Only Happy When It Rains (Live 2007)

[tallica4life07]

This is MUCH better than original. Metallica rules! :)

[Heuchler52]

@tallica4life07 No it's not. You don't compete with female rock vocal, or you die tired =)

But it's a very good cover.

I'm glad to see Metallica FINALLY to untighten their "chocolate starfishes" and play a good joke. 'cause inbefore, they've been friendly trolled by Blind Guardian, long time =)

[DanielMoselly]

Porra! Shirley canta essa música melhor que ele. Esse cara parece que está com dor estomacal.

[pinkdisney4ever]

All Metallica's cover songs are AWESOME ! \m/

[modusn]

Keep smashing the Snaredrum, Lars! Go for it......

[purestr4omar]

James Hetfield at his worst ?

[MrWWEThemeSongs1V2]

@purestr4omar <----- idiot at his best

[bliztrieg]

I think Garbage did a cover of this song =P

[rosieposiefoxburr]

@bliztrieg Garbage sings the original bro :D

[bliztrieg]

@rosieposiefoxburr lol ikr... i said that because this version is better.. lol

[TheSphereHunter]

@bliztrieg

You can't be fucking serious if you consider this country bs better.

[bliztrieg]

@TheSphereHunter not my problem if u dont like it -.-

and yes this version better

[sh856531]

Really cool - would love to see het mixing it up a bit more...

[deathtothemushroom]

no thanks I choose Garbage on this one

[darrenkills]

and then you remember metallica still sucks

[MrWWEThemeSongs1V2]

@darrenkills and then you should stfu

[gruponaya]

OMFG! O_o

[tallica1997655]

bets way

[JAPSCANTFLY]

Garbage

[QuickSpade]

Holy shit, the cover brings out a completely different side of the original. Both versions are great!

[krisgraves69]

!WTF!

[alvinhogoalkeeper]

and they say that james can't hit the E note -.- !!

[crystal186]

I prefer the original but still it's a damn good cover

[helloweenarctico]

XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD­DDD

[LemFly]

With video:

/watch?v=worctaQdArE

[Shuji4]

si metallica toco esta cancion, es por que a ellos tambien les gusta, y dejense de mamadas Garbage es lo mejor :D

[christiannandres]

hahaha terrible

[LarsUlrichFan1988]

People actually don't get the garbage joke? Come on :D

[CBRHurricane6]

@LarsUlrichFan1988 i got it,

theres way worse jokes out there,

example: Lada gaga now thats a bad joke HAHAHAHA

[MsMetallicaFan1996]

I didn't get Hetfields joke "Thats Garbage" untill I seen the featured video. "Garbage-- Only happy when it rains" A HA I GET IT NOW!!!

[MsMetallicaFan1996]

@ral008 OMG IT MAKES IT TEN TIMES BETTER!!!!! Thank you for the input!!!! From now that is how I am listening to this!!!

[TheNitzanHavoc]

James, you're one of my top 3 artists in history, you've helped raise me and turn me into a metal man... but this is below your level, below the MetallicA standard, you guys made one of the best covers in the world (Turn The Page), let Shirley do her thing and you do yours!

[virtuozis]

you are fucking idiots, this is the great cover



[wdowa94]

Really- he's voice is good, but not with this song, so much mystakes (detunes)

[metalblade80]

if this is garbage why you even watching it. METALLICA is kick ass band.

[coast3dg3]

@metalblade80 This is a cover of the band: Garbage. No-one is saying this is garbage (as in bad)

[ramacure]

como cagaron el tema aguante garbage fuera metallica

[tryptzerofanatic]

Metallica knows how to ruin a great song.

[xXxDaRealSlimShady]

METALLICA IS THE SHIT!!!!!

[iLoveIbanez1]

@xXxDaRealSlimShady What the fuck did you say? Then you have shitty life. Go fuck with justin bieber.

[Hotrodx199]

@iLoveIbanez1 He said IS THE SHIT not IS SHIT.

[ral008]

Play this along "Sounds of Rain and Thunder on the River" It makes it even better, no joking!! :D

[MrSnakepitSlash]

From who is the original ?

