If it weren't for Billy there would be no perfect circle. Sure maynard is amazing, but billy is the mastermind behind these beautiful masterpieces. Give him some damn credit. Also.. Paz needs my penis. SOO anyway.. yeah. give him some fucking props. His guitar solo in this song is awesome.
This band and Tool has changed my life and view of life. i have become a different person because of this kind of music. back in the day i grew up on Rap and Hip Hop ghetto sh*t, i am glad i found myself.
I love Maynard James Keenan, but I'm starting to hate he's the only thing people notice in these videos. You have beautiful, intricate instrumentals (esp. Billy Howerdel on guitar) and all people say is "Maynard Maynard Maynard". Hell it's not what he intended. Why do you think he stands in the back during live shows?
Does anyone know what effect Howerdel uses on his guitar in this song? What effect and what type of reverb? If anyone knows also the amps he uses, I thank you. His guitar at 2:15 is fantastic.
billy's guitar is so dark but yet melodic it perfectly fits on maynard's vocals, apc drummer is amazing i watched him playing live in canada , the band sound was incredible live, perfect!cant wait for some new material , can you imagine howard's melodic riffs combine with adam's raw metalic sound?
This is one of my favorite front artists of all time, literally, been consistently for over a decade, Maynard, from Tool, and also Perfect Circle. Something about this mother fucker just makes me feel invincible and omnipotent and like f#$%ing jamming my life away, I LOVE MAYNARD. If I could come back reincarnate of my choice i would be the exact personification of Maynard. Maynard is most inspirational....
How did this crap become bigger than Tool. Sorry it's not crap. It's good crap like Puscifer. But thats what the man's into. Tool is so much more better lol.
@Pujabie Uh, they were never bigger than Tool - Tool has always gotten more radio play, sold out more and bigger shows, and honestly, the only reason APC ever got popular was because it shares the same singer as.. Tool.
@daisyvision u know nothing!apc sound and emotion is different from tool's music direction, tool is my favorite band but apc deserves its own space cause they are not maynard's pet or toy, apc has its own soul and feeling i know it cause i went to see them live on canada and its nothing like tool they are:a perfect circle
@choibai No, I just thought of Magdalena as a "lovely goddess," as the song implies. I didn't hear the, rather vulgar, word "hooker" anywhere in there. This song is in appreciation of a divinely beautiful and sexy woman which I see no problem with since everyone, everywhere seems to appreciate divinely beautiful Goddess women! You don't? Does this song really break down to you as "hooker" alone? Honestly, I just liked the name.
@isisbybobdylan sorry my idea of a divinely goddess is not someone who sells herself.
And no, this song is about the loss of identity and living in grandeur. The author is telling of a stripper that he has put on a pedestal and made her this holy idol which he worships. It is his only source of self esteem and belonging. He makes his sacrifice to her in dollars.
@isisbybobdylan great explanation of what you feel about the lyrics, i think that's the way it works, i mean they put out a song and us(the listeners)have the right to understand it in our own way,that makes the art work eternal and infinite as many versions could feet according to each one's capability and experiences...of course some are deeper than others but altogether create a massive idea around one single art expression: one song.
@SalSanMar3 that was my fantasy(comment)some time ago...that would be amazing , billy's melodies along with adam's raw sounds while maynard sings some older style(orestes,sober,3 libras,etc)songs...
look at the song lyrics, written on a picture of a bar napkin. It says Cat Eye Lounge in the corner. at the beginning of the video you hear them mention the now closed bar. One of the coolest bars of all time. RIP
Mmm giv m taste.
PSCreativeGaming 3 weeks ago
If it weren't for Billy there would be no perfect circle. Sure maynard is amazing, but billy is the mastermind behind these beautiful masterpieces. Give him some damn credit. Also.. Paz needs my penis. SOO anyway.. yeah. give him some fucking props. His guitar solo in this song is awesome.
coreyhhh 1 month ago
++APC++TOOL=thebestmusic
eskelectro242 2 months ago
i need to make love to paz lenchantin in the missionary position for the sole purpose of procreation
BewareTheWater11 3 months ago
Comment removed
the1stbeaner 2 months ago
@BewareTheWater11
You cannot procreate... with a goddess.
the1stbeaner 2 months ago
Fuck this is sexy music!
nataliemuffle123 3 months ago
This band and Tool has changed my life and view of life. i have become a different person because of this kind of music. back in the day i grew up on Rap and Hip Hop ghetto sh*t, i am glad i found myself.
