@UsedHeartuser Some people want more orchestral music, some want more vocal music, some want more chamber music, some want more piano music ... I can't please everybody ... so I just try to please myself.
@smalin I understand. I just wanted to say, that your animated scores are, in my opinion, perfect to follow chamber music, in which every voice is equally important! Therefore seeing the individual voices helps tremendously! :)
i really enjoyed this piece. I am not able to read music and i find this visual most intriguing. I have also seen your newer versions with wonderful diamond style visuals, but find them less educational for me to see how the music is played. Thanks for sharing your fabulous technique.
@smalin I've seen you're to don't list, and I think you should seriously reconsider Dvorak's 9th. It is an extremely beautiful and intricate peice that would be delightful to see visualized.
I thought the MAM only works with MIDI files (if I'm wrong correct me)... but how would a MIDI sound this close to a Steinway and have that "childlike" tone so common in Mozart? Even if it's a MIDI file based on a person playing, I don't think that would happen...(unless it's Steinway sampled) Anyway, this is a totally amazing invention, and whenever I play I picture one of these in my mind. :D Thanks smalin!
Just brilliant! Its a whole new way to appreciate music. Reminds me very much of what Herman Hesse wrote in Magister Ludi, the Bead Game, finding analogies from one art form to another.
@MaxPace89 I've tried that, and I don't like it as much. It's a matter of personal taste; one of my best friends loves the line, and we've argued about it endlessly. The freeware software (available on my web site) has a switch to turn the line on and off. Lots of people use that software to make videos they post to YouTube, and most of those have the line turned off, so either they didn't notice the feature, or their tastes agree with mine.
I love your work, smalin. This just adds another dimension to my appreciation of Mozart. His music is beautiful visually, indeed. May I ask you what the origin of the name "smalin" is?
@vulpae2 "smalin" was my user name on the WELL (the first online system I belonged to, back in the days before the bit was invented), and this YouTube account was one of the last accounts I set up using it before I switched to using musanim (my web domain) and "stephen" for everything. I've set up a musanim account and a stephenmalinowski account on YouTube, but I keep this one going (and use it as the main one) because there are lots of links to the videos here and I don't want to lose them.
@smalin Even more story to it, I see. Well, thanks for the replay! I find it amazing how you manage to reply to a lot of comments considering the huge amount of videos you have posted. I'm a great fan as well. Your videos have both inspired me to learn and love the piano, and enjoy classical music. And for that the least I can do is thank you!
I'd request you to animate Ravel's Daphnis et Chloe, either the Lever du jour segment or the Introduction to the full ballet with chorus through the Danse religieuse, but putting that together would probably kill you!
If you think how small and insignificant the life of a single human being is, the fact we still listen to Mozart and revere his genius after 200 is simply astonishing. Truly a king among men.
This is so beautiful. When I listen with my eyes as well as my ears I notice things that always slipped by in other listenings. It just makes it all the more enjoyable. Thank you for the wonderful thing you're doing!
I am again in tears 'cause of this Mozart. The music in places pretends to be so stupid while being so divinestly geniously wise and light and consolatory.
I love the deceptive cadence at 7:15. Instead of landing on I it lands on a flat VI chord. I can't remember enough music theory to remember what that is called though.
Since you are still making the software, this is sort of like a beta test, so I have some feedback for you to help make it better.
I think that when you are mixing the circles with the lines, you should turn off the zooming in the circles animation, so it would be easier to see how the two parts synchronize with each other..
It also may be worth the trouble to make the size of the circle depend not on the length of the note but on its volume, changing size dynamically as the volume changes, so if the note starts loud and fades, the circle would start large and then shrink.
I just recently started listening to classical music mainly because of how terrible rap and how horrible most of todays music is anyways thank for the video Im beginning to love mozart
Stephen, thanks for animating our interpretation of this! It's beautiful and you can really SEE why Mozart is considered such a rhythmic master. So many little asymmetries, so subtle that you can feel it more (like bubbles in a jacoozi, lifting you up) than actually point to it consciously. But now you can see it :)
excelente todo, la interpretación y la grafía analógica. Felicitaciones!
germanruizvm 1 month ago
This is great!!
