i really agreed with vemma, the judgement and rating should be for the overall performance, otherwise defeat the purpose of organization. anyway, judgement is subjective, no right and wrong.
I actually think 潔瑩 sang really well this time. She is not a fancy singer but her beat and pitch are very good without any "background music". Her simplistic way of singing fits Cappella style IMO.
Yeah totally agreed with triplet2005 should get 30 points. Best captivating performance but then the judge Lam Chik wanted Lee Chien to win this competition. How can he said KY arrogant anfd the 1 point he did not give to KY bcos it was for Sirens but Sirens performance was great! I can tell the final result is Lee Chien will win as the judges wanted him to win this Season competition. Lam Chik is obviously so bias.
@kimmy2965 KY gave a good performance. But please face the fact. Lee Chien is winner material just like Jess Lee. Lee Chien is simply awesome! BTW, I am a Malaysian. I have to admit though, Lam Chik is a bit bias.
@kimmy2965 stupid judge of lam chik. he tot he so great ah compose cantanose song then very great ah. so bias all the time. That 12 years old kid that time also he biased say that kid arrogant. who cares arrogant as long as sing greatly. stupid judge. And dont compare lee chien with jess lee lor. Jess lee sings good modern nice sound. So far lee chian sang like an old folks not nice at all. Like that also can win go die better. lolz
支持潔瑩!!!!!
jc55139 2 weeks ago
这能证明星光的乐队有多烂。。。
alwazbluez0401 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
前面的音文歌很好聽
mimi200321 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
get a grenade for ya <3
smalpotato 2 months ago
nice
hewittzhong 2 months ago
很喜欢赵洁莹，且非常喜欢！
觉得她是天生的表演者，站在舞台上总能吸引人的目光。
她和其他参赛者最大的不同点是，没有拘束感，看她的演出，是一种享受，因为她自己本身把一场场的比赛当作是自己的演唱会，所以每一次都是那么尽兴的演出。
其他参赛者都是那么的尽力表现自己，可是，重觉得他们的演出很拘束，唱得有点战战兢兢的。
另外，当赵洁莹和其他人一起合作时，更加发亮，因为她重来没有尝试去超越合作伙伴，而是享受整个过程，所以，她每次和其他歌手合作，都会产生化学效应！
赵洁莹，加油！
ilu516 2 months ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
怎麼樣都覺得趙潔瑩比較適合去演歌仔戲的小生
(她的整個嘴整個臉......) 反正聽她唱歌就感覺很不誠懇
在流行樂界的發展......?
在歌仔戲界可能比較能闖出自己的一片天空
嗯~純屬個人意見...... 覺得她適合演小生(古裝)請按讚!!!!!!!!
km19931101 2 months ago
i really agreed with vemma, the judgement and rating should be for the overall performance, otherwise defeat the purpose of organization. anyway, judgement is subjective, no right and wrong.
sootin77 2 months ago 3
Comment removed
sootin77 2 months ago
I actually think 潔瑩 sang really well this time. She is not a fancy singer but her beat and pitch are very good without any "background music". Her simplistic way of singing fits Cappella style IMO.
jibikao 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
'Grenade' move my emotion from bottom-complaint to piercing cry-ever ever....again & again....
Archidcreater 2 months ago
起鸡皮疙瘩～！！！好强～！！！
almonsyao93 2 months ago
趙潔瑩 真是棒极了～～听出耳油。。。
不容易唱啊，音感跟节奏超好的！
特喜欢趙潔瑩大剌剌的个性，非常令人觉得舒服！
支持你！
adelinegoh84 2 months ago 6
don't even know how she got so far in this competition. she had a flat voice with not much voice techniques....
extra333 2 months ago
要是那麼容易滿分那就不用比直接出唱片就好啦 (?)
選手對分數都沒意見了為甚麼還要在這裡罵?
SweetxTrue 2 months ago
love it! 潔瑩you are the best!!!!! Sirens 超好聽!
yanying85 2 months ago 2
評分還有分開評的，那麼何必叫其他的團體來一起演出，這是考驗參賽者和團體的默契和融入度。這樣才能產生火花，這就代表哪個參賽者付出更多的努力，既然是比賽就要公平的評分，而不是評審喜歡那個參賽者就給他高分而給他機會，這樣是對其他參賽者不公平的。
vemma1121 2 months ago 5
finally... fair play
hstjkt 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
李佳薇, 趙潔瑩聲樂派唱法(平的) ---- 如何練習
1．聲樂練氣法 ------ 聲樂派重視練氣如聲樂家用氣一樣
2．三平層次法 ------ 注意嘴形，嘴形大中小代表高中低音，下巴與聲帶肌肉是連動的，下巴肌肉強而有力，所以高音又順又穩，固定三音階，交替使用，簡單易學，嘴越大音越高，如聲樂家嘴型
閉上眼睛就聽出來很多地方是平的，使用三平層次法，就聽不出來是唱平的
想參加華星2嗎??? 就來用李佳薇，趙潔瑩聲樂派(平的)唱法
ilove4114 2 months ago
火星人的歌改編得超好聽的!!
和Sirens搭配得天衣無縫!!
