Very strange interpretation...too rushed, too staccato, almost like he had somewhere else to be in a hurry. Also, it might be the recording, but that's the worst sounding Steinway I've ever heard.
Apparently he had not his day, he cannot keep his mouth shut while playing: some cold or whatever. He plays too hasty and the resolution at 8'30" is much too quick. Ashame for a great pianist. I would advise him to delete this performace.
@hendrik044 I would advice to leave it like it is.But if you want to delete go ahead.Wat houd je eigenlijk tegen?Belachelijke kommentaar geven om jezelf belangrijk te voelen?
The very worse version I have heard of this Ballade. Did he swallow a metronome or what? The paradox is, Why does he put such extasis faces for such quality of performance? God!
This is an incredible piece, and it deserves a much better performance than this. This is downright mediocre. He takes no rubato, and barely phrases. At 3:25, that is such a huge climax, but the way he plays it, I feel like nothing happened. And the end! I have never heard anything so efficient! And come on! Slowing down at the end? Your in the middle of an accelerando! This is awful!
@Shivalingam9 He hardly ever releases wrist/arm - maybe that's why he has had to cancel so many concerts due to hand injuries. As Rosina Lhevinne said - "Fingers, fingers, fingers - that's all I hear!" Still love his musicianship, though.
@maestrojimbo: In 1990, Perahia suffered a cut to his right thumb, which became septic. He took antibiotics for this condition, but they affected his health. In 1992, his career was threatened by a bone abnormality in his hand causing inflammation requiring several years away from the keyboard, and a series of operations. Do you mean to say that the bone abnormality was caused by his failure to release his wrist/arm? If so, that's the most absurd thing I've heard in a while. :P
@juniore1 I was being tongue in cheek about my computer but I'll agree with you about it being an old recording. Nothing worse than wobbly notes. Does something to my ears :)
my favorite chopin ballade performances are done by perahia. i have them on cd. this one is great, and i like the one i have on cd even better, i think it's a little older.
altogether amongst so many greats i prefer perahia's chopin. he proves that playing chopin's pieces exactly like how chopin wrote them without getting all creative and changing things around and ruining the music does NOT mean playing them flat and lifeless. his way of playing chopin is similar to rubinstein's i think.
@brassmonkeyjew: so 63 it too old to be sharing musical genius. You know nothing of this man and his capabilities for if you did you would not be making such absurd statements. I have attended many recitals of perahia all throughout the last two decades and his playing has only become more impassioned. His technique has not lost any of it's vibrancy. None!
Going to see this magnificent pianist live at the Bridgewater Hall next week and he is playing not this ballade but ballade no.3 alongside a second half dedicated to Chopin and first half includes Bach and Beethoven and I am really looking forward to the concert, he remains one of the greatest performers still on the concert platform today.
Don't waste your time and money. He's far to old now to be worth your while!
Spend the time and money instead, toward inventing a time machine. So you can attend this very concert, back when he still could do the music justice!
It's nothing personal. Every musician comes with an expiry date. Just be thankful we live in this day and age where we have a record of his past greatness forever contained!
And the silly twit did himself no favours in his own P.R when he said pianists after the age of 60 were past it. The only thing I can suggest is that pianists over the age of 60 do still have it and are not past it and that really infuriates him as he tries to establish his position alongside far greater pianists than he and also he is hacked off he never really had it in the first place. All pyrotechnical wizardry with no thought to the performance or sensitivity to the composers intentions
Perahia still sounds ten times better even with poor sound quality than that buffoon Lang Bang as he bangs, clangs, crashes and wollops his way round the piano IN DIGITAL QUALITY SOUND I MIGHT ADD WHICH MAKES IT SOUND EVEN WORSE OR HEAVEN FORBID YOU WASTE YOUR MONEY ON A TICKET TO SEE HIM LIVE(AS IF?) in a feeble attempt to extract some sort of music out of the piano that is audible AS MUSIC. Perahia in digital sound quality and live performance has no comparison with Banger Langer.
