@kais01 that's not true, everyone knows that, and his own bestfriend is a proof of that, don't know if anyone here has heard of it, it's an interview with his bestfriend who told everything abou Ahmad Zahir going to prison with him and another friend and about him being accused for the murder of a girl that he never killed and at the very end he was questioned about Ahmad Zahir's death. He said he never died in a car crash, infact he got out after the accident and asked if the people who were
@kais0 with him were ok, then they were brought to hospital where they got to see Ahmad Zahir dead ody beingbrought, his bestfriend also told what happened, Ahmad Zahir was shot first in the head and then someone threw a big stone at him so that his eyes would pop out.....you can even search on google where th doctors who had examined his body confirmed that he infact was shot in the head. He was against communists you know....he was very politically invovlved so you can't say for sure.
@kais01 Communists were enemies of Afghans. They martyred innocent Afghans and initiated the destruction of the whole system, they are responsible for murdering our pride "Ahmad Zahir", Watch Ahmad Zahir's sister saying that on youtube.
@badmintonworldvideos This all was propaganda taught by the West to destabilize the country and win the cold war, Just think and imagine why would a governement do that. Dont believe the rumours and the media, judge and think for yourself.
Ahmad Zahir was not only a legend, but he was a good moslim. He helped always poor people. he was 32 old years when he is deed...... But ,... about this ... Mansour,
.. How old is he.... ? and ,, what deed he for the poor people?
Ahmad zahir is the king of persian music(afghanistan and iran) so what if mansour jan copys him after we r brothers with the same history zinda bad persia
omg AHMAD JAN ZAHIR SONGG O LOVE THIS SONGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!! it ok caz everyone noes it afg songs not iranian... lool... nice song love it lotsssssssssssssssss
I never agree what you say.Because Ahmad Zahir is a suprbe singer and a great musician forever.His musics famous and has worht for 30milion ppl only in Afghanistan.If you think Mansor is better so why he desire to copy his music?
Don´t talk about freedom of rights and better human beeings, when you can not even write a polite comment. It shows me that you are a narrow-minded person with an egoistic paradox, which have turned you to lose your memory. This is why people can finde contradictions in your cheap words! Go and talk to your teacher and learn more :-)
He is the king of music for you. This is just a matter of interest, desire and taste. Lots of that is connected to the culture and the person´s mother-language. If you go 500 km west, east, north or south you finde another king of music. Don´t talk like a child!
To all Iraninas.....Plz search for ( Tolo Promotion) in youtube.....This clip will correct misiformations you get through your history books inside Iran.
what´s Tolo promotion and which misinformation are you talking about?! By the way! History books are not written only in Iran. It shows me that you are a narrow-minded person before I know about your subject of discussion. I serached for this Tolo Pro, but I still don´t know what it is and what you mean.
As an Iranian I used to listen to Afghani music when I was growing up...all I know jAnam fadayeh opperesed Afghan va Afgahni people..that have fallen in hands of brutal and unjust political schemes by Western countries allied with Saudies, Qatars etc. and radicals that do not have any respect for humanity...I salute you Afgahnestan ( brothers and sisters) for enduring so much injustice and pain...every bone in my body feels your pain and I refuse and will not FALL in divisional tactics. PEACE
Kambizz jaan tashakur. Only if all other iranians and afghans were like you donya bayhisht mayshud! I really appreciate and thank you for your wonderful comments. BTW, i really like this song of Masoud. he has done such a great job! Keep up the good work Masoud jaan! :)
guys no fight here please actually tajik and irani r same ppls......and actually is persian part of afghanistan is real part of iran...fucking pashtoon took it from iran...its actually part of iran...tats wat history said...
yes i beleive you,pashton are pakistani kochi.i hate these ppl,because they are kon frosh and kos frosh.they are mordaar khor,they are watan forosh,they are the main probleem of afghans and afghanistan.
Hey hey be carefull of you're badly word and unhumanity woords.Next time if you came to youtube try to listen to concern what the music say.You know that yourself here is not the place of discussion about your ASS or HOLE .I am not saying you are not a bad person but put alittle bit respect .A question for you CAN YOU EXPLAIN ME HOW PASHTONS HAVE SAVED OUR ASS?do you think that Pashtons were the only nation who have saved all afghans nation from russian invasion?
please shut up and listen the song... its remind us our beloved Ahmad zahir, may Allah bless him.. and who cares that mansour copied.. everyone copy.. iranians from afghans and afghans from iranians.. don't give a shit about it.. really nice song mansour jan.. all the best
guys tajik of afghanistan and iran was same country bak then............we r same ppl same culture and same language.....we consider persian too.......
tajikistan afghanistan iran uzbekistan and turkministan was same country bak then CALLED SAR ZAMEEN E KHORASAN and the capital was HERAT so no fight irani wa afghani is same ppls
Khak be sare hamatun you guys are sitting in jaye garm tooye America who is afghan who is Iranian which one is better are you kidding me listen to the damn song and know both of our countries are in the hand of shit people with a shit idealogy find some damn common ground for a change believe my no American looks at one of you as any better than the other, no matter how much dahd bezani
hahahahaaaaaa....afaren! using words like "tooye" i can understand you are Irani I'm Afghan but I have Iranian friends and respect them for who they are....and your comment here.... man i just couldn't stop laughing. so true only if we can embrace each other and respect each other. I get very sad when i see us fight like this over nonesens.
