As with any kohl liner you need to set it with powder eyeshadow. Kohls's are mean't to be smudgey, soft, and smokey. If you don't like that smokey smeared look then you need to set it with powder eyeshadow. If you want a stay put liner to give you crisp and clean lines then you should use a powerpoint liner or any waxy type liner. Kohl's transfer easier then any other liner too and have best pigmentation.
You said the MAC feline doesn't stay on very long, how long is 'not very long'? And also, does it turn your eyes into raccoon eyes like the MAC technakohl liner? PLEASE answer! I really want to know whether it's worth buying as it's out again with the Cham Pale collection!!
@Fmousy It probably depends on your eyes, but for me, Feline doesn't last long on my waterline at all. And it does tend to move down to underneath my eyes, usually on my lower lash line but it also ends up right below my lash line. It's a pretty messy liner. *lol*
You can't even imagine how many times I've seen this video. I am going to get my mother in law one of these liners and I keep forgetting which one. But it is going to be the Urban Decay she wants something that's not SMUDGEY. LOL
Great review though, I have been wanting to buy this for a very long time, but have no MAC store near me and am more of an Urban Decay girl, but this review definitely makes me want to go buy this more.
Do you know if Urban Decay has some shade of liner in black-gray color which is slightly lighter than ZERO? I can order UD only online from abroad and have to trust someon else's perseption of colors.
This was a great review! thanks so much for it! I didn't think the feline could really have been that much darker than the 24/7 but when you swatched them I could really see the difference. You're awesome Irene and thanks for all you do. :)
kohl or kejel it's a mineral, like charcoal but in the safe way to be use as in cosmetics products, in Saudi Arabia is used by men too because it clears the eyballs and it make them wetty so the sand and other stuffs won't damage your eyes, you can buy natural kohl or kejel, you will see it's powder, some companies uses kohl in their liners and mascaras to give that truthly dark black color, also you kind find kejel in pearl and peach color
Thanks for the review, Pinkiecharm! I've been jonesing for that MAC feline pencil, but was wondering if it was worth it considering that I already have a bunch of black pencil liners that I hardly wear.
That Stila liner is gorgeous, tho'--and it's not limited edition, no? So I'll probably get for that.
i was wonderinq what is the best eye sharpner to sharpen these eyeliners? i have all three and the sharpner i use doesnt quite sharpen them. i never get a sharp point.
They're also selling a few other kohl powers in the same collection, the red one which is raven I believe, and I think there's a blue called Sense of Style. It might be purple, not sure though.
i like this eyeliner but i find its too smudy. i have ppl laughing at me because i will have black smudges on my face because it smudges off my water line and i try to rub it of my lower lash area.
Irene I had a question about MAC Kohl pencils in general. You said that they are soft to smudge right. Because I have Phone number and it's so hard to put on my eyes. I don't know if it got dried out or does. I dunno. And mine is so hard to smudge!
I do not buy M.A.C eyeliners, especially not kohl. However, you made me curious so I looked it up on make up alley and it gets fairly good reviews. 4 lippies and 72% of people would repurchase.
hey sweetie, i hav a quick question. so is kohl pencils save for contact lens users? cuz when i tried tht loreal kohl pencil i think, after a while it got on my lenses and i had to remove the lenses cuz i cudnt see. do u think its the same wit all kohl pencils or was it tht one?
I wear contacts and I'm a makeup artist, I wear and use mac kohl's all the time. You wanna be careful not to get any kind of makeup on your contacts, ever (especially not cream or oil based cosmetics) . You may just need to work on your application technique. You should use a flat liner brush to apply it, or you might want to try setting your eyeliner with a black powder eyeshadow, might help. :-)
Its soo funny how the Urban Decay looks almost brown next to the other too. I love Feline except for the smudging. Hate the Urban Decay, its just not dark enough for me.
I had a major smudge issue with Mac's pencil in Minted. I thought it was the color or something (I just wore it by itself, no eye shadow and within an hour it was bleeding up into my crease) but it made me feel a little better when you said that Feline does it too.
