I really felt sorry for Logan , but to be honest it was always Jess & Rory .
they werde made for each other, yes he left her once when he was 18 and went to cali .. but he got his life together, worte a book, begged rory to come with him, told her " i love you" and so many other things.
i even disliked rory when she was with logan, cause she changed so much.
OH MY GOD SAY YES STUPID!!!!! T___T They were sooo perfect for each other ;( I always thought, that Logan would be Rorys big love and if my big love would ask me to marry me i would say yes! T__T I hate this T__T
I see that Rory and Logan are perfect together ,, i hate that she refused in the end ,, he was like her soul mate ,, she thinks only of her career ,, i still can't believe it , how could she say NO ????!!
you can so tell that Lorelai basically told Rory to say no. Rory trusts her mom above herself and Lorelai hates Logan. Why the hell would Rory ask her mom, who only ever liked Dean, if she should marry Logan. I wouldn't listen to anyone if i was proposed to. I would ask myself, if I could see myself with that person for the rest of my life and if I love them above anyone else. Rory loved Logan and cared for him and worried about him while he was in the hospital. That would be a yes to me
@TheMostEvilAngel Of course she's not happy. She'll be losing Rory since if she did marry him since they would go to San Francisco. That's the one thing I didn't like about Lorelai. Even though they were so close, she doesn't ever want to lose Rory. Yet she still lost her in the end when Rory worked as a Obama's reporter. She needs to learn to let go.
@shadesofgrey1947 Why does it say it all? Lorelai really annoys me sometimes. She thought neither Jess nor Logan was good enough for Rory and the only person she was ever happy with was Dean, who would have held Rory back. I like Lorelai but she judged way too easily, funny because she screwed up every relationship she ever had.
@sylarisshot cheating IS black and white and he did cheat. I don't hate Logan, but Jess was better for Rory. And I'm not saying leaving is a small thing, but Jess did it once. Logan screwed up many more times. And I'm not stalking you, you replied to me on another video, which his why I know what you said. And ok, if you like rich spoiled guys then that's your choice. We'll just agree to disagree.
@XshamosasX No, it isn't? Are you 13. Have you even been in a relationship? Cheating sucks because someone breaks your trust. If that someone doesn't even think he is in a relationship with you, how is he breaking your trust?
How did Logan screw up more than Jess?
And hey, if you like pretentious entitled guys, that's your choice too.
@sylarishot I'm 14 actually, and no I have not been in a relationship. It wasn't cheating to Logan, but they were not officially broken up. Even if he didn't technically cheat, what he did was wrong. And like I said, Jess didn't exactly get many chances to screw up, considering their relationship didn't last very long. He skipped town and didn't tell her, okay. That was once. Logan however, encouraged her to drink, party, steal, quit school as well as "breaking up" with her, cheating, being a
@XshamosasX Actually, that was all of Rory's doing. He never wanted to steal a boat, that was all Rory. Logan always thought Rory would go back to school, but Rory was hardheaded. Logan let Rory be herself actually. And Jess was the one who was honest about it. It was Rory who was making all the wrong decisions.
@mmmmmvodka It wasn't his idea, but he encouraged it. And no he didn't... he just let her do it, not even ONCE did he try to convince her to go back. Logan changed her completely - it was his influence. Yes, it was her doing, but around him, she was different - maybe it wasn't actually his fault, but around Jess she was completely herself. You could see it when he came back to see her, their banter, everything, she acted like the old Rory.
@sylarishot dick to Jess, telling Lucy and Marty about Marty and Rory's friendship, etc. Other things too, but I can't remember. Also, about the cheating thing, one thing that bothered me was that Logan never even acknowledged that what he did was wrong - he just kept making excuses and went on and on about what a great boyfriend he was. Also, in the end he discouraged Rory from following her dreams, while Jess was always the one who encouraged her.
LOL I love how even though this is a Rory/Logan video, the Jess and Rory forever comment is the highest comment. I think it's undeniable that Rory and Jess are meant to be together, & they clearly have the biggest fan base. Also, ASP always meant for them to end up together... so take THAT Logan/Rory and Dean/Rory shippers! That being said, I did like Logan & Rory at times. They were cute together, but they're just no comparison to Rory/Jess. Plus, she was a completely different person w/ Logan.
@XshamosasX I don't know how that is undeniable? Rory rejected Jess. End of story. She grew as a person with Logan. They were together for a LONG time. People change.
@sylarishot She changed for the worst. Rory after season 4 was just insufferable. She didn't "grow as a person"... she went backwards. How does it matter how long they were together for? So what if she rejected Jess? The only reason she was with Logan for so long was because Milo refused to come back in season 7... and that's not just my opinion, that's a fact. Even the writers believed that they would have ended up together in the end.