This realy is an Ahmad zahir song, but he has changed it cleverly and sang a more modern version of it, he kind of made it his own hes good, He is Iranian so what, no ones is perfect. lol
Music has no boundaries and there is no such thing that Afghanistan was part of Iran.
And if it was, so was Iran part of Afghanistan if history was to be referred to. What matters is that we have more similarities than differences and we would like to strenghten that as two peaceful neighbours.
Yes there is such thing that it was part of Iran. All those bordering coutnires and more were part of our ancient empire, and actually, Afghanistan was one of the MAJOR parts of the land of Iranics, which is why u see much of our influence with language and culture still exists more than in other lands.
Well, with all due respect Iran, Afghanistan, and the neighbouring countries are very heterogeneous in terms of their ethnic composition because of their location as crossroads of different empires. As such Afghanistan cannot be part of Iran or vice versa as different empires rose and fell from the different corners of this area of land. I often times get this comment from my Iranian friends and each time we have a debate over this. I blame it on misinformation in circulation.
no, u obviously have misinformation. Ppl dont teach about Iran and our great history becuz of their bias and becuz of the fact that much of it was lost. Everything about Afghanistan started with iranicz, they were all iranic peoples. Go read some more. Afghanistan was a huge part of the irani history and was a major part of the Persian Empire.
I don't deny that the people of the area are similar people and that they share a lot in culture and customs. My problem is that Iranians claim that Afghanistan was part of Iran. If you are talking about Kings/rulers from the modern day Iran parts ruled Afghanistan, then kings/rulers from the modern day Afghanistan ruled Iran. It is a fact that goes both ways. Remeber that Iran and Afghanistan have been the Southward migration route for the Turkic people of central Asia. to be continued...
... as such the dominant rule of the people of Fars was eroded by the turkic people who were better fighters on their horses. Shah Ismail Safavid was the one who established firm control over modern day Iran and brought the Shiiate version of Isalm. Iran used to be a sunni dominated country, but was forced to either convert to shiite or flee eastward. As such Fars people (original inhibitants of Iran)were ruled by the turkic migrant people of Central Asia.
what does that prove? Nothing other than what i just said. All of the bordering coutnries and ESPECAILLY Afghanistan were major parts of the Iranic land. Afghans didn't rule us they had no power compared to us. We were all one and later divided and now there result is as seen, small powerless and uncivilized countried round about and arguin.
That lil Mr. Bukhari that u guys take so much pride in, he was technically born in modern day Afghanistan, but is considered to have been a Persian man. Why? Becuz all of those lands were part of and the same as Persian Empire and were infact major beds of the culture.
Interesting! I think your interpretation is based on what they teach in Iran. It is not unusual for countries to write their own history and lay claim on anything they can. A reading of history by objective and unbiased historians might be of help.
No actually, go ahead and ask a professor of history in a college in California and they'd say the same. If they don't its becuz they read the historical bias of the west, aquired from Greeks, who by the way, were rivals of the Persians.
I am begining to realise that we agree, but only to disagree. For your information, Dari is the old Persian and there was a time when the Samanids in modern day Afghanistan saved Iran from losing its Persian language. After all, modern day Afghanistan is the birth place of Maulana Jalal-u-din Mohammad Balkhi and many more Dari poets. Hope this helps and nice debating with you, even if it resulted in disagreeing with you.
u said there is no such thing that Afghanistan was part of Iran. Thats a huge lie. Modern day 'Afhganistan" was a MAJOR part of Iran Zamin and no one can deny that.
Afghanistan was part of Iran, so who cares who the singer is. If the singer was chinese or Indian well that worth paying attention that mansour has sang his song.
Why am I sure? For many reasons. One is that I am invited to that private party by my Iranian frineds and was told that hey, "Afghanet Miyayay, too baayad beyaayee" . The rest is up to you guys to accept it or not.
ahmad zahir and ustaad jalil zuland are history! Mansour is the present. Mansour has given a taste of the music listened nowadays. What the hell is up with this bullshit afg/persian delima- it's almost present in every god damn song in youtube!!
woah woah...you seriously need to prove your statement there, cuz at the moment acceptin that mansour is an afgan is somethin I serioulsy would have never even thought of.
