Added: 2 years ago
From: Hannahsfriend13
Views: 36,395
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (119)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @OfficialIT Not all people. Contrary to popular belief, some actually ARE desperate-- to find something good in their life. Hannah seemed like that kind of person to me. Maybe cause I was the same way, I just wanted one good thing to happen, one. And it didn't for a very long time and it was heartbreaking.

  • I watched all tapes so far without commenting but can everyone please shut up about Selena being bad ? She hasn't done anything yet ? And I think she'll be good and if she's not... ? Well so what none of you have ever made a movie. She can do what she wants and I for one can't wait to see this movie no matter who's hannah. This is a great story... Please don't lower it's expections :)

  • So, who didn't pass the tapes on? >.>;

  • @BelaCharm thats what i was thinking.

  • @BelaCharm Well technically we don't know if the tapes were passed on after Jenny (thats who Clay mailed them 2 cuz the book ended but so far everyones passin it) but the reasons they got out in the first place was because Mr. Porter and he has no one to pass them on2.

  • Hannah told mr.porter to go to hell, she gave him a big hint and he just told her to move on. :/

  • i first thought this was diana agron's voice!:)

  • CHEESE.Is this book.It's Swiss!

    :D

  • so sad :,(

  • She wouldnt tell him ANYTHING, its not his fault..

  • @simpsonbieberbealdes Hannah hinted about suicide about Mr.Porter,He just said "Just move on."

  • Love love love this story, Jay Asher. Though, this isn't how I pictured Hannah's voice.

    I wish more people would read Hannah's story, I think there would be a lot less bullying in high schools if they did.

  • Is this real? I'm so confused because I never read the book I'm going to have to because I hate suspense. Loved the tapes though.

  • love this book so much

  • I don't like this voice. I imagined Hannah's voice to be twisted- in a good way. She wants people to suffer for what they did to her and she wants revenge. She's happy to go away, to take all the pain away yet she knows that some people will miss her. This sounds too...desperate. Like she's sad she's leaving. Some people are glad that they are leaving their 'living hell' and I always imagine her to be one of those people.

  • @OfficialIT Hannah never seemed like the kind of girl who sent these tapes for revenge. Sure, I bet she was angry for what the people did to her. However, I doubt it was ever to make them feel her pain. That seems...too malicious for Hannah. I dont believe she wanted to die either. That's why she went to Mr. Porter, and she brought the tape recorder with her. She wanted to be saved, but she never was. That's why she sounds so sad.

  • Even though I like Selena Gomez, I don't think she would be a good Hannah Baker. I picture Hannah having long blonde hair, and clearly, Selena does not have that. I think Selena Gomez is too Disney-like to play Hannah.

  • @jadeneharmony

    I agree and I really can't picture/want to picture the stuff that happends to Hannah happen to Selena (like the part when she's in the hot tub with that boy)

    I think they should do an all new actor (:

  • @jadeneharmony Wel, how would you know? Selena hasn't had a chance to broaden her genres.Give her chance then give your opinion. You didn't even let Selena try yet. Even Jay Asher thought she was perfect for the role, trust his judgement.

  • @jadeneharmony THANK YOU!

  • Comment removed

  • this girls voice is perfect for how hannah's voice sounds the whole time that I was reading the book I heard this voice. I just can't picture hannah sounding like this with selena gomez but maybe she will do good with this role I'm intrested how she protrays hannah.

  • I loe this book. It broke my heart, although it describes...me. I want to hear about Clay and Skye.

  • Her reasons are similar to my life...... Hannah reminded me of myself.....

  • I'm not to sure if I'm happy with Selena as Hannah. But hey, everyone knows this book is life-changing and hopefully the movie will be too. *wishing*

  • I don't think the voice is that good for Hannah. I mean, it's a pretty dark book, and the girl sounds kind of bright at the rest of the tapes.

  • he should do another book....13 reasons y skye was saved

  • @familyclifton Agree! Skye is so...i don't know, but I feel sorry for her :c

  • this voice reminds me of dianna agron from glee

  • Wheres the rest of the tape?

