林欣彤 - 我恨我愛你

[33333poi]

@b762468你個妒忌狂四圍做打手惡意攻擊仲係道死頂爛頂~­睇過你d風言醋語既人都知你搞邊科啦~醫返都嘥藥費~

[33333poi]

坦白嗰句~放低妒忌心就知佢唱咩~都唔知要睇耳科先得~~~~~­

[b762468]

@33333poi 同佢有親咩... 要妒忌佢!? 有病定冇病啊!? 佢紅唔見得我有著數.. 佢唔紅唔唱我亦唔覺得可惜... 要好過佢既人好多... 要差過佢既人亦好多... 在網上講句野就問人要唔要睇耳科... 真係有咩歌手就有咩粉屎囉~ 不知所謂...

[b762468]

都係戈句~ 冇歌詞真係唔知佢唱咩~~~~

[1995wkm]

阿mag好可愛!!!

[abc1040506]

d頭髮好令:o

[magmaglove1000]

兩位都唱得好..兩位都鍾意..簡直係稱心滿意..加油!

[166vt]

胡鴻鈞與mag比較一定是,胡鴻鈞好得多,他的感情唱功每隻字都­聽得很清楚.唔一定要嗌先叫唱歌.只可說mag唔算太差.亦唔算­係好好聽.

[166vt]

只可以講,不過不失, 唔可以話好好聽,表情多過唱出的感情,有好多字都唱唔出音黎,而­且有點做作,,找個老師教吓路啦,否則不進則退.

[B85000]

真是不好聽,他唱得不清楚好像在用鼻子讀書一樣,感情缺乏, 可能是我對亞妹的歌很熟識亞妹唱得太好聽所以有所比較吧!就算不­是這個原因, 我還是覺得不太好聽吧!

[magmaglove1000]

好有感情好好聽好清楚我愛您

[CHANELGIRL2011ABCD]

冇字幕真係唔知佢唱乜?!

[juouful]

矜貴善良 獨一無二

[yukochanful]

RUBBISH ENGLISH

[cairobaby7]

I LOVE IT <3

i'm quite touched =))

for people who criticise her, maybe you should TRY standing on the stage with no professional training and sing like her... it is HARD

[tinalove588]

胡鴻鈞好啲

[wcpaul]

阿MAG有幾樣好:

1. 唱得唔算PEFECT, 但係可以見到, 佢仲有好多進步空間.., 而家已經好聽過好多人.

2. 唱得好聽過佢的人, 有大把..., 但係好似佢咁有觀察緣, 就唔多..

3. 佢仲好PURE,

[michelle90615]

吐词问题喔 棒

[33333poi]

林欣彤真係幾掂....當然係要繼續努力增值啦!呢個係做人最簡­單嘅道理囉(您實得嘅)

[didierdrobga11]

林欣彤唔係唔掂....不過係同atv俾較係差十幾皮姐(講堅)­

[hui4a888]

其實我真係唔好明點解成日都咁多人話阿Mag唔掂-.-

[pweyot]

to all: Music is not a competition. 唔需要成日呀 Gem 勁D, 呀 mag 勁D....

[sze1416]

好好聽

[chickensalad98]

i love you voice, ignore all the mean comments and just be yourself, you have a very unique voice :) add oil! :D

[cvbn815]

罕有音飾樂壇寶塊確實難得！讚！

[manbabii51]

佢係唔係太低音?有時聽得有d辛苦@@

[jacksona333]

Heart Touching Voice Of All Time~Jess Lee Jia Wei. She will be in Hong Kong on 20/9/11 to launch her new album.

Mag is equally a very good singer too!!

[mmtheman]

呀mag好喜歡唱張惠妹d歌, "我恨我愛你", "勇敢", "聽海" 都cover過.

[33333poi]

致bad打手有自知之明自認..........~~~~...­..

[bbq3able]

佢超樣衰...巴聲超難聽

[najaibaby33]

你地真係覺得佢唱得好?

TBB成日用人氣爆登,超人氣,紅星,

講到真係天后咁..

要知道呀妹真係天后,佢唱'天后'既歌唔等於佢有'天后'既實力­..

反而對比更大..

唔該你地聽下原唱先啦.

[Tami867]

她唱這首真不錯,,,



[yukochanful]

乜咁好數口呀.. 睇你吳出喎..低b仔:~(

[magmag54321]

@yukochanful

彼此彼此

[yukochanful]

@magmag54321 點會阿! 係你應得既, 講到繪形繪聲咁, 吳知扮代表, 好笑!

[magmag54321]

係~係幾低O架!

智商15,低你幾度,

睇你都有智商20,都係醒目仔嚟O架!

恭喜晒.

[yukochanful]

因為智商低, 所以佢吳會明架, 佢凈係識吳知扮代表同吹之嘛!

[CharleneFed]

mag lam? huh just a joke. LOL



[33333poi]

@uicetful

新人do吾錯錯錯錯錯錯錯錯錯.......啦啦啦!!!

[tfwan7889]

張惠妹好太太太太太太太太太........多了!!

[TheEdwinaMay]

@tfwan7889 Of course, A-mei is one of the best femaile Chinese singer around for some years; but why would you compare her with a young novice like Mag ???

[ilikemusic1966]

@TheEdwinaMay Well said! Mag has also been compared with other veteran/established singers like Fei Wong, A-Lin etc. You always wonder what these people are thinking. Thank God that we have level headed people around. Otherwise there is no hope for newcomers with great potential like Mag who can sing very well. A pity & very sad to see vicious/nasty comments posted daily on Mag's videos. I sincerely hope can progress to become a superstar one day. God bless Mag!

[alexfong3]

男版有胡鴻鈞,女版有阿MAG~真心唔錯!