You should do more chamber works, please!!
And more Mozart, too!! :)
Thanks
UsedHeartuser 2 months ago
@UsedHeartuser Some people want more orchestral music, some want more vocal music, some want more chamber music, some want more piano music ... I can't please everybody ... so I just try to please myself.
smalin 2 months ago
@smalin I understand. I just wanted to say, that your animated scores are, in my opinion, perfect to follow chamber music, in which every voice is equally important! Therefore seeing the individual voices helps tremendously! :)
And Mozart is just my favorit composer! ;)
UsedHeartuser 2 months ago
@smalin A worthy philosophy
GarlandDrest 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@smalin
=I can't please everybody ... so I just try to please myself.=
Best algorithm ever.
mphello 1 month ago
I'm a cellist, I really wanna play this!
BenAdams98 2 months ago in playlist Classic orchestra/piano
I want this as a piano solo!
I have no access to a string quartet...
supersmashermeta 3 months ago
felicidades esta poca madre
sadistsagittarius 3 months ago
i really enjoyed this piece. I am not able to read music and i find this visual most intriguing. I have also seen your newer versions with wonderful diamond style visuals, but find them less educational for me to see how the music is played. Thanks for sharing your fabulous technique.
veeTV 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
AVNIM6 BACK SOON!!
check out my channel please and thank you xx
AvniM6 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I see what's going on here...
adondebass 4 months ago
Mozart himself thought very highly of this piece of his. "This is the best I have written so far", he wrote to his father.
MrAndieMusik 4 months ago
@MrAndieMusik
Mozart was referring to his quintet for piano and winds( k.452) in that quote.
jeunehomme9 4 months ago
@jeunehomme9
I checked it... Yes, you are right. Thank you! My memory has failed me. However, I like this piece much more than K.452.
MrAndieMusik 4 months ago
i want to learn the piano part on 3:50 on guitar aha
rjc102938 4 months ago in playlist Liked
Mozart broke Youtube.
MsLoubylouby 4 months ago
the dis-like bar is like a ninja, you know its their, but you can't see it lolz
dadnapt24 5 months ago
@dadnapt24 Don't look for it! It's a trap!
MyMasterController 4 months ago in playlist Classial masterpieces
a most complicated piece indeed
faleru 5 months ago
7:13 E-Flat Major comes out of nowhere. I think Mozart liked to screw around with his audience a little. :)
amadeus5889 5 months ago
I wonder how a person with synesthesia would view, err, hear? This? ;)
kuan12345 5 months ago
@kuan12345 kind of reddish with bits of yellowy orange.
capequod 4 months ago
Damn, I've never even heard of this piece! Shame on me. Thanks for the upload.
mysterioso2006 6 months ago
@smalin I've seen you're to don't list, and I think you should seriously reconsider Dvorak's 9th. It is an extremely beautiful and intricate peice that would be delightful to see visualized.
CanadianBeaverJerky 6 months ago
When Mozart meets Liszt
PabloDelRococo 6 months ago
Mozart's music in bar graph reminds me of that commercial, TASTE THE RAINBOW
dadnapt24 7 months ago
A showpiece.
louiseduvee 7 months ago in playlist classical
3:38 - 4:02 best part.
Jelubaful 7 months ago
beautiful piece of mozart and beautiful animation from you. thanks.
andresilveray 8 months ago
The only thing missing is the dynamic of forte and piano ... maybe in the shade of the color where forte would be much brighter?
Mr6ear 9 months ago
The string notation is so fuckin' trippy.
