Halal, Kosher or Hoax قالوا ما في بطون هذه الأنعام خالصة لذكورنا

[matrx2006]

@obaidkarki حلووة اوووي

[mgmastrakanakis]

Haram means Forbidden, not crime! Crime in Arabic is Jareema

[obaidkarki]

@mgmastrakanakis

forbidden: ممنوع

crime: جنحه

jareema: وَلاَ يَجْرِمَنَّكُمْ شَنَآنُ قَوْمٍ عَلَى أَلاَّ تَعْدِلُواْ اعْدِلُواْ هُوَ أَقْرَب د

أدب الحديث:السلام ثم السؤال للسؤال وان لم يشأ فالسلام بلاكلام

[obaidkarki]

@obaidkarki

i will give another chance to tell me what is the meaning of haram in single word

dont blowup your o-ring. this time

[mgmastrakanakis]

@obaidkarki و لكن حرام ليس معناها جريمة و انما انها ممنوعة.. فالبيت الحرام و الحرم الجامعي لا علاقة للحرمة بالجريمة

[obaidkarki]

@mgmastrakanakis

الضراط مايغطي الحنحنه

[obaidkarki]

@mgmastrakanakis

الحرام والحرم يعني الجدار ويعني بالعيرية الحرام بكسر الحاء وهو اسم احد الشياطين الذي امره سيدنا داود عليه السلام لبناء المسجد الاقصي واما الحرام الذي اقصده هو عكس حلال في المأكل وليس له علاقة بالجريمة

فالحرام في المأكل جاء من العبرية وهو الطريف والحلال في المأكل بالعبرية هو الكوشر أوالكوثر

والله اعلم

[Bagawould]

I am an American who believes in Christ as the last prophet living in the Muslim world. You failed to mention to the people that "Halal" also means the "chicken" was killed under Islamic Rites which means saying a prayer to allah while killing the chicken. Whether it is true or not any person living there who believes in Christ would have a problem with that as I am trying desperately to get away from the "red sticker". No half truths please.

[Bruno243141]

omg,, hearing you speaking my native language is so annoying!!

[Shaheed1993]

In jewish law, lobsters are indeed haram . Probably because they dwell at the most bottom of the sea and feed on dirty things, thus they are unlean.. Some people get allergies from eating to many lobsters haha.

[PetraGHJ]

Did you know that CAMEL PISS is also halal?

[obaidkarki]

@PetraGHJ

after you CAMEL PISS is halal. just stop babooning in this vlog. pleeeeeeeeeeeease

[thisishalal]

PLEASE WATCH "THIS IS HALAL" on the youtube channel This is Halal

[popalafg]

I agree with you that eating meat from people of the book is Halal

But the question is are these people who killed the animal in USA , people of the book? Do they believe in Jesus as prophet or God? If they pray to Jesus than they are not people of the book right? Or the person who killed the animal could be a hindu or Buddhist.

Please clarify this for me.

Thanks Salam

[obaidkarki]

@popalafg

allah almighty made an easy diet for muslims so they dont starve themselves to death or diseases as jews in tarief and hindus in non-veg both do. if allah said eat people of the book meat period. eat it even it is slaughter buy none believers if you obide then almighty will send his angels to kosher the meat and make it halal for you to eat. bottom line here that allah command eating meat than corpse.

[popalafg]

@obaidkarki unfortunately your answer is not satisfying.

That is ok.

[obaidkarki]

@popalafg

aha you are looking for rhetoric

[popalafg]

@obaidkarki It is just that I never accept anything without logic. And your answer does not make sense. Don't worry about it. I fill find some one who is educated in this area and ask them the question.

Thanks

[obaidkarki]

@popalafg

good luck

[spiritfingers1]

@popalafg As I understand it the "people of the book" is the islamic term for religious jews and christians who both use the the bible/old testament/book as the basis of their faith. Only difference after this is that jews then have mishnah, talmud and oral torah, where as christians have new covenant/testament to elaborate on the tanakh/old testament and record of the life of Jesus and the early church. There has to be an overseer who is trained in islamic food laws/prayer for halal slaughter.

