趙學而 - 最佳位置

[lastcar]

好希望佢有多d好歌出

[Sweetmochixx]

喜歡這種淡淡的苦澀

[hkg4755]

呢家日日睇佢起皆大歡喜發癲真係睇唔出唱歌咁好聽

[Mr216Crazy]

evolutionvi 於 2006-11-13 上傳

2012仲有聽既過黎讚好!

[Suki96413]

雖然我唔覺咩好唔好過Kelly 不過一定好過 林欣彤~唉... 香港唔會再有好歌聽

[s20064001]

@Suki96413 超級認同.. 唔明D人點解咁中意林欣彤。

[guschcc]

最佳位置:

"虔誠地 熱戀一輩子 , 共你也許真的不容易 ,喜歡你最好不要講 ,安守這位置"

明目張膽:

"我怕揭露了　不精彩

拆穿了　總盼望誰在意　蜜月難再

如若你發覺有我在　就結束暗戀的時代"

[BbJai169]

又靚女又唱得好過原唱

點解會消失左架 香港樂壇點搞架

[Chanchyin]

@BbJai169 香港無樂壇, 只有娛樂圈。

[kl825]

@Chanchyin

[tencrance]

请你给我留下位置~~

[wing0304]

每日都聽…直到結局改變

[jpcknald]

請你給我留下位置

[kofuku717]

Like her, she is a strong woman!

[he890se7en1994]

唉，以家唔識唱歌戈d就出唱片而趙學而唱得咁好要唔出唱片，咩世­界？d

[snakesss1112]

@he890se7en1994 佢有出~新碟你買左未?

[ben1233321]

結婚了: )

[wawawawaxd]

@ben1233321 我在地鐵聽到這消息也為學而祝福

如果佢開concert我一定去

[alienvisiting]

只可說陳慧琳出生於一個太幸福的家庭﹐有一條太幸運的命﹐所以相­比起來﹐學而一定有感情過陳。學而也是一個悲傷故事過來人﹐但她­很堅強。

[wingwing0404]

學而既version 佢handle得好好, 佢輕聲淡淡然咁唱, 唱出作為一個朋友無力將關係再一步既無奈, 真真正正切合歌詞意思, 真正的感動到我.

[TSzHO330033]

唱得好過陳慧琳？

其實唱功不是差很多~

不過 這個版本我蠻喜歡~

很柔和......

[wingwing0404]

@TSzHO330033 我個人真係認為學而唱得好聽D. 而且arrangemen都係比較好.

[ivantalkative]

老實, 我覺得kelly同趙學宜都好聽...(我留意左趙學宜好耐, 佢好耐之前ge作品都好正 e.g. 據為己有)

一樣睇法請比賺...

[lovejinyoung1]

讚!!!!

這版本實在觸動深很多.

kelly那個是一般傷情慢歌,

這個唱法, 這個編曲, 更突顯歌詞那種深藏的感覺

連mv都正到暈, 好sad.

詞寫得很好, 很能表達這種態度--雖然,我不贊成.

\

[tamki811]

唱得好好！

[cheriwip]

Oh I cried she sang out all my feelings...

[cheriwip]

幺心幺肺

[MrSantonix]

呢首歌的歌詞意境, 學而個唱法比較適合D

[suyikwan]

I love this version~~

[hysc228]

其實我覺得首歌嘅編曲都幫左好多~~~

[2010cyk]

Kelly先唱，之後填詞人黃偉文出精選，找趙學而重唱自家詞作­，唱出原本填詞時的feel及編曲…

[bearbear1231220]

本身唔知佢係邊個.. 岩岩睇緊皆大歡喜 先知佢係趙學而.. 原來............ 佢唱歌咁正.. 比佢把聲吸引住喇!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

[fcm3388]

good...................



[fcm3388]

聲音很靚,如果放棄唱歌太可惜...



[booooo222]

@fcm3388 冇放棄到唱歌wo佢 8月1出新碟 trinity

[john199322]

請你記著留下給我這位置

[coollym]

very good! :)

does it have eng ver lyrics?

