.

  • hyorin and insooni's voice are soo similar both husky... but i still think the original sings it the best because it's their song...

  • i can't stop pressing the replay button

    i <3 her voice

  • hyorin sang emotionally and drew everyone in

    i loved it

    at first i couldnt hear because she sang really low i can imagin listening to it that way

  • yoseob love her voice hyorin!!

  • love her voice.. <3

  • 1:07 best moment of the video

  • Okay I have to put aside the fact I love Hyorin's voice, but it is hard to not compare to alot of popular kpop artists out there, especially female idols. Hyorin's high not is sooo different from the rest of kpop female. If you listen to IU which is mentioned alot in here, her high not is not so smooth as well with, Jieun from secret, Taeyeon which alot may say she is a power house, but I beg the differ. The Davichi girls, they have nice voice but those high notes, NAW..okay I am tired of typing

  • whys everyone comparing iu to hyorin? :L they both hav different voices that are amazing in its own way .

  • Her voice is strong and powerful but its not the kind i like to listen to... i perfer IU sweet and soothing voice

  • in my opinion , iu better than hyorin to sing ballad song , hyorin much better than iu to sing like a playfull song (i don't know the name ) . because iu have a sweet voice , hyorin has a power voice

  • when u compare hyorin to iu its like comparing taeyeon to jessica. In terms of vocals there completer opposite. IU has a unique high pitch voice meanwhile hyorin is ment to show off her strong and powerful voice.

  • i agree with minyong...but i feel IU voice is nicer

  • Which ep is this?

  • OOOH , i crie, she's a great voice !

  • the difference is not hyorin's power and IU's clarity and perfection.....the difference is hyorin's heart, and how much heart she puts into her songs. The delivery is not just pure power or cleaniness, it's about feeling the song and putting it thru to listeners, the pain the hurt the joy the anger.....this is something i've never seen from IU yet...

  • @isftish true that....iu's version lacksthat emotion. i wouldn't dare say she didn't put any in it at all, but i feel like she doesn't fully know and understand what she's singing about therefore the lack of emotion?

  • @rosey9cheeks i've watched other IU videos, like those talent show before she became famous....she can sing, but seems that she just delivers the song, but she doesn't get the heart of the song. Just straight plain singing.

  • @isftish yup. took the words right out of my mouth. :)

  • I admit that her voice is really powerful, and she is one of the best singer out there, but her voice is just not my type that I can listen to all the time...

  • seriously you people bias me against hyorin by saying stuff like she's better than IU even though it was a great performance. just stop it so i can enjoy my music

  • HYORIN >3

  • wooww, hyorin has a beautiful voice, really love her so much...I dream about someday i will sing together with her :)

  • Could someone please tell me the context of this video? I saw a flash of IU's face; what is this?

  • @the100blogger this is from a show called immortal song 2. this is just a cut from ep. 1

  • QUE BELLA VOZ

  • sohyang is still the best in performing this song............

  • her voice is really strong! i like iu and her voice is also strong but not enough to win over hyorin! still iu is cute and i like her! both of them have such a deep and strong vocale <3<3<3

  • What show is this ??

  • @ipwn194

    immortal song 2

  • She puts lots of emotions here, I don't know what you people are talking about...Don't talk down on Hyorin just because you're an bigger IU fan

  • i like hyorin's voice.. junjaa~~ i hope shee sings more in Dream High 2

  • I love all the zooming in on the unsuspecting people. Yoseob looked stunned haha ^_^

  • do people even know what emotions are? in order to be a good musician (which hyorin is) you have to put emotion into almost everything you perform. hyorin quite clearly puts emotion into everything, listen to her music with your eyes closed and you can just feel it. IUs version is great too, but why is everyone comparing the two? no two covers are ever going to sound the same and i'd love love love to see all you judgemental freaks sing a song of this standard and pull it off.

  • @Zigglee I agree with most of what you said but people can critique something objectively without actually participating in that field. What counts is If you have the knowledge to back up one's claim.

  • the starting was a little bit low

  • She really did good on this song. Its kinda true that even IU can't beat her singing this song

  • @Tamagatchi55 sohyang can definitely beat her vocal in singing tis song.............