  • how did you get these?

  • @fabinafan1533 she hinted to about her plans to commit suicide still allowed her to leave his office and failed to follow up properly. His poor advice was the last straw for Hannah.

  • I'm just worried that they will turn it into a sweet, buttoned-up Disney-esk version of 13 Reason's Why

  • @aRoseByAnyOtherName Selena is Hannah & she aint disney anymore

  • @4evermuziclover whatever

  • if selena is casted in this movie i dont think it will be too good..

  • I'm sorry but Selena Gomez has no idea how Hannah feels. She is rich and famous and one of the most loved child actors out there today. She's best friends with her mom and has an attractive boyfriend

  • @aRoseByAnyOtherName so? the reason she is all that is because she is an ACTRESS. she can act

  • the person on the tapes is olivia thirlby, Mila kunis, or ellen page!

  • the person reading this is awesome. i love the voice but i am excited to see how selena gomez does.

  • Selena Gomez is going to play Hannah.

  • @MrsLisaPotter //  I'd rather have Dianna Argon play Hannah... Selena Gomez is uhh not a good actress in my opinion...

  • they are making a movie of it! :D finally

  • I want them to make a movie of this book. Then again, I don't because, they might do the same thing that they did with these tapes. Cut all the important stuff out. I'd rather have no movie than see all the good and important things cut out from it.

  • I heard that they are making a movie - I for one hope they cast a complete unknown as Hannah - Using someone with a face would dilute the effect, if you ask me. . .

  • @aRoseByAnyOtherName selena gomez is cast as hannah baker

  • @0irule01 whaaaaat?

  • @aRoseByAnyOtherName its true. go to wikipedia and type in selena gomez and you will see she is cast. people even announced it

  • @0irule01 No I believe you. I just don't think it fits. I just always saw Hannah more like Hannah Marks, Elizabeth Mclaughlin or Madison Davenport. Pretty, but still shy and kind of awkward.

  • Why didn't they use this Hannah on the audiobook? The Hannah on the audiobook kinda sucked because she seemed to have a throat infection or something.

  • Hannah sounds exactly the way I imagined. This book is so tragic... I wish people would never feel that way about themselves.

  • This chicks a cry baby suck it up

  • If i was her, i think i wouldve done the same thing.. her life is crazy. She was traumatized by all the stuff that went around her. :/

  • @Mivillim actually she said that she failed. So she did blame herself

  • What did Mr. Porter Do??

  • I think the book is stupid . It was Hannahs' desision to kill herself, wasn't it ?!

    So now she gives the fault to other peaple . She could have searched for help !

  • @CaribaPhoebeFan She did. You should read it. Besides, honestly, you don't get it until you're there. These people are the thirteen reasons why she committed suicide. You don't up and decide to kill yourself for no reason, and most of the time, the reasons are based in the actions of other people. I enjoyed the book. 

  • @LovelessInfinity333

    She could have searched for help. It's not like killing herself was the only way out of this 'Drama' ...

  • @CaribaPhoebeFan She did the only thing she could do: she talked to a guidance counselor, possibly the only one in her school.

  • @CaribaPhoebeFan

    It's called disposition of depression.

    Not stupidity.

  • I hope they make a movie ..

  • Is it just me or did she not do the whole tapes?

    But either way -- fabulous job!

  • Its great

  • I noticed that not everything Hannah said was in the tapes as Im reading the book, because there are things she's saying I dont remember...Did you leave parts off? just asking. Or maybe I wasnt paying attention to her? But I'll be damned if I wasnt paying attention..I was doing nothing else except listening to the tapes. lol.

  • Hannahsfriend13, please finish the tapes. I realize that this is a way to promote the selling of the book, but please let us hear the whole cassette tapes. This book is so moving and every time I hear the voice of "Hannah Baker," I get tears in my eyes. I would really just like to hear the whole tapes.

