Rock Band the beatles: a Paul is Dead "clue"

[Supermopho]

These rumors came out in the mid to late sixties. Its all BS. How can you find a left handed bass playing look alike? Plus, the kind of medical science to make some one a look alike wasn't around then.

[HaloGuy2112]

where is the clue

[Godzillabreath1]

Really bro? Thats stupid. People need to get over this stupid and UNTRUE rumor.

[BeatleManiaForver99]

In some religion the hand over a head means death, for the people that dont know. And that was George's hand!

[stratocaster1231]

How does that tell he's dead. And he isn't dead he has the same birth mark he had before 1966 when he "died"

[gakirkham]

i saw the guy live a month ago. He's not fucking dead.

[rocklive88]

kueeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­k

[itscalledBeatlemania]

well, that was stupid -__- Paul McCartney is NOT dead, end of story. there's nothing else to discuss.

[olimpicus]

@itscalledBeatlemania who is discussing?

[adictoalaaviacion]

@itscalledBeatlemania right

[VivaCanibbal]

@itscalledBeatlemania Paul McCartney is dead, it`s the really

[fruitfan44]

Paul is not dead

[fifiesponja07]

-.-'

[TheNightOwlsSquadron]

No no no you have it wrong. It's the fact that the plane has 10 windows that Paul is dead. "Honestly don't you two read?"

[WuvMuffin72]

THAT WASNT ANYTHING

[BeatlesForever60]

that was before they thought that he died

[star1999ish]

i think paul isn´t dead

[Rayven10]

Ok, this "Paul is dead" thing is getting a bit too much. Some of the "clues" are interesting (but stupid), but this one is just a serious reach.

[aNoeHFproduction]

I dont get it...

[dimebuckerpickups]

palm over his he u think?

[Pollandtheawesome]

what kind of lifeless moron are you?

[conductor5001]

Wow people he not dead

[JulianSaucedo1985]

i'd don't get it?

[Bahamutdordi]

*Sigh*..... Dude? -.-

[Harleyquinn191]

SCREAMER!

oh, wait no.

[NTConner]

Gusse what paul is not dead so go to beatles school if you can

[TheRuberito]

not even!

[26klyde]

George's strumming and picking hand.

[blablabla7947]

ARE YOU SHIT.... what?

[LouSoufier]

Aside from the chem trails in the sky nothing noteworthy here.

[TheFourFingers11]

its georges hand!!!!

[MrGhero96]

hm there are alot of paul is dead clues, and then again there is alot of evidence that he is alive.

but all that really matters is the music! they rocked the world and still do :D

[ixcheli99]

FAKE

[TheBlueBeatle3]

I love people who explode because of the Paul is dead conspiracy. We will know if he is DEAD or ALIVE the day the remaining Beatles depart to the afterlife! Because when one dies, SOMETHING is going to be left behind!

[MrLintRoller]

Awesome if people dont get the reference fuck them i am a true beatles fan i got the reference very nice find! By the wa people wouldnt believe the truth if it was handed to them.

[gradsssara]

lol, i just like to point out that i thought i my bro should be dead so i put my hand over his head

turns out

he is still alive

man i thought that would work but guess not

[areposo]

OMG NOT EVEN THE VIDEOGAMES SAVES FROM THAT STUPID STORY PAUL IS NOT DEAD OMG

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo It's part of The Beatles history, ok?

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 BULLSHIT

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo It is. And if you can't handle it, then so sorry for you, my friend. But it's connected to them which makes part of their history and legacy. If you want to be stubborn then go right ahead. I am being honest.

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3  again , bullshit

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo Obstinate

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 BULLSHITER

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo Again, obstinate.

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 AGAIN BULLSHITER

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo (Facepalm) Look. All I am going to say is that despite the rumor, most of their songs have the clues, meaning that either way, the "rumor" is always going to be there. Whether it is true, or false.

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 (Facepalm) you are just a huuuge bullshiter

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo Smh

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 jmwo

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo LOL (: But even so, THE BEATLES ROCK! xD

[areposo]

@TheBlueBeatle3 FINALLY WE AGREE!!!

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@areposo xP Rumor or not, they are the freaking GREATEST!!!!

[MrPabloFTW]

Paul is not dead!! I follow him on Facebook and Twitter!!!

