Yo if you didnt mess with Joe before this or started doubting him. This should make you a fan or bring you back in the fold. That boy be killing them.
only dude that would do that, other rappers would get at their manager, and his manager would get at lantern. stood for his shit. fuck if youont like it.
@flyingpowerlogitech no not at all not one person in the wu can spit like joe budden the wu sucks right now joe budden will outspit 95% of the rap game matter of fact there is not even 8 emcees that can outspit joe budden bar for bar
@flyingpowerlogitech naw guy not even close i used to love the wu but real talk they fell off YEARS AGO and joe got too many bars for them dudes he could go at then solo and them all together and it would still be light work
@TheFatMack Are U nuts?? Bout "WU fell off"!! LMAO!! U'r tellin' me Raekwon fell off??? Genius fell off??? Dawg, U'r chopped!!! Joey does has bars, but don't get it twisted. Raekwon's style ALONE is murderous nvm. And I'm not even gonna talk bout GZA. Mef is the only one U could say isn't as raw. The smaller members weren't all that to begin w.
@Chaingeeazi the wu has fell off and thats just facts and rae got 1 good album and that was his 1st joint the rest are TRASH rae is wack GHOST is nice GZA is nice the rest of the clan are weak or just pure wack
@TheFatMack what about Killa Priest? or cappa or ghost, or rae or Gza ? The most budden could do wit any of dem is say somethin cleva then get murdered. people act like wu fell off but ..." they best Karate still inside" lol I respect your view but i gotta disagree Joe is sick but... I don't think he could catch them dudes I just mentioned.
@soulestial i like killah priest i actually got ALL his album and IMO he is the BEST member outta the WU period BUT no way can he go bar for bar against Joe budden bar for bar i dont think there are even 5 rappers in hip hop that can hang wit joey no questions
@TheFatMack wel I geuss we are talking 2 different realms... in a battle eventually there are plenty of Mc' that I feel could bury Joe Lyrically but as u suggest a bar for bar marathon a few mc's come to my mind. Consider the following, AZ, Mos Def, Redman, Kool G Rap these guys share the same never say die mentality when it comes to bar for bar on the spot no inspiration necessary.
@TheFatMack wel I geuss we are talking 2 different realms... in a battle eventually there are plenty of Mc' that I feel could bury Joe Lyrically but as u suggest a bar for bar marathon a few mc's come to my mind. , AZ, Mos Def, Redman, Kool G Rap, Busta Rhymes these guys share the never say die mentality when it comes to bar for bar on the spot no inspiration necessary obliterate ya with no hesitation. Joe is just some one who just wants to out talk ya .yes it takes skillbut it gets corny.fast
@soulestial LOLOLOLOL mos def sucks az had 1 great verse in his career and has still never done anything even close to his verson on nas first cd redman has good punchlines but thats about it kool g rap is a og i give him props but its not 1991 its 2011 and busta is a hot 16 when he spits fast but lyrically not even close to joe budden
@TheFatMack I disagree about az and mos. I would agree their attempts at mainstream success have fallen short but cmon dude.. feel 4 u, uncut raw ,rather unique, not to mention AZ's latest ..cmon dude.. can't judge skill by that standard alone ...Joe for instance... alot of brothas dissed his first album and called it garbage now all the sudden he ill. He only had pump it up it banged 4 a few months and then....nothin... But like i told dudes back then u can't front on skill and joe got it
@TheFatMack YES THEY ARE mos is not even almost close to Joe budden and AZ is a 1 verse wonder dude is still living off NAS verse he has NEVER lived up to that 1 verse hype thats still his best verse he ever spit come on son Joe budden will out spit both of them on his worst day
@TheFatMack COME ON BUDDY you smoking something if you seriously think Joe Budden bar for bar is fucking with AZ. AZ has had success in mainstream, not as much as people would have liked to see, but even bigger success as an underground artist. if you ask me id rather blow up underground then mainstream. And how is he still living off Nas, AZ has had 3 classic albums, all with lyrical mastery. joe has had none. Joe is nice but get real you cant put him in the catergory of AZ he is 1 of the GOAT
@DMVaReAkID AZ is actually better then NaS, thats why their whole beef started. NaS was upset and said that he didnt want to work with anyone who sounded better then him on his own track
@mrwhatever213 i don't kno u and u don't kno me brotha. I'm jus giving my opinion. Ther's no dick riding here dog ease yo pups . I f they said that then they said it ...I don't kno everything that come out their mouth I'm only saying what I believe ...u don't like it cool that's u ...but pls . don't disrespect me. i know u prolly gotta live up 2 your user name...4 all I know u do... but tha don't mean much to me.
hey everybody, if your a fan of eminem, joe budden n da whole slaughterhouse gang or just a general fans of real hip hop, you'll definitly enjoy my music. pleez check me out, i got punchlines n heart felt topics that i touch on and not to mention the quality of the music is more than excellent! listen n subscribe!
See the way Freeway wouldn't shake his hand, but after Jada give him his props about how ILL is his verse was, they was all like.. Ok Joey DOPE! people saying Joey scared? He's smart, he knows what he's doing... #WATCH!
Real shit Jump Off one of the nicest niggas doing it.
I remember as a young bol I heard Mood Muzik II, and my fuckin' head exploded, being exposed to real lyricism, story telling and just real shit. You can hear how hungry Joey is, nigga knows he's nicer than most but broker than most. You can hear how frustrated my nigga is.
Search Eddie Pesos "North of Death" and "Hayley", Puerto Rock kid from PA droppin' ill joints on the mic.
Im tripping.. because how can someone tell me how to feel about what joes lyrics mean to me.. Joe is the deepest writer in the game,period.. he's realistic,not the clicheness of some macho MC is supposed to be.. and fuck off with the comparisons.. who cares.. that wont change my opinion.. and my genre started with KRS ONE BDP.. I feel joes lyrics because i can relate.. fuck the over exaggerated hood shit.. C'mon Son FOHWTBS!!!
@TheAnce15 He said was up there for once reason. He spit and was out. Thats not nervous and antsy. He just wanted to be about his business and be out.
