Added: 2 years ago
From: Top40Countdown
Views: 47,231
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Awesome compilation!

    Check our music on my channel

    Long live STONER!!!

  • BOOBS at 5:40 in this video, amg youtubz is slippin with teh censorz!!1

  • Oh yeah, and where the FUCK is EYEHATEGOD!!!?

  • the tops weren't bad. however you missed quite a few better than alot of your lower rated ones. like Acrimony. Eternal Elysium. early Boris. High Rise. come on man get with it.

  • Just wondering where the hell Mastodon and High on Fire are? Both are very DOOM. Nice to see Acid Bath though

  • no acid king, the gates of slumber, toner low, jex thoth etc. good songs but you missed a lot of really good ones that should have got some light.

  • @virel360 i questioned this aswell. Acid king is the shit.

  • Crowbar > All sludge.

  • @dcs2690 I respectfully disagree... :P

  • @dcs2690 Hmmm Nop ...

  • HAND OF DOOOOOOM!

  • ELECTRIC WIZARD.

  • great top

    too bad i didnt get to see Altar when i had a chance

  • had a nice trip! cheers from Cyprus!

  • dystopia?

  • BLack FLag - Nothing Left Inside!!! the beggining of Sludge

  • Eye hate god is one of the pionners of sludge music

  • Electric Wizard owns

    

  • @pickmetofight  Hail Thy Mighty WIzard

  • @pickmetofight if anyone diagees, do yourself a favor a smash your face in, much abliged

  • NOOTHGRUSH!!!!!

  • d0Wn?!?! not top of the list? do what now?!?!?

    and where's EYEHATEGOD>>!>!>

  • 1:13 THE WITHERED EGG

    GIANT SMORES

  • ELECTRIC WIZARD?

    OH GAWD HIDE THE CHILDREN D:

  • No Boris? I would've thought you'd have a song by the band "Boris", or the song "Boris" by the Melvins. I also can't find Gojira "Ocean Planet" in your list. You had Kyuss, but that Kyuss song was hardly their best. Demon Cleaner coulda fit better. Big Business was also nowhere to be found. Overall, I'm disappointed.

  • @uiruu

    You expected Gojira in this video? :S

    they're a hard band to pin down to a genre but they are in no way doom/sludge/stoner metal.

  • @PeterElliott Oh, no, I'd say they are pretty sludgy. Or rather, the songs I've heard from them. Progressive sludge metal I guess.

  • @PeterElliott

    i agree...Gojira is hardly doom/sludge/stoner. i'd say they're more like death/thrash/groove, with some sludge riffs, but plenty of genres have sludgy riffs thrown into the mix. Gojira shouldn't be on this list.

  • Acid Bath FTW!!!!!!!!

  • i would have used electric funeral or sweet leaf for sabbath :)

  • fools, black flag were more than just punk, they were a crossover act that laid the foundation for the melvins first album, and consequently sludge metal.

  • CROWBAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • electric wizard FTW!!!

  • what! big loader only at 34?! ok...the wizard at 12 yesss!! nice mix mate...i'd been wondering where sabbath was (prefer behind the wall of sleep though)...but I miss WARHORSE, and do somewhat agree with the eyehategod shouters (sisterfucker or southern discomfort perhaps)...but tastes differ I suppose..still, great selection of music you got there!

  • cool list. wino, pentagram. etc. hard to pick em. but i'm gonna sneak in anathema, restless oblivion :)

  • Soundgarden-Gun

  • Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath

  • dude! i abso-fucking lutely love the album art!

  • All the other metal scenes out there can't beat us. We have Ozzy!

  • i like how the top 2 comments are the exact opposite opinion on the same subject

  • Dope Flood - A Planet On Four Legs more into slow stoner rock

  • Graves At Sea - Wormwood. Absent :-(

  • @Omletofon I checked this out, awesome choice man.

  • electric wizard :foneralopolis

    sleep : dragonaut

    1 and 2

  • ACID BATH!!!!!yeah!!!!

  • dopethrone should been #1 :P

  • Where's Boris holy shit?!?