Mr5424cesar 5 months ago 16
@Mr5424cesar -welcome to the bliss! :)
amusingmyslf 5 months ago
man apc's guitarist is a buff motherf**** i wish i had those guns
zedacar 5 months ago 7
Who is the one dislike for this video a rubber house plant???
bilderbergresistance 6 months ago
@bilderbergresistance a troll most likely xD
Mrpissedface 5 months ago
MJK on the the best all time.
bilderbergresistance 6 months ago
and the guy next door said "let me help you with that"
homemoviesaustintx 7 months ago
why is maynard holding his water bottle like that? lol product placement
KingMichael 7 months ago
good stuff
GreenThisBitch 7 months ago
If God could sing...would do it like this <3 Eargasmic!!!!!!!!!!!!!
CarolynnRiv 8 months ago
@CarolynnRiv what do you mean if? the result...materialized!!!!!
croniclone81 7 months ago
@croniclone81 jajajajaja! oh yeee!
CarolynnRiv 7 months ago
"i'd sell my soul, my self esteem a dollar at the time"
Migas128 8 months ago 3
Orgasmic!
JAP633 8 months ago
the cat eye lounge
shanecombs1993 9 months ago
@shanecombs1993 I never knew. Thanks. Sounded a bit like "the jedi lounge".
mbdgbt 8 months ago
@mbdgbt yea its like a bar in arizona where maynard met "magdalena"
shanecombs1993 8 months ago
@mbdgbt haha that's what i always thought he said
schism206 7 months ago
@schism206 hahahahaha! i still say it! that's hilarious.
mbdgbt 7 months ago
@mbdgbt i just figured maynard was a star wars geek
schism206 7 months ago
A Perfect Circle - Magdalena (Live At America West Arena, Phoenix, AZ - 06/04/2000) where the hell was I :O !! #ifail
sleek462 10 months ago
@sleek462 Haha I wish I could have been there as well.
Stinkfist43 8 months ago
2:16 till the end. epic.
opethinchains 11 months ago
is that guy the singer from metallica?
19slipstream84 11 months ago
@19slipstream84 That is fucking hilarious!
rottencore0 4 months ago
Is that Maynard's real hair or is that a wig?
Astrodude55 11 months ago
this song makes me horny and i dont know why
mongoleet 11 months ago
@mongoleet because lyrics is about some sexxxy girl, about desire, damn is treating about sexxx.
BigBoss1982 11 months ago
@BigBoss1982 that might be true. but its more than that. its not important WHAT its about, but HOW its about ;)
mongoleet 11 months ago
@mongoleet very true man ; ) very true. Lyrics written by Maynard are always breath-taking, magic and amazing.
A mystery and secret is the second name of APC and TOOL.
BigBoss1982 11 months ago 2
I love Maynard James Keenan, but I'm starting to hate he's the only thing people notice in these videos. You have beautiful, intricate instrumentals (esp. Billy Howerdel on guitar) and all people say is "Maynard Maynard Maynard". Hell it's not what he intended. Why do you think he stands in the back during live shows?
InSovietRussia1 1 year ago
@InSovietRussia1 emm maynard maynard maynard maynard ....... tool= maynard danny justis adam but apc maynard maynard maynard jajajajajajjajaj
hellbalck 11 months ago
@hellbalck ehhh....... i didnt um..... i, i dont think i could quite, erm, maybe u could uh....... wat?
opethinchains 11 months ago
Comment removed
kyoso23 1 year ago
Comment removed
gdub454 1 year ago 2
Does anyone know what effect Howerdel uses on his guitar in this song? What effect and what type of reverb? If anyone knows also the amps he uses, I thank you. His guitar at 2:15 is fantastic.
Gnomofoby 1 year ago
@Gnomofoby He uses a 1991 Gibson Les Paul 1960 Reissue, Marshall Amps, A lot of reverbs, A lot of chorus, and a lot of rack equipment..
