Added: 5 years ago
From: shipperheart
Views: 59,953
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (150)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Someday is a lovely song, but it didn't really fit the moment. In the stage musical it fits perfectly in the moment and it's one of the strongest numbers.

  • Someday is a beautiful song. Celtic Women did a version of it. :)

  • I do prefer "God Help the Outcasts", but seeing this makes me like "Someday" more. It didn't seem to fit at all with the pop version even though I like All-4-One. I didn't mind the happy ending in the movie. I guess the stage production is more similar to the book, but that ending was very sad and disturbing.

  • i think that "god help the outcasts" guaranties much more goosebumps than "someday"

  • While I agree that it works better as a humbling moment in the context of the movie, this version of the scene is still beautiful. Now WHEN are they going to release an American 2-disc DVD with the deleted scenes and tons of other stuff?? The 10th anniversary came and went, the 15th anniversary came and went - how long do we have to wait???

  • Hands down the best version of this song.

  • they need to make a special edtition of the HUnchback of Notre Dame dvd.

  • Why hasnt this been realsed in the US ?

  • This reminds me of Thumbelina's 'Soon'.

  • @ZydrateCupcake exactly what it reminded me lol memories

  • I like the decision made by the directors. Someday wasn't right for the moment and was a much better ending song. God Help the Outcasts fitted Esmeralda's plight in that scene perfectly, whereas Someday represented the coming of a better day after the movie.

  • @hunchbackofNDluver it's ok.....I am too XD lol

  • i agree with the directors on this. but hey, Someday wasn't completely lost All-4-One did a great version during the end credits ^^

  • @GoddessOfWhim2003 Check out the version by the great late Broadway actress Laurie Beechman it's also great!

  • :'-(

  • This song is nice, but God help the Outcast in better in the show. Someday is a rather hopeful song, and Esmeralda is feeling rather sad at the moment

  • @Queerlioness MUCH LIKE I HAVE ALWAYS SAID ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR MOVIE. NICELY SAID. GOD HELP THE OUT CASTS WAS MUCH MORE FITTING BECAUSE IT WAS MORE OF A PLEA FOR HELP.

  • I wish I could find a picture of Heidi Mollenhauer.

  • @xlefreakcestchic

    I wish I could find anything of Heidi Mollenhauer. The poor woman seems to have disappeared.

  • Atleast it survived to be in the credits...

  • I wish they had kept this. It would have been amazing to see. It sounds beautiful.

  • ok fuck youtube, where is my HoND disc?!

  • i love it when she sings "Someday, my fight will be won then," :) BEAUTIFUL!!!! i SOOOOO UBER wish they kept this song in the movie :(

  • I love her voice!

  • Asmerelda is my absolute fav. disney character, Megara is a close second. however Asmerelda sacrifices everything for the purpose of making life good for all and she even risks her life for quasie before she even knew him solely for the purpose of it being the right thing to do. then later in the movie after he rescues her she risks her life for him again by trying to pull him back in from the ledge of a balcony that Frollo was gonna kill them both on.

  • I definitely like this, the original, version better than the pop version that is on the CD, but I'd have to say that "God Help The Outcasts" is a bit more fitting for the situation Esmeralda is in in this scene, as well as the theme of the movie. But, they're both good songs. I just can't stand the pop version by All-4-One . . . ^_^;

  • @Moyayuhi I actually agree Heidi doe's this song better justice but 'Someday" does seem to have hope and I feel since she's praying and in all intents and purposes 'God help the outcast' seems like a prayer because she had little hope and she was asking for something to look forward to.

  • It was good, but I definitely like God Help The Outcasts better. That one seems more fitting for her situation.

  • I honestly can't decide which one I prefer, both God Help the Outcasts and Someday are beautiful songs, but I agree that GHtO fits a little better with the movie.

  • The scetches are trueling beautiful in this sequence, not to mention the singer is as well.

  • i think 'someday' is more tragically heartfelt... like my heart tugged at her plea

    but i also think they were right to keep 'God help the outcasts' b/c it sounded more like a prayer and it was more powerful and it just FIT u no? lol i couldnt imagine anything else but that being there..

    both songs are absolutely beautiful

  • I would have to respectfully disagree it gave me the feeling like she had hope that someday things will be different, and Gold Help the Outcasts sounded like a plea to god in my own opinion but either way they are both just georgous songs

  • hey np! dissent is encouraged!

    thx for not freakn out like some ppl would if they disagreed and so i completely respect your opinions! i also agree that both songs are so so beautiful

  • np lolz I thinks it's retarded and so immature to write a long rant out of anger . when I read those all people r like arrrgg... this is a waste of time. but when I read that all i think is then why waste more time being angry for stupid reasons lolz.