@lewars1912 Believe me I have tried to appreciate his playing as he has such a cult following but find I no soul in his playing, if his interpretations matched his showmanship he would have everything, but as it is he is just the latter.
This is from a VHS tape of a WKAR production circa 1981, televised from the Kellogg Center on the campus of Michigan State University. Hence one can't expect "digital" quality.
I have never doubted Perahia's musicality, especially in Chopin and Bach. A great recording! Are there other recordings by him playing the other 3 ballades? I would be interested to watch.
This could well be Horowitz's piano...it sounds like it. Horowitz let no one touch it, however he liked Murray Perrahia so much he lent it to him for concert use. I don't know when it was though. Anyone got any ideas?
Although at times his tone and phrasings were well done, his timing and structural frame for the piece is unsteady, thus lacking nobility and grace, which is the hallmark of true Chopin.
Is it just me or is any comment deviating from the lines of "wow this is the best EVER" getting five thumbs down or more? If the latter, then this comment is going to get pretty far into the negatives...
Yeah, I've noticed that as well.. fanboyism is a bad thing. (I bet I'm gonna get a lot of thumbs down as well) Not to be mistaken, I think he plays very well.
The whole Universe is in awe of human hair patterns. Hey, it's the first thing *I* notice in anybody - politicians, artists, school teachers, carpenters, the unemployed....
Same here... Though I've never thought Snape has that type of hair ( I imagine it longer and more tangled, as it was in the book). I'm more reminded of that crazy assassin Anton Chigurr (Javier Bardem) in No Country for Old Men. This guy's just a bit more friendly-looking...
I have heard Perahia live, and there is something so magical in his sound you need to be there in person to hear it. If you ever get a chance, do whatever it takes to hear this man in person, you will not regret it!
No doubt Perahia is an extremely accomplished pianist. With that said, I prefer the Ashkenazy interpretation of this Ballade. Vlad plays it with such delicacy that it can make you cry.
oh dude... just listen to zimerman, harasiewicz, rubinstein, pollini... perahia's interpretation is not bad of course but imo it's nothing senstaional...
The first time I heard Perahia was on the radio sometime in mid 80's with his interpretation of Chopin's Fantaisie Impromptu. It was almost an effeminate interpretation certainly lacking the 'agitato' I was so accustomed to hearing. But the more I listened the more I was entranced by his playing. When it was over, I misunderstood the announcer to say that it was "Marie Perahia" thus confirming my intitial impression. Regardless, I love Perahia - certainly a GIANT among giants!
The short section around 2:40 is, to me, the most sublime piano 'moment' of all time. There's a section in Scarlatti's Sonata no. 87 that comes close but this one makes me swoon. Brilliant.
It has been said that every aspect of technique touched uponm by Chopin in his etudes is addressed in this Ballade. That in itself is wonder enough.....
I've been having a love affair with it all my life! The opening three octaves float in from out some silvery stillness - and then the narrative that follows, all passion and poetry so measuredly spent. This Ballade alone places Chopin amongst the choicest masters of his art for here more than anywhere his writing is so closely aligned to Bach and it is that that sets Chopin apart - his counterpoint - and Perahia here is a Prince! Utterly superb!
Glorious account of one of the masterpieces of the piano repertoire. Even then Murray was a beautifully sensitive performer; everything he has done since has, in my view, simply confirmed his status as a giant of the keyboard, not only in our own time but of any time.
not real legato sorry
chadmaster410 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very strange interpretation...too rushed, too staccato, almost like he had somewhere else to be in a hurry. Also, it might be the recording, but that's the worst sounding Steinway I've ever heard.
jjp009 3 months ago
he looks like miss swan! excellent performance of this masterpiece.
AvidHobbyist 5 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Apparently he had not his day, he cannot keep his mouth shut while playing: some cold or whatever. He plays too hasty and the resolution at 8'30" is much too quick. Ashame for a great pianist. I would advise him to delete this performace.
hendrik044 5 months ago
@hendrik044 I would advice to leave it like it is.But if you want to delete go ahead.Wat houd je eigenlijk tegen?Belachelijke kommentaar geven om jezelf belangrijk te voelen?
abmsghost1 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The very worse version I have heard of this Ballade. Did he swallow a metronome or what? The paradox is, Why does he put such extasis faces for such quality of performance? God!
