i would agree with most of what you just said, except myung doesnt shred well if he does then you never hear him so he doesnt play as fast as petrucci
(Sorry If you don't understand my english, 'cause I speak spanish...)Only Shit! That song was awesome!, the bassist is the best bassist I have ever heard, and the guitar was...........only crab! JAJA! I love it...I mean, the song, of course
Ihave a honest question. and i want and honest answer. wich is harder to play, the guitar or the bass. i think the guitar is but thats just my opinion
I have to say I think the bass would be harder at parts because during the fast parts the bass is right with the guitar, and has alot farther reaches. I dunno, just looks harder to me.
im gonna have to say bass for this one because the frets are WAAY farther apart and the strings are much harder to press down and they're farther apart. I play guitar and when i try to play a bass its just alot harder but as you play your instrument you get used to it and it becomes much easier so it just depends on what you play or who you are.
Neither. With bass you have to play with your fingers(if your a real bassist) and the frets are farther apart. With guitar there are more techniques like sweep picking(really hard), tapping and pinched harmonics. They are both difficult in there own ways.
i totally agree with you on that. i just want to say one thing about bass. some bands that play really fast stuff (like a lot of punk bands) make it impossible for bassists to play with just their fingers, and have to use a pick.
most bassists are lazy because if you look at them most are fat. not john myung. and the guitarist is either skinny or muscley. and the singer is a pretty boy with long hair. and the drummer is either always funny or someone with lots of hair.
What a great song! The intro sounds like the riff from Black Sabbath, the song - it's the same root-octave-tritone sequence. That thing during they do during the "Taking in the view from the outside..." section is really cool! They cut the second bar to 7 beats and stretch the next one to 9 - simple but it does trip you. DT rules man \m/
metallica = poop old metallica = metal pioneers dream theater = 2nd best band evar! (1st is not metallica to be clear) kirk hammet = awesome john petrucci = god james labrie = ridiculously good singer with an impressive vocal range james hetfield = unique mike portnoy = animal lars ulrich = crybaby john myung = learned to play bass before learning to speak perhaps jordan rudess = goofy dude haha dave mustaine = next president! my opinion = priceless
well I think he meant it becouse ifhe says he learned to play bass before learning to speak he means that john myung would have learned to play bass like when he was just a baby(not literally)
metallica is much better than this in my opinion. the singer of this band just ruins it for me. he's just not impressive. as for the guitars... who cares? the drums are what's impressive in this band. lars whoever can't come close to this drummer, based on studio recordings.
Actually a lot of Metallica stuff isn't 4/4. Particularly stuff on AJFA, but also on other albums. Leper Messiah is 5/4, Blackened is in 7/8 and 6/4, One is in 3/4, etc. The main difference is that Metallica songs are a lot of 4/4 with occasional "proggy" sections, whereas Dream Theater is non-stop prog (most songs).
for everyone talking about whos better, petrucci or kirk, to me people seem to be confusing speed and technique and flow, yes petrucci has a bit more speed than kirk in some riffs, but kirk has an amazing technique that you cant fid in many guitarists these days, kirk can be going slow or fast in a solo or riff , and garantee it will still be one of the best souding riffs you'll hear
i agree i like dream theater more then metallica but metallica are great and all there songs are solid and the 4/4 times they use may be basic but whats wrong with that and this is not 9/8 i would say 6/8 and some 4/4 times and no matter what the speed or how complex it is all that matters is if it sounds good am i right and metallica did a good job of that
i dont know about u but if it came to a fist fight i thing kirk would stab petrucci. its the only metal way to go. stop bitchin and listen cocksuckers.
