Added: 1 year ago
From: TheHumanSlinky
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,052)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lol at the thumbs up that says she's the winner, but she actually didn't win. XD

  • this gives me chills. absolutely amazing.

  • It's 2012, Idol is back on (and I'm glad), but I'm still pissed at Randy for his self-indulgent, juvenile treatment of Haley last year. It was like the delinquent who scratches a beautiful automobile...just because he can! I don't expect him to own up publicly to his self-serving behavior, but I do hope he learned something from the fan reaction to his oh-so-obvious abuse of his judge's position and will behave himself more maturely this season. And, yes, Haley should have won, hands down.

  • Randy is a jealous fuck! watching this in 2012 and I'm still pissed;p

  • I haven't seen this video in forever. I forgot how rude Randy was to Haley the whole season. I was utterly shocked at his reaction to her singing all over again! When I just listened to it again I was like "Wow, how did she not win?!" Best season ever, all of the top 3 deserved to be there!

  • such a fantastic voice

  • speaking from the UK I have to say we do not have talent like you guys have over there in the UK. American idol makes our talent competitions look embarrasing. haley R is a great case in point. spell binding. Shocked Randy did nt get it.

  • "fallin" alicia keys

    

  • whats song name??

  • I LOVE HALEY SO MUCH :)

  • @renesme71901

    Grow the fuck up and practice good grammar, you lazy fuck.

  • @renesme71901 She is 10000 times hotter than you. No one cares that you hate her voice, she'll still go on to make her CD and become famous. It's called confidence by the way.. you know it's a good thing for people to have.. jealousy is ugly.

  • I love Haley Reinhart. She is amazing and I think that she should have won American Idol because she was the best. But, that is usaully how things happen. The ones that can really sing gets booted off while the ones that are not that strong wins it all. Same thing happen between Clay Aiken and Rubben Studdard. Ruben could not sing better than Clay but, in the end; It was Clay's career that went to the top and Rubben struggled.

  • Speaking of Pia. IMO, she ca only sing high notes. She has a problem singing in her low regimen(ms).

  • i don't like her voice here.

  • lauren scotty and pia are the best of the whole seaso.........

  • @drpepperwomen Pshh. Are you not watching this video? Haley is amazing and will go much farther than those three.

  • @drpepperwomen you have crap on your head. No arguing.

  • @halabrdave

    who ever this is needs to stop and i

    dont have crap on my head and for 1 i'm not

    Arguing

  • that move of his legs is so halley's,she is sexy with her attitude not only with her style and beauty

  • Cute

  • Keepin' it real? Didn't do much for you?

    .

    It made me a fan and I'm here more than 8 months later.

  • she hits high notes good!

    way better than rebecca black!

  • @99612052 HAH. I hope you're not insinuating that Rebecca Black can even be compared to this girl! :)

  • fantastic

  • She's got a mouth for honeycombs.

  • There is a new Haley Video in town...Posted by Casey Abrams (yes that Casey) -- -PierceAbrams- haley and Irvin Mayfield in new Orleans

    11 minutes of sublime perfection

  • @seker7 link pretty please, I need my haley pill

  • this is awsome and its coming from a white girl!

  • Sexy and can sing her ass off...

  • wow

  • WHO EVER SAY NO YOUR CAZY

  • OMG did you know that when James was eliminated the ratings of American idol actually went up, 0.5 million more viewers watched the top 3. But after Haley was eliminated, the finale actually lost 3 million viewers from the previous week. I mean really, if either Scotty or Lauren would've been eliminated that wouldn't happen because either way there is a country representant in the finale. But is Haley who actually brought up some millions of viewers. 

  • She is so sexy !

  • Amazing Haley.

  • omg i love this ! amazing job, she brought it all

  • hmm.. haley should go on x-factor :P even though she has a record contract.. haha LOVE U HALEY amazing job

  • @samtheashtondrums She certainly does seem to have what Simon calls the x factor. The complete package. Her stage presence is remarkable. That she is cute as can be does not hurt either.

  • @hgrebnesor Thank you. I have been saying that all along. Haley is the whole package. And yes she has IT or the X Factor just like you said. There are a lot of good singers. But Haley takes it to another level. She is not like all the other singers. She has a very unique voice and style that is amazing and just hers. She also has great stage presence and is adorable and very sensual. It all comes so naturally to her. I believe that she is destined for stardom.

