Harry Potter HBP Deleted Scene - Harry, Hermione and Ron at Astronomy Tower

[sptvdfan007]

umm....im confused here. Ron and Hermoine only get together in the last part right? So, how come Harry asked them to keep it to a 'minimum' in the 6th part itself? I guess thts why this scene got deleted. Its a shame, its like on of the best scenes, but it was ahead of its time. Literally.

[JoxisOi]

This was in the film!

[lthodde116]

this wasn't in the movie guys, in the movie it's hermione saying that Harry should keep his snogging with Ginny to a minimum when they're around Ron lol.

[207257]

.I.

[Jenzzyuk]

I really Like that scene and I hate that they had to  remove it

[CReepyVERY]

thats my fav line "keep the snogging to a minimum"

[TheMerkedpro]

This scene was in the film

[Beckiiy100]

@ArricFarick13 like mental lol ,, crackers, etc

[nexttobeloweredd]

I just don't understand why Ron is sitting there in the backround. In the book this is such an important ''trio moment''. Hey, Kloves, they're a trio, just thought you would like to know.

[darkb4lightt]

@nexttobeloweredd I hated that. I agree with you. Makes no sense that he is just sitting there with nothing to say.

[patitatitatitatitona]

those bitches cutted the scene that harry talks about hermione snogging ron and thats so fucking amazing. ugh. sometimes i just want to go there and kill all of those bitches. idek

[emilyk20086375]

I love this scene, at first I thought it was fake tho......, but now I know that it is real:)

They shouldn't kept it in.

[PDCgirl]

*FANGIRLS* why did they cut this?!?!?!?!?!?

[GodericG]

the fan-girls would have loved this scene

[inci4ever]

he??so they where together at the end ?? cool :D

[QueenOfTheWeevils]

Wish this had been kept in but oh well ;) at least we get to see it somehow :))

[Anieckieee]

They réally should kept this one! <3

[onypotter]

do you think ron heard them? I hope so but im not sure,...!!!

[dano181]

it is in idiots!

[LoveTheHinchman]

I would have kept it in. That sucks that they removed it.

[HermioneYr7]

awww they are such good friends :)

[musicalsara]

Very nice scene, although i'm a Harry and Hermione fan(:

I saw this scene in DVD though ..

[isurisonghui]

Can someone plz, plz, plz tell me what they're saying like subtitle? I can't hear British Eng very well and I want to know exactly what they're saying...

It's something about kiss (snog) right?

Plz...

[GrayTigerProductions]

@isurisonghui From the beginning...

Hr: You need us, Harry.

H: Just do me a favor... *looks at Ron* when I'm around, keep the snogging to a minium, please.

Hr: Like that's going to happen! Besides, he's... barking.

H: Funny, he says the same thing about you.

Hr: Yes, but I am exceptionally perceptive.

H: *small laugh* You're brilliant. ... You're both brilliant.

*end scene*

Was that good enough? :)

[isurisonghui]

@GrayTigerProductions Thank you so much...

Do u know what Hr means by "he's barking"... Can u plz tell me if u don't mind?

[GrayTigerProductions]

@isurisonghui "barking", as well as "barmy", is a British word for, well, crazy. Understand though that in this case "barking" is being used in a playful/joking sort of way. Most of us has called our friends/boy-or-girlfriends/sib­lings crazy at least once in our lifetime. Hermione doesn't ACTUALLY think Ron is mentally disturbed, she's just joking.

[isurisonghui]

@GrayTigerProductions Thank u so much... they shouldn't delete that scene

[nazchowder]

@GrayTigerProductions it looked to me as though harry and ron exchanged secret affair looks at the end like *sly grin*

[dashadowdogg]

@severedalltheseties because hes a ginger

[todayonmtt]

I would like Miss Granger to give Mister Potter a warm kiss. Well, Mister Weasley should stay away from them for this moment. XD

[xMagicHorseShoesx]

WOW. Best quality I've seen all day!!! :)

[ThatGEEKChanel]

why didnt they keep this scene in?! it would help especially if you didnt read the book!

[livethemagic91]

Wait, why would Harry talk about Hermione and Ron snogging, if they don't even kiss until the next book/film? I thought HBP was about Harry and Ginny getting together, not Hermione and Ron. I don't know why this scene was made in the first place, because I think it's chronologically wrong.

[skysurvivor619]

@livethemagic91 its a figure of speech, hes saying that they like each other, hes kinda making fun of them in a way.

[SpiderBoy992]

@livethemagic91 NO; think about it. This one set up the ronmione relationship with the love triangle w/ lavender/ron/hermione. in the end, they are together, and harry with ginny. they all get ready for what is to come..........THE END!!!

[TheMysteriousTiger]

what's "barking" means???

[GrayTigerProductions]

@TheMysteriousTiger It's pretty much a very "English" English word for crazy. (barmy is another English slang for it)

[TheMysteriousTiger]

@GrayTigerProductions Thank you! So she said that in this context : "Besides he's barking. I won't kiss him! I won't kiss such crazy person!" ???

[GrayTigerProductions]

@TheMysteriousTiger Yeah, pretty much. Understand though that in this scene 'barking' is used in a more sort of playful/joking way. She doesn't ACTUALLY think he's mentally disturbed, she just think he's slightly barmy.

[PhebzPechy15]

@Clodeenie yes me too. i had watched that somewhere

[kirraleadatsme]

this is horrible! they're alluding that there's something going on between harry and hermione- its just not right!

[LadyParis123]

Ron is barking???

Lol. And why would Hermionie and Ron be 'snogging'?

[SuperJackie76]

y its deleted??

[darkb4lightt]

A very cute scene! The only thing that really annoyed me was how Rupert didn't get to speak at the end of the movie. He just sat there.

[MrBurgundy76]

@Clodeenie same here!

[dynomite1988]

Emma Watson (hermione) looks so beautiful. my only question is when is she gonna do a porno :P

[Kampfmongo]

Fail Question. xD

[Joe90051]

hermione is simple supper klasse fantastic ..... I love her character her art her accent .... she's just beautiful

[47rockgirl]

i have watched all the scenes they deleted and i would kept every single one of them specialy this one.

[ladyjenkins97]

which 1?

[SpiderBoy992]

@47rockgirl this one is like POA, cutwise, cause they didn't cut much out of this one suprisingly, except for those 6 1/2 mins. of scenes, a couple of shots, and some lines missing...........this was the MOST complete one!!!

[Avaritiada]

quite important scene, don't you think? I would have kept in.

[MrBurgundy76]

@Avaritiada you know what was important? DUMBLEDORES FUNERAL

[Avaritiada]

Yeah, you're right. But they can't ignore that ... it might be in the beginning of the next film. Like a flashback? On the other hand - that would not be their style... :-/

[Palacetilidie]

@Avaritiada would of kept harry dumping ginny from the book too tho & there was no sign of that cos that scene shows how she always loved him.. they messed up on hbp in my opinion lol

[inci4ever]

@Avaritiada yes i think so too.

[auzziegurlheidi16]

so beautiful

[DarkLady4eva]

I WISH TYE KEPT IT

[LozzieLass93]

i love this,

i like it out though

because they always have Harry, Hermione and Ron at the end in a happy moment with just music, so it would have ruined the flow if theyd kept it.

But i do love this.

The scene is beautifully done.

[Soccergirl2008]

haha that's so funny i wish they would have kept that in the final film!!

"When i'm around keep the snogging to a mininum...please?" haha dan is so funny!!

[FranceSnape]

Coucou! tu as mis " Harry, Hermione and Rupert " dans ton titre :) au lieu de Ron