I know how Joe feels, That dj mention everybody and when he got to Joe he said who the fuck is this...? Joe should of waited a little before going off and the dj should think about how people might react before taking.
people in here thank think joe budden is the deepest lyricist in the game have no fucking idea what good music is... im outta here, its useless to try make u understand when u think someone like JOE is the deepest lyricist in the game... you people are preschool hahahah
O.C is a deep lyricist... listen to "born to live" and tell me what joe budden song come's REMOTELY close in terms of lyrics, how the bars are written and what the message is... give me a fucking break, KRS-1 is a deep fucking lyricist... hiphop has been around for what, like 40 years? and you think that hiphop gave birth to this average nobody as the "deepest lyricist" in the game? HAHAHAH :D
@darrenbleech nigga Joe is deep Mood Musik mixtapes are ill you must be a fuckin 106 and park lackey that wears skinny jeans and think lil wayne is good or you a white kid from the suburbs kuz you really on some bullshit
@budfsu2001 most rappers dont freestyle, he actually admits that he doesnt(not in this vid) they consider a freestyle nowadays as not having a paper in front of your face to read off of.
@ZatoSama he prolly do....u dont kno me n wta talent i got!!!! its obvious u dont kno hip hop!!! listen to this man lyrics n obvious u are a fan u r here listening.....n " fuck you too man"" lol..u prolly som white bitch from the hamptons....go listen gunz n roses mister lol
i can mention at least 300 mc's that are better than joe in every aspect.... you are just 2 much of a retard to know good hiphop when you hear it,... also, what does it matter if im white and from the hamptons? it doesnt change the fact that you have no idea about what you talking about... method man smacked joe and proved joe is nothing but a cunt, thus having cunt fans like urself
@ZatoSama alright go ahead......name 300 mc's that are better than JOE BUDDEN!!!go ahead name them.....ill be waiting...fuckin dumb retard,,,,deepest lyricist in the game.....NAME 300 MC'S THAT ARE BETTER RIGHT NOW!!!!!
@ZatoSama DO U PEOPLE HEAR DIS FUKIN CLOWN...HE NAME ALL THOSE N NOT EVEN MENTION PAC OOR BIGGIE.....U CANT SAY NUTTIN TO ME NEMORE....N B-REAL????? R U SERIOUS.... MAN HE IS THE DEEPEST RIGHT NOW I NTHE GAME....DONT REPLY TO ME OBBVIOUSLY U DOTN KNO SHYT
@ZatoSama all those people are good emcee's and writers of their time.. but joe seems to incorporate all those and blend them together without a flaw.. he is the deepest writer/emcee of our time.. no joke.. joe speaks realistically and from the heart,no compromise.. Pac+Biggie=Joe budden
Half those people aren't deep at all. Amazing lyricists, but not deep... You mean to tell me "I got a big dick bitch... that aint a punchline, i got a big dick bitch" is deep? get the fuck outta here.
@ZatoSama youre a fucking joke... busta rhymes lyrically better than joe budden? not a fucking chance.. big l more lyrical? not a fucking chance.. REDMAN???? no fucking CHANCE.. gtfo faggot
@ZatoSama dude your belittling yourself.. joe is a human like you.. dude you wouldnt of did shit with seven niggaz around you.. i dand it wasnt method man either.. it was some random dude in reakwons click.. stupid.. get your facts right.
@ZatoSama No, you can't name 300 mc's that are better than Joe. That's a joke. You can't even name 300 MC's better than 50 Cent. And good job spelling too, as 2..
And on another note, learn your facts before you start chirping on youtube. Method Man never touched Joe, Raekwon did, and when Royce confronted him about it later (go watch the vid on youtube), Raekwon bitched out. Your inability to come up with any insult other than the use of the word cunt just proves you should stop posting now.
@ZatoSama LMAO wow kid, you are the true definition of a hater!! Who you listen to?? You must be a wu-tang dickrider huh? lol Dont fall victim to trying to defend one side of a "beef" in the industry bro... In all honesty you're robbing yourself of some good inspirational music. I was like that too back in the day when Joey was goin at it with G-Unit, but then you grow up and start thinking for yourself.
@ZatoSama LMAO that means absolutely nothing, thats like a slutt telling a nun not to lecture her because she has a mean bible collection lol
In all honesty what you're doing is hating, I'm a real hip hop head. Before I make a comment about a rapper or an MC I make sure I know what the hell I'm talking about! In all reality you're being biased because he went against an MC you like. But even though we disagree, I know our positions aint gona change so lets agree to disagree.
of course it means alot, the fact that i listen to more hiphop then you ever will tells that i know if budden got skills or not and compared to most mc's, dude got no lyrics.. i listened to all the tracks in his first album "joe budden" wich was pretty nice actually compared to other average shit i heard and then recently before i posted here i listened to some of the tracks in "padded room".. then i came across this freestyle and some dumb fuck saying hes the greatest rapper
and the fact that some people (like yourself) still talk about what a great rapper he is ticks me off.. its like you compare him to no one special and find him good... how the fuck can someone sit and listen to joe budden when there is TONS of mc's out there dropping hot shit? you dont know shit, i aint hating just stating the facts, dude aint that special AT ALL.. the fact that im a wu tang fan doesnt change the fact that he is average.. comprende? :)
@ZatoSama LMAO you have no Idea, I listen to EVERYBODY!!! I am far from a dickrider, Im a fan of lyricism. I love Wu-Tang, bought dam near every one of their albums. I guess to put it in a way you might understand since you arent a fan, some people (like myself) have had a very rough childhood and had NOTHING, so when you hear a song about shit you been thru, Its like a breath of fresh air. You have obviously never heard this man's whole catalog. Like I said, Agree to Disagree
@ZatoSama cool story bro.. fuck off troll. Go listen to whom you feel.. how can you even argue with someone elses opinion? thats redundant.. how can you sit there and think your opinion is greater? Idiot.