[azraelhob1]

人地都盡左力拉., 剩係批評人.. 自己又唔去唱'!!! 講就如何如何'

[siuman7004]

本身我都系聽左丫mag唱呢首先再聽張惠妹...

我發覺mag 有d歌唱開頭戈陣一定好細聲...同chock聲

一定要到到副歌先開始發力

[hoholoney]

@siuman7004

如果純講呢首歌....佢真係唱得好差....

一個吹噓到咁勁的歌手,出左3日碟有萬5隻,係得咁ga實力??­?

唔好話搵張惠妹比較.....佢已經上左神台了

你聽下台灣,曾昱嘉唱的版本~!!計音準,咬字等等已經無得比較

感情上的發揮差距更加無得比!!!2者都係歌唱比賽出身架!!!

下面d人話,只係識批評~!!!有批評先會有進步,

如果覺得佢真係無希望,邊有人會得閒理佢?

唔好吹到佢咁大,等佢慢慢磨練下吧~!!!

[kamanli0320]

@hoholoney 不能同意更多

[TheEdwinaMay]

@hoholoney How to promote her latest release is a commercial decision, if you have better ideas pls approach TVB. Sales volume is a market issue, people bought if for various reasons n complicated to find out why. Mag sings with her heart and I am sure she expect people to listen with the same. Technically speaking she got a lot to improve just like every other novice and constructive critics will get her going. Last but not least we should judge thing without any preconceptions.

[magmag54321]

@hoholoney '

講咁長篇大論,都唔知你想講乜????????????

[najaibaby33]

@hoholoney 你就有道理啦,真係D人講到佢唱得幾好咁,我聽開呀妹唱既,真係­一定就知差幾遠..

要知道呀妹D歌係金曲獎係橫掃咁多個獎,呀妹實力差唔多全球華人­都証明到,

港人唱國語歌最緊要咬字好,講到感情、技巧佢真係無得同人比!!­!

要唱人地既歌就一定點都會有人拎嚟同人地比,要唱'天后'既歌就­一定會有人拎嚟同'天后'比!!!



[magmaglove1000]

magmag好好聽

[leeeee26]

@uicetful打手5通讚好ar

[iltw523]

佢把聲唱好難聽

[keungchify]

@33333poi 呀mag 新秀比人咁招呼法..

您係第一個, 至叻係您喇!..

[shan114839]

手歌唔太岩佢唱講真

佢同張惠妹既風格唔同

其實佢唔明手歌講咩

個音唔岩佢.佢好勉強唱得.唱得仲快左

一時有感情.一時冇咁

[keungchify]

多謝你既寶貴意見,..呀Mag宜家已經進步咗好多,..

呀Mag同紫棋都係好努力既,..樂壇既接班人非佢哋莫屬架喇!­..

我哋都要為佢哋打氣!..呀Mag加油!..紫棋加油!..一家­人齊齊加油!!

[kai1999510]

我喺Gem啲fans (講到明架喇!預咗俾你地啲fans插)

其實佢呢首歌唱得幾好 我真心講- -"

不過佢咬字唔清楚 如果佢可以再高音小小黎唱 真喺好正!

但我覺得佢應該喺唱啲呢啲斯斯文文既歌 而唔喺唱A.I.N.Y呢啲咁激既歌囉

[jackylst]

好憎啲人吾係兩個版本都聽哂就係度亂鬧

[10chinchin]

唔睇歌詞真係聽唔清唱緊乜!

[hoshino148]

@10chinchin 話少陣人唔得..?唔知唱咩咪唔好聽囉= _=

[loveuforever31]

一D都唔感动lo

Hubert唱得好听好多

[IvyHui03]

我覺得胡鴻鈞唱E首歌既時候比ar Mag唱得更穩定`

一開頭既時候覺得ar Mag 唱D音好飄"

But +Oil :)

[sweetstar2baby]

吾錯~~

仲有好中意magmag呢個look x).



[poonbbb]

我覺得胡鴻釣好d

[hk156]

Just nice!  Thanks Mag!

[49101517]

呀mag唱這類型嘅歌很有恩賜，由其是在尾音的部份，＂可憐兮兮­....!＂好感動！

[okboy2011]

睇見D打手留言真係好好笑, 呢首歌就話冇高低起伏, 嗰首歌就話起伏過大,

真係唔鐘意就唔好辛苦自己去聽啦.

MAG都就黎出碟, 好心D人就唔好葡萄人啦, 自己比心機唱好自己既歌仲好啦.

[catkizzhk]

同意樓下, 啱啱好無多無少, 過多就失控, 過少又唔夠, 剛剛好, 聽得好舒服

[leeloming66]

呢首歌我就覺得MAG唱到啱啱好, 講真好過好多乜星物星參賽者.

[ChowJoo]

@leeloming66 如果唔係點贏- -

[vincyleung0409]

我比較鍾意李建龍版本多D



[hoholoney]

如果...用一個普通人黎計

佢唱得好唔錯....

但係用歌手黎計,唔多得lol~_~"

tvb 用天后級的宣傳,想谷紅佢

但比起人地曾昱嘉...差距大到無得計算,更唔好話張惠妹

咁谷佢...只會玩死佢,覺得佢有潛質的...

[1977623dog]

@hoholoney 完全贊同,她只把基本的音唱出來而已,聲音大小的控制有待改善,­但在香港已經是算好,因為香港新歌手已經找不到3個能聽的,難道­我們還要繼續聽鄧x欣,阿sa之流嗎?

[wing2988]

@1977623dog

[TheBillows]

@hoholoney 睇曬咁多Comment你最中肯

[magmag54321]

@TheBillows

睇曬咁多Comment你最識借刀殺人

叻!!!

[secondaryone]

for this song, i personally think Hubert sang better.