[safeeer1]

he's crazy or mentally ill

or an agent of ***

liar

[sil1997]

stoning ? crimeeeeee.

Amputation? Crimeeeeeeeee.

Covering faces in puplic places? Crimeeee.

driving car? crimeeeeeeeee. (in saudi for women)

[kevrs2]

why dont you religious nut jobs fuck off, and leave normal people alone,you bunch of uneduacated ,asshole fools,do you think you are talking to children

[kangurski]

killing animals in "halal" way is haram

[DragonxxxFire]

@kangurski -

actually the way the people do it is cut the neck of the animal really fast. muslims do it the WRONG way but the right way really is to cut the neck of the animal really slowly and wait for the animal to die and say prayers.

thats how my kind does it but let me assure you, there's different kinds of muslims out there

[kangurski]

that's not only sick, that's a very sadistic way of killing a poor animal. you wanna pray while the animal suffers? makes me puke

[DragonxxxFire]

@kangurski

all we say is Bismillah which means

"in the name of Allah, the gracious, the merciful" thats all the prayer we say and its not sick. animals eat animals and they are called Scavengers. Humans are NOT scavengers.

when a human dies you say prayers. when an animal dies you dont say shit so i wouldnt be talking

[kangurski]

animals hunt other animals, humans slaughter them humanly, and muslims (and jews, cos there is hardly any difference in the method) sadistically murder animals while claiming to be performing some rituals. this is total bullshit my friend, animals do feel pain, and unless you can prove that your "prayer" eases animal pain, you shouldn't be talking shit.

[DragonxxxFire]

@kangurski

what the fuck are you talking about

its not like Christians dont eat animals. But they DO eat meat PLUS they eat pig so i wouldnt be talking

and at least we DO a ritual before we kill an animal unlike you filthy christians that just go out in a forest get your rifle out and shoot an animal

your the one thats talking shit right now

[kangurski]

you are a retard, aren't you? the fact, that your kind dances around with your skirts up and then drop on your knees and fart into each other faces does not make cruel slaugher of animals any less cruel. We don't fuck around, we stun the animals first so they don't feel the pain, you idiot. And we don't invent excuses for it. If you still don't get it into your primitive brain, then i won't be the one to explain it to you. the end

[DragonxxxFire]

your religion is what is the end

you have no fuking idea what your talking about, thats what makes you a dumbass.

its not like stunning an animal doesnt hurt them. we dont pull up our skirts and start farting. what the HELL? wow i cant believe you couldnt think of a better insult than an elementary one.

we dont even do a ritual, we just say 1 sentence, thats ALL, i cant believe your making a deal out of cutting an animal. MOST christians dont even appreciate what they get when they eat. ass

[kidi1232]

actually, in judaism you must have an extremely clean and sharp knife, than cut the neck of the animal really quickly without putting any pressure (the idea is to cut the artery, not the windpipe).

it's not as quick as a shocker, but the animal feels no pain. you say a prayer before you even touch the animal, and you say a prayer after it is dead.

[kangurski]

hmm.. and you seriously claim that cutting throat is painless. tried it yourself?

[kidi1232]

if you ever got cut by a sharp object when it barley had any pressure on you- than you would know that sometimes you cant even notice you were cut.

[kangurski]

hmmm.. i think you have a slight problem in telling the difference between getting a paper cut and butchering an animal.

[kidi1232]

look, i'm not saying that this is the painless, most human way to kill, there is no such thing as human way to kill.

but, what i'm saying, is that it is almost painless & it brings the animal unconsciousness very quickly. very few tissues are being destroyed (again, clean cut, only the artery), and the animal will loose consciousness very quickly because no oxygen will get to the brain.

[kidi1232]

is it the best way? i think not.

is this way is ok to be used? i think yes.

when it is not OK to butcher? when you are causing alot of pain to the animal, that lasts longer than a second.

btw, i dont care how my meat was butchered, although i care about the type of the meat (if it's one of the meat types that is defined kosher), and even that is a traditional stuff, not religious.