Feline is AMAZING! I was very very skeptical about it when I first saw it. I thought, it's just another black eyeliner, whats the big deal about it? Well, I finally caved before it was too late and I am totally obsessed! I see why it has a cult following. Stupid mac, they need to make it permanent! It is hands down the darkest black liner around
Feline will be out again in Jan on the 6th I believe so You do have time to save up and stock up. I am going to because i love feline and it doesn't run out of my waterline. You really have to try all of the liners to see what works for you because the UD in zero does run on me. =(
great review! I've got to go out and get it tomorrow, I have the UD 24/7 - Zero, but you just totally encouraged me to purchase Feline... Thank you!!! :)
Feline and Zero 24/7 are my FAVORITE liners...I bought 4 when they re-released :p They're $4.00 cheaper too, and I like them so much. It is a tie between the MAC one and the UD one, but obvs I'm going for the cheaper when available<3
I've had the MUFE Aqua eyes and the UD 24/7. To me, they're pretty much the same product. From 2 different companies. They don't show up as dark on the first swipe so you have to build it up. But once you do it lasts relatively long on the waterline. Not all day but long enough for me to repurchase!
hahaha i think it's funny how everyone "competes" for the first comment.
anyways, i love your videos pinkiecharm. they are very helpful and informative. i like the style and how much stuff you can pack in one video. keep up the great work. thanks for being so wonderful!!!!!
a good long lasting eyeliner on the waterline is makeup forever aqua liner pencil! amazinggg!!
mandymoffatt 3 weeks ago
As with any kohl liner you need to set it with powder eyeshadow. Kohls's are mean't to be smudgey, soft, and smokey. If you don't like that smokey smeared look then you need to set it with powder eyeshadow. If you want a stay put liner to give you crisp and clean lines then you should use a powerpoint liner or any waxy type liner. Kohl's transfer easier then any other liner too and have best pigmentation.
BeautieCandy 2 months ago
"thanks mac" lol i liked the way u said it!!
lovaby 5 months ago
is this actual Kohl, i mean like the one that arab people use?
ksavemem 9 months ago
I wish Feline was permanent collection
victoriaindigo 9 months ago
wow, zero looks brown in the videoswatches x)
chrisbeeblack 11 months ago
ich heisse feline... =D
Mrssinggirl12 1 year ago
You said the MAC feline doesn't stay on very long, how long is 'not very long'? And also, does it turn your eyes into raccoon eyes like the MAC technakohl liner? PLEASE answer! I really want to know whether it's worth buying as it's out again with the Cham Pale collection!!
Fmousy 1 year ago
@Fmousy It probably depends on your eyes, but for me, Feline doesn't last long on my waterline at all. And it does tend to move down to underneath my eyes, usually on my lower lash line but it also ends up right below my lash line. It's a pretty messy liner. *lol*
pinkiecharm 1 year ago
@pinkiecharm Does it migrate as bad as MAC technakohl liners?
Fmousy 1 year ago
i found that the milani liquieye metalic pencil in black doesnt budge. i love it
supercuteism 1 year ago
they need to make feline permanent! aaaah i can never find it!
NinnaNightmare13 1 year ago
@NinnaNightmare13 it is now out with the cham pale collection! :)
xogymnastxo7 1 year ago
would you recommend the mac feline its being repromoted is it worth it thnks
dorki08 2 years ago
You can't even imagine how many times I've seen this video. I am going to get my mother in law one of these liners and I keep forgetting which one. But it is going to be the Urban Decay she wants something that's not SMUDGEY. LOL
THANKS IRENE!
aeonflux707 2 years ago
Hi Irene :) I was wondering what you thought about the smolder eye kohl by mac?
joannnx33 2 years ago
Great review though, I have been wanting to buy this for a very long time, but have no MAC store near me and am more of an Urban Decay girl, but this review definitely makes me want to go buy this more.
mastoidrama 2 years ago
MATTHEW BELLAMY!!!
mastoidrama 2 years ago
Yes.. thats excatly wat I need since I have oily skin... finally. thanks for the rivew, very infomative
Nenakhmer 2 years ago
Do you know if Urban Decay has some shade of liner in black-gray color which is slightly lighter than ZERO? I can order UD only online from abroad and have to trust someon else's perseption of colors.
