@melkicia studio version? this is the only version that exists. i saw it too in new haven last week. i had tickets to the same show on sat but got snowed in :/
Was fortunate to be in the audience when he performed this at the Loews in Jersey City... must admit I had never heard this particular song before but wow it just absolutely floored me. You could have heard a pin drop in the audience while he played it, everyone was mesmerized. Amazing.
Until last night, he said THIS was the ONLY time he performed this song in public... I got to see it the second time, and it was great. I'm so glad Jeff decided to play it. I know it was tough for him to revisit that place, but he did and it was beautiful. Thanks so much, Jeff. You gave me one hell -- or should I say heavenly -- of an experience.
Art. at its peak. Jeff takes simple chords..lands heavy lyrics and fictional melodies and creates songs that even my hairs understand and decide to stand up for in respect.
when i was young, this song haunted me. it still does. but seeing jeff seeing it makes me unsure of what i feel. it could be more matter-of-fact, less haunting. i will never be the same girl as i was before i heard this version.
@danny3flip what he's doing is the same thing he did on oh comely, he is playing half the chord than the other half, so strings 6-4, then 3-1. at least im pretty sure...could be wrong
@lloplop yeah i know it sounds good but, it just sounds like he has a cold dosen't he? and he was sick often during this time or somthing similar unless its just the microphone capturing the reverb of the room or somthing.
@jaybyrd570 You can go to zamzar. com go to the "download files" tab and put in this link and your email address and you can convert this into Mp3, mp4, or whatever you want. its such a useful site
saw this on saturday in brooklyn - the studio version was similar to the live version
melkicia 1 month ago 2
@melkicia studio version? this is the only version that exists. i saw it too in new haven last week. i had tickets to the same show on sat but got snowed in :/
lloplop 1 month ago
@lloplop look up little birds studio - he also put it, with this version, on a record in the nmh box set.
melkicia 1 month ago
@melkicia oh shit. I had no idea that happened! I stand corrected. Thanks!
lloplop 1 month ago
where is this place?
shipoffoolsful 3 months ago
@shipoffoolsful It was at a private party for his friend Chris Bilheimer. I think he was a graphic artist that designed the cover for ITAOTS.
lloplop 1 month ago
Was fortunate to be in the audience when he performed this at the Loews in Jersey City... must admit I had never heard this particular song before but wow it just absolutely floored me. You could have heard a pin drop in the audience while he played it, everyone was mesmerized. Amazing.
stover33 3 months ago
I heard this Saturday night at the loews theater and I'm still touched by it
freshandlegal 3 months ago
One of my favorite songs of all time! I never get sick of it.
ShuuussshKabobs 4 months ago
Until last night, he said THIS was the ONLY time he performed this song in public... I got to see it the second time, and it was great. I'm so glad Jeff decided to play it. I know it was tough for him to revisit that place, but he did and it was beautiful. Thanks so much, Jeff. You gave me one hell -- or should I say heavenly -- of an experience.
mussman717word 4 months ago
@mussman717word I really hope someone got it on video.
lloplop 4 months ago
@lloplop
I know, me too. They didn't allow any cameras, but who knows if someone discretely brought one or not?
mussman717word 4 months ago
@mussman717word there is a video check my favs its a few videos down
lloplop 4 months ago
@lloplop
Man, I can't believe it. That's excellent.
mussman717word 4 months ago
@mussman717word i saw the third time he played it, last night in New Jersey, most beautiful thing ever
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago 3
Best. Birthday Party. Ever.
AnotherFoxglove 5 months ago 2
Jeff Mangum composes the most perfect melodies to epitomize every feeling of the human condition. A little gay, but for me, it's true.
BlackKnightDipper 6 months ago
yoooooooooooooooo
cky12qxz 6 months ago
Art. at its peak. Jeff takes simple chords..lands heavy lyrics and fictional melodies and creates songs that even my hairs understand and decide to stand up for in respect.
iMachboos 8 months ago 7
when i was young, this song haunted me. it still does. but seeing jeff seeing it makes me unsure of what i feel. it could be more matter-of-fact, less haunting. i will never be the same girl as i was before i heard this version.
apple0zebra 8 months ago 2
this song is on the accordion peas bootleg. google it as hard as you can
iamabomination2 10 months ago
@iamabomination2 or this version on the Chris Bilheimer's Birthday Party 5/12/98 recording
lloplop 10 months ago
how does he pick the strings?
danny3flip 1 year ago
@danny3flip
as in strum pattern.
danny3flip 1 year ago
@danny3flip what he's doing is the same thing he did on oh comely, he is playing half the chord than the other half, so strings 6-4, then 3-1. at least im pretty sure...could be wrong
GradeSchoolRecords 9 months ago
@lloplop the music, he don't sing, just do HAAAAAAAAMMAAAAAAAUUUUUUUUMMAAAAAAAAAA.
you know it ? Mantra.
HAHAHAHAHAHA
trash !
TheTrollart 1 year ago
I wish jeff didn't have the flu when he did this song it would sound so much better
Vartex 1 year ago
@Vartex sounds perfect to me.
lloplop 1 year ago 20
@lloplop yeah i know it sounds good but, it just sounds like he has a cold dosen't he? and he was sick often during this time or somthing similar unless its just the microphone capturing the reverb of the room or somthing.
Vartex 1 year ago
i am absolutely obsessed with this song HELP
he hits somewhere untouched
ottovongrace 1 year ago
Where can I download this video? Or at least the audio.
jaybyrd570 1 year ago
@jaybyrd570 if you message me your email address, I'll send you the song.
lloplop 1 year ago
@lloplop Never mind, I found it, but thanks
jaybyrd570 1 year ago
@lloplop Do you think you can send the song too?
iamnotanija 1 year ago
@jaybyrd570 You can go to zamzar. com go to the "download files" tab and put in this link and your email address and you can convert this into Mp3, mp4, or whatever you want. its such a useful site
weamdebest 1 year ago
Now he's in the water.
Come on Jeff, I don't think he realizes how fucking entrancing his lyrics are.
darkshines0 1 year ago 5
Thankyou sir.
jonobomb 1 year ago 3
I can't get enough of this.
socialistperspective 1 year ago 5
One of the most beautiful ad haunting songs I've heard in my life.
heylookitsme07 2 years ago 34
@heylookitsme07 Agreed.
christinespage 1 year ago
wow..
NighttSwimmming 2 years ago 11