[FretLegendSmithy]

this is so overblown. People have just said "oh look there's a hand over his head, he must be dead!"

it's like saying, oh my god look he's wearing black shoes! HE'S FUCKING DEAD!

idiots. overblown crap.

[SirVanLongDong]

No wonder they would include this hand over the head shit

That goes all the way back to pepper and is pretty much beatle tradition. Im pretty sure that the beatles rock band is filled with more PID clues and is just waiting to be cracked by some nut case.

[TheBlueBeatle3]

@SirVanLongDong Well that "nut case" will have done a lot of research to put at ease this conspiracy.

[KaiPiter]

Paul McCartney is alive and well and that was George's hand, my friend.

[olimpicus]

@KaiPiter i think you're right my friend, greetings!

Peace & Love

[NirvanaNerd364]

@KaiPiter Dude thats the point a big thing in the paul is dead movie is that on album covers various people are holding their hands witha peace sign over his head thats the joke in this picture George is holding a peace sign over paul's head

[LasgalenOsten]

12 people and the author of the video brain's are dead

[laughablemania]

12 people forgot to dislike this

[dominicanoaki]

ok i am thumb downing the video.... there!

[olimpicus]

@dominicanoaki thanks for watching ;)

[Redhotice54]

Nobody ever would have noticed the so called "clues" if nobody had mentioned the idea that Paul was dead in the first place.

[TJS2400]

That arm was George's wasn't it?

[olimpicus]

@TJS2400 yes

[TJS2400]

@olimpicus Then, how's it a clue?

[olimpicus]

@TJS2400 the hand over Paul's head, that's the clue in the PID theory. I don't remember seeing that someone in particular had to do it. It just have to be a hand over Paul's head

[John37816]

@olimpicus its te open palm hand they say its a symbol of death

[olimpicus]

@John37816 you're right, i think in hindu philosophy or in many cultures I'm not sure i saw it a long time ago...

[Ihy744ppp]

man, get a life, paul is alive!

[olimpicus]

@Ihy744ppp I know, but this (i think) is a Paul is dead "clue" as the title says. PID is part of the beatles mythology, and a very creative game made by them

[Ihy744ppp]

@olimpicus its just a fucking coincidence.. or is it?

People tend to believe that they're clues..

When John sang The walrus was Paul, it had nothing to do with it, just stating a fact that he was in the costume and to make the song rhyme...

Or is that a coincidence..?

(smile)

[olimpicus]

@Ihy744ppp but there are lots of "clues" on the beatles albums, they even played in their solo carreer like George in "when we were fab", I think it could be an artistic way of showing the importance of Paul in the band or maybe some internal fight or a way to play with the car accident that Paul suffer in the 60's... I don't know but what I think I know is that the "Paul is Dead" game was intentional.

[Ihy744ppp]

@olimpicus No, it's not, you just see what you want to see, there also WERE never clues on the solo albums, rubbish.. In fact the Beatles didn't make it up, somebody else did (in 69) , the fabs played along a little, but never with clues, the whole Abbey road theory is a load of crap, I do think Paul was involved in a car accident, some books say he was and it maye have appeared in some papers, so the people who thought up the whole thing used that as an perfect (perhaps brilliant) alternative.

[olimpicus]

@Ihy744ppp I respect your opinion if you think they never tried to make this Paul is dead game, it's ok.

Peace & Love.

[Ihy744ppp]

@olimpicus It's not a Paul is dead game, ok.. but plz understand that Paul was never dead, I mean thinking about it makes no SENSE at all, Peace and love..

[olimpicus]

@Ihy744ppp plz read what i post here, I don't think he is dead, i just think the beatles made "clues" maybe like a way to play with his car accident, or for some esotheric thing I don't know. They were very creative so to me is not weird. AGAIN i don't think Paul is dead (first post)

[Ihy744ppp]

@olimpicus Ok, but plz understand that there aren't any clues...

Atleast not trhe abbey road cover, it's all in the mind you know....

[olimpicus]

@Ihy744ppp no one really knows

[Ihy744ppp]

@olimpicus I do.. That you want to see what you want to see..

[dhruvluke]

a hand over pauls head as he stands next to george? nahhhh. we all know george didnt actually have arms.theres no way he is sticking his arm out next to paul.

[jpzorrilla]

Faul is dead!