To you guys saying that this sounds like Metallica. Well... I used to be a Metallica fan, and I'm a huge DT fan now. It's nothing like Metallica at all. First of all, Metallica plays 4/4. No exceptions. I'm guessing a lot of strange stuff like 9/8 and 15/16's here. Progressive, in other words. The musicianship of DT is so much superior to that of Metallica. Not to mention the solo. Could you even imagine Kirk playing that? No? That's what I thought. Now, you Metallica fans may flame me.
i'm sorry, i have to speak up. metallica is an awesome band, and as much as i like dream theater, i like metallica so much better. metallica revolutionized metal. they started a style of thrash that was so different and unique for its time. metallica created a style that most metal is based off of today. metallica has inspired many more bands than dream theater, and they've became legends. listen to a song like master of puppets, fade to black, or one, and maybe you'll understand.
Obviously you did not read my comment in it's entirely. I was a Metallica fan. I've heard all their songs a thousand times over. It's true that they revolutionized trash. But what about Dream Theater? One argues if the roots of todays progressive metal origins from Pink Floyd, Rush or DT. I have to say it's from PF. But DT brought it out in the world like no other band ever has. Both DT and Metallica are huge names in metal. But you can't deny that Petrucci plays better than Kirk..
in this song DT, defends their music and lyrics against the ones who accuse them of being so artificial and robotic and out of soul.. he says "where's your soul u cannot touch the way I play, or tell me what to say!"
I've really been into this song lately, it's so awesome anyway so ya thanks for posting this song, but kinda sucks its just a black background the whole time but i just listen to it anyway. DT Kicks ass btw
THIS SONG IS FUCKIN' AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dreamtheater just... ROCKS!
erzea 3 years ago
Song was amazing but the video was even better.
Skwigelf100 3 years ago 6
lol
vitrix69 3 years ago
yer ground braking shit lol
crazddrifterr 3 years ago
hhaha xD
Great song love it
szoko173 3 years ago 3
LOL yes the video was faaar better x]
AyeYirDa 3 years ago
lmao
BlackOsker 3 years ago
5:22
amazing
FireFromTheSky95 3 years ago 2
dude the guitars are ao deep!
JuventusAAR 3 years ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!!!!!!!!!!! this song is pop dawgin
SingingNerd16 3 years ago
sick solo
blackcloak666 3 years ago
dream theater (y)
supermatti 3 years ago
i LOVE this song..
Zel0fan 3 years ago
i love thisss
HotAssMchot 3 years ago
They'd be666666666666444444
LEGliddon 3 years ago
awesome guitar solo in this song!
surfthecrowd 3 years ago
lol I would say so myself.
BoY860 3 years ago
metal church by metal church have the same intro ..... idk!
rkdodz 3 years ago
i would agree with most of what you just said, except myung doesnt shred well if he does then you never hear him so he doesnt play as fast as petrucci
Tr1vium666 3 years ago 2
awesome song =)
flurppo 3 years ago 2
powerful bend like them
jaglebagle74 3 years ago
john myung is amazing. The only time ive really seen him use a pick was in the dark eternal night. There may be other times though.
harrisonthewiz 3 years ago
mike portnoy has redefined drumming. hes amazin
hockeyplaya774 3 years ago
aamzing song!
ArnoldStrong89 3 years ago
man these guys REALLY rock!!!
xterminator0202 3 years ago
lars is no crybaby ffs
rasmusandre 3 years ago
how many times would i tune my guitar down to get A E A D G B
FORSoulless 3 years ago
you drop 3 full steps from drop D
thats really low so get heavier strings on you guitar(Y)
qweasdzxcvfr123 3 years ago
(Sorry If you don't understand my english, 'cause I speak spanish...)Only Shit! That song was awesome!, the bassist is the best bassist I have ever heard, and the guitar was...........only crab! JAJA! I love it...I mean, the song, of course
gallardo2244 3 years ago
LOL you have to change your only shit to holy shit lol cuz you are saying that it sucks XD
Azakure 3 years ago
Only shit should be Holy shit.
