I'm more or less ignorant of biochemistry, so you'll have to pardon this, but what does a salt water droplet have to do with emergent life? I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just curious.
@butsgalore -- if the improbable is happening trillions of time over billions of years, it becomes inevitable. It's the law of large numbers in a way. It works with organic molecules too, but maybe that simulation is best kept on supercomputers.
NaCl...? So the sodium cations are forming nanoparticles? What's up with that? Shouldn't they repel? They don't even seem to be densely surrounded by the oxygen end of the waters.
And I guess the simulation is of a tiny droplet in a water vapor gas under zero gravity?
@Octoschizare Just speculation here, Not sure of the accuracy of the sim, but I think that as the Chlorine Ion is stripped away, The Sodium Ion must immediately bond with the nearest electrical charge. Be it several water molecules, or another Stripped sodium atom. (Which is more likely due to the fact that the sodium is in a dense crystal lattice.
The result behaves almost like blobs of oil and water on a quantum level. =\
@L00NGB00W Not to be picky... but all your charges are reversed. The oxygen end of water is a negative dipole due to it's electronegativity, ionic chlorine is negative (-1), ionic sodium is positive (+1).
@Octoschizare Oh that's fine. I was a little unsure. You're right.
I imagined that since the H portions of the molecule were balanced, they would be negative. Because their electrons were outermost.
But when you consider that those electrons are bound to the neigbouring O atom, then the (+) nucleus of the H atoms would be 'exposed', so to speak. And present a net positive charge.
My confusion stems from the fact that if you look closely, there are multiple blue spheres stuck together. Seeing that sodium chloride is a BCC structure, it would not make sense that multiple sodium atoms are clumped together. This also does not make sense because of the plus one charge the sodium has due to ionization due to the chlorine. Maybe there is something going on which I don't know about but it seems illogical to me that it is sodium.
@hobbitsarecool It is hard to say what the composition of the 'salt' is.
If you strip an electron away from a sodium atom, you're left with a full shell underneath. I don't see how they could bond together. Unless it's possible for a sodium atom to hold an ionic bond with eight others... I have no idea... but it sure is fun to speculate! ;)
@shlunko Errr... osmosis requires two solvents with different concentraions of a solud in it and a semipermeable membrane. Otherwise there is no osmosis because the liqiud can't balance out the concentration.
Or did i miss something quite important in the simulation?!
@derAnubis Errr... nope.avi -osmosis only requires a SINGLE SOLVENT with different concentrations of a SOLUTE and a semipermeable membrane. There is no requirement for there to be two solvents. Namely, this solvent is water; the different concentrations of the solutes, because of entropy & thermodynamics, cause an imbalance in water potential, forcing the solvent (not the solute, particularly in the case of larger molecules) to diffuse across the semipermeable membrane.
@derAnubis my apologies, what I saw was the attraction of water molecules to salt; the end product of osmosis. After sitting through a three hour biology exam the other day, my brain's ability to process this kind of simple data has become somewhat fuzzy.
Never the less you are indeed right, so thank you!
I'm more or less ignorant of biochemistry, so you'll have to pardon this, but what does a salt water droplet have to do with emergent life? I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just curious.
Emperorlawson 4 months ago
Thank the spagetti monster we have clever folks like you Thunderbr0 working on research for the good of us all! ;)
mamolian 4 months ago
I saw the hand of god in this. It was over in the right corner, next to a vibrating molecule. I swear!
saxmanchiro 4 months ago
Is this thunderf00t's second channel?
dXoverdteqprogress 4 months ago
@dXoverdteqprogress Yes. His beautyintheuniverse channel is another with great videos.
WickeDFate4 4 months ago
Looking forward to the videos you will be doing on self replicating life, fascinating stuff, can't wait! ~PG~
PaganGlade 4 months ago
this should be on the main channel!
mhale71 4 months ago
this reminds me of a heart for some reason
lostismyconstent 4 months ago
consider what we know today compared to a hundred years in the past, and what we will know in the future.
I love science, and the universe!
viicISrotcib 4 months ago
So is this how water breaks apart salts into their Constitution ions? This is pretty cool TF.
ilackedtheheart 4 months ago
When you see something like this, the "god must have done it" argument somehow fails even harder.
Vanja4life 4 months ago
Kevin is offended, he finds Sodium rather arrogant and insensitive.
DontTaseMeBro77 4 months ago
I will not click "Like" because I did not understand....
Paxmax 4 months ago
@Paxmax I will click "Like" for that very same reason.
tazer95 4 months ago
@tazer95 hehehe! each to it's own =o)
Paxmax 4 months ago
I don't see how this video can be used as an example of how the self replicating emergent life is more an inevitability than improbability.