  • lol completely agree!

  • glad you agree lolz : )

  • i prefer the outcast.

  • I sang that song for my school spring concert away back in March. It was the first solo that I have ever done and it was a huge success.

  • thats great congrats!

  • good I'm glad for you : )

  • I prefer the Outcast one more.

  • I heard this on youtube one day, and I knew it wasn't actually in the film, so I got really confused...

    Then I finally realised where I'd heard it.

    It's actually heard as a background score throughout some parts of the movie...and the credits, of course. But I'm so glad I found it. its really lovely =]

  • why can't I find this song anywhere to download only the versions of Eternal and All 4 One.

  • Because it was a deleted song I guess and maybe people don't feel like ripping it. And Disney doesn't want to give the US and Canada a special edition DVD with all the cool special features like this one. This WOULD be awesome to have on my iPod, but I'm okay with the All-4-One version.

  • If you don't have this version I have it.

  • I don't have it

  • that was so pretty.

  • would have been so beautiful if she sang the song and then he drops some of the candle holders so she hears him and says: Wait. where are you going? and she follows him and they fell in love.

  • I like the song, but in my opinion, while "God Help The Outcasts" shows Esmerelda as a selfless crusader, while "Someday" paints her as rather selfish.

  • i completely disagree, the song basically is esmerelda praying someday her fight for equal rigts for her ppl will be over and she will be free to be herself without being persecuted for witch craft etc

  • i agree god help the outcast always makes me cry when i see it especially at the part where she says "I ask for nothing, I can get by..." after all the other people asked for very selfish things like for wealth, love and for god to bless THEM

  • That's why I love it too. It's like the story of the Good Samaritan that those we least suspect can have the most goodness and humility.

  • this song is truly beautiful and powerful!!! I too would have loved to see its finished version. if only they finished all 3 deleted songs, the storyboards are really beautiful, but a finished version would have been priceless. The orchestration exactly in the beginning where she says "in your house of peace and beauty" really gave me goosebumps!! the message of the song is truly powerful. 2 thumbs up to Alan Menken and the artists!

  • I would love to see this is a finished version, animated, I mean :D

  • this song makes me cry

  • The pop version of this song plays during the credits and is sung by All 4 One. Excerpts of the music can also be heard throughout the movie at key points.

  • Yeah, it's weird it wasn't technically in the film in it's completed form, but now that I've heard it I can pick up where it is in the score when I watch the movie... lovely :)

  • Haha. I can too, every time I heard while watching it the other day, I was like, "OMG. Someday!"

    Teehee, my family though I was crazy.

  • no wonder! i was like wait, i KNOW i've heard this song. haha.

  • why did they cut this song from the movie?

    this version was the most beautiful i've ever heard

    luv this version

  • The best songs from the old Disney movies were the credit songs. This one, "If I never knew you" from Pochahontas, and I love "True to your Heart" from Mulan.

  • mmmm....that is pretty. I'm glad Someday was expanded into the whole song that was sung by Celtic Woman (I wasn't a fan of the ending credits version of it from this movie). It's a good song to listen to over and over. I love singing along :D.

  • I love the spansih version of this song. Sung by Luis Miguel

  • um.. but this WAS animated... when i was little i used to watch it all the time.. and "Someday" was my favorite song.. lol.. so i know they animated it.. Im confused now. But i watched it in spanish, so idk if thats the reason..

  • um i think your talking about god help the outcast's though i swear i`ve heard this song before?and no i know the titles are this song but it isn`t that!lol

  • They did use this song in the movie. It's featured in the credits, but a different band sings it. maybe thats where you remember it from

  • big for the moment? BIG DEAL! You two should have added another scene.. just for this spectacular song!

  • ok this is what should of happened in disney's hunchback.

    Esmeralda sings god help the outcasts in the notre dame.

    Then in the scene that esmeralda was supposed to be in the dungeon, she should have sang someday in there!

    That would have been so perfect!

    Disney pisses me off sometimes =[

  • That's what they do in the musical.

  • Wich scene esmeralda is supposed to be in a dingeon..??? I don't remember...