@XshamosasX That's your opinion. I loved her throughout. I thought the change in her was gradual and natural. Their time together matters because it is stupid to say that Rory was a 'different person' around him. Rory met him when she was young and she spent years with with him. Whether YOU think that she was insufferable is beyond the point. She changed as a person because people change. Not because of Logan.
@sylarishot Question: what makes u love Rory exactly? The fact that she slept with a married guy, stole a yacht, became so weak for a guy that she agreed to having a casual relationship (which is basically sleeping around in my eyes) & became so weak that 1 opinion caused her to drop out of Yale? Or that she treats her mom and grandparents like crap, &forgives a guy again &again even after he cheated on her? Btw, everyone says Jess treated her like dirt but Logan did things that were WAY worse.
@XshamosasX People make mistakes. Her mistakes made her more real. She wasn't perfect. & LOL with your slut shaming. There is nothing wrong with casual relationships. Rory and Logan went out together, they weren't just sleeping around. So, it doesn't matter what it looked like IN YOUR EYES. Logan never cheated on her. And no, Jess treated her way worse.
@sylarishot And actually, it does matter what it looks like in my eyes because it is MY OPINION. Logan did cheat on her - she didn't know they were broken up and he never clarified. There is no gray area in cheating... it either happens or it doesn't. All Jess did was leave. That's IT. Logan screwed up WAY more. And can you make up your mind, because in another video you said you liked Rory and Jess better than Rory and Logan, and Jess better as a character than Logan, so...
@XshamosasX You are a misogynist then, have a star. & No. Things are never that black or white. Cheating is horrible because a person who swore his commitment to you did not value it. Logan DID NOT do that. & Lol at you categorizing all the hurt Jess put Rory through as 'just leaving'. Oh, cute. You are stalking me. Yes, I like Jess/Rory more than Logan/Rory. I still think Logan/Rory makes way more sense. Jess was a better constructed character than Logan. I still like Logan more.
@XshamosasX & Jess/= Milo. In CANNON, Rory rejected Jess because she was in love with Logan. Jess and Rory were together for half a season and he treated her like shit. The writers may have planned for great things for Rory/Jess but guess what? They didn't pan out. In CANNON, Rory and Logan make way more sense than Jess/Rory ever will.
& that is not a fact anyway. Milo refused to return after S4. That's when Logan was introduced.
@sylarishot well you're one of the few, because A LOT, I'd say majority, of fans found her insufferable after s4. He didn't treat her like shit, & they didn't happen because Milo didn't want to return... Rory/Jess made less sense than Rory/Logan? Are you kidding me? Whatever, that's your opinion, but the reason R&J have the biggest fan base is because they make the most sense. They understand each other. They were endgame and everyone knew that... uh, after s4? He was in s6, in case you forgot.
@XshamosasX Of course, he treated her like shit. And what has the biggest fanbase got to do with it? If I wanted to read the fans' version of the show, I'd read fanfiction. How do they make more sense? Logan and Rory went through so much together. They stuck with each other through thick and thin. They both grew as people together. That is way greater than some high school fling.
Yes, after S4. Jess came in S6 so that he could get closure. The writers wanted to end their chapter once & for all.
@sylarishot Fanbase has a lot to do with it. &maybe you should get your facts right - he didnt come back for closure, he was supposed to come back for more episodes and ASP's original ending had Rory and Jess as a couple - which does in fact make them the meant to be couple because they actually WERE supposed to end up together. & R&J make more sense because he understood Rory in a way Logan never did - i.e. he was the only person who could convince her to go back to Yale. Logan didn't even try!
I loved Jess :) Dean was way to boring for me and Logan was too ... I don't know, too cliche? In my head Jess always ended up with Rory, no matter how it plays out, whether she gets married or has children or is still single by the time she's in her fifties, eventually she will find Jess again ... cause she always does :) I'm not saying that I hate Logan, cause I don't, I just never liked him WITH Rory... :/
I agree, he shouldn't have done it in front of a crowd but he had good intentions. Most people just like Jess and Rory because that was her first real love, aside from Dean, but i'm not a fan of him at all. But if Logan happened to be with her before Jess then most people would love Logan. It's all about who was with Rory first, minus Dean. So this is why I am a Logan and Rory fan because they balance each other out. Logan wasn't responsible for Rory changing into a brat, it was all Rory.
@coollionel275 You just contradicted yourself. "Most people just like Jess & Rory because that was her first real love, aside from Dean". That doesn't prove your point at all. &actually, Rory loved Dean more than she loved Jess (which was STUPID of her), so I would disagree that Jess was her first real love. &people love R&J because they have CHEMISTRY, he loved her the most (so he had some flaws in the beginning... he changed, didn't he?), & he was good for her & vice versa. R&J are meant for
@coollionel275 each other and timing of who came first has nothing to do with it. I don't really know where you came up with that... Rory and Jess forever!
@coolchick602 I think jess is good too. I am so tired of people saying they hate logan. I am done talking about it. I can see her winding up with either.