3eyedweasel 9 months ago
this way you notice better the genius mozart was
Scaar81 9 months ago
1:18 Rondó K 485 :)
TikiFury 10 months ago
Really beautiful :)
88coldsummer 10 months ago
does this design remind anyone else vaguely of HAL 9000?
derekchewie11 10 months ago
shame people today can't truly appreciate this kind of music. =/
XxRuinWitchXx 10 months ago
I thought the MAM only works with MIDI files (if I'm wrong correct me)... but how would a MIDI sound this close to a Steinway and have that "childlike" tone so common in Mozart? Even if it's a MIDI file based on a person playing, I don't think that would happen...(unless it's Steinway sampled) Anyway, this is a totally amazing invention, and whenever I play I picture one of these in my mind. :D Thanks smalin!
azppiano 11 months ago
@azppiano I make MIDI files that match audio files.
smalin 11 months ago
@MrAgnost Well, I notice too, but I guess we don't need to be THAT accurate.... It's a visualization. Let's enjoy it and not pick at it. ;-)
azppiano 11 months ago
huh? Is it me or is there a very small delay in the video/audio tracks? Seems like the audio is just a little ahead to me.
MrAgnost 1 year ago
I love the bubbles.
Iemanonymous1 1 year ago
The string dots make me feel dizzy, but otherwise I like this and your other videos very much.
BellXlleb 1 year ago
Just brilliant! Its a whole new way to appreciate music. Reminds me very much of what Herman Hesse wrote in Magister Ludi, the Bead Game, finding analogies from one art form to another.
huzone600 1 year ago
When the strings' dots initially light up it causes a delay that makes it look like the video is out of sync. :(
ashleylynnjoan 1 year ago
"I"ve 'Worked'-it-OUT ... Simply TELL-Musicians &-Other Detractors to Hold-R-Mirror-UP to-Their Computer-Screens &-Then Tilt-it On-R-'Slight'-Angle ... until It-Comes Into-Line with-their-Way of 'Hearing' The-Music!!! >(*U^)<
WRETCHEDAVION 1 year ago
Mmmm. Synesthesia!
Balancement 1 year ago
absolutely beautiful......
sarahbaptisteee 1 year ago
Can I give you a lil' advice?
It'd be nice if you place a visibile, maybe white, line where the music PLAYS.
I know, it's the center, where the notes highlights themself, but if you place a visible "playscene" that'd be more "followable".
MaxPace89 1 year ago
@MaxPace89 I've tried that, and I don't like it as much. It's a matter of personal taste; one of my best friends loves the line, and we've argued about it endlessly. The freeware software (available on my web site) has a switch to turn the line on and off. Lots of people use that software to make videos they post to YouTube, and most of those have the line turned off, so either they didn't notice the feature, or their tastes agree with mine.
smalin 1 year ago
@smalin Ah ok =)
Sorry for the assertion, so.
That's for sure a matter of taste, thanks for the answer and the info.
And keep up the good work, that's really GREAT!
MaxPace89 1 year ago
Smalin, this is one of my favourites!!!! I spend all my work hours just listening and watching ur music! Truely inspirational!
JackRogue18 1 year ago
My dreamsenario would be to show a deaf person this kind of video, and see if it makes sense to him (:
MrsPineapplesandwich 1 year ago
I love your work, smalin. This just adds another dimension to my appreciation of Mozart. His music is beautiful visually, indeed. May I ask you what the origin of the name "smalin" is?
mcfly17 1 year ago
@mcfly17 It's a short form of my name.
smalin 1 year ago
@mcfly17 AFAIK his name is [S]tephen [Malin]owski; the brackets indicate the letters used to write out Smalin. :o) Almost like a conspiracy theory!
vulpae2 8 months ago
@vulpae2 "smalin" was my user name on the WELL (the first online system I belonged to, back in the days before the bit was invented), and this YouTube account was one of the last accounts I set up using it before I switched to using musanim (my web domain) and "stephen" for everything. I've set up a musanim account and a stephenmalinowski account on YouTube, but I keep this one going (and use it as the main one) because there are lots of links to the videos here and I don't want to lose them.
smalin 8 months ago
@smalin Even more story to it, I see. Well, thanks for the replay! I find it amazing how you manage to reply to a lot of comments considering the huge amount of videos you have posted. I'm a great fan as well. Your videos have both inspired me to learn and love the piano, and enjoy classical music. And for that the least I can do is thank you!