    Thank you for your time,

    Anissa

  • These tapes are cool! Love the book also!

    woah! go up to your address bar, put the letter "Q" between the words you and tube, then press enter or click go

  • i thought it was so stupid he didnt even do anything for her i was like wtf??? why the hell didnt u help her!!!

  • they should make a movie, oh and this person who is talking on the tapes is just right for hannah's voice!!!! they should make more to the tapes.... :) the book is sad, and I'm glad this never happened in real life

  • @DaddysGirl4ver

    i agree. they should make this a movie. :)

    itd be amazing.

  • i agree,

    sadly though things like this do happen in real life. people are ignorant and don't help the ones who need it most. the outcome is suicide. :'/

  • @DaddysGirl4ver

    I agree. The unfortunate thing is though that stuff like this does happen in real life, more often than it ever should.

  • @DaddysGirl4ver It could happen

    

  • @DaddysGirl4ver sadly it does happen every day but the tape idea i doubt...

  • @DaddysGirl4ver It happens in real life all the time.

  • @DaddysGirl4ver they're making the movie, but selena gomez is playing hannah...which i dont approve of but oh well, she's a good actress

  • @DaddysGirl4ver I bet you this has happened in real life almost to me...

  • @DaddysGirl4ver

    They are making a movie. Selena Gomez is playing Hanna

  • @DaddysGirl4ver i think theyre making a movie in 2012 or 2013

  • @DaddysGirl4ver Unfortunately, even worse things have happened in real life..

  • the book made me cry so much !!! especially cassett 4

  • wheres clay??

  • tape 9

  • this book was soo good (;

  • i really wanna read the book but aLL MY FRIENDS ARE READING IT AND WHEN THEY FINISH THEY WILL LET ME BORROW IT SO I REALLY WANT THEM TO FINISH.

  • you should say moree

    like seriously

    these need to be longer

    they freaked me outt

    <3

  • omg x 3!!! the last tape!!! yaay~~~

  • I LOVED the book! IT made me cry! and these tapes are really good.

  • any1 kno wen the movie comes out?

  • I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U! I love this! Are there gonna be anymore? Because I read part of this at a book store and isn't there a HOT TUB before this? You should do the whole thing. The whole tapes I mean.

  • agh i love these tapes!!

    but whats gonna happen now??

  • wat happens now is u READ THE BOOK

  • ive already READ THE BOOK about 4 months ago.

    what im wondering is whats gonna happen now with these videos since its reached the final person =)

  • is that it?

  • well thats not how it ends... most of these tapes skip some parts of the actual book but the story goes on after this

  • i love love love love this girl's voice...it's what i think hannah would have sounded like.

  • I love her voice too!!

  • Good job!!! =) i love it. ur asome!

  • isn't the 13th tape supposed to be for Clay jensen? I haven't read the book, but that's what I expected, even so I love this part, it feels so real

  • awesome! :) i wonder who records these.

  • I LOVED ITTTTTTTTT

    but of course she gives life another chance.

    otherwise this wouldent be very good. you know what i mean? ooh... there's 13 tapes, and now shes dead. no. because that's just not what a good writer does. they make it so you have to buy another book, or you know promote the liking to the author.

  • shes dead didnt your read it? lol shes not coming back

  • ? i didn't read the book.... i was just going by the tapes.

  • she is dead... read the book... the book is awesome!!!

  • well thats why your clueless.

    shes dead.

    she really did kill herself.

    why would she make those tapes then not do it?

    thats really dumb.

  • well here it says shes giving life another chance, to keep the tapes going i guess?

  • Just in case...

  • oh lol ok you should it answers the questions and its better

  • But she dies....before the book even starts I believe. Did you even read it, crispi? And, besides, the only authors I know of that've done that are JKR and stefenie meyer. and doing things like that for that reason make them bad writers. good writers tell a story as it should be, not change it specifically to keep book sales going.

  • Comment removed

  • OMG! jon you listen to these too?!

  • Comment removed

  • My god, you're dumb!

  • um....i dont get this one,is there a continued tape? oh well i luv these vids!!!

  • Wow, I'm the second viewer of this video. Never done that before. Getting interesting!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more