Great point! The teachings of Islam are not justified via logic and philosophy, in the tradition of the west (and in my mind, common sense). However, this isn't to say that all Judea-Christian beliefs, can be backed by logic either. But In the West, almost all laws are free of Religious constraints. Sharia Law is primitive.
At MyErick2012 You are wrong on all points you have made. In regards to Sharia Law, don't listen & let Fox News educate you about it. Go To your local Masjid and ask to learn more about it.
I don't see any difference between sharia law and bill of rights or magna carta. Sharia law is not what we normally think of like what to wear, which language to speak, what to buy etc etc..
such things are very small things and change over time and with culture.
Sharia is basically fundamental laws of humanity, like bill of rights etc..
Panel codes is a section of sharia, for e.g stoning of aduterers
@ingehs Give ditails one some of these things and I will bring ditails on why I belive it's not. Because i dont wanna have a discusion, based on claims without prof. :D ok with you?
@xzaxx ''islamic state'' ? you got the point, brilliant. that is all i want you to understand. there is a hell lot of difference between islamic state, muslim majority state and islamic doctrine.
as far as we know there is not a single islamic state in this world. not a single one. although there are muslim majority states. not a single muslim majority country practise sharia law.
can you name any true islamic state. a state with a Caliph ? free education, food, elctricity, justice ? ANY ?
@ingehs with islamic state i mean a country which praticies sharia-law. alot of countries practice sharia. but only a few of them practise the whole sharia. Afghanistan, iran, saudi arabia, jemen, oman, egypt, pakistan, these are the countries which practise the whole or some of the islamic laws!
@xzaxx all the muslim majority countries you have mentioned donot confirm to an ideal ''islamic sharia state''. No one.
none of these countries have a Caliph. only saudi is a close example but saudi has US armies on its soil, i mean they are allies. this is straight against the islamic law and sharia.
so how come these countries are islam ? except the fact that they are muslim majority countries.
why don't you blame corruption, dictatorship, mismanagement etc etc which is evident ?
@ingehs Are you asking me us constitution is evil ? which is evil anyway because it only upholds freedoms for the citizens of US only and violates the freedoms of others.
same goes to islamic law, it upholds and protects freedoms of its followers but it certainly don't violate the freedoms of non-followers.
sharia believes in stoning adulteres. like any other law it has pre requisites of finding out if the accused are guilty. in sharia there are two possible ways of finding out if an acuused person is really an adulterer. first the accused can admit the he commited adultery and face the charge of stoning (which is not possible to happen because no one wants to be stoned). second the prosecutors have to find 4 people that actually saw the accused commiting adultery (which is not possible either).
Sharia is about descendant rules that are derived or inspired from the holy book, it maily treats corruption causing social and legal matters that are inherently subject to controversy, it defines truth about moral and ethical matters, it also defines the role of men and women and their respective responsability. Democracy on the other hand is an utopic elusive system, it cannot be implemented cause there is no freedom, there are only rights "those available in the sharia".
i dont get why people argue over religion ? its like saying "topic of discussion will be your mother today" and then we talk about one persons mother ... lol find something better to do in life. my last 2cents... find something real to do with ur life.
If I may ask you a question please....You say you, alongside a group of others, were trying to build a democratic situation government for Iraq.
How would you feel if some group in Iraq were sitting in their comparative politics class, draw up a form of government for the u.s with whatever kind of government ideology in their agenda. Not so funny I guess...
So my friend, what gives you the right to plan for another people their form of government?
Sharia Law simply means the Laws of Nature and so whether Sharia Law is compatible to Democracy, it actually depends in whether Democracy is compatible wit the Laws of Nature. Like if you burn fossil fuels and create CO2 that earth cannot absorb, you create global warming and face the consequences as a result. The point is, God created this world with a log-book 'sharia law" and so if you violate the rules of nature, you are faced with consequences which you have to pay. I hope you get my point.
"You can't justify Sharia law with people like you"
Of course you can't, you have people like her killed, how dare she question dogma!
"It is still better than your society that allows homosexuals, animal sex, prostitution"
If two consenting adults wanna hanky panky, it's none of your business, also animal sex isn't legal. If your excuse is that it occurs in western nations, let me drop the "boomb" on you- it happens often in the middle east too.
@TurboDally haha bro u been drinking too much haterade. sounds like ur religion is media. no matter how much clean something is. it always end up having dust over it. pre-martial sex is cool with you. i doubt be happy to find out if ur wife had sex with ur best friend/ brother or dad before marriage. ur life wouldnt be the same after. what islam teaches has a lot more deeper meaning to it. best thing to do before attacking something is to learn about it :)
Sharia law is a system of non sense invented by barbarians. They believe in the circumcision of both men and women. They also take away a hand for theft.
I dont know why we like to find the differences between us ... and not follow the one common thing that all religions have... ONE GOD... HE is not a person .. people have different names for Him.. Like Essah is Jesus's name that he was refered to as when he was among us... Stop Fighting with each other ... fight with the ones who are full of HATE and the ones who cause us to fight ... all religions are rivers that connect to the same sea... like pillers of the same building...
according to sharia law women should dress pretty much like nouns .... when they around someone they can legally get married to or have sex with . To not provoke sexual desires of other men without wanting to.. whats wrong with that ?
less pre-martial sex/ rapes / unwanted babies / lives ruined / whores on the street ... world becomes a better place for your kids to grow ... eliminating one of the most 3 desired things from the world ( money , power , bitches <--- this one)
Some men have desires for women just looking at them even in a veil...You have it ass backwards- the MAN should control his desire, the female shouldn't have to make special reservations- stop being weak.
"pre-martial"
Doesn't matter.
"rapes/unwanted babies/lives ruined"
Does matter.
However, locking women up or covering them up in tents is like brushing dirt under the carpet, you haven't fixed the flawed mind, you've just hidden it.
@TurboDally how is "locking them up" connected with sheria law ? its about the dress code and no where in sheria law it says lock or suppress woman. infact its the first religion that says to treat woman equally to men "written" in the book itself. forcing anything on someone is wrong. the word "muslim" means "one who submits to God WILLINGLY". the people who force stuff are wrong wither it be islam or western mentality. there is a reason why its the fastest growing religion in the world.
Almost an excellent video; but two key observations, first that you were driving a stick-shift car :), second, trying to relate "sharia" aka religious law with a democratic way of life. Sharia or for that matter any religious law just cannot be compatible with the democratic society for the reason that democracy attempts or at least tries to accommodate people of all believes and faith and so on, where are religious laws are based on a set of codes from their good books abstract ideas!
No it is not compatible with democracy because sharia law is not democracy. Sharia law is how Muslims live their lives. & Sharia comes from the Quran and sacred traditions of the Prophet(PBUH). You cant justify one system of law using another? Its like asking communists to justify their system comparing it to democracy. Sharia is for Muslims only by the way. I think a bunch of other people said it but you need to read up some more. good luck
A person who is born in a family of Muslims, doesn't have the choice to NOT be a Muslim. When such a person reaches the age of reason and wishes to leave the religion- aka not be a Muslim, it's most likely that in a country that adopts sharia- that such a person will be killed/imprisoned. So technically, it does affect non-Muslims. But I'm sure there are a few other things I may have missed out that were relevant to the topic.
thats a different case. according to Sharia if a person leaves the religion in a muslim country they are to be killed yes. The reason for being that they will lead other to leave the religion. a person can be a non Muslim if they want but they want to spread the religion how else does anyone find out that you are no longer a Muslim. Again though these are OUR principles. We believe Allah is just and there is a reason for everything he decrees. You should become a Muslim.
@Iqra1289 if you want sharia you can have it or if you live in the west you can have it go live in the middle east easy, dont try forcing it on none muslims
IsIam is based on the teachings of a pedophile. Moo-HAM-ID married a girl of six but waiting a whole three years to consumate the marriage. marrying a 9 year old, wow, now that is a reall man who takes control of a little girl.
@wgrudows i guess ignorance is blliss... that is till the angel of death rips ur soul out of your body like wool from a bush of thornes and then u will see and you will cry blood and rip off your skin in regret but to no avail for the only way a human gets to heaven is through the mercy of the one which you mock and dont believe in. a criminal against your own creator and what a horrible loss yhou shall have. wow
@FlawlysTheKing You may want to follow the words the merciful creater supposedly passed on to a 40 year old man who had sex with a 9 year old. You may want to live the life of a leader of a band of theives. I won't say you are wrong. I will say I would much rather follow the words of the Son of God, who teaches peace and tolerance for others. as they treat me. Sharyia law has some good points, however it also has MAJOR flaws.
