saw Paul in a bar in Nantes a few years ago now and he was brilliant, a few of us stood with him and sang a couple of Queen songs with him, what a great guy
@Zeubrahagra it's not about speaking english, because most of them actually know english better than majority of Americans (I'm one myself), it's just.......they're german
@terra1492 yeah i used to live in germany and you have to admit germans can be really reserved, until they have one schnapps too many, then whoah hell yeah they can party... they clearly needed a few more schnapps on this particular day... bet they were all crawling out of the door by the end of the night though... lol
Yes I can. The Band played with Paul only once on this special Event. There was only one short Rehearsal with Paul. Guitar: Ingo Sandhofen, Bass: Raoul Walton, Drums Andreas Keller, Piano Martin Schmitt, Organ, Heinrich Haas.
Im sad that Pauls not using his voice fully.....he dosent take the higher notes and reach out the scale...är besviken på att han inte sjunger ut och tar dem högre noterna där man verkligen kan njuta av hans härliga röst!
What's with that audience??, lame clapping and head swinging twits, ('twits', that was not a typing error). Brilliant tight band with Paul. PAUL, WHEN ARE YOU COMING TO AUSTRALIA?? Great clip spoilt only by that audience.
I am now into double figures the times I have seen Mr Carrack perform live. Without doubt I would recommend his live concerts to anyone, If you are appreciative of good music performed by an accomplished song-writer, musician and singer, who is aided by an incredibly talented band then don't miss-out.
What a great song! What a shitty audience! Either clap on the one and the three or the two and the four. Not that hard! As much rhythm as the Republican National Convention. How about dancing? Or at least standing up? Testament to how good a musician this guy is that he rocked it the whole way through without letting the lousiness of this crowd distract him.
Nice... mellow and melancholy at the same time! Smoooooth vocals! Lyrics remind me of Kenny Wayne Sheperd's "Last Goodbye". Is this guy touring the East Coast anytime soon?
@amanyttap Baden-Baden..... was ertwartest du? Sekt und teure Klamotten. Die haben wahrscheinlich gar nicht gewusst was die da für Musik machen (da sie nur Opernsänger und ein paar Dirigenten kennen). Viel zu fein für erstklassige Soul/R'n'B musik noch dazu mit einer fetten Hammond B3 auf der Bühne (die dachten sicher, das sei ein Chuppendale-Möbelstück) ;-)
@MrKnopf sorry, but the audience is typically carrack! boston.. supertramp... phil collins... what do you think the audience has to be like or look like?
Paul Carrack is one of the best soul singers we have performing today. Its a from teh heart and the lyrics resonate with you as you groove to the music
in germany it's pretty unusual to sit while listening to live music.
Rock concerts are almost always in front of a standing crowd. I guess that's why sitting puts us into "critic"-mode. You almost expect some opera or classical piece. Rocking and sitting at the same time? MINDEXPLOSION.
The audience are sitting around tables with each other - not a typical concert, if they wanted to join in they would be singing at their friends and I imagine a lot of people would find that inhibiting - I would.
This is one of my fav. songs of all time and I am definitely diggin' this live version, very relaxed. Haha poor girl @ 1:07 she's wondering why everyone else isn't grooving along and swaying with the music... I would have been for sure! Nice job Paul!
Totally agree. This is an authentic, excellent pop song. I remember when it was released in '95. We gave it a ton of airplay on KSCB. Remains one of my favorites. Should have been a much bigger hit but unfortunatley the radio programmers wont touch it due to hip-hop and teens being in a younger demo that would not attract attention to this legend.
@MonoCabron123 Yeah, no shit... this guy is probably one of the few singers left that don't need any kind of voice modifications to actually get a good tone out of their mouths lol.
Great performance indeed
max3cube 6 days ago
my hero
koltonliveband 1 month ago
What a voice!
MojaveAmps 1 month ago
Fucking apathetic audience. APPRECIATE THE GENIUS BEFORE YOU!
liammccabe05 1 month ago
@liammccabe05 here here !!
koltonliveband 1 month ago
to mourn and piss
pakitovillanueva 1 month ago
Another great song by Paul.Carrack.
Good audience: they were there to see Paul Carrack. All audiences are different. they are German and they enjoy it enormously in their own way
Thanks for upload.
soundspur 1 month ago
I wish Paul Carrack were my dad!!!
