Added: 7 months ago
From: Atoszone11
Views: 67,538
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • please saya orang indonesia tapi disini yang hebat malaysia kok.. yang bagus2 di malaysia dapet yang lebih pantas.. congrats malaysia :))

  • CT's vocal mesmerize than the others....... superb ! so soothing

  • Good performance...love them all

  • SITI !

  • bodoh... gaduh pasal music buat apa?????

  • I'm Indonesian and I proud, so I love Malaysia.

    ^^ Peace!! Love!! Unite!! ^^

  • Gemersik merdulah suara melly. Sapa kata suara dia kureng dalam ni?? Rasanya paling ada soul. Siti nyanyi jujur dr hati. Jac..errr ok suara dia high pitch. Nothing special for that.

  • tp ade satu yg pelik asal siti atau jac x harmonize arrr??? diorg klu bab harmonization nie mmg hebat...part2 last tu muke semua macam dah pelik...but mmg diorg hebat :)

  • knpa lah masih ade lagi yang saling memaki hamun...

    for malaysian and indonesian we're brothers and sisters..

    we speak the same language but only in different accent..

    music is not the place to raise up any political issues and so on..

    im proud to be Malaysian and i love indonesian..

    all of the were great in this video :D

  • 1 question, why malaysian love to kutuk or maki hamun to everything ?

  • @junniquilent801...Qta s'haruznya b'syukur..cuz, bukan Qta eang b'buat s'perti itu!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @junniquilent801 WAH,,,mulut spt penghuni neraka saja kmu ni.....najis???? tp, knp rakyat indon dtg sini cri rezeki??? dasar negara mundur, tak tau malu...tak pandai bersyukur.,malaysia jauh lebih maju dri indonesia...truth..

  • @lizALoVeCT Heh pukimak, kalo berani ko usir aja rakyat indonesia yg ada disana. brani gak negara mu ?? NGOMONG aja loe biadap

  • Sorry, Jac has a very power voice but she sing with no soul :(

  • Siti, aik da bukak tudong? Bukak tutop bukak tutop. Main2 pe pki tudong?

  • gr8 performance by 3 divas... luv it...

  • DCT paling mantap , tpi dy very humble tknk overshadow sangt :D

  • hmm i luv them all.....mereka lebih hebat dibanding orang yang koment dengan nada menghina disini...melly,jac,siti sama hebat!!

  • ct mcm x allout, myb xnak overshadow penyanyi lain.. pakaian jac x menyerlah..

  • Untung Melly berimprovisasi, klu gak suaranya sama rata aja.

  • terbaik la

    3 vokal wanita mantoppp...

  • Jacklyn i love you

  • sore yg plg x harmoni pernah aku dengar! syg sbb sumer penyanyi power yg nyanyikan..xtaw mn silap! :(

  • Kembali liat video ini cuma karena melly doank... suara hampir tidak terdengar disini tapi suaranya yang keluar dari hatinya membuat hati saya kembali dan menangis :')

  • Melly goeslaw sounds great. The other two....er...

  • @yazza449 , he wouldnt have made it, if he doesnt want it in his creations.

  • melly bkn islam kot....

  • uniknya indonesia

  • melly goeslow who wroete those song right??? wat a talented singe of melly.. btw, siti and jac are great too..

  • melly goeslow punya suare terlalu gemersik , sukar di faham ! tapi sore memang hebat ,

  • jurutaip online pengiklanan diperlukan...rm300-rm800 seminggu...

    maklumat lanjut sila layari bisnestype.webs.com......."

  • I <33 Melly because when she sings she delivers it with her heart.

    Been her fan and will always be :)

  • what the hell fucking is melly wearing????? lmao

  • dato ct.....cantik nya......THE BEST FOREVER <333

  • melly bangga memakai baju batik,,,yang seratus persen budaya indo.i likeeeee.....

  • cerewettt,,,,,semua tinggal lihat aja,pake cerewetttt,,,,

  • dato ct boleh buat kaw2..tp dia hormat

  • Dato Ct da best..... so humble... bg peluang kat melly n jac....