I dont care who you list.. doesnt matter.. not at all..
i will listen to whom ever i feel u quief... bugger off
my opinion IS greater, if u listen to joe budden while kool g rap been dropping the most hardcore shit for 20 years then YOUR reduntant.. fucking misfit
@ZatoSama "IS" Lol.. really? Kool G Rap is a legend.. no doubt.. but music doesnt stop there with him.. idiot..
today: J.Cole,Jay electronica,Asher Roth,Vinny Paz,Ill Bill,Joe Budden,Royce,Crooked I,Joel Ortiz,Earl Sweatshirt.. These guys are carrying the torch for what YOU keep arguing about.. real hip hop.. im not gonna even talk about talib,Mos.. Or Dead Prez. for that fact.. or Slain,Wale or whomever.. What about Pharoah Monch? your point is dismissed.. hip hop isnt about 1 era..
who the hell said that the torch was given to them? are you fucking stupid? kool g rap isnt exactly working at mcdonalds right now, he still making music so why i should listen to a average fag like joe buddens when i can listen to g rap? i didnt say hiphop is about 1 era, i said joe sucks dick, wich he does.. fact that royce and crooked i are in the same group as him blows me away, dude is below average and ive listened to hes pre-school wack albums(2 of them), then i got sik
and if u wanna listen to joe then do it but dont come saying hes the nicest out because thats what i reacted 2 from the start until u cunts came along talking about era's and me being a wu tang fan thus hating on joe buddens.. dude is wack, period
@ZatoSama you know what,your right.. im a huge wu tang fan too! I understand why youd say that tho.. after listening to the grimey era.. and people like dead prez.. i agree.. joe's average,i was a bit of a fan boy reacting,i apologize good sir.. i still love joes music tho.. he's got some dope ass songs,imo.. but hes not the greatest,ur right.. so there sir,i agree on that..
also, the fact that you said im robbing myself of "good inspirational music" just cuz im not listening to budden 24/7 is fucking hilarious... inspirational HAHHAAHAHAHHAHA what a fucking joke, your the one that been robbing yourself of good hiphop music when you decided that this is inspirational shit hahahahaah "Guess what y'all? I know magic, I could make your pulse dissapear and no hat trick"... how inspirational ahhaahh budden dropping inspirational bars!
@ZatoSama That comment alone shows how absolutely ignorant you are when It comes to lyrics. How on earth are you gona talk about something you know nothing about??? Please save yourself the trouble of trying to convince people who HAVE hear Joey, that he is average because he's not. All you're doing is using MC's to protect yourself and your ignorant and biased opinions. Its obvious you arent intelligent enough to comprehend his lyrics lol No wonder you dont like Joey LMAO
@ZatoSama I was reading the back and forth with the other dudes and Ill never say hes the deepest dopest emcee alive, but what makes you say hes wack? Hes a talented dude. And smart too. Capitalizing off of an emo mixtape series...
he is wack compared to mcs that actually matter. well of course he is talented, all people that make it in this business or in ANY business is talented in some way but what does that have to do with anything? hes smart? how the hell u know hes smart? i dont know him, he might be retarded or a pure genius but that doesnt matter much.. dude is just wack to the ones i consider worth listening to... even royce 5'9 makes him look like a fool
also, judging by this video he seems ignorant, childish.. but i cant judge him for this video alone.. dude is just lame and needs to step his lyrics up and his attitude before he can be considered a good mc
Big l... Actually, hes legendary and beyond good but ill go for him.. kool g rap is good.. hell ROYCE is fucking good, joe is average... just compare him to royce da 5'9 and royce isnt even amongst the best... so you tell me why anyone would claim that budden is good.. sure hes good but it all comes down to who you compare him with doesnt it and since i listen to good shit, i feel budden is average
@ZatoSama Royce is one of my favorite MCs, and that's one of my favorite songs. But aside from the flow on it, it isn't as great as you make it out to be.
@ZatoSama Well thats because you either need to get your ears checked or you're simply too ignorant to understand this man's complex metaphors... Listen to "Dear Diary", "Black Cloud", "Inseparable", "Pray for Me", "3 Sides to a Story"... shit and the list goes on, you tell me ANY MC that is as talented in EVERY category wether its; beef records, story telling shit, punchlines, flow, and just raw ass emotion other than Nas and Em without a biased opinion and Joey'll match it song for song.
@07liberian my point is the album wasn't nearly as great as some classic platinum albums. the album was trash outside a few songs, and shouldn't even be spoken in the same sentence as the black album, ill matic etc. come on son you don't need me to break everything down for you do you? Incoherent fuck.
OMG "Real Hip Hop" Fans Are So Fake. They Bitch And Moan All Day Everyday About How "Hip Hop Is Dead" And All Types Of Shit, But When A "Real Hip Hop" Album Comes Out NOBODY SUPPORTS IT.
The Slaughterhouse Album Should Be Platinum By Now But IT'S NOT EVEN CLOSE, Only 50,000 Sold.
The Same Thing Will Happen To Budden's Album, Technique's Album Etc Etc Until These Assholes Stop Talking And Start Walking To The Record Store And Buy The Damn Albums.
damn you stupid as fxck, record sales don't mean shit anymore, platinum CD's are CD's that are controlled to go platinum, people even buy their own albums (their label does just to make sure it does good). enlighten yourself sheep.
joe buddins a straight biter!!! Bit the song from Ellay Khule called 'Who Killed Hip hop'. Ellay came up with the concept in 2004 and Slow Joe came out with his weak ass version in 2008. Come on joe go make your money somewhere else man, leave hip hop to the true artist. trying to take someone elses work and claim it....fucin thief! Getcha own style boy! make sure and listen to 2:02 for the truth bout it! YOU TUBE >> search sloppy joe vido.joe budden diss
Joe is a true MC. I used to think he had no emotion in his raps, until I seen this lol. He's raw.
ChaseWilsonMusiq 1 week ago
@xdivision100 I did and I still think he's trash, lol. Just a couple of good punchlines, thats it. Lil B destroyed him, and hes garbage
psylence81 1 week ago
Joe's got issues ..
YungJoshii 2 weeks ago
DOPE
TonyTheDisciple 3 weeks ago
Joe Buddens is trash, he has a few good punchlines, but other than that he sucks
psylence81 1 month ago
@psylence81 agreed
EmceeSlick4life 3 weeks ago
@psylence81 listen to the cypher he did at the bet awards
xdivision100 1 week ago
I aint here for none of that shit, fuck all that! Joey is a fucking beast, better than the rest, nobody can touch him.
SuperSeth28 1 month ago
@SuperSeth28 Hows you a thug and you superman? Just seened you in tha club doing the superman!
SuperSeth28 1 month ago
Yo if you didnt mess with Joe before this or started doubting him. This should make you a fan or bring you back in the fold. That boy be killing them.