[idoldollzina]

趙學而勝陳慧琳九千幾條街

[aw05172001]

她的低音共鳴跟聲音魅力，比現在的所謂天后好太多

[wolfmen]

這版本實在觸動深很多.

kelly那個是一般傷情慢歌,

這個唱法, 這個編曲, 更突顯歌詞那種深藏的感覺

連mv都正到暈, 好sad.

詞寫得很好, 很能表達這種態度--雖然,我不贊成.

[christyk97]

he should be able to succeed even more! i miss her! hopefully she will continue her acting and singing career!

[faatchannel]

比陳慧琳強得多了

[chibihing]

很好聽，佢開演唱會我一定去。永遠支持。佢當年那首[每隔兩秒]­，到而家都覺得好好。

[garylo2010]

好有苦悶既feel

good!!!

[adjustlove]

趙學而唱得好好，無可挑剔，感覺雖然得好似淡淡然，但係實則係無­奈，所以更加幺心幺肺。

[chunyinho]

honestly, I think the orginal verson is better.. i do think classic canto-pop arrange suit the song more. it's actually a K song with sad mood* but I would say this is also a nice cover.

[dickandron]

this version flows much better compared to kelly's

[pterosur0529]

感覺像是

苦笑著跟對方說 無論你喜歡誰  請你記住留下給我這位置

很舒服 沒有聲嘶力竭 只有苦笑無奈

很動聽:)

[suetyeee]

無論你喜歡誰 請你記住留下給我這位置!!!!

[hkmoonlam]

佢首自欺欺人..我到而家都仲記得

佢肯出返黎唱..我第一個去睇!!!

[TheHello4488]

真系唱得好好啊

[edwincwt]

好好聽....

唱多d歌俾我地聽喇~~

[mc525]

kelly's version is better.....

[hkgsoso]

佢把聲係靚

但唱既方法係唱錯

呢首歌跟本係首覺得好委屈既歌

但佢唱左好享受咁既感覺

[S9259003]

@hkgsoso 應該係會委屈 只不過主角好enjoy呢 一種關係 先至唱到咁

[wolfmen]

@hkgsoso

我唔覺佢唱得好享受, 好明顯係唱得好內歛及抑壓,

正正係想保持o既位置唔見得光先會有咁o既表現.

[devil0609]

一個羅敏莊,一個趙學而,兩個都係滄海遺珠

[thomastmwc]

@devil0609 hi fi 友先識羅敏莊

[mrmimi1967]

點解咁好聽都唔紅呢?欠缺什麼呢?

[jovi115]

表達到無奈, 又接受左個事實, 同首歌好夾 讚!!

[FrostRuby]

超級巨聲請左羅敏莊之後應該講埋趙學而! 讓大家見識見識!

[thisisisabee]

@FrostRuby 對！我都有這樣想過，希望會成真，真的好期待！

[jamesontse]

oh god, this verison is so worse than kelly's one. she sounds breathless, fragile and vocally weak....

[molly0922]

覺得呢首係不得不放棄之後唱出既無奈...又或者係解脫

但KELLY 個ver 係仲醞釀緊, 未放低既...未甘心放低...!

個人覺得kelly ver 會好d, 因為...聽落肉緊d 先有共鳴,

我都係覺得自己個情況無奈, 慘先去聽d 慘情歌...而呢首好明顯係慘情歌...

所以覺得kelly ver. 好聽d~

[am5a03]

一種很舒服、relax的感覺

深夜聽著簡直是一種享受

[mintjambaby]

下, 我覺得一D都唔好聽, 呢首歌係一首好無奈, 好委屈, 好自我安慰的歌,

竟然編首咁輕快的音樂, 再+ 埋咁輕快的唱法,

KELLY 版本係正勁多囉....

[bebuho]

@mintjambaby

我就反而覺得呢個version好過kelly果個

無人規定過呢首歌一定要唱到好委屈

可能你先入為主啦..

我一開始聽kelly果個都覺得唔錯

但係聽完趙學而呢個version就覺得好舒服

反而kelly過份用力...

但係有時心稔 如果wyman真係覺得kelly唱得到既話

就唔會邀請bondy再唱多次啦...