[kangurski]

and you "almost" are right. and that "almost" makes a huge difference. Animals are not religious, they don't care whether a jew or filthy muslim is killing it, it probably doesn't care whether its suffering a lot of pain or "almost" less and whether some idiot is praying or not while it is dying, cos it is an animal.

The difference is that I do care, because how we treat animals (even those that we eat) reflects on us as humans. And btw, pigs are delicious.

[kidi1232]

i was talking about the butchering way, personally i dont care who is doing that, for years i bought meat that raised by a muslim, butchered by a muslim & bought it from a muslim. i dont care how the animal is butchered or by who, i just want the meat to be a type of meat judaism allows to eat (and i'm doing that as a tradition, not a religious act).

i'm happy you are enjoying you bacon, i will just politely refuse.

[SirTezek]

Seems like it's becoming impossible for Sikhs to avoid Halal/Kosher meat these days. People often ask me why Sikhs are probhibited from eating these meats and no it's not because we have eternal hate towards Muslims for what they did to our Gurus, it's more to do with the fact that the animal suffers when slaughtered this way. We only eat meat that has been killed with one swift cut to the neck NO PAIN.

[olaya310]

you are stupid

[guardalastoscas]

finger pointing?:"rudeness"!!!!

[GakharWajidHazarvi]

does it matters if you cut with machine or hand?

[zapatista512]

See Meet Your Meat for halal vs non halal. That is difference.. it is about being humane to animal by giving a swift death.

[asiagohead]

WTF...Keep buying HALAL AND MAKE THEM RICHER...WATCH THE VIDEOS PEOPLE...THERE IS NO PREYERS SAID in THE VIDEOS I am seeing. Just muslims paying higher prices for bullshit fed to them

[zapatista512]

just hunt/fish yourself for halal meat. Kosher is halal too, most important is how the animal is killed by cutting the neck. Kosher inspections are also like an extra tax on the meat.. but when you compare this to non-halal meats.. it is far better. Search Meet your Meat on Youtube

Also, I always thought Haram meant prohibited or forbidden not crime. There are varying degrees of prohibited things.. it says in Qu'ran some things are more important than others.. there is priority.

[zapatista512]

Prohibited meats:

No Pork, No carnivores, no scavengers (carnivores), no animals that die of themselves (like disease).

I agree meat industry is a problem, and the inspection industry is bad as well, but nobody prevents you from huntin/fishing, raising/farming, and then slaughtering your own game. Kosher would be halal as well for an alternative.

[DragonxxxFire]

@zapatista512

it also says that if you are in the middle of nowhere, and are dying of hunger and all you have available pig then you MAY have a little chunk or the pig

not all of it. you may only eat a little of it to get more energy and find the food you CAN eat.

God doesn't want to poison you but he doesn't want to kill you either

[hurahman]

buddy...you dont know shit...in islam there more then 2 ways...look it up!!

halal --permissible

mustahabb---recommended

makruh---undesirable

haram---unpermissible

[bravouk666]

can u show me these words in Quran?

[duarius]

i'm no muslim but its there, smartass. YOU look it up.

[rorohemox]

do you like to be a paki nation?

i luv islami's not pakis

[rorohemox]

yer man

[ZamaniSahib]

I thought haram meant not permissible.

[redmk5]

you are right.. the guy on the video is insane!

[coolstir10]

Did he suggested that i can eat beef and chicken from my school?

Someone told me i can't eat and others told me i can? Which is the truth?

Please help me.

[Centauro7209]

Eat whatever you want and what your economy can afford.

[UFMD1]

Doesn't Quran mention about eating certain kinds of fish, with scales, and also that we are not to eat scavengers and carnivorous animals? I am not an expert on this but I was sure I read that these animals are not good for us or perhaps "haram." Please answer and if someone else answers, please cite your source so I can read it too. Shukran.