[blackspiderman12345]

@jpzorrilla i know they misspelled it ha

[CharlieMansonIsGod]

Also I love from Sgt Pepper on in the game they still make Paul McCartneys doppleganger look more like the real Paul, nothing like he did really in 1967 on. Though if you notice, even the pre-66 Paul was tampered with, It's truley the most hybrid image of both Pauls split down the line i've ever seen. Another interesting note is they tamper the 69 songs with a little bit more of a Billy mug.

[CharlieMansonIsGod]

they have interviews from a ton of staff members that are hardcore "beatles fans" speak about there coming of aging with Beatles music, than as the credits are rolling they have a little contest to see who can draw the best Paul McCartney. No doubt a huge majority of the developers knew of this undeniable fact beforehand, because it's usual standard if your to work with Beatles material, but I wonder how many developers figured it out just while pixelating.

[CharlieMansonIsGod]

oh man, glad you found that, cause i've noticed how amazingly liberating that came was to the publics conciousness of who The Beatles actually were. Just like painters ranging from the late 60s to now, once you try to draw or paint Paul McCartney, ESP being an accompished and educated illustrator the facts become undeniable. I've heard countless recollections from people. The most interesting of things they did while promoting this game, is that you watch the half hour long VH1 promotion

[Cigarello23J]

@GnikNusEht the backwards Tuesday sign might be a reference to I Am the Walrus?

[thefootstepsofdawn]

It's probably mocking the "mysterious" extra hands which appear at random intervals in the Help! movie, which were put there for the sake of comedy... or it's mocking how people mistook those extra hands as Paul is Dead clues.

[greenhalos725]

Wow, even in the game there's a clue.

[Polanca54XD]

o shit no again!!!

[elbuenbeto666]

Well, I noticed that Paul looks very pissed on I Am The Walrus, is that a PID too?

[beetlezumbie]

i dont see the clue

[olimpicus]

a hand over Paul´s head

[ThatOtherGuy201]

@beetlezumbie neither do I. So it's a hand. what does that mean?

[DieToFleshNotSpirit]

@beetlezumbie In Every album Paul had a right hand on top of his head.

[ladybuglove4all]

@beetlezumbie in some cultures a hand above someone's head mean's that guy is dead, and if i didn't knew that, i would have said the same ;)

[TRUTHSHALLMAKEYOUFRE]

and the chemtrails

[elmokoning]

I also saw another clue yester. I was playing hello goodbye and the wave goodbye, but the hand above paul's head is different from the other hands

[guitarmonsterthing]

thats not a good clue

[elmokoning]

@guitarmonsterthing but the were always screwing up the hand above paul thingie. I think this is a parody to that

[gh3freak70]

@elmokoning

[TheColts99]

Wow!

[Freakshow180]

Oh wow! I was wondering if this game was going to have any Paul is Dead clues. I love looking for these.

[Nacho2333]

The funny thing is he isnt dead.

[olimpicus]

I think that there´s still a lot of things to learn, I just hope that at the end there will be an answer

[dhanifan1]

I noticed John's hand over Paul's head in the Walrus sequence but missed this one, thanks! Also, there were some post cards that came with the game (for x box 360 anyway) and there was the picture of Paul holding a sign with a ?, it's an old picture but why would they add it? Cause PID!

[olimpicus]

you´re right I guess.... I love all this PID mith, it adds some mystic to all the Beatles stuff

[felipegcs]

At the end of the same trailer -intro for the Rock Band videogame, the fab 4 appeared over a giant elephant. Note that John appears like the walrus -dressed in black-, and he putted his hand over Paul's head... AGAIN in the same videoclip!!

Obviously NOT a coincidence

[MegaMacTV]

True, but that image of them was derived from an actual photo they had, which back then was too linked with the hand and the Paul is Dead mess, lol.

[moroccita1]

and look, we must not forget the "chemtrails" .. also appear in the image ;-D

[olimpicus]

wow I didn´t saw that, thanks moroccia ;)

[olimpicus]

I saw your comment and I found the video. The only thing that called my attention was that in 1:43 appears a guy in a wanted sign that (maybe) looks like crowley...

[AlanLhb]

What's with it?

[olimpicus]

a hand over Paul´s head is a PID clue for the PIDers, its a reference to death in some cultures I think....