這次的表演超讚的><
pa1233733 2 months ago
既然是藝文合作表演賽 就應該看 整體的表現啊 不然今天的選手如果都要扣掉藝文團體 那要唱得怎樣的境界才給滿分呢 今天就潔瑩唱得部分也已經很接近完美了!! 加油~~
t8zj6xji6 2 months ago
林夕老师很吝啬
MegaSozaii 2 months ago in playlist 華人星光大道 20111218 創新曲風狂想曲 積分賽2
This has been flagged as spam show
@MegaSozaii 我同意， 林夕老师真的很吝啬 ！之前给劉漢傑的“好膽你就來”@20111211 --29分。 就是要保留 1分 。
pink84528 2 months ago
哇！！真的是太棒了！！两者配合得很好，而且歌曲也选得好。100%!!
alin0422 2 months ago 4
唱到咁都叫強@＠？！＠！＠！＠？？？？？
以前班人勁好多!！！！
mikeip33 2 months ago
@mikeip33 高手呀 , 期待你高歌一曲 , 讓我見識 見識 ......
kelvinboyful 2 months ago in playlist 華人星光大道 20111218 創新曲風狂想曲 積分賽2
This has been flagged as spam show
默契100%的演出~~~ Sirens 是真的太太太强哦，趙潔瑩也太棒了！
那個默契配合好的沒話說。。。在那個4.48的point 實在太贊！！！
林老師評分 有點怪異。。。 合作賽 就應該看全面的演出啊！
ChinMini86 2 months ago in playlist 華人星光大道 20111218 創新曲風狂想曲 積分賽2
Yeah totally agreed with triplet2005 should get 30 points. Best captivating performance but then the judge Lam Chik wanted Lee Chien to win this competition. How can he said KY arrogant anfd the 1 point he did not give to KY bcos it was for Sirens but Sirens performance was great! I can tell the final result is Lee Chien will win as the judges wanted him to win this Season competition. Lam Chik is obviously so bias.
kimmy2965 2 months ago 4
@kimmy2965 KY gave a good performance. But please face the fact. Lee Chien is winner material just like Jess Lee. Lee Chien is simply awesome! BTW, I am a Malaysian. I have to admit though, Lam Chik is a bit bias.
desi533 2 months ago
@kimmy2965 stupid judge of lam chik. he tot he so great ah compose cantanose song then very great ah. so bias all the time. That 12 years old kid that time also he biased say that kid arrogant. who cares arrogant as long as sing greatly. stupid judge. And dont compare lee chien with jess lee lor. Jess lee sings good modern nice sound. So far lee chian sang like an old folks not nice at all. Like that also can win go die better. lolz
lam86 2 months ago
太吵耳
wesleychan2810 2 months ago
我觉得评分应该乐团与歌手合起来评才公平。因为这次的考题就是考参赛者与乐队/团的默契、谐调，如果无法好好配合掌握，整个表演就会十分不搭、怪异。加上参与的乐团乐队，在道上都小有名气，数一数二，各参赛者若无法在选曲、配合上取得谐调，如何可以打动听众的心？所以林夕老师“分开式评分”法，实在让人错愕。那不如让乐团们单独表演算了，何必多此一举与参赛者配合，反正分数分开评！
ellim03 2 months ago 9
@ellim03 说得好～我也这么认为，明明是合作赛，为什么分数要分开评呢？真觉得这个表演应该满分的！
xinyi1206 2 months ago 4
很少有讓它讓人唱到雞皮疙瘩的感覺
這次的搭配真的太棒了
peterlkkyu 2 months ago 4
good show...
yyfsur 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i dont really like how she sings the 1st song but the 2nd one was not bad.. love the beatbox and the harmony xD
sagiting 2 months ago 2
选歌重要！！
TheBlue819 2 months ago
Jie Ying - gambateh !
triplet2005 2 months ago
should get 30 points instead of 29 .
triplet2005 2 months ago 23
Wow, this is very good. She did it again!
jibikao 2 months ago in playlist 華人星光大道 20111218 創新曲風狂想曲 積分賽2 2
Sirens人聲樂團蠻贊的，的切換那位選手都好用這樣的組合分數一定高！
designerwing001 2 months ago in playlist 更多由hahawawalala1提供的影片
@designerwing001 Sirens 是真的很强，但没有音乐伴奏，选手本身的节奏感就要很好。要不整首歌会变得死气沉沉。和其他选手搭配，sirens可能会被沦为配乐，而不会产生这样的火花。这次洁莹唱得很棒
jartze 2 months ago in playlist 華人星光大道 20111218 創新曲風狂想曲 積分賽2 48
@designerwing001 沒錯 雖然我也喜歡潔瑩 但是明顯人聲樂團才是得高分的主要原因~應該像林夕一樣把人聲樂團的因素去掉 這樣才公平!
TheAndyiloveyou 2 months ago 9
@TheAndyiloveyou you're right!!!!!!!
Elaine721026 2 months ago
這樣的話，就不用和樂團合作啦。。。。個人solo就可以。主辦單位有這樣的安排是有他們的原因。那當然我也覺得sirens是非常棒
carsonlhc 2 months ago
@carsonlhc跟樂團合作, 就是考驗選手的音樂性和樂團默契配合的程度 這一點潔瑩做到了~~ 但是瞭解Siren的人都知道, 他們是強到什麼樣的歌聲都能合,而且評審明顯有把樂團的表現加在裡面, 潔瑩表現很好, 但是就歌聲來說,不覺得到29分的地步
~我也喜歡潔瑩 只是就事論事! peace~~
TheAndyiloveyou 2 months ago