@ipbalkenende Contrariwise ... it takes a healthy human to disguise such things (e.g. homosexual themes in children stories, or suppression of feelings themes, glorification of destructive authority etc) and courage to show it. Think Wilhelm Reich vs Sigmund Freud. Of course some ppl will always complain, and want to have the disguise back ... as shown by Alice Miller ...
My father used to read this to me and my 3 older brothers all the time when we were little. I hated it. I always just thought they burned MaryAnn to death :L
The ka mate haka: a primal, violent cry of conquest. Perhaps the conquest of man over nature? Just as the white man has taken a once proud dance for his rugby games, so does he pervert and deform the land with his machines.
Perfect, perfect! Ever since I first heard this story at age six I lamented Mary Anne's ignominious end. A fine digging machine, stripped of all dignity...
@JFiannaca 95% similar but there were also some small similarities... So... would you say it was 100% similar? Was it.... Mike Mulligan And His Steam Shovel??
I am the same age as this book and readi it since I was five, including to my children. It is a happy story, showing how there is a place for old technology, in this case for a machine that receives a well-earned and functional retirement for a remarkable achievement. The story also demonstrates the psychological truth that we sometimes perform better if people are around to appreciate our endeavours. Only as an adult did I notice that the steam shovel is female.
@diplipito11 Haha come on man, he is not serious. He reads children's books and throws in dark twists. Besides, what any book means is completely subjective to the reader.
May I suggest that you go back and re-read the early Babar books? I suspect that Werner might have some interesting observations about the taming of the metaphorical savage by elder white women (The Story of Babar) or about the polyannish attempt to create utopia by fiat (Babar the King.)
The 'joke' is a lighthearted children's story is turned into heavy depressing poetry by Werner Herzog. An underlying theme may be an intellectual's inability to refrain from over-analyzing simple things and finding depressing themes. A demonstration that ignorance is bliss.
@ipbalkenende I personally don't think it's 'over-analyzing'. It's being realistic. The true crime is to fill children's head with falsehoods that will inevitably be torn asunder before their crying eyes by the forces of reality.
Is this a spoof? Is this fellow a reverse climate snob? Or is this guy my uncle Henry Giguere who operated a steam shovel back in the 40's who had no idea its impact on the natural landscape?
@RyanIverson: that's great (and even better than kleines Engel)! Now please... please please PLEASE make more of these - they are fabulous. And two are just not enough. Hmmm.... how about The Velveteen Rabbit?
@ipbalkenende Contrariwise ... it takes a healthy human to disguise such things (e.g. homosexual themes in children stories, or suppression of feelings themes, glorification of destructive authority etc) and courage to show it. Think Wilhelm Reich vs Sigmund Freud. Of course some ppl will always complain, and want to have the disguise back ... as shown by Alice Miller ...
2stunden 1 week ago
These are are so wonderful. I just hope Klaus K. doesn't rise from the dead and shoot someone over this.
frankenstein1887 2 weeks ago
My father used to read this to me and my 3 older brothers all the time when we were little. I hated it. I always just thought they burned MaryAnn to death :L
glitteraddict44 4 weeks ago
The ka mate haka: a primal, violent cry of conquest. Perhaps the conquest of man over nature? Just as the white man has taken a once proud dance for his rugby games, so does he pervert and deform the land with his machines.
polymphus 4 months ago 2
The Mike Mulligan movie like defines my childhood.
iReAcTzWorld 5 months ago
i used to really like this story (when i was 5) now...im just sad
BurnSpangler 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I hope you don't mind I'm posting these on my blog - picturebooksreview.blogspot.com. Can I include your name or a link for you?
radiosweetheart9 6 months ago
"... surrounded by his guilt, and Mary Anne's twisted, deformed remains."
straton9 7 months ago 4
I wish it was abit louder...
GameNinja13 7 months ago
That was... Morbid.