@wgrudows show me one place in bible where jesus says i m god pray to me ill convert to Christianity today.. Theres a reason why he only had 1 daughter which was from His first Wife. if jesus was here wont all the nouns in the world marry him like they do now ? We are all children of God in the context Jesus said he was.. Pray to GOD not Jesus the one God who created the heavens and earth the one that all his prophets prayed to including jesus mohammad david moses.
"u will see and you will cry blood and rip off your skin in regret but to no avail"
Oh wow, for a second I thought you were talking about some psychopath/murderer (if you're a Muslim, dare I say EVIL AMERICAN CAPITALIST PIG (dog) torturing Muslims), but I was wrong- you were talking about "GOD", ahhh, well then it's okay!
"a criminal against your own creator and what a horrible loss yhou shall have"
Disbelief is not a crime, unless you're a cult leader.
"Sharia" means "law", so it is redundant to always put the word law after the word sharia. (Sorry, just being a besserwisser/smartass). Is sharia compatible with the democratic system? I would say NO NO.
As an ex-Muslims, I challenge Muslims to dispute the following points: 1) Islam condones slavery unequivocally, 2) Islam allows husbands to beat their wives, 3) Islam condones the rape of non-Muslims women, 4) Islam teaches that a Muslim is superior to non-Muslim who holds PhD. Now, isn't Islam a fascist ideology? Islamofascism.
@EmpireIraq Here is the evidence: Slavery and sex with non-Muslims, Qur'an: Sura (33:50) . . . "If you fear high-handedness from your wives, remind them [of the teaching of God], then ignore them when you go to bed, then hit them." Quran 4:34 . . . Do you need more?
"Were is your evidence for this, and please don't reply back to me if your just gonna say that i have to disprove these claims."
He provided evidence for his claim, you and your fellows decided to mark his post as spam, or should I say...Censor. It's like silencing WikiLeaks for exposing war crimes, if those who censored concentrated on ensuring the war crimes wouldn't happen, you wouldn't need to hide anything.
@MyErick2012 references to ur 4 points from quran would help. and IF u r able to find something even close to what you stated there. read the whole page in english i m sure ur find ur answers.
Have you seen someone drunk before? If you are an invader, you don't want your troops drinking alcohol...I want my perception of reality to be as accurate as possible- I don't take drugs, alcohol, or indulge in superstition (religion).
"Sex out of Marriage...HIV PREVALENCE LOWER"
It's also lower in people who can control themselves and CARE for health, marriage certificate not necessary ;)
"you didnt build a government for iraq u destroyed iraq"
She? She's a student...She's not out there supporting war mongers or coming to Iraq with a gun in one hand, and a bible in another...
"you trying to build a government that suit you"
A hypothetical situation- to build a government that speaks for ALL. How do you cater for all people without giving 1 group of people more power than others, etc. No one is denying that the Iraq was was unjustified.
It shows how far we have slipped from are past norms that such a question could be asked. In no way is Sharia Law compatible with a modern western liberal society . and in answering DJFG85`s comment I witness what sharia law means in muslim countries and I understand it well. If a woman gets raped she would be better keeping the rape a secret rather than reporting it as she would need to produce two male witnesses or she will end up being punished.
Nobody even knows what Sharia Law really is. Americans, typical of their nature, believe everything they hear on TV. I support a totally secular society and I like living in one but how can you all bash a law system without researching it yourself from BOTH sides?
Go to a Mosque and ask some qustions, they're really nice there. No reason to be shy. Don't ask non-Muslims qustions about Islam. Its like going to the Chevy car dealer and asking about the Ford Motor Co.! Friday is Prayer Day 1:00 PM
@hamzah938 I am an ex-Muslim, and I know this: if a non-Muslim goes to a Mosque and attempts to ask questioning regarding Islam, Muslims will lie to him/her. Muslims are trained to lie non-Muslims about Islam in order to hide the real Islam.
It doesn't seem compatible because it is not. Sharia is a barbaric medieval system that kept a bunch of barbarians in check. Western moral thinking does not mix with it, and never will. The day Sharia takes hold in a western nation is the day that nation gives up freedom and progress both morally and scientifically.
A headless, handless corpse formerly known as "Muhammed" would be the true prophet of Islam, had Islam undertaken its actual course set in Sharia. How befitting for a religion of DEATH be ruled by a corpse! Muslims should be like their prophet should have been and decapitate themselves. The other alternative is to LEAVE ISLAM. Oops! Muhammed's advice was to kill them in that case. What does he know, in any case. He's just a handless, headless corpse by his own reckoning.
It would have been better had Muslims cut off the hand of Muhammed, the thief of desert caravans going to Mecca. Yes, Muhammed sans his right hand would have been a better model for would-be Muslims. (Let Muhammed eat food with the same hand with which he wipes his butt and conducts business. That's desert justice!) While Islam was at it, it might have beheaded Muhammed, since he was an adulterer and an apostate, having left his own religion for a new one he invented a la "abrogation".
Am very disappointed of EXPERTS who attack sharia while there way of learning is resting there asses on the couch and just google it whatever shit is written.
Sharia is a whole study , but since you can't READ books
@SoProudMuslim It doesn't take an expert to "attack" & dismantle Sharia. My free-thinking superstition-free 7 year old can do it in a moment. She uses simple fundamental human needs like compassion, mercy & equality; things which Islam is choking its medieval self without.
Youtube video ("sharia Q.9")?
Yes, he fits the Islamic 'expert' tag very well. The usual compassionless anti-humanitarian dogmatist giving excuses for the inexcusable. Myriad literature tells me the exact same sorry story.
@SoProudMuslim No, it's not just me who doesn't agree with Sharia. Basic instinctive human traits like compassion and mercy tell me that those against include the majority of humanity. Another fundamental trait of human self-preservation, fear, means that the world's Muslims, who are threatened (legally by Sharia - or otherwise) with death for criticizing or wishing to leave such an 'ideology', are still not able to voice their true feelings.
@SoProudMuslim No, I didn't mention "cutting hands" but your consideration of this criticism of Sharia as the "everyman" argument is very apt. Much as you try, you and every other deluded Quran-basher can't escape your own humanity. Once your brain is drained of fear & indoctrination, I feel sure that you'll join every other global tongue in attacking the Sharia murder of adulterers, gays & 'apostates'... as well as considering the limb amputation of thieves as the backward desert cruelty it is.
People, great news for you all. Find out just why thousands upon thousands are starting to realise how much they have been lied to for centuries and are now starting to leave this evil cult for the truth by visiting my channel.
@dummbatz48 yes u r right, if by civilized u mean allowing rapists to go free and abusive alcoholic fathers to get a spank on the rist over nighter in jail or to let cheating husbands/wifes just keep on cheating or to let people idolize th body of woman to the point of prostitution and every freakin comercial has a naked mother/daughter/sister/wife in it to sell the product then yes u r right. how civilized
what an insensitive video ... you know what law is compatible with iraqis , you just as an oppressing nation take every one u don't like put him in AbuGhraib Guantanmu whatever
and show them ur laws in prison ,, AND WE HAVE SEEN THESE LAWS ..
what gave u the right to invade a country that never harmed an american citizen ?and u do projects for the suitable system to rule it ..
But ur government has already forced the system on the people ..
@SoProudMuslim Proud? Try conceited and closed. This person didn't plan any invasion or invade Iraq. With goodwill she asks some reasonable questions and you show the true colours of the 'great Islamic tradition of debate'.
@blackmore4 I am not attacking her cuz she is a good person ,, and there is something called SENSE you have killed 700 k people in Iraq and it was kinda mean to intervene more in this , right ??
so , my Islamic tradition doesn't satisfy you ,, but blood thirsty mass murderer traditions is good enough for you !!
@SoProudMuslim So Healthyaddict is now off the hook and you've shifted the responsibility to me personally for the murder of "700k"? The real answer is much closer to home than you'd ever admit with Islamist factions responsible for up to between 80 & 90% of Muslim deaths.
So, not only does your "Islamic tradition" not "satisfy" me, its "blood thirsty mass murder" appalls humanity.
@blackmore4 Man !! you are talking nonsense ,, does it make when I say "you" that you have killed muslims in crusades ,, that you have converted jews and muslims in Spain by force
does it make that you ve travelled across places and slaughtered indigenous people like south america ,,
does it mean that you ve nuked japan
I say "you" cuz u stand for the west and hate islamic tradition which without islamic history no sciences would have been preserved .