ChocolateGiant716 1 month ago
"I figured out why men try us cuz we OD on rims and thin tires for that we Len Bias"
"Take the rachet go home and just Chris Benoit"
gross3634 2 months ago
what's the beat he spittin' on ?
yellowdimellow 2 months ago
@yellowdimellow onyx ft dead prez - last dayz reloaded
illezTKicko 1 month ago
I LOVE THAT LINE "US COWBOYS DONT NEED YOU BILL PARCEL" LMAO
karwanGoTSwaGG86 3 months ago
only dude that would do that, other rappers would get at their manager, and his manager would get at lantern. stood for his shit. fuck if youont like it.
jaredabunn 3 months ago
that was unecassary to be such an asshole, i like him less now
mr76dukestah 3 months ago
@mr76dukestah wow!! If all it took was a bad mood for you to flake on him, then you a fake fan... #FanBoyFail
shiggadee 2 months ago in playlist Joe Budden
@shiggadee nahh i love his music, always will, hes just kind of a dick. thats all
mr76dukestah 2 months ago
"Been in tha bing for dayz,show u how im real-come home to tha truck with tha Optimums Prime grill!!"........Dope ass line from Budden!
stephen205able 3 months ago
how weird for joey be in the room with mad roc lol
mcgowan311 4 months ago
joey is one nice mc i love the way styles p is just watching him but no diss to buddens but he cant fuck with styles p that guy is too fuckin real
slickpulla07 4 months ago
NEW RANSOM VIDEO !!!!
BEWARE
RASHEED45scientific 4 months ago
the green room, sucka shit hostility , I think joe needs a chill pill
komicmaka 5 months ago
HE FUCKIN BODIED THAT BEAT
LH2OLH2O 5 months ago
HIP-HOP battle rap line....call 218-862-4272.......ITS FREE AND WE GOT HUNDREDS OF KILLAH SPITTAZ....also cash prize tournies and battles!
MusicYoungMoney 6 months ago
25 people do the superman in the clubs
BackTheRow 6 months ago 2
whoever thinks any member of the WU can spit even almost as good as JOE BUDDEN your on drugs Joe Budden will outspit any wu member on his worst day
TheFatMack 7 months ago
@TheFatMack LMAO you're a fucking retard
flyingpowerlogitech 6 months ago
@flyingpowerlogitech no not at all not one person in the wu can spit like joe budden the wu sucks right now joe budden will outspit 95% of the rap game matter of fact there is not even 8 emcees that can outspit joe budden bar for bar
TheFatMack 6 months ago
@TheFatMack raekwon, ghostface killah, meth and the gza would outspit joe budden anyday... but i respect your opinion so its cool
flyingpowerlogitech 6 months ago
@flyingpowerlogitech naw guy not even close i used to love the wu but real talk they fell off YEARS AGO and joe got too many bars for them dudes he could go at then solo and them all together and it would still be light work
TheFatMack 6 months ago
@TheFatMack Are U nuts?? Bout "WU fell off"!! LMAO!! U'r tellin' me Raekwon fell off??? Genius fell off??? Dawg, U'r chopped!!! Joey does has bars, but don't get it twisted. Raekwon's style ALONE is murderous nvm. And I'm not even gonna talk bout GZA. Mef is the only one U could say isn't as raw. The smaller members weren't all that to begin w.
Chaingeeazi 6 months ago
@Chaingeeazi the wu has fell off and thats just facts and rae got 1 good album and that was his 1st joint the rest are TRASH rae is wack GHOST is nice GZA is nice the rest of the clan are weak or just pure wack
TheFatMack 6 months ago
@TheFatMack A lot of good rappers don't make good albums. I wouldn't listen to a Beans or Freeway album but they're ill.
Chaingeeazi 6 months ago
@Chaingeeazi beans first 2 albums were dope his first album is a pure clasic hip hop album and free is not ill he is ok
TheFatMack 6 months ago 2
@flyingpowerlogitech no they won't! they even said there not battle rappers. look it up on youtube. Joe already challenged them.
mrwhatever213 6 months ago
@TheFatMack what about Killa Priest? or cappa or ghost, or rae or Gza ? The most budden could do wit any of dem is say somethin cleva then get murdered. people act like wu fell off but ..." they best Karate still inside" lol I respect your view but i gotta disagree Joe is sick but... I don't think he could catch them dudes I just mentioned.
soulestial 6 months ago
@soulestial i like killah priest i actually got ALL his album and IMO he is the BEST member outta the WU period BUT no way can he go bar for bar against Joe budden bar for bar i dont think there are even 5 rappers in hip hop that can hang wit joey no questions
TheFatMack 6 months ago
@TheFatMack wel I geuss we are talking 2 different realms... in a battle eventually there are plenty of Mc' that I feel could bury Joe Lyrically but as u suggest a bar for bar marathon a few mc's come to my mind. Consider the following, AZ, Mos Def, Redman, Kool G Rap these guys share the same never say die mentality when it comes to bar for bar on the spot no inspiration necessary.
soulestial 6 months ago
@TheFatMack wel I geuss we are talking 2 different realms... in a battle eventually there are plenty of Mc' that I feel could bury Joe Lyrically but as u suggest a bar for bar marathon a few mc's come to my mind. , AZ, Mos Def, Redman, Kool G Rap, Busta Rhymes these guys share the never say die mentality when it comes to bar for bar on the spot no inspiration necessary obliterate ya with no hesitation. Joe is just some one who just wants to out talk ya .yes it takes skillbut it gets corny.fast
soulestial 6 months ago
@soulestial LOLOLOLOL mos def sucks az had 1 great verse in his career and has still never done anything even close to his verson on nas first cd redman has good punchlines but thats about it kool g rap is a og i give him props but its not 1991 its 2011 and busta is a hot 16 when he spits fast but lyrically not even close to joe budden
TheFatMack 6 months ago
@TheFatMack I disagree about az and mos. I would agree their attempts at mainstream success have fallen short but cmon dude.. feel 4 u, uncut raw ,rather unique, not to mention AZ's latest ..cmon dude.. can't judge skill by that standard alone ...Joe for instance... alot of brothas dissed his first album and called it garbage now all the sudden he ill. He only had pump it up it banged 4 a few months and then....nothin... But like i told dudes back then u can't front on skill and joe got it
soulestial 6 months ago
@soulestial every one of Joe budden MOOD MUZIK 1,2,3,4 and 4.5 mixtapes smash anything mos and at has EVER put out put together
TheFatMack 6 months ago
Comment removed
rennyren77 6 months ago
@TheFatMack Your buggn`. So all the Mood Muzik's are better than AZ's Do or Die and Mos Def's Black on Both sides.......really?
