A lot of people don't seem to understand that the point of covering a song isn't to make it better than the original. They're so different, I think it's ok to like both.
Blade, that is aweosme. But remember, Bill has also been a baseball, basketball, rugby, and tennis player, among other careers as a children's book author, a lawyer, a MLB manager, a drummer for Medeski Martin and Wood and a guitarist for Good Charlotte.
Bill, why didn't you tell us you were so accomplished?
This is very creative. I really enjoyed but I think I enjoy the original better, the song is slower and seems to fit the meaning. Nonetheless this is more fun to dance and scream along to.
then i should have left my previous comment up then. Ska / Punk and grey shirts is not emo. Emo is a style of music derived from the hardcore scene in the 80s, later renamed for the stylings of bands like the Get Up Kids and Sunny Day Real Estate in the 90's. Emo is a word that has now formed itself into absolutely no meaning whatsoever, cept for people to use it when they want to talk poorly about someone. It means absolutely nothing.
When this video first started I was like "Woah Bill, whatcha doin' there..." but then you won me over (yet again) by the end of the first verse. Arguably better than the Alan/Tom version--and that's saying something. *kudos*
This was amazingly well done. I love that you took it to a completely different genre of music and really made the cover your own. Great job on using some of the imagery from the music video for 'Can't' as well. I don't think that I can say enough positive things about this cover. You are incredibly talented and I hope you continue making music for a long time to come.
bill, when i heard this song this morning from alan i instantly fell in love with the song all over again! love your take on the song. i think it's great that you kept the puppet them going for this video.
hahaha the mask lol the part where ur attached to ribbons is really weird lol ur friends!! XD awesome song (tom's voice isnt exactly great) i luv this one better <3 dr. noise ftw!!! :)
why does the intro sound like teenage mutant ninja turtles?? :D
ElectricNeonBlue 10 months ago
it's the skaa remix!
s0merand0mdude95 11 months ago
It really sounds like a noise, not a song. Hoooraaayyy for doctor noise :D
Darvys 1 year ago
I love this cover, but I still like the original better! :)
vesleMari 1 year ago
This song is amazing. :D
It reminds me of AFI, a lot...?
TheBloodMoonShines 1 year ago
God, I love your covers :D
reinix 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
theyre like fags that having a gay party at their house and its so not cool
MichaelKenneth19 1 year ago
Is it hard to play guitar with that mask on?
I love this cover, but it won't download on iTunes :(
bo0kw05m 1 year ago
@bo0kw05m practically impossible haha
doctornoise 1 year ago
Yours is by far my favorite version. Excellent work.
virverum 1 year ago
@virverum thanks so much <3
doctornoise 1 year ago
I love the woah's in this so much. haha One of my favorite parts of this version.
Marj12592 1 year ago
@Marj12592 yaaaay :)
doctornoise 1 year ago
what the .. ?
LEEKIMHOUNG 1 year ago
Bill's covers make me happy to be alive. Then, the originals.. those are like pure gold.
Awesome cover, I think I love all three versions.
iownyewall 1 year ago 2
@iownyewall there's a million versions of this song now, I love 'em all too!
doctornoise 1 year ago
i love the original video
smashleyBFMV 1 year ago
I just realized I wasn't subscribed to you. How did that happen? hmmm..
kaylenfalse 2 years ago
A lot of people don't seem to understand that the point of covering a song isn't to make it better than the original. They're so different, I think it's ok to like both.
OhmigodAreyouserious 2 years ago 14
@OhmigodAreyouserious ;) you are correct.
doctornoise 1 year ago
This is so freakin epic!! Win for doctornoise! Seriously, I can't believe how well this song fits in this style.
also - wow.... I am disappointed by the amount of people on here who don't get the point of a maxi single....lol
bekabee24 2 years ago 5
@bekabee24 welcome to a world where stupid is allowed a voice xD
doctornoise 1 year ago 5
this is still one of my favorite songs ever
breakthroughassault 2 years ago
@breakthroughassault cheers mate!
doctornoise 1 year ago
I love this version, you rock!
If anything, it's at the very least better than the ALL CAPS version, which I also quite enjoyed
countcube 2 years ago
I like this. I think I'll buy this.
781228XX 2 years ago
i love the original and you guys did a cool rendition of this ;)
Pollishus 2 years ago
i prefer the original video
this just seems tacky and as if ur making fun of the original which im sure ur not
but it annoys me
so even tho i prefer ur version the original is better
:)
SmileysAreMagical 2 years ago
The original is better.
