2008 and 2009 was vocally her worste, she was dealing with miscarrige, and honestly she was probably drinking alot, but recently she sounds amzing, listen to that christmas albulm, she sounds as good as TEOM
I Love her. Give her a break she's not 20 anymore.... She sings better than today's Whitney and most artists out there. She is only going to get older.... a women's voice changes as they get older. It's a fact other female sings same problem Olivia Newton-John for example... youtube You're the one that I want live in 1978 with Donny Osmond and compare it to 2008 it's gonna be a big difference!!!!
From 2:55 to 3:08 sounds so amazing. I love how her voice has changed over the years because she still adds to the song her own unique sound based off of her vocal ability!
Despite singing in the cold which is very difficult she still pulled it off! I love the raspiness that she had in her voice. It made the performance sound more soulful. I love Mariah Carey.
She is the queen :D The problem is... in the morning the voice sound horrible :l Sometimes, of course... Leave her alone :D She is amazing, i love her so MUCH :D
OK .... I'm a big fan but we can't say she sounds good here, she hasn't rested enough, it's ok she did so much better on tour and she was so AMAZING here :
for those who say she cant sing - all i have to say is " bitch can you sing and be the #1 female bst selling artist and be the only single artist to have the most number one hits"
@guitarralopez Then why he was dumped out of Sony shortly after Mariah left. Maybe this "genius" owes some of his years as Sony CEO thanks to Mariah success, don't you think?. He was lucky to receive Mariah demo and he'll always be credited as discovering and developing the career of one of the most successful artist ever. I wonder if he was so "genius" why he couldn't do anything for her wife career hahaha.
I think she did have problems with her ear piece while performing this....you can she pulled her ear piece off... But hey Mimi made it..She is still the the best!
i love her but ill give her some props for trying this song live lol come on she sounds ok but she dose not sound like she used to and she has to fight to even get close to the old notes she used to hit i want the mc back who didnt have to try it just came out love ya but get it together
People need to leave her alone, it's getting annoying now! Mariah is human & her voice very, very, very different than alot of people's. . . Most people don't sing the way she does so they don't need to rest their Voice, but she Does & all the saying she's lipping Stfu who cares she's gave us plenty of Beautiful live vocal performances & if she doesn't wanna sing live who cares! & Dont act like you know when she's lipping cause you don't, even if you do think your close to her entourage!
If you don't like her "Why Are You On A You-Tube Video Of Her!" People wonder why she say's "This Is For My Real Fans!" or when she's asked about her fans she say's the "Real Fans," it's because Fans don't turn on you because others have or because you change your Hair or wear more Make-Up than when you were young or because you Change your music style, or because you gain Weight!
As a Mariah fan I always keep in mind that Mariah doesn't have to sing she's Filthy-Rich! Mariah sings becuase it's what she loves to do! & Whenever i see her Live or listen to her i can tell she cares about her fans & their Opinions, but it's her life & Career! Mariah has alot more to her than just a voice until you find out your not a "REAL-FAN!"
I Believe This Was A Video Clip Of NBC News' Today's Toyota Concert Series Report On Mariah Carey Singing Her 1991 Hit, "Make It Happen" On Friday Morning, October 2, 2009.
I watch hundreds of Mariah Carey videos weekly, and I am a HUGE fan. I've noticed her live vocals during the MOAIA era were very week, mainly in her chest voice. But she actually sounds very similar to her 1995 madison square garden performance 0:30 to 1:00 , seems from what I've noticed once she cracks, its hard for her to regain and good sound. But her Christmas performance on ABC was FLAWLESS! All her voice needs is rest :)
@austintylerjohnson93 if anybody is a huge fun that would be me! but sad enough to admit, her voice is gone :( her christmas performance on ABC was back tracked and lypped. many people made it a controversy, but mariahs reps paid a huge check to shut everyone up
@1mcluver Thats invalid. Yes the show was dubbed during some songs, but there was a live band on the abc special and you cant lip because the risk is too much :P
@1mcluver any facts or proves? Mariahs bad at lipping, you can see it in the SIO Performance 2005 or when she lipps the long C5 in WBT (eg @Opra Ellen etc...)
@1mcluver Not at all she can hit the very low notes, because it's more easier! It's the same for the high notes! U judje mariah on a performance when (sadly i have to say) her voice isn't at the best (she was cold maybe). But listen to all the performances that came after this one her voice is amazing and u'll see what i mean!
@1mcluver NOT AT ALL all the performances are not lipped and only 2 are lipped (All I Want For Christmas I s You and Oh Santa!) and the rest of the show is 100% live. So when you don't know anything about something, just shut the fuck up!
@candyblinggg No Oh Santa was lipped and all I want for x-mas is you too...the others aren't because they doesn't sound like the album version. But the others r 100% live & lore Mariah delivered us an amazing performance of those songs. It was awesom and absolutely amazing! Even in summer I'm listening to those performances and the songs!! Lol. Oh I love the name of your profil "candyblinggg" one of my fav song of the album "Memoirs Of An Imperfect Angel" even if i love the whole album lol!
@underworld91200 sorry to bust ur bubble hunny but i was there vip not to mention i know her people...i know exactly when she lipps and when she doest...i don't blame her because its very hard to sing while pregnant but those r the songs that were lipped
@candyblinggg What songs r u talking about darling? The songs during the ABC Special Christmas?
If it's it yes it's hard songs but she can still sing songs like those... Everybody know that her voice changed but it follows her musical style which changed too. And more yes she was pregnant so it's more difficult!
@underworld91200 i know she can still sing them...but during that special she lipped O Holy Night, All I want for christmas and Here comes santa clause...
Now although her voice was damaged by her using whistle, her age,etc.. , but Mariah Carey try to make everybody has feeling like her. so i will always remembet her voice that be good at the past and i will always love mariah carey.