hiphopfanatic101 5 months ago
@TheFatMack YES THEY ARE mos is not even almost close to Joe budden and AZ is a 1 verse wonder dude is still living off NAS verse he has NEVER lived up to that 1 verse hype thats still his best verse he ever spit come on son Joe budden will out spit both of them on his worst day
TheFatMack 5 months ago
@TheFatMack COME ON BUDDY you smoking something if you seriously think Joe Budden bar for bar is fucking with AZ. AZ has had success in mainstream, not as much as people would have liked to see, but even bigger success as an underground artist. if you ask me id rather blow up underground then mainstream. And how is he still living off Nas, AZ has had 3 classic albums, all with lyrical mastery. joe has had none. Joe is nice but get real you cant put him in the catergory of AZ he is 1 of the GOAT
DMVaReAkID 5 months ago
@DMVaReAkID AZ is actually better then NaS, thats why their whole beef started. NaS was upset and said that he didnt want to work with anyone who sounded better then him on his own track
DMVaReAkID 5 months ago
@DMVaReAkID joe budden wil outspit AZ on his worse day easy
and AZ has ZERO classics dude has 1 classic VERSE and thats IT AZ hasnt made anything close to that verse and never will
TheFatMack 5 months ago
@soulestial they can't fuck with joe in a battle. method and ra already said they can't. so stop dick riding.
mrwhatever213 6 months ago
@mrwhatever213 i don't kno u and u don't kno me brotha. I'm jus giving my opinion. Ther's no dick riding here dog ease yo pups .
soulestial 6 months ago
@mrwhatever213 i don't kno u and u don't kno me brotha. I'm jus giving my opinion. Ther's no dick riding here dog ease yo pups . I f they said that then they said it ...I don't kno everything that come out their mouth I'm only saying what I believe ...u don't like it cool that's u ...but pls . don't disrespect me. i know u prolly gotta live up 2 your user name...4 all I know u do... but tha don't mean much to me.
soulestial 6 months ago
hey everybody, if your a fan of eminem, joe budden n da whole slaughterhouse gang or just a general fans of real hip hop, you'll definitly enjoy my music. pleez check me out, i got punchlines n heart felt topics that i touch on and not to mention the quality of the music is more than excellent! listen n subscribe!
jaegunzisback 7 months ago in playlist Joe Budden
See the way Freeway wouldn't shake his hand, but after Jada give him his props about how ILL is his verse was, they was all like.. Ok Joey DOPE! people saying Joey scared? He's smart, he knows what he's doing... #WATCH!
MyPenSpeaks 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Real shit Jump Off one of the nicest niggas doing it.
I remember as a young bol I heard Mood Muzik II, and my fuckin' head exploded, being exposed to real lyricism, story telling and just real shit. You can hear how hungry Joey is, nigga knows he's nicer than most but broker than most. You can hear how frustrated my nigga is.
Search Eddie Pesos "North of Death" and "Hayley", Puerto Rock kid from PA droppin' ill joints on the mic.
PurpleHaze1824 9 months ago
As good as this nigga is, his ego takes away from alot of it
abmujvek1 9 months ago
I figured out why men try us, cuz we O.D. on rims and thin tires, for that we Len Bias
wow that's...that's fuckin FIRE. Joey a BEAST.
JSqAuD14 9 months ago
Lol@Zato for listing one line.. i can list numerous lines from your favs that were pure garbage.. fucking trolls pop up everywhere..
Prologick 9 months ago
Im tripping.. because how can someone tell me how to feel about what joes lyrics mean to me.. Joe is the deepest writer in the game,period.. he's realistic,not the clicheness of some macho MC is supposed to be.. and fuck off with the comparisons.. who cares.. that wont change my opinion.. and my genre started with KRS ONE BDP.. I feel joes lyrics because i can relate.. fuck the over exaggerated hood shit.. C'mon Son FOHWTBS!!!
Prologick 9 months ago
asshole
Akirsch16 10 months ago
JERSEY (201)!!!
FrankPifiorati 11 months ago
They screwed up the original footage. The freestyle was originally over the track by Onyx "Last Dayz.."
step2meNYC 1 year ago
Jay z
buck50Roc 1 year ago
who could go in after that
imahustla50 1 year ago
Why was mouse so heated ?
names667 1 year ago
201!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
NYCORIGINAL 1 year ago
it cracks me up everytime i see this joe just crazy
alotofshots 1 year ago 2
lol, doesnt it suck when ur verse sounds WAY better on another beat.....joey got off
killuminatiplz 1 year ago
Top 5 Dead Or Alive
Buddens is HUNGRY
2shizz 1 year ago
slapped!
8888888A8888888 1 year ago
3:56 for freestyle
toucanboy888 1 year ago
budden is a coward!
theman200830 1 year ago
killleeedd this shit!!! SLAUGHTERHOUSE!!
dmp220 1 year ago
check my channel yall i gat more hot tracks
dboypimp101 1 year ago
Joe Budden is still the d0pest niqqa t0 t0uch a mic since KRS 1
KiDmAcKiN1 1 year ago
dat nigga scared
that nigga a bitch
NoLove931 1 year ago
dat nigga scared
NoLove931 1 year ago
just look at him bitching hahahahahahahaahah
ZatoSama 1 year ago
Hottest in the game today HANDS DOWN!
VIRUS300C 1 year ago
Why is Dis Nigga Movin so ansy and shit...Get Da fuk outta dere if u scared and nervous hoe budden..
TheAnce15 1 year ago
@TheAnce15 wow u sound real sensitive. good verse though
lubui2583 1 year ago
@TheAnce15 He said was up there for once reason. He spit and was out. Thats not nervous and antsy. He just wanted to be about his business and be out.
BigSmurf 1 year ago
u dissin moi, take the ratchit go home n juss chris beniot
ShinySuwoo 1 year ago
I know how Joe feels, That dj mention everybody and when he got to Joe he said who the fuck is this...? Joe should of waited a little before going off and the dj should think about how people might react before taking.