Assan25y 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
CLAP FAIL 0:34-0:39
:)
RobRoj9987 2 months ago
Comment removed
RobRoj9987 2 months ago
Die Klatscher (die immer klatschen müssen, auch ohne den Takt zu treffen)von Musikantenstadel waren auch kurz da!!
micheloderso 3 months ago
saw Paul in a bar in Nantes a few years ago now and he was brilliant, a few of us stood with him and sang a couple of Queen songs with him, what a great guy
monty1105 5 months ago 3
Bad audience..
Zeubrahagra 6 months ago
@Zeubrahagra they're german
gathalion7 6 months ago
@gathalion7 I know, but it's not complicated to clap your hands and sing "oooover my shouldeeers !"
Even if you don't speak english
Zeubrahagra 6 months ago
@Zeubrahagra it's not about speaking english, because most of them actually know english better than majority of Americans (I'm one myself), it's just.......they're german
gathalion7 5 months ago 2
Carrack plays Gibson, that´s good to know!
good whistler, PC
2508wolfman 6 months ago
That quilted maple Bass guitar is gorgeous
n2motocross 6 months ago 2
Hes voice is so pure! These days the song never sounds as good when they sing in live.... This one sounds the same as the video!
4743stephenf 6 months ago 2
Memories of my childhood :) great song really !
bizholix 7 months ago
crowd look german.. awesome performance though and great live band
babybrowneyes10101 8 months ago in playlist Paul Carrack
@babybrowneyes10101
they look like cliché germans ^^ Being german myself I just cant understand why they dont dance and sing along with him.
worst thing is they are german thats why he says 'vielen dank, dankeschön' in the end ^^
terra1492 7 months ago
@terra1492 yeah i used to live in germany and you have to admit germans can be really reserved, until they have one schnapps too many, then whoah hell yeah they can party... they clearly needed a few more schnapps on this particular day... bet they were all crawling out of the door by the end of the night though... lol
babybrowneyes10101 7 months ago 2
@ma9th.........Thankyou for that.Youre a star!
mikejgibbons 8 months ago
Yes I can. The Band played with Paul only once on this special Event. There was only one short Rehearsal with Paul. Guitar: Ingo Sandhofen, Bass: Raoul Walton, Drums Andreas Keller, Piano Martin Schmitt, Organ, Heinrich Haas.
ma9th 8 months ago 6
Can anybody please tell me the names of the musicians in Pauls band?They are fantastic!
mikejgibbons 8 months ago
nice gibson gitter, Paul!
2508wolfman 8 months ago
what a voice , amazing !
juampixx 8 months ago
OMG what a retarded crowd lmao
there like a very badly dubbed film
ooo i couldn't possibly sing along.
To much god dam money.
sunhouse76 8 months ago 2
This has to be the most unresponant audience ever!!!!! It's unreal!!!
Rachimaker 9 months ago
This has to be the most unrespondant audience ever!!! It's unreal!!!
Rachimaker 9 months ago
outstanding performance!!!!!!
rikikocev 9 months ago
That crowd dont deserve to hear such talent....
portugal88 9 months ago 3
Im sad that Pauls not using his voice fully.....he dosent take the higher notes and reach out the scale...är besviken på att han inte sjunger ut och tar dem högre noterna där man verkligen kan njuta av hans härliga röst!
grubbelkillen 9 months ago
Jag är besviken på att paul mesar med sin röst...han kan ju så mycket bättre!
grubbelkillen 9 months ago
The Crowd sucks-.- Hey it´s Paul Carrak!!! Move your Ass :D!!!
Fliegerfabi91 10 months ago
@Fliegerfabi91 Carrack ! sorry^^
Fliegerfabi91 10 months ago
Thank God that we're living in the Paul Carrack age!!!!!
grotebonne 10 months ago
Amo essa musica.......
fabizinha83 10 months ago
A great song. I like it.
valsmith706 11 months ago
een geweldig nummer
ottoandre1959 11 months ago
i didn't know Tony Soprano could sing..
manucarlos751 11 months ago
He's not one of the best- he is THE BEST! Not bad for a Sheffield Wednesday fan either (I'm a Sheffield United fan).
croftonblade 1 year ago
muito boA mesmo essa música .......
marcos25041 1 year ago
Paul Carrack's still an amazing musician.....
npeg76 1 year ago
21 people need to put the hearing aid to the ON position !!....