  • I. . .honestly can't see what everyone is saying about Hyorin lacking in emotion in this song. There are parts where her voice almost breaks because it sounds like she's about to start crying all throughout the song, and her facials are consistent with the song during most of the performance! Maybe it's just me. . .but I honestly thought that Hyorin showed a LOT of emotion in this song.

  • insooni version owns all. nuff said

  • Hyorin has a beautiful voice but sometimes her voice cracks when she hits the high notes. I love this song & IN MY OPINION Davichi the only one that done this song justice Hae Ri & Mi Kyung voices together are like heaven & they both can hold all the notes & its perfect you feel emotional when you hear them sing :) I love hyorin & all the other singers that sang this song but i dont know why i only get emotional when i hear DAVICHI sing this!!!

  • so flippin amazing.. im in awe.. but i jus wish she'd put more emotion and soul into it.. but other than tht shes amazing!!

  • MY OPINION IS,hyorin is one of the best singer,she can dance powerfully and sings without panting,but sometimes,i just can't feel her emotions in slow songs.of course her voice is so powerful,but i feel like it's just powerful singing and lack emotion.but i don't deny the fact that she's a powerful singer.

  • 저음이 컨트롤이 안되네 그리고 키를 낮췄나? 힘이 좋아서 깔끔하게 이어지긴 하는데 고음이 안되서 낮춘 모양이군

  • para mi IU tiene una voz muy tierna y dulce!!!! canta muy bonito mejores que otras cantantes!!!!

  • in my opinion iu is better than hyorin.....

  • @aminahmohdyusof so, go to IU's videos...

    people is SO retarded...

  • @aminahmohdyusof same2..sy pun suke iu..haha..

  • What’s with people comparing Hyorin with IU? I came here to listen to Hyorin’s beautiful cover of this song and all the comments mentioning how IU is jealous of Hyorin’s voice totally spoilt my mood. I don’t mind people giving their opinions of whose cover they love most (I personally love Sohyang’s :D) but discriminating other singers? Both of them obviously have different voice tones. Their voices are beautiful in their own ways. Just appreciate the music alright? :)

  • 唱的很棒

  • wat show is this btw? immortal song?

  • hyorin sang this really great! and yea, suzy's performance on dream high was recorded, i just don't kno bout eunjung, i think she can sing this song perfectly too just like iu and hyorin :)

  • what show is this ??

  • @kpoplover251 immortal song 2

  • Well, of course some of you would say Suzy sings it way better in Dream High, but honestly they recorded that. If Suzy was to sing it live I don't think she could compare with Hyorin or IU^^

  • @GrowingYellowDaisy Suzy n Hyorin is the best....thay both beat IU up.....with their voice.......

  • Both IU and Hyorin are like the best female singers in the kpop industry (in my opinion) Both voices are COMPLETELY differently voices so you can't really compare one to the other

  • this is a beautiful song & hyorin sang it greattt (: love her <3

  • she sings this better than iu for this song omg!

  • u cant help but to tear up every single time i listen to this song.. and and and.. hyorin sang this song so beautifully.. ToT

  • for me, Suzy sing this song is the best!

  • hyorin's voice has a kind of thickness and power that IU can never dream of having. IU has a cuteness and cleanliness vocal voice that hyorin can never dream of having. they are like the best in the world to me. they have the voice that i can never dream of having. no need to compare both of them.

  • ohh suzy and eunjung sang this on dream high. no wonder why it sounds so familiar

  • 가수가 노래만 잘하면 됬지 효린 좋음ㅠ

  • the cameramen sucks!

    they shot the weird audience face

    the audience would be crying seeing their face on TV

  • is this a show? cuz if it is then wat show is it?? wat concert??

  • @1pinkrink >< dammit forgot what this was called but its like a battle between singers :O. The talented singers are given songs from a long time ago and recreate it a bit to fit there image :] and the audience decides the best song! xD

  • @1pinkrink immortal song 2 

  • who is the person at 0:39... he looks familiar

  • @w1999wr lol he's yesung from super junior...:)

  • @bey0ndzer09 I knew it was yesung it just doesn't look like him from that point of view.....

  • she has one of the greatest voices in KPOP...but to be famous also it is needed good songs (lyrics+ music!) ..thats why SISTAR is not that recognized......their company needs to buy good song... not just cute-sexy style!

    !

  • IU is jealous at 1:08...XDDD what a beautiful voice of Hyorin

  • She sang it better.