It's beautiful. I was told that Mansour is actually Afghani but he was born and raised in Iran! When I went to his concert, I asked my friends who brought him over and they said, no. And then they told me he's Azari(Iranian Turkish)! Oh well, both Mansour and Ahmad Zahir are good.
this SUNNI or SHIA thing has been brought to our lives by some fucked up ARAB WAHABIS who are just like JEWS you fucking son of a bitch ask your mom she will tell you which one he is.
well i know he copied this song by our great afghani singer but he has a beautiful voice mansour and he is great singer this is important i think but anyway god bless ahmad zahir, mansour and all muslims
relax!Our singers sang this song 20 years ago in Afghanistan, composed by zulaand,but still its new and a modern song for u cheaters Tajiks & Iranians OK.
hahaha dats funny a tajik talks about music u lier f u could read u wouldnt say dat "its mansours song" u guyz lost ur literature,music even ur written litters, u r slaves of russian ppl,i've been in Tjk for many years they're celebrating birthaday of Ahmad Zahir our legend every single year,even they made his biography & de book of his songs lyrics's just a week ago i think problem is with u.go and learn literature of ur own tajik music & then talk about Ahmad zahir, and Mansour. da pashol.
hahaha dats funny a tajik talks about music u lier f u could read u wouldnt say dat "its mansours song" u guyz lost ur literature,music even ur written litters, u r slaves of russian ppl,i've been in Tjk for many years they're celebrating birthaday of Ahmad Zahir our legend every single year,even they made his biography & de book of his songs lyrics's just a week ago i think problem is with u.go and learn literature of ur own tajik music & then talk about Ahmad zahir, and Mansour. da pashol.
Hey i'm not arguing OK, unless i love Mansour more. Watch the clip carefully from the start, its written (AAHANGSARAA WA AAHANSAAZ USTAAD JALIL ZULAAND)or u cant read Persian or Dari either. & i'm not comparing mansourak to our legend AHMAD ZAHIR!
i dont think any of those 2 wrote or sang this song first it was all Ahmad Zahir but Mansoor does sing it better .... coming from an afghan who has actually heard Ahmad ZAhir sing it.. i luv ahmad zahir hes a beast composer
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
Some songs are classic..they never get old with time..and everytime u hear it..it makes sense in da the past/present and future..nyce song by Mansour..But the original is better
Mansour is not an Iranian he is from Afghanistan his family are living in Kabul. But he is singing in Iranian accent.
Bacterietheafghan 2 months ago
Come on guys we should be United Afghanistan,Iran,Tajikstan.
waleedwafaable 2 months ago
@afghanmsn dont lie, he was killed in a car accident, dont blame communists..they were the true patriots,kid!
kais01 8 months ago
@kais01 that's not true, everyone knows that, and his own bestfriend is a proof of that, don't know if anyone here has heard of it, it's an interview with his bestfriend who told everything abou Ahmad Zahir going to prison with him and another friend and about him being accused for the murder of a girl that he never killed and at the very end he was questioned about Ahmad Zahir's death. He said he never died in a car crash, infact he got out after the accident and asked if the people who were
Msmalo29 7 months ago
@kais0 with him were ok, then they were brought to hospital where they got to see Ahmad Zahir dead ody beingbrought, his bestfriend also told what happened, Ahmad Zahir was shot first in the head and then someone threw a big stone at him so that his eyes would pop out.....you can even search on google where th doctors who had examined his body confirmed that he infact was shot in the head. He was against communists you know....he was very politically invovlved so you can't say for sure.
Msmalo29 7 months ago
@kais01 Communists were enemies of Afghans. They martyred innocent Afghans and initiated the destruction of the whole system, they are responsible for murdering our pride "Ahmad Zahir", Watch Ahmad Zahir's sister saying that on youtube.
badmintonworldvideos 2 months ago
@badmintonworldvideos This all was propaganda taught by the West to destabilize the country and win the cold war, Just think and imagine why would a governement do that. Dont believe the rumours and the media, judge and think for yourself.
kais01 2 months ago
Ahmed zaher is the legend, but fucking kummonist killed him.. But good video
afghanmsn 9 months ago
love ahmad zaher jan
Ahmadshahbaba1 11 months ago
Ahmad Zahir was not only a legend, but he was a good moslim. He helped always poor people. he was 32 old years when he is deed...... But ,... about this ... Mansour,
.. How old is he.... ? and ,, what deed he for the poor people?
gholamnabi 1 year ago
Ahmad zahir was good singer in Afghanistan mansour best singer in iran
ahdshoaib 1 year ago
chame siya dari ghorbanat shawam man khana koja dari mehmanet shawam man. aslesh ein ast
davidnemat 1 year ago
@davidnemat yeah thats right... this one is nice too..
twinklesoraya 1 year ago
migam khodayish in dokhtare kojash cheshman siahe? :D
ybyjasmine 1 year ago
Ahmad Zahir is the kinng off all persians singer. Good voice
isaq99 1 year ago
Ahmad zahir is the king of persian music(afghanistan and iran) so what if mansour jan copys him after we r brothers with the same history zinda bad persia
afgcheckpoint 1 year ago
Sorry to burst everyone's bubble but Ahmad Zahir NEVER sang this song
This song was produced by Ustad Zaland(RIP) if you see the credits to the song it shows his name, not AZ's(RIP)
Kaihaan7, please do your research before posting inaccurate info.