vulpae2 8 months ago
@vulpae2 I take my YouTube audience seriously (except, of course, in those individual cases where I don't).
smalin 8 months ago
I used to listen to this music many, many times; now I can see it. So beautiful. Thanks!
feanando 1 year ago
Why are the strings spheres that slightly warp and travel across time ? Sustain is just a bar for the piano.
trombone7 1 year ago
@trombone7 I can't explain it; they just do.
smalin 1 year ago
@trombone7 Why not?
dadnapt24 1 year ago
Brilliant!
I'd request you to animate Ravel's Daphnis et Chloe, either the Lever du jour segment or the Introduction to the full ballet with chorus through the Danse religieuse, but putting that together would probably kill you!
trilliwig 1 year ago
mute-deaf persons can add such visual to their vibrational-beat experiencing -
leading to better dancing ability
anasthasys 1 year ago
If you think how small and insignificant the life of a single human being is, the fact we still listen to Mozart and revere his genius after 200 is simply astonishing. Truly a king among men.
Bassfully 1 year ago
Pure unalduterated bliss
I'm in music heaven
Bassfully 1 year ago
This is so beautiful. When I listen with my eyes as well as my ears I notice things that always slipped by in other listenings. It just makes it all the more enjoyable. Thank you for the wonderful thing you're doing!
terrybeaton 1 year ago
thank you once again...PERFECT, PRECISE, AND PASSIONATE !
duyagetme 1 year ago
This is one of my favorites from my all-time favorites list!
MoriMaris 1 year ago
@MoriMaris Mine too!
feanando 1 year ago
i have LOST MYSELF from watching and following the notes, "It's feel like am in another worlD!!!! :D"
diepthanhthe 1 year ago
this is REALLY COOL. Please release software!!!! Thank you for making this.
ElusiveHermit 1 year ago
@ElusiveHermit The MAMPlayer software (on my web site) does something like this.
smalin 1 year ago
@smalin honestly, this changes the way I hear music.
ElusiveHermit 1 year ago 2
@ElusiveHermit YAY!!! Home run!
smalin 1 year ago
Me to man ): ): ): ): ): x999999999999999
juliog1984 1 year ago
I wish Motzart never died..
mariannightmare 1 year ago
Yes like this, but there a very false note at 7:34
potpourri360 1 year ago
Comment removed
potpourri360 1 year ago
ooo amazing.. beautyful piece and good videos smalin!!
raticida123456 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Muito bom o seu vídeo, adorei o seu vídeo, vc faz videos ótimos , me add no MSN
daniel.barao@bol.com.br,
BaraoDaniel 1 year ago
Would you consider doing an animation of Mozart's Flute Quartet (K 285), please?
SSteinnes91 1 year ago
THANK YOU, kind sir.....perfect!
duyagetme 1 year ago
This is incredibale....mega
alandufour 1 year ago
Me encanto!!
WillzUQ 1 year ago
I am again in tears 'cause of this Mozart. The music in places pretends to be so stupid while being so divinestly geniously wise and light and consolatory.
KolyaKomarov 1 year ago
i gotta question that is not in ur faq:
where can a find the tabs for the composition?
omoshiroidayo 1 year ago
I enjoyed it
nofxskatepunk 1 year ago
I love the deceptive cadence at 7:15. Instead of landing on I it lands on a flat VI chord. I can't remember enough music theory to remember what that is called though.
WillsWords 1 year ago
@WillsWords interrupted cadence or something i think :P
geo9m 1 year ago
You could turn this into "Classical Pianist Hero" if you rotated it so the notes came at you semi-3d style. ;-)
WillsWords 1 year ago
The beggining looks like a movie from Dysnet Pixar.
leovailati 1 year ago
The animation is that made bye a computer automatically or by a person?
christianvladila123 1 year ago
@christianvladila123 See the "How did you synchronize..." item in the FAQ.
smalin 1 year ago
ok, this one hits the nail on the head!
mostermaus 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is not the G minor quartet, but the E flat one, K.493 :-)
mirongerstmann 1 year ago
nicley done
bunnybunnybunny8 1 year ago
thank you ...as always. thank you!
duyagetme 1 year ago
Very nicely done. And glad to see so much great chamber music lately.
scherzoq 1 year ago
trippy.
gpaese 1 year ago
I love the combination of the two views. Awesome!!