[mintjambaby]

@bebuho 但歌詞根本係講緊佢做後備好無奈,

好似乞討個男人, 無論如何都比個「位」佢咁..

首歌唱得咁輕快, 攪到趙學而好似好ENJOY 做後備咁,

我聽KELLY 果首真係有心痛的感覺....

不過都係各人意見啦~係有D 好奇點解會無人鍾意KELLY VER =口=..

[lamchuini]

佢把聲好好聽!

[53521]

原版唱到好以叫救命,呢隻版本舒服好多,好聽!!!

[sls19057]

better than kelly

[balesjay]

好過陳慧琳... VERY GOOD!

[pennywong852]

I like kelly very much

but in fact, 趙學而's version is much better

support support 趙學而

[tamsaiwing]

學而 <3333

[summer08802002]

兩個不同的版本，兩個不同的編曲，

兩個不同的情感，兩個不同的表達。

何必要硬去做不公平的比較？

[vincent731]

好悶...唔好聽

kelly唱得好聽好多

[crazeduk09]

歌詞內容岩呢種style既唱法/version

[ky2324]

無端Mv定Style.

我都鐘意Kelly個版本多啲.

[jamesoncastor]

i like kelly's version more

[tigger82917]

先入為主！！！趙學而好ｄ

[din3786]

覺得呢首歌既感覺係心甘命抵

KELLY版就係被逼等待既感覺

鐘意呢首歌d

[littleegirll]

ho ho tang!!!

[kwanathena]

佢唱得好過陳慧琳

好好聽.....

[manyi1021]

@kwanathena 唔可以咁講；唔同覺得囉>< 2者都好好!

[rinoama]

kelly used too much skill to sing this song so that the feeling kind of doesnt match the song

趙學而 sings well and I can feel what she sings.

[spaceship2009]

i like this version more

[bondychiuclub]

too bad bondy isn't in this MV it would have been much better seeing her. I'm not too fond of mvs where you can't see the singer at all.

[katzlouie]

個人很喜愛這個版本, 很有 feel!!

[sunshinysky]

趙學而歌藝好d，老實講，我覺得陳慧琳唔係好識唱歌

[sap00acm]

Kelly o個首就傷心d...

依首就輕鬆得意d....

[ltk0020]

mv最後係咪有人被掉低左??

[S1a08]

個mv好特別..

[amylamsl]

正！趙學而唱得好有feel...

[simpson680]

I like Kelly Chan's as well, but I like this version more than that

[edmond1128]

I love this version more than original version

[lpy031504]

趙學而真心覺得佢係正~

佢d歌ga風格好特別~~

比起e+d歌手-_-.....

[qmhandy]

學而的歌聲比joey更好

[safarihk]

呢啲仲駛問嘅,容祖兒根本冇得同學而比,容小姐收啦.

我細個睇娛樂新聞眼已經好鍾意佢.

[joeyfans]

有咩冇得比 ?

唔覺得容祖兒差過趙學而。

[ok3Q]

very fun 唱出很不同的感覺

感覺很頹 將所有感情都放低了 沒有一絲不開心

只要他能有空時想起她 約她喝杯茶 傾下計 就已經足夠了

真的有趣 一首歌有兩種不同的感覺

[Nausataki]

說得很對~

[wonkalover222]

hehe, this is a fun verison~~ not bad...no longer a sad song. =)

[arsheir]

好有 feel

唔係單單show個歌唱技巧出黎

個人鍾意呢個版本多於原本既版本

[lpy031504]

同意~

哩首d節拍表現得好輕鬆

[Kellychen7]

nice.. but the original version is better :)

[BritishRacingGreen]

nice video

[taffytong]

i like 趙學而 version

[mapyman]

都係原唱好啲

support Kelly's version

[50255244]

趙學而version太好了

[bondychiuclub]

too bad they didn't make a real music video with Bondy in it...I wanted to see her in the MV :(

[evolutionvi]

this version is 趙學而

[bondychiuclub]

maybe you should put it in the description and tags that would be easier for the viewers thank you :D

[vivisaeri]

kelly chan

[joe6041887]

does someone know the artist's name?