hehehe..I know Aussie and western people who sing operas frm gremany, italy with perfect pronounciation.
yeh min youngki has a great voice but it is going to waste singing the english version.
if he sung in Korean he would be fantasic ^^...I found Korean opera/ musical singers just sing in Korean and sometimes english. yet other opera singers who are not eg. german or italian can sing opera in those languages fluently with perfect pronounciation. So why cant u guys do the same in eng?
Kim So Hyun sang this great in Korean, but she lets her poor English mar the wonderful rendition she gave of this song when she sang it in Korean. She is one of the best singers for Christine's part in ANY language of the Phantom of the Opera that I've seen perform and yet this performance makes me sad.
그리구요, 전 분명히 '이분 가창력까지 단순히 발음만으로 평가할꺼면 한국말 손나 정확하게 할 수 있는 쉐키들만 댓글달아라'라고 적었는데, 거기다가 '한국분'이 아주 당당하게 '난 한쿡어 발음 잘할수 있떠염 뿌우'3' 그리고 님 문법이나 제대로 쓰세염' 하는 식의 댓글이 달리니 그저 어이없을 따름이네요.
아이고 그러세요, 오타 하나 가지고 참 까칠하시네요. 그리고 전 민영기님의 가창력이 단지 발음 하나로 이렇게 국제적인 사이트에서, 그것도 자국 사람들한테까지 무참하게 까이는게 기분 나빴을 뿐이네요. 그나저나 영어가 모국어인 사람들은 이게 웃기게 들린다 쳐도 님은 왜 이게 불만인건데요?ㅅ?
yes i can xD i will post a cover this song in Korean OK ? and I will prove it to u but im not gonna sing christine cuz I cant xD but i can sing the phantom ^^
아오 씨발 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 민옵 발음'만' 가지고 이 사람은 글러먹었네니 뭐니 하고 썩을 드립을 치는 양키님, 네 댁 잘났습니다 참 잘났어요. 이러면 말씀하시겠죠? '전 이거 깐 적 없습니다' 하구요? 안 '깠'으면 그냥 그대로 넘어가세요 ㅋㅋ 님한테 하는 말 아니니깐 태클걸지 말고, ㅇㅋ?
Their pernounciation is very well in this. I've grown up around alot of people that came from China, Korea and Japan. and they all had an increadible accent. So considering, they did a very good job on this, I think
am i the only one who dislikes his voice, not his pronunciation???i forgive him that! i couldn't sing in korean, and imagoina how hard english is a language! poor thing! but i dislike his tone in this, no offense. kims voice is beautiful, very soft. shes struggling with the highs notes, but they were still very lovely.
i really hate the man. He pronounces so badly and sing the lyrics wrongly-__-..However, the girl sings much better than him but she can't sing more trebly.
his accent is better than most of those korean pop singers and also really good for someone who grew up in korea and learned enlgish as a second language. See how you sound if you were to sing in a different language. I really love his voice!
No need to nit-pick every single thing. All of the actors act the way they want. Maybe he wants to smile while other actors don't. It's all a matter of preference.
I don't think he can help the accent. The girl might have just gotten a better english education, or possibly lived in the UK or US awhile. And I think in this song, the phantom is alowed to smile derangely.
Thei voices are truly spectacular! especially for singing in a different language! Those notes of hers were stratospheric!!!
SamSkii14 9 months ago
Comment removed
SamSkii14 9 months ago
kinda laughed when I heard his lyrics.. but he's got a great voice nonetheless.. i wish they just translated the song like what the japanese did.
hopeydopeysmokey 1 year ago
Went too early with the "Sing for me my angel of music" OH WELL :D.
MyArtIsLoved731 1 year ago
@musicalrapture That's because Korean is easier to say. But people have accents that can totally cause them to make it sound like Engrish.
MyArtIsLoved731 1 year ago
they are really good!
especially the part when she sang that high note! :D
TheShehan123 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP. She is amazing. That high note was INCREDIBLE> She is ten times better than any crappy Christine I've heard!
ChristineDaaePhan07 2 years ago
hehehe..I know Aussie and western people who sing operas frm gremany, italy with perfect pronounciation.
yeh min youngki has a great voice but it is going to waste singing the english version.
if he sung in Korean he would be fantasic ^^...I found Korean opera/ musical singers just sing in Korean and sometimes english. yet other opera singers who are not eg. german or italian can sing opera in those languages fluently with perfect pronounciation. So why cant u guys do the same in eng?