Search at google: Billy Howerdel guitar rig, click at the page digitalburn
resevil2008 1 year ago
tight as hell live
CellpanTV 1 year ago
Effing YESSS! \m/
Wendellerins 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thumbs down this if you don't agree.
APC > TOOL
eyebal 1 year ago
When did Alice Cooper start singing for APC?
osensei75 1 year ago
@osensei75 Hahaha. I wonder if Maynard is going to bust out with old APC theme, wig and everything.
DeddSoul 1 year ago
@osensei75 Dude i bout choked when i read ur comment....U r so right ..when did Alice Cooper join APC lollollol 8-))
gdub454 1 year ago
who was the drummer on phoenix?
javirengo 1 year ago
i can't wait to see a perfect circle again, they are returning \:D/
Grafkores 1 year ago
Where can I get this? Is it a live dvd?
Stinkfist43 1 year ago
billy's guitar is so dark but yet melodic it perfectly fits on maynard's vocals, apc drummer is amazing i watched him playing live in canada , the band sound was incredible live, perfect!cant wait for some new material , can you imagine howard's melodic riffs combine with adam's raw metalic sound?
christiannandres 1 year ago
This is one of my favorite front artists of all time, literally, been consistently for over a decade, Maynard, from Tool, and also Perfect Circle. Something about this mother fucker just makes me feel invincible and omnipotent and like f#$%ing jamming my life away, I LOVE MAYNARD. If I could come back reincarnate of my choice i would be the exact personification of Maynard. Maynard is most inspirational....
neofilm 1 year ago
I'm so glad this concert is on Youtube. I wanted to be there so bad but couldn't.
JewelEGirl 1 year ago
How did this crap become bigger than Tool. Sorry it's not crap. It's good crap like Puscifer. But thats what the man's into. Tool is so much more better lol.
Pujabie 1 year ago
@Pujabie Uh, they were never bigger than Tool - Tool has always gotten more radio play, sold out more and bigger shows, and honestly, the only reason APC ever got popular was because it shares the same singer as.. Tool.
daisyvision 1 year ago
@daisyvision u know nothing!apc sound and emotion is different from tool's music direction, tool is my favorite band but apc deserves its own space cause they are not maynard's pet or toy, apc has its own soul and feeling i know it cause i went to see them live on canada and its nothing like tool they are:a perfect circle
christiannandres 1 year ago
@christiannandres I agree, this is Billy's band
Tmanvolfan 1 year ago
@Pujabie Theyre just used in more movies and soundtracks, Tool is more popular. They havent been in any movies because it would make alex grey mad.
Tmanvolfan 1 year ago
@Tmanvolfan I like it.
Pujabie 8 months ago
Josh Freese - What a guy!
heavyonit 1 year ago
Wow, this is for real one of the best performances I've seen out of them. And the video quality is great. Thumbs up
Charkie10 1 year ago
Fuck*** amazing! So much energy going out of this, incredible!
Oxtrack26 1 year ago
I'd sell my soul, my self esteem a dollar at a time to see APC live :/
cristianbam 1 year ago
He totally messed with that solo of his and made it sound even more amazing then the original.
tolhead 1 year ago
I named my daughter after this song ~ Magdalena Rose.
isisbybobdylan 1 year ago 5
@isisbybobdylan You do know that in the song magdalena is a hooker...
choibai 1 year ago
@choibai No, I just thought of Magdalena as a "lovely goddess," as the song implies. I didn't hear the, rather vulgar, word "hooker" anywhere in there. This song is in appreciation of a divinely beautiful and sexy woman which I see no problem with since everyone, everywhere seems to appreciate divinely beautiful Goddess women! You don't? Does this song really break down to you as "hooker" alone? Honestly, I just liked the name.
isisbybobdylan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@isisbybobdylan sorry my idea of a divinely goddess is not someone who sells herself.
And no, this song is about the loss of identity and living in grandeur. The author is telling of a stripper that he has put on a pedestal and made her this holy idol which he worships. It is his only source of self esteem and belonging. He makes his sacrifice to her in dollars.
choibai 1 year ago
@isisbybobdylan great explanation of what you feel about the lyrics, i think that's the way it works, i mean they put out a song and us(the listeners)have the right to understand it in our own way,that makes the art work eternal and infinite as many versions could feet according to each one's capability and experiences...of course some are deeper than others but altogether create a massive idea around one single art expression: one song.
christiannandres 1 year ago
@christiannandres Yes, Dylan is the master at this craft. Are you a fan, by chance?
isisbybobdylan 1 year ago
Wouldn't you all LOVE to see Adam Jones and Billy Howerdel play a song together? Two wonderful guitarists.