It's nice to see the molecular dynamics of salt ions and water molecules though.
But not very related to self emergent life.
butsgalore 4 months ago 2
@butsgalore -- if the improbable is happening trillions of time over billions of years, it becomes inevitable. It's the law of large numbers in a way. It works with organic molecules too, but maybe that simulation is best kept on supercomputers.
virumoz 4 months ago
If this were to be "recorded" in "real time", how cold would this substance be?
FHomeBrew 4 months ago
NaCl...? So the sodium cations are forming nanoparticles? What's up with that? Shouldn't they repel? They don't even seem to be densely surrounded by the oxygen end of the waters.
And I guess the simulation is of a tiny droplet in a water vapor gas under zero gravity?
Octoschizare 4 months ago
@Octoschizare Just speculation here, Not sure of the accuracy of the sim, but I think that as the Chlorine Ion is stripped away, The Sodium Ion must immediately bond with the nearest electrical charge. Be it several water molecules, or another Stripped sodium atom. (Which is more likely due to the fact that the sodium is in a dense crystal lattice.
The result behaves almost like blobs of oil and water on a quantum level. =\
L00NGB00W 4 months ago
science is boring. I rather read stories.
TomValedro 4 months ago
What are the blue things? I can identify the water and the chlorine but the blue structures don't seem to be sodium.
hobbitsarecool 4 months ago
@hobbitsarecool I'm pretty sure that:
Red = O
White = H
Green = Cl
Blue = Na
If you look closely, you can see that:
The Red(+) is attracted to the Blue(-) Ion.
And that the White(-) is attracted to the Green(+) Ion.
Although I'm not sure why blue is clustering. I'd assume it's because Cl only has one empty valence electron.
L00NGB00W 4 months ago
@L00NGB00W Not to be picky... but all your charges are reversed. The oxygen end of water is a negative dipole due to it's electronegativity, ionic chlorine is negative (-1), ionic sodium is positive (+1).
Octoschizare 4 months ago
@Octoschizare Oh that's fine. I was a little unsure. You're right.
I imagined that since the H portions of the molecule were balanced, they would be negative. Because their electrons were outermost.
But when you consider that those electrons are bound to the neigbouring O atom, then the (+) nucleus of the H atoms would be 'exposed', so to speak. And present a net positive charge.
L00NGB00W 4 months ago
@L00NGB00W
My confusion stems from the fact that if you look closely, there are multiple blue spheres stuck together. Seeing that sodium chloride is a BCC structure, it would not make sense that multiple sodium atoms are clumped together. This also does not make sense because of the plus one charge the sodium has due to ionization due to the chlorine. Maybe there is something going on which I don't know about but it seems illogical to me that it is sodium.
hobbitsarecool 4 months ago
@hobbitsarecool It is hard to say what the composition of the 'salt' is.
If you strip an electron away from a sodium atom, you're left with a full shell underneath. I don't see how they could bond together. Unless it's possible for a sodium atom to hold an ionic bond with eight others... I have no idea... but it sure is fun to speculate! ;)
L00NGB00W 4 months ago
This kinda blows my mind. Something thats not "alive" and it has so much movement. Makes the border of alive and not alive so.... blurry.
barakuda1111 4 months ago 2
@barakuda1111 I agree man.
Halflifefan54 4 months ago
Always nice to see the simple things such as osmosis up close.
shlunko 4 months ago
@shlunko Errr... osmosis requires two solvents with different concentraions of a solud in it and a semipermeable membrane. Otherwise there is no osmosis because the liqiud can't balance out the concentration.
Or did i miss something quite important in the simulation?!
derAnubis 4 months ago
@derAnubis Errr... nope.avi -osmosis only requires a SINGLE SOLVENT with different concentrations of a SOLUTE and a semipermeable membrane. There is no requirement for there to be two solvents. Namely, this solvent is water; the different concentrations of the solutes, because of entropy & thermodynamics, cause an imbalance in water potential, forcing the solvent (not the solute, particularly in the case of larger molecules) to diffuse across the semipermeable membrane.
Mandalor91 4 months ago
@derAnubis my apologies, what I saw was the attraction of water molecules to salt; the end product of osmosis. After sitting through a three hour biology exam the other day, my brain's ability to process this kind of simple data has become somewhat fuzzy.
Never the less you are indeed right, so thank you!
shlunko 4 months ago
Suppose.. that little things, behaved very differently than anything big.
volound 4 months ago
@volound Such is the quandary betwixt Quantum Physics, and General Relativity
L00NGB00W 4 months ago
nice vid phil
MICKTAM12 4 months ago
Did you write this? It's an impressive simulation. Simple, but complicated at the same time.
Jallenbah 4 months ago
It's the FSM!
gspahr 4 months ago