  • hyorin is the best

  • Im so amazed...HYORIN is my number 1 fav singer in Korea now!!!! But seiously people need to stop hating and flaming IU she has a really different style to how she sings so people should'nt judge her lyk IU will never sing it better thsn hyorin cuz its just RUDE im sure if hyorin wud see this she wldn't b happy and lyk what u said srsly...grow up. STOP comparing an jus enjoy what they give their best to.

  • I dont know why everyone is comparing IU to Hyorin...IU's face wasn't of disapointment, she was listening to the music and truly feeling the emotion in the song, just as everyone else was. They both sang it in their own unique way, and it was beautiful either way.

  • Bản này thực sự quá hay <3

  • My mouth.. wide open.

  • can't stop replaying

  • she looks so diva... u know im a Filipino.... in my opinion filipino's like singers who really can sing live... like gary v or za sha padilla.... u woudn't even know them but wat im trying to say is.... when i saw her sing like this.... i can compare her to filipino divas... respectful... ah i seem can't get what i want to say..... poor me... go hyorin!^^

  • Hyorin always had the raspy voice so when she sing with all her might, she sounds like she's crying. IU has her way of singing it, doesn't have to be a sad song you know. Stop comparing.

  • hey, why wasn't yeobso there when IU sang it D:

  • I think IU nailed the low tones and Hyorin was awesome at the higher notes ^^ love em both ~ -3

  • I can't shake off SoHyang's version.

  • her voice just make me say " WOW"

  • Hyorin's definitely amazing <3

    Eunji's vers was also amaaazing :]

    I don't really think you can compare IU to these two though, since her voice is drastically different, it's not suited for this song.

  • awesome

  • Wow, am I glad these are all still up here to compare. I LOVE HyoLyn's voice. Just love her. Her speaking voice is adorable, and when she opens her mouth, it seems like nothing wrong can come out.

    However, as @B2STLover4Eva noted, Apink's Eunji also knocked this song out of the park.

    I'm having trouble deciding between Hyorin's version and Eunji's. No offense to IU, I love her vocals as well, so unique, but these two really KILLED IT.

  • More more love this song , when she's cover

  • she just kill IU.. did you see IU face, she sang it way better than IU ever will

  • @sleepyheadblanket Wowz IU facial expression was like "she has such a pretty voice," not "omg i will never be as good as her" --....-- feg. And FYI they are both talented singers -...- IU is more gentle cute and adoring, WHILE AS hyorin is the sexy, aggressive type (cause alot of times shes like uhhsheuis >< idk how to describe it but, she makes the kinda beautiful sound that most african american womens sing.... lets just say shes good with deep voices)They are both EQUAL! :P

  • @sleepyheadblanket and the song also seemed to be too easy for hyorin :D <3

  • is that IU at 2:57?

  • @kkkichong yes it is. :3

  • Hyorin is awesome!!!! Her voice is completely amazing :) unfortunately, she couldn't reach the low notes perfectly :( I remember when i heard this song for the first time, Insooni's voice was just.... Perfecto. But still, great job Hyorin!

  • Why are there 47 haters?

  • best version ever... for me better than the original

  • my skin is kasjdkjsadsa WAU"

  • hyorin really should sing more songs like this :D

  • Comment removed

  • nice reaction 3:19 :D

  • do u hav yesung's part???

  • @nettehardy just search yesung "the first poem." or you can find the full episode subbed on daebaksubsdotcom.

  • hyorin has a beautiful voice :) good job

  • insooni the best always.

  • Hyorin's voice is beautiful I like it, but no one can compare to Insooni obviously.

    I wish I was talented at singing though.

  • dont really like hyroin singing this song, yes her high notes are nice, but the rest of the song sounded like she was mumbling or something just my opinion.

  • Comment removed

  • THIS.IS.GREAT.. NEVER BORED :D

  • Everyone got their own personality. I am a fan of IU too but I prefer Hyorin sing this song :) <3 Daebak HyoRin~

  • yoseob's face completed my day ^^

  • Comment removed

  • 44 dislike - because hyorin voice broke their speakers.

  • i don't understand a word, but i cried listening to hyorin's version. continue to work hard hyorin ! (:

  • I heard it sung better but she's easy on the eyes and easy on the ears...a winner in my book. Hope you realize your dreams...you go Girl!!!