IndustrialMarketing1 5 months ago
I didn't know Professor Snape played the piano.
carsonlo 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is an incredible piece, and it deserves a much better performance than this. This is downright mediocre. He takes no rubato, and barely phrases. At 3:25, that is such a huge climax, but the way he plays it, I feel like nothing happened. And the end! I have never heard anything so efficient! And come on! Slowing down at the end? Your in the middle of an accelerando! This is awful!
SpongedobShortpants 6 months ago
at 8:46 its like chopin thought "let me through this ending in for all those who thought the rest of the piece was hard"
JazZebra 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This sound quality does no justice to this amazing Performance whatsoever! It's a crime! Get the Youtube police on this video!
wagneristhebest 7 months ago
@Shivalingam9 He hardly ever releases wrist/arm - maybe that's why he has had to cancel so many concerts due to hand injuries. As Rosina Lhevinne said - "Fingers, fingers, fingers - that's all I hear!" Still love his musicianship, though.
maestrojimbo 8 months ago
Comment removed
liszt85 7 months ago
@maestrojimbo: In 1990, Perahia suffered a cut to his right thumb, which became septic. He took antibiotics for this condition, but they affected his health. In 1992, his career was threatened by a bone abnormality in his hand causing inflammation requiring several years away from the keyboard, and a series of operations. Do you mean to say that the bone abnormality was caused by his failure to release his wrist/arm? If so, that's the most absurd thing I've heard in a while. :P
liszt85 7 months ago
murray is a living legend. one of the best pianist in all times
klausknulp 8 months ago 2
/watch?v=a_Adh_H2Roc
hellboyreloaded 8 months ago
Zim is great; but I have to go with Murray's live take on #4.
P.S. there are no "best" renditions of any Chopin work(except for the one the
composer left behind; but was voted off the island 'cause Rachmaninov
played it faster.) So much is personal choice; and we are lucky to have options;
among which to choose
TheJmd441 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great performance!! Amazing!! Absolutely perfect!!!
infospaceserver 1 year ago
ringo starr playing classical music!
musicandminastirith 1 year ago
i love the looks of ecstasy on his face as the young Perahia channels the brilliance of the master Chopin
TheRealBobbyChase 1 year ago
This is divine but I think Zimerman is better.
stefanpetkovic 1 year ago
I like it.. but please listen to bolet :)
FishGush 1 year ago
c'est pas mal il faut écouter celle de samoschko au concour reine élisabeth de belgique
fastben2010 1 year ago
c'est pas mal il faut écouter celle de samoschko
fastben2010 1 year ago
Magical !
christinehoffmanred 1 year ago
Is it my computer or does this sound out of tune? Notes sound wobbly.
lewars1912 1 year ago
@lewars1912 is just the recording. Like in the old movies, you know :)
juniore1 1 year ago
@juniore1 I was being tongue in cheek about my computer but I'll agree with you about it being an old recording. Nothing worse than wobbly notes. Does something to my ears :)
lewars1912 1 year ago
Peerless.
maestroadam 1 year ago
Magical - for me, this is just right.
sanfranpam 1 year ago
Perahia har sitt plats i musiken for alltid vackert och väl spelad,chopin.
Perahia tiene para siempre su lugar en la musica i muy bien interpretado,bueno chopin.
erasmobernales 1 year ago
one of the best interpretation of this poetry
fxv26 1 year ago
my favorite chopin ballade performances are done by perahia. i have them on cd. this one is great, and i like the one i have on cd even better, i think it's a little older.
altogether amongst so many greats i prefer perahia's chopin. he proves that playing chopin's pieces exactly like how chopin wrote them without getting all creative and changing things around and ruining the music does NOT mean playing them flat and lifeless. his way of playing chopin is similar to rubinstein's i think.
ibclappin 1 year ago
@brassmonkeyjew: so 63 it too old to be sharing musical genius. You know nothing of this man and his capabilities for if you did you would not be making such absurd statements. I have attended many recitals of perahia all throughout the last two decades and his playing has only become more impassioned. His technique has not lost any of it's vibrancy. None!