Well in comparison to the pop female singers out there now (except for Beyonce) then vocally she's still on top. In comparison to her performances before - it used to be twice as good as this.
This is a really awesome performance!! :):) I love Mariah with all my heart!! This perfromance lets people know that she still hasn't, even though some may complain it doen't sound like the 1993-1996 Mariah. SO WHAT!! She's only human :):) Love you Mariah !!
WTH you say??That just a kind of image or figure of speech!!This song is not even for herself but for everyone who wants to realize his/her dreams...So,it doesn't matter for the price of shoes are under 500 dollars or not.
Huh~keep your faith and hold on every opportunity~~~GOD BLESSED YOU~
@TheJan2988 Nope: it means when she was younger she only had one pair of shoes; a size too small with holes in them & she used to walk to the recording studio in the snow at like 3am trying to make demo tapes.
because "not more than three short years ago" when she made this song she was struggling to find money to eat and had one pair of shoes therefore shes telling us her life and telling us she didnt give up shes inspiring others
@Flames00809 Please go reacquiant yourself with your right and cite your opinion to your blow up doll, whom im sure is the only one who cares for it. Despite what you say, this woman is gonna continuously sell albums and remain the best selling female artist of all time. End of story. You are a nobody and thats all youi ever will be. Its ok that your jealous provided that Mariah Carey has more talent in one eyelash than you have in your whole body. Fuck off and die.
Thank God for the existence of Youtube , because we are allowed to watch the performance of MIH live on Madison Square Garden in 95 and maybe forget this one.
Do you understand no matter how you feel about Mariah the lady is swimming in dough and you're here, watching her video and being the hater that you are? Get a life because hating on someone who don't even know of your existence is a waste of time
Do I care about making millions? Nope. I am not a greedy person like fat ass Carey. But isn't she swimming in dough and YOU are commenting her videos as well? Are you swimming in dough?
@Flames00809 The difference between you're comments and mine is that I'm not hating on her. She worked hard for her money and she should reap the benefits of her hard work. You can call every name in the book and shell still be one of the top best selling female artists of all time and you'll still be nothing more than a hater.
That still does not mean I cannot type anything I want about her. Oh and btw last night her Christmas special sucked. She lipped the whole thing and looked a fat, blubbery mess. I don't care if she is one of the top selling female artists. I can give a fuck about that. U can throw all her accomplishments at me and I still would not like her. She may have sold a lot but nowadays she is NOTHING.
Oh I am a hater? You're just another nonexistent Mariah fan in everyone's eyes.
@Flames00809 It's sad that you wasted your time to watch her video and hate. Like really, if you hate her so much why watch her video? And if I defend her that makes me a fan? Seriously get a life because no one wants hear you cry about how much you hate Mariah. Go hang yourself, it'll be much easier.
I think it's sad you spend so much time defending her. Why are you replying to my comments?
Yes you ARE a fan basically if you defend her. What? Ur not a fan but yet you would take time out of ur day to defend her? Smh. And u type ur NOT a fan?
@Flames00809 I'm not a fan because I defend her, you're a hater for watching her video and acting like a bitch when someone disagrees with our comment. You must be bored if you can sit here and watc her videos and then talk about her. It's sad that you spend your time hating someone that doesn't even know you alive. I met Mariah once and I can admit her personality suck but if someone work they're ass off they should be able to reap the rewards of their labor.
I have no problem with anything. YOU guys have a problem with agreeing with my comment. Alright fine. That does not bother me one bit. I have every right to defend myself when I got people at my heels. And again STOP repeating what every other fan says. It gets so fucking annoying. GET LOST. GET A LIFE. Let me have my opinion and FIND a life or something else to do!
@Flames00809 You're truly a complete idiot. First of all when I commented on this video I didn't comment on your opinion, it was directed at any particular person YOU felt the need to say something and now you're upset because people who just want to enjoy this video in piece are calling you exactly what you are, a hater. How idiotic does it sound to take the time to look up a Mariah video and watch it just to comment on it and to say how much you hate her? If anyone needs a life it's you
How on earth am I a hater? Because I'm typing rude things about some washed up whale? So anyone who has a negative opinion on anyone is a hater? Aren't you a hater as well for calling me an idiot? And if I am a complete idiot like you type then why are you wasting your time with an "idiot"? Takes one to know one right?
@Flames00809 You're a hater because you took the time out to write about some washed up whale. P.s. I don't know you so I guess you're in the idiot box by yourself
@Flames00809 Says the person that can't stop hating on someone that doesn't even know you exist. Don't you have something better to do? Of course not that's why you're on here 24/7
@Flames00809 I didn't pick a fight with you, you made a comment towards me. I f you don't like to hear other peoples opinions then this is not the website for you. I'm not defending anyone i'm making a point. Why search Mariah just to hate on her? I didn't come on here to argue with Mariah's haters I just wanted to watch a video, sadly I can't say the same for you.
I can say the same for you. If you don't like my opinions, walk away. Simple as that. Mariah is nothing nowadays anyways. Her latest Xmas album flopped globally and in the United States. Look at Susan Boyle's Xmas album and compare her sales to Mariah's. There is NO comparison.
@Flames00809 You're on every Mariah video bitching, grow up and stop being obsessed!! Go someway you stalker!! Who cares about her xmas album?! I just wanted a video
@Flames00809 Um Flop No....."Oh Santa!" debuted at number twelve on Billboard's Hot Adult Contemporary Tracks chart, becoming Carey's highest debut on that chart in her 20-year career. The song jumped to number one on the Adult Contemporary chart the following week, making it the fastest rise to number one in that chart's history.United States (RIAA) Gold Certification
Oh Santa charted at number 100 on the Billboard Hot 100 which is a failure. Who the fuck be checking for a stupid Adult Contemporary chart? The Billboard Hot 100 is where it's at.