MoDizzle92377 1 year ago
people in here thank think joe budden is the deepest lyricist in the game have no fucking idea what good music is... im outta here, its useless to try make u understand when u think someone like JOE is the deepest lyricist in the game... you people are preschool hahahah
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama then why dont you educate us on who you think a deep lyricist is
koolguy1 1 year ago
@koolguy1
O.C is a deep lyricist... listen to "born to live" and tell me what joe budden song come's REMOTELY close in terms of lyrics, how the bars are written and what the message is... give me a fucking break, KRS-1 is a deep fucking lyricist... hiphop has been around for what, like 40 years? and you think that hiphop gave birth to this average nobody as the "deepest lyricist" in the game? HAHAHAH :D
ZatoSama 1 year ago
what was budden mad about ? and what was he saying about ransom did in the end?
sickvids84 1 year ago
@sickvids84 He was mad because he just got dropped by Def Jam like 5 minutes befopre this was filmed.
xlskidzorzlx 1 year ago
joe's a great rapper, but what a pain in the ass.
mikeavelli1979 1 year ago
@mikeavelli1979 He was mad because he just got dropped by Def Jam like 5 minutes befopre this was filmed.
xlskidzorzlx 1 year ago
@mikeavelli1979 That pretty much sums up his whole career.
BigSmurf 1 year ago
JOE BUDDENS CAN SPIT BUT HES A BITCH BEANS AND FREEWAY REALLY DIDNT SHOW LOVE WHEN THEY WALKED IN...
heebrew313 1 year ago
joe u r shit give up punk
darrenbleech 1 year ago
@darrenbleech yu must be on some good ass shit too think dat joey sucks
i wuld wana kno watever type of shit yu doin so i can do it
Kraz3Crew 1 year ago
@darrenbleech nigga Joe is deep Mood Musik mixtapes are ill you must be a fuckin 106 and park lackey that wears skinny jeans and think lil wayne is good or you a white kid from the suburbs kuz you really on some bullshit
19IndependenVision88 1 year ago
Man Beans would body joe budden
S0GiFTED 1 year ago
@S0GiFTED Never why would u wanna see them beef instead up collabing
grayeyedphreek 1 year ago
@grayeyedphreek idc what they do, i'm jus stating a fact
S0GiFTED 1 year ago
buddens is the shit but that wasn't a freestyle he memorized that for weeks
budfsu2001 1 year ago
@budfsu2001 most rappers dont freestyle, he actually admits that he doesnt(not in this vid) they consider a freestyle nowadays as not having a paper in front of your face to read off of.
Didda3rd 1 year ago
Joey get it in!
exzotik81 1 year ago
was dis before or after the d-block rocafella beef!!!
Gasto876 1 year ago
@Gasto876 before, but buddens doesnt like freeway and beanie becos there with the roc aka gay z (no homo). yeah and beans is now done with the roc
paultrep 1 year ago
@Gasto876 way after.....
k2stypoint 1 year ago
@Gasto876 way after. this is like 2008 and the beef was like 2002
articledon 1 year ago
this shit never gets old!!
ckootood 1 year ago
@ckootood unless u got mood muzik 3, then it gets old real quick. Wasnt even the best verse on the song.
BigSmurf 1 year ago
classic line by Styles P
"don't sit joe buddens in the green room no more like that?" WOOOOO i feel you joe buddens, TIGHT!"
Bstreetz07 1 year ago
joe budden can suck my balls and his children should tie their faggot daddy to the bed and burn his wack ass alive
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama SUC MA 2 INCH DICK MUTHA FUCKER!!!!!! BUDDENS THE NICEST OUT
Gasto876 1 year ago
@Gasto876
fuck you man what the fuck you know about hiphop you inbred piece of shit... joe budden has just as much talent as you do, useless cunt
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama he prolly do....u dont kno me n wta talent i got!!!! its obvious u dont kno hip hop!!! listen to this man lyrics n obvious u are a fan u r here listening.....n " fuck you too man"" lol..u prolly som white bitch from the hamptons....go listen gunz n roses mister lol
Gasto876 1 year ago
@Gasto876
i can mention at least 300 mc's that are better than joe in every aspect.... you are just 2 much of a retard to know good hiphop when you hear it,... also, what does it matter if im white and from the hamptons? it doesnt change the fact that you have no idea about what you talking about... method man smacked joe and proved joe is nothing but a cunt, thus having cunt fans like urself
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama alright go ahead......name 300 mc's that are better than JOE BUDDEN!!!go ahead name them.....ill be waiting...fuckin dumb retard,,,,deepest lyricist in the game.....NAME 300 MC'S THAT ARE BETTER RIGHT NOW!!!!!
Gasto876 1 year ago 2
@Gasto876
@Gasto876
Ill give you 30 since your a waste of time:
Starang wondah, krs-1, nas, immortal technique, buckshot, az, freddie foxxx, louieville sluggah, tek, steele, too poetic, royce 5'9, method man, shabazz the disciple, redman, b-real, gza, a&g, big punisher, 12 o'clock, big l, sean price, busta rhymes, stic man, masta ace, m-, inspecta deck
you are fucking hilarious if you think joe budden is the deepest lyricist in the game... what a fucking joke hahahahhahahahaahhahahah
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama DO U PEOPLE HEAR DIS FUKIN CLOWN...HE NAME ALL THOSE N NOT EVEN MENTION PAC OOR BIGGIE.....U CANT SAY NUTTIN TO ME NEMORE....N B-REAL????? R U SERIOUS.... MAN HE IS THE DEEPEST RIGHT NOW I NTHE GAME....DONT REPLY TO ME OBBVIOUSLY U DOTN KNO SHYT
Gasto876 1 year ago
@ZatoSama all those people are good emcee's and writers of their time.. but joe seems to incorporate all those and blend them together without a flaw.. he is the deepest writer/emcee of our time.. no joke.. joe speaks realistically and from the heart,no compromise.. Pac+Biggie=Joe budden
Prologick 1 year ago
Comment removed
ZatoSama 1 year ago
Half those people aren't deep at all. Amazing lyricists, but not deep... You mean to tell me "I got a big dick bitch... that aint a punchline, i got a big dick bitch" is deep? get the fuck outta here.
xlskidzorzlx 1 year ago
@xlskidzorzlx nigga thats not a good example lol if u gonna diss his shit then pick an actual deep song from him smh
goldenhoward1 1 year ago
@ZatoSama youre a fucking joke... busta rhymes lyrically better than joe budden? not a fucking chance.. big l more lyrical? not a fucking chance.. REDMAN???? no fucking CHANCE.. gtfo faggot
L3athaface 3 months ago
@L3athaface
hahahahahahaahahhahaahahahahah wow... sorry man i was wrong, budden is better than all the ones i mentioned.. be quiet now
ZatoSama 3 months ago
@ZatoSama dude your belittling yourself.. joe is a human like you.. dude you wouldnt of did shit with seven niggaz around you.. i dand it wasnt method man either.. it was some random dude in reakwons click.. stupid.. get your facts right.