Ive just started watching this and currently on season 5 but I loved Dean :( maybe its just because I LOVE Jared Padalecki but still dean was soo nice but i guess ill have to go through to the end to see if I start liking logan!.... Jess was good but he and rory just didnt match!
I would hate to be put on the spot like this. Proposing should be intimate, not a show.
Rory should have gotten back together with Jess. Jess was a jerk at the beginning, but by the end he was mature and really the reason why Rory got back into Yale and got her life back on track.
i wish she'd said yes, the ending of this episode totally ruined the whole series for me... even though it is still really awesome, i wish she'd said yes! xD d
jess was definitely best they had so much in common and he did really care about her. lol he was so funny in the first few series but then he grew up ;) dean was bleurgh to needy and pathetic but he had loved her and logan was ok... i guess... they need to finish GG off properly us fans aren't satisfied !
I love Logan but proposing to her in front of everyone was a bad idea and I also don't think those 2 should've gotten married THEN. However, i hated that they broke up, because to me it didn't make sense, then again none of season 7 made sense....at all
that's because they only showed re-runs and the order wasn't quite consistent. the cw was the only channel that would have for sure aired this episode.
i loved jess2!!...dean was so nt right4her...bt nw jess is gne...n d mre i think abwt it d mre i love logan!!c:)...hpe she says yes...im 4rm england and we hvnt watched dese episodes yet!!! :p
Why does everyone like Jess so much? If you love someone, you don't leave them hanging for a year! Ever. And I hate it when people propose in front of a big crowd, totally agrre with you keinukeiju.
i totally agree i think right now with Heroes even more people like Jess- as in milo- and you are right he was the best one.
he was somewhat of a bad boy but that suited rory that time in the show because she and dean were getting too boring and maybe domestic is a right word for it.
jess was amazing he is hot and i love him in Heroes.
es hobts jo keine ahnung! der Logan ist der richtige! Logan and Rory were perfect for each other i know it! Logan is intelligent, hot and funny! what du you want more?
Omg! I haven't seen the 4th series yet but then i was lookin at moments from series 3 and i saw this title so i knew what happened so i watched it.. :s .. lol
i absolutely love dean. marty is second place. but logan was too inconsistant for rory, as was jess at the beginning. i think jess started to show signs of change, so he was better for her than logan.
in my opinion i didn't like rory with logan and i knew they wouln't end up together....rory is just starting a great journey in her life and this would hold her back...plus i think she would end up with someone like jess or even jess himself.
Could U imagine what was going through Lauren Graham's head during this scene she was probably thinking omg what if this was my real daughter what would she say would she say exactly what Rory said?
In a long show such as this, the actors sometimes become more of the characters, so there is more a possability she was happy that the character finally was moveing onward, its complicated
Wow, my grandmother is exactly like Rory's grandmother. She would likely have done the same thing. I expected Rory's grandmother to physically kick the guy out of her house (at the back door of course, you can't let the guests see you, it would be bad manners)
I always hated Dean and Logan... BRING OUT JESS! Hehe
cOrncHipS90 2 weeks ago
Holy snap if he proposed to me i wouldnt even think it would be a HELL YES! ;) luv Logan :) Hotttttt
MissSpoilRoyal 2 weeks ago
I WANT RORY AND DEAN!!!!
Jerseyqueens4 1 month ago
I always hated Logan!
TheVirgo8282 2 months ago 5
i couldnt watch this when this was on air i cant even watch it now
RAch711baby 2 months ago
Rory and Dean Rory and Logan
nichele115 2 months ago
haha im sure the guy playing the piano is the same guy who plays the piano in glee :D
chaelihol09 2 months ago
I really felt sorry for Logan , but to be honest it was always Jess & Rory .
they werde made for each other, yes he left her once when he was 18 and went to cali .. but he got his life together, worte a book, begged rory to come with him, told her " i love you" and so many other things.
i even disliked rory when she was with logan, cause she changed so much.
<3 jess & rory
nady271090 3 months ago 7
poor logan D: i'll take him now though! hehe
joeshmoethe3rd 3 months ago
did rory really love logan? you dont spend three years with someone and not know how you feel about them.
the rory character went downhill and became too wishywashy
231thedream 4 months ago
OH MY GOD SAY YES STUPID!!!!! T___T They were sooo perfect for each other ;( I always thought, that Logan would be Rorys big love and if my big love would ask me to marry me i would say yes! T__T I hate this T__T
SunnieCookie 4 months ago 2
I see that Rory and Logan are perfect together ,, i hate that she refused in the end ,, he was like her soul mate ,, she thinks only of her career ,, i still can't believe it , how could she say NO ????!!
merevat 5 months ago 3
the woman at 1:02 is so hot!