Only crab should be Holy crap.
leak86 3 years ago 2
Ihave a honest question. and i want and honest answer. wich is harder to play, the guitar or the bass. i think the guitar is but thats just my opinion
FORSoulless 3 years ago
i think the guitar is too. u have more strings to work with and many picking techniques
mastermetal777 3 years ago
I've played this with my friend (he plays bass)
I have to say I think the bass would be harder at parts because during the fast parts the bass is right with the guitar, and has alot farther reaches. I dunno, just looks harder to me.
HellishWolf 3 years ago
im gonna have to say bass for this one because the frets are WAAY farther apart and the strings are much harder to press down and they're farther apart. I play guitar and when i try to play a bass its just alot harder but as you play your instrument you get used to it and it becomes much easier so it just depends on what you play or who you are.
qweasdzxcvfr123 3 years ago
Not only that, but this is played on a 6 string bass.
HellishWolf 3 years ago
I play it on a 4 string..
BandDprod 3 years ago
Um?
A facking Bass?
4-string guitars suck.
strypes 3 years ago
No shit a bass...
BandDprod 3 years ago
uhm, Well 4string isnt that bad
samreiu 3 years ago
4 strings don't suck, most bass players use them
FireFromTheSky95 3 years ago 4
Myung used a 4 String for Systematic Chaos..
oOoOViperOoOo 3 years ago
No he didn't.
He moved down from a 6 to a 5.
BandDprod 3 years ago
Neither. With bass you have to play with your fingers(if your a real bassist) and the frets are farther apart. With guitar there are more techniques like sweep picking(really hard), tapping and pinched harmonics. They are both difficult in there own ways.
harrisonthewiz 3 years ago
i totally agree with you on that. i just want to say one thing about bass. some bands that play really fast stuff (like a lot of punk bands) make it impossible for bassists to play with just their fingers, and have to use a pick.
ZeppelinRox5710 3 years ago
totally, but some people are lazy and aren't that dedicated to there instrument. Even john myung has to use a pick sometimes.
harrisonthewiz 3 years ago
totally. those are the bassists (actually, musicians in general) that suck =P
ZeppelinRox5710 3 years ago
most bassists are lazy because if you look at them most are fat. not john myung. and the guitarist is either skinny or muscley. and the singer is a pretty boy with long hair. and the drummer is either always funny or someone with lots of hair.
FistOfChaosTheBand 3 years ago
Tapping is also done on bass fyi
arQuest 3 years ago
you can do pinched harmonics on a bass. they just sound kinda horrible.
Zeverynth 3 years ago
haha no doubt
flipdeck1818 3 years ago
Yes i know, but not very often.
harrisonthewiz 3 years ago
hey! the pitch is higher than usual!
emmyellaleo 3 years ago
Awesome song. Sounds like Sabbath in the intro :D
TomBandfield 3 years ago
nothing is more metal than a augmented 4th there so evil sounding
thunderinblack 3 years ago 2
This song is Amazing!!!! and i like the vid xD
jaked416 3 years ago
dream theater has a lot more talent musically then tallica, but if it wasnt for tallica dream theater wouldnt be shit
fadeawaybaby 3 years ago
nice vid... if there was a vid
AFNYOAQIS 3 years ago
What a great song! The intro sounds like the riff from Black Sabbath, the song - it's the same root-octave-tritone sequence. That thing during they do during the "Taking in the view from the outside..." section is really cool! They cut the second bar to 7 beats and stretch the next one to 9 - simple but it does trip you. DT rules man \m/
ConcreteLake 3 years ago
I don't think metallica is as good as dream theater but that's just my opinion. I don't really like the ending of this song, though.
emmyellaleo 3 years ago
DaSupaFoo 3 years ago 9
lars isnt cry baby only cry baby in here is you idiot fucker
HeavyMetalDude95 3 years ago
Motherfucker!! John Myung is great bassist.
Tuloisboss 3 years ago
well I think he meant it becouse ifhe says he learned to play bass before learning to speak he means that john myung would have learned to play bass like when he was just a baby(not literally)
eagel1000 3 years ago
Oh, yeah. Thx man. I am sorry DaSupaFoo.