Gold in the United States? LOL What about the rest of the world?
@Flames00809 Why are you here? Your the meaning of HATER. Someone who goes out looking for videos they hate,but nonethless clicking it and then posting negative comments... How about Fuck off? lol
@Flames00809 Haha that right bitch/hating douche - Merry christmas ii you went Gold!!!! Ha ha - keep on hatin - still wont get YOU any whee in life bitch! Hahaha!!
But yet Susan Boyle's Xmas album sold WAY more than Mariah's lousy Xmas album. Gold only? LOL! So how do you go from 6x Platinum, to Platinum, to Gold, and STILL Gold. What a fucking FLOP
@Flames00809 Oh god she had a slump. Never happened before to any artist. You better go tell past Mariah to stop at Glitter because it didn't do too well!
@Conner526 So you are telling me that a woman who has sold over 220 million album was preparing for a flop? When her last album went platinum?? Hmm - oh yeah and let me guess her label wanted to drop her after she bagged the label their most successful single which was number 1 for a record smashing14 weeks???
In Mariah's own words - You're delusional!
Like i said keep commenting - you are very amusing to argue with!!
@Flames00809 Do you have some sort of mental ailment/ The adult Contemporary chart is the second most important chart in America and you degrade it like that? Oh, and since when has any christmas album topped that chart before??? Her achievements are obviously far too much for you to handle so i'd rather you just stop commenting and go to bed. She has topped the official billboard 18 times which is more than Elvis Preseley. She holds the record for a solo artist with the most. Flop? Not really..
And how on Earth do you know that? YOU go to bed and stop acting like she still HAS a career nowadays. Yes she does have the most number one singles but I can guarantee you her 18th one was her LAST one: I can write you a check and you can take it to the bank and cash it, bitch.
@Flames00809 How do you mean she has no career nowadays - even if she did have no career and you were right - what does that mean. She's broken all the records there are to break so what does she need to prove to idiots like you? Now - she does have a career becuase she still holds the record in Japan for the biggest selling album by a non Japanese person! And her latest christmas album went gold in america and it was only really promoted in America so if it charts anywhere else - that is extra
She DOESN'T have a career ANYWHERE nowadays. She better enjoy Obsessed because that might have been her last top ten single. Her Xmas album barely did shit anywhere too. I can care less what records she holds, THAT is irrelevant to this argument. I am talking about her RECENT career. YOU mention useless things.
@Flames00809 I did'nt say it wasn't prmoted bitch, i said it wasn't promted worldwide - promotion was only heavy in america since it was only a christmas album. Your really funny dubass! - trying to make out as if susan oyle is more succesfull! Haha
Susan Boyle + YOUR comment = FLOP!!
Mariah Carey + 18 number 1's + 5 Grammys + Billboard achievements + 20 years + Millions of fans + Celibrity adoration = Success!!
Ha - haters like you make me laugh - keep commenting - your amusing!!
Of course it will not be promoted worldwide since it was set to flop anyways worldwide. Susan Boyle IS more successful than Mariah Carey nowadays and she is nearly 50.
Millions of fans? If she has millions then why did her album flop hard?
@Flames00809 Ha - MARIAH RULES FOREVER BABY!!!!!!!!! - forget the haters!!!
arey’s career U.S. album sales [as certified by the RIAA], since SoundScan began tracking sales in 1991, the highest sum among female artists. Celine Dion ranks second among women with sales of 51 million, followed by Shania Twain (33.9 million), Britney Spears (31.5 million)
Carey’s U.S. physical singles sales, . Her best-selling single is “One Sweet Day,” with sales to date of 2,334,000.
@Flames00809 Bcuz that's the fcking point! Ppl like you obviously need 2 be REMINDED what this woman has accomplished. Like I said, Mariah has EARNED her right to commit ANY FLAW IN ANY PERFORMANCE ON ANY DAY!.....GREAT PERFORMANCE BTW.
@Flames00809 STILL breaking AND SETTING records wit her CHRISTMAS ALBUM AND 2 CHRISTMAS SONGS, not 2mention her SUCCESSFUL fragrances and she's already garnering success with her butterfly rings and wtf mariah is STILL THEE MOST SUCCESSFUL FEMALE ARTIST OF ALL TIME. TOUCH MY BODY JUST SET A RECORD- THAT'S CONSIDERED RECENT SUCCESS, her song Obsessed also set a record, and THAT'S considered RECENT success. STILL writing her OWN hits and the only people she has to please NOW are her FANS. Fck off!
What records has she broken with her xmas album? Last time I checked it commercially flopped worldwide. I am talking about her recent one not her last one where she was more popular. She is NOT the most successful recording artist. If you haven't noticed her record sales seem to change. One source says 200, another source says 175 million; I sense INFLATION.
Obsessed set a record? WOW. Just because it went platinum? LOL How did it chart worldwide? How many countries did it hit #1?
@Flames00809 And uhh, can't sing anymore?? Are we listening to the same albums & recent songs?? And if you're talking about LIVE then listen to "Oh Come All Ye Faithful" which is her 2010 Christmas performance in Washington when she sang 4 the president.
@Flames00809 I find it funny that i'm still entertaining you. What I say will not change ur opinion about her, & what u say will not change the fact that she's STILL the MOST successul female artist of ALL TIME! "Can't Take That Away" 4rm her. Plz Don't Respond.
Yes you are "entertaining me", if that is the way you want to put it. So be it. She is not the most successful female artist of all time. Unless I see a source like the Guinness World of Records say it, THEN I will believe it. When was the last time she had a number one hit all over the world? 100 years ago.
that awkward moment when a very famous song is ruined by the original singer herself
AndrewJamesYo 2 weeks ago
0:15 haha, try being the operative word
TheXwatts 3 weeks ago
@TheXwatts lolsss
AndrewJamesYo 2 weeks ago
"Not more than A FEW short years ago..." nice, Mariah! rsrs
brunofm58 3 weeks ago
@brunofm58 what is rsrs?