Chopin1976l 1 year ago 6
inspiring
willpianofreak 1 year ago 6
Wow !! 7 months !!@@
what a long journey !!
gcaee 1 year ago
is there a video of Perahia playing Chopin's 2nd scherzo? I can't seem to find it on YouTube...
mangagrl01 1 year ago
PERAHIA's !!! performance TOUCHES MY HEART SO DEEPLY..:-) Soo..I keep watching this video for..7 months now..:-)
Again.. So grateful for sharing !
lanarv 1 year ago 15
Going to see this magnificent pianist live at the Bridgewater Hall next week and he is playing not this ballade but ballade no.3 alongside a second half dedicated to Chopin and first half includes Bach and Beethoven and I am really looking forward to the concert, he remains one of the greatest performers still on the concert platform today.
TheGreatPerahia 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheGreatPerahia
Don't waste your time and money. He's far to old now to be worth your while!
Spend the time and money instead, toward inventing a time machine. So you can attend this very concert, back when he still could do the music justice!
It's nothing personal. Every musician comes with an expiry date. Just be thankful we live in this day and age where we have a record of his past greatness forever contained!
brassmonkeyjew 1 year ago
And the silly twit did himself no favours in his own P.R when he said pianists after the age of 60 were past it. The only thing I can suggest is that pianists over the age of 60 do still have it and are not past it and that really infuriates him as he tries to establish his position alongside far greater pianists than he and also he is hacked off he never really had it in the first place. All pyrotechnical wizardry with no thought to the performance or sensitivity to the composers intentions
TheGreatPerahia 2 years ago 13
Perahia still sounds ten times better even with poor sound quality than that buffoon Lang Bang as he bangs, clangs, crashes and wollops his way round the piano IN DIGITAL QUALITY SOUND I MIGHT ADD WHICH MAKES IT SOUND EVEN WORSE OR HEAVEN FORBID YOU WASTE YOUR MONEY ON A TICKET TO SEE HIM LIVE(AS IF?) in a feeble attempt to extract some sort of music out of the piano that is audible AS MUSIC. Perahia in digital sound quality and live performance has no comparison with Banger Langer.
TheGreatPerahia 2 years ago 17
@TheGreatPerahia I think you secretly love both Bang Lang and Lang Bang.
lewars1912 1 year ago
@lewars1912 Believe me I have tried to appreciate his playing as he has such a cult following but find I no soul in his playing, if his interpretations matched his showmanship he would have everything, but as it is he is just the latter.
TheGreatPerahia 1 year ago
@TheGreatPerahia I too dislike Bang Bang.
maestroadam 1 year ago
@maestroadam Well, have you ever heard him live?
TheAL845 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
um he looks ugly:DD
pebbli94 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
there lacks a sensitivity or gracefulness, which is made up or replaced entirely with forcefulness and forward motion
mdoub 2 years ago
@mdoub
You make abslolutely no sense. Try again.
Frozentoes1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
his hair looks like chopin's.lols
danielchong1234 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
His everything looks like Chopin...he could be a clone
wewantcupcakes 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hahaha
danielchong1234 2 years ago
This is from a VHS tape of a WKAR production circa 1981, televised from the Kellogg Center on the campus of Michigan State University. Hence one can't expect "digital" quality.
ronaldjevans 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
good but nothing to do eith zimerman's interpretation
0bambi0deer0 2 years ago
I have never doubted Perahia's musicality, especially in Chopin and Bach. A great recording! Are there other recordings by him playing the other 3 ballades? I would be interested to watch.
