Roger Waters at Coachella 2008: Dark Side of the Moon part 3

[brejo57]

David sings this song, not Roger. It's obvious, seeing as how the other guy has to come in and sing, because Roger doesn't even know the words.

[emboladoomeiodecampo]

Meu DEUS, que maravilha. Voltei uns trinta anos tempo, da minha bela e linda juventude.

[omarmhalilovic]

roger is best 4 ever

[777jones]

This version is fully completely awesome.

[JohnnyCreepy]

sound alot better than 90% of the new junk out there...

[bonghead420]

I did imagine this when I was 17, at the Denver Coliseum on April 22, 1975 on the "Wish You Were Here Tour". One of my best all time concerts that I have seen over my 51 years of age.

[MrQuintero79]

imagine this with david and rick it would have been amazing

[damsdams]

@MrQuintero79 And Nick ?

[Cindydelacruz9]

ha! i agree! nobody like david! :D

[celerno]

a ese guitarrista le faltan unos 500 kilogramos de la sencilles que le sobra a Gilmour.

[EspyerAZ]

I was fortunate enough to watch this with my own two eyes and hear it all echo within my highly enratptured brain, entirely intoxicated.

That is such a beautiful guitar.

[fcernig33]

Who is singing Richard's part?

[voodoochild1975]

That would be Jon Carin... how has also played with Pink Floyd along side Rick Wright... Jon is brilliant... but I really miss Richard

[jagalleg]

There is a good possibility that I would have soiled myself if i saw this live.

[splurtagious]

Their music will live on for generations to come if not forever. It speaks to the heart of the human condition of our era.

[jduran9123]

ahhh its all coming back to me..this was the greatest night of my life.

and the best part is i only live 5 minutes away from this festival :-)

[austin316brand]

god i wish i could relive this night w/ 10x more drugs. but 4 E pills worked out just fine. GOD I LOVE THIS ALBUM!!!!!!! life defining

[breathedarktimes]

Gilmour

[TheStrokesNirvana]

i was front row for his whole performance. Its so strong. I had chills and watery eyes the whole time.

[NateNoS]

lonchaney76 - That "Crap" your reffering to as Dark Side of the Moon is one of the best selling albums of all time... And I'm sorry your not in touch with your spiritual side, but maybe someday you'll get it like the rest of us.

[lonchaney76]

I'm convinced that the only people who listen to this crap are college students who believe they SHOULD like it to be cool right next to Bob Marley and the like. Roger always made crap music for people who do drugs who are always losers to begin with.

[rnwepc]

go listen to fall out boy

[holbop86]

you have no clue.

[Bluesub6]

This from a thirty year old man who listens to Marilon Manson and Prodigy. I doubt very much you have the slightest familiarity with Roger's music, and reading the comments in you profile, it sounds like you're a Bible-thumping war-lover with a boner for the Bush administration.

Go open a vein.

[SwingRiots]

This from a Marylin Manson fan...a blatant Alice Cooper rip off.

As Alice himself said-"he wears make up and has a girl's name. How original".

Tosser.

[KillTheTowelHeads]

fuck you asshole

you dont know the meaning of real music....fuck off and dont talk shit to people who do...

[janislmc]

i saw roger waters play the same set in houston 4 days ago. which i will say that i would have loved to see pink floyd, but the musicians playing with roger waters definatly pulled it off. roger is definatly one of the best musicians alive today.

[mattthedream]

why is there two bass players...no need

[petitelsd]

WOW.

[rockaires]

R Waters the ultimate and last Rock Hero. Peace.

[consciousmess]

Spell 'Syd' correctly please. And his name is actually Roger, just lke our friend Roger Waters.

[stingray1964]

Eat shit...did I spell that correctly!?

[consciousmess]

You did, well done! Now back to school for you.

[stingray1964]

ha! Rock on bro!!

[stingray1964]

Actually if we had studied Pink Floyd in school it would have been more interesting...

[stingray1964]

I've never seen Floyd with out Waters or Waters with out Floyd...but this seems like this is about as close as you're gonna get to the real thing...even though Floyd currently has more original memebers this somehow has more soul..? To me Waters is Floyd! I wonder which one Sid would like..?

[b1llygo4t]

waters tends to play songs he wrote, while pink floyd plays it all, i saw waters in 06 or 07 and iv seen a few live recordings, my favorite by far is pulse, the set is similar to that of waters, but not as much wall action (syd actualy only "wrote" comfortably numb on that movie/play/album, read the insert for "is there anybody out there?" its the wall live (from the 29 plays they did) they talk about how the wall was kinda waters' solo album. also roger lip syncs, while pink floyd does not.