Cheshirecat55 8 months ago
Perfect, perfect! Ever since I first heard this story at age six I lamented Mary Anne's ignominious end. A fine digging machine, stripped of all dignity...
virginiaorganbuilder 9 months ago 4
Sir, if you don't do the Giving Tree, I don't know how I will get on with my sorry little life.
jbresland 11 months ago 2
I read this book and I have it
fox454x 1 year ago
Comment removed
MSFsean 4 months ago
@MSFsean ??????
fox454x 4 months ago
@fox454x sorry man
MSFsean 4 months ago
Need to marry you **busizz4me.info**
mayakanthineela 1 year ago
More, please! These are hilarious!
mirthblaster36 1 year ago
I need more of these!!
mirthblaster36 1 year ago
Lmao
LingFu123 1 year ago
R. Lee Ermey reads Madeline, maybe?
begrackled 1 year ago
I thought this was a really grim book when I was a kid. Herzog only confirms my suspicions.
radiofan6872 1 year ago
can do the work of a hungrad men in a viick
88pie88 1 year ago
Please please do Babar the Elephant!
gweipo 1 year ago
This video is so goddamn quiet!
Cotundrem 1 year ago
I read a book that was 95 % similar to this book but there were some small similarities anyone know what book I read ?
JFiannaca 1 year ago
@JFiannaca 95% similar but there were also some small similarities... So... would you say it was 100% similar? Was it.... Mike Mulligan And His Steam Shovel??
abetterpepper 1 year ago 3
WTF!
pseudodionysis 1 year ago
Wasn't there a cartoon version of this book?
tsuyoshi15 1 year ago
youtube.com/watch?v=QX_n-4lGGkA
- Brand new Werner Herzog reading of the famous poem 'If' is located at the above link.
DirtyGarnet 1 year ago
I am the same age as this book and readi it since I was five, including to my children. It is a happy story, showing how there is a place for old technology, in this case for a machine that receives a well-earned and functional retirement for a remarkable achievement. The story also demonstrates the psychological truth that we sometimes perform better if people are around to appreciate our endeavours. Only as an adult did I notice that the steam shovel is female.
Herzog has got it wrong.
diplipito11 1 year ago
@diplipito11 Haha come on man, he is not serious. He reads children's books and throws in dark twists. Besides, what any book means is completely subjective to the reader.
AppleCookie117 11 months ago
Oh my god, I loved that book when I was a kid!!!
imneatneatneat 1 year ago
too quiet.
rick4318 1 year ago
really love these but you need to boost the sound I can't hear it very well
on a laptop.
SiLeNtPuNk1 1 year ago
This is my favorite one of the "Warner Herzog reads ___" so far. This was one of my favorite books as a child. Do "Little Black Sambo" next.
jsl6554321 1 year ago
I like the haka chants at the beginning and end of the video. Why? Because they are pointless and have nothing to do with the story. lol
saintdenis11 1 year ago
That sucked. Very boring, without a point and very depressing. Leave me alone to think of happier thoughts.
JoeMarman 1 year ago
sir - you are a genius!
benpapworth 1 year ago
How about Ferdinand?!
StillKingToMe 1 year ago
fuck man that is some heavy dark shit lol it kinda. made the rest of my day sad
rapid638 1 year ago
do twilight.... that would be epic. really think about it.
dragonclam1 1 year ago
I think this one is the best so far!!! :)
sujuk1 1 year ago
brilliant, so so so so so brilliant
Fuzzy192006 1 year ago
Hahahahaha, I'm never the type to laugh at the internets, but oh man, this just ravaged my childhood. Well done, "Warner." Hahahaha.
paxson001 1 year ago
Hahaahaa these were all amazing! :D
Blossomadorable 1 year ago
How about "Werner Herzog reads The Grinch"
Zardoz151 1 year ago 4
May I suggest that you go back and re-read the early Babar books? I suspect that Werner might have some interesting observations about the taming of the metaphorical savage by elder white women (The Story of Babar) or about the polyannish attempt to create utopia by fiat (Babar the King.)
Juneappal 1 year ago
Of all the Werner Herzog impersonators you're by far my favorite one!
pyllyeinari 1 year ago
please make more!
thank you!
flambagels 1 year ago
Wow...I never thought I'd say this, but...Mike Mulligan is worse than Hitler.