SimplifiedIce 2 years ago 3
Yes, he has recorded all 4
youvebeensmoked 2 years ago
this recording sounds sooo much like horowitzs piano. its very mellow and a tingly nasal sound. love it
spike2133876 2 years ago 12
Very well put.
adrct 2 years ago 3
I think it's partly the sound quality, but I do understand what you mean
youvebeensmoked 2 years ago
i love this song its really amazin
animalover82 2 years ago 7
Argh! It's not a song, it's a piece. There are no words!
juzzyfuzz 2 years ago 7
i wish it were a better recording because despite the low quality i still keep listening
kettlebellconvert 2 years ago 14
simply amazing, IMO best of the 4 ballades
RapidFire929 2 years ago 15
This is magnificent playing. Fabulously musical.
cattleman6420012000 2 years ago 19
fantastic work. why aren't the audience on their feet at the end?
OJD84 2 years ago 28
This has been flagged as spam show
cuz they're old lol
Bzakatron 2 years ago
@OJD84 all snobs !!!!
flouz2 2 months ago in playlist Récital
truly unsurpassibly magnificent
PhilPhilUSA 2 years ago 20
I can hear the dynamics of Horowitz here.
herraotic 2 years ago 30
that's right!
zurzica51 2 years ago 7
What a beautiful dialogue..piano-pianist :-)
He sees nobody..So impressive,and expressive :-)
Can't stop watching it..
lanarv 2 years ago 35
My new favorite interpretation of, in my opinion, the most beautiful piece in piano literature
aznfilamdude 2 years ago 38
This has been flagged as spam show
Toca bien, pero es feo el guacho ee!! jajaja
Paradoxes09 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jajaj!sisi
tsequ 2 years ago
This could well be Horowitz's piano...it sounds like it. Horowitz let no one touch it, however he liked Murray Perrahia so much he lent it to him for concert use. I don't know when it was though. Anyone got any ideas?
davidgray2 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Although at times his tone and phrasings were well done, his timing and structural frame for the piece is unsteady, thus lacking nobility and grace, which is the hallmark of true Chopin.
freeqwerqwer 2 years ago
I agree
deleuzeguattarixxx 2 years ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
Is it just me or is any comment deviating from the lines of "wow this is the best EVER" getting five thumbs down or more? If the latter, then this comment is going to get pretty far into the negatives...
Robotman42 2 years ago
Haha you just made the idiots shoot themselves in the foot! Although you have to admit, he does play it quite well!
davidgray2 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah, I've noticed that as well.. fanboyism is a bad thing. (I bet I'm gonna get a lot of thumbs down as well) Not to be mistaken, I think he plays very well.
taviona 2 years ago
Extremely beautiful and sensitive playing.
cattleman6420012000 2 years ago 43
This has been flagged as spam show
Doesn't have a natural singing line as does Zimerman
maxi937 2 years ago
Oh yeah, like that piece was hard!!!! Just kidding!!! Amazing playing here!!
Gman6755 2 years ago
touching. beautifull tone. just great!
paradajz13 2 years ago 26
This has been flagged as spam show
even though he's not a midget, he always looks like one in the videos. sorry, i had to say something negative, everyone is being absurdly positive.
mdoub 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I just have to say.. He looks a bit like Severus Snape with that hair!! That said, I think this interpretation is so charming and enchanting!!!
GrandPatzer 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The whole Universe is in awe of human hair patterns. Hey, it's the first thing *I* notice in anybody - politicians, artists, school teachers, carpenters, the unemployed....
nearenough3 2 years ago
Same here... Though I've never thought Snape has that type of hair ( I imagine it longer and more tangled, as it was in the book). I'm more reminded of that crazy assassin Anton Chigurr (Javier Bardem) in No Country for Old Men. This guy's just a bit more friendly-looking...
Ginatus 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahaha Snape...
Elicgt 2 years ago
What a lovely hair he used to have !
Paulo78180 2 years ago
Incredible! This is easily one of my favorite Chopin pieces.
rocklikeluda 2 years ago 24
This has been flagged as spam show
the only thing wrong with this vid was the haircut
jimmyshitbags 3 years ago
good one. But you gotta remember: it's the 80's.