  • @233roz All we need to do is keep the buzz up here - and when her cd drops we need to purchase it. Our job is simple. Haley has to do the hard part. Not to worry - I firmly believe she will

  • Randy should not be a judge. He is awful.

  • wtf Randy you r such a jackass

  • I'm just saying...Randy is so full of bullshit in general

  • woohooo--this is smokin' hot-n-sexy--go Haley!

  • Wether you are a sportsman, athlete, acter, model, musician or an artist trying to reach higher in your career, we have the right tools for you. Customize your profile with your personal pictures or use our video presentation feature to give a visual presentation of yourself. connectedstars! c.o.m

  • im so mad, why she dont won?

  • awesome vid

  • she did great job with this song....

  • he voice is so SEXY

  • if i agreed with you wed both be wrong*.* loved itt

    

  • Where the H did Randy get karaoke from. He must be brain dead and tone deaf. He would not know talent if it hit him in the face. I thought Haley sang great. What an exciting entertainer. This young lady is going to be a star.

  • Why all the other contestants appear soooo booooring ? Because Haley is a great performer and artist.

  • @solanjoe That's for sure. When Haley got eliminated the show got really boring. Haley is by far the best Idol ever. She owns the stage and her stage presence is phenomenal. What a great voice, she can sing everything and do it all so well. It still amazes me that this very talented rising star did not win AI this year. We can thank AI's crazy voting system for that. Haley is the real winner of AI 2011. We Haliens know that and soon the whole world will know it too.

  • people did not like Randy's comments and thus.... the ranking is affected... Haley is wonderful as usual.

  • I came.

  • AMAZING OMG LOVE!!!!!!!

  • funny how they got guys who can't even sing judging other singers...

  • this song made me her fan :) i fell in love with her growls here.

  • EXCELLENT, SHE IS THE WINNER

  • I thought Randy was unbelievably OFF on this one. Go Haley!!!

  • she should have won!

    but lil girls voted for the cute kid -_-

  • very good;)

  • I dont understand why haley fans rank this performance at the bottom... i love this

  • @kimtv5 You are completely right. That's because we Haley fans know better and is quality that matters. Of course I love this but is not her best. So at least me, I really dig for her top class stuff which she has showed she is capable of.

  • Her singing gives me goosebumps, she is sooo sexy, and voice is .. maaan..

    Wtf is wrong with America, why not her!

    Who the f* let J'lo judge American Idol??? Or judge anyone who can sing at all!! I can't even have a crap while listening to J'lo singing. daaaamn

  • I hate randy hes such and assss

  • Haley and Pia Toscano are the best ...

  • She was the only one who did good here! I loved this! Haley is amazing!

  • gosh im seriously in love with haley

    shes got it all

    the face

    the hair

    the voice and everything

  • Haley was my fave idol and she should have won AI but I gotta say this was her worst performance!!

  • 0:49 she looked exactly like alicia keys :|

  • @kensnicole33 i've noticed you're a lauren fan

    .........interesting

  • this wasn't her best though

  • Jennifer spot on judging here, what happened later on =(

  • @metalmania28 are you referring to that she didn't move well on stage later on? or that she needed to get out of her head? or it must be the trip on the Led Zep song you are talking about..

  • @halabrdave no im referring to jennifer not haley. what happened to jennifers judging later on.... she was great at judging here... and then later on.... all the judges judging went downhill...Haley did freaking amazing "later on".

  • this performance was underated.

  • boner achieved! O_o

  • I swear Jennifer and Steven should just judge the show themselves because Randy is just trying to be the Simon of the show. Lick my asshole out Randy. You suck and you don't know what the fuck your talking about. People like you in the industry are the reason why we have nothing but autotuned teeeny boppers who can't sing getting all the fame and fortune when they aren't deserving of it.

  • Fuck Randy... her vocals were on POINT. Like seriously  blow your "fantastic" music career out your ass. You obviously don't know shit.

  • i love her style, she sing so good really love it

  • i wish she won :(

  • f randy

  • she's overdoing it ! with a texan accent

  • When I watched people sing this song it was horrible because no one can do this song but when i saw her do this song i was shocked. this the best version cause her voice and her growl.

  • Keeping it real Randy is that you are an I D I O T judge ffs, Haley nailed this point blank jeez take that fucking cheeseburger outta your ear

  • Sexy & Sassy !

  • shut up randy

  • I give up

  • she looks like a lighter version of alicia keys LOL!

  • and why dont i hear hear her on radio?!?!?!?!

  • @TrueCountryCutie16

    You don't hear Haley on the radio because...