  • electric wizard is the best

  • @lllcerolll DOPETHRONE! shoulda been #1

  • one of these things is not like the others!

    one of these things does not belong!

    but black flag does fit here

  • Of all the Acid Bath song's you pick that? it's gotta be one from WTKSP, like God Machine, or Jezebel, or Cassie Eats Cockroaches.

  • I love war pigs, but if your going to put a Sabbath song in a catarory titled

    Top 40 Doom/"STONER"/Sludge Metal Songs of all time it has to be

    SWEET LEAF

  • Good songs! Thank you!

  • Where is stoner tree by Rwake ? Awesome song

  • That band "down" sounded like Phil Anselmo singning.

  • @halo368 That is actually one of Anselmo's other bands. Check them out, if you haven't already, they have some rockin' tunes.

    And if you want to hear Phil rock out on some guitar, check out Arson Anthem :)

  • Decent list, but I think the Melvins should've at least made the top ten!

  • i think instead of war pigs anything from Master of Reality would have been better because that album pretty much influenced the genre

  • For everyone disregarding the Black Flag entry, I have this to say:

    Gluey Porch Treatments.

  • @TheAxlSnaks Nice

  • BLACK FUCKING SABBATH

  • Acid bath are the best.

  • /watch?v=OrcJS2XuNbI&feature=r­elated

  • Acid Bath is the best band out of all these.

  • DOWN and CROWBAR!!!!!!!!

  • stonerfags

  • @IMBACHABRI Turd Fag

  • Man this takes me 8 years back. I got lost since then, now I'm listening to shit like jazz now. When in the hell did I get old??

  • funeralopolis end of story

  • Sunn O))) is drone, 13 is sludge, Crowbar is sludge, COC is sludge, Acid Bath is not doom. Nice try though, I suppose :/

  • @kangasnoot What is acid bath? What are they singing about? I purchased their "when the kite string pops lp" brand new at me local record exchange store. Is that somthing that would be okay to open and listen to? It was only 15 bucks and I want to listen to it but not if it's worth money. \\m//

  • @SuperCommentDude2 Of course you should listen to it! It's not rare or anything. It's got elements of lots of metal genres in it including doom and sludge, but it can't really be classified as any one thing. It's a great album for sure.

  • @JTOwens89 okay cool. i love those guys. I can't stand band with people yelling about hate and satan sometimes but I don't know what acid bath is talking about. I'm into intrumental metal but all I coulf find was bongripper attomica death_breath cemetary and i know there's got to be more. Do you know any?

  • @SuperCommentDude2 Nah, not really. I don't listen to any purely instrumental bands. If you liked "When The Kite String Pops" and you don't have "Paegan Terrorism Tactics" I recommend that, it's just as good.

  • @JTOwens89 I have both on vinyl. They're pretty cool. All I do is listen to music. I'm a highschooler. I'm in my room it's 1 in the morning. I usualy stay up till 3

  • i was about to say, WHERE IS PENTAGRAM?!

  • Where into "Into The Void" or "cosmic Funeral" or "Electric Wizard"?

  • Was Witches by Candlemass on this list? If not it shouldve been but nice list anyway all great songs/bands.

  • Down YES!!!!!

  • We saw the Melvins live recently they fucking rock man....flawless performance

    Our band will get there...eventually haha

    fuck man electric wizard kicks assssssssss

  • Yes. Candlemass representing!

  • wheres goatsnake man 

  • Awesome to hear Reverend Bizarre on here.

  • electric wizard owns

  • C L U T C H definitely needs to be on this list! One of the best Stoner Bands around!

  • @dpeab11370 Clutch would need to be metal first. Clutch does some amazing shit...but if anything they're more stoner rock.

  • no dopesmoker im sorry but that is absurd

  • This list started off pretty cool but there are too many important bands you failed to mention.

  • Check out the "Best Doom/Stoner/Sludge Bands" on youtube.

  • Sleep "Jerusalem" should most definitely be on here. Then again, I didn't make the video, so whatever.

  • black flag doesent really fit into this catagory...theyre punk

  • @Teutonic1250 they pretty much started sludge, I think that warrants a place here besides my war is a classic anyway.

  • @Teutonic1250

    The second side of the "My War" album is all sludge.....haven't you ever heard that Black Flag is just a sped up version of Sabbath!?