AndrewJamesYo 2 weeks ago
@AndrewJamesYo These are *laughs* in Portuguese... haha Sorry...
brunofm58 1 week ago
she can't belt anymore :(
AndrewJamesYo 1 month ago
@AndrewJamesYo yh she can, she just has good days and bad days (especially that day)
TheXwatts 3 weeks ago
2008 and 2009 was vocally her worste, she was dealing with miscarrige, and honestly she was probably drinking alot, but recently she sounds amzing, listen to that christmas albulm, she sounds as good as TEOM
zblamm2121 1 month ago
I Love her. Give her a break she's not 20 anymore.... She sings better than today's Whitney and most artists out there. She is only going to get older.... a women's voice changes as they get older. It's a fact other female sings same problem Olivia Newton-John for example... youtube You're the one that I want live in 1978 with Donny Osmond and compare it to 2008 it's gonna be a big difference!!!!
kevgonzal85 1 month ago
1:58-2:02 MADE ME LOL I never noticed it until now lmao!
blackroomfish 1 month ago
people need to stop criticizing; i doubt that anyone can sing like that....sides i think the raspiness adds a sexiness to her voice. :)
shakirafreak90 1 month ago
From 2:55 to 3:08 sounds so amazing. I love how her voice has changed over the years because she still adds to the song her own unique sound based off of her vocal ability!
PrinceMontrey 2 months ago
She usually sings falsetto to sing in her higher range. This is her natural voice. She's naturally an alto.
josbo51715 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2007/2008/2009 were really awful !
But fortunately, in 2010, she sang it so powerfully, never thought she could sing like that again !
==> watch?v=mzcyZCsGBsQ&list=FLRdlYh5iPu1kZv_VIYhIorQ&index=27&feature=plpp_video
==> watch?v=x4Z_1CXn0CI&list=FLRdlYh5iPu1kZv_VIYhIorQ&index=135&feature=plpp_video
THUMB UP FOR PEOPLE TO SEE
polute13 2 months ago
Comment removed
polute13 2 months ago
the best ever
BlissSkittles 2 months ago
I actually like the raspy effect.
delijon 2 months ago
@delijon I do as well!! I thought that I was the only one :)
capcomfighter13 2 months ago
The program and in the morning, her voice is too cold, just that.
Olivercord 2 months ago
I think she screams at the beginning to test if she can belt :-)
SuperFapple 2 months ago
yea i love her her voice was good she needs water or tea
bxi7669 2 months ago
I love the rough and raspiness of her voice here.
jchall2009 3 months ago
@jchall2009 I'm sorry but that's how your voice sounds like when you can't get any higher:p
promisuous88 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thumb up to let people know that she did so much better during her tour few month after this live :
watch?v=enpMq7WNLp0&hd=1
or watch?v=x4Z_1CXn0CI
or watch?v=jC-ZFGMoAGM&feature=related
or watch?v=bCmV9hxkl-w
polute13 3 months ago
Despite singing in the cold which is very difficult she still pulled it off! I love the raspiness that she had in her voice. It made the performance sound more soulful. I love Mariah Carey.
capcomfighter13 3 months ago 2
She is the queen :D The problem is... in the morning the voice sound horrible :l Sometimes, of course... Leave her alone :D She is amazing, i love her so MUCH :D
0414locos 4 months ago
Not bad, but she didnt rest enough :( she sounds scratchy, still amazing though!
zo12 4 months ago
OK .... I'm a big fan but we can't say she sounds good here, she hasn't rested enough, it's ok she did so much better on tour and she was so AMAZING here :
watch?v=x4Z_1CXn0CI
polute13 5 months ago
You can quite clearly hear that she has a cold or something. Her voice sounds nasally and cracked. She has since done much better performances.
BigBlyeEyes1234 6 months ago
for those who say she cant sing - all i have to say is " bitch can you sing and be the #1 female bst selling artist and be the only single artist to have the most number one hits"
itspophoe 6 months ago 2
People keep saying she can't sing anymore and stuff. She CAN still sing, have you heard her new christmas album? This was just a bad performance.
JimmothyDean 6 months ago
@guitarralopez Then why he was dumped out of Sony shortly after Mariah left. Maybe this "genius" owes some of his years as Sony CEO thanks to Mariah success, don't you think?. He was lucky to receive Mariah demo and he'll always be credited as discovering and developing the career of one of the most successful artist ever. I wonder if he was so "genius" why he couldn't do anything for her wife career hahaha.
juancito1975 6 months ago
The rehearsal was SO much better!
mcdamian17 6 months ago
It was a little rough cause it was in the morning, then it was chilly and cold is very harsh on the throat. She did a fabulous job.
seandoe24 6 months ago
I think she did have problems with her ear piece while performing this....you can she pulled her ear piece off... But hey Mimi made it..She is still the the best!
innermaxagent06 6 months ago
i love her but ill give her some props for trying this song live lol come on she sounds ok but she dose not sound like she used to and she has to fight to even get close to the old notes she used to hit i want the mc back who didnt have to try it just came out love ya but get it together
aldanahanson 7 months ago
@aldanahanson shes older now.20 years of non stop singing and vocal folds.give her a break
BeyFan3000 6 months ago in playlist Mariah Carey 2009 Performances
People need to leave her alone, it's getting annoying now! Mariah is human & her voice very, very, very different than alot of people's. . . Most people don't sing the way she does so they don't need to rest their Voice, but she Does & all the saying she's lipping Stfu who cares she's gave us plenty of Beautiful live vocal performances & if she doesn't wanna sing live who cares! & Dont act like you know when she's lipping cause you don't, even if you do think your close to her entourage!