D:
Lugiaheart 2 years ago
i think the original is better.... (I THINK)
Dunn0ne 2 years ago
this is stupid the original version is best
MichaelKenneth19 2 years ago
@MichaelKenneth19 I understand you don't like it, but next time try not to be so rude.
iownyewall 2 years ago
I do like it, but I'm sorry, any song without Tom Milsom just isn't good enough for me ]=
FlameDemo 2 years ago
lol, is that your way of saying... no song is good without Tom? you may be his biggest fan ;)
doctornoise 2 years ago
@doctornoise i adore him! haha!
FlameDemo 2 years ago
poor little puppet i say give your self a mouth and sow the little girls mouth together so she nkow how it gfeels
peacelover1651 2 years ago
awesome :P
kkhaydee164 2 years ago
its ok but my fav is still the original
MsSparta14 2 years ago 11
friggin awesome
n___n
duuumb 2 years ago
a little Irish drinking songish but i liked it, a good cover, you put your sound to the original well.
pennpluto14 2 years ago
ahhh!
I like the original. but then making a cover that changes it to my favorite music genre?
5 stars.
holdthescuzimanAINT 2 years ago
Good Cover...Better then orginal :)
Adrianboxcarracer 2 years ago
No it is not
LadyLizzyLizard 2 years ago
yes it is ;)
Adrianboxcarracer 2 years ago
no its not
j21721j21721 2 years ago
Yes it is :)
punkslilncs 2 years ago
I think the music was to loud for the song it is suposed to be a nice soft beat
mrmonkey238 2 years ago
i kinda like it haha
it sounds pretty wicked
xXxkillerxkerstinxXx 2 years ago
Nice attempt.
RethParish 2 years ago
I like the other one better
scarpredator247 2 years ago 2
Haha this is cool. but I like the other original better.
shiningeyes999x 2 years ago 2
I'm glad you enjoyed the song!
doctornoise 2 years ago
this is a happier version of the song lol. I love this too!
kyomaru411 2 years ago
hooray! cheers
doctornoise 2 years ago
wth man
emobutterfly12 2 years ago
so much better!
doggiking 2 years ago
I'm glad you enjoyed the song.
doctornoise 2 years ago
i liked this version alot better
XpriceXofXbloodX 2 years ago
I'm glad you liked it.
doctornoise 2 years ago
i like this version ,but it conveys a different meaning to the original.
abbeycat104 2 years ago
tiz true. ;)
doctornoise 2 years ago
For some reason I feared for the singer to fail...but he didn't. This version is way better than original.
Ramboclot 2 years ago
you dare question me?! ;) I'm glad you liked the song.
doctornoise 2 years ago
very nice
bobogej 2 years ago
thanks bob
doctornoise 2 years ago
LOVED IT! :D
I love the original song, and I love your cover as well! :)
Becky2266 2 years ago
You should make some original ska songs!
This cover is fantastic.
-Francis
Francis9105 2 years ago
Blade, that is aweosme. But remember, Bill has also been a baseball, basketball, rugby, and tennis player, among other careers as a children's book author, a lawyer, a MLB manager, a drummer for Medeski Martin and Wood and a guitarist for Good Charlotte.
Bill, why didn't you tell us you were so accomplished?
latestranger 2 years ago
I didn't wanna sound all braggy pants. Duh. XD
doctornoise 2 years ago
Are you kidding me???
punkslilncs 2 years ago
Bill Martin (born William Wylie Macpherson, 9 November 1938, Govan, Glasgow) is a Scottish songwriter, music publisher and impresario.
Wow, Bill, I didn't know you were this old. Or Scottish.
The irony is insane though, that guy being a songwriter and all.
Blade5468 2 years ago
it doesn't matter hopw many times I hear this track- the intro STILL sounds like the original theme to Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles!
Bill- quality cover, as always.
FreqyBiker 2 years ago
hah i thought it sounded like teenage muntant ninja turtles too :)!
awesome cover bill
cazxpenguin 2 years ago
I'm not hearing it.. and I so was hoping to, I love TMNT.
punkslilncs 2 years ago
haha, that's funny. Thanks a lot! :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
LOL - Rock on man!
owningyourfinances 2 years ago
*favorite*
Absolutely amazing. I love your nerdness:)
dougiedannyluv 2 years ago
haha, thanks mate
doctornoise 2 years ago
lenore ftw
L0VEgun 2 years ago
That was the awesomest thing I've ever seen, Bill!
erfelgamazig 2 years ago
I lvoe your music ^__^
Silver1226 2 years ago 3
This was awesome, Bill! Can't wait for Subreality!!
emmfan09 2 years ago 2
SO JOKES!
kisachan18 2 years ago
lol wow awesomely cooly
E290 2 years ago 2
This is very creative. I really enjoyed but I think I enjoy the original better, the song is slower and seems to fit the meaning. Nonetheless this is more fun to dance and scream along to.
shaylaluna 2 years ago
I love this so much. It's truly epic <33333
xxxSinead96 2 years ago 2
thank youuuuuu
doctornoise 2 years ago
This was very awesome, both the music and the video.
