@grandweasel Sorry for answering this after 2 years; read it in the video comments. Kolinar is Atreides in the end. He is a mentat, true, a master of assassins, but it must be worried about what is good and what is not. Desperated, he has forgot the debt from the Smugglers, maybe the recovery of the flight 23 advanced carryalls. They can't ever be trusted. Achillus got to autorize this action.
@grandweasel Atreides Mentats are incredibly faithful and fanatical, but also given a degree of humanity lacking in their counterparts. Also, Leto I decided to let smuggling go on when he was Duke ,in exchange for a cut of the action- hence Atreides has links with the smugglers Ordos and Harkonnen do not.
hmm but the harkonnens also got kickback from the smugglers. Letos plan was simply to replace the harkonnens smugglers with his own. Also he wanted to run down the harkonnens to the emperor for their corruption
@SirPepe666 Leto made enduring friendships and business contacts with the Arakeen Smugglers while the Baron used them as mere tools in their spice corruption. The Atreides make friends with people, the Harkonnen generally force people to help them (and the Ordos of course swindle them). In the books at least a noble Harkonnen marries an Atreides later on, eliminating the stigma Harkonnen have.
true. but this wasnt what i meant. What I wanted to say is that not only the Duke worked with the smugglers. of course the practices of this "teamwork" where completly diffrent to each other. and the duke not only wanted to make friends with the smugglers also to run down the harkonnens. Its long time ago i read the novels but i think I will read em again. Would be cool to have someone to talk about dune - if you ask me you can interpret the wohle dune universe totally difrent
@SirPepe666 of course every House has relations with the smugglers- no one likes the Spacing Guild at all and sending tithes to the Emperor is usually done reluctantly. The noble Atriedes however treat them like business partners, while the Harkonnen only use them to get what they themselves can't steal or buy, then probably eliminate them to keep it quiet.
I've been reading the first book recently and the part which goes "My lord, I have failed you, I will of course tend to my resigna-" "Do not play the fool!"
was taken almost word for word when the Duke is talking to Hawat after the failed assassination of Paul
I don't like to attack the Harkonnen with the Atreides, with an Ordos's debt. They have tried to kill the Duke. Somebody tell me wath think about this.
You know the duke unlike the other factions has a brain of his own. The baron has the mentat to do the thinking for him. While the executrix having four minds couldn't think of an idea on getting themselves of the planet.
seems like that to me too. So they made atreides mentat a narcoman? Hell they're screwing their noble reputation here in emperor well:-) That is why i like Dune 2000 for storyline more. Altough it's much less of actual story, it definitely featured much better actors. John Rhys-Davies as mentat Norree Moneo is excellent and so is the Ordos mentat Edric O much better than Roma Atani. And Mentat hayt is even more scary than the original Piter - brad dourif
worf is serious!
acandterra 5 months ago
I never dared to attack Geidi Prime as Atreides or Ordos.
Orcraider94 6 months ago
@Orcraider94 I always attacked Geidi Prime with this too factions. For me, it is really easier to defeat Harkonnen with Atreides than Ordos.
TimurKOI 4 days ago
Do you know why I like the Ordos. Cos they won't ignore me in cutscenes.
DarthRushy 6 months ago
At 0:23, you can see the white collar of the Mentat from behind, completely reflecting green. And the Ordos Mentat also reflects it.
DarthRushy 7 months ago
omg that is Worf from star trek and that Romanof from RA2
SupremeLordReptyle 1 year ago
@SupremeLordReptyle= Funny, considering Patrick Stewart was in the theatrical release back in 1984.
vigo894 8 months ago
@grandweasel Sorry for answering this after 2 years; read it in the video comments. Kolinar is Atreides in the end. He is a mentat, true, a master of assassins, but it must be worried about what is good and what is not. Desperated, he has forgot the debt from the Smugglers, maybe the recovery of the flight 23 advanced carryalls. They can't ever be trusted. Achillus got to autorize this action.
1992OS 1 year ago
Holy shit, it's Worf! And he's competent!
phocjame 1 year ago
"How could you have foreseen this?" "Uhh, sir - it's kind of my job to try and figure out these kinds of plots before they unfold." "Oh."
ODMSys 1 year ago 2
Notice that those infantrymen are evidently reflecting green light off those brown uniforms? =D
G0ldbl4e 1 year ago
@grandweasel Atreides Mentats are incredibly faithful and fanatical, but also given a degree of humanity lacking in their counterparts. Also, Leto I decided to let smuggling go on when he was Duke ,in exchange for a cut of the action- hence Atreides has links with the smugglers Ordos and Harkonnen do not.