[ral008]

@MrSnakepitSlash Garbage

[mandsmsn]

@MrSnakepitSlash it's Garbage, a band with famale vocals

[norwinx3]

Metallica is soooooo fuckin good...they can play other bands's songs and put their stamp on it and yet its not overdone...this is certainly a good cover....

---Metallica forever!

[trv773]

I live for Metallica! have for 25 years! thanks guys, i only hope i can thank you one day

[Survivinator]

Nice Metallica cover of Garbage song. They are so diverse. Salute* 

[schleeff]

very poppy when it comes to good acustic evrybody is the same,everybody is pop

[CDoug25000]

Metallica covering garbage?!?! Metallica going acoustic? Look folks, I understand musicians grow in their musical understanding, but if you name your band Metallica and you created speed/thrash metal in the eighties it seems to me one would try to avoid acoustic (definitively unmetal) and morose poppy goth rock trash from garbage. Nothing respectable about that. Maybe they should rename their band "P****licka"

[garranto]

@CDoug25000 maybe you should go get your metal and shove it up your ass mate, they dont need your consent to do what they what want to do or play what they want to play. they left the thrash scene ever since the idea of load came i their heads. metallica are musicians, versatile and awesome. they can play thrash, rock, blues, or whatever they feel like playing. you dont rule over everything. your just a nobody. as am i. now would you kindly gtfo.

[dyeyzeee]

@CDoug25000 you know dude....so what if you don't like them....then don't fucking watch their vids..and besides i think they have the right to play what they want to play coz it's their band...not yours...so take your lame-ass, stupid comment and shove it up your ass...and in this video they are doing it for a benefit..that means for a GOOD CAUSE...so don't go hating them for doing something worthy, unlike you..you're a worthless piece of GARBAGE..

[Theshiggityshwa]

@CDoug25000 Fuck Metal. I listen to music.

[didkolol]

@Theshiggityshwa you contradict yourself bro. metal is the only music

[dyeyzeee]

You know what...this shows how versatile Metallica is..I mean some people hated them because they switched genres..but WTF it's music and they didn't confine their talent to only one style...they explored..and that's how they got so good and respected..

[dyeyzeee]

T.G.I.M. Thank God It's Metallica....

[TheAsh13ss]

Oh my God, this is killing me! Thank you God for creating Metallica!

[TheVicHardy]

Great cover....James always rocks....

[vladimir3886]

I wept with emotion when I heard this. One of my 100 favorite songs, and now performed by METALLICA! METALLICA Rocks!

[TheStapleZ]

James is a terrible singer, but his music always sounds good. I don't know why this is.

[Fedeleven]

@TheStapleZ He has his days, sometimes he's terrible, and sometimes he has an amazing voice.

[TheStapleZ]

@Fedeleven I recently was told that his voice got messed up from doing thrash way back when. Is that true?

[Fedeleven]

@TheStapleZ He pushed his throat a lot, specially in the first 12 years. He screamed a lot live, and didn't take care of his throat. Also, they played a lot of shows. It's quite strage the guy can still sing. That plus the fact that he is 47 years old so his voice is not the same.

[GorehamM20]

@TheStapleZ Somewhat true, James blew his voice box out during a performance back in the 80's. But he still sounds awesome to this day!

[Motorfixxxer]

@GorehamM20 while doing So What by the anti-nowhere league

[19511pino]

james fantastico

[DownBYOB]

"That was garbage..."

"NO, ¡REALLY!"



[patison4ik5]

Awesome! Never heard performances of songs of another bands by Metallica (besides Garage days, of course:))). Cool performance.

James's voice is Perfect.

[danieljos182]

This song' awesome and so are Metallica

[Daggerback]

Them kids from mid 70´s says hed´s the man.. he flikking is. Maver shakes his hand, while i steal his guitar..

[dspikey]

Shite....originals far better

[simosolo]

They took Garbage and made it METALLICA!

[04bulgakova]

This is better than Garbage.