18yenko 5 months ago
you can so tell that Lorelai basically told Rory to say no. Rory trusts her mom above herself and Lorelai hates Logan. Why the hell would Rory ask her mom, who only ever liked Dean, if she should marry Logan. I wouldn't listen to anyone if i was proposed to. I would ask myself, if I could see myself with that person for the rest of my life and if I love them above anyone else. Rory loved Logan and cared for him and worried about him while he was in the hospital. That would be a yes to me
Ems15196 5 months ago
I always hate Logar
karlymoon 6 months ago
@karlymoon why? I liked logan.
halopairemilofanatic 5 months ago
I don't get it. Why does Lorelai look so unhappy? I think she should be happy for her daughter....
TheMostEvilAngel 6 months ago
@TheMostEvilAngel Of course she's not happy. She'll be losing Rory since if she did marry him since they would go to San Francisco. That's the one thing I didn't like about Lorelai. Even though they were so close, she doesn't ever want to lose Rory. Yet she still lost her in the end when Rory worked as a Obama's reporter. She needs to learn to let go.
mmmmmvodka 5 months ago
Loreali's face throughout the whole thing says it all
shadesofgrey1947 7 months ago
@shadesofgrey1947 Why does it say it all? Lorelai really annoys me sometimes. She thought neither Jess nor Logan was good enough for Rory and the only person she was ever happy with was Dean, who would have held Rory back. I like Lorelai but she judged way too easily, funny because she screwed up every relationship she ever had.
natflix 6 months ago
@sylarisshot cheating IS black and white and he did cheat. I don't hate Logan, but Jess was better for Rory. And I'm not saying leaving is a small thing, but Jess did it once. Logan screwed up many more times. And I'm not stalking you, you replied to me on another video, which his why I know what you said. And ok, if you like rich spoiled guys then that's your choice. We'll just agree to disagree.
XshamosasX 7 months ago
@XshamosasX No, it isn't? Are you 13. Have you even been in a relationship? Cheating sucks because someone breaks your trust. If that someone doesn't even think he is in a relationship with you, how is he breaking your trust?
How did Logan screw up more than Jess?
And hey, if you like pretentious entitled guys, that's your choice too.
sylarishot 7 months ago
@sylarishot I'm 14 actually, and no I have not been in a relationship. It wasn't cheating to Logan, but they were not officially broken up. Even if he didn't technically cheat, what he did was wrong. And like I said, Jess didn't exactly get many chances to screw up, considering their relationship didn't last very long. He skipped town and didn't tell her, okay. That was once. Logan however, encouraged her to drink, party, steal, quit school as well as "breaking up" with her, cheating, being a
XshamosasX 7 months ago
@XshamosasX Actually, that was all of Rory's doing. He never wanted to steal a boat, that was all Rory. Logan always thought Rory would go back to school, but Rory was hardheaded. Logan let Rory be herself actually. And Jess was the one who was honest about it. It was Rory who was making all the wrong decisions.
mmmmmvodka 5 months ago
@mmmmmvodka It wasn't his idea, but he encouraged it. And no he didn't... he just let her do it, not even ONCE did he try to convince her to go back. Logan changed her completely - it was his influence. Yes, it was her doing, but around him, she was different - maybe it wasn't actually his fault, but around Jess she was completely herself. You could see it when he came back to see her, their banter, everything, she acted like the old Rory.
XshamosasX 5 months ago
@sylarishot dick to Jess, telling Lucy and Marty about Marty and Rory's friendship, etc. Other things too, but I can't remember. Also, about the cheating thing, one thing that bothered me was that Logan never even acknowledged that what he did was wrong - he just kept making excuses and went on and on about what a great boyfriend he was. Also, in the end he discouraged Rory from following her dreams, while Jess was always the one who encouraged her.
XshamosasX 7 months ago
Is that the piano man from Glee??
liyue4 8 months ago
@liyue4 yes it is
231thedream 4 months ago
Takes after her Mother :-)
rachbat3231 8 months ago
FUCK YOU LOGAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TEAM JESS :)
kaileyisgreen 8 months ago 3
LOL I love how even though this is a Rory/Logan video, the Jess and Rory forever comment is the highest comment. I think it's undeniable that Rory and Jess are meant to be together, & they clearly have the biggest fan base. Also, ASP always meant for them to end up together... so take THAT Logan/Rory and Dean/Rory shippers! That being said, I did like Logan & Rory at times. They were cute together, but they're just no comparison to Rory/Jess. Plus, she was a completely different person w/ Logan.
XshamosasX 9 months ago
@XshamosasX I don't know how that is undeniable? Rory rejected Jess. End of story. She grew as a person with Logan. They were together for a LONG time. People change.
sylarishot 8 months ago
@sylarishot She changed for the worst. Rory after season 4 was just insufferable. She didn't "grow as a person"... she went backwards. How does it matter how long they were together for? So what if she rejected Jess? The only reason she was with Logan for so long was because Milo refused to come back in season 7... and that's not just my opinion, that's a fact. Even the writers believed that they would have ended up together in the end.