@SoProudMuslim No, I don't "stand for the west", I stand for humanity and as such condemn the same genocides and nuclear slaughter as you. You see, I knew you had it in you! Just go that extra mile and stop stoning adulterers, hanging gays and beheading blasphemers and give women total legal equality with men and then we can conspire against the global corporations over tea :-)
@blackmore4 I am proud cuz you don't like Islamic tradition in which jews lived peacefully under Islamic THEOCRACY
and when christians ruled they escaped to wherever muslim land they could find because europe is a very TOLERANT place ,,, this is Islamic tradition .
Under Muslim theocracy there were debates going between an atheist (heretics) and a muslim in Baghdad ,,
the same time europe used to burn any one who say the earth is round as heretics
mohammed is example which all muslim (men) should follow. Quran as his book.
Democracy at certain times were limited to men in societies. so it is not a "modern" (the now, not back then) democracy if women are not given the same opportunities as men holding American democracy as the standard.
democracy is a 'system' originated in Greece. Why are Americans dummies to learn this fact. What makes 'democracy' absolutely 'right' as though its a God given systes and so should be imposed by the West on others against their will? if Muslims choose 'Shariah' (Law of Allah, based on the Quran and teachings of Muhammad (pbuh), which of course is not much different than the Jewish Tanakh/Bible - then let people choose freely. Reason why people hate US is coz of your meddling and imposition.
I too am in columbus. my response is as a muslim i don't have to"justify shari'ah" i can explain it but i don't have to "justify" it. aspects of shari'ah are compatible with democracy as some aspects of democracy are compatible with shari'ah.
Sharia law will not be and will never be compatible with Democracy for several reasons, but one major reasons most overlook is that Democracy relies on secular discussion for value exploration, since Christian society leave exploration of the human nature (love and options) this gave birth to Democracy. Sharia law will never allow for exploration of secular values (real time values) thus may never be compatible with democracy.
Case in point the American constitution being an enabling text.
The main objective of Sharia Law is to create a society in which the main motivation of people is not material gain, and individualism, but self improvement and collective success of the entire society. Instead of creating an economy based on competition and individualism Sharia Law focuses on creating a society based on equal distribution of wealth and collective thinking, a society in which people are not running in a rat-race for individual success but learn and work for collective success.
pisslam is the violation of human rights especially women and children. I am glad that western culture is watering down pisslam. Anyone who follows the ideas of a child rapist (dick be in him) is as bad as the rapist himslef!
The main thing common between democracy and Sharia Law is that the laws in both are defined democratically by the people living under these laws and they can be changed democratically in the same way. The main difference is that the principles of laws in Sharia are based on Islam. So Sharia Law can only be applied to a society in which the majority of people believe in Islam. Sharia Law is not meant to be enforced on a non-Muslim society.
@TwyztdValkyrie No that is the truth brother. The countries that apply discriminatory laws today in the name of Islam are not actually applying Sharia Law, they are applying their "traditional laws". The principles of Sharia Law are based on the Quran and the Quran says that men and women are equal and does not prescribe any discriminatory law for non-Muslims.
@CreativeZed Valkyrie = germanic warrior goddess. Im a woman. And discriminatory law IS sharia. You are cherry picking the one part of the quran where it states that all muslims are equal before allah. You also aren't mentioning the fact that women are seen, in the quran, as half a man, as the property of their fathers and husbands, as breeding chattle, as objects -- even in infancy -- for bartering. Those are not equal. AND dhimmitude is governed by sharia. You fail.
@TwyztdValkyrie Ok sis! with due respect I have to say that you have been misguided. Can you please quote to me the verses of the Quran which state that:
1. Women are half a man
2. Women are the property of their fathers
3. Women are the property of their husbands
4. Women are breeding cattle
5. Women are objects
6. Women can be used for bartering
7. Discriminatory laws for non-Muslims
Also can you tell me who did you learn Islam from? It will help me answer your questions.
@CreativeZed 1) A woman is worth one-half a man. 2:282
2+3) Men are in charge of women, because Allah made men to be better than women. Refuse to have sex with women from whom you fear rebellion, and scourge them. 4:34 [there are more, but this sums it up]
4) "Marry of the women, who seem good to you, two or three or four." 4:3
5) Have sex with your women whenever and as often as you like. 2:223
Women have rights that are similar to men, but men are "a degree above them." 2:228
You may not forcibly inherit women, unless they flagrantly lewd. 4:19
7) Dhimmitude is the status that Islamic law, the Sharia, mandates for non-Muslims. Dhimmis, are free to practice their religion in a Sharia regime, but are made subject to a number of humiliating regulations designed to enforce the Qur'an's command that they "feel themselves subdued" (Sura 9:29).
@CreativeZed Not forgot, not enough room and not important. I took religion in school, have studied theology has a hobby since childhood, was christian for quite awhile, my friend growing up was Muslim so I studied, I have studied islamic family law... shall I go on? I didnt realise I had to be a scholar to have a clear, studied opinion. I also didn't realise I had to know arabic to have an opinion. That would be like saying I have to know latin (which I do) to be allowed to critisize xtianity.
@CreativeZed so you are admitting that the book for man for all man kind from the ultimate creator must and can only be understood in arabic??? Hello dude, there are more than 6000 languess in th world, why the hell would a god only make it understandable in one language? what a joke.
Not one of you fools answered the nice lady's question, How does a muslim reconcile sharia law when living in a democracy?
You all go off on theological debates and argue about meaningless rubbish. Is there one intelligent muslim out there that can focus on the question because I too am interested in the answer.
this woman starts with the foolish assumption that america has a democracy and that it can be exported to a nation like Iraq. america is a plutocracy devoted to greed, violence, and immorality. it invaded Iraq not to bring freedom but to advance its own geopolitical agenda. killing tens of thousands and sticking poor americans with huge amounts of debt. before america tries to remove the plank of sharia law from Iraq, maybe it should remove the plank in its own eye.
Why does the civilized world keep trying to help these 9th century barbarians? Their are millions of them in America now, why? Ever been to an area thats loaded with them? The way they look at Americans , act toward Americans. They hate our guts, they smile in your face and want your throat cut.
The women vote being half was due to the fact that the women in that time didn't get themselves involved in such situations. Due to their inexperience in situations being dealt with in the court their vote was considered half.
Study the whole concept of the Sharia law from proper sources and you won't need the explanation from Muslims.
Are you seriously creating a video blog while driving?! I need to get better insurance. I think driving should more of a priority to you than Sharia at the time.
Shari'a: Islamic Law put together for Khilafat (meaning under one Islamic leader) in the muslim world. There is no justification for something that cannot be implemented.
Of course if the country is muslim and the government is muslim a sharia system is better. If you get a total understanding of a proper sharia system and run the country in a proper sharia system then you will see its benifits, we look at iran for instance im not having a go at them but you have to understand, that shia'ism is a very small minority of islam and there sharia understanding is different to the Sunni's which make up the majority of muslims' today over 95 %
Sharia Law is not compatible with the Western way of life, and it's not right even to try to apply it here (in the West). Sharia Law is only compatible in a country which citizens are true muslims.
@GODandPEACE - there was your mistake that you put Hadith at the same level as the quran. If you had rejected hadith as a deviant source and then read the quran you would have felt different.
@AliAbdurRasheed - Get your head out of your ass and quit quoting this sort of propaganda. Democracy is older than Islam - it was developed by the Greeks. It was the rule of the land for the Romans. Islamic empires did not bring more enightenment because in the last 100 years the western countries have contributed more to development of humanity than all other previous empires.
Wake up, you and your hadith toting muslims screwed it up for all muslims and now it seems for all of humanity.
@AliAbdurRasheed - Why don't you stick to your 1400 years of sound tradition and scholarship and remain immersed in the gutter of ignorance, believing in garbage for guidance. And, Hadith is 1200 years old i.e. Bukhari, Tirmidhi, Muslim (all of them were persians by the way) published their version around 1200 - 1250 years ago. And of course you have not studied the Quran in any sense otherwise you would have refrained from using the "Quran Only" term. go and read Quran 31:6
@AliAbdurRasheed - Lack of knowledge does not refute a fact. Have you studied the Bible? Have you studied Hadith? Have you studied the books of Zoroastrians?. If not then do it and then opine.