AvidHobbyist 3 years ago
this is pure love!
bassodivo 3 years ago 61
This has been flagged as spam show
Hurray!
daughtersprince 3 years ago
from still anuder admirer
ri8009 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
huh? don't thumbs down me
bonesat 3 years ago
I have heard Perahia live, and there is something so magical in his sound you need to be there in person to hear it. If you ever get a chance, do whatever it takes to hear this man in person, you will not regret it!
HansVonBulow 3 years ago 114
@HansVonBulow I have been in a masterclass he gave. It was breathtaking! Truly fascinating!
This is one of the greatest musicians I have ever heard.
pila406 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
No doubt Perahia is an extremely accomplished pianist. With that said, I prefer the Ashkenazy interpretation of this Ballade. Vlad plays it with such delicacy that it can make you cry.
FrankBo26 3 years ago
the best recording i have heard of the best piece ever made for piano
guillermopv90 3 years ago 104
i second that motion
bassodivo 3 years ago 46
@guillermopv90 you know, I agree. I think as well, that this is the greatest piece ever written for solo piano.
maestroadam 1 year ago
@guillermopv90
"Zoltan Kocsis plays Chopin's Ballade 4 live" THE BEST
akossziklai 1 year ago
@guillermopv90 you should listen Zimermann
Distefanix 1 year ago 5
@Distefanix i like zimermann and perahia but i much prefer to listen to perlemuter
paulphilip1 10 months ago
@guillermopv90
oh dude... just listen to zimerman, harasiewicz, rubinstein, pollini... perahia's interpretation is not bad of course but imo it's nothing senstaional...
mx19idlewilder 11 months ago
la mejor interpretación de la balada no 4 de chopin, en mi opinión
guillermopv90 3 years ago 62
The first time I heard Perahia was on the radio sometime in mid 80's with his interpretation of Chopin's Fantaisie Impromptu. It was almost an effeminate interpretation certainly lacking the 'agitato' I was so accustomed to hearing. But the more I listened the more I was entranced by his playing. When it was over, I misunderstood the announcer to say that it was "Marie Perahia" thus confirming my intitial impression. Regardless, I love Perahia - certainly a GIANT among giants!
utubuser10 3 years ago 4
The short section around 2:40 is, to me, the most sublime piano 'moment' of all time. There's a section in Scarlatti's Sonata no. 87 that comes close but this one makes me swoon. Brilliant.
ToledoWingNut 3 years ago 5
wow!!!
stienwayz 3 years ago 70
yeah, this guy is amazing.
piedijon 3 years ago 66
My goodness, this man just blew me away with his interpretation.
Rure 3 years ago 79
Whats the name of this man?
dirtybirdiebob 3 years ago
Murray Perahia
deichhorn 3 years ago
It has been said that every aspect of technique touched uponm by Chopin in his etudes is addressed in this Ballade. That in itself is wonder enough.....
PhillipLWilcher 3 years ago 65
I've been having a love affair with it all my life! The opening three octaves float in from out some silvery stillness - and then the narrative that follows, all passion and poetry so measuredly spent. This Ballade alone places Chopin amongst the choicest masters of his art for here more than anywhere his writing is so closely aligned to Bach and it is that that sets Chopin apart - his counterpoint - and Perahia here is a Prince! Utterly superb!
PhillipLWilcher 3 years ago 66
Glorious account of one of the masterpieces of the piano repertoire. Even then Murray was a beautifully sensitive performer; everything he has done since has, in my view, simply confirmed his status as a giant of the keyboard, not only in our own time but of any time.
rabengeraun 3 years ago 63
Absolutely phenomenal!
halevans7 3 years ago 57
I love the beginning so much!! This is a rare recording.
shijunpiano 3 years ago 43
Good work!
aaabbbccc5 4 years ago 21
This has been flagged as spam show
oNE OF A KIND...
Wandalandowskaya47 4 years ago 20