There is comparison... Seger's live version is perfect. Metallica's is just another bar band copying it. The production is good, but they lose any possiblity of musical viablity once they kick in the Marshalls. From there on it's just another wall of noise.
I love both versions.
holtzpackerfan 2 years ago
thats good
cheatsago456 2 years ago
i was going to put the live version of Bob Seger's Turn the Page, but i couldn't find it :P
cheatsago456 2 years ago
There is comparison... Seger's live version is perfect. Metallica's is just another bar band copying it. The production is good, but they lose any possiblity of musical viablity once they kick in the Marshalls. From there on it's just another wall of noise.
ih8thishit 2 years ago
I agree. I'm a Metallica fan bu you just can't make a good song out of a wall of noise AND you can't replace a saxophone, you just can't.
Segers live version IS perfect, awesomely brilliant.
Dogutopia1 2 years ago
bob seger's is better
segerfan 2 years ago 2