Im guessing anti islamic web sites are a regular visit to go crazy with the cutting and pasting...good luck...what good is knowledge when all you ever is focus and follow the "apperant negatives"...an unbiased individual who seeks knowledge would start with the truth, not "bukhary' what is that? cut and paste i can do that with any topic and make you all for it too...good luck with the hate campaign
Allah condemns hadiths: Surah 7:185,12:111, 31:6, 45:6, 52:34, 68:44, 77:50
“These are the communications of Allah which We recite to you with truth; then in what saying (hadeethin) would they believe after Allah and His communications?” Surah 45:6
Allah is the best guidance, Allah explains: Surah 3:73, 4:26, 4:87,17:9, 25:32, 34:6, 39:23, 41:44, 45:6. 54:17,22,32,40, 56:75-81, 75:16-19, 77:50, 10:35, 7:3, 27:79, 33:3, 16:89
Bitch aasss yu ugly af just saying
Fr3eSTyL3SoCCerDude 2 months ago
Great point! The teachings of Islam are not justified via logic and philosophy, in the tradition of the west (and in my mind, common sense). However, this isn't to say that all Judea-Christian beliefs, can be backed by logic either. But In the West, almost all laws are free of Religious constraints. Sharia Law is primitive.
zadeh79 3 months ago
Islam allows women to drive. It's only in Saudia for political safety reasons.
MuslimVlogGuy 4 months ago
There is no moral sane moral justification for Sharia in the 21st century!
ByTheShortAndCurlies 4 months ago
At MyErick2012 You are wrong on all points you have made. In regards to Sharia Law, don't listen & let Fox News educate you about it. Go To your local Masjid and ask to learn more about it.
Mumineen99 4 months ago
@Mumineen99 Why should any one from the west learn about it if you want to live by it go to the middle east
701shep 1 month ago
muslims that support sharia-law can justify it. but i dont agree with their reasons for sharia-law.
xzaxx 4 months ago
I don't see any difference between sharia law and bill of rights or magna carta. Sharia law is not what we normally think of like what to wear, which language to speak, what to buy etc etc..
such things are very small things and change over time and with culture.
Sharia is basically fundamental laws of humanity, like bill of rights etc..
Panel codes is a section of sharia, for e.g stoning of aduterers
hope you get the point
ingehs 5 months ago
@ingehs So sharia is evil?
chrstilen5 5 months ago
@chrstilen5 No sharia is not evil.
Sharia upholds
1. Freedom
2. Education
3. Economic opportunities
4. Rules for a peaceful and just society
5. Freedom of religion
etc
howcome sharia is evil ?
ingehs 5 months ago
@ingehs Give ditails one some of these things and I will bring ditails on why I belive it's not. Because i dont wanna have a discusion, based on claims without prof. :D ok with you?
chrstilen5 5 months ago
@ingehs there is no freedom of religion!!!! when a muslim converts into another religion he is going to be executed in a islamic state!
xzaxx 4 months ago
@xzaxx ''islamic state'' ? you got the point, brilliant. that is all i want you to understand. there is a hell lot of difference between islamic state, muslim majority state and islamic doctrine.
as far as we know there is not a single islamic state in this world. not a single one. although there are muslim majority states. not a single muslim majority country practise sharia law.
can you name any true islamic state. a state with a Caliph ? free education, food, elctricity, justice ? ANY ?
ingehs 4 months ago
@ingehs with islamic state i mean a country which praticies sharia-law. alot of countries practice sharia. but only a few of them practise the whole sharia. Afghanistan, iran, saudi arabia, jemen, oman, egypt, pakistan, these are the countries which practise the whole or some of the islamic laws!
xzaxx 4 months ago
@xzaxx all the muslim majority countries you have mentioned donot confirm to an ideal ''islamic sharia state''. No one.
none of these countries have a Caliph. only saudi is a close example but saudi has US armies on its soil, i mean they are allies. this is straight against the islamic law and sharia.
so how come these countries are islam ? except the fact that they are muslim majority countries.
why don't you blame corruption, dictatorship, mismanagement etc etc which is evident ?
ingehs 4 months ago
@ingehs i forgot syria!
xzaxx 4 months ago
@ingehs and england.
xzaxx 4 months ago
@ingehs Are you asking me us constitution is evil ? which is evil anyway because it only upholds freedoms for the citizens of US only and violates the freedoms of others.
same goes to islamic law, it upholds and protects freedoms of its followers but it certainly don't violate the freedoms of non-followers.
ingehs 4 months ago
sharia believes in stoning adulteres. like any other law it has pre requisites of finding out if the accused are guilty. in sharia there are two possible ways of finding out if an acuused person is really an adulterer. first the accused can admit the he commited adultery and face the charge of stoning (which is not possible to happen because no one wants to be stoned). second the prosecutors have to find 4 people that actually saw the accused commiting adultery (which is not possible either).
QandahaarIsTheBomb 5 months ago
Sharia is about descendant rules that are derived or inspired from the holy book, it maily treats corruption causing social and legal matters that are inherently subject to controversy, it defines truth about moral and ethical matters, it also defines the role of men and women and their respective responsability. Democracy on the other hand is an utopic elusive system, it cannot be implemented cause there is no freedom, there are only rights "those available in the sharia".
warrior4just 6 months ago
i dont get why people argue over religion ? its like saying "topic of discussion will be your mother today" and then we talk about one persons mother ... lol find something better to do in life. my last 2cents... find something real to do with ur life.
arhamz 6 months ago
Who are you to develope a law for Iraq? Iraq is under an illegal american occupation.
AF6H4N1ST4N 6 months ago
She sounds like a trailer trash.
AF6H4N1ST4N 6 months ago
Islamic Religion is evil
scotlandmurray 7 months ago
If I may ask you a question please....You say you, alongside a group of others, were trying to build a democratic situation government for Iraq.
How would you feel if some group in Iraq were sitting in their comparative politics class, draw up a form of government for the u.s with whatever kind of government ideology in their agenda. Not so funny I guess...
So my friend, what gives you the right to plan for another people their form of government?
One man's food is another man's poison. Right?
sultanofswing58 7 months ago
Sharia Law simply means the Laws of Nature and so whether Sharia Law is compatible to Democracy, it actually depends in whether Democracy is compatible wit the Laws of Nature. Like if you burn fossil fuels and create CO2 that earth cannot absorb, you create global warming and face the consequences as a result. The point is, God created this world with a log-book 'sharia law" and so if you violate the rules of nature, you are faced with consequences which you have to pay. I hope you get my point.
sultanofswing58 7 months ago
I'd like to see a muslim woman respond to this, without referencing the quran or citing god etc. But on a humane basis.
FHomeBrew 7 months ago
You can't justify Sharia law with people like you that don't know what justice is !
LearnToReadTheKuran 8 months ago
@LearnToReadTheKuran
"You can't justify Sharia law with people like you"
Of course you can't, you have people like her killed, how dare she question dogma!
"It is still better than your society that allows homosexuals, animal sex, prostitution"
If two consenting adults wanna hanky panky, it's none of your business, also animal sex isn't legal. If your excuse is that it occurs in western nations, let me drop the "boomb" on you- it happens often in the middle east too.
TurboDally 7 months ago
@TurboDally
You finished ?
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
@TurboDally
You finished ?
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
@TurboDally haha bro u been drinking too much haterade. sounds like ur religion is media. no matter how much clean something is. it always end up having dust over it. pre-martial sex is cool with you. i doubt be happy to find out if ur wife had sex with ur best friend/ brother or dad before marriage. ur life wouldnt be the same after. what islam teaches has a lot more deeper meaning to it. best thing to do before attacking something is to learn about it :)
arhamz 7 months ago
Comment removed
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TurboDally
T̡̖̩͓̹̝̩̥̹̋͆ͨ̽̾ͪͬ̂͘͠R̸̷̥̘̼̺̓ͪ̇̋͐ͫ͠O̡̨̝̤̻̰̯̗̞̜ͯ̿̃ͫ̿ͤ͐ͤ̉̽ͬ̚L̢̗̹͇̗͉̽́͛̄͢O̴̡̫̝̗͈͖̗͓̠͓̼̱̪͓̞̱͇̳̦ͯͮ̔͞Ḻ̵̻̙̙̖̭̫̣̙̣͕̠̜͈͇̩͛̽͒ͨ͂̓ͭͥ̅͛ͯ̾̎͐͛̈́́́̚͢ͅO͔͍̺͉͔̩̲̥̖͍ͤ̂ͫ̄̓ͨ̂̀͒̈́̇̄͘͟ͅL̷̶̛̲͙̖͎̫̰̞͍̠̣̙̺̘̼̫̗̞͛ͦ̌̽ͫͨL͐̅͊͋̾̾ͧ̏̈̌̃҉̯̱̗͖̻̜̜̮̲̠̰̬͠Ǫ̴͓̯͙̯̼̥͎͚̘̥̥̪ͣͨ͐͌̋̓̚͘͜L̵̡̢̤̫̤͖̜̜̙̯͍͂̾ͪ̊͋̆͛̀̇̈͒͝͠Ȯ̡̤̜͎͕̭̝̲̥̰͒ͧͦͭ̋́͘͘͝ͅĻ̷̷̛̜̱̼̹͓̑̈́̑̒ͣ̋ͦͨͨ̂̀͡O̡̯͖̖̝̦̍̌̂̐͝Ḷ̵͔̙͚̘͉̙̪̒̉̓ͦ̂̊ͭͫͪ͡Õ̷̧̗̠͕̟͓̝̾ͯ̎̊͑̍ͥ̍̅͐ͣ͘͢ͅL̫̥̟͇͎̞̳̦̬̯̺̫̣̦̓ͮͯͥͫ̄̂͆͜O͗ͨ̏͌ͧ͐ͮ̎ͬ̉ͧ̎̏̾ͥL
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
See this:
youtube(DOT)com/oKaTsu1FwcI?t=18m25s
imadalmansary 8 months ago
Sharia law is a system of non sense invented by barbarians. They believe in the circumcision of both men and women. They also take away a hand for theft.