mariahpowerful 7 months ago 14
If you don't like her "Why Are You On A You-Tube Video Of Her!" People wonder why she say's "This Is For My Real Fans!" or when she's asked about her fans she say's the "Real Fans," it's because Fans don't turn on you because others have or because you change your Hair or wear more Make-Up than when you were young or because you Change your music style, or because you gain Weight!
mariahpowerful 7 months ago
As a Mariah fan I always keep in mind that Mariah doesn't have to sing she's Filthy-Rich! Mariah sings becuase it's what she loves to do! & Whenever i see her Live or listen to her i can tell she cares about her fans & their Opinions, but it's her life & Career! Mariah has alot more to her than just a voice until you find out your not a "REAL-FAN!"
mariahpowerful 7 months ago
i think that it's morning's fault that she couldn't nailed it...
BajcoTheSinger 7 months ago
i like the breaks she does somewhere at about 2:56 Don't ever let go Uh-uh-uh-uh-uh-uh oh-oh-oh
the09conradz 7 months ago
I Believe This Was A Video Clip Of NBC News' Today's Toyota Concert Series Report On Mariah Carey Singing Her 1991 Hit, "Make It Happen" On Friday Morning, October 2, 2009.
radiodj1520 8 months ago
To farkhunda i hate u lol..ni wish i was there :(
luisboricua9 8 months ago
You Earned Our Respect Mariah We Love you!!
Ehadurkah 9 months ago 11
OMG, I didn't think she performed her "forgotten" classics anymore! Praise God!!!
tomomichan2 9 months ago
absolutely awful
XTINASDISCIPLE 9 months ago
I watch hundreds of Mariah Carey videos weekly, and I am a HUGE fan. I've noticed her live vocals during the MOAIA era were very week, mainly in her chest voice. But she actually sounds very similar to her 1995 madison square garden performance 0:30 to 1:00 , seems from what I've noticed once she cracks, its hard for her to regain and good sound. But her Christmas performance on ABC was FLAWLESS! All her voice needs is rest :)
austintylerjohnson93 9 months ago
@austintylerjohnson93 if anybody is a huge fun that would be me! but sad enough to admit, her voice is gone :( her christmas performance on ABC was back tracked and lypped. many people made it a controversy, but mariahs reps paid a huge check to shut everyone up
1mcluver 9 months ago
@1mcluver Thats invalid. Yes the show was dubbed during some songs, but there was a live band on the abc special and you cant lip because the risk is too much :P
austintylerjohnson93 9 months ago
@1mcluver I just hate those fake-fans with unproven "facts"
296218047 8 months ago
@296218047 my dad and mom are huge mariah fans, as am i. she lips many parts of hersinging now a days, even the very low notes she cant hit anymore.
1mcluver 8 months ago
@1mcluver any facts or proves? Mariahs bad at lipping, you can see it in the SIO Performance 2005 or when she lipps the long C5 in WBT (eg @Opra Ellen etc...)
296218047 8 months ago
@1mcluver Not at all she can hit the very low notes, because it's more easier! It's the same for the high notes! U judje mariah on a performance when (sadly i have to say) her voice isn't at the best (she was cold maybe). But listen to all the performances that came after this one her voice is amazing and u'll see what i mean!
underworld91200 8 months ago
@1mcluver NOT AT ALL all the performances are not lipped and only 2 are lipped (All I Want For Christmas I s You and Oh Santa!) and the rest of the show is 100% live. So when you don't know anything about something, just shut the fuck up!
underworld91200 8 months ago
@underworld91200 actually oh santa was live...o holy night, here comes santa clause and all i want for christmas is you were lipped...
candyblinggg 8 months ago
@candyblinggg No Oh Santa was lipped and all I want for x-mas is you too...the others aren't because they doesn't sound like the album version. But the others r 100% live & lore Mariah delivered us an amazing performance of those songs. It was awesom and absolutely amazing! Even in summer I'm listening to those performances and the songs!! Lol. Oh I love the name of your profil "candyblinggg" one of my fav song of the album "Memoirs Of An Imperfect Angel" even if i love the whole album lol!
underworld91200 8 months ago
@underworld91200 sorry to bust ur bubble hunny but i was there vip not to mention i know her people...i know exactly when she lipps and when she doest...i don't blame her because its very hard to sing while pregnant but those r the songs that were lipped
candyblinggg 8 months ago
@candyblinggg What songs r u talking about darling? The songs during the ABC Special Christmas?
If it's it yes it's hard songs but she can still sing songs like those... Everybody know that her voice changed but it follows her musical style which changed too. And more yes she was pregnant so it's more difficult!
underworld91200 8 months ago
@underworld91200 i know she can still sing them...but during that special she lipped O Holy Night, All I want for christmas and Here comes santa clause...
candyblinggg 8 months ago
@candyblinggg Lol, yes she even lips when she's recording new music in the studio LOL.
juancito1975 6 months ago
@juancito1975 its two different things to sing in a recording studio and live
candyblinggg 6 months ago
@candyblinggg really? do you know what being ironic mean?
juancito1975 6 months ago
I WAS HERE :)
farkhunda123 9 months ago
Now although her voice was damaged by her using whistle, her age,etc.. , but Mariah Carey try to make everybody has feeling like her. so i will always remembet her voice that be good at the past and i will always love mariah carey.
haloalicia 9 months ago
Well in comparison to the pop female singers out there now (except for Beyonce) then vocally she's still on top. In comparison to her performances before - it used to be twice as good as this.
fistagamm 10 months ago
@fistagamm LOL...SO TRUE
Mannequin2009 9 months ago
i love how she shaked the guys hand!
the09conradz 10 months ago
This is a really awesome performance!! :):) I love Mariah with all my heart!! This perfromance lets people know that she still hasn't, even though some may complain it doen't sound like the 1993-1996 Mariah. SO WHAT!! She's only human :):) Love you Mariah !!
banantwon 10 months ago
She is fantastic!