  • sepatutnya one of the singers should b from Singapore baru adil each singer represents each country kata APM

  • sepatutnya salah Satu dari mereka Adalah penyanyi  Singapore baru adil ni kan apm each singer represents each country..

  • andars"e2 lrik dato ct yg tls...!!dh mmg melly xbest.dgr s0re die t0l2...aq xmnt jac,tp aq rsa lbh bg0s pd melly...pe2 p0n dato ct t'baekk.

  • melly cam nenek kebayan daaaaaa

  • kenapa melly duk goyang2 baju 2..

  • Setelah bersara dari dunia nyanyian, melly kini berkhidmat sebagai dukun jowo, specialty dalam bidang menyantau dan belaan jin. Dipaparkan dalam video diatas ialah melly dengan pakaian rasmi dukun bersama anak2 jin belaan nya (tidak kelihatan kerana jin ialah makhluk ghaib). Trollolololol

  • walaupun dia 2 org dia..tapi dia ttp org malaysia...semangat 1 malaysia 2 ttp ada..kita bkn lahirkan kita untuk benci kaum lain..tapi tuhan lahirkan kita untuk syg antara 1 sama lain...bukan nak pandang rendah,,,agama bukan segalanya.....yg penting hati.....hmmmm

  • xsuke jaclyn victor..tau la bole bawa note tggi tp dia keling..tu yg aku xbole trime..ehh,siti nyanyi lagu keling sedap sgt..cube kasi jac nyanyi..huhu..melly suara unique sgt..merdu dan feeling..1)siti 2)melly 3)jaclynn

  • @firdaus0091 dude, what's your problem?ape masalah ko dgn org india?ko racist ey?

  • @firdaus0091 bodo kaw ni. racist betul.

  • bgus tera mna pn artis dorg tilawah alquran ttp kita pegang,,,

  • Siti n jac punya skill dan tekhnik untuk bernyanyi sangat baik.. tapi jujur kenapa saya lebih merinding hati bergetar dengar melly menyanyi.. terkadang menyanyi bukan masalah tekhnik tapi masalah menyampaikan isi lagu dengan perasaan Good performance :)

  • @TheTarabudi betul banget Gw setuju bro, masalah suara siti ama jac bagus banget. tapi saat melly nyanyi pas part "Biar semua tau apa adanya.. diriku kini sendiri" suara nyaris ga kedengeran tapi itu yang bikin merinding jujur Gw ampe nangis, dia benar-benar nyanyi pake hati.

  • @nueyful kata orang2 mah saat ingin tau nyanyian mana yang datang dari hati? A: pejamkan mata dan dengarkan saja. kalau ingin tau penyanyi mana yang menyanyi dengan hati? A: liat matanya dan matanya yang berbicara bukan mulutnya... haha

  • @nuradja102 haha kayax kenal nieh... Bahasanya dalem banget, yes setuju. Kendala pengendalian emosi aja teh melly kurang, emosi meledak-ledak jadi suaranya begitu mungkin karena dia dapat award yang begitu besar atas dedikasinya didunia musik bahkan di negerinya sendiri belum dapet award khas begitu.

  • @TheTarabudi haha Loe ngikutin Gw ya... lol. Betul sekali d Indo mana dapet dia beginian....

  • sedap masing-masing duk komen sana-sini artis...korang mcm bagus plak kan? kalau nak bagi pandangan bagilah yg boleh membina...even, diorang nyanyi best ke x? diorang dh pegi jauhhhh..dh mcm2 anugerah dirangkul n lagu2 diorang tetap menjadi ingatan dan MEGA...engkauuu HADO? geram aku mcm BAGUS je..nak kutuk artis-artis korang mampu ke menyanyi high pitch mcm Jac? mampu menyanyi semerdu Dato' CT? mampu untuk menghasilkan lagu-lagu yg puitis mcm Melly? Mampooooooooo? ke tidekkkkkkk?