Inhuman and should be out lawed!
skepticalinquier 8 months ago 2
@skepticalinquier
It is still better than your society that allows homosexuals, animal sex, prostitution, usury ... etc !
LearnToReadTheKuran 8 months ago
@skepticalinquier
What is inhuman is that Casey Anthony walks free !
Let me see what system was she tried under ?
Oh yeah ... it is the "civilized american justice" system where the rich always walk free !
LOL FAIL !
A dog chasing its tail has more sense than your feeble lop sided comment.
TROLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
The problem with the question is that Iraq was a secular country (a brutal dicatorship , yes) before we bombed the crap out of it.
So, sharia law has come about because of our actions and not because the Iraqis are a muslim country !!
bakersteven3 9 months ago
sharia law is the worse law in history period.
gergar121 9 months ago
A 9 year old girl can given in marriage to a man over 50, and her husband can have sex whenever he wants. Yeah, that's God's wish.
I guess it's okay for women to drive, but I recommend both hands on the wheel, unless...
CircumSquare 9 months ago
Justify your boring opinion to me
jasondewey1 10 months ago
I dont know why we like to find the differences between us ... and not follow the one common thing that all religions have... ONE GOD... HE is not a person .. people have different names for Him.. Like Essah is Jesus's name that he was refered to as when he was among us... Stop Fighting with each other ... fight with the ones who are full of HATE and the ones who cause us to fight ... all religions are rivers that connect to the same sea... like pillers of the same building...
arhamz 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@arhamz
"the one common thing that all religions have... ONE GOD"
Wrong. You probably come from a monotheistic background hence the monotheistic bias, but there are religions out there which worship many gods.
"all religions are rivers that connect to the same sea... like pillers of the same building..."
Religions diverge, they don't converge on the truth. Science does however converge, which is why science wins when religion fails.
TurboDally 7 months ago
Comment removed
arhamz 10 months ago
according to sharia law women should dress pretty much like nouns .... when they around someone they can legally get married to or have sex with . To not provoke sexual desires of other men without wanting to.. whats wrong with that ?
less pre-martial sex/ rapes / unwanted babies / lives ruined / whores on the street ... world becomes a better place for your kids to grow ... eliminating one of the most 3 desired things from the world ( money , power , bitches <--- this one)
arhamz 10 months ago
@arhamz
"To not provoke sexual desires of other men"
Some men have desires for women just looking at them even in a veil...You have it ass backwards- the MAN should control his desire, the female shouldn't have to make special reservations- stop being weak.
"pre-martial"
Doesn't matter.
"rapes/unwanted babies/lives ruined"
Does matter.
However, locking women up or covering them up in tents is like brushing dirt under the carpet, you haven't fixed the flawed mind, you've just hidden it.
TurboDally 7 months ago
@TurboDally how is "locking them up" connected with sheria law ? its about the dress code and no where in sheria law it says lock or suppress woman. infact its the first religion that says to treat woman equally to men "written" in the book itself. forcing anything on someone is wrong. the word "muslim" means "one who submits to God WILLINGLY". the people who force stuff are wrong wither it be islam or western mentality. there is a reason why its the fastest growing religion in the world.
arhamz 7 months ago
... lol pople critisize the death penilty in islam but the electric chair is still used to this day in america with a whole bunch of peoplewatching
FlawlysTheKing 10 months ago
Almost an excellent video; but two key observations, first that you were driving a stick-shift car :), second, trying to relate "sharia" aka religious law with a democratic way of life. Sharia or for that matter any religious law just cannot be compatible with the democratic society for the reason that democracy attempts or at least tries to accommodate people of all believes and faith and so on, where are religious laws are based on a set of codes from their good books abstract ideas!
sam4phd 10 months ago
No it is not compatible with democracy because sharia law is not democracy. Sharia law is how Muslims live their lives. & Sharia comes from the Quran and sacred traditions of the Prophet(PBUH). You cant justify one system of law using another? Its like asking communists to justify their system comparing it to democracy. Sharia is for Muslims only by the way. I think a bunch of other people said it but you need to read up some more. good luck
Iqra1289 10 months ago
@Iqra1289
"Sharia is for Muslims only by the way"
A person who is born in a family of Muslims, doesn't have the choice to NOT be a Muslim. When such a person reaches the age of reason and wishes to leave the religion- aka not be a Muslim, it's most likely that in a country that adopts sharia- that such a person will be killed/imprisoned. So technically, it does affect non-Muslims. But I'm sure there are a few other things I may have missed out that were relevant to the topic.
TurboDally 7 months ago
@TurboDally
Get lost whiteboy before you get dropped !
LearnToReadTheKuran 7 months ago
@TurboDally
thats a different case. according to Sharia if a person leaves the religion in a muslim country they are to be killed yes. The reason for being that they will lead other to leave the religion. a person can be a non Muslim if they want but they want to spread the religion how else does anyone find out that you are no longer a Muslim. Again though these are OUR principles. We believe Allah is just and there is a reason for everything he decrees. You should become a Muslim.
Iqra1289 4 months ago
@Iqra1289 if you want sharia you can have it or if you live in the west you can have it go live in the middle east easy, dont try forcing it on none muslims
701shep 1 month ago
Well, I am a Muslim living in Canada, and I practice Sharia Law all day long every day. Perhaps you should review what Sharia actually means.
HarunDanyal 10 months ago
@HarunDanyal exaaaaaaactly!!
FlawlysTheKing 10 months ago
IsIam is based on the teachings of a pedophile. Moo-HAM-ID married a girl of six but waiting a whole three years to consumate the marriage. marrying a 9 year old, wow, now that is a reall man who takes control of a little girl.
wgrudows 10 months ago
@wgrudows i guess ignorance is blliss... that is till the angel of death rips ur soul out of your body like wool from a bush of thornes and then u will see and you will cry blood and rip off your skin in regret but to no avail for the only way a human gets to heaven is through the mercy of the one which you mock and dont believe in. a criminal against your own creator and what a horrible loss yhou shall have. wow
FlawlysTheKing 10 months ago
@FlawlysTheKing You may want to follow the words the merciful creater supposedly passed on to a 40 year old man who had sex with a 9 year old. You may want to live the life of a leader of a band of theives. I won't say you are wrong. I will say I would much rather follow the words of the Son of God, who teaches peace and tolerance for others. as they treat me. Sharyia law has some good points, however it also has MAJOR flaws.
wgrudows 10 months ago
@wgrudows show me one place in bible where jesus says i m god pray to me ill convert to Christianity today.. Theres a reason why he only had 1 daughter which was from His first Wife. if jesus was here wont all the nouns in the world marry him like they do now ? We are all children of God in the context Jesus said he was.. Pray to GOD not Jesus the one God who created the heavens and earth the one that all his prophets prayed to including jesus mohammad david moses.
arhamz 10 months ago
@FlawlysTheKing
"u will see and you will cry blood and rip off your skin in regret but to no avail"
Oh wow, for a second I thought you were talking about some psychopath/murderer (if you're a Muslim, dare I say EVIL AMERICAN CAPITALIST PIG (dog) torturing Muslims), but I was wrong- you were talking about "GOD", ahhh, well then it's okay!
"a criminal against your own creator and what a horrible loss yhou shall have"
Disbelief is not a crime, unless you're a cult leader.