    One: You listen to country music stations.

    Two: Her signing was just officially announced today.

  • @LookingAtYouFool i had one of the most stupid moments ever when i commented this! i didn't see the 2011..kinda hard to miss though...well thanks for the info lol

  • how did she didn't pass to the hollywood week in season 9 ????

  • @deadfuckyou nope, i wish she did too she got 3rd place.. scotty mcreery won

  • RANDY STFU! LET THE OTHER JUDGES TALK! THIS SHOW IS NOT ABOUT YOU!!!

  • jennifer was on fire with the judging. it was the movements & performance vibe that distracted me... and good on jennifer for picking that out. cos thats how she improved. and jennifer also said right about the vocals we saw heaps of different things.

  • i'll be honest the first time i saw this i was like... the vocals were incredible and so unique... so i didnt get why she was such an underdog at the start.

  • i didnt think she was dat great i wanted kendra or lauren turner to make besides her because i thought she was weak shes sexy but im not a fan of her voice

  • @brandonneizman Sad to think that. She improved a lot very fast and gave actually the best performance of the season some weeks later. Eventually she became the best contestant since the top 7 and on she always gave the best performance of the night, got 4 standing ovations and received the support from celebrities and previous idols. And in the end she was totally screwed finishing third when she rocked it out at the top 3 night America went totally country. Now she has the haliens behind her.

  • damn she's greattttt

  • her voice gave me goosebumps shes great!!

  • Did she win the season?

  • @Deadfuckyou too bad.she came in third place.she should have won!!

  • @tedkawaii Thank you for your answer, in fact I'm french and I can't watch American Idol here... But, by seing that on the internet, I said "Oh my godness, this woman sings so well!" and I'm sure she'll have a great career!!

  • @Deadfuckyou I hope that so^^

  • Haley's Most Viewed Videos are being taken off youtube due to copyrights, and Nigel Lythgoe jealousy toward her popularity. Make sure we show him what "Hayliens" are all about make all her videos have a high view count!

  • @Tulsasparty575 the three octave thing is a rumour, no one knows for sure lol.maybe someoneshuld ask Haley!

  • Kendra [who sang this for her final solo] is sitting on the sideline saying, "Damn, I just got owned."

  • 1:41 DESASTER!!!

  • FAB - I miss seeing her every week. Randy was so wrong in his critique.

  • A post on AI site when this first aired: "I am hoping you will actually see this since there aren't 5 million comments yet...I have been waiting for so long for someone to sing that Alicia Keys song, and actually sing it to the amazing potential it has. Music moves me to the core, especially that song. I am very picky but you brought tears to me tonight, which is not an easy thing, I think you are absolutely amazing on so many different levels, and I pray for nothing but the best for you girl."

  • Comment removed

  • @msspringtime99 Howso? Ugh no reason to argue you're just an idiot

  • marry meeeeee!!!!!!! 

  • please somebody can tell me the name of this song?????

  • @isarathai

    Fallin' by the talented Alicia Keys. Haley's done her proud.

  • james durban is better

  • @honeydukes17 then go watch HIS videos as simple as that :)

  • @honeydukes17 I totally agree with you!!! James is SOOO much better and honestly i dont see how Hayley made it farther than James! James should have won this season!

  • @ChristinaMcd061493 James could have made it farther than Haley, but trust me he would not have made it to the finale. If Haley didn't, James couldn't have either. And that's just fucked up because both should've been finalists, with Haley winning of course. They both got screwed by the beloved country kids.

  • @halabrdave I think the finalists should have been James and Lauren or James and Casey. I dont really like Haley. Sorry I just dont but she did a GREAT job on "I Who Have Nothing". but the winner should have been James! He had the best voice out of all of them. Im not a country fan so yes I do agree with ur last sentence.

  • @ChristinaMcd061493 well, right now I'm getting used to the fact that Haley or James didn't win because they were looking for a country star this season and it is more than obvious. She actually was the one who made it farhter outside the country kids. And as you say, she did a GREAT job on "I Who Have Nothing", then she deserved and rightfully went through that week, when James was eliminated. That if the 2 were competing each other, in non-country American Idol Haley is first, James is second.

  • @ChristinaMcd061493

    "i dont see how Hayley made it farther than James!"

    She now has a record contract and James doesn't.

  • @LookingAtYouFool SO that doesnt mean ANYTHING! James will have a record contract too and James can sing way better! : )

  • @ChristinaMcd061493

    Except for that whole singing on pitch thing. James is a great showman. He needs to work on being more consistent vocally.