XshamosasX 8 months ago
@XshamosasX That's your opinion. I loved her throughout. I thought the change in her was gradual and natural. Their time together matters because it is stupid to say that Rory was a 'different person' around him. Rory met him when she was young and she spent years with with him. Whether YOU think that she was insufferable is beyond the point. She changed as a person because people change. Not because of Logan.
sylarishot 8 months ago
@sylarishot Question: what makes u love Rory exactly? The fact that she slept with a married guy, stole a yacht, became so weak for a guy that she agreed to having a casual relationship (which is basically sleeping around in my eyes) & became so weak that 1 opinion caused her to drop out of Yale? Or that she treats her mom and grandparents like crap, &forgives a guy again &again even after he cheated on her? Btw, everyone says Jess treated her like dirt but Logan did things that were WAY worse.
XshamosasX 8 months ago
@XshamosasX People make mistakes. Her mistakes made her more real. She wasn't perfect. & LOL with your slut shaming. There is nothing wrong with casual relationships. Rory and Logan went out together, they weren't just sleeping around. So, it doesn't matter what it looked like IN YOUR EYES. Logan never cheated on her. And no, Jess treated her way worse.
sylarishot 8 months ago
@sylarishot And actually, it does matter what it looks like in my eyes because it is MY OPINION. Logan did cheat on her - she didn't know they were broken up and he never clarified. There is no gray area in cheating... it either happens or it doesn't. All Jess did was leave. That's IT. Logan screwed up WAY more. And can you make up your mind, because in another video you said you liked Rory and Jess better than Rory and Logan, and Jess better as a character than Logan, so...
XshamosasX 8 months ago
@XshamosasX You are a misogynist then, have a star. & No. Things are never that black or white. Cheating is horrible because a person who swore his commitment to you did not value it. Logan DID NOT do that. & Lol at you categorizing all the hurt Jess put Rory through as 'just leaving'. Oh, cute. You are stalking me. Yes, I like Jess/Rory more than Logan/Rory. I still think Logan/Rory makes way more sense. Jess was a better constructed character than Logan. I still like Logan more.
sylarishot 7 months ago
@XshamosasX & Jess/= Milo. In CANNON, Rory rejected Jess because she was in love with Logan. Jess and Rory were together for half a season and he treated her like shit. The writers may have planned for great things for Rory/Jess but guess what? They didn't pan out. In CANNON, Rory and Logan make way more sense than Jess/Rory ever will.
& that is not a fact anyway. Milo refused to return after S4. That's when Logan was introduced.
sylarishot 8 months ago
@sylarishot well you're one of the few, because A LOT, I'd say majority, of fans found her insufferable after s4. He didn't treat her like shit, & they didn't happen because Milo didn't want to return... Rory/Jess made less sense than Rory/Logan? Are you kidding me? Whatever, that's your opinion, but the reason R&J have the biggest fan base is because they make the most sense. They understand each other. They were endgame and everyone knew that... uh, after s4? He was in s6, in case you forgot.
XshamosasX 8 months ago
@XshamosasX Of course, he treated her like shit. And what has the biggest fanbase got to do with it? If I wanted to read the fans' version of the show, I'd read fanfiction. How do they make more sense? Logan and Rory went through so much together. They stuck with each other through thick and thin. They both grew as people together. That is way greater than some high school fling.
Yes, after S4. Jess came in S6 so that he could get closure. The writers wanted to end their chapter once & for all.
sylarishot 8 months ago
@sylarishot Fanbase has a lot to do with it. &maybe you should get your facts right - he didnt come back for closure, he was supposed to come back for more episodes and ASP's original ending had Rory and Jess as a couple - which does in fact make them the meant to be couple because they actually WERE supposed to end up together. & R&J make more sense because he understood Rory in a way Logan never did - i.e. he was the only person who could convince her to go back to Yale. Logan didn't even try!
XshamosasX 8 months ago
omg thats the same piano player from glee love GLEE
uglyfaces234 9 months ago
I loved Jess :) Dean was way to boring for me and Logan was too ... I don't know, too cliche? In my head Jess always ended up with Rory, no matter how it plays out, whether she gets married or has children or is still single by the time she's in her fifties, eventually she will find Jess again ... cause she always does :) I'm not saying that I hate Logan, cause I don't, I just never liked him WITH Rory... :/
MyFallingAngelxx 9 months ago
i was so sad when they broke up :(
TheWurzelx3 10 months ago
I never liked logan at all. He was spoiled and cocky and i couldnt stand that he always got things easily...
jloney007 10 months ago 5
is it just me or does Logan and Chistopher looks similar?!?!?
either way their both HOT!!