SantomPh 1 year ago
@SantomPh
hmm but the harkonnens also got kickback from the smugglers. Letos plan was simply to replace the harkonnens smugglers with his own. Also he wanted to run down the harkonnens to the emperor for their corruption
SirPepe666 1 year ago
@SirPepe666 Leto made enduring friendships and business contacts with the Arakeen Smugglers while the Baron used them as mere tools in their spice corruption. The Atreides make friends with people, the Harkonnen generally force people to help them (and the Ordos of course swindle them). In the books at least a noble Harkonnen marries an Atreides later on, eliminating the stigma Harkonnen have.
SantomPh 1 year ago
@SantomPh
true. but this wasnt what i meant. What I wanted to say is that not only the Duke worked with the smugglers. of course the practices of this "teamwork" where completly diffrent to each other. and the duke not only wanted to make friends with the smugglers also to run down the harkonnens. Its long time ago i read the novels but i think I will read em again. Would be cool to have someone to talk about dune - if you ask me you can interpret the wohle dune universe totally difrent
SirPepe666 1 year ago
@SirPepe666 of course every House has relations with the smugglers- no one likes the Spacing Guild at all and sending tithes to the Emperor is usually done reluctantly. The noble Atriedes however treat them like business partners, while the Harkonnen only use them to get what they themselves can't steal or buy, then probably eliminate them to keep it quiet.
SantomPh 1 year ago
@SantomPh
without beeing wrong from someone eles interpretaion ^^
SirPepe666 1 year ago
He might be playing the Duke too.
macman1138 1 year ago
Someone must have uploaded Windows into that Mentat's mind when he wasn't looking.
Elyseon 1 year ago
@grandweasel behold the flaw in mentats some reach the answer faster then others.
horusrage 1 year ago
It seems the Arakeen Smuggler's Guild owes everybody favours
dragondisaster 2 years ago
I've been reading the first book recently and the part which goes "My lord, I have failed you, I will of course tend to my resigna-" "Do not play the fool!"
was taken almost word for word when the Duke is talking to Hawat after the failed assassination of Paul
SolidSnakeXL 2 years ago
i pitty da fool :3
ishallkillall 2 years ago
yeah, i like those little references to the book
legendarycupcake 2 years ago
he´s voice reminds me of the game oblivion :P
teamvikingdk 2 years ago 2
I don't like to attack the Harkonnen with the Atreides, with an Ordos's debt. They have tried to kill the Duke. Somebody tell me wath think about this.
1992OS 2 years ago
You know the duke unlike the other factions has a brain of his own. The baron has the mentat to do the thinking for him. While the executrix having four minds couldn't think of an idea on getting themselves of the planet.
payot 3 years ago
Agreed... one of them a few seconds before he was strangled by his new Baron.
Cindywong2000 3 years ago
It's to show how wonderful the Duke is, basically. And it means that the Duke has an excuse to show forgiveness. Character enhancement, and all that.
harlequin2262 3 years ago 12
Harkonnen mentat also got some help
dragoon003 3 years ago
yeah a bit of morale boost eh?
Arrinao 2 years ago
yeah u right grandweasel. Only the mentat of atreides cannot help his commander in that situation.
gigazelle 3 years ago 2
You know, I've watched these videos hundreds of times and I never noticed that before. You're right!
smithdanger 4 years ago
@smithdanger at least the Atreides Mentat gets to resign! If this was Harkonnen his head would be rolling down a hill...
SantomPh 1 year ago
its Worf and Premier Romanov! i think the redness around the mouth is from drinking spice tea..... or its SPACE HERPES.
gigafart3 4 years ago 4
lol
ianforbes 4 years ago
"I have falied you-"
"What? I wasn't listening. Your herpes is distracting me."
Xbogey 4 years ago 5
does he have sapho stained lips?
inhuman216 5 years ago
Either that or cold-sores...MOUTH HERPES!
smithdanger 5 years ago
seems like that to me too. So they made atreides mentat a narcoman? Hell they're screwing their noble reputation here in emperor well:-) That is why i like Dune 2000 for storyline more. Altough it's much less of actual story, it definitely featured much better actors. John Rhys-Davies as mentat Norree Moneo is excellent and so is the Ordos mentat Edric O much better than Roma Atani. And Mentat hayt is even more scary than the original Piter - brad dourif
Shartallon 4 years ago 3
I totally agree.
smithdanger 4 years ago
couldn't agree more
zhshsG7 3 years ago
@Shartallon Dude the Atreides mentat is Romanov from Red alert 2!
TheRealRealFlippy 9 months ago