  • superb! anugerah tuhan yg esa!

  • @sitizulaikaa bukan mandul,orang anaknya udah tiga.bukan,,,bukan mandul.subur koq melly peranakannya.

  • @rinny1221 hurmmm..?? sitizulaikaa bilang melly itu mengandung atau pregnant ke..? kapan dia bilang si melly mandul dong.....

  • macam dah tak der artis lain je smp 2x kena buat...

    promote laa sikit artis yang lain..kan banyak..adeyh

  • Comment removed

  • melly hancur...siti and jac mantap! tahniah siti

  • tidak dinafikan melly komposer yg hebat tp bukan penyanyi yg hebat....pandangan masing2 kan

  • melly memang bagus, nyanyian melly x tinggi tapi penuh perasaan. itu yang paling ikhlas. sebab tue lagu2 dia klu perasan kebanyakkan touching our heart. Siti n jac memang superb. tapi bila dengar melly nyanyi memang klu tuan lagu bawa lagu dia extra special sbb feeling yang tuan lagu tue bawa. superb..................

  • baju ape lah si melly pakai ni...suare da le ke laut..hahaha...ko xde pon xpe daaa...

  • @mbm4087 tone dia sedap lar. ko ape tahu.

  • @mbm4087 kalau tak ada melly tak mungkin lah siti nurhaliza bisa menyanyikan lagu biarlah rahasia,,,,,, yang jelas tak ada kau ( @mbm4087 ) tak apa lah ,,,,heheh

  • I am an avid fan of both Siti and Melly. Siti and Jac are well-known for their amazing vocal prowess and it'll only take me one listen of Siti's song for me to love it. While Melly, I love her music, especially "Jika" and "Menghitung Hari", so I'm actually looking forward on how they will bring the song. I want to see them "goreng" the song, make my hair stand on end....but the opposite happen. really, it's quite disappointing... :-( I still love them though

  • Comment removed

  • dalam sebuah lagu bagiku yang penting karangan nya,soal penyanyi banyak penyanyi bersuara bagus.so,,,semua tergantung penciptanya.

  • jac panjit bawak lagu ni hehehe:) btw aku dah lama tunggu ct n jac satu pentas hehehe:) ..... akhirnya dapat jugek tgk wow!! best2 ,,,,

  • ct the best (^o^)/

  • Among all 3 singers when notice their vocal,pitch and stamina Jac is the best .Siti is good same goes to Melly but Jac is the best

  • @740129 If i were a judge, Siti 71.5% Jac 69.8% and Melly 12.8%

  • @shahrilselena24 thats ur judgement which i cant change basically i am a singer at pubs in local so i've seen many singers from local to international but Jac is much more better than Siti .If me the judge i'd give 90.5% for Jac ,siti 60.5% and Melly 30.5%. Siti high pitch note always breaks but not Jac, melly starts up with a break voice itself

  • @740129 memandai ja ko bg peratus kat ct, ct lebih better dari jac, ko ni emmag pekak la

  • Comment removed

  • @shahrilselena24 agree,,its bcoz ct much better than jac in lower n middle register eventhough jac has wider vocal range.besides

     ct's tone is so melodious

  • @740129 bodoh

  • nyanyian jac agak keras dan kasar, but siti dan melly sgt smoth, sgt sesuai dan terbaik la

  • @sambalmamu kalau u buat bandingan vocal ,pitch and stamina antara 3 artis Jac memang power . Suara SIti dan Melly Tenggelam lah di high pitch and does not sound real

  • @740129 Yes, Jac's voice can go higher than Siti, but bear in mind that a good singer is not all about singing higher note.. for me, Jac is superb with her high note, but in terms of versatility, Siti is far better.... dont u know those British professional musicians praised Siti's vocal versatility during her concert at Royal Albert Hall long time ago..?? that's why Siti always win singing competition locally and internationally.. and she's been dubbed as The Voice of Asia as well... fact!!