Prologick 1 year ago
@ZatoSama No, you can't name 300 mc's that are better than Joe. That's a joke. You can't even name 300 MC's better than 50 Cent. And good job spelling too, as 2..
And on another note, learn your facts before you start chirping on youtube. Method Man never touched Joe, Raekwon did, and when Royce confronted him about it later (go watch the vid on youtube), Raekwon bitched out. Your inability to come up with any insult other than the use of the word cunt just proves you should stop posting now.
xlskidzorzlx 1 year ago
@ZatoSama LMAO wow kid, you are the true definition of a hater!! Who you listen to?? You must be a wu-tang dickrider huh? lol Dont fall victim to trying to defend one side of a "beef" in the industry bro... In all honesty you're robbing yourself of some good inspirational music. I was like that too back in the day when Joey was goin at it with G-Unit, but then you grow up and start thinking for yourself.
LeadSpillz 10 months ago
@LeadSpillz
Go into my fav's section and tell me if your in a position to lecture me on hiphop music.. you clueless fucking inbred
ZatoSama 10 months ago
@ZatoSama LMAO that means absolutely nothing, thats like a slutt telling a nun not to lecture her because she has a mean bible collection lol
In all honesty what you're doing is hating, I'm a real hip hop head. Before I make a comment about a rapper or an MC I make sure I know what the hell I'm talking about! In all reality you're being biased because he went against an MC you like. But even though we disagree, I know our positions aint gona change so lets agree to disagree.
LeadSpillz 10 months ago
@LeadSpillz
of course it means alot, the fact that i listen to more hiphop then you ever will tells that i know if budden got skills or not and compared to most mc's, dude got no lyrics.. i listened to all the tracks in his first album "joe budden" wich was pretty nice actually compared to other average shit i heard and then recently before i posted here i listened to some of the tracks in "padded room".. then i came across this freestyle and some dumb fuck saying hes the greatest rapper
ZatoSama 10 months ago
@LeadSpillz
and the fact that some people (like yourself) still talk about what a great rapper he is ticks me off.. its like you compare him to no one special and find him good... how the fuck can someone sit and listen to joe budden when there is TONS of mc's out there dropping hot shit? you dont know shit, i aint hating just stating the facts, dude aint that special AT ALL.. the fact that im a wu tang fan doesnt change the fact that he is average.. comprende? :)
ZatoSama 10 months ago
@ZatoSama LMAO you have no Idea, I listen to EVERYBODY!!! I am far from a dickrider, Im a fan of lyricism. I love Wu-Tang, bought dam near every one of their albums. I guess to put it in a way you might understand since you arent a fan, some people (like myself) have had a very rough childhood and had NOTHING, so when you hear a song about shit you been thru, Its like a breath of fresh air. You have obviously never heard this man's whole catalog. Like I said, Agree to Disagree
LeadSpillz 10 months ago
@ZatoSama cool story bro.. fuck off troll. Go listen to whom you feel.. how can you even argue with someone elses opinion? thats redundant.. how can you sit there and think your opinion is greater? Idiot.
I dont care who you list.. doesnt matter.. not at all..
Prologick 9 months ago
@Prologick
i will listen to whom ever i feel u quief... bugger off
my opinion IS greater, if u listen to joe budden while kool g rap been dropping the most hardcore shit for 20 years then YOUR reduntant.. fucking misfit
ZatoSama 9 months ago
@ZatoSama "IS" Lol.. really? Kool G Rap is a legend.. no doubt.. but music doesnt stop there with him.. idiot..
today: J.Cole,Jay electronica,Asher Roth,Vinny Paz,Ill Bill,Joe Budden,Royce,Crooked I,Joel Ortiz,Earl Sweatshirt.. These guys are carrying the torch for what YOU keep arguing about.. real hip hop.. im not gonna even talk about talib,Mos.. Or Dead Prez. for that fact.. or Slain,Wale or whomever.. What about Pharoah Monch? your point is dismissed.. hip hop isnt about 1 era..
Prologick 9 months ago
@Prologick
who the hell said that the torch was given to them? are you fucking stupid? kool g rap isnt exactly working at mcdonalds right now, he still making music so why i should listen to a average fag like joe buddens when i can listen to g rap? i didnt say hiphop is about 1 era, i said joe sucks dick, wich he does.. fact that royce and crooked i are in the same group as him blows me away, dude is below average and ive listened to hes pre-school wack albums(2 of them), then i got sik
ZatoSama 9 months ago
@Prologick
and if u wanna listen to joe then do it but dont come saying hes the nicest out because thats what i reacted 2 from the start until u cunts came along talking about era's and me being a wu tang fan thus hating on joe buddens.. dude is wack, period
ZatoSama 9 months ago
@ZatoSama you know what,your right.. im a huge wu tang fan too! I understand why youd say that tho.. after listening to the grimey era.. and people like dead prez.. i agree.. joe's average,i was a bit of a fan boy reacting,i apologize good sir.. i still love joes music tho.. he's got some dope ass songs,imo.. but hes not the greatest,ur right.. so there sir,i agree on that..
Prologick 9 months ago
@LeadSpillz
also, the fact that you said im robbing myself of "good inspirational music" just cuz im not listening to budden 24/7 is fucking hilarious... inspirational HAHHAAHAHAHHAHA what a fucking joke, your the one that been robbing yourself of good hiphop music when you decided that this is inspirational shit hahahahaah "Guess what y'all? I know magic, I could make your pulse dissapear and no hat trick"... how inspirational ahhaahh budden dropping inspirational bars!