Aliz1113 1 year ago
@Aliz1113 ahmad zahir sang this song... chashme sia dari, qurbanet shawom man, khana kuja dari mehmanet shawom maa;)
KingEhsanjan 1 year ago
i loveeee Mansour!!! and i really liked it that he sang this song of A.Z <3
MaryamMiss 1 year ago
Tajik bad nako ahmaaq. you compare this shit with a legend? then iranis say they don't know afghan songs.... pand begeren iranis
tkdleeds 2 years ago
Ahmad Zahir King of Afghan Music
afghan4mylife 2 years ago 2
He sings it way better than ahmad zahir!!!!
TajikMacho 2 years ago
great song,
roshanaye 2 years ago
afterall its an afghan song <3
fatimahkhanom07 2 years ago
omg i love him, i love him, i love him lollz he seems so romantic, and i love his voice :)
fivesher 2 years ago
Beautiful !!
Mansour joon cheghat en ahnag rah ba halei khonden.. LOVE IT
dukhtareafghani 2 years ago
ahmad zahir will put him on show anyday
khisraw420 2 years ago
with all respect zahir jaan was much better...
khatiegak 2 years ago
Ahmad Zahir still sings it much better
afgangel05 2 years ago 2
ahmad zahir owned him
MichaeljacksonAFG 2 years ago
yes mansoor is a good persian singer
qari0aryana 2 years ago
wow how nice he done ahmad zahir jan afghani song
TheFivelion 2 years ago 3
salam.
its probably one of his uncompleted songs..
otherwise try to search the web also.. maybe you will find somethin inshallah.
afqhanii 2 years ago
veryyyyyy niceeee
afghanjan 2 years ago
I love Ahmad Zahir, but i love all farsi speakers:)
MrQalandariii 2 years ago 2
youtube: "Ahmad Zahir The Legend chashme sia dary"
rayj778 2 years ago
its called chashme sia dary
wahidjon 2 years ago
iam not big fan from ahmed zahir but the way mosoud sang it drives me crazy . i love it
afghandream100 2 years ago
Simply wonderful music
vafkamat 2 years ago
chashman siah
sinafgun 2 years ago
omg AHMAD JAN ZAHIR SONGG O LOVE THIS SONGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!! it ok caz everyone noes it afg songs not iranian... lool... nice song love it lotsssssssssssssssss
XoAsma4Xo 2 years ago
I understand most things he is saying but I understand everything Ahmad Zahir sings in this song. I am from Tajikistan.
TheTrippleEight 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mansoor's version is better thn ahmad zahir
its his accent if he sings in his own language no matter
afta all ahmad zahir copied elvis presley style n songs n muhammad rafi's songs
samarbostani 2 years ago
I never agree what you say.Because Ahmad Zahir is a suprbe singer and a great musician forever.His musics famous and has worht for 30milion ppl only in Afghanistan.If you think Mansor is better so why he desire to copy his music?
dosteddaram 2 years ago 4
yeah tastes are diffrent ~!!~
i love ahmad zahir but this song i love mansoor`s version as we know ahmad zahir is the best !!!!!!!!
samarbostani 2 years ago 2
that is up to you.but i give ahmadzhair 10/10
dosteddaram 2 years ago 2
dude learn DARI befor sing a afghan song. and try to use a better music cus this just sucks
FardinRosa 2 years ago
copy of afghan singer looooooool
but it is okay
not bad ,
afgstylz 2 years ago
Don´t talk about freedom of rights and better human beeings, when you can not even write a polite comment. It shows me that you are a narrow-minded person with an egoistic paradox, which have turned you to lose your memory. This is why people can finde contradictions in your cheap words! Go and talk to your teacher and learn more :-)
tamad12 2 years ago
i think zahirs version is better but thats ok too
dukhtareafg1 2 years ago 3
i know that was a mistake bukhara and samarqand belonk to uzbekistan but i meant that shiraz is a part of iran i´m sure !!
AFGpersiangirl 2 years ago
what2search
shiraz is a part of iran but herat, balkh, bukhara, samarqand belonged to afghanistan i know !!!
AFGpersiangirl 2 years ago 2
wow great song !!!