TurboDally 7 months ago
"Sharia" means "law", so it is redundant to always put the word law after the word sharia. (Sorry, just being a besserwisser/smartass). Is sharia compatible with the democratic system? I would say NO NO.
TheHmmhmm 10 months ago 2
As an ex-Muslims, I challenge Muslims to dispute the following points: 1) Islam condones slavery unequivocally, 2) Islam allows husbands to beat their wives, 3) Islam condones the rape of non-Muslims women, 4) Islam teaches that a Muslim is superior to non-Muslim who holds PhD. Now, isn't Islam a fascist ideology? Islamofascism.
MyErick2012 11 months ago 8
@MyErick2012 Were is your evidence for this, and please don't reply back to me if your just gonna say that i have to disprove these claims.
EmpireIraq 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@EmpireIraq Here is the evidence: Slavery and sex with non-Muslims, Qur'an: Sura (33:50) . . . "If you fear high-handedness from your wives, remind them [of the teaching of God], then ignore them when you go to bed, then hit them." Quran 4:34 . . . Do you need more?
MyErick2012 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@EmpireIraq
"Were is your evidence for this, and please don't reply back to me if your just gonna say that i have to disprove these claims."
He provided evidence for his claim, you and your fellows decided to mark his post as spam, or should I say...Censor. It's like silencing WikiLeaks for exposing war crimes, if those who censored concentrated on ensuring the war crimes wouldn't happen, you wouldn't need to hide anything.
TurboDally 7 months ago
@MyErick2012 references to ur 4 points from quran would help. and IF u r able to find something even close to what you stated there. read the whole page in english i m sure ur find ur answers.
arhamz 7 months ago
Just some thoughts. I would like to see someone who is a supporter of Sharia law justify it without the use of the Quran.
HONEY.
1 Alcohol IS Forbidden in Islam AS YOU KNOW ALCOHOL DO MORE HARM THAN GOOD.
2 Sex out of Marriage MUSLIM COUNTRYS: HIV PREVALENCE LOWER AMONG MUSLIMS.
3 FAMILY RELATION IN ISLAM.
zest12 11 months ago
@zest12
"Alcohol"
Have you seen someone drunk before? If you are an invader, you don't want your troops drinking alcohol...I want my perception of reality to be as accurate as possible- I don't take drugs, alcohol, or indulge in superstition (religion).
"Sex out of Marriage...HIV PREVALENCE LOWER"
It's also lower in people who can control themselves and CARE for health, marriage certificate not necessary ;)
TurboDally 7 months ago
you didnt build a government for iraq u destroyed iraq and you trying to build a government that suit you
iraq had government 5000 years ago not since 1776
zest12 11 months ago
@zest12
"you didnt build a government for iraq u destroyed iraq"
She? She's a student...She's not out there supporting war mongers or coming to Iraq with a gun in one hand, and a bible in another...
"you trying to build a government that suit you"
A hypothetical situation- to build a government that speaks for ALL. How do you cater for all people without giving 1 group of people more power than others, etc. No one is denying that the Iraq was was unjustified.
TurboDally 7 months ago
It shows how far we have slipped from are past norms that such a question could be asked. In no way is Sharia Law compatible with a modern western liberal society . and in answering DJFG85`s comment I witness what sharia law means in muslim countries and I understand it well. If a woman gets raped she would be better keeping the rape a secret rather than reporting it as she would need to produce two male witnesses or she will end up being punished.
FeignofCordor 11 months ago
Nobody even knows what Sharia Law really is. Americans, typical of their nature, believe everything they hear on TV. I support a totally secular society and I like living in one but how can you all bash a law system without researching it yourself from BOTH sides?
DJFG85 11 months ago
O H!
ttgator2003 11 months ago
Go to a Mosque and ask some qustions, they're really nice there. No reason to be shy. Don't ask non-Muslims qustions about Islam. Its like going to the Chevy car dealer and asking about the Ford Motor Co.! Friday is Prayer Day 1:00 PM
hamzah938 11 months ago
@hamzah938 I am an ex-Muslim, and I know this: if a non-Muslim goes to a Mosque and attempts to ask questioning regarding Islam, Muslims will lie to him/her. Muslims are trained to lie non-Muslims about Islam in order to hide the real Islam.
MyErick2012 11 months ago
@MyErick2012
liar liar
there is nothing to hide everything is quran
zest12 11 months ago
@zest12 You try to hide that Islam condones slavery; beating wives; molesting little girls, killing non-Muslims or infidels....etc.
MyErick2012 11 months ago
@MyErick2012
you can even Make a Discussion say something useful or go play with kids
zest12 11 months ago
@zest12 Islam condones slavery; meaning, Islam legalizes slavery. Dispute that point.
MyErick2012 11 months ago
@MyErick2012
SLAVERY!!!! I DONT KNOW WHO TOOK MILLIONS FROM AFRICA TO Europe AND AMERICA OR MAYBE THAT WAS TO GIVE THEM BETTER CHANCE IN LIFE.
MUSLIMS DID NOT: EXTERMINATE THE NATIVE PPL IN AMERICA , AUSTRALIA ,NEW ZEALAND ... EXT
WE ARE WATCHING EVERY DAY IN THE NEWS WHAT IS GOING ON IN YOU CHURCHES THERE IS NOTHING TO ADD.
zest12 11 months ago
@zest12 Answer the question: Does Islam prohibit slavery? This is the question.
MyErick2012 11 months ago
@zest12
"SLAVERY!!!! I DONT KNOW WHO TOOK MILLIONS FROM AFRICA TO Europe AND AMERICA OR MAYBE THAT WAS TO GIVE THEM BETTER CHANCE IN LIFE."
I would sarcastically say the same about the Arab slave trade- which was similar in size to the European slave trade, humans can be tools, innit?
"MUSLIMS DID NOT: EXTERMINATE THE NATIVE PPL IN AMERICA , AUSTRALIA ,NEW ZEALAND ... EXT"
No, they exterminated the native people of other countries- convert, pay protection money, or die.
TurboDally 7 months ago
It doesn't seem compatible because it is not. Sharia is a barbaric medieval system that kept a bunch of barbarians in check. Western moral thinking does not mix with it, and never will. The day Sharia takes hold in a western nation is the day that nation gives up freedom and progress both morally and scientifically.
Judicial78 1 year ago
A headless, handless corpse formerly known as "Muhammed" would be the true prophet of Islam, had Islam undertaken its actual course set in Sharia. How befitting for a religion of DEATH be ruled by a corpse! Muslims should be like their prophet should have been and decapitate themselves. The other alternative is to LEAVE ISLAM. Oops! Muhammed's advice was to kill them in that case. What does he know, in any case. He's just a handless, headless corpse by his own reckoning.
jhall38 1 year ago
It would have been better had Muslims cut off the hand of Muhammed, the thief of desert caravans going to Mecca. Yes, Muhammed sans his right hand would have been a better model for would-be Muslims. (Let Muhammed eat food with the same hand with which he wipes his butt and conducts business. That's desert justice!) While Islam was at it, it might have beheaded Muhammed, since he was an adulterer and an apostate, having left his own religion for a new one he invented a la "abrogation".
jhall38 1 year ago
What???? A WOMAN DRIVING???? Where are my stones?????
karnubawax 1 year ago 16
@karnubawax Not in your underwear, for sure....
hamzah938 11 months ago
@karnubawax You may beat her with the rope which holds the table cloth your head!
RockStudioLive 8 months ago
@karnubawax Forgot about that rule. I will have to stone my sisters.
LLOYD19851012 7 months ago
First of all WHO ARE U TO DECIDE WHAT LAW should be followed in IRAQ??
Idiot
killerfrontline09 1 year ago
Am very disappointed of EXPERTS who attack sharia while there way of learning is resting there asses on the couch and just google it whatever shit is written.
Sharia is a whole study , but since you can't READ books
utube : "answers about sharia Q 1"
hope you see till Q 9
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim It doesn't take an expert to "attack" & dismantle Sharia. My free-thinking superstition-free 7 year old can do it in a moment. She uses simple fundamental human needs like compassion, mercy & equality; things which Islam is choking its medieval self without.
Youtube video ("sharia Q.9")?
Yes, he fits the Islamic 'expert' tag very well. The usual compassionless anti-humanitarian dogmatist giving excuses for the inexcusable. Myriad literature tells me the exact same sorry story.
blackmore4 1 year ago
@blackmore4 of course it doesn't take an expert , simply immature brainless people do that .
you have done like everyman summarizing sharia in cutting hands and eng / Fadel has refuted ur attacks ,,
so what ??"you" don't agree , it doesn't make any difference, my comment wasn't for you .
he made the video ,, message him discuss with him , if u r expert enough as u think .