Tuloisboss 3 years ago
metallica is much better than this in my opinion. the singer of this band just ruins it for me. he's just not impressive. as for the guitars... who cares? the drums are what's impressive in this band. lars whoever can't come close to this drummer, based on studio recordings.
JJDarklink 3 years ago
fcking great song...first song i heard from DT
PumpMan92 3 years ago 4
Actually a lot of Metallica stuff isn't 4/4. Particularly stuff on AJFA, but also on other albums. Leper Messiah is 5/4, Blackened is in 7/8 and 6/4, One is in 3/4, etc. The main difference is that Metallica songs are a lot of 4/4 with occasional "proggy" sections, whereas Dream Theater is non-stop prog (most songs).
Kneescrape911 3 years ago
Wtf. 99% of this is 4/4. no 6/8s or 9/8s here.
triggahfingah 3 years ago
for everyone talking about whos better, petrucci or kirk, to me people seem to be confusing speed and technique and flow, yes petrucci has a bit more speed than kirk in some riffs, but kirk has an amazing technique that you cant fid in many guitarists these days, kirk can be going slow or fast in a solo or riff , and garantee it will still be one of the best souding riffs you'll hear
hereticsway 3 years ago
i agree i like dream theater more then metallica but metallica are great and all there songs are solid and the 4/4 times they use may be basic but whats wrong with that and this is not 9/8 i would say 6/8 and some 4/4 times and no matter what the speed or how complex it is all that matters is if it sounds good am i right and metallica did a good job of that
brad3910 3 years ago
and btw, petrucci is a MUCH better guitar player than kirk hammett will ever be
fuel126 3 years ago 4
remind me again who sold out after 4 albums? thats really pathetic
fuel126 3 years ago 2
i dont know about u but if it came to a fist fight i thing kirk would stab petrucci. its the only metal way to go. stop bitchin and listen cocksuckers.
ihateyourface456 3 years ago
i agree with eareshel petrucci is alot better than kirk hammett
guitarman812 3 years ago 2
This band deserves WAY more fame than it has.
But well, that's real metal for you.
PeaceNirvana1912 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs down =D
cBkBoBo 3 years ago
to:
PeaceNirvana1912
haha
just kidding =D
Great song thumb down to you xD
cBkBoBo 3 years ago
O_o
Weird.
You're pretty weird, man.
=D
PeaceNirvana1912 3 years ago
To you guys saying that this sounds like Metallica. Well... I used to be a Metallica fan, and I'm a huge DT fan now. It's nothing like Metallica at all. First of all, Metallica plays 4/4. No exceptions. I'm guessing a lot of strange stuff like 9/8 and 15/16's here. Progressive, in other words. The musicianship of DT is so much superior to that of Metallica. Not to mention the solo. Could you even imagine Kirk playing that? No? That's what I thought. Now, you Metallica fans may flame me.
eareshel 3 years ago
totally agree with you man...
k1ng92 3 years ago
i'm sorry, i have to speak up. metallica is an awesome band, and as much as i like dream theater, i like metallica so much better. metallica revolutionized metal. they started a style of thrash that was so different and unique for its time. metallica created a style that most metal is based off of today. metallica has inspired many more bands than dream theater, and they've became legends. listen to a song like master of puppets, fade to black, or one, and maybe you'll understand.
darkfiend3792 3 years ago
Obviously you did not read my comment in it's entirely. I was a Metallica fan. I've heard all their songs a thousand times over. It's true that they revolutionized trash. But what about Dream Theater? One argues if the roots of todays progressive metal origins from Pink Floyd, Rush or DT. I have to say it's from PF. But DT brought it out in the world like no other band ever has. Both DT and Metallica are huge names in metal. But you can't deny that Petrucci plays better than Kirk..
eareshel 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i always wonder why DT fans just don t go in their kitchen and turn on their electric mixer instead of buying the "new supercool DT album"
Nickhating 3 years ago
ow nice clip man
gielomir2 3 years ago
ace
klakkaros 3 years ago
solo fucking OWNS!