AFGpersiangirl 2 years ago
Wow I love Mansour! Great rendition of the original by Ahmad Zahir!
Love it!!!!!!
rodream20 2 years ago
Ahmad Zahir is King of music.
This gonna stay like that for at least 1000 years.
U can not compare his golden voice to any singer in the world.
No one can sing a song like him, no one.
afghan4mylife 2 years ago
He is the king of music for you. This is just a matter of interest, desire and taste. Lots of that is connected to the culture and the person´s mother-language. If you go 500 km west, east, north or south you finde another king of music. Don´t talk like a child!
tamad12 2 years ago
no u wont find another king lyke Ahmad Zahir... it dozent matter, even if u go to the other side of the world,styll the same
WaleedAFGnAqsaPK 2 years ago
To all Iraninas.....Plz search for ( Tolo Promotion) in youtube.....This clip will correct misiformations you get through your history books inside Iran.
sekandary22 3 years ago
what´s Tolo promotion and which misinformation are you talking about?! By the way! History books are not written only in Iran. It shows me that you are a narrow-minded person before I know about your subject of discussion. I serached for this Tolo Pro, but I still don´t know what it is and what you mean.
tamad12 2 years ago
pple don't compare junkies with our legen (Ahmad Zahir) no one did and will take his place in the world.
Fowad861 3 years ago
Nice try. Mansour is good singer and has better songs.
The original is nicer (Ahmad Zahir)
Islamrules4ever 3 years ago 3
Mansoor is a child for Ahmad Zahir
gholamnabi 3 years ago
ahahahah Mansoor??? is he better than Ahmad Zahir??? hahahaha
gholamnabi 3 years ago
we love iranian brothers and sisters...
they are our really brother...same relgion...same lunguage...same culture...
so why we must fight and abuse each other??
let,s live peacefull...and be friends with each other...
longikongi 3 years ago 4
I have to admit that Mansour sings this songs better than Zahir.
Me00721 3 years ago
hahah.....u r funny...
nice joke...
longikongi 3 years ago
No, brother. I´m serious.
Me00721 3 years ago
u think this singer sings better then ahmad zahir?
yeha?
haha
if u r sierously...i will still lough at u :)
cuz nobdy can sing better then AHMAD ZAHIR,S SONGS ....
ESPECIALLY HIS SONGS
longikongi 3 years ago
Your comment proves that you dont know much music . haha
CHAPANDAZ714 3 years ago
Hey, you are really right. I don´t know much about the technique of singing but in my ears this version sounds better than Zahirs version.
Me00721 3 years ago
very nice song... love it
bumsduer 3 years ago
see my "vids" online now before youtube takes them off again
uMmMmMmMmm hai 2 u. bored? lets chat! im naked! =) maybe ff
aeruflu 3 years ago
I'm not and Iranian nor I'm a an Afghan but I wanna say that Mansour's verison is much better and his voice is awsome!!
TajikMacho 3 years ago 2
oOw Luv thi3 3ong
luv66lo0s 3 years ago
woow you have too much information,impressive dawg!.
four40volts 3 years ago
She is the sexiest thing on earth !
XermikK 3 years ago
Mansour is an Irani Hazara both from mom and dad's side!
TurkmaniStyle 3 years ago
good job ,peace
1963ki 3 years ago
good job
1963ki 3 years ago
naqab2008, thanks you for kind comment here. I apologize for misbehavior of this stupid guy. we are all one nation.
afghanboy232 3 years ago 10
fuck off with ur stupid comment. if u r really 1 afghan.
sardarkabuli 3 years ago
yes this is ahmed zaher song
nargesllllllllllllll 3 years ago
As an Iranian I used to listen to Afghani music when I was growing up...all I know jAnam fadayeh opperesed Afghan va Afgahni people..that have fallen in hands of brutal and unjust political schemes by Western countries allied with Saudies, Qatars etc. and radicals that do not have any respect for humanity...I salute you Afgahnestan ( brothers and sisters) for enduring so much injustice and pain...every bone in my body feels your pain and I refuse and will not FALL in divisional tactics. PEACE
kambizz1 3 years ago 30
Kambizz jaan tashakur. Only if all other iranians and afghans were like you donya bayhisht mayshud! I really appreciate and thank you for your wonderful comments. BTW, i really like this song of Masoud. he has done such a great job! Keep up the good work Masoud jaan! :)
Pakawra 3 years ago 3
@kambizz1 God Bless you
Nazaneen1000 11 months ago
Comment removed
Nazaneen1000 11 months ago
guys no fight here please actually tajik and irani r same ppls......and actually is persian part of afghanistan is real part of iran...fucking pashtoon took it from iran...its actually part of iran...tats wat history said...
samzafg 4 years ago
yes i beleive you,pashton are pakistani kochi.i hate these ppl,because they are kon frosh and kos frosh.they are mordaar khor,they are watan forosh,they are the main probleem of afghans and afghanistan.