ZatoSama 10 months ago
@ZatoSama That comment alone shows how absolutely ignorant you are when It comes to lyrics. How on earth are you gona talk about something you know nothing about??? Please save yourself the trouble of trying to convince people who HAVE hear Joey, that he is average because he's not. All you're doing is using MC's to protect yourself and your ignorant and biased opinions. Its obvious you arent intelligent enough to comprehend his lyrics lol No wonder you dont like Joey LMAO
LeadSpillz 10 months ago
@ZatoSama you really think method man is the one who smacked joe??????
lmfao
L3athaface 3 months ago
@ZatoSama I was reading the back and forth with the other dudes and Ill never say hes the deepest dopest emcee alive, but what makes you say hes wack? Hes a talented dude. And smart too. Capitalizing off of an emo mixtape series...
BigSmurf 1 year ago
@BigSmurf
he is wack compared to mcs that actually matter. well of course he is talented, all people that make it in this business or in ANY business is talented in some way but what does that have to do with anything? hes smart? how the hell u know hes smart? i dont know him, he might be retarded or a pure genius but that doesnt matter much.. dude is just wack to the ones i consider worth listening to... even royce 5'9 makes him look like a fool
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@BigSmurf m
also, judging by this video he seems ignorant, childish.. but i cant judge him for this video alone.. dude is just lame and needs to step his lyrics up and his attitude before he can be considered a good mc
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama Who do u consider a good MC?
EverybodyAVictim 1 year ago
@EverybodyAVictim
Big l... Actually, hes legendary and beyond good but ill go for him.. kool g rap is good.. hell ROYCE is fucking good, joe is average... just compare him to royce da 5'9 and royce isnt even amongst the best... so you tell me why anyone would claim that budden is good.. sure hes good but it all comes down to who you compare him with doesnt it and since i listen to good shit, i feel budden is average
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama Royce can outflow Budden, hands down. Budden is better in every other category.
RakimAllah777 1 year ago
@RakimAllah777
ahhahahaha show me 1 budden track that is better than royce - king of kings overall.. plz hit me :)
ZatoSama 1 year ago
@ZatoSama Royce is one of my favorite MCs, and that's one of my favorite songs. But aside from the flow on it, it isn't as great as you make it out to be.
3 Sides to a Story>>> as far a storytelling
Pray for me>>>
Dumb Out>>>
Stand Up Nucca>>>
RakimAllah777 1 year ago
@ZatoSama Well thats because you either need to get your ears checked or you're simply too ignorant to understand this man's complex metaphors... Listen to "Dear Diary", "Black Cloud", "Inseparable", "Pray for Me", "3 Sides to a Story"... shit and the list goes on, you tell me ANY MC that is as talented in EVERY category wether its; beef records, story telling shit, punchlines, flow, and just raw ass emotion other than Nas and Em without a biased opinion and Joey'll match it song for song.
LeadSpillz 10 months ago
if these dudes live then im the created player?
seriously? ha ha ha damm...
rbthaSMOKA 1 year ago
Comment removed
rbthaSMOKA 1 year ago
sound like he got robbed
lubui2583 1 year ago
"If these niggas is live, I must be the creative player." Dumb niggas won't even catch that line..
YoungHandsome31 1 year ago
@YoungHandsome31 *Created
RakimAllah777 1 year ago
@YoungHandsome31 LOL LOL...HARDBODY!!!!! AM AN EDITED PLAYER U FEEL ME LOL
Gasto876 1 year ago
YOu dissing muah??... take the ratchet go home and just chris benoit!!
lilherm85 1 year ago 8
@lilherm85 muah as in Jadakiss? i dont think so with Styles P there
billzdar 1 year ago
Moi as in me
chez372 1 year ago
@billzdar muah as in me!!
lilherm85 1 year ago
whats the name of the beat he freestyled to?
jad1793 1 year ago
onyx -last dayz
beastydon 1 year ago
thanks
jad1793 1 year ago
Top 5 free style of all time!!! period
CTCJOHNNY 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jesusinawhitetee I Can Name A Million Rap Albums That Was'nt Classic Quality That Still Went Platinum...So Whats Your Point ???
07liberian 1 year ago
@07liberian my point is the album wasn't nearly as great as some classic platinum albums. the album was trash outside a few songs, and shouldn't even be spoken in the same sentence as the black album, ill matic etc. come on son you don't need me to break everything down for you do you? Incoherent fuck.
jesusinawhitetee 1 year ago
Acapella the whole left side of his chest.
union410 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OMG "Real Hip Hop" Fans Are So Fake. They Bitch And Moan All Day Everyday About How "Hip Hop Is Dead" And All Types Of Shit, But When A "Real Hip Hop" Album Comes Out NOBODY SUPPORTS IT.
The Slaughterhouse Album Should Be Platinum By Now But IT'S NOT EVEN CLOSE, Only 50,000 Sold.
The Same Thing Will Happen To Budden's Album, Technique's Album Etc Etc Until These Assholes Stop Talking And Start Walking To The Record Store And Buy The Damn Albums.
07liberian 1 year ago
@07liberian No, the slaughterhouse album is no where near classic quality so why would it be platinum? And they didn't even sell 50k.
jesusinawhitetee 1 year ago
Comment removed
07liberian 1 year ago
nigga shut ya hatin azz up! u write a fuckin rap verse and hear how ya wacka flocka azz sound! slaughterhouse top 4 alive
beastydon 1 year ago
damn you stupid as fxck, record sales don't mean shit anymore, platinum CD's are CD's that are controlled to go platinum, people even buy their own albums (their label does just to make sure it does good). enlighten yourself sheep.
ReggieBailey31 1 year ago 38
@ReggieBailey31 Whoa son you went in,on whoever (LOL), but that shit is so true.
step2meNYC 1 year ago
joe budden wants this beat to be on
Gangsta4Life17 1 year ago
wow what a chump...does he think he's cool or something?
treyslap 1 year ago
Put your family in a box, meet the brady bunch.. hahaha.. joe budden is top 5 material, hands down..
frankC317 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
joe buddins a straight biter!!! Bit the song from Ellay Khule called 'Who Killed Hip hop'. Ellay came up with the concept in 2004 and Slow Joe came out with his weak ass version in 2008. Come on joe go make your money somewhere else man, leave hip hop to the true artist. trying to take someone elses work and claim it....fucin thief! Getcha own style boy! make sure and listen to 2:02 for the truth bout it! YOU TUBE >> search sloppy joe vido.joe budden diss
sickboy0130 1 year ago
does anybody knows the beat in the beginning of the video
emonstar87 1 year ago