WizardWalk 1 year ago
I love this!
PaleriderTV 1 year ago
3:40 - 3:50 sounds sooooo good i could listen to that the whole day THANKS
1erdling1 1 year ago
@1erdling1 badap bup bup bup bummm
pieguyfry22 1 year ago
Since you are still making the software, this is sort of like a beta test, so I have some feedback for you to help make it better.
I think that when you are mixing the circles with the lines, you should turn off the zooming in the circles animation, so it would be easier to see how the two parts synchronize with each other..
therealEmpyre 1 year ago
It also may be worth the trouble to make the size of the circle depend not on the length of the note but on its volume, changing size dynamically as the volume changes, so if the note starts loud and fades, the circle would start large and then shrink.
therealEmpyre 1 year ago
i don't like the colors in this too much
refuseit 1 year ago
Great choice of this piece. Once again! Thanks!
TheAspenTom 1 year ago
Lovely music. Please upload the other movements, too - I'm learning this piece at the moment. :)
And I'm just curious, but what made you decide to do something like this? It's really original!
ThatRachGirl 1 year ago
@ThatRachGirl You should probably look at the "history" section of my website.
smalin 1 year ago
I just recently started listening to classical music mainly because of how terrible rap and how horrible most of todays music is anyways thank for the video Im beginning to love mozart
TheNotoc 1 year ago 2
I love the fluidity of the circles.
N1K0M1LT0N 1 year ago
wow this is like 7 minutes of bliss =)
yeah! mozart!!! his stuff just...get me
thank you.
ScribbleMouse 1 year ago
is there a animation of this, but Only der balls, without the lines? that would be nice ;D
Luke00126 1 year ago
1:57 awesome part! nice to see
Luke00126 1 year ago
Stephen, thanks for animating our interpretation of this! It's beautiful and you can really SEE why Mozart is considered such a rhythmic master. So many little asymmetries, so subtle that you can feel it more (like bubbles in a jacoozi, lifting you up) than actually point to it consciously. But now you can see it :)
EtienneAbelin 1 year ago
so beautiful :]]
moonbbox 1 year ago
this song makes me just a little bit more happy!
FuzzBucket1000 1 year ago
The timing is impeccable and the actual comprehension and understanding of the different textures is so good! So awesome!
thebeardman88 1 year ago
Am I the only person that thought the strings at the beginning kinda looked like balloon animals? ;D
theaaroneason 1 year ago
wow that was awesome! the piece was pretty long but nevertheless still captured my attention. nice animation too :)
geo9m 1 year ago
You've encoded the entire piece!?! That must have taken days!
UberMenschNowFilms 1 year ago
my ears = on fire at 3:53 - 4:10
ipwnallnubscuzirock 1 year ago
@ipwnallnubscuzirock Ha! Think how hot the pianist's fingers were!
UberMenschNowFilms 1 year ago
I very much enjoyed this version. Please stay with this one for now, Smalin!
Hazelrat10 1 year ago
Ah, I love the bars for the piano and the bubbles for the strings. That works really well.
Nykytyne2 1 year ago
I really need to make a playlist of your stuff. You've posted some truly great music, present company included.
TheCrypticPie 1 year ago
Mozart floats my boat.
Nomm098 1 year ago
I love the mix of instruments in this one between piano and strings! Very good pick smalin!!
urchin34 1 year ago
At 2:57 i thought it was going to be Fur Elise
XxTTechxX 1 year ago
@XxTTechxX haha that was a good observation
xXMonkeymufinXx 1 year ago
yay~ something i can try to understand
BladeOfDawn 1 year ago