Qurban89 4 years ago
fuck off asswhole.. i am both so dont be talking shit..
why you hating on the pashtuns. because we saved your ass from russia?
GunnersOwnAll 3 years ago
Hey hey be carefull of you're badly word and unhumanity woords.Next time if you came to youtube try to listen to concern what the music say.You know that yourself here is not the place of discussion about your ASS or HOLE .I am not saying you are not a bad person but put alittle bit respect .A question for you CAN YOU EXPLAIN ME HOW PASHTONS HAVE SAVED OUR ASS?do you think that Pashtons were the only nation who have saved all afghans nation from russian invasion?
dosteddaram 3 years ago
dw.. that was in response to some idiot a while ago.... that ass was the one who started it..
You are right.. we all saved our nation from the soviet invasion.. idiots like him think its funny to bring disunity..
GunnersOwnAll 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kos nago baba ... kiram to khodeto afghanestaneto ahmad zahiret hahah..
aalireza20 4 years ago
Wow how a beautiful song <33
and nice voice
keep it going
MalalaiAFG 4 years ago
please shut up and listen the song... its remind us our beloved Ahmad zahir, may Allah bless him.. and who cares that mansour copied.. everyone copy.. iranians from afghans and afghans from iranians.. don't give a shit about it.. really nice song mansour jan.. all the best
sotahra 4 years ago 5
guys tajik of afghanistan and iran was same country bak then............we r same ppl same culture and same language.....we consider persian too.......
tajikistan afghanistan iran uzbekistan and turkministan was same country bak then CALLED SAR ZAMEEN E KHORASAN and the capital was HERAT so no fight irani wa afghani is same ppls
samzafg 4 years ago 10
thank u aziz. now go teach ur ppl that too coz they just deny it all the time.
Khoda hefzetun kone! :)
gypsy5724 4 years ago
Khak be sare hamatun you guys are sitting in jaye garm tooye America who is afghan who is Iranian which one is better are you kidding me listen to the damn song and know both of our countries are in the hand of shit people with a shit idealogy find some damn common ground for a change believe my no American looks at one of you as any better than the other, no matter how much dahd bezani
GoliTiffen2b 4 years ago 3
hahahahaaaaaa....afaren! using words like "tooye" i can understand you are Irani I'm Afghan but I have Iranian friends and respect them for who they are....and your comment here.... man i just couldn't stop laughing. so true only if we can embrace each other and respect each other. I get very sad when i see us fight like this over nonesens.
Pakawra 4 years ago 2
This realy is an Ahmad zahir song, but he has changed it cleverly and sang a more modern version of it, he kind of made it his own hes good, He is Iranian so what, no ones is perfect. lol
ZIVONZivon 4 years ago
Music has no boundaries and there is no such thing that Afghanistan was part of Iran.
And if it was, so was Iran part of Afghanistan if history was to be referred to. What matters is that we have more similarities than differences and we would like to strenghten that as two peaceful neighbours.
Afg4lion 4 years ago
Yes there is such thing that it was part of Iran. All those bordering coutnires and more were part of our ancient empire, and actually, Afghanistan was one of the MAJOR parts of the land of Iranics, which is why u see much of our influence with language and culture still exists more than in other lands.
gypsy5724 4 years ago 2
Well, with all due respect Iran, Afghanistan, and the neighbouring countries are very heterogeneous in terms of their ethnic composition because of their location as crossroads of different empires. As such Afghanistan cannot be part of Iran or vice versa as different empires rose and fell from the different corners of this area of land. I often times get this comment from my Iranian friends and each time we have a debate over this. I blame it on misinformation in circulation.
Afg4lion 4 years ago
no, u obviously have misinformation. Ppl dont teach about Iran and our great history becuz of their bias and becuz of the fact that much of it was lost. Everything about Afghanistan started with iranicz, they were all iranic peoples. Go read some more. Afghanistan was a huge part of the irani history and was a major part of the Persian Empire.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
I don't deny that the people of the area are similar people and that they share a lot in culture and customs. My problem is that Iranians claim that Afghanistan was part of Iran. If you are talking about Kings/rulers from the modern day Iran parts ruled Afghanistan, then kings/rulers from the modern day Afghanistan ruled Iran. It is a fact that goes both ways. Remeber that Iran and Afghanistan have been the Southward migration route for the Turkic people of central Asia. to be continued...
Afg4lion 4 years ago
... as such the dominant rule of the people of Fars was eroded by the turkic people who were better fighters on their horses. Shah Ismail Safavid was the one who established firm control over modern day Iran and brought the Shiiate version of Isalm. Iran used to be a sunni dominated country, but was forced to either convert to shiite or flee eastward. As such Fars people (original inhibitants of Iran)were ruled by the turkic migrant people of Central Asia.