[EFCthebest]

Syd didn't write Comfortably Numb as

b1llygoat suggests - Dave Gilmour wrote the music and Roger Waters the words-

[b1llygo4t]

sry, i got syd and gilmore mixed up, my bad. it is the only thing that he wrote on it tho

[DonZabu]

You have to give this band credit for their guitarist actually making me cry on the solo.

[anacrobat89]

Wow...brilliant! Roger Water is a genious! I have to say though, I missed David Gilmore's voice.

[earthsign74]

i miss David Gilmore's hair :D

heh.

[rocknrobin1231]

jonas brothers are way better than this shit

[JimXvr]

Cool mini- rototom kit on the intro there.  What can ya say, f'n Roger Waters as always.

[earthsign74]

what was with the roto-tom intro?! i thought he got a bit over enthusiastic.. nothing like the original.

Rogers pre-recorded voice sounded good too but how could a pre-recorded voice NOT sound good really.. I think Rogs voice suits Time.

[scottss7]

excuse him, he must be an artist or something

[earthsign74]

perhaps he was on methamphetamines! hehe. no no, it was just more-is-less for me is all..

Graham Broad (the drummer dude) has always had great technicality, but just not the right feel for Floyd songs i feel.

but i'm sure on the day it all sounded "cool" though :D

[wydawake]

I agree w u as 2 Graham's great percussion ability & technicality. The right feel for any 'PF' song can only be fulfilled by all 4 members who created the songs. Wish they will all get 2gether someday...

[3aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa]

His abilty is thare He has sthe feal for the floyd songs but he plays with his style .

In my opion he is the most udersetmed drumer of all time .

[EFCthebest]

I was talking to someone who saw him at Coachella and he was convinced there wasn't a vocal backing track -

[damsdams]

Imagine the challenge of the guitarist : "I must replace Gilmour !". Terrific !

[wydawake]

This is my all time fav. song from 'Dark Side'. IMHO 'D.G' guitar solo on this song is one of all time best guitar solo's. This Guy ain't 'DG' but he surely played that solo to perfection. Gr8 Guitarist. Who is He?

[sjice69]

Dave Kilminster on lead guitar and Snowy White on rhythm guitar on this song. Met Dave at a cd signing in NYC last year. Real nice guy, and great guitar player.

[basundra]

three day pass...

should have gotten the fucking three day pass...

thanks for recording EVERYTHING.  you are the coolest!!

[g6u6s5]

standing in 100 degree weather

for 11 hours straight

no food. little water.

sitting through all the bands.

just to be front row

of this amazing musical performance

by one of my heros.

i will remember this FOREVER.

[waxpkm]

no maems ...........

me cado con la pura presencia de roger waters aunk kisiera robarse el nombre de pink floyd

[W1tchingHour]

David Gilmore should have been there....nobody can play his riffs like he can. Shhhheeeit.

[kurtisblow3000]

yeah, if this was Pink Floyd playing it would be even cooler.

actually a lot cooler.

[babydollash]

Thanks for posting this! I was at Coachella and this was the best performance by far!

[tkswin2]

ohh ohhh ohhh, this is an amazing video

[echoes707]

hello my friend i was on the front of you that was fantastic concert

[knottythreadz]

THANK YOU EYENECKHOLE! For sending me this Clip of TIME. What a great reminder of how AWESOME Roger Waters was at Coachella 2008, and this happens to be my favorite all time song to test my speakers on! And I thank the person who put this on You Tube! Rock On!

[mog78]

awesome. thanks for posting. loves coach.08 and can't wait for coach.09!

[CocaC]

I love this song!!

[josh69706]

his set was absolutely amazing! better than that... no words can explain, really... i wish i was still at coachella!

[butterflyfmx]

EPIC

[mbbrightman]

Amazing

[sjice69]

Nice clip. If you like the Roger Waters/Pink Floyd stuff, check out some of my clips. I got a ton of stuff from his tour last year. One of the best tours that I have ever seen.

[ALVERMIC]

mag thank u sooo muchhh for putting the videos from yesterday, I couldnt go and I live 10 minutes away from the coachella fest, hating myself.

[mavidateeta]

Go ROGER! Whooo. roger sounds great.

"Thats my pig, hes a big mean pig isnt he? F**k Off pig." I still wish the floyd would reunite though.. it would be great to see them live one or five thousand more times.

[floyd1r]

BEST SONG EVER!!!!!