[streetsNY]

Quran didn't say that wine is bad for us. The Quran said that there is a benefit on it (this is what scientists and researches are saying and confirming) but the harm coming from it is more than the benefit (How many people are killed each years because of drinking alcohol and abusing on wine?).

[jjhays36]

more like abusing on beer and hard alcohol, preety sure wine is a small percentage.

[totallybarefoot]

Not so. Wine has a more elegant image, carefully produced by the vineyards, but you are as likely to find a bottle of cheap wine in the brown paper bag the street alcoholic drinks from as hard liquor or beer.

The alcohol is the same. Wine is just as bad as beer or hard liquor.

[passwordthisass]

Eat my penis , it is definately Kosher . Also I washed it once .

[totallybarefoot]

The animal from which the meat comes must be free of disease. I assume that also means mental disease, or organic brain disease. So, your penis cannot possibly be Kosher. Nor can it be halal, but if you really really WANT it to be severed from your body with a razor sharp blade, Iran DOES provide halal sex change operations.

[AKOUM452]

What our Imams never told us is that the diet of the Prophet Mohamed was almost vegetarian. You have to read just Sahih-el-Bukhari to learn more about the diet of our prophet. Many Imams are telling people in North America to use chicken from super market because they know that chicken is not really a chicken. Even the Vudu people don't use it for their ceremonies. Many of my Muslim brothers are addicted to meat and many of them tell you that they can't eat a meal without it.

[totallybarefoot]

1. Yes, the Prophet ate little meat, but did tell Ali to eat beef once every forty days.

2. Supermarket chicken is real chicken! There are vegetarian "chicken nuggets" that are soy protein, but if it looks like a chicken and is called a chicken, it's a chicken. Supermarket chicken is inhumane and to be avoided though.

[streetsNY]

First time I heard about the prophet mophamed (PBOH) telling Ali to eat beef once every forty days and I never heard about cows or bulls in mecca. AKOUM452

[totallybarefoot]

Maybe it was filet mignon imported from New Zealand. I recall the hadith, not the name of the Prophet's family's meat distributor.

As I heard this hadith from an Afghani who did not speak English as his 1st, 2d, or even 3d language, it is possible he referred to all "red meat" as "beef". I know he referred to buffalo as "beef", and I've never heard of an absence of cattle in Mecca OR Medina.

Could you find something more trivial upon which to comment?

[streetsNY]

Maybe dried salted beef meat imported by travelers.

[jjhays36]

what is the difference between a supermarket chicken and a chicken? LOL!

[totallybarefoot]

The absence or presence of feathers, beak, and pulse.

Seriously, organic free range chicken, such as Amish chicken or chicken lucky people can raise themselves on their own land, are far superior in taste and nutrition than chickens from large companies like Tyson, where the birds are treated terribly, their legs cannot support their own weight, etc. These are not only cruelly raised, but the meat is mooshy, the bones without calcium...there are videos here and full documentaries online.

[tjenk71]

Rape is a crime in the same context with eating pork???? WFT?? Pork taste good. Haram is a word for hypocrits. I assert it is IMPOSSIBLE for a person to call anothers act HARAM without he himself to commit a Haram act within 5 minutes (I.E. THOUGHT(lust, greed, envy) ACT (smoking, eating fattening foods known to damage health, etc)...

[baetores]

From a biblical point of view, I can say that you are totally right about what you say here in your speech. Kosher is also extended to a non-food meaning.

Speculating about why this word is used, I come to the same kind of conclusions like you. Halal or kosher means something like pure, ONE, integrated whole, logical combination, healed, whole. Purifying from sin is something that happens for example, indicating that sin = crime = impure.

[AltarRS]

As-Salāmu 'Alaykum Obaid Karki

One thing I have always wanted to ask and dared not to ask is :

Is tobacco ha'raam?

[obaidkarki]

AltarRS

NOP

[UFMD1]

Addiction/slavery to anything is not desired. I would say something like Shisha wouldn't be as bad, most people do not become addicted to it, but cigarettes contain addictive chemicals and creates slavery.