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim No, it's not just me who doesn't agree with Sharia. Basic instinctive human traits like compassion and mercy tell me that those against include the majority of humanity. Another fundamental trait of human self-preservation, fear, means that the world's Muslims, who are threatened (legally by Sharia - or otherwise) with death for criticizing or wishing to leave such an 'ideology', are still not able to voice their true feelings.
blackmore4 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim No, I didn't mention "cutting hands" but your consideration of this criticism of Sharia as the "everyman" argument is very apt. Much as you try, you and every other deluded Quran-basher can't escape your own humanity. Once your brain is drained of fear & indoctrination, I feel sure that you'll join every other global tongue in attacking the Sharia murder of adulterers, gays & 'apostates'... as well as considering the limb amputation of thieves as the backward desert cruelty it is.
blackmore4 1 year ago
People, great news for you all. Find out just why thousands upon thousands are starting to realise how much they have been lied to for centuries and are now starting to leave this evil cult for the truth by visiting my channel.
ever1ast 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sharia Law is not compatible with civilized humans, period.
dummbatz48 1 year ago 17
@dummbatz48 yes u r right, if by civilized u mean allowing rapists to go free and abusive alcoholic fathers to get a spank on the rist over nighter in jail or to let cheating husbands/wifes just keep on cheating or to let people idolize th body of woman to the point of prostitution and every freakin comercial has a naked mother/daughter/sister/wife in it to sell the product then yes u r right. how civilized
FlawlysTheKing 10 months ago
@FlawlysTheKing
Well it's a good thing then that that's not what I mean by civilized people.
dummbatz48 10 months ago
@dummbatz48 well all of that goes on in the "greatist, most civilized COUNTRY" in the world so yeah
FlawlysTheKing 10 months ago
@FlawlysTheKing
I don't get what you're trying to say, just fucking say what you want and quit pussyfooting around it.
I never said any specific country was more civilized than others, but Sharia is not a pathway to being civilized, there, happy?
dummbatz48 10 months ago
@FlawlysTheKing All what goes on? Where? Be specific or go home.
RockStudioLive 8 months ago
what an insensitive video ... you know what law is compatible with iraqis , you just as an oppressing nation take every one u don't like put him in AbuGhraib Guantanmu whatever
and show them ur laws in prison ,, AND WE HAVE SEEN THESE LAWS ..
what gave u the right to invade a country that never harmed an american citizen ?and u do projects for the suitable system to rule it ..
But ur government has already forced the system on the people ..
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim Proud? Try conceited and closed. This person didn't plan any invasion or invade Iraq. With goodwill she asks some reasonable questions and you show the true colours of the 'great Islamic tradition of debate'.
Proud? Of what? Ill-manners?
blackmore4 1 year ago
@blackmore4 I am not attacking her cuz she is a good person ,, and there is something called SENSE you have killed 700 k people in Iraq and it was kinda mean to intervene more in this , right ??
so , my Islamic tradition doesn't satisfy you ,, but blood thirsty mass murderer traditions is good enough for you !!
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim So Healthyaddict is now off the hook and you've shifted the responsibility to me personally for the murder of "700k"? The real answer is much closer to home than you'd ever admit with Islamist factions responsible for up to between 80 & 90% of Muslim deaths.
So, not only does your "Islamic tradition" not "satisfy" me, its "blood thirsty mass murder" appalls humanity.
blackmore4 1 year ago
@blackmore4 Man !! you are talking nonsense ,, does it make when I say "you" that you have killed muslims in crusades ,, that you have converted jews and muslims in Spain by force
does it make that you ve travelled across places and slaughtered indigenous people like south america ,,
does it mean that you ve nuked japan
I say "you" cuz u stand for the west and hate islamic tradition which without islamic history no sciences would have been preserved .
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
@SoProudMuslim No, I don't "stand for the west", I stand for humanity and as such condemn the same genocides and nuclear slaughter as you. You see, I knew you had it in you! Just go that extra mile and stop stoning adulterers, hanging gays and beheading blasphemers and give women total legal equality with men and then we can conspire against the global corporations over tea :-)
blackmore4 1 year ago
@blackmore4 I am proud cuz you don't like Islamic tradition in which jews lived peacefully under Islamic THEOCRACY
and when christians ruled they escaped to wherever muslim land they could find because europe is a very TOLERANT place ,,, this is Islamic tradition .
Under Muslim theocracy there were debates going between an atheist (heretics) and a muslim in Baghdad ,,
the same time europe used to burn any one who say the earth is round as heretics
yes, I am proud of my islamic tradition
SoProudMuslim 1 year ago
white liberal women loves Sharia Law LOL
tacotony24 1 year ago
In short... NO!
But..
Can you justify driving while videotaping yourself?
FatRakoon 1 year ago
mohammed is example which all muslim (men) should follow. Quran as his book.
Democracy at certain times were limited to men in societies. so it is not a "modern" (the now, not back then) democracy if women are not given the same opportunities as men holding American democracy as the standard.
everything sharia is, our system is not.
VersatilityInfinite 1 year ago
democracy is a 'system' originated in Greece. Why are Americans dummies to learn this fact. What makes 'democracy' absolutely 'right' as though its a God given systes and so should be imposed by the West on others against their will? if Muslims choose 'Shariah' (Law of Allah, based on the Quran and teachings of Muhammad (pbuh), which of course is not much different than the Jewish Tanakh/Bible - then let people choose freely. Reason why people hate US is coz of your meddling and imposition.
robin4good 1 year ago
Sharia is good for society
Churruminonian 1 year ago
Vlog ing while driving, not wise, do your sex a favour and save it till you get home :)
beechy111111 1 year ago
I too am in columbus. my response is as a muslim i don't have to"justify shari'ah" i can explain it but i don't have to "justify" it. aspects of shari'ah are compatible with democracy as some aspects of democracy are compatible with shari'ah.
jihad68 1 year ago
they do not justify, they just cannot choose and only know taht they have to believe in that way of having "God"
no choice, no chance to choose
just because they live in a country where human rights are foreveryone they do not care about the sharia, it's is not for themselves!
gdililc 1 year ago
Sharia law will not be and will never be compatible with Democracy for several reasons, but one major reasons most overlook is that Democracy relies on secular discussion for value exploration, since Christian society leave exploration of the human nature (love and options) this gave birth to Democracy. Sharia law will never allow for exploration of secular values (real time values) thus may never be compatible with democracy.
Case in point the American constitution being an enabling text.
dibaterman 1 year ago
Sharia law is not comnpatible with democracy or any other western freedoms!
moonshineinsummer1 1 year ago
islam and peace go together like peanut butter and fish icream
Kinjaffa 1 year ago
The main objective of Sharia Law is to create a society in which the main motivation of people is not material gain, and individualism, but self improvement and collective success of the entire society. Instead of creating an economy based on competition and individualism Sharia Law focuses on creating a society based on equal distribution of wealth and collective thinking, a society in which people are not running in a rat-race for individual success but learn and work for collective success.
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@CreativeZed
Anbd I thought it was absolute submission to allah the moon god!
moonshineinsummer1 1 year ago
@CreativeZed
pisslam is the violation of human rights especially women and children. I am glad that western culture is watering down pisslam. Anyone who follows the ideas of a child rapist (dick be in him) is as bad as the rapist himslef!
moonshineinsummer1 1 year ago
@CreativeZed As long as you're not a woman or a dhimmi right?
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
The main thing common between democracy and Sharia Law is that the laws in both are defined democratically by the people living under these laws and they can be changed democratically in the same way. The main difference is that the principles of laws in Sharia are based on Islam. So Sharia Law can only be applied to a society in which the majority of people believe in Islam. Sharia Law is not meant to be enforced on a non-Muslim society.
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@CreativeZed Thats a massive load of bullshit and you either know it, or are drunk on the koolade
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
@TwyztdValkyrie No that is the truth brother. The countries that apply discriminatory laws today in the name of Islam are not actually applying Sharia Law, they are applying their "traditional laws". The principles of Sharia Law are based on the Quran and the Quran says that men and women are equal and does not prescribe any discriminatory law for non-Muslims.
Thanks!
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@CreativeZed Valkyrie = germanic warrior goddess. Im a woman. And discriminatory law IS sharia. You are cherry picking the one part of the quran where it states that all muslims are equal before allah. You also aren't mentioning the fact that women are seen, in the quran, as half a man, as the property of their fathers and husbands, as breeding chattle, as objects -- even in infancy -- for bartering. Those are not equal. AND dhimmitude is governed by sharia. You fail.