partygirl209 10 months ago
Real thing is , I'm not on Jess 's side I perosonaly think Logan's better , just in case , Logan 's awesome I'm shaking
London2507 11 months ago
Real thing is , I'm not on Jess 's side I perosonaly think Logan's better , just in case
London2507 11 months ago
I agree, he shouldn't have done it in front of a crowd but he had good intentions. Most people just like Jess and Rory because that was her first real love, aside from Dean, but i'm not a fan of him at all. But if Logan happened to be with her before Jess then most people would love Logan. It's all about who was with Rory first, minus Dean. So this is why I am a Logan and Rory fan because they balance each other out. Logan wasn't responsible for Rory changing into a brat, it was all Rory.
coollionel275 11 months ago
@coollionel275 You just contradicted yourself. "Most people just like Jess & Rory because that was her first real love, aside from Dean". That doesn't prove your point at all. &actually, Rory loved Dean more than she loved Jess (which was STUPID of her), so I would disagree that Jess was her first real love. &people love R&J because they have CHEMISTRY, he loved her the most (so he had some flaws in the beginning... he changed, didn't he?), & he was good for her & vice versa. R&J are meant for
XshamosasX 9 months ago
@coollionel275 each other and timing of who came first has nothing to do with it. I don't really know where you came up with that... Rory and Jess forever!
XshamosasX 9 months ago
@mrsmiloventimiglia83 He was such a douche!
ggaddict1537 11 months ago
@prettylitleliarfreak
The piano player is the same piano player from glee, he's called brad.
alicev92 11 months ago
i wish she said yes
coolchick602 11 months ago
@coolchick602 I think jess is good too. I am so tired of people saying they hate logan. I am done talking about it. I can see her winding up with either.
StefanandElenalover 11 months ago
ooh its brad from glee at the piano in the beginning!
alicev92 1 year ago
Ive just started watching this and currently on season 5 but I loved Dean :( maybe its just because I LOVE Jared Padalecki but still dean was soo nice but i guess ill have to go through to the end to see if I start liking logan!.... Jess was good but he and rory just didnt match!
SerenityRei92 1 year ago
i wanted them to get married i cried
gilmoregirlsfreak98 1 year ago
emily's "play something now" always makes me chuckle
BlondeRooster90 1 year ago
YESSSSS. Rory, YEEEEESSSSSSS!
kissame104 1 year ago
Omg please tell me she said no!
gottaluvMEgan 1 year ago
Team Logan <33
EvenHeavenCries1 1 year ago
Why couldn't she say yes
biblegirl 1 year ago
My Beloved Cat Rory
TL250Rider 1 year ago
Thank the Lord she said no. I hated Logan sooo much! I still do. Him and Christopher are the ones that I have always hated.
Rory and Jess
Luke and Lorelai
Forever and ever and ever and ever......
ggaddict1537 1 year ago 17
"you amaze me, Rory Gilmore, everyday, everything that you do, everything that you are" <3 awww
Smi1eyFace 1 year ago 3
Wow. That was painful to watch. Jess would never have put her on the spot like that.
Jojo09071985 1 year ago 14
@Jojo09071985 lol Jess was a big douche too. Are you R/J shippers even serious ever.
sylarishot 8 months ago
team dean!
springinkerl7 1 year ago
Is that the piano man from Glee?
HalfricanNerd 1 year ago
@HalfricanNerd It is!
syikana 1 year ago
god, how much do i love that all the comments here are pro-jess :-))) just more proof of what the fans wanted
kali902000 1 year ago 4
Team Jess forever :D
but logan is the second election :D
GAGii93 1 year ago 6
Logan was just a replacement for Tristan because Chad Michael Murray was on One Tree Hill... and I liked Jess better than all of them
HelloIdiotsWhatsUp 1 year ago 7
get on your knee you stupid man.
...jess would have gotten on his knee.
HazieRox 1 year ago 40
@HazieRox ikr, the thing that cheered me up in that scence, was seeing the piano guy form glee sitting by the piano!!!
TheVictorious124 1 month ago 2
naw, we want jess!
SarahYaBass 1 year ago 18
so jealous! logan is so hot! why did she say no???? he is so perfect and hot!!!
jac0bluva1996 1 year ago
@jac0bluva1996 im glad she said no. theyre cute together but theyre just not right somehow
dudet3493 1 year ago
I would hate to be put on the spot like this. Proposing should be intimate, not a show.
Rory should have gotten back together with Jess. Jess was a jerk at the beginning, but by the end he was mature and really the reason why Rory got back into Yale and got her life back on track.
elvickRULES 1 year ago 6
I don't like Logan that much. I like Jess. Rory should've been with Jess
Krulte 1 year ago 8
Logan is the best one of the best ones and he is so cute and he loves her truthly.
But the crowd, right it's to much for Rory.
percielein 1 year ago
I'd say Dean and Rory were meant to be.
heartflower111 1 year ago 3
no Dean was the best!!
SimcaWaSuwaro 1 year ago
i wish she'd said yes, the ending of this episode totally ruined the whole series for me... even though it is still really awesome, i wish she'd said yes! xD d
messytessy88 1 year ago
Jess=Unmentionables.