  • @eastwest2010 Well is that how u judge a good singer by only having a good versatility ?come on a good singer is not judged by this it is actually a package of voice and stamina . Which i x c in Siti n Melly pls bear this in mind ok.Jac a very new singer she has also been awarded golden award in Shanghai .Siti started on1997 but jac has yet to achieve more she is new siti is already old in the industry oh come u r comparing in a very shallow base.Jac is still the best even siti confessed this

  • @740129 Versatility is one of the quality in order to be a good singer.. You're talking about package?? Dear, Siti has a better package, obviously! LOL. I bet u're not a fan of Jac, coz u dont even know since when Jac started.. Jac won MI in 2004, but she already started her career 9 years before that, dont u know it? Btw, Jac won gold award in Shanghai? Dont u know that Siti was the the first artist to win that gold award as well? Plus, Grand Prix Champion in Kazakhstan n Australia as well.. =)

  • @eastwest2010 sorry for interrupt, Dato' Siti was the 2nd winner after Ziana Zain in Voice of Asia 1995... btw, I love both of them since small child, they r so close n friendly each other seem like a couple of sibling... In addition, Siti also ever been invited by 8TV at that time for giving some comments regarding Jaclyn Victor's performance along with Roslan Aziz, Fauziah Latiff & Paul Moss... try u search for that video... (^_^)v

  • @princearjuna88 my dear, actually, i'm talking about Shanghai Asia Music Festival in China.. while you're talking about Voice of Asia in Kazakhstan, it's a different competition.. For your info, in Shanghai, only Siti Nurhaliza, Deja Moss, Misha Omar and Jaclyn Victor used to be the winner before it has been transferred to Penang, and Shila Hamzah won it.. While for the Voice of Asia, only Siti is the winner of Grand Prix Champion in 2002.. yes, Ziana won in 1995, but in the first place..

  • @740129 For more in info, u can check up Azharkent's videos.. he's the vivid fan of Siti, i guess.. and u'll see how good siti is.. btw, siti has been praised by many talented singers, composers, musicians locally and abroad.. so, no matter how low u rated her as compared to Jac, she's by far better in every aspect.. and EVERYBODY know it.. that's why Alicia Keys rated Siti Nurhaliza as The Voice of Asia... ok buddy?? proven enough in Channel V and MTV Asia as well...

  • @740129 apa yg stamina pulak , aku tgk biasa ja la hahahha

  • Melly ada tatoo.... Dah masuk agama islam tak nak remove...nanti kalau apa2- jadi nanti lagi teruk!!!  But Siti stands up!!!

  • kalau dgr elok2.....melly sounds great....gemersik suara tu buat tenaNG jew....n merdu suara siti mmg xyah nak ckp...meremang juga bulu roma........jac......ok juga but terlalu biasa dgr dia nyanyi cmtuu....xda kelainan...hehehe...btw.....go­od colaboration....

  • siti and melly mmg superb....hope dat jac will follow the steps......

  • serius lah... suara ct mmg the best a... klah jac n melly..

    melly nyanyi lgu kris pon x sesedap ct..

    cayalah~

  • Siti the best...lunak merdu..ingatkn vokal ct tenggelam bila duet jac tp langsung xtenggelam..ct mmg unik, xperlu jerit mcm jac da buat org terpukau...wow3x ct mmg supernova!

  • 3 wonderful singers! but i have to say that melly stands out!! love her!! CONGRATS MELLY!!!

  • saya heran bila melly cakap alhamdullilah kepada allah tetapi anda semua nampak tk tangan kanan nye ada tattoo...walau mcm mana pun,do the best melly...ni bukan nk kutuk melly tapi saya heran la...jangan marah saya nye...

  • @manhearted75 Hello - Melly Goeslaw memeluk agama Islam bila khawin dengan suaminya. Jadi, mungkin dia ada tattoo itu sebelum dia jadi Muslim. :) Tattoo bukan senang nak remove. Hope that answers your question.