[donny457]

a lot darker with James version

[stevenmarm]

I can't help but give respect  to James for having the balls to try something new, even of I don't agree much with it. Also I didn't realize he has a hell of range in singing

[666Dodik666]

awesome, sounds like its a metallica song for real

[jc096]

omg what if metallica coverd cee-lo green f**k you lol

[jc096]

god i love this song

[theJPguy]

I'm ok with this, it's a good cover, but it kinda bothers me that they played a pop song like this. It's cool, though.

[DangerousDan2]

@theJPguy I didn't know Garbage was pop..I thought they were Rock?!?!?

[theJPguy]

@DangerousDan2 Let's say Pop Rock. Back then Pop wasn't crap like nowadays.

[TheCanadianPrairies]

@theJPguy

What? Garbage is alternative rock!

[theJPguy]

@TheCanadianPrairies Well you know better, so I believe you

[deadaquarius]

@TheCanadianPrairies so what

[nawfalben44]

james kills me with this song

[zago18585]

When James sings songs from other band he gives her style and he sings them better than the original. for example Only Happy When It Rains, hole in the sky, prowler, detroit rock city,so what, killing time ect.

[Dgod13]

@zago18585 all the covers that he has done!!

[GabrielPomps]

nice jamess

[donmestrinho]

Only Metallica to make a chick song rock!!

[6aokan]

great to know they used a garbage song

[jimcorneliu]

oh.. james, james.. where are your vocals? good old times. always love Matallica!

[oddboatrc]

suddenly this became metallicas song for me:) who is garbage u know:) hehe

[6aokan]

@oddboatrc aa don't go rude brother

[oddboatrc]

@6aokan maby i said it wrong, the thing i ment was that when metallica plays another artists song its better (my oppinion) and more intresting to listen to. maybe his voice isnt as it used to be, but i dont care couse i know what metallica was and still are.

you now understand?

[destihado1]

Enough with this bulshit. They were supposed to call themselves Metallica. Where's metal?

[phpeni]

@destihado1 That's just their name, metallica is not limited to only playing metal. This is a great cover.

[Tassenalarm]

how nice it would be, seeing james playing

[jeramie1100]

Great song

[metalinita]

:) Lo dijo Shirley y lo dijo James!!

[metalinita]

:) Si no lo dice Shirley lo dice James...

[thelefthandpath]

james is amazing!

[C5rrr]

17 people are morons;p

[AnimeLoverOfMusic]

i fucking love this!!! cant get enough!!

[LagKnight1]

heh, im just 16, and when i imagine that in my life i will still be arround when those grate musicians will die, makes me sad, but eh, enjoy them as long as they will be arround to say what they have to say

[checho286]

@LagKnight1 you can die tomorrow my friend, don't forget that

[LagKnight1]

@checho286 verry true but they can die aswell tomarrow  or you .. or me .. or every 1 :p we cannot controll it and personally i don't even want to controll that

[distantworld]

Next they should also cover Cherry Lips lol

[ScarlettRoberts]

@distantworld LOL James Hetfield's strong voice like the sweet voice of shirley singin that... sorry but that It just Hilarious to me because that song is just too much pop LOL BUT I LOVE GARBAGE FOR LIVE! and metallica are great to... please dont kill me o_o

[Viperzep]

@ScarlettRoberts hahaha funny comment

[jazzspazz22]

Obviously people who don't appreciate the music of metallica do not know what real music is.

[ral008]

The day James dies, I die.

[umid95]

@ral008 remind me,i will kill myself too

[ral008]

@umid95 I will

[123MetallicA1234]

@ral008 the thing you said there, described my feelings while i heard to this song...

[coast3dg3]

@ral008 Gods don't die

[carlos50105]

it sounds like garbage

[tehkevxor1983]

@carlos50105 I see what you did there...

[metallicaboy123]

i have lost all faith and hope for humanity....why....why....why tallica....

[metallinacho]

dnt they have this on a dvd or something ?

[Bdh777]

Love both bands but this is just not good.

[Masterfighterx]

I wont leave this world without seen all four atleast 1 time and meet N' greet with them :)

[Noksvalo]

James is god!

[liquidmetall711]

@Noksvalo he's awesome but he's not God

[athlonbob]

@Noksvalo God is James

[metalpowerportugal]

Really awesome!