MrNoble76 1 year ago
amazing song 0.o from portugal
MrXxExtremxX 1 year ago
Jeez: cockroaches and this audience- the only thing that will be unmoved by a nuclear war. Fabulous song!
slaphead99uk 1 year ago
are the crowd MP's?
mertz123 1 year ago
What's with that audience??, lame clapping and head swinging twits, ('twits', that was not a typing error). Brilliant tight band with Paul. PAUL, WHEN ARE YOU COMING TO AUSTRALIA?? Great clip spoilt only by that audience.
stevesmahalo 1 year ago
This fella is massively unknown but should be hugely better rated, pure genious and amazing singing voice
patrick2504 1 year ago
great tune!
manjulabambula 1 year ago
I love this song since I was a child... :D
Molybutty 1 year ago
one of my favourite songs(=
LasDivinasChannel612 1 year ago 20
The audience need a rocket up their backsides!!
You`re brilliant Paul. See you in Glasgow Feb 2010. You`ll hear me from the back of the hall! xxx
bonniekilty 1 year ago 3
lol... I had the same impression! -.-'
ju4n1nh4 1 year ago
this takes me back - love this song
simonkaracinski 1 year ago
But at the end, the dead livings wake up!
limuswin 1 year ago
to Limuswin: what did you expect? they are drunken germans! hahaha!
Abdelmoutalib 1 year ago
@Abdelmoutalib but I think someone put drugs on their beers
limuswin 1 year ago
Comment removed
MasterMikeyie 1 year ago
What did they put in the audience's drinks? What a lame crowd.
hockeytown49341 1 year ago 2
paulllllllllllllllllllllllll,my favoroite
giuliakizz 1 year ago
i think the public is dead :p
douwehandbal 1 year ago 3
so great,bacio cla
giuliakizz 1 year ago
love you paul
giuliakizz 1 year ago
I am now into double figures the times I have seen Mr Carrack perform live. Without doubt I would recommend his live concerts to anyone, If you are appreciative of good music performed by an accomplished song-writer, musician and singer, who is aided by an incredibly talented band then don't miss-out.
teabag3339 1 year ago
What a wank audience
Yklip91 1 year ago 2
hihihihihi .... zingen ze nou mee of niet?! tjonge...tuff crowd :s
lisetteberkeveld 1 year ago
4:02 Worst Crowd ever.
MonoCabron123 1 year ago 3
Crowd must be on tranqs. Just too good !
whenairhitsyourbrain 1 year ago 3
This song is a real refreshment to the soul.
timmhg 1 year ago
Im 17 but fortunately ive got good taste in music ;) I LOVE PAUL CARRACK D: and mike and the mechanics in face<3 5*****
FRUITBATmusic 1 year ago 2
@FRUITBATmusic Hmmmm .... 17 going on 40! :o) Good on ya, mate!
harryf200 1 year ago
WHAT A TALENT !!!!! WHAT A TERRIBLE CROWD !!!!! LIKE PLAYING TO THE DEAD !!!!
thundermoon123 1 year ago 2
@thundermoon123 Yeah, that crowd was a bad 'un, bad 'un ...
harryf200 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@thundermoon123 Yeah, that crowd was a bad 'un, bad 'un ...
harryf200 1 year ago
What a great song! What a shitty audience! Either clap on the one and the three or the two and the four. Not that hard! As much rhythm as the Republican National Convention. How about dancing? Or at least standing up? Testament to how good a musician this guy is that he rocked it the whole way through without letting the lousiness of this crowd distract him.
jafrocubic 1 year ago 2
Wonderful !!
ProjectEnigma1 1 year ago
its just fucking awesome! what a voice!
arschinator 1 year ago 2
i would ve been on my feet for this one!
zezebestor 1 year ago
this crowd does nt deserve this performance
npscholes 1 year ago 3
So sensitive and hartbreaking this song.
It almost brings me to tears.
I like it very much.
He is very convinsing when he sings it.
pennyjansen 1 year ago
Nice... mellow and melancholy at the same time! Smoooooth vocals! Lyrics remind me of Kenny Wayne Sheperd's "Last Goodbye". Is this guy touring the East Coast anytime soon?
juicyfruitca 1 year ago
See Paul Carrack live @ Maryport Blues Festival.. 23rd July 2010.
mptblues 1 year ago
yesss....i like this song
chitchitify 1 year ago
Well aint this a fine howdy do!
devno9904 1 year ago
Si la gente cero onda que lástima
monch67 1 year ago
Este compa canta de poquisisisisima madre... me encanta su timbre de voz. En lo personal su voz me gusta un chingo.
unmayl 1 year ago
This song is amazing :) It reminds me of good times of my life...Thank you Paul
6002mac 1 year ago
omg...was ein kaltes publikum !!!! big hand 4u paul !!!
amanyttap 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@amanyttap Baden-Baden..... was ertwartest du? Sekt und teure Klamotten. Die haben wahrscheinlich gar nicht gewusst was die da für Musik machen (da sie nur Opernsänger und ein paar Dirigenten kennen). Viel zu fein für erstklassige Soul/R'n'B musik noch dazu mit einer fetten Hammond B3 auf der Bühne (die dachten sicher, das sei ein Chuppendale-Möbelstück) ;-)
aihoschema 1 year ago
die zuschauer hässlich :P !