KoreanVisualKei 2 years ago 2
Good =D 5/5
jbrs007 2 years ago
Awesome! Both of them are just... WOW! :D
Annetagonistic 2 years ago
Kim So Hyun sang this great in Korean, but she lets her poor English mar the wonderful rendition she gave of this song when she sang it in Korean. She is one of the best singers for Christine's part in ANY language of the Phantom of the Opera that I've seen perform and yet this performance makes me sad.
Reveredjedi 2 years ago
his english is worse but he projects his voice far better
KoreanVisualKei 2 years ago
그리구요, 전 분명히 '이분 가창력까지 단순히 발음만으로 평가할꺼면 한국말 손나 정확하게 할 수 있는 쉐키들만 댓글달아라'라고 적었는데, 거기다가 '한국분'이 아주 당당하게 '난 한쿡어 발음 잘할수 있떠염 뿌우'3' 그리고 님 문법이나 제대로 쓰세염' 하는 식의 댓글이 달리니 그저 어이없을 따름이네요.
gommtang 2 years ago
제 코멘이 어딜봐서 그런식으로 만드는지 정확하게 지적해 주실래요? 아 이거 깐적 없으시다니 그점은 사과드릴께요 ㅇㅇㅇ 뭣도모르는 양키들이 발음만 가지고 손나 지랄을 해대는데 하도 이골이 나서 헷갈렸네요. 그렇다고 님의 댓글을 찾아 일사천리 역주행할 필요가 있는거도 아니구요.
gommtang 2 years ago
아이고 그러세요, 오타 하나 가지고 참 까칠하시네요. 그리고 전 민영기님의 가창력이 단지 발음 하나로 이렇게 국제적인 사이트에서, 그것도 자국 사람들한테까지 무참하게 까이는게 기분 나빴을 뿐이네요. 그나저나 영어가 모국어인 사람들은 이게 웃기게 들린다 쳐도 님은 왜 이게 불만인건데요?ㅅ?
gommtang 2 years ago
you guys who complain about Min's pronunciation, CAN YOU SPEAK KOREAN WITH PERFECT PRONUNCIATION THAN?
gommtang 2 years ago
yes i can xD i will post a cover this song in Korean OK ? and I will prove it to u but im not gonna sing christine cuz I cant xD but i can sing the phantom ^^
KoreanVisualKei 2 years ago
아오 씨발 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 민옵 발음'만' 가지고 이 사람은 글러먹었네니 뭐니 하고 썩을 드립을 치는 양키님, 네 댁 잘났습니다 참 잘났어요. 이러면 말씀하시겠죠? '전 이거 깐 적 없습니다' 하구요? 안 '깠'으면 그냥 그대로 넘어가세요 ㅋㅋ 님한테 하는 말 아니니깐 태클걸지 말고, ㅇㅋ?
gommtang 2 years ago
Comment removed
gommtang 2 years ago
Their pernounciation is very well in this. I've grown up around alot of people that came from China, Korea and Japan. and they all had an increadible accent. So considering, they did a very good job on this, I think
ShinzeyBlacksword 3 years ago
the guy who plays the phantom sings well... but then... i think he's inventing some lyrics... i think they should have translated this in korean...
hopeydopeysmokey 3 years ago
lol yup he definitely changed the lyrics.. but what a voice!
simplyandrooo 3 years ago
Believe me, it's very difficult for a Korean person to speak clear English. So her English is almost perfect. ;)
amokintes 3 years ago
Sing one again with me our STROM Duet.. and The Fentom of the opera. Bad prnounce
ClimateFish 3 years ago
am i the only one who dislikes his voice, not his pronunciation???i forgive him that! i couldn't sing in korean, and imagoina how hard english is a language! poor thing! but i dislike his tone in this, no offense. kims voice is beautiful, very soft. shes struggling with the highs notes, but they were still very lovely.
RaWrZzZz 3 years ago
why does the girl sing the opening really high? it works because it's a compatible octave; i was just wondering.
schoenesmaedchen 3 years ago
why didn't they just sing this in Korean???
ChantantReve 3 years ago
i really hate the man. He pronounces so badly and sing