Tigra1411 2 years ago
This was a great review! thanks so much for it! I didn't think the feline could really have been that much darker than the 24/7 but when you swatched them I could really see the difference. You're awesome Irene and thanks for all you do. :)
MichCoccaBene 2 years ago
best review ever! thank youuuu for comparing all three! :D
morganandkatieshow 2 years ago
I really like your lipgloss color. if you remember what is it?
KSrags2riches 2 years ago
its being repromoted in a december or january collection!
lindseybaby251 2 years ago
can you please do a review on the stila kajal eyeliner in topaz? thanks :D
xGlowBabyGlow 2 years ago
can you smudge the UD 24/7 liner at all?
SaddBlueEyes 2 years ago
nope
redpanda441 2 years ago
Do the stila smudge pots last longer than UD 24/7
XBiscottiLadyX 2 years ago
can you do a review on mac's penultimate eyliner thanks!
girlygal2324 2 years ago
what does the term 'kohl' mean in terms of eyeliner?
ShAzZrUlZ 2 years ago
kohl or kejel it's a mineral, like charcoal but in the safe way to be use as in cosmetics products, in Saudi Arabia is used by men too because it clears the eyballs and it make them wetty so the sand and other stuffs won't damage your eyes, you can buy natural kohl or kejel, you will see it's powder, some companies uses kohl in their liners and mascaras to give that truthly dark black color, also you kind find kejel in pearl and peach color
AluryNinia 2 years ago
omg... thank you SO much i always thought that kohl meant like 'safe to use on waterline' but now i know :D
ShAzZrUlZ 2 years ago
Amazing review irene!!
:)
gigglesmansonn 2 years ago
hey i have a random question
are you 18?
you look so young!
JulieAlbrightclub11 2 years ago
So strange, Urban Decay's Zero does not stay on my waterline. The MAC one lasts about 2 hours before I do a quick reapply.
SparklemotionX 2 years ago
thanks for the review!!! i hate that i can't give you stars! ^^
mellylavi 2 years ago
I hate that I can't "thumbs up" your comment! lol
CherryColaKiss 2 years ago
the feline will also be repromoted with the "Warm and Cozy Collection" in December for anyone who is having trouble finding it right now! :)
and I must have a defective 24/7 liner because mine doesnt stay on my waterline at all! :(
mrsnicholasjjonas95 2 years ago
how do I find out when MAC products will be repromoted?
the 24/7 smudges on me too after a while, interestingly sometimes only on one side, so I have to carry it around with to touch up :/
I heard the MUFE is better though, Fuzkittie did a comparison in her blog a while ago, so I'll try it next
PipsyPops 2 years ago
Thank you for the review! :)
BellamyBlue 2 years ago
oooooohhh....what a good review! now i know i wanna buy Feline!!!!
Lisasz09 said that probably it is going to be in the permanent collection from december....i think!
OrientalLagoon 2 years ago
Hi Irene!
I have the L'Oreal Extra-Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner in Black. How does that compare to Feline? Pretty dang similar or worlds apart?
Thanks so much for all ur help :)
colettemakeup 2 years ago
Lol triangle of death
lozzapie1 2 years ago
Thanks for the review, Pinkiecharm! I've been jonesing for that MAC feline pencil, but was wondering if it was worth it considering that I already have a bunch of black pencil liners that I hardly wear.
That Stila liner is gorgeous, tho'--and it's not limited edition, no? So I'll probably get for that.
tokyorosa 2 years ago
thanks for the video ! I've been waiting for someone to make this review :)
xoxo Laurie
abrunettegirl 2 years ago
heeey I have request!! could you make a review on the revlon colorstay pressed powder foundation??!
that would be awesome!! Thanks!!