MrGamer467 1 year ago
maybe a flare would wake the audience up
xxluigixxuk 1 year ago
lool...really... a bad public :-D
AllesRatten 1 year ago
haha yes lameee crowd
stunning take
STARKASTT 1 year ago
dang...are they deaf?!
archibalddurden 1 year ago
lame audience, what the hell?? this song is awesome!!!
negative1985 1 year ago
amazing voice :) very clear !
MagginDizeDC 1 year ago
what a fucking voice
S2MaCaroLS2 1 year ago 2
Paul Carrack concert Chesterfield, January, the best, could not be better, a great night, very civilised and very entertaining
306bad 1 year ago
Great concert but as all of you said...the audience really sucks!
Leorocha77 1 year ago
@Leorocha77 yea dude really sucks, my dog is happier than everybody in this concert
melecorporation 1 year ago
yeah wtf? :S
i would be like whooooo!!!!!
oODkLiciousOo 1 year ago
Paul Carrack rocks!
TheScratcher32 1 year ago
lol see that audience. the audience sucks
douwehandbal 1 year ago
Great song, great artist, great gig, sucking audience... Who can't dance on this song???
Thomascuba 1 year ago 4
Probably Germans
Marathanz 1 year ago
jep south west german^^
Markkassel 1 year ago
genialer song
TheNetter26 1 year ago 2
Great singer / artist, great song, great performance, but retarded crowd.
You should notice that Baden Baden is a spa town, so most inhabitants are elderly rich people - not the best crowd for such a concert. :-)
MrKnopf 1 year ago 12
@MrKnopf
Fuck me...wish I could have retired at their age !
fireandrain1 8 months ago
@MrKnopf sorry, but the audience is typically carrack! boston.. supertramp... phil collins... what do you think the audience has to be like or look like?
chettee 8 months ago
some old dickheads are starting an argument while teh world famous star is singing!! such ignorance!!
mentamusician 2 years ago 4
great performance !!!!
katemate06 2 years ago 2
kickass tune!
jazzmanEE 2 years ago
Yeah... Very good!!... and with the Best drummer Andreas Keller =)
greetings
loudandhot 2 years ago 11
3:50 - 4:14 ??????
limuswin 2 years ago 3
great song and performance!!!! and one of the worst crowd if ever seen!!!
gunnerCologne 2 years ago 6
paul is doing a tour in january in britain if you get a chance go and see him is a great night
mattices 2 years ago
@mattices
Managed to see Paul last week at the Grand Theatre in swansea.........the place was bouncing absolutley fantastic evening
broughtonjack 2 years ago
toller auftritt! aber das publikum dort is ja mal echt zum sche**sen! klatschen könnens aber das wars schon!
ehkloar 2 years ago
stupid crowd, he should play in a full yankee stadium or something
kupie16 2 years ago 2
muy buena
gigli6 2 years ago
Paul Carrack is one of the best soul singers we have performing today. Its a from teh heart and the lyrics resonate with you as you groove to the music
temptsrule 2 years ago 51
@temptsrule
one of the best white singers for decades (like robert palmer, robert plant etc)
cheer for posting this!
punkeruit1965 1 year ago
Paul Carrack jest naj naj lepsiejszym gościem,a te buraki ni nie rozumieją
MrMont50 11 months ago
hahaha
ye you're right
allmightypol 2 years ago 2
good whistler
oldboy229 2 years ago
the worst fans ever... XD
SKALPEL1985 2 years ago 8
Completly right
MargaridMartins 2 years ago 2
man he changed from 95 to now a lot
internalpeaceseeker 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
oldboy229 2 years ago
ke mierda de publico JAJAJAJA no se mueven ni pa sus muertos
KANIANIS 2 years ago 5
braindead audience!! no respect!!
mentamusician 2 years ago 20
te odeo
5x83e 2 years ago
me too
7trudi7 2 years ago
I love it!
kaylunnaris 2 years ago
he can't sing high notes here
dorotttta 2 years ago
age
internalpeaceseeker 2 years ago
Does anyone know if this concert is available on DVD?
msmcdougal 2 years ago
great music and perfomance, but is public zombie?
limuswin 2 years ago 25
@limuswin: They're listening & enjoying.