  • Comment removed

  • @manhearted75: sebab-sebab Islam mengaharamkan tattoo bukan sebab ia menghalan 'wudhu' tetapi process tattoo itu menyakitkan badan dari physical (membunuh cell kulit) dan juga mengubah-ubah ciptaan Tuhan. Tattoo itdak mengahalang air mengalir kepada kulit. Segala yang dilakukan seseorang hanya antara dia dan Allah. ORang yang tak ada tattoo tak sembahyang pun tak ada bezanya.

  • @yazza449 : what about a boy getting circumcised (alias sunatan)? A boy was born with a foreskin and it's a painful process to cut off the skin. jadi.. sunat itu sakit dan mengubah ciptaan tuhan. why is it ok then?

  • @alexjacquet Male circumcision is not compulsory (fard) but actually sunnah. There has been no mentioning of male circumcision in the Quran, However, it is encouraged by Prophet Muhammad. It was instructed by Allah to prophet Abraham and has been a practice by Jewish and Muslim males worldwide. I'm sure are aware of the health benefits and cleanliness of circumcision. Why is it ok? because Allah permits it because he knows what is best for his creation.

  • lvu siti ... ssssssssssssssiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiiiiiittttttttttttttttttttttt­ttttttttttttttttiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

    llllllllllllllllllllllllllllll­lllllllllvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv­vvvvvvvvvuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

    u the best ...

  • melly still maintain what.... siti and jac is divaaassss...

  • - Dato' Siti Nurhaliza is the bestt !..(= Siapa penyokong/fans Siti,tolonq like..Huhuhu..

  • - Merepeknyer @HijauKertas

  • top2 semuanya...Malaysia the best!!! (^_*)

  • wow!!!! superb!!! marvelous performance!!!! it's very spectacular in this year!!! for the first time collaboration between them.... Mmg x dinafikan dato' ct dgn mudahnya bleh tandingi vokal tinggi jac... suara dato' ct merdu lantang... nampak mmg btul2 padan ngn jac... x tnggelam pon... sbb kebiasaannya jac suka menjerit!!!!!!!! klu pnyanyi lain nyanyi dgn jac, mesti suara pnyanyi tu tenggelam.... (^_^)v

  • not many knows, how powerful melly's vocal was...

  • melly, ntah apa2..

  • ak ske gabungan 3 org ni....dct sore merdu,jac suare sharp2,melly lak ok la..tpi dia amat bgus dlm cipta lgu yg menimbulkn fenomena..hrp lepas album inggeris ni..siti buat albm duet ngn jac..mkn hati sape yg dengar

  • suker sgt collaboration diarg ni.women power,,LOVE u CT!!

  • siyes aq suke ble melly masuk...sedap weh!

  • suka siti, suka lagu2 melly... hampir semua orang serantau suka siti dan hampir semua orang serantau suka lagu2 melly...

  • hebat...tapi baju melly tu siyes kelakar..memang macam dukun santet...

  • @HijauKertas hahahhaahah...ykerr body ct same ngn melly???...aku tercari2 lah persamaan tuh...tp still gak xd..ntah2 body ko kot yg same ngn melly..cian ko sampai dah xknal body cndry..hahahahahahahhaah..pity of u..

  • jac superb...

    siti ok lah ...suke dy jugak

    melly genius

    JAC TETAP HEBAT !!!

  • melly cm dukun dah aku nengok pakaian dia..huhu

  • jac u r the best..blh menyanyi semua lagu yg diberi...siti pun sama...

  • siti n jac paling menyerlah...best vokal..siap pengacara sebt 2 diva dr malaysia

  • It's been about 11 years I've drowned in this genius lady's music, still, never suffocated. Thnx Melly for making the soundtracks of my life...

  • i think...melly is smart...die tau suara die tak bole high so part die die terus low note yg over. mcm nk tido je dengar...so jac and siti terpaksa la ikut, klu tak media dr sebarang kata mcm mcm lak...tp well done to ct n jac, for me they professional walopun sakit ati tgk kesluruhan video ni....btter jac, siti n kd..