  • @starbuck246 haha...after searching around for more yt vids of her, i realize that she's a big star already...i don't speak korean or follow kpop, so I had no idea....oh well...it's obvious she's a beauty, imho, both visually and voice...

  • @starbuck246 yep, hyorin's the lead vocal of Sistar and she's going to be in the drama "Dream High" Season 2. She's so talented!

  • 1:19 is that Running man's maknae FD?? LMFAO

  • @asiasdolphin001 LMFAO!! haha i thought so too but he's not lol

  • Thats what you call a goddess's voice

  • @MsSunday19 lol actually its he exact opposite haha its not the about the first person who sings it or that last person who sings it its actually about whos listening and what it means to them everyone has their own style of music like if you here you probably think korean music is amazing like me but some people dong like this style so its not really who's singing it but who's listening

  • i love her version! and i also like Taeyeons and Suzy´s version i like IU but i dont think the song suits her voice...

  • i love both IU and hyorin. i think they both did really well.

  • Wahh!! Yesung and Yoseob and IU (I think)!! They were all like... "Holy cow can she sing..." and faces were like O.O

  • hyorin's husky voice <3

  • lol this song seems to be the judge for a good singer...almost all the best korean singers have sung this song

  • i love this song when i watched DREAM HIGH

  • I feel like I can't compare Hyorin's, IU's, and Taeyeon's with Suzy's version of Goose's Dream.. Her's was pre-recorded.... and she cut out certain parts of the song.... She sang it with Eunjung too.... I like Suzy's better.. but her's wasn't live like the others >.< I think out of all 3.. IU's was the best! ^^

  • This woman is the greatest performer Ive seen in many many years she will bring emotions back you thought were long gone!

  • what show is this ?

  • @nadastasia thought it's immortal songs

  • @wichen91  aha thank you

  • Concordo com "A voz dela é incrível!... Mas, também prefiro na voz da SUZY.

    A SUZY é a cantora coreana que mais gosto!

  • I think its silly that people say she doesn't convey emotion. I don't speak Korean, but i love this performance so much. Her voice is amazing.

  • her voice good bt doesnt suit the song..

  • Hyorin has by far the most power, but personally, she doesn't convey emotions to me as well as other less-powerful singers.

  • wow... her voice is so nice...

  • god not TheSONE4ever again; she/he goes on almost every kpop video and bashs (or sometimes even insults the artist) and compares them to snsd

    although I am a sone myself, i have to admit that hyorin is a better singer than taeyeon

    (although I liked taeyeon's duet with leejeok more)

  • A song that makes Hyorin be a singer is described on the screen.

  • i think you can compare if 2 singer sing a same song.

  • @TheSONE4ever this asshole had been going on all hyorin's video and starting a fanwar by saying the same thing. taeyeon is a better singer. honestly, i have enuf sones causing a fanwar at all the other idols videos. it's stupid, immature and clearly these idiot have no life. so pls if u see this person pls report for spam.

  • hyorin vocal transition from low note to high note not so smooth...but it's okay....just the high note make this perf special...

  • nice voice!

  • nothing special...

  • why compare...Taeyeon and Hyorin are both good singers...just sit back, chill, relax and enjoy...

  • Comment removed

  • i know this lovely song from Dream High .

    today , i just knew that Hyorin is one of the Actress in Dream High 2 . !!!

  • taeyeon sings the best. Hyorin cannot compare

  • @TheSONE4ever lol hyorin voice is like voted the top.

  • @TheSONE4ever don't start to make fanwar ;)

  • @TheSONE4ever NONONO HYORIN IS ALOT BETTER THAN TAEYEON!! COMPARE SNSD LIVE PERFORMANCE AND SISTAR'S LIVE PERFORMANCE, ITS ALOT DIFFERENT!!!!

  • see..??hyorin much better than eunji...but..she still good..:)

  • I think i first heard this song from Davichi, then Dream High 1, then taeyeon's version and now this! :D

  • you guys better see apink eunji cover for this song...although its a rookie group but it really daebak...

  • iu and hyorin have completely different styled voices~~~both are good :)

  • I like this song because dream high. :)

  • this song is from ..? dream high? SUZY? :3

  • @ShinHye1206 nooo orignal singer is insooni this is a classic song