[totallybarefoot]

If I may--we are not to destroy ourselves, and it's clear that cigarettes destroy our health. Asked by a man who said he liked to drink but did not get drunk, our Prophet told him something bad for you in large amounts is to be avoided in small amounts. A cigarette is a small amount of something that will kill you, a small amount of suicide if you will. Also, habitual smokers cannot pray in the mosque unless they take care to bathe, change clothes, and still their breath is bad as garlic.

[UFMD1]

I'm against toxins but there are many things that become toxic in large amounts that are beneficial in small amounts. Water for example. We die without it, but too much and we die too. So I'm not sure about that Hadith. I don't smoke, but how many of us take sugar, caffeine, chemical medicines, etc? These things are harmful as well. Moderation is key and avoidance of purely negative filth is beneficial.

[Prowler1]

helo,

interesting to know that about halal,

just like kosher food.

i guess both have to be prepared in a certain way or manner to get that stamp of approval, and to be considered as halal/kosher.

it's the same here,

kosher stamp where also have been missed used for monetary purposes.

[obaidkarki]

Prowler1

thanx for Rabbi Levin video

i am v-responding to yahuda shortly about prayers for rain.

[bryghtwines]

What an idiot.

[tarabrine]

It's true this Kosher Halal nonsense is brutal and creating rift among mankind plus all other unnecessary nonsenses such as the Kosher Tax. G*d wouldn't have given such silly instruction. It's time to reform.

[Live2Eat2Live]

As a contribution towards better Humanity, I decided to make an educational video on Kosher & Halal (the link doesn't work, just search for Live2Eat2Live and then look for "The Holy Scam - Kosher & Halal").

I consider Kosher & Halal Anti-Humanity!

[ihavenofate]

yeah and it was a dumb video

[alaarizk]

اشكرك على ردك على رسالتى

انا ساعات بحس انى هادمع لما انته بتتكلم فيه حاجة غريبه معايا بس ده كويس مخلينى عايز ابكى انا مبسوط انى بدمع و ببكى ده شئ كويس

[alaarizk]

السلام عليكم اخى الكريم

انا عابر سبيل واريد منك طلبا اريد ان تتكلم فى لقاءات اخرى باللغه العربيه

[obaidkarki]

alaarizk

وعليكم السلام

اشكرك علي العبور علي موقعي

العرب يشكلون واجد بالمائة من المشتركين في قناتي

[CatsupIslam]

I ate shark , Taste just like steak just a little fishy,Of course it was cooked like a steak.

[naughtygirl22]

yeeeah me too i ate shark ... i never heard or read that it's haram :-O .. anyway here in morocco we can eat everything we want ... we are not that extremists 7amdulah :-)

[rebyoshi]

Hey brother. In ENglish, the opposite of 'Crime' in English is "Permissable."

[rezmo777]

the opposite of crime is nocrime or notcrime

[JAALIUS]

Finally:

Our Beloved Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was always invited by Jews & Christians !!!

I CHALLENGE ANYONE TO NAME FOR ME ONE NARRATION WHERE Our beloved PROPHET(PBUH) WHOM WE SHOULD FOLLOW HIS SUNNAH !!! HAS EVER EVER ASKED ONE OF HIS HOSTS WHO INVITED HIM HOW THEY SLAUGHTERED THEIR FOOD !!!

HE SAID BISMILLAH & HE ATE (PBUH) !!!

may ALLAH have mercy on our Imam Ibnu Othaimeen & on all our Righteous SALAF

Ameeen

[JAALIUS]

OUR SHAIKH IBNU OTHAIMEEN (RA) was asked if it was Halal or Haraam to eat Macdonalds or food that was slaughtered by Christians:

He answered using the verse I mentioned & clearly used the AUTHENTIC HADEETH OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH) which we learned in grade school when a group of companions came to the Prophet (PBUH) and told him we eat meat and we dont know if it was properly slaughtered!