GinAnMaCa 2 years ago 2
oh hey look, its adam. i didnt know him when i first saw this.
PaulSaysThings 2 years ago
that's really awesome.... :D surreal puppet masks ftw!
smilinglimpet 2 years ago
SKAAAAAAAA!!!!!
CaptainWilhelm 2 years ago 2
since when has the late doctor noise ever done anything remotely emo??
thetallkid 2 years ago
This is love. As always. :D
LifeNeedsWork 2 years ago
<3 Awesome cover, as always, Billiam. 863 stars.
How'd you do the marionette thing? I'm fascinated and slightly confused.
AshleyDough 2 years ago
Awesome Bill! I like how you incorporated bits of Alan's music video into yours. The mask is epic! :)
-Jenea
xXDiscoLemonadeXx 2 years ago
Damn, that's a fuckin' cool video!
PrimusTool08 2 years ago
Oh, wow. This is so awesome.
adamskaviolet 2 years ago
Is that @adamwmichaels who pops up at 0:53. I think it is. :) lol
spazzumgurl 2 years ago
Your pure awesome nerdfighter comebacks make me smile Bill. :)
spazzumgurl 2 years ago
I think you mean. . .HE'S EPIC!
blithium 2 years ago
Yes, that is in fact what I mean Blith. Reading my mind again are we . . . tsk tsk tsk.
Seriously. Epic.
Emo. Never. *rolls eyes at non drocker ignorance*
spazzumgurl 2 years ago
. . .follow adamwmichaels on twitter. . .
blithium 2 years ago
Awesome, really like your cover (of course), the masks are slightly creepy but I do like the concept, especially the puppet strings.
-Julian
ItTakesII 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ugh! Practically emo!
longse0 2 years ago
are you just making a joke? (removed my previous comment just in case you were)
doctornoise 2 years ago
sort of kind of not really
I like the song though
the music video was just emo what with the puppet thing and the mask and everybody wearing grey striped shirts although the chorus was cool...
longse0 2 years ago
then i should have left my previous comment up then. Ska / Punk and grey shirts is not emo. Emo is a style of music derived from the hardcore scene in the 80s, later renamed for the stylings of bands like the Get Up Kids and Sunny Day Real Estate in the 90's. Emo is a word that has now formed itself into absolutely no meaning whatsoever, cept for people to use it when they want to talk poorly about someone. It means absolutely nothing.
doctornoise 2 years ago
that's cool, didn't know there was that much history behind it
longse0 2 years ago
Sometimes you put me in awe.
punkslilncs 2 years ago
You did an awesome job on this one. It sounds completely different than the (amazing) original, but in an awesome way.
Look forward to see what you come up with next.
SupremeAmanda 2 years ago
Haha this is so awesome.
Marj12592 2 years ago
very great, another fav. of mine. XD
charliepace101 2 years ago
Wow, awesome!
Paper mask ;
^_^
-Hazel
hazelizabeth 2 years ago
When this video first started I was like "Woah Bill, whatcha doin' there..." but then you won me over (yet again) by the end of the first verse. Arguably better than the Alan/Tom version--and that's saying something. *kudos*
cupcakes0711 2 years ago
yaaay I'm glad you enjoyed it so much cupcake!
doctornoise 2 years ago
This was just Awesome.
Bill, you need to cover EVERY song ever written.
thhelix 2 years ago 3
hahaha, that's a tall order!
doctornoise 2 years ago
your covers tend to be better than the originals
htpo 2 years ago 2
I approve your comment. lol... seriously though thank you
doctornoise 2 years ago
LOL The mask made me think Jhonen Vasquez.
Awesome job!
WanderingConfused 2 years ago 3
ooooh, yes I can see that. Ed's drawing of that character kinda looks a Jhonen style too, if you ask me. :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
awesome XP
UncoProductions 2 years ago 2
thanks unco!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Great cover. Didn't really know what to expect but I thoroughly enjoyed it.