  • So hot. Nobody was close to her.

  • Instead of giving the pagent answer to that question she could of just broke into a gender adjusted chorus of "Money for Nothing" or "Rockstar".

  • So I had to watch this video again just to quote her: "I wanna be an inspiration, I wanna be a visionary for people in the world." Haha Haley you have no idea how much you have lived up to those words with your talent alone. And of course you will keep doing what you love and continue inspiring. You just Reinharted a lot of haliens! hehe

  • @chuggggggy

    "haliens"? thats not funny..

  • @ynotbeauty I didn't come up with that. In fact is posted in this same page and it's already a legit term on the internet. Would you like better "haleyians"?

  • How the hell Randy could call this karaoke is beyond me. The only thing I can figure is the that Randy is jealous of Haley because she is wearing that dress much better than he could.

  • Girl looks amazing here.

  • give this chick a couple of years to grow up and she'll be huge!!

  • love to see this chick and Alicia do this together

  • HALIENS: The next video in line for 1 Million veiws is God Bless the Child. Let's view as much as we can! Please give this a Thumbs Up so it can get to the top! Also, copy and paste this to all of Haley's videos to get the veiws up! Do this for our girl Haley! Thanks!!

  • Check it out!

    I who have nothing: 1,376,125 views

    House of the rising sun: 1,005,122 views

    Rolling in the deep: 2,328,547 views

    Benny and the jets: 1,395,879 views

    God bless the child: 792,782 views

    Total sales for EPs: 10K

    Haley's audition: 529,440 views

    You go girl! #dominating

  • Randy is a flipping idiot ! it was perfect

  • STFU, Randy! You are the ONLY judge who constantly talks OVER the other judges! You had your say, now let the other judges speak without your interrupting the and/or shouting over them! And stop with the "Yo, yo, yo" crap. We're sick of hearing it. I wish you'd quit. You bring NOTHING to the show. No one CARES what YOU think. You're a joke!

  • @pollutedyouth Yepp!

  • Love how she looks to the addiance when Randy starts in as if to say "did you not just give me a major standing O? Well get behind me and staighten this ass hole out!".

  • Randy, Geez! And when Jennifer says" get out of your head" didn't get that at all! I saw her give an audio-video lap dance. Maybe a stuck on herself PR and a gay guy couldn't get it. Steven thanked her for that performance. I would love to have a studio version of this. Miss Keys probably wouldn't go for it.

  • Randy has a huge jealous stick far up his ass

  • @Tulsasparty575 I think Haley does have an amazing voice. I do also think she overdoes it and often changes octaves and doesn't keep a steady key. I was simply saying that because her singing is sexy doesn't mean it is musically talented. That is all.

  • Wow Haley is so beautiful and her voice is just amazing and equally as sexy as she is. If you dont believe me listen to just the song and dont watch the video and you will see that her voice is amazing and just plain sexy.

  • damm! soo good!

  • Smokin' hot and ON key/tune/note or whatever you want to call it, they should've been dusting off the trophy for her that night; Randy can DIAF with his award-winning stupid comments; Haley was dead-on telling Randy to go fk himself and his ears.

  • her voice is so sexy!

  • Her growl is sexy. She is smokin hot. She should have won, she was the best out of the two boring country singers.

  • @bb321ful I love Lauren but I have to admit you write the words of truth

  • @Rahetor2 thank you and some people tell me that i speak the truth.

  • what is the fat ass Randy Jackson doing on the judge panel? it's like if the SYTYCD judges couldn't dance. His critique is stupid like he was deaf

  • o_____________o

  • wow,so cool, brilliant

  • Some of you guys on here need to differentiate between good singing on key and what's "sexy". This is not about who sings with the most sex appeal. It's about music.

  • KINDLY CHECK OUT LISA LEUSCHNER - MOST ROBBED CONTESTANT EVER IN AMERICAN IDOL HISTORY

  • @nikaledesma AGREED!!

  • Alot of the time with Haley, Randy was a complete MORON this year.

    I'm with Steven. That performance was sexy as hell, and there WERE some raspy Reinhart tones in there. Open your frikkin' ears.

  • Sharp!

    Very sharp!

    Randy esta comiendo mier......

  • the way she says "pleasure" is sooooooooooooooooooooooo sexy! :O

  • Pia is the best

  • Randy I think your meds needed adjusting on this night.