Ligadorra 2 years ago
i was wonderinq what is the best eye sharpner to sharpen these eyeliners? i have all three and the sharpner i use doesnt quite sharpen them. i never get a sharp point.
keyvinrodriguez 2 years ago
Do you have the one by MAC? I think it's probably your best bet.
PossumNosePink 2 years ago
@keyvinrodriguez I use Urban Decay's sharpener and it works wonderfully.
pinkiecharm 2 years ago
Decenber 26th is the next releease date.
They're also selling a few other kohl powers in the same collection, the red one which is raven I believe, and I think there's a blue called Sense of Style. It might be purple, not sure though.
EAC1215 2 years ago
What font do you use in your intro/on your banner? Please and thank you! :)
Pikapookie 2 years ago
i like this eyeliner but i find its too smudy. i have ppl laughing at me because i will have black smudges on my face because it smudges off my water line and i try to rub it of my lower lash area.
kmm24556748 2 years ago
Rimmels self sharpened black khol eyeliner is pretty fricken black and creamy. I love it over my urban decay zero eyeliner.
littlerayray77 2 years ago
Irene I had a question about MAC Kohl pencils in general. You said that they are soft to smudge right. Because I have Phone number and it's so hard to put on my eyes. I don't know if it got dried out or does. I dunno. And mine is so hard to smudge!
aeonflux707 2 years ago
huh? A phone number?
opaqueheart09 2 years ago
No it's a color called PHONE NUMBER LOL ur funny
aeonflux707 2 years ago
LOL. Sorry babes, I had no idea! LOL
I do not buy M.A.C eyeliners, especially not kohl. However, you made me curious so I looked it up on make up alley and it gets fairly good reviews. 4 lippies and 72% of people would repurchase.
hehe toodles, babes!
opaqueheart09 2 years ago
hey sweetie, i hav a quick question. so is kohl pencils save for contact lens users? cuz when i tried tht loreal kohl pencil i think, after a while it got on my lenses and i had to remove the lenses cuz i cudnt see. do u think its the same wit all kohl pencils or was it tht one?
joshnuresh 2 years ago
I wear contacts and I'm a makeup artist, I wear and use mac kohl's all the time. You wanna be careful not to get any kind of makeup on your contacts, ever (especially not cream or oil based cosmetics) . You may just need to work on your application technique. You should use a flat liner brush to apply it, or you might want to try setting your eyeliner with a black powder eyeshadow, might help. :-)
cutiepiedev 2 years ago
Thanks so much =)
joshnuresh 2 years ago
the feline is supposed to be coming out again in december, keep an eye out if you want it!!
shimmerinchim 2 years ago
I think it will be in one of the next couple releases as a repromote. I will be getting a couple more!
angelpantz4599 2 years ago
I love my feline, however I do set my liner with black shadow for it to last a bit longer...
mekax3 2 years ago
Its soo funny how the Urban Decay looks almost brown next to the other too. I love Feline except for the smudging. Hate the Urban Decay, its just not dark enough for me.
MsVideoWatcher100 2 years ago
I LOVE the eyeshadow you are wearing...what brand/color is it? please and thank you:)
rkyarunts 2 years ago
triangle of death, lol. damn you mac.
giltgold 2 years ago
would they have it at a CCO since its from an old collection?
geezilikecheez 2 years ago
They had it at my CCO. Along with the other stuff from that collection.
mandiea28 2 years ago
your eye makeup IS GORGEOUS!