WasItJustMe 2 years ago 2
haha, thanks much
doctornoise 2 years ago
this is amazing! i didnt think you could do anything better than the original song but its fantastic, awesome job!
sawdust4stardust 2 years ago 2
thanks stardust!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I loved that. good job! :)
sammicula 2 years ago 2
thank ya gurl freeeeeeen
doctornoise 2 years ago
This was amazingly well done. I love that you took it to a completely different genre of music and really made the cover your own. Great job on using some of the imagery from the music video for 'Can't' as well. I don't think that I can say enough positive things about this cover. You are incredibly talented and I hope you continue making music for a long time to come.
spixdon 2 years ago
thanks thanks thanks! I really appreciate your descriptive comment (and would if it was criticism too). you rule spixdon
doctornoise 2 years ago
awesome bill awesome
loboanjo 2 years ago 2
appreciate it lobo
doctornoise 2 years ago
LOVE it.
Well done :)
MusicIsFreedom42 2 years ago 2
thanks!
doctornoise 2 years ago
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII wanna rock and roll aaaaaaaaaaall niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight! AND PARTAY EVERY DAY!
doctornoise 2 years ago
you are so much fun.
hopeonatenspeed 2 years ago
I always seem to love your covers of songs, Bill. You take an awesome song on it's own like "Can't" and turn it into something fun and rocking.
How do you do it, Bill? HOW?
-Sara
CleverestWitch2188 2 years ago
I sold my soul to the make alternate versions of songs devil. XD
doctornoise 2 years ago
Cool, like the video :D Love this version! (And the other one, too. It's hard to pick XP)
dedicatedrr 2 years ago
no need to pick, they're different enough that you can listen to both! :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Yay, human marionettes!
Loved the cover! I should have a review of the CD shortly so that I may own this fantastic piece of music. =-)
shawnmarie2004 2 years ago
yaaay, def. do a review!
doctornoise 2 years ago
effin' amazing. :)
(i like this version better than the original!)
elfkwest 2 years ago 2
woo hoo! thanks Katherine!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I'm just going to add to the heap of comments, I loved it. [:
p.s. I don't know if I've ever told you this, but I really like your use of the green screen.
imgonnabeatree 2 years ago
thanks for the comments and compliments karissa :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
So so fun! Awesome!
valerie2776 2 years ago
thanks val!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Man this is bloody brilliant. So awesome.
You're the best
liamu99 2 years ago
thank you Liam!
doctornoise 2 years ago
BRILLIANT. <33
nerimon 2 years ago 2
thank ya much Alex :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
i love this =]
BassistsRule 2 years ago
thanks! and bassists DO rule :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
This is a win :)
PS I think I'm driving through Vegas on August 5...woo?
amelioooo 2 years ago
awesome let me know when you're coming thru
doctornoise 2 years ago
Loved the group you got together. You should put some of these in HD sometime.
AdmiralGreenscreen 2 years ago
I actually would, but I don't have an HD camera, so it wouldn't be worth it to expand on the resolution :( wish I had one though
doctornoise 2 years ago
Loved it! Very interesting take on the song =D
shaha403 2 years ago
thank you shaha!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Ahhh I can't wait until Taking Leave comes so I can do the blog entry to get this!
'Tis fantastic!
xGlowFliesx 2 years ago
yaaaay, I'm glad you purchased it!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Hah this was great fun. You really made it work as a ska tune :D
GoldenGryffin 2 years ago
thanks! ska/punk used to be about all I listened to back in the late late 90's. :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
i can't even tell you how much of my hero you are.
superj0kes 2 years ago
I loved this...
TMBG1337 2 years ago
glad to hear thank you :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
another awesome performance
goldanima 2 years ago
thanks a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
sweet sweet video Bill :-)
FaeryFaith 2 years ago
thank ya heather!
doctornoise 2 years ago
5 stars for masks and marionettes!
CRAIGworks 2 years ago
hoooray, thanks Craig
doctornoise 2 years ago
Omgosh... I like this version better... am I allowed to say that? Cause yeah... I do. =D
caseadillas 2 years ago
you're allowed... I don't mind lol thanks much
doctornoise 2 years ago
bill, when i heard this song this morning from alan i instantly fell in love with the song all over again! love your take on the song. i think it's great that you kept the puppet them going for this video.
way to go!
saradod 2 years ago
thanks sara, I loved the puppet theme and felt it had to stay in this vid too. it was fun trying to string all that up lol
doctornoise 2 years ago
Hey bill where do you get your drum tracks?
LiquidFriction 2 years ago
I make them
doctornoise 2 years ago
with what?
LiquidFriction 2 years ago
hellz yea. good stuff
thinkthegirlsgonemad 2 years ago
thanks much :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
hahaha the mask lol the part where ur attached to ribbons is really weird lol ur friends!! XD awesome song (tom's voice isnt exactly great) i luv this one better <3 dr. noise ftw!!! :)
BriIsTheFinestCheese 2 years ago