Oelm3n 1 year ago
@Oelm3n this is true, but some old drunken bastards tried to start a discuss, this is such an idiotice, even more when you have Paul Carrack there.
limuswin 1 year ago
@limuswin lol they are ..
MrMusicMinister 1 year ago
@limuswin
in germany it's pretty unusual to sit while listening to live music.
Rock concerts are almost always in front of a standing crowd. I guess that's why sitting puts us into "critic"-mode. You almost expect some opera or classical piece. Rocking and sitting at the same time? MINDEXPLOSION.
Starcraft2scene 1 year ago
Comment removed
limuswin 2 years ago
awesome
bubot17 2 years ago
Grandissimo,formidabile pezzo,uno dei pochi!!
mslucianin 2 years ago
Good find ! Thank You ma9th !
kongmingmusic 2 years ago
all dead people for this dead song
damm
it is so arfull that i gonna die
douwehandbal 2 years ago
Great performance.
The audience are sitting around tables with each other - not a typical concert, if they wanted to join in they would be singing at their friends and I imagine a lot of people would find that inhibiting - I would.
jonnyzz139 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
love this song
lenavogel22 2 years ago
Great song, but that is possibley the most dead audience i have ever seen lol
RPAYNE1990 2 years ago 4
omg...5 people singing with them? Stupid audience ^^
Jacksmedulaoblongada 2 years ago 4
a pity...the audience don't DIG that...awesome song...I like it...
amanyttap 2 years ago
Great Live Version and what a voice
Stuttgart1482 2 years ago
come on, what's going on with this audience? Are they all deaf, or dead or something?
That song's awesome.
sinetiketar 2 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
Well said! I love this song....
littlemorella 2 years ago
nice one!
plychrs468 2 years ago 2
over my sholder is good song, i remember for my old love etc ... i prefer HiP HoP but, this song is realy good, respect .. :-)
608644144 2 years ago 2
@he4rtandsoul=> check gibsonizer229 version
bluestough 2 years ago
This is one of my fav. songs of all time and I am definitely diggin' this live version, very relaxed. Haha poor girl @ 1:07 she's wondering why everyone else isn't grooving along and swaying with the music... I would have been for sure! Nice job Paul!
he4rtandsoul 2 years ago 5
Absolute Quality
AuRellu 2 years ago
except this blonde @1:07
gibsonizer229 2 years ago
indeed this audience looks like frozen upperclass champagne-boozing ignorants, nothing to do with rhythm & blues, dudes
bluestough 2 years ago
paullllllllllllllllll great
giuliakizz 2 years ago
why the fuck is this only two stars? It's offensive how people have such a bad taste. This is incredible. What a pity the crowd is so quiet.
MonoCabron123 2 years ago 33
I agree!
tropicana2812 2 years ago 2
Totally agree. This is an authentic, excellent pop song. I remember when it was released in '95. We gave it a ton of airplay on KSCB. Remains one of my favorites. Should have been a much bigger hit but unfortunatley the radio programmers wont touch it due to hip-hop and teens being in a younger demo that would not attract attention to this legend.
watermanandyg 2 years ago 3
@MonoCabron123 Yeah, no shit... this guy is probably one of the few singers left that don't need any kind of voice modifications to actually get a good tone out of their mouths lol.
webhito 1 year ago 28
@webhito Yep. Totally agree with you on that one my friend!
julietcharlieen1 7 months ago
@webhito so relieved to know somebody knows talent apart from me! x
gillysmusic 4 months ago
@MonoCabron123 Maby they thike that you have a bad taste?
Have you ever thought about that? (But still. I Love the song)
Warmouse213616 1 year ago
c tro bon!!!!!!!!!!!
vinena64 2 years ago
^ i L O v E tHisS
SheilasSsP 2 years ago
koos ik was er ook geweldig ;D
rockeend 2 years ago 2
Deze man stond gisteravond in het voorprogamma van de eagles in het gelredome .
Beregoed
koosmeuldijk 2 years ago 4
Helemaal mee eens,
de volgende dag hebben we meteen kaartjes gekocht voor oktober!!
Aimee3003 2 years ago
Ik heb hem daar gezien, echt super.
xLonaa 2 years ago 3
I like this in some ways better than the studio version! I love how he personalizes his singing.
bbrown4163 2 years ago 2