  • It's in the German musical, Der Glockner Von Notre Dame, which is being re-vamped for the American stage. I think it's used after Frollo captures all the gypsies in the Court of Miracles (I haven't seen the show).

  • yes, you're right. it transitions the jail to the pyre

  • Does Esmeralda and Quasimodo die in the Der Glöckner von Notre Dame? Or is it the same ending in the Disney film?

  • the show version?

    esmeralda dies :(

    she gets torched for witchcraft :(

    but quasimodo lives and throws frollo off the bell tower. :)

  • Well, at least they got it right for the most part. Thanks.

  • You know, I kind of appreciate that they tried to make it more like the book, but if it is ever brought to America, which I heard it might be, I kind of want it to stay like the movie.

  • Esmeralda dies, Quasimodo lives

  • This song should have been added to the movie!

    Its a trillion million more times

    beatiful then god help the outcasts

  • @esmeraldagirlxxa I love ur youtube account name :) but I'm afraid I have to disagree with the comment.... I believe they're both equally beautiful. but however God Help the Outcasts meant more to the story.... it fit in better I think.

  • i've definetely heard this song elsewhere.

  • Celtic Woman did a version of this song. That's how I know the song, its actually one of my favorites.

  • my opinion this version with esmeralda alone is more beautiful then eternal's and all 4 one's version =]

  • they should have added both songs to the movie!

  • celtic woman sang that song too!

  • If me and my friends start a band then we could sing this song.

  • this a very beautiful sing!!! i'm doing it fo my 15!!

  • this song is awesome! it is very beautiful but, i think it would have been better that essie sings a prayer more than an anthem. =) very beautiful song

  • I LOVE the song! So beautyful. :)

  • Every now and then, a creative genius wakes up at Disney and produces a real winner like "Hunchback of Notre Dame". Disney movies have been good for the most part, but "Hunchback" was simply awesome! Great music and script. Too bad they couldn't find a place for "Someday" in the film.

  • This is a beautiful song, but I do think God Help the Outcasts fit better in the cathedral, whereas Someday would have been perfect if they had a scene in the film where she sings in the dungeon. Or if she sang it while on top of the cathedral with Quasi just before they climb down. I like this version MUCH better than one on the soundtrack (90's pop music.....eeeeeew).

  • This is a gorgeous song, but God Help the Outcasts worked and fit so much better for the moment. I think Someday/Einmal works *perfect* for how they used in the German stage production - she starts singing it while in the dungeons, Phoebus and the choir join her, and it continues as she is led into the town and tied to the stake. There, it is the huge powerful ballad it is supposed to be. I can't imagine someone belting out Someday in a church, while GHTO is a softer, more somber song.

  • I totally agree with you. If they had such a scene in the movie that would be the place for the song. It was fitting in the stage production

  • Yeah... btw, are you shipperheart on livejournal? I think you were the one who uploaded the stage production that I ended up downloading... :D

  • @givemeyourhand89 are there video recordings of that German Production?

  • @givemeyourhand89 I've never heard Phoebus sing in this movie.

  • As much as I love God Help the Outcasts, this is much more intense and goosebump-inducing.

    They use it in the German stage adaptation of the movie, and the choir reprises it when Esmeralda dies (instead of surviving, she wakes up for a few minutes when Quasi is with her after the sanctuary scene, and then she dies), and it's absolutely amazing.

  • I remember that one. It's a very sad scene

  • @shipperheart

    Yeah, I prefer the much happier ending to the original movie (in which Esmeralda survives and is free to pursue a relationship with Phoebues once Frollo is gone) myself.

  • wait so in the disney of hunchback,

    esmeralda dies?

  • No, she doesn't. The German stage version was loosely based on the Disney movie. Basically, they only used the songs. The story they used was a lot darker.

  • @Harikou are you KIDDING ME!!!! :( *tears......can't beleive they killed her off.

  • Muahaha but I didn't buy this disk >:D

  • I kind of prefer this to God Help the Outcasts, but I love that song as well.

  • I stumbled across this song while looking up Heidi Mollenhauer and I recognize this song, it's sung by Celtic Woman's Chloe Agnew -- Ironic how the song that was cut out of the film yet made it's way out there into the world.

  • yeah that was the version I heard first too. But I also have a more upbeat version sung by Donna Summer...Was this used as an ending theme to the movie? It's been so long I don't remember. It just seems weird that the song got out there without being used at all in the movie.

