i am only 12 and am no expert on the flute yet!!!! i have listened to many recordings of this movement so know ruffly the style and how it should go but i have to say this performace was good in places but overall i just notcied way to many mistakes and just not enuff drive!
i hope you dont mind my honest opinion....overall some really good playing
A lovely musical performance,but it's a miracle it sounds any good considering his flute is aiming straight to the floor! What awful posture! I can't believe he can get ANY movement in his right arm, it's bent at his elbow and is hand is a claw!
I do really like though that this is played vigourously, as this movement should be.
I think that you all need to listen to more flute players then James Galaway and Paula Robison. This is a great recording! Fenwick Smith rocks, I'd like to see you hold a position in the BSO. As far as his posture goes he actually plays out of the side of his mouth (can't see due to video quality) so to make the flute even with his lips the flute has to be pointed down.
i am only 12 and am no expert on the flute yet!!!! i have listened to many recordings of this movement so know ruffly the style and how it should go but i have to say this performace was good in places but overall i just notcied way to many mistakes and just not enuff drive!
i hope you dont mind my honest opinion....overall some really good playing
mmcoopstar 2 years ago
あんまり上手じゃないよね~・・・
ほんとにフルーティストなの?
choco931 2 years ago
I don't like...
I'm sorry
mozartfl92 3 years ago
I agree with you.
zaffiro61 2 years ago
Que fracasso total da pianista... falta interação
CarmenSkaf 4 years ago 3
he plays it to slow and without enthusiasm, how said evaaba
he shold show more differences between the parts, in the sound for example
kissingacherry 4 years ago
it could have more enthusiasm
evaaba 4 years ago
nice, but I prefer the violin version.. but anyway, it's very interesting to know where this sonata comes from!
mirelapaulus 4 years ago
The viol in version of this sonata was written by Oistrack with the permission of the composer. The original version is for flute!
zaffiro61 2 years ago
Very good performance! This piece it's really HARD!! I think it's only a bit slow!
lrodor 4 years ago
awesome articulation on the low register. This is REAL flute (see my channel).
ninaflute 4 years ago 4
I agree, I've never understood how people can play like that.
TraurigeJunge 4 years ago 2
A lovely musical performance,but it's a miracle it sounds any good considering his flute is aiming straight to the floor! What awful posture! I can't believe he can get ANY movement in his right arm, it's bent at his elbow and is hand is a claw!
I do really like though that this is played vigourously, as this movement should be.
Phoenixbird27 5 years ago 2
I think that you all need to listen to more flute players then James Galaway and Paula Robison. This is a great recording! Fenwick Smith rocks, I'd like to see you hold a position in the BSO. As far as his posture goes he actually plays out of the side of his mouth (can't see due to video quality) so to make the flute even with his lips the flute has to be pointed down.
irenicflutist 4 years ago 4