He said(PBUH) : (( YOU SAY BISMILLAH & EAT !!! ))

[JAALIUS]

So Our beloved Prophet (PBUH) did not tell the companions to go look and see how it is being slaughtered!!! NOR DID HE TELL THEM TO LEAVE WHAT IS CAUSING THEM DOUBT !!! Which means THERE IS NO DOUBT IN FOOD !!! If you wat with a Christian or Jew you say BISMILLAH & YOU EAT AS LONG AS IT ISNT PORK OR UNLAWFUL MEAT !!!

[karlaelisa]

is this strictly for animals or does it apply to fish too?

[muslima11]

you right about some businesses using the halal hoax but it is the intention that count if they tell me it is halal then i'm gonna buy it..it's between them and their allah if they lie about the product... they gonna be accounted for that on the day of judgement, i will not go the suppermarket and buy meat i don't care what anybody says about those businesses.

now.. what i wanna know is.. are you giving a fatwa without enough information about the what is halal meat and what is not?

[obaidkarki]

muslima11

wrote

"what i wanna know is.. are you giving a fatwa without enough information about the what is halal meat and what is not?"

unquote

obaidkarki

no i am not authority to fatwa neither you.

[muslima11]

and i was not giving any.. but the reason i asked the question was.. you said it was ok to eat any meat as long as it not pork knowing that people have different ideas about halal meat ... so you are changing their mind.

[muslima11]

i think when you tell people it is ok to do such and such thing and it is about a religion you gotta be careful.. because those of us that live in nonmuslim countries face this halal stuff challange every day and it is very sensative issue.. sorry if i misunderstood you.

assalamu alykum

[obaidkarki]

muslima11 part-2 Say: "I find not in the message received by me by inspiration any (meat) forbidden to be eaten by one who wishes to eat it, unless it be dead meat, or blood poured forth, or the flesh of swine,- for it is an abomination - or, what is impious, (meat) on which a name has been invoked, other than Allah.s". But (even so), if a person is forced by necessity, without wilful disobedience, nor transgressing due limits,- thy Lord is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful.

[obaidkarki]

muslima11 Part-1 This is not doctrinaire video. It is a verbatim definition of Halal & Haram If you are enlightened please do not question God's Wisdom to puzzle others That's Unislamic. There is no room for reasoning of mind here. If you belong to the HALAL business then I have Nothing to say but LA HAWL WALA QUWAT ELLA BELLAH. If you belong to Halal believe then this the place. I am unsympathetic but I love you Please don't ditch me for Byzantine hearsay

[muslima11]

first...i dont't have a HALAL business.

second ... you don't live in a nonmuslim country so you don't know what you are talking about..and i say this because you don't know how they slaughter animals in nonmuslim country.

third.. it is not a hearsay to avoid any meat that is NOT slaughtered with the name of allah.

and last this is not going anywhere so this is my last comment.. i know what kind meat that's halal for me so don't worry about it.. assalamu alaykum brother.

[obaidkarki]

muslima11 No i live in non moslem country too India, denmark, france, usa ireland & australia have halal slaughter houses Directed to qibla they don't electrified Animals if instruct. Halal mafia seen this as competition they went into sunna , use redundant hadith Grassroot clergies & self-appointed mullah to criminalize it. The west put a Halal chicken on Moslem table for a Dollar Halal mafia put same chicken for $2. Is this halal or haram? Halal mafia sell meat 3-4 times market price.

[muslima11]

as far as i know halal meat is when the animal is slaughtered with the name of allah.. not electrocuted or the neck chopped off with a machine.. that is my understanding.. and there are no ahlu kitabs today that slaughter animals with the name of allah.. at least where i live..you live in a muslim country and you don't have this problem.

[JAALIUS]

sister muslima11 you fell into what you are warning against and you just gave a very dangerous fatwa that there are no Ahlul Kitaab today MAY ALLAH FORGIVE YOU sister! I assume you are inchALLAH from those whom ALLAH said they listen to the Sayings & Wisdom & they follow the best of Saying & Wisdom!!!