Conner526 10 months ago
Haters, you can kill yourself!
Mariah = the queen!
Ihateeminem1985 10 months ago
I'm sure when she says "no proper shoes up on my feet" she means shoes under 500 dollars. :P
TheJan2988 11 months ago
@TheJan2988
WTH you say??That just a kind of image or figure of speech!!This song is not even for herself but for everyone who wants to realize his/her dreams...So,it doesn't matter for the price of shoes are under 500 dollars or not.
Huh~keep your faith and hold on every opportunity~~~GOD BLESSED YOU~
rulove999 11 months ago
@rulove999 I say what I want, and that was just a joke.
TheJan2988 10 months ago
@TheJan2988
That's ok~I'm sorry to get it wrong that you did it on purpose.I know it's just a joke but feels like you're a hater.If not that just fine...
rulove999 10 months ago
@TheJan2988 ahahahah maybe more :P
gordiam 10 months ago
@TheJan2988 Nope: it means when she was younger she only had one pair of shoes; a size too small with holes in them & she used to walk to the recording studio in the snow at like 3am trying to make demo tapes.
Hanzy123 10 months ago
@Hanzy123 oh oh oh! Hellooooo! I know she meant that when she wrote the song, that was just a joke of what she prob thinks now, relax.
TheJan2988 10 months ago
@TheJan2988 Sorry, I just assumed you were one of those ignorant people who hates on Mariah for her material goods.
Hanzy123 10 months ago
@TheJan2988 yes she does say that
because "not more than three short years ago" when she made this song she was struggling to find money to eat and had one pair of shoes therefore shes telling us her life and telling us she didnt give up shes inspiring others
fan4mc 10 months ago 2
best performance of this song!!! her voice actually sounds more interesting when its like this
potatosalad8 11 months ago
@Flames00809 Please go reacquiant yourself with your right and cite your opinion to your blow up doll, whom im sure is the only one who cares for it. Despite what you say, this woman is gonna continuously sell albums and remain the best selling female artist of all time. End of story. You are a nobody and thats all youi ever will be. Its ok that your jealous provided that Mariah Carey has more talent in one eyelash than you have in your whole body. Fuck off and die.
capcomfighter13 11 months ago
Thank God for the existence of Youtube , because we are allowed to watch the performance of MIH live on Madison Square Garden in 95 and maybe forget this one.
hrick92 1 year ago
@hrick92 I am obsessed with Mariah and I can even admit that this was not half as good as the 1995 performance at Madison Square Garden.
misterbee66 1 year ago
very sad :(
esteban55200 1 year ago
She sounds amazing. The Voice! Fuck you haters. Mariah Is The Queen. Mad?
DioniIsThatDude 1 year ago 26
all these worst attention seeking person, go to a doctor, mariah cant help you ^_^
zanaomusic 1 year ago
Comment removed
Flames00809 1 year ago
Comment removed
Flames00809 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
U #FAIL
Flames00809 1 year ago
Comment removed
zanaomusic 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
Who?
Flames00809 1 year ago
Comment removed
zanaomusic 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
Who?
Flames00809 1 year ago
I guess the background singers sang better than her.
I noticed that mariah's voice had changed since her album "Butterfly" in 1997. After that it went worse and worse ;-(
Ask her to sing "There's got to be away" now..
I bet she won't be able to do that..
MrHandyronny 1 year ago
Yeah her voice may have died through the years but wtf, sounds like she's been fricken smoking too
prozie286 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Mariah Carey I grew up listening to (Emotions album) is looooong gone.
prozie286 1 year ago
Comment removed
prozie286 1 year ago
She cant sing anymore,so sad.
madonnabiggestfan 1 year ago
@madonnabiggestfan actually if you've watched her recent christmas performances, you would realize that she can once again sing very well.
Raymondkeys 1 year ago
@Raymondkeys But never like before, still sad.
madonnabiggestfan 1 year ago
That's her voice most of the time these days, and sometimes it gets back to what it was more or less,
darrin1701 1 year ago
it was the morning guys, give her a break. It's so very hard to sing in the morning expecially with nodules.
Jared95C 1 year ago
Do you understand no matter how you feel about Mariah the lady is swimming in dough and you're here, watching her video and being the hater that you are? Get a life because hating on someone who don't even know of your existence is a waste of time
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
Do I care about making millions? Nope. I am not a greedy person like fat ass Carey. But isn't she swimming in dough and YOU are commenting her videos as well? Are you swimming in dough?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 The difference between you're comments and mine is that I'm not hating on her. She worked hard for her money and she should reap the benefits of her hard work. You can call every name in the book and shell still be one of the top best selling female artists of all time and you'll still be nothing more than a hater.
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
That still does not mean I cannot type anything I want about her. Oh and btw last night her Christmas special sucked. She lipped the whole thing and looked a fat, blubbery mess. I don't care if she is one of the top selling female artists. I can give a fuck about that. U can throw all her accomplishments at me and I still would not like her. She may have sold a lot but nowadays she is NOTHING.
Oh I am a hater? You're just another nonexistent Mariah fan in everyone's eyes.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 It's sad that you wasted your time to watch her video and hate. Like really, if you hate her so much why watch her video? And if I defend her that makes me a fan? Seriously get a life because no one wants hear you cry about how much you hate Mariah. Go hang yourself, it'll be much easier.
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
I think it's sad you spend so much time defending her. Why are you replying to my comments?