Just wow.
ivand1979 1 year ago 2
Mike Mulligan's steam shovel was a MARION, not a Bucyrus!
studebaker62 1 year ago
Idiot...there are simply no other words.
1955ke 1 year ago
ahahahaha rhis is funny shit.
UguyzRnerdZ 1 year ago
Fucking awesome!
shatchett0 1 year ago
i had no idea this was so sad. i thought it was just a lighthearted story about a steam shovel and its operator....
but such is the tragic and inevitable march of time, knowing no rest but death.
sphinks714 1 year ago 2
So I did not get the joke. Again.
bernhardlermann 1 year ago
The 'joke' is a lighthearted children's story is turned into heavy depressing poetry by Werner Herzog. An underlying theme may be an intellectual's inability to refrain from over-analyzing simple things and finding depressing themes. A demonstration that ignorance is bliss.
ipbalkenende 1 year ago 41
@ipbalkenende: your comment is 10X more enjoyable when read out loud in a Werner Herzog accent. yes, i really did that.
doombuggy84 1 year ago 2
HA! It's true!
spindlegold 1 year ago
@ipbalkenende it's awesome how you come off as even less fun than Werner Herzog
howisbabbyformed 1 year ago
@ipbalkenende I personally don't think it's 'over-analyzing'. It's being realistic. The true crime is to fill children's head with falsehoods that will inevitably be torn asunder before their crying eyes by the forces of reality.
Zellig 1 year ago 2
i love you, fake werner herzog
molecularash 1 year ago
Is this a spoof? Is this fellow a reverse climate snob? Or is this guy my uncle Henry Giguere who operated a steam shovel back in the 40's who had no idea its impact on the natural landscape?
dropintheforest 1 year ago
LOL Great
Guinnie 1 year ago
does he say good night my klein zwiebel?
willnother 1 year ago
Comment removed
hasslefactory 1 year ago
Comment removed
hasslefactory 1 year ago
@willnother: I believe he said "Good night, mein kleines Engel."
hasslefactory 1 year ago
Yeah, it's klein zwiebel. Good ear!
RyanIverson 1 year ago
@RyanIverson: that's great (and even better than kleines Engel)! Now please... please please PLEASE make more of these - they are fabulous. And two are just not enough. Hmmm.... how about The Velveteen Rabbit?
hasslefactory 1 year ago 9
@hasslefactory: There's another one coming. Not TVR, but I think you'll like it.
RyanIverson 1 year ago
@RyanIverson What does klein zwiebel mean?
Cheshirecat55 4 months ago
@Cheshirecat55 Small onion.
Waroftheworlds112 2 months ago
Seriously, these are brilliant!
tomaitoe 1 year ago
I love the sign-offs on these, like that one. Sehr lustig
estribillos 1 year ago
Sorry, but this is not the voice of Werner Herzog. Please compare to his documentary work
bernhardlermann 1 year ago
Oh really? Really? This is not really Werner Herzog? Man, I'm glad there are people around to tell me things like this.
sightergoliant 1 year ago 30
Awesome! However, Bad Lieutenant was directed by Abel Ferrara.
qu1et 1 year ago
He directed the "kind-of" remake that came out last year.
shiversjoe 1 year ago
But yeah I agree the audio is too low in the mix.
amarpai007 2 years ago
Brilliant.
amarpai007 2 years ago
This is a work of genius. Thank you!
bunuelista 2 years ago
Why is this one so quiet?
DevonDeFazio 2 years ago
Terrific!
hcmcb4 2 years ago
RyanIverson, I think I got your point.
datingwomensex 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¤ø„¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 9 other vids
¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice
¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background
hotrod1212121 2 years ago
I am in awe with your captivating voice, sir.
iReima 2 years ago
you are a truly sick, beautiful and brilliant man. kudos.
rockandrollmadonna 2 years ago
These are amazing.
EthanMReeser 2 years ago
Amazing. Truly, my childhood is over.
(This was my favorite book growing up.)
UltraNurd 2 years ago
Brilliant.
br1991 2 years ago
Woo!
sidecarcomedy 2 years ago