Plz read this verse from Surat Al Maidah very very carefully & reflect upon it & contemplate & think!!! and then read my comments that follow carefully for anyone who is seeking the truth !!!

[muslima11]

Jaalius i did not say there are no ahlu kitab... i said there are no ahlu kitab today that slaughter animals with the name of allah.. at least where i live..so i understand where you are coming from... but i know what ahlu kitab is and who they are..assalamu alaykum.

[JAALIUS]

sister can you have a look at all my comments

Jazaak ALLAH khair

and I appologize sincerely for taking your statement out of context! but we have some groups where I live who say there are no Ahlul Kitab today and they preach it in their mosques!

Please accept my appology sister!

and can you read the rest of my comments addressing the christian food issue?

[muslima11]

i was not offended at all.. i read your comments and i appreciate your concern.. i know what you are talking about.. may allah reward you for your effort..

assalamu alaykum.

your sister muslima11.

[muslima11]

my concern is not about ahlu kitab.. i was refering to the meat at the suppermarkets and i know they were not slaughtered with the name of allah, besides why do i have to bother looking ahlu kitab when i can find a muslim halal meat store.. if there are no muslim businesses then that is different issue.

assalamu alaykum.

[JAALIUS]

wa 3alaikum al salam

I wasnt saying you shouldnt buy ur meat from a Muslim slaughter house

but to say the food of the Christians is Haraam is indeed a grave misguidance & saying upon ALLAH(SWT) with no knowledge

I appeal from you to read my comments regarding the AUTHENTIC HADEETHS ON THIS ISSUE

JAZAAKUM ALLAH KHAIR

[JAALIUS]

You said there is no Ahlul Kitab today but our ALMIGHTY ALLAH (SWT) said in his PERFECT book Al-Quran:

{{ Made lawful to you this day are At­Tayyibât [all kinds of Halâl (lawful) foods, which Allâh has made lawful (meat of slaughtered eatable animals, etc., milk products, fats, vegetables and fruits, etc.)...

[JAALIUS]

... The food (slaughtered cattle, eatable animals, etc.) of the people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) is lawful to you and yours is lawful to them. (Lawful to you in marriage) are chaste women from the believers and chaste women from those who were given the Scripture (Jews and Christians) before your time... }} (Al-Ma'idah 5:5)

[JAALIUS]

OK NOW I TELL YOU WHERE YOU FELL IN DANGEROUS INNOVATION sister! and if someone taught you this I advise you stay away from this person and read for the authentic scholars of Ahlul Sunnah because this person will MISGUIDE YOU! GOD FORBID !

OK you fell into three major innovations:

#1. Saying that there are no Ahlul Kitaab today means is just like saying the QURAN DOES NOT APPLY FOR ALL TIMES!!! which is A DANGEROUS MISGUIDANCE TO UTTER wal Iyazu BILLAH !!!

[JAALIUS]

#2. It is like saying ALLAH (SWT) does not know the future wal IYAZU BILLAH & it is a rejection of what ALLAH has made HALAL for us & rejecting a CLEAR VERSE IN THE QURAN !!!

[JAALIUS]

#3. If I AGREE WITH YOU THAT THERE ARE NO AHLUL KITAB TODAY THAT MEANS THAT!

YOU JUST INVALIDATED THE REST OF THE VERSE WHICH ALLOWS FOR MUSLIMS TO MARRY AHLUL KITAB & INVALIDATE THE MARRIAGE OF MANY MUSLIMS MARRIED TO CHRISTIANS OR JEWS & YOU BELIEVE THEIR CHILDREN ARE ACTUALLY CHILDREN OF FORNICATION !!! wal IYAZU BILLAH !!! and NO ONE HAS EVER BEAT YOU TO THIS SERIOUS ACCUSATION to my little knowledge !!!

[JAALIUS]

And I didnt issue any fatwaa! Our Imam Ibnu Othaymeen issued a CRYSTAL CLEAR fatwaa backed by both the Quran & Sunnah regarding this issue.