And did anyone notice that the pianist was Brad "tinkles", the pianist from Glee?
gibbozi 1 year ago
@gibbozi haha it is! Just with shorter hair. Man a guess he is always around. lol that made my day!
michaun13 1 year ago
jess was definitely best they had so much in common and he did really care about her. lol he was so funny in the first few series but then he grew up ;) dean was bleurgh to needy and pathetic but he had loved her and logan was ok... i guess... they need to finish GG off properly us fans aren't satisfied !
xxmaterialxgirlxx 2 years ago 4
I don't like Logan!
Dean was the best, and Rory was too stupid...
philippehungary 2 years ago
i agree!!!!
Schakalaka1234 2 years ago
DEAN!!!!!!!!!!!
belle649 2 years ago
O_O I'd be liiiiike... *pretends to faint*.
DizzyDior12 2 years ago
Comment removed
XshamosasX 2 years ago 7
I love Logan but proposing to her in front of everyone was a bad idea and I also don't think those 2 should've gotten married THEN. However, i hated that they broke up, because to me it didn't make sense, then again none of season 7 made sense....at all
FelineMimiDavis76 2 years ago 4
I know season 7 was not as good because they changed the original writer
canitalknow 2 years ago 3
I know, but they changed because the original writers left, the Palladinos, who also created the story
FelineMimiDavis76 2 years ago
ROFL
brokentopiecs 2 years ago
He should have told her he was going to propose to her before hand, so if she said no before, he wouldn't have done it.
(never propose in front of other people.)
Rachy2049 2 years ago 3
JESS AND RORY FOREVER.
LiteratiRulz 2 years ago 131
@LiteratiRulz UG
olympiafencing 1 year ago
oh GOD what a cringe :|
supercatwd 2 years ago 4
i dont care if he´s good or not good for her but he´s hot ^^
Aloha0from0Me 2 years ago
Lol i agree!
CharstarCullen 2 years ago
TIP FOR ALL THE GUYS!!!: do not propose in front of a bunch of people, especailly people the both of you know really well!
WiteRainbeau 2 years ago 60
thank goodness she said no
i hate logan :)
Fizzydarts027 2 years ago 5
i don't know why this is down rated! me too!
supercatwd 2 years ago
in my opinion logan is not good for Rory
marizza16paula 2 years ago 8
ummm wow. That would be way hard to answer just like on the spot. But i dont like logan
Matellorox 2 years ago
especially since what happened when dean just simply told rory that he loved her and she freaked out, and now a proposal?!
bruty16 2 years ago
Nooooo! I liked him:[
MrsNickJonas1201 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ahaha i hate logan :)
BlahBeth 2 years ago
i love you logan!!!
megydiana 2 years ago
wow, logan, way to put her on the spot! i didn't like him
longlists 2 years ago
i think logan loved her the most.
and this was just so amazing.
i cant believe she said no.
why did she say no anyways?
no one has ever told me that.
nicole3694 2 years ago
OMG! this is so sad i loveeee Logan!
loveydovey101k 2 years ago 3
I knew she wouldn't say yes. Rory is a smart girl.
Californiachik85 2 years ago 14
wail. that's sad. and embarrassing. Lorelei knew it. she knew Rory would say no. poop. and i like logan
AngelsTurtle 3 years ago
abc family never aired this episode!!!!!!!!!!
iheartEAMC 3 years ago
that's because they only showed re-runs and the order wasn't quite consistent. the cw was the only channel that would have for sure aired this episode.
cooky212 2 years ago
yesyesyes
dorka090 3 years ago 3
poor dude=(
TheHunkIsSprunk 3 years ago 2
WTF!!!!!!!!! does she say yes or no!!!
nomyrara 3 years ago
she says no
sushmonster 3 years ago 3
i loved jess2!!...dean was so nt right4her...bt nw jess is gne...n d mre i think abwt it d mre i love logan!!c:)...hpe she says yes...im 4rm england and we hvnt watched dese episodes yet!!! :p
kamzo7 3 years ago
You also haven't attended school. Check your spelling. Rory would be ashamed of you.
serojay 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love edward and bella, i love stephanie meyer and all her saga
shelyp3 3 years ago
What the hell do they have to do with this?!
09Santanico20 3 years ago 2
wtf? is this about them? NO!
nomyrara 3 years ago
Why does everyone like Jess so much? If you love someone, you don't leave them hanging for a year! Ever. And I hate it when people propose in front of a big crowd, totally agrre with you keinukeiju.
Byou452 3 years ago
I hate when people propose in front of a big crowd. It's harder to say 'no'. :/
But I'm in the team Jess. He was the best! Dean was too boring and Logan too suave, but Jess was perfect... :)
keinukeiju 3 years ago 81
i totally agree i think right now with Heroes even more people like Jess- as in milo- and you are right he was the best one.
he was somewhat of a bad boy but that suited rory that time in the show because she and dean were getting too boring and maybe domestic is a right word for it.
jess was amazing he is hot and i love him in Heroes.
dunaasu 3 years ago 2
es hobts jo keine ahnung! der Logan ist der richtige! Logan and Rory were perfect for each other i know it! Logan is intelligent, hot and funny! what du you want more?