  • melly syik tukar tangan pegang mic....hehehe...berat gelang kot...huhuhuhuhu....

    pape pun memang gabungan 3 suara yang unik...

    Dato' Siti Nurhaliza---Melly Goeslaw---Jaclyn Victor

  • entah hapahapa tengok ambot jac cam sial kot.

  • Aku rasa CT n JAC yang mantap!!!kurapdulang ni buta seni ke ape...ntah2 dia yg sengau bila nyanyi mcm melly....

  • tak tahu nk cakap pe....nampak siti dan jac mcm tak match jew...macam musuh jew...tgk cam ikhlas...

  • merduny suara ct....

  • gabungan 2 vokal terhebat malaysia dan genius muzik indonesia!!superb!!

  • I like Siti's make-up style in this video, such a big eyes she had!

  • Comment removed

  • ni celebration untuk melly....xkn ct nak tggelamkan sowe melly....

  • @MrMiss93love betul2, =) dorang sumer mmg xde rase nk jatuhkan yang lain..

  • suke!!!

  • @kurapdulang nama pon kurap..eeei~~

  • ini baru 3diva namenye kn!!! superb r....

  • @HijauKertas mmm..xpela..ko cakap la org yer tak beranak lg..ak nak tgok ko lak camne..xtau la lau ko ni jantan ke betine ke..lau jntan tgok la nti bini ko leh branak ke tak..lau ko betine lak xtau la ko tu MAMPU beranak ke x coz 1 jari kite tunding kat org 4jari lg tunjuk ke arah kite balik..jd2 renung2kan lah yer..tp lau ko pondan la jgn kate beranak..sistem pranakn pon sah2 xde..hahahahahaha

  • Siti the best!! Beliau tahu di mane kemampuan beliau bile bergandingan dgn seseorang artis itu! Dress pon lawa..! =)

  • lagu ni memang makanan Siti lah~!! :)

  • <3 Fantastic Harmonising.. <3

  • lemak merdu suara ct

  • rasa mcam xpuas tngok perf.Jac & Ct sbb mcam vocal power dorang xkuarkan malam tuu ..bygkan kalo ct & jac keluarkan ...wooow...tenggelam ibu melly..ahaha

  • jac hebat...

  • ttetiba rasa yang microphone jac n siti dikurangkan sket volume utk match ngan melly~

  • Uhhh Hijau KErtas mmg patut Di Copkan kat Dahi dia uhh Peminat No satu Dato!!! sbb mana2 Vid Dato ada ja dia sbgai pengKritik Tetap!! hahaha...cari publisiti tol si Hijau Kertas..gelii I warna hijau nihhh... LUMUT JER hahaha

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • body siti dh nak sama dgn body Melly Goeslow. tp Melly body mcm tu x pe sbb dia ada anak! yang tu?? non ada!

  • @HijauKertas mata kau, hati kau semua dh ditutup oleh tuhan ka ?? takkan ko nampak sama ?? Tu la.. sapa suh busuk hati. Kt dunia dh dapat cash!

  • @Pedotcomey hijaukertas tu mmg mulut lahanat..wat dunno je..

  • KAMI BENCI @HijauKertas

    SAPEW SETUJU SILA LIKE.TQ.

  • @haziq165 setuju sgt3...sabar jela org mcm dia tu..apa2 pun kak ct tetap senyum walaupun wujud nya org mcm dia..so biarla dia..kak ct tetap bahagia..dia belum tentu bahagia..^O^

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @haziq165 likeeeeeeee!!!!!!

  • @HijauKertas biau la badan sama ke x, yg penting x terpeleot suaranya....

  • Siti & JAC !!! Such a nice collaboration !!!!!

  • napok vouge n perfect jer ble mek ti pakai gni!!! pkai gni slalu yer mek ti... jgn pakai yg serabut2 n yg bejuntai...

  • thanxx atos!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more