    Props to the video maker for putting that in there, My War influenced bands like the Melvins for sure.

    Just one thing, no EHG?! Maybe it's on part one. I hope so.

  • no BARONESS?

  • songs from When the Kite Strings Pops are nice as well

  • holy effin shit, you do a TWO PART video labelled doom / stoner / sludge, and the MAJORITY of the song cited ranges from hardcore punk (Black Flag) to NWOBHM (Wittchfinder General, Pentagram) to some idontknowwhichmelodicmetalstly­e...

    dude... there definitely ARE at least 40 bands of each, you could've done a fine setlist.

    where's Karma to Burn, where's Acid King, Orange Goblin, Spirit Caravan, Alabama Thunderpussy, Monster Magnet, Nebula, Sleep, Brant Björk... ?

    dude...

  • @karcosur Pentagram is NWOBHM...? What the fuck?

  • @Beenyad shit, just confused them with VENOM in the rush, I was entirely confident Pentagram is from brittain too. my bad.

  • Blew out my speakers listening to DOPETHRONE too loud. great list by the way.

  • Corrosion of Conformity- Albatross

    yes!!

  • @emperorofthenorth5 Thats what I was thinking

  • First, Electric Wizard sounds fuckin kick ass.

    Second, Whenever I hear Down, I feel sorry for Phil. lol

  • @burlingamevideos Electric Wizard IS fucking kickass.. Heaviest shit in the universe

  • where is st vitus?

  • Solstice lamentations is a great album

  • HOW IN THE HELL CAN U PUT THAT GAY ASS BAND "THE OBSESSED" HIGHER THAN DOWN?!!!!! U MUST HAVE GOT AHOLD OF SOME BAD SHIT!!

  • @TrENDKiLLR784 You're an idiot or a troll. Leave the hall either way. The Obsessed >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Down and Phil asstomouth

  • I take it back acid bath was number seven fuckin win..

  • Uh last time I checked Black Flag was punk

  • @ace32295

    True... but My war has some Proto sludge/doom in it

  • @ace32295

    They're old-school hardcore, but after they toured with St. Vitus, they came up with the slow songs that are half of the "My War" album. Probably baffled many skinheads at the time.

  • @JCQuinnEdit clearly there sabbath influence i know henry rollins and greg ginn are big fans

  • @ace32295 the list just says top SONGS not bands.. I would say that black flag song is along the lines of stoner sludge doom type of thing...

  • @ace32295 Shows what you know

  • War Pigs!

  • @ace32295 their first 2 albums were hardcore punk, but after that they moved into sludge metal/ noise rock

  • @ace32295 the last time i checked they didn't put labels on their music. ...and henry himself has saisd that the b sides to my war were Sludgy Punk...

  • @ace32295 thats time i checked they never put labels on their music.and the songs are clearly not punk in conventional terms.

  • @ace32295 yeah, labels are such a great invention...a pity sludge, krust, grind, doom, death, stoner, and all the -core's didn't exist yet forty years ago...

  • man you forgot MASTODON.................

  • i love all these bands, but i wouldnt really concider sunn0))) sludge metal

  • Sunn O)))!!

    Btw where's YOB? They are easily one of the best Doom bands out there.

  • Black Sabbath is probably my favorite metal band and I think War Pigs is a terrible example for the #1 Doom Metal Song.

    If you want doomy Sabbath, listen to Master of Reality. Especially Into the Void.

  • Albatross!

  • acid bath should be first...and i dont even think its in this video

  • @RHCPfan I hear ya should be sleep/acid bath/electric wizard in that order

  • I think that bands like eyehategod, down, and raging speedhorn are tolerable in their vocal style. unfortunately vocals really make or break doom/sludge metal for a lot of people. for example i would listen to greif but the vocals are too harsh for me

  • ACID BAAAAAAAAATH!!!!!!

  • Not a bad list. I personally think though, that Reverend Bizarre should've had "Doomsower" instead of "In the Rectory", and that Electric Wizard should've had "Funeralopolis" instead of "Dopethrone". Also, while it was a good Top 40, I don't think "War Pigs" should've been number 1. There are a lot of songs that are much better than that one, including other Sabbath songs. Oh well.