MiniRox88 3 years ago
glad she says no!?!?!
her mom knew what she was going to say?!?!? lol
jessmindadumbass 3 years ago 2
jess jess jess!!!!!!!yes!!!!!!!!!!
helen01bond 3 years ago 9
Omg! I haven't seen the 4th series yet but then i was lookin at moments from series 3 and i saw this title so i knew what happened so i watched it.. :s .. lol
ElizabethRoberts08 3 years ago
i don't know.
i actually hated jess.
he was always like 'i don't care about anything' when obviously he did and to me...
he seemed like the guy on 90210.
but hell, what do i know?
i guessed i liked dean the most because he was her first everything.
i thought they were cute, but i wouldn't want them to get married or whatever.
i actually haven't seen much of the gilmore girls with logan (i haven't rented those seasons yet!) haha so i guess i don't really know about him XD
ichherzpogo 3 years ago
JESSSSSS♥
kate1989x 3 years ago 8
Jess was the one!!!
DisneyArtistFanatic 3 years ago 7
OMG!!!!Jess was better!!!
Adus482 3 years ago 6
am i the only person in the world who thinks rory and dean were perfect for eaach other?
animefreakedie 3 years ago
I totally agree with you..
dean loved her so much he was the best.
they were perfect.
weirdkid568 3 years ago
he was so controlling.
SimsMusicBox 3 years ago 10
he loved her, but he was a giant douche bag, and had no future.
i've dated a dean.
missyafro3169 3 years ago 4
ditto that
logan is right for her
rhibee123 3 years ago
i absolutely love dean. marty is second place. but logan was too inconsistant for rory, as was jess at the beginning. i think jess started to show signs of change, so he was better for her than logan.
cpgrl2008 3 years ago 3
Who cares who's best? It's all about the moments :D To tell the truth, I don't know who I liked best for her lol :P
StaroftheSea136 3 years ago
i so agree with you about the moments :)
cpgrl2008 3 years ago 2
ahhhhhhhhhhh i want her ring
hermione841 3 years ago
in my opinion i didn't like rory with logan and i knew they wouln't end up together....rory is just starting a great journey in her life and this would hold her back...plus i think she would end up with someone like jess or even jess himself.
indxtc112 3 years ago 6
i loved logan; that was so unfair of her, but i guess it was better that she said no know she can do what she always wnated
i also loved jess. . .
dean was okay, not for rory but for someone else
14pixiedust 3 years ago
i cried........
GilmoreGirlzRox 3 years ago 2
WHY DIDN'T RORY SAY YES! awee...rory and logan belong together!
bollywood1987 3 years ago
awkward! poor rory.
cedricdigs 3 years ago 3
I think it is kind of to show that Rory is more like her mother than we all thought. Lorilie has been unmarried all this time etc.
cheerforlove 4 years ago 2
I think so, too. With men Rory kinda is excactly like her mother.
Calina89 3 years ago 2
Yeah, I mean her mother did turn away from a proposal too, or was she actually engaged that time??
cheerforlove 3 years ago 2
AH.
I LOVE RICHARDS HAIR!!
Randum87 4 years ago
Could U imagine what was going through Lauren Graham's head during this scene she was probably thinking omg what if this was my real daughter what would she say would she say exactly what Rory said?
gilmoreluver06 4 years ago
In a long show such as this, the actors sometimes become more of the characters, so there is more a possability she was happy that the character finally was moveing onward, its complicated
GilmoreSeason8 4 years ago
She should have said YES!! I can't beleive that this show is over with, if she would have said yes then the show might have had a better ending.
mickeybou818 4 years ago
RORY SHOULD HAVE SAID YES!!!!!!!
gilmoregirllover2396 4 years ago
Wow, my grandmother is exactly like Rory's grandmother. She would likely have done the same thing. I expected Rory's grandmother to physically kick the guy out of her house (at the back door of course, you can't let the guests see you, it would be bad manners)
florapikachu 4 years ago
Imagine what Lorelai would feel! She watched her daughter grow up and go to Chilton, then Yale and now this!
littlemsporkbun 4 years ago
it breaks my heart that she says no, and i can understand why he says that it has got to be all or nothing. but couldn't she have said yes??
my goooooood
JuliSchmuli 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
logan's not that good lookin'
imkata 4 years ago
i think she should married Dean<3
LineHelen16 4 years ago
Yeah, Dean is the kind of guy I want to marry someday (sorry, just rewatching the new season =p)
Heartxbeat87 3 years ago
i don't like logan...selfish and silly
8marcie8 4 years ago