TheDirtyProduction 3 years ago 7
Dream theater was influenced by Metallica and Black sabbath, but this clearly is the DT sound.
metallicpark 3 years ago
I thought it was a metallica song first time I heard it :))
mrkiky 3 years ago
I thought your mom was a Metallica song the first time I heard it (this is why my friends don't let me tell "your mom" jokes anymore).
darkfiend3792 3 years ago 3
osso
grindmaggots666 3 years ago
in this song DT, defends their music and lyrics against the ones who accuse them of being so artificial and robotic and out of soul.. he says "where's your soul u cannot touch the way I play, or tell me what to say!"
DT FUCKS OUR WORLD.
amromoussalol 3 years ago 9
RIGHT ON MAN RIGHT ON!!!!
drloveskittles 3 years ago
Kick ass song
eXtremegamer09 3 years ago 3
Hey, where's the picture?
alwrig 3 years ago
No, that guitar sounds like Dream Theater.
Tuloisboss 3 years ago 6
The guitar sounds like a guitar!
RayTheMetalGuy 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow this guitar sounds exactly like metallica
deanpubert 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song kicks ass!!!
intensivecarexxx 3 years ago 2
man..every single member of this band are seriously talented at what they do..aside from petrucci,my favorite member is the bassist..
15viceandvirtues 3 years ago
I <3 THIS SONG!!!!!
XphantomXofXtheXoper 3 years ago
No Picktures? By the way
1. As I Am
2. This Dying Soul
3. Stream Of Consciousness
TOT best of.
Tuloisboss 3 years ago
Don't forget Endless Sacrifice!
archonio 3 years ago
That´s very great!
arisch1990 3 years ago
Definitely one of Dream Theater's best. Right up there with Finally Free with it's nasty drum solo.
mineslonger 3 years ago
nice song.. fantastic solo.. the riff n that sounds pretty much like a Metallica song..
MusicRapid 3 years ago 2
a lot in this song reminds me of metallica.
haircut74 3 years ago 2
o my dog , it's true ! XD
Alkemi0 3 years ago
Dream Theater are very influenced by Metallica, and they say so themselves.
archonio 3 years ago 4
well, for me intro riff sounds like black sabbath...
Cyvil 3 years ago 2
im agree whit you
metalmaster1992 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
damn this song
xcute22 3 years ago
what do you mean??..
MusicRapid 3 years ago
on train of thought, as i am ties with this dying soul. both are awesome songs.
snowboardingfreak94 3 years ago
I think Endless Sacrifice and Stream of Consciousness are great, too!
archonio 3 years ago 2
fucking awesome song
rafaelr 3 years ago
im learning it on guitar :D:D:D:D:D
Emosrulechavssuck 3 years ago
Have fun, the first two riffs are fun as hell to play.
Garganthanon 3 years ago
i know, the verse riff is orgasmic [: am onto the solo now
Emosrulechavssuck 3 years ago
This whole album is pretty fun to play. Got some nice heavy riffs for DT, I always end up going back to this album, it's the metalhead in me...
Garganthanon 3 years ago
I love this song.
360ths 3 years ago
I've really been into this song lately, it's so awesome anyway so ya thanks for posting this song, but kinda sucks its just a black background the whole time but i just listen to it anyway. DT Kicks ass btw
someidiot001 3 years ago
i mean song not dong hahahaha
x0w0lf 3 years ago
dude thx for putting this on great dong =P
but...
why dident you make a mix clip?
x0w0lf 3 years ago
thankyou for puttin a non live version of this song haha !! finally haha
MrMoteef 4 years ago 5
fucking headbang song love it
mtrcurse 4 years ago 3
I love This Fuckin Song Thanx $ putting it up this songs the shit rock on
thaserialkilla74 4 years ago 4