    That clip was beautiful. I wish they animated it ^_^

  • I prefer this to god help the outcasts! :) though i love god help the outcasts too!

  • Thats cool how it's a mix between "God Help The Outcasts" and "Someday" :D...♥♥♥

  • This song is so beautiful...

  • "And thank you for buying this disc."

    Ha ha.

  • I love this song ... but I think the director made the right choice. "God Helps The Outcast" convey much more despair - especially Esmeralda's last few words in the song "God Helps the Outcast": "... God help the outcasts, Children of God." The way the last note lingered just fits for me. The song "Someday" has a despair tone in it but not as much as "God Helps The Outcast"

  • I really like this version of the song. I don't think it was to over the top for the movie. I think it was perfect because it not only described Esmeralda's feelings of not being accepted and treated fairly, but it spoke for Quasimodo and the other gypsies as well. One of my favorite Disney animated films, this one by far seems to me to be the most dramatic of the animated musicals.

  • Wow... I loved it. :)

    Thanks for uploading shipperheart. :)

  • You're welcome

  • i like the german version of this song more

  • I liked it, too, but I liked Aladdin better. Hunchback's one of those where if you watch it when your younger, and don't like it,t hen re-watcfh it, you do. hunchback's not in my top 5 favorites though. Top Ten, yeah, but the top five belong to Aladdin, Mulan, Beauty and the Beast, Lion King and Little Mermaid. But hunchback's in place ... seven or eight in my book.

  • I don't know for you but this has been my favourite movie since I saw it for the first time - I was 7 or 8. I don't remeber why I liked it so much at that age but when I watch it now I see how deep it is!

  • I think it's because Disney made a film that was too Adult in plot for kids. It is such an underappreciated movie, yet I only saw it once or twice when it came out. Now, I'm 18 and I love it, it's one of my fave Disney films, musically (the music is AMAZING!) and aesthetically. I just love it. The story's great too.

  • yea...the music in hunchback is better than any other disney movie.

  • me too, I think it was way too under appreciated in its time, the animation was sick ( in a good way!), the songs were friggin awesome, and yea! wish it was better noted , like no one in my class has seen it!

  • I think this is my favorite version of this song. Thanks for posting it!

  • O, now it works again!

  • Does this video still work?

  • è piu' bella questa secondo me!cmq anche quella attuale è molto bella

  • nice - but i prefer laurie beechman's version

  • Sure, but there is not very much

  • This is nice. But I still like GHTO better. But maybe I'm biased since I loved that song since ever. haha

  • Sending you a message

  • That was on the credits for the orignal movie. I reconize some of the scenes in the movie.

  • The people who do this storyboard... are just amazing.

  • That's a shame they deleted this song.

    I sort of wish they kept this song, God Help the Outcasts just seems to be the shorter verison of this song.

    However, both songs are good.

  • I'm glad God help the outcasts made it instead. I just love that song to much. :)

  • celtic woman also does a beautiful rendition of this song look at it and compare videos

  • Ohhh! This was at the end of the credits

    =D I love this

  • Can you please upload more behind the scenes stuff?

  • Sure. I also have the two deleted songs

  • two bad she couldnt do both in the moive i would have loved that

  • Pause on exactly 2:00, she looks drunk.

  • she does...hahahahahaha XD

  • I love this song, but I can see what the Directors meant. It is "too big" for the scene of Esmerelda's prayer. It does however go nicely with the ending credits...sort of along the theme as "last words" for you to hear and know. It makes a point, but overall, I'm glad they went with God Help the Outcasts :).

  • Beautiful.

    I just don't like her hair style in the drawings :P lol

  • Thank you so much for posting that.

  • I like this song, but I'm glad they went with "God Help the Outcasts". The song is pretty though. I think the version in the ending credits doesn't have this song's intro. (the part with the "God Help the Outcasts" tune)

  • hey....the Celtic Women sing this song! I didn't know it was from Hunchback...awesome..

  • Oh Thank you for this .

  • I like this version the best.

  • Fantastic song... I wish it would've found its way into the final film somehow, besides the credits.

    It's kind of sad how this song is sung with a voice of hope, yet 600 years later (Hunchback taking place in the 1400s), we're still just as far from "someday" as we were then.

  • beautiful song. <3

  • I am SO glad they stuck with "God Help The Outcasts".

  • I'm glad they still used it in the end credits ;-)

  • I dunno... this version just sounds kind of preachy.

  • Its about time this video was found!!! AWESOME!!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more