Afg4lion 4 years ago
what does that prove? Nothing other than what i just said. All of the bordering coutnries and ESPECAILLY Afghanistan were major parts of the Iranic land. Afghans didn't rule us they had no power compared to us. We were all one and later divided and now there result is as seen, small powerless and uncivilized countried round about and arguin.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
That lil Mr. Bukhari that u guys take so much pride in, he was technically born in modern day Afghanistan, but is considered to have been a Persian man. Why? Becuz all of those lands were part of and the same as Persian Empire and were infact major beds of the culture.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
Why do u think ppl in Afg still speak Dari? They are slowly ruining that side of themselves, but they are decendants of the ppl of Iran Zamin.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
Interesting! I think your interpretation is based on what they teach in Iran. It is not unusual for countries to write their own history and lay claim on anything they can. A reading of history by objective and unbiased historians might be of help.
Afg4lion 4 years ago
No actually, go ahead and ask a professor of history in a college in California and they'd say the same. If they don't its becuz they read the historical bias of the west, aquired from Greeks, who by the way, were rivals of the Persians.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
I am begining to realise that we agree, but only to disagree. For your information, Dari is the old Persian and there was a time when the Samanids in modern day Afghanistan saved Iran from losing its Persian language. After all, modern day Afghanistan is the birth place of Maulana Jalal-u-din Mohammad Balkhi and many more Dari poets. Hope this helps and nice debating with you, even if it resulted in disagreeing with you.
Afg4lion 4 years ago
u said there is no such thing that Afghanistan was part of Iran. Thats a huge lie. Modern day 'Afhganistan" was a MAJOR part of Iran Zamin and no one can deny that.
gypsy5724 4 years ago
there was not such things ever.
i think you were a baby ,you have
seen such dream there on you'r bed.
follow you'r dream.hey man afghanistan
is an independent land and live for afghans.
hope you ever not find ,,,so wake up.
afghan boy ,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Qurban89 4 years ago
wake up? how about pick up a history book and read about the origin of the Afghan peoples. lol.
gypsy5724 4 years ago 2
same goes for Turkey
Shiften2000 4 years ago
Afghanistan was part of Iran, so who cares who the singer is. If the singer was chinese or Indian well that worth paying attention that mansour has sang his song.
Shiften2000 4 years ago
I wish there we more people that would think like you. I 100% agree that nationalism is the stupidest thing ever!
Naztrovje 4 years ago
its a gud song
tats all tat matters reali
no need to fus about whos wat
its just a song just lisnten n injoy it
afgchic 4 years ago
Farshad1975, you're so funny. I had a good laugh reading your comment. Thanks for the humor!
fa7rah 4 years ago
Who cares whether its zahirbabas song or abdollahs? Its not exactly "bethowens fifth".
Farshad1975 4 years ago
Why am I sure? For many reasons. One is that I am invited to that private party by my Iranian frineds and was told that hey, "Afghanet Miyayay, too baayad beyaayee" . The rest is up to you guys to accept it or not.
whoozyourdaddy 4 years ago
Mansour is not Iranian. He is an Iran based Afghan. He is coming to NYC this weekend. :)
whoozyourdaddy 4 years ago
ahmad zahir and ustaad jalil zuland are history! Mansour is the present. Mansour has given a taste of the music listened nowadays. What the hell is up with this bullshit afg/persian delima- it's almost present in every god damn song in youtube!!
hijran05 4 years ago
he is afghan but he is born in iran and he say he is irani.
afgehsanjanegol 4 years ago
woah woah...you seriously need to prove your statement there, cuz at the moment acceptin that mansour is an afgan is somethin I serioulsy would have never even thought of.
hijran05 4 years ago
It's beautiful. I was told that Mansour is actually Afghani but he was born and raised in Iran! When I went to his concert, I asked my friends who brought him over and they said, no. And then they told me he's Azari(Iranian Turkish)! Oh well, both Mansour and Ahmad Zahir are good.
fa7rah 4 years ago
hey guyz who cares just lestin the song who cares
both are the best
every singer has their different style
don't fucking argue
schooles 4 years ago
not just the song that he is singing is Ahmad Zahir's he also look and copy wearing things like MAKHMAD ZAHIR JAN bache khala.
paryan7 4 years ago
Son of the bitch
TajikMacho 4 years ago
no way MANSOUR is much better!!!
TajikMacho 4 years ago
Janem go ask Mansour himself if he is better than Ahmad Zahir lol
afgun4life 4 years ago
Don't see anything of Ahmad Zahir but the lyrics, copletely different song. But very nice in its own way. thanks for posting
mujibjenah 4 years ago
I like Mansour's Music. But honestly Ahmad Zahir sings this A LOT Better. By Far.
cableconnection6 4 years ago
Mansour singe this song better than ahmad zair so please don't argue. He has the best voice!!!!
