Celtic Thunder on QVC's Rose of Tralee Celebration - 9/9/09

[liveLOVEsingDREAM]

I think Neil needs way more solos. He has an absolutely amazing voice but he is stuck as back up vocals witch is cool but he should sing more solos like Keith and Damian. The odd thing is when he sings i get really tired and agitated. his voice is amazing but it boars the hell out of me. still love him though.

[liveLOVEsingDREAM]

so totally love this version of Ireland's call. Neil sounds so much better in it than Paul.your still cool though Paul. Neil also looks really good in that blue. bit of a shock though. all I've ever seen any of them in is black and white.

[PrinceTrexus]

where was paul byrom when this was filmed?

[vertstylus]

I love Neil's voice. It's a country singer's voice!

[2010Bells]

Neil rocks, Will be great to see all 6 of them tomorrow on QVC.

[JennyB1124]

oooooo I love Neil but he does NOT blend well with the rest of the guys. Definitely need Paul!!

[livetoworshiptheKing]

@JennyB1124 Actually he blends really well with them all, his mic was just turned up higher here (at least that's what it sounded like to me) which is why his voice was standing out above the rest. :)

[girllovesmusic]

wow- she has their names memorized... imagine.

I'll try to pick myself up off the floor here.

On the other hand, I wouldn't mind having the dvd... in fact, I'd love it. ;)

[kekintz]

Pimpin' the Celtic Thunder. (: God I love them. <3 Ryan is adorable.

[DamianMcGintyRox]

who is neil? and y is he in celtic thunder?

[MrsMcGinty91]

he's been part of CT since the beginning, playing guitar and drums, but Paul was sick that day and Neil filled in. He's a bigger part of It's Entertainment. Dude. Don't diss the Neil. XD lol

[floridachick333]

Paul :(

[MissSunFlower94]

I think Ryan just looks happy to not be the shortest here :p

randomly - I must admit I wasn't too gone on Neil's voice here, but in the new show he sings two songs with everyone and I like it a lot more now. ^__^

[hvuseenmemonster]

LOL!!

[iSkittlezzz]

But Paul should be back on tour now. (Forgot to add that to my last comment)

[iSkittlezzz]

Paul was sick, so they had Neil replace him for this

[127sexyback]

I NEED PAUL

[MovieGoerSupreme]

LOVE George!! He looks like most huggable person!! I also think Ryan's a hottie!! Yay Storm in October!! <3

[CelticSweets]

Neil gose better with them than paul! but i still love swanky!!

[alegria101]

Holy cow! Neil Byrne with short hair! He looks good, really good! Sounds good too!

[moonlightthunder]

P.S. You did an awsome job Neil! I've listened to you singing background on the DVD, and knew you had a great voice.

This was cool to hear something different.

[moonlightthunder]

We love you Neil, but missin Paul!

[Hollygirlwwe]

This was great, but I agree with qweensarah; where is Paul?? Neil sounds great!!! Why Does'nt he sing with them more often?

[LoveCelticThunder]

Paul was ill. Missed him terribly. It's good that Neil could fill in, though. Talented people!

[qweensarah]

where is paul !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!the other guy did good thou but is todly wered to lison to this without paul

[mvanputten]

neil was amazing n i love him but i think paul fits better in the group cuz they lok good 2gether....it would suck if dat pack was broken

[chrisnao]

Who is that guy who replaced the other member? He is WAY better and is a much better fit with the group!

[callton88]

He plays the guitarr in the band. He fitts better but paul is great as well. The this is that CT is a mix of all sorts of songs and they need paul for that

[qweensarah]

paul is awesome  and i think paul is a verry importin part of celtic thunder

[damiangirlzz12]

<3 Damian <3 he has grown SOOO much!!!! <3

[IloveDamian92]

*thud*

[ILoveKeithHarkin222]

Keith is sooooooooooooo!!!! Cool..............

[mkc1023]

is this the whole thing??? i heart neil, KEITH AND DAMIAN!!!!!!!!

[kbspots]

Not bad.  Almost did not recognize Neil without the kilt and guitar! Love the whole production.

[nesneJselkcA]

omg i love celtic thunder! whens damians bday? i thought it was sept 15th? guess i was wrong lol!!! *swoon*

[xCTAngel98x]

it's the 9th, so he just turned 17! :)

[nesneJselkcA]

thanks!!! im not confused anymore lol

[xCTAngel98x]

ur welcome, i know a lot about ct cuz i'm completely obsessed (probably more than i should be, hahaha!)

[nesneJselkcA]

hahah i totally understand! thats how i am bout the tv show Supernatural!

i wish i knew everything bout celtic thunder! lol

[Ryanne81]

Neil is the guitarist and back up singer for CT he's been there since day one, and once again Paul was sick!!

[johnnycakeMHMMM]

omg! good! i totally thought at first that Paul had like quit or something!! :(( i'm glad he was just sick..even though that's not good either obviously :))

[monkeybus995]

who is the new guy and where is paul!!!!?????

[ChesterEldar]

They are very good as ever. Neil is even more 'Irish' than Paul... maybe they will become six ...

[louises267]

Thank you so much for this. I think Neil did a great job filling in for Paul.  Even though he was missed very much.

[Ryanne81]

I thought Neil did a fabulous job!

[MissSunFlower94]

PAUL IS STILL PART OF CELTIC THUNDER!! Neil is just filling while the poor guy is sick in Ireland!! He's a human being he gets sick. Neil did fine on such notice, and while he's no Paul, he is still PART of CT, and if you love the guys you could at least respect him!

[monkeybus995]

oh thank you for clarifying that but how is he part of CT???

[vidssesw]

OK! note to everyone watching this and asking!!! PAUL was sick and couldn't be there. NEIL is an amazing singer and although it sounds different, it is still good. And going on QVC was amazing for their publicity....Paul will be back soon, and everyone should thank Neil for stepping in with very little warning..... Please do not insult any of them, even the musicians!!! They are all amazing!!

[WickedFabala]

WHO IS "NEIL"?

what happened to Paul!?

WHAT!?

[Irelandhasmyheart]

I was so disappointed i didnt see it on the website. I kept waiting but had to go :( But thanks for posting its fantastic as usual!! :) Well done Celtic Thunder!

[Mariclare1000]

Thank you for posting this - it was very good of you to share it. And what a great performance! Well done Damian,. George, Keith, Neil & Ryan :)

[richellis88]

whos the new guy

[Mariclare1000]

The "new" guy is Neil Byrne who has been part of the show since the very first DVD was filmed ;)

He is normally yhe guitarist & backing vocals but stepped in for this show because he was needed.

And I think he did a fantastic job! :)

[SmilingWood]

The chemistry is all wrong here. Paul is far too important to the group..like each member is in his own way.

I just can't digest this. lol

They SHOULD have ME fill in. heh!

[irishdancer2323]

I love celtic thunder but i wish Paul was there.

[ScarredMaskOfPain]

I LIKED PAUL BETTER AHHHH.!!!!!

And I didn't even LIKE Paul. Ohmygod.

This guy is two grapes short of a fruit basket. HES BAD.!!!!

Paul made the group.!!

THIS GUY KILLED IT.!

My god.

[2Die4YOU13]

OMG thank you for posting this! I missed so much of it cause i was in school. Thank you!