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
@TwyztdValkyrie Ok sis! with due respect I have to say that you have been misguided. Can you please quote to me the verses of the Quran which state that:
1. Women are half a man
2. Women are the property of their fathers
3. Women are the property of their husbands
4. Women are breeding cattle
5. Women are objects
6. Women can be used for bartering
7. Discriminatory laws for non-Muslims
Also can you tell me who did you learn Islam from? It will help me answer your questions.
Have a great day!
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@CreativeZed 1) A woman is worth one-half a man. 2:282
2+3) Men are in charge of women, because Allah made men to be better than women. Refuse to have sex with women from whom you fear rebellion, and scourge them. 4:34 [there are more, but this sums it up]
4) "Marry of the women, who seem good to you, two or three or four." 4:3
5) Have sex with your women whenever and as often as you like. 2:223
Women have rights that are similar to men, but men are "a degree above them." 2:228
continued
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
Comment removed
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
@CreativeZed
6) Instructions for exchanging wives 4:20
You may not forcibly inherit women, unless they flagrantly lewd. 4:19
7) Dhimmitude is the status that Islamic law, the Sharia, mandates for non-Muslims. Dhimmis, are free to practice their religion in a Sharia regime, but are made subject to a number of humiliating regulations designed to enforce the Qur'an's command that they "feel themselves subdued" (Sura 9:29).
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
@TwyztdValkyrie And who exactly did you learn the Quran from? You forgot to mention that.
Thank you!
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@TwyztdValkyrie Also can you read, write and understand Arabic?
CreativeZed 1 year ago
@CreativeZed Not forgot, not enough room and not important. I took religion in school, have studied theology has a hobby since childhood, was christian for quite awhile, my friend growing up was Muslim so I studied, I have studied islamic family law... shall I go on? I didnt realise I had to be a scholar to have a clear, studied opinion. I also didn't realise I had to know arabic to have an opinion. That would be like saying I have to know latin (which I do) to be allowed to critisize xtianity.
TwyztdValkyrie 1 year ago
@CreativeZed so you are admitting that the book for man for all man kind from the ultimate creator must and can only be understood in arabic??? Hello dude, there are more than 6000 languess in th world, why the hell would a god only make it understandable in one language? what a joke.
Takaja316 1 year ago
Not one of you fools answered the nice lady's question, How does a muslim reconcile sharia law when living in a democracy?
You all go off on theological debates and argue about meaningless rubbish. Is there one intelligent muslim out there that can focus on the question because I too am interested in the answer.
justpaul62 1 year ago
this woman starts with the foolish assumption that america has a democracy and that it can be exported to a nation like Iraq. america is a plutocracy devoted to greed, violence, and immorality. it invaded Iraq not to bring freedom but to advance its own geopolitical agenda. killing tens of thousands and sticking poor americans with huge amounts of debt. before america tries to remove the plank of sharia law from Iraq, maybe it should remove the plank in its own eye.
froberts7 1 year ago
@afridisworld - Who the hell told you to believe in hadith you dumb ass.
McChirkeen 1 year ago
Why does the civilized world keep trying to help these 9th century barbarians? Their are millions of them in America now, why? Ever been to an area thats loaded with them? The way they look at Americans , act toward Americans. They hate our guts, they smile in your face and want your throat cut.
1QuikTransAm 1 year ago
healthyaddict you have copy of the Quran read 6:150-152 that is what is required of the individual Muslim regardless of the geographical location.
As for the Iraqi constitution it need to be sharia compliant , so i suggest for the Iraqi
government to adopt U.S constitution and add one article that read the Quran is the Arbiter.
falcon02012 1 year ago
The women vote being half was due to the fact that the women in that time didn't get themselves involved in such situations. Due to their inexperience in situations being dealt with in the court their vote was considered half.
Study the whole concept of the Sharia law from proper sources and you won't need the explanation from Muslims.
icriosphinx 1 year ago
Are you seriously creating a video blog while driving?! I need to get better insurance. I think driving should more of a priority to you than Sharia at the time.
rickjack76 1 year ago
Shari'a: Islamic Law put together for Khilafat (meaning under one Islamic leader) in the muslim world. There is no justification for something that cannot be implemented.
NebulousEsoteric 1 year ago
Comment removed
Serge1965 1 year ago
@Serge1965 And you are God to say so? Repent for your prejudice and ignorance to your christ.
NebulousEsoteric 1 year ago
@Serge1965 Repent for your God complex ignorant kid.
NebulousEsoteric 1 year ago
@NebulousEsoteric You are the ignorant one, asshole! Not only is this chick prettier than you, she's smarter, too! You're obviously just jealous.
leomcallister9 1 year ago
@leomcallister9 Your an idiot.
NebulousEsoteric 1 year ago
Of course if the country is muslim and the government is muslim a sharia system is better. If you get a total understanding of a proper sharia system and run the country in a proper sharia system then you will see its benifits, we look at iran for instance im not having a go at them but you have to understand, that shia'ism is a very small minority of islam and there sharia understanding is different to the Sunni's which make up the majority of muslims' today over 95 %
JEMOMER 1 year ago
Sharia Law is not compatible with the Western way of life, and it's not right even to try to apply it here (in the West). Sharia Law is only compatible in a country which citizens are true muslims.
P.S. I am a muslim
JackSparrowDepp 1 year ago
Comment removed
talha6k 1 year ago
Comment removed
tony00165 1 year ago
You don't know the purpose of sharia law? I know. I also know why we have a home-grown terrorism.
juneride 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ironically Those Hadiths are Biblical ! ..FALSE INSERTIONS made by false Crypto(biblical scholars)disguised as muslims
See how they(Hadiths) CONTRADICT the Quran and on the same time FULLY COMPLY with the Bible?
Muhammad PBUH would NOT " SAY", "ACT",or " LEGISLATE" things that has NO signtaure LET ALONE CONTRADICT THE QURAN[69:44-50]
HONOUR KILLING IS IN BIBLE Deut22:13:29 NOT QURAN 24:1-2
WHAT IS MORE AUTHENTIC THAN QURAN ? ! ! !
Jesusthepalestinian 1 year ago
hehehe
JesusIsPalestinian77 1 year ago
@GODandPEACE - there was your mistake that you put Hadith at the same level as the quran. If you had rejected hadith as a deviant source and then read the quran you would have felt different.
McChirkeen 1 year ago
@AliAbdurRasheed - Get your head out of your ass and quit quoting this sort of propaganda. Democracy is older than Islam - it was developed by the Greeks. It was the rule of the land for the Romans. Islamic empires did not bring more enightenment because in the last 100 years the western countries have contributed more to development of humanity than all other previous empires.
Wake up, you and your hadith toting muslims screwed it up for all muslims and now it seems for all of humanity.
McChirkeen 1 year ago
@AliAbdurRasheed - Why don't you stick to your 1400 years of sound tradition and scholarship and remain immersed in the gutter of ignorance, believing in garbage for guidance. And, Hadith is 1200 years old i.e. Bukhari, Tirmidhi, Muslim (all of them were persians by the way) published their version around 1200 - 1250 years ago. And of course you have not studied the Quran in any sense otherwise you would have refrained from using the "Quran Only" term. go and read Quran 31:6
McChirkeen 1 year ago
@AliAbdurRasheed - Lack of knowledge does not refute a fact. Have you studied the Bible? Have you studied Hadith? Have you studied the books of Zoroastrians?. If not then do it and then opine.
McChirkeen 1 year ago
Im guessing anti islamic web sites are a regular visit to go crazy with the cutting and pasting...good luck...what good is knowledge when all you ever is focus and follow the "apperant negatives"...an unbiased individual who seeks knowledge would start with the truth, not "bukhary' what is that? cut and paste i can do that with any topic and make you all for it too...good luck with the hate campaign
beyzasmum 1 year ago
@AliAbdurRasheed
Allah condemns hadiths: Surah 7:185,12:111, 31:6, 45:6, 52:34, 68:44, 77:50
“These are the communications of Allah which We recite to you with truth; then in what saying (hadeethin) would they believe after Allah and His communications?” Surah 45:6
Allah is the best guidance, Allah explains: Surah 3:73, 4:26, 4:87,17:9, 25:32, 34:6, 39:23, 41:44, 45:6. 54:17,22,32,40, 56:75-81, 75:16-19, 77:50, 10:35, 7:3, 27:79, 33:3, 16:89
Way to reject the revelation of Allah.
Peace.
Surah72