PlainBlackBandana 2 years ago
i freakin love your videos
PlainBlackBandana 2 years ago
helloooo!!!
can you do a comparison of the Urban decay 24/7 eyeliner in zero and this mac feline kohl power? please
loredana018 2 years ago
@loredana018 Didn't I do that?
pinkiecharm 2 years ago
Hi, what is on your lips? It's gorgeous! :)
beautyissimple 2 years ago
Your makeup is so very pretty today :)
Thanks for the review
0Hermia0 2 years ago
feline is my favorite eye pencil its so intense
kimmiem231 2 years ago
I had a major smudge issue with Mac's pencil in Minted. I thought it was the color or something (I just wore it by itself, no eye shadow and within an hour it was bleeding up into my crease) but it made me feel a little better when you said that Feline does it too.
guitarsoloist07 2 years ago
can you review mac's smolder eye kohl?
i mainly want to know about it's staying power on the waterline.
flawlessbackflipx 2 years ago
the staying power is a few hours :)
its more intense than feline, and it can kind of burn.. :(
strawberryelectricc 2 years ago
It smudges worse than feline
MsShotta 2 years ago
have you tried the regular kohl pencils from mac? are they better than 24/7? thanks!
makeuponmee 2 years ago
great video!
mzrey 2 years ago
I compared it to the stila kajal in ony also and I actually thought the stila one was a bit darker, but yeah theyre both very black
Yajairad 2 years ago
What is the best way to sharpen Zero? It always breaks on me because it is so soft.
befany14 2 years ago
@befany14 I use Urban Decay's sharpener and it works fine.
pinkiecharm 2 years ago
Hi! how does mac's feline compare to revlon colorstay eyeliner?
makeupaddict14 2 years ago
Feline is AMAZING! I was very very skeptical about it when I first saw it. I thought, it's just another black eyeliner, whats the big deal about it? Well, I finally caved before it was too late and I am totally obsessed! I see why it has a cult following. Stupid mac, they need to make it permanent! It is hands down the darkest black liner around
noellekilian 2 years ago
Feline will be out again in Jan on the 6th I believe so You do have time to save up and stock up. I am going to because i love feline and it doesn't run out of my waterline. You really have to try all of the liners to see what works for you because the UD in zero does run on me. =(
missyl044 2 years ago
UD runs on me too , I have yet to find one that doesn't ...looks like I will be trying Feline now
painted00eyes 2 years ago
Best black out there!! LOVE
mdlb1229 2 years ago
ughhhhhhhh been waiting for this thanks
nodelin 2 years ago
Limited edition for a black eyeliner. I just don't understand it.
crazytlccool 2 years ago
@crazytlccool haha, so true...it just doesnt make sense, does it?!
Lumanette09 2 years ago
great review! I've got to go out and get it tomorrow, I have the UD 24/7 - Zero, but you just totally encouraged me to purchase Feline... Thank you!!! :)
mS3riKa 2 years ago
I want Feline SO bad!!!! Glad to have a dupe for it now!
dwilliams19831 2 years ago
Feline and Zero 24/7 are my FAVORITE liners...I bought 4 when they re-released :p They're $4.00 cheaper too, and I like them so much. It is a tie between the MAC one and the UD one, but obvs I'm going for the cheaper when available<3
andlove21 2 years ago
oooooh awesome. i definitly wanna get that asap
KimiToxxxic 2 years ago
i'm addicted to this eyeliner... it is so black but it smudges so i set it with black eyeshadow
CoralistaGirl 2 years ago
how would these compare to Make Up Forever's liner? :D
izukii 2 years ago
I've had the MUFE Aqua eyes and the UD 24/7. To me, they're pretty much the same product. From 2 different companies. They don't show up as dark on the first swipe so you have to build it up. But once you do it lasts relatively long on the waterline. Not all day but long enough for me to repurchase!
lilmzann 2 years ago
hahaha i think it's funny how everyone "competes" for the first comment.
anyways, i love your videos pinkiecharm. they are very helpful and informative. i like the style and how much stuff you can pack in one video. keep up the great work. thanks for being so wonderful!!!!!
gymnast725 2 years ago
@gymnast725 I usually delete them so it doesn't matter who's first. :)
And thank you!
pinkiecharm 2 years ago
Comment removed
gnomeofprincess 2 years ago
I love Feline. I wish it was permanent. I think its coming out again soon.
661yrz 2 years ago
i want this!! :)
purplelove516 2 years ago