Yes you ARE a fan basically if you defend her. What? Ur not a fan but yet you would take time out of ur day to defend her? Smh. And u type ur NOT a fan?
If u weren't a fan u wouldn't have bothered then!
U go slit ur wrists for all I care about.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 I'm not a fan because I defend her, you're a hater for watching her video and acting like a bitch when someone disagrees with our comment. You must be bored if you can sit here and watc her videos and then talk about her. It's sad that you spend your time hating someone that doesn't even know you alive. I met Mariah once and I can admit her personality suck but if someone work they're ass off they should be able to reap the rewards of their labor.
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
I have no problem with anything. YOU guys have a problem with agreeing with my comment. Alright fine. That does not bother me one bit. I have every right to defend myself when I got people at my heels. And again STOP repeating what every other fan says. It gets so fucking annoying. GET LOST. GET A LIFE. Let me have my opinion and FIND a life or something else to do!
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 You're truly a complete idiot. First of all when I commented on this video I didn't comment on your opinion, it was directed at any particular person YOU felt the need to say something and now you're upset because people who just want to enjoy this video in piece are calling you exactly what you are, a hater. How idiotic does it sound to take the time to look up a Mariah video and watch it just to comment on it and to say how much you hate her? If anyone needs a life it's you
immarocker247 1 year ago
How on earth am I a hater? Because I'm typing rude things about some washed up whale? So anyone who has a negative opinion on anyone is a hater? Aren't you a hater as well for calling me an idiot? And if I am a complete idiot like you type then why are you wasting your time with an "idiot"? Takes one to know one right?
Dumbass.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 You're a hater because you took the time out to write about some washed up whale. P.s. I don't know you so I guess you're in the idiot box by yourself
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
And you took the time to reply back to something u don't like. It takes one to know one right?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Arguing with idiots is a personal hobby of mine. I find you amusing that's the only reason I reply back. You're still a lonely hater
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
You are one sad person then. I am sure you can find a better hobby. Run along now.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Says the person that can't stop hating on someone that doesn't even know you exist. Don't you have something better to do? Of course not that's why you're on here 24/7
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
I can type the same thing for you. She doesn't know you exist either, so why are you defending her?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 I didn't pick a fight with you, you made a comment towards me. I f you don't like to hear other peoples opinions then this is not the website for you. I'm not defending anyone i'm making a point. Why search Mariah just to hate on her? I didn't come on here to argue with Mariah's haters I just wanted to watch a video, sadly I can't say the same for you.
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
I can say the same for you. If you don't like my opinions, walk away. Simple as that. Mariah is nothing nowadays anyways. Her latest Xmas album flopped globally and in the United States. Look at Susan Boyle's Xmas album and compare her sales to Mariah's. There is NO comparison.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 You're on every Mariah video bitching, grow up and stop being obsessed!! Go someway you stalker!! Who cares about her xmas album?! I just wanted a video
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
No I'm not! Get a damn life and enjoy her flopped Xmas album!
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 mariah is a legend, firs artist who has 18 number #1s & rich as hell, jealous? ^_^ #LOL
zanaomusic 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
Who?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 haha jealous, which mariah vids do you spamm now? attention seeking loser ^_^ #LOL
zanaomusic 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
Who?!
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 loser, poor jealous person ^_^ who? who? who? your mother #LOL
zanaomusic 1 year ago
@zanaomusic
Who?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 I could say the same thing for you, pitiful hater.
immarocker247 1 year ago
@immarocker247
Who?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Um Flop No....."Oh Santa!" debuted at number twelve on Billboard's Hot Adult Contemporary Tracks chart, becoming Carey's highest debut on that chart in her 20-year career. The song jumped to number one on the Adult Contemporary chart the following week, making it the fastest rise to number one in that chart's history.United States (RIAA) Gold Certification
1marisolmc 1 year ago
@1marisolmc
Oh Santa charted at number 100 on the Billboard Hot 100 which is a failure. Who the fuck be checking for a stupid Adult Contemporary chart? The Billboard Hot 100 is where it's at.
Gold in the United States? LOL What about the rest of the world?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Why are you here? Your the meaning of HATER. Someone who goes out looking for videos they hate,but nonethless clicking it and then posting negative comments... How about Fuck off? lol
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua
2 weeks later another delusional Mariah fan comments back repeating the same old shit. Don't you guys ever get bored?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 nope... Don't you get tired of hating?
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua
Of what? She has NOTHING I want.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Did you even read my post correctly? I said don't you get tired of hating?
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua
Don't you get tired of defending this whale?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 No, but im getting tired of you. :P chou...
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua
But yet you still reply back lol
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 CHOU DAMNIT! CHOU!!! lol
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua
lol!
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Haha that right bitch/hating douche - Merry christmas ii you went Gold!!!! Ha ha - keep on hatin - still wont get YOU any whee in life bitch! Hahaha!!
TheSamuelkStuff 1 year ago
@TheSamuelkStuff
But yet Susan Boyle's Xmas album sold WAY more than Mariah's lousy Xmas album. Gold only? LOL! So how do you go from 6x Platinum, to Platinum, to Gold, and STILL Gold. What a fucking FLOP
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Oh god she had a slump. Never happened before to any artist. You better go tell past Mariah to stop at Glitter because it didn't do too well!
Conner526 1 year ago
@Conner526
She is gonna stay in this slump for a LONG while especially since she got fat ass hell.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 God, how dare she get fat when she is pregnant with twins! Do you hear yourself?
Conner526 1 year ago
@Conner526 So you are telling me that a woman who has sold over 220 million album was preparing for a flop? When her last album went platinum?? Hmm - oh yeah and let me guess her label wanted to drop her after she bagged the label their most successful single which was number 1 for a record smashing14 weeks???
In Mariah's own words - You're delusional!
Like i said keep commenting - you are very amusing to argue with!!