[wovenv2]

Garbage's version is nearly masochistic in my view. Garbage's version is having no hope, accepting that you have nothing good in front of you in life, and finding the sweetness and your own strength in that.

This is different, of course, don't mind it though.

[qwertysc666]

Shit man! James makes every song sound just AWESOME... Acoustic Metallica ROCKS! LOVE YOU METALLICA! Fucking THANKS for existing!

[thelefthandpath]

@qwertysc666 well said! best band ever!

[90kulu33]

i actually likes his singing on this, even tho it doesnt fit metallica, but it sounds great eitherway!

[ooponsecondthought]

So cool when they f**k up other tunes, but they'll sue you if they even think you remotely do their stuff. Awesome [NOT] band outdoing their time. How out of time and tune is this???

[JOSHSKORN]

this sounds horrible!

[tajtaj88]

Tak jeden z moich ulubionych koverow>

[cupcakkerobber]

its kinda weird seeing i mean hearing lol metallica playing garbage

[thelefthandpath]

Simple fuckin amazing! james is god!

[chloerials]

I was at this concert. It was better live :( i wish I could find A good recording

[Doedeljoris]

sorry guys.. i rather have them playing metal.. this truelly doesnt fit the voice..

[wallsy2010]

I think it would do but it's way too high for James, that's the problem.

[bartek180590]

Has Metallica ever covered any of Nickelback songs?

[elmasshop]

@bartek180590 no, but nickelback covered Metallica

[bartek180590]

Yeah, I know that, only though it worked another way around ;) Still, thx for the answer

[MetaRevealer]

Wow .. metallica are something else man..

those gods covered a song from garbage..

they are so respectable God bless u

[kmacmuzikmafia27]

Wow this is cool :)

[STEPPENMOON]

NOT as  GOD as hoped...

[Ritaliation]

@STEPPENMOON well just how GOD did you expect it to be?

[lawchihei]

That's awesome...Metallica cover Garbage!

[Theros91]

Why do my replies keep going to the top of the comments instead of under the person's comment I replied to???

[muzapstar]

yeah they do that for me too.

[Ibik]

yeah this is so Garbage, lol i love Metallica

[metallica4ev]

who is this originally by? and how is this garbage? i must love garbage a lot then

[ShowstoppinKid]

the original version is by Garbage.

[JustinTyme]

It is originally by Garbage.

[fksfjkdjfkdfdjfkdfdj]

interesting version

[butterandcheese92]

Well this is just pure garbage.

[dagerback]

Good one...

[Theros91]

terrible pun...

[butterandcheese92]

Do you know a better one?

[Theros91]

no puns are good :)

[butterandcheese92]

I would have to agree with you on that. But there's something about them that's just so hard to resist - for me at least.

[Theros91]

Exactly, puns are fun for the punner not the punned :p

[MAVERICKALP]

I won t leave this world without shaking hands with james

[JamesHetfield7]

James is pure awesomeness!

[LinkinParkRomania]

i won't leave it without playing one song with MetallicA

[metalheadjames45]

@MAVERICKALP i already did! i won a meet and greet with em in toronto :)

[MAVERICKALP]

@metalheadjames45 wow man that is quite cool thing !! But now I am working in sonisphere İstanbul concert ))) Still has a chance !!

[joaopfer]

@MAVERICKALP Been there, done that :P

[BitsOfYourFriendsOnU]

@MAVERICKALP i tell mysel that everyday

[Koindrank]

@MAVERICKALP Neither will I cause I allready have. :)

[jcamp84]

@MAVERICKALP I did it was over rated. Sort of like shaking hands with with a vice grip wraped in sand paper.

[Amy8Rob]

@MAVERICKALP

Now that you say this I am glad I had the chance to meet Metallica in 2006 at the Meet and greet. I will remember this day all my life. I shook hands with them and when I die I leave behind a guitar for the next generation that was signed by them on that very special day. God Bless Metallica and James Hetfield, they made a dream come true. They truly are my inspiration.

[MAVERICKALP]

A new approach ,a new form and the result is simply great..

[JamesHetfield7]

When MetallicA quits playing, is the day i quit buying music. Cause they r all i like. :]