  • rerevend bizarre !

  • solstice

  • Hails for putting Black Flag on there!

  • If you're allowing enough leeway for some of these bands like COC and BLS (don't see any reason not to), then I think a few songs off of Soundgarden's first two albums would definitely qualify, which would then vocally put everything to shame here except for Ozzy and John Garcia. Everyone to their own taste said the old lady as she kissed the cow, but I'd have: 5) Fu Manchu - King of The Road 4) Boris - Electric 3) Soundgarden - Flower 2) Kyuss - Whitewater 1) Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath

  • alot of good shit in this top 40 reminds me of some old school sabbath. you gotta check out some isis or neurosis

  • Well i think everyone can agree with NO. 1

  • Pretty good list, I would've put Trouble and Saint Vitus much higher, like in the top 5. Solstice being rated higher than Solitude Aeturnus is a bit of a travesty also. There was definitely some stuff on here I haven't heard that I'll have to check out though, which is the whole point of making a "top...." video. Nobody will ever completely agree with the order.

  • Why is everyone whining about eyehategod, they are the worst band in sludge. The reason why they aren't in here is because they have yet to release a good song. Duh, and anyone questioning BLS and COC are morons plain and simple.

    Great vid.

  • no eyehategod??? Comon! Jack Ass In The Will of God, Depress, Sister Fucker Pt.1, Southern Disconfort damnit! it was a good tune though but cmon! EYEHATEGOD is more of a Doom Stoner Sludge than black label society!

  • Solstice, SunO))),  Down, etc. Nice list.

  • CHECK OUT MY SLUDGE BAND. WHERE CALLED HEAP OF STONE. CLICK ON MY NAME. THE SONG IS CALLED BREW.

  • Dude, Black flag is good but there higher on this list than Vitus,Pentagram ,crowbar and the obsessed???? I think THEY would even disagree on that one man.

  • where in the hell is eyehategod??!!?

  • Good choice of Candlemass song.

  • acid bath ftw!

  • Where's Grails?

  • @jameschains They're probably on a drone countdown.

  • Nice choices, but I would have liked some EYEHATEGOD, Kyuss and more Electric Wizard.

    But this is your video and your opinion. Nice collection.

  • Electric Wizard's the best

  • nice fuckin music man, real headbangin shit!

  • no EYEHATEGOD? really?

  • @thomass10207 I agree.

  • Hey Acid bath is in here, Now I wont have to smack a bitch.

  • hail the wizard

    and the 60s psycedelic era

    hail doom backed up with an army of identical 60s gogo chicks!

  • awesome list, the reason why eyehategod isn't here is because they were never good to begin with. so stop whining. They might be a #41.

  • Yeah where is Eyehategod? Sabbath will never die.....yew!

  • Eyehategod's missing here..

  • thought Gnaw Their Tongues and Bloody Panda are pretty good doom metal bands

  • Nice to see Black Flag's Nothing Left Inside on the list. Fucking brilliant sludge archetype. Sweet video \m/

  • HEY! I LOVE THOSE STYLES!! GREAT JOB!

  • acid bath FTW!

  • I don't like how 90% of the bands on the top 40 sing like Dio. haha.

    Doom bands need to work on their vocals!

  • @AryanAlphaMale I know, they either sound like Dio or a dying walrus!

  • I think Electric Wizard have the best vocal style for a doom metal band.. Far away, distorted, melodic but not clean.. Nice!

  • @Wigbolt i actually think Acid King has the best vocals, but EW definetely second place.

  • @onehugesob I dig Acid King TOO much!

  • @Wigbolt 100% :**** pure love with El.WiZARD

  • @Wigbolt hellyeah bro

  • but ronnie james dio rules the universe

  • Good shit with Electric Wizard, Down, Corrosion of Conformity but where was Spirit Caravan, Earthride or Clutch?

  • nice choices sir.

    i'm currently in love with a song called Changing by Witch, can't get those epic riffs out of my mind

  • you really put black flag in this mix? I figured "acrimony" or "zoroaster" or "Acid king" would be there. none the less, good selection and compilation sir.