TheSamuelkStuff 1 year ago 22
@TheSamuelkStuff It is so logical for a company to ditch their most successful artist!
Conner526 1 year ago
@TheSamuelkStuff I hope you know, I was praising her.
Conner526 11 months ago
@Flames00809 Do you have some sort of mental ailment/ The adult Contemporary chart is the second most important chart in America and you degrade it like that? Oh, and since when has any christmas album topped that chart before??? Her achievements are obviously far too much for you to handle so i'd rather you just stop commenting and go to bed. She has topped the official billboard 18 times which is more than Elvis Preseley. She holds the record for a solo artist with the most. Flop? Not really..
TheSamuelkStuff 1 year ago
@TheSamuelkStuff
And how on Earth do you know that? YOU go to bed and stop acting like she still HAS a career nowadays. Yes she does have the most number one singles but I can guarantee you her 18th one was her LAST one: I can write you a check and you can take it to the bank and cash it, bitch.
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 How do you mean she has no career nowadays - even if she did have no career and you were right - what does that mean. She's broken all the records there are to break so what does she need to prove to idiots like you? Now - she does have a career becuase she still holds the record in Japan for the biggest selling album by a non Japanese person! And her latest christmas album went gold in america and it was only really promoted in America so if it charts anywhere else - that is extra
TheSamuelkStuff 1 year ago
@TheSamuelkStuff
She DOESN'T have a career ANYWHERE nowadays. She better enjoy Obsessed because that might have been her last top ten single. Her Xmas album barely did shit anywhere too. I can care less what records she holds, THAT is irrelevant to this argument. I am talking about her RECENT career. YOU mention useless things.
It wasn't promoted? Are you making excuses?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 I did'nt say it wasn't prmoted bitch, i said it wasn't promted worldwide - promotion was only heavy in america since it was only a christmas album. Your really funny dubass! - trying to make out as if susan oyle is more succesfull! Haha
Susan Boyle + YOUR comment = FLOP!!
Mariah Carey + 18 number 1's + 5 Grammys + Billboard achievements + 20 years + Millions of fans + Celibrity adoration = Success!!
Ha - haters like you make me laugh - keep commenting - your amusing!!
TheSamuelkStuff 1 year ago
@TheSamuelkStuff
Of course it will not be promoted worldwide since it was set to flop anyways worldwide. Susan Boyle IS more successful than Mariah Carey nowadays and she is nearly 50.
Millions of fans? If she has millions then why did her album flop hard?
So much for "millions of fans".
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Ha - MARIAH RULES FOREVER BABY!!!!!!!!! - forget the haters!!!
arey’s career U.S. album sales [as certified by the RIAA], since SoundScan began tracking sales in 1991, the highest sum among female artists. Celine Dion ranks second among women with sales of 51 million, followed by Shania Twain (33.9 million), Britney Spears (31.5 million)
Carey’s U.S. physical singles sales, . Her best-selling single is “One Sweet Day,” with sales to date of 2,334,000.
13.8 million
MariahcareyMichael 1 year ago
@MariahcareyMichael
And what is the point of posting sales she primarily got in the 90's?
Flames00809 1 year ago
@Flames00809 Bcuz that's the fcking point! Ppl like you obviously need 2 be REMINDED what this woman has accomplished. Like I said, Mariah has EARNED her right to commit ANY FLAW IN ANY PERFORMANCE ON ANY DAY!.....GREAT PERFORMANCE BTW.
oldd13 11 months ago
@oldd13
Yes: HAS accomplished. What has she done lately besides commercially flop? Be made a joke out of by people on the internet calling her fat and etc.
This performance sucks. She can't sing anymore.
Flames00809 11 months ago
@Flames00809 STILL breaking AND SETTING records wit her CHRISTMAS ALBUM AND 2 CHRISTMAS SONGS, not 2mention her SUCCESSFUL fragrances and she's already garnering success with her butterfly rings and wtf mariah is STILL THEE MOST SUCCESSFUL FEMALE ARTIST OF ALL TIME. TOUCH MY BODY JUST SET A RECORD- THAT'S CONSIDERED RECENT SUCCESS, her song Obsessed also set a record, and THAT'S considered RECENT success. STILL writing her OWN hits and the only people she has to please NOW are her FANS. Fck off!
oldd13 11 months ago
@oldd13
What records has she broken with her xmas album? Last time I checked it commercially flopped worldwide. I am talking about her recent one not her last one where she was more popular. She is NOT the most successful recording artist. If you haven't noticed her record sales seem to change. One source says 200, another source says 175 million; I sense INFLATION.
Obsessed set a record? WOW. Just because it went platinum? LOL How did it chart worldwide? How many countries did it hit #1?
Flames00809 11 months ago
@Flames00809 And uhh, can't sing anymore?? Are we listening to the same albums & recent songs?? And if you're talking about LIVE then listen to "Oh Come All Ye Faithful" which is her 2010 Christmas performance in Washington when she sang 4 the president.
oldd13 11 months ago
@oldd13
I find it funny how you have to direct performances which makes me infer the rest of her performances are shit.
Flames00809 11 months ago
@Flames00809 I find it funny that i'm still entertaining you. What I say will not change ur opinion about her, & what u say will not change the fact that she's STILL the MOST successul female artist of ALL TIME! "Can't Take That Away" 4rm her. Plz Don't Respond.
oldd13 11 months ago
@oldd13
Yes you are "entertaining me", if that is the way you want to put it. So be it. She is not the most successful female artist of all time. Unless I see a source like the Guinness World of Records say it, THEN I will believe it. When was the last time she had a number one hit all over the world? 100 years ago.
Flames00809 11 months ago
@oldd13
You are too funny "Plz Don't Respond" #LOL !!!
OKzs 11 months ago