SalSanMar3 2 years ago 4
@SalSanMar3 Good lord, that would make my head explode. In a good way.
mnwalke 1 year ago
@SalSanMar3 that was my fantasy(comment)some time ago...that would be amazing , billy's melodies along with adam's raw sounds while maynard sings some older style(orestes,sober,3 libras,etc)songs...
christiannandres 1 year ago
Went to a Tool concert at this arena last July, lol.
tydwidell 2 years ago
MJK can sing the panties right off of me!
Lisajo009 2 years ago 68
@Lisajo009 LOL me too. This is the sexiest song.
KesORhaN 2 years ago 2
wow, i dont mean any disrespect but that's pretty sad. just because a person can sing, you are enchanted to the point you would give up your body.
DragonHunterG 1 year ago
@DragonHunterG but its Maynard so your arguement is invalid, im a straight dude and he can sing my pants off any day lol
xXninjasupremeXx 1 year ago 5
@Lisajo009 Yeah, but for me, it's Billy's guitar playing in this song. Holy shit is it hot.
ArtOfMe021 1 year ago
@Lisajo009 where i come from we call that a whore
tr763 1 year ago
@tr763 Are you from Dickland? The land of the dicks?
fsandt 1 year ago
@Lisajo009 yeah mine too!
adjournell 5 months ago
What did he say the beginning?
SalSanMar3 2 years ago
Maynard doesn't want anyone to steal his water bottle.
SimonRivas 2 years ago 11
where I can find this live dvd??
drummeroulis93 2 years ago
i wish i could transmit this feeling as easily as maynard does
stacygirl777 2 years ago
this sounds so much better than the studio version. and btw marnard is the greatest lyricist of all time!
bythasword 2 years ago 5
indeed
omgidntknowut2put 2 years ago
the guitarist reminds me of voldemort
androssthegreat 2 years ago 4
yea and the 2nd one is snape :/
WickedWitchKING 2 years ago 2
and Maynard is a young beardless version of Dumbledore!
kiwikroger 2 years ago
This is for sure one of the best bands ever! I love them and this is a beautiful song.
Hope to see them back in the near future.
carlangas54070 2 years ago 2
that. solo. that. bridge. goosebumps. speechless. maybe the best APC song
ShopliftersUnite 2 years ago 2
is he using in the solo delay or reverb???? can someone help me??
mistercrane 2 years ago
I use both for the sound with distortion and chorus.
RedKroovy 2 years ago
That is about the greatest sound made with guitar, that I've heard. (Just an opinion)
RedKroovy 2 years ago
both!
bythasword 2 years ago
I think it's a bit of both
bruceamey 2 years ago
this F'ing KICKS ASS
Custanza14 2 years ago 2
thanks to you, i really got into this song and appreciate it so much more because of this live performance!!!
great post!!! thank you!!!
ILLeagle23 2 years ago 3
that wouldve been such a sick concert
dawse1234 2 years ago 3
purely divine!
xxxdarkmexxx 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
patman82 2 years ago
AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME
Joeberries 3 years ago
look at the song lyrics, written on a picture of a bar napkin. It says Cat Eye Lounge in the corner. at the beginning of the video you hear them mention the now closed bar. One of the coolest bars of all time. RIP
legacycar1 3 years ago
How are they so good?!
zerogecko 3 years ago 5
they did a pact... with me.
rodssslive 3 years ago
That riff.. The musical definition of passion.
Daubster 3 years ago 42
@Daubster yes,it's truly amazing!
LaVelvetVicenza 1 year ago
Listen that riff on LSD!!! holy shit
wazzzabeee 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
hey man. im naked!!
i need a man to sex me up tonight hehe. msg me on m.s.n. ID is in my ep
comedyguy21 3 years ago
Wow, what are the source of this video? Have they released a dvd?
meltic 3 years ago
It was on MTV2.
crazymiles 3 years ago 2