If I wrote anything right it is from ALLAH ALONE and if Ive written anything wrong it is from myself & the shaytaan! & may ALLAH forgive me & forgive you muslima11 & forgive all Muslimeen!

Plz forgive me if I was a little harsh sister. wal Salamu 3alaikum! Ur Brother in Islam & Sunnah

[spiritlite]

Salaam, Thanks for the video, good information.

[Muhyialdeen]

Another thing Obaid, if we want to eat things from the ahlul kitab, there are certain conditions. Firstly, if the halal meat is not available in a certain area, then we can go but meat from the jewish kosher butchery. But however, the rest of the meat at supermarket are not halal. Why ?? because the method they kill the animals is just by cutting their necks one by one with machine . Poor chicken, it doesn't want to die and people force them to do so. That's what I call cruelty to animals.

[Muhyialdeen]

But Obaidkarki, the only ahlul kitab we can eat from today are the jews because there are no christians today who slaughter meat in the name of Allah. Allah warned us in the Quran that cursed are those who eat things whivh Allah's name is not invoked upon. The christians during the time of Rasulullah slaughter calfs and goats by saying bismillahi but today obaid, mmost europeans countries just stunned the animal with electric shock. Now can that be considered halal ?

[obaidkarki]

Muhyialdeen

please email me both comments i will to authority to reply you

[MoslimKid]

I live in the US. You mean to say all meat at my supermarket is halal? I don't think you are right. One doesn't know who and how that meat was prepared, how could it be halal? But I agree, the price difference is unjustified.

[a3rabi]

halal food means food that was obtained according to whats lawful to God and to culture. if you take something from some one if you asked for permition its halal if you don't its haram. same thing with taking an animals life you can't take a life without God's permission and apone God's terms. but the most important thing for meat to be halal is its sacrificed for God and only God ( Allah )... nice video bro and i am going to watch you..

salam

[letmeinviteyou]

Beutiful aadhan. I live in the UK, and even some muslim butchers claim they are halal, but they are not. But I supose its all about intention.

[ahmed2597]

U use Athan software init? what happend to mosques in dubai? i thgt there were enough plus you had seven around your house! remember? ;) ...btw nice video! alot of analyzed information ..

[obaidkarki]

ahmed2597

naughty kinky ahmed as usual

eleven mosques

but my nokia mosque strikes 2 minuted before abdelbasit sh obaid mawalawi and abelhassan

i am so lucky in this nine star islamic hood

my next video about crazy people called ahmed just kidding

barrakallah feek

[muhterem]

Halal is good, Haram is no good.Thank u for video and for info.

[marcellogentile1]

interesting thank you.

Peace

[afundie]

Which other kinds of meat are you not allowed to eat? I figure that any types of exotic animals that weren't already known to the people, God couldn't tell them not to eat them.

Apparently pork tastes like people. So maybe anything else that tastes like people is also off limits.

I'm a vegetarian BTW.

[shezanbaig2004]

surah 5:3-5 i think is the basic framework

great video btw! it is sooo true! they make "halal" into their own business, may Allah guide them insha'Allah.

[falzaabi]

I'm a vegetarian , and i think it rely nice to be that way , but I don't judge people who eat meat , its bart of or life , for me to be a vegetarian is kind of realization, its not logical thing its just like that, so I rely cant go Around till people be a vegetarian, no . they will find out by themselfe beside its Alha plan

[a3rabi]

bro if your choice of diete it apon health matter then thats the true right way.. meat is not a basic need for life cause you can get your energy and protines from some othere placis like suger carbs milk soya products cheese. but then if your harmed but not eating meat you are going against nature because your body is telling you that you need meat.... good luck

[falzaabi]

thanks for the nice reply ,,, but as i say .its not logical thing

[CompanionableIlls]

I'm very glad you made this video. The halal food being sold here in the states (at least in Cleveland and Dearborn), is priced atrociously. I can't reconcile the price differences in my mind! Lol I love the crab impersonation.

[IslamIs1st]

lol