ZENDE BOD MANSOUR!!!!!!
TajikMacho 4 years ago
Hey guys, is he a Suni or Shia???????
TajikMacho 4 years ago
this SUNNI or SHIA thing has been brought to our lives by some fucked up ARAB WAHABIS who are just like JEWS you fucking son of a bitch ask your mom she will tell you which one he is.
paryan7 4 years ago
Hey mother fucker I'm gonna fuck your whore mother all righ bith? i just asked a question son of the bith.
TajikMacho 4 years ago
he is not half persian..he is 100% AFGHAN (hazara) he was just raised in iran
feresh82 4 years ago
how come he is half persian and half afghan? just wondering.
ishaiscool 4 years ago
my asss, just shut up this is an afghan song all the way.
Aminkhan786 4 years ago
well i know he copied this song by our great afghani singer but he has a beautiful voice mansour and he is great singer this is important i think but anyway god bless ahmad zahir, mansour and all muslims
sotahra 4 years ago
we all need to shut up and respect both ahmad zahir and mansour cuz they both are great singers! IRAN WAS APART OF US ONCE SO RESPECT THAT
bonethugz320 5 years ago
yup
TajikMacho 5 years ago
love this song...tanx for uploading it..
kais01 5 years ago
Our legend fucked ur whole family hahaha u damn motha fucka thats y u r copying him. Go fuck ur mother don't talk about our legend assholes
Fowad861 5 years ago
fuck of he is a great singer... i don't care if copied Ahmad jan e zahir at least his has a great voice...
sotahra 4 years ago
this is what ur fathers did with ur sisters, because ur mothers were bitches & u r son of a bitch tajik.u shutttt up.
setara 5 years ago
relax!Our singers sang this song 20 years ago in Afghanistan, composed by zulaand,but still its new and a modern song for u cheaters Tajiks & Iranians OK.
setara 5 years ago
Hahaha look! people of the world! this is a Tajiki's generation attitude. talks about music hahahaha
setara 5 years ago
hahaha dats funny a tajik talks about music u lier f u could read u wouldnt say dat "its mansours song" u guyz lost ur literature,music even ur written litters, u r slaves of russian ppl,i've been in Tjk for many years they're celebrating birthaday of Ahmad Zahir our legend every single year,even they made his biography & de book of his songs lyrics's just a week ago i think problem is with u.go and learn literature of ur own tajik music & then talk about Ahmad zahir, and Mansour. da pashol.
setara 5 years ago
hahaha dats funny a tajik talks about music u lier f u could read u wouldnt say dat "its mansours song" u guyz lost ur literature,music even ur written litters, u r slaves of russian ppl,i've been in Tjk for many years they're celebrating birthaday of Ahmad Zahir our legend every single year,even they made his biography & de book of his songs lyrics's just a week ago i think problem is with u.go and learn literature of ur own tajik music & then talk about Ahmad zahir, and Mansour. da pashol.
setara 5 years ago
Hey i'm not arguing OK, unless i love Mansour more. Watch the clip carefully from the start, its written (AAHANGSARAA WA AAHANSAAZ USTAAD JALIL ZULAAND)or u cant read Persian or Dari either. & i'm not comparing mansourak to our legend AHMAD ZAHIR!
setara 5 years ago
i dont think any of those 2 wrote or sang this song first it was all Ahmad Zahir but Mansoor does sing it better .... coming from an afghan who has actually heard Ahmad ZAhir sing it.. i luv ahmad zahir hes a beast composer
bonethugz320 5 years ago
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
setara 5 years ago
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
setara 5 years ago
haha NO this song is USTAAD JALIL ZULANDS compose, read it its in the song. Zuland is the best Afghan composer, mansour requested him to give him the premision 4 singing this song, AHMAD ZAHIR sang it better, but mansour is cute irani singer too:D
setara 5 years ago
AHMAD ZAHIR ZINDABAD!!!! man w/e this was orignali ahmad zahir i know that and everyone else does to stop hating!
bonethugz320 5 years ago
Some songs are classic..they never get old with time..and everytime u hear it..it makes sense in da the past/present and future..nyce song by Mansour..But the original is better
kabulzFynest 5 years ago
nice song
masood2007 5 years ago
hes sooo cuteee....
finestShorty 5 years ago
iran has copied frm afghanistan lol
patan101 5 years ago
omg i lovee dis song i love da way ahmad zahir sings dis bt hes good too & da music is jst off da hook..
finestShorty 5 years ago
I Know Ahmad Zahir is THE BEST !!!
kaihaan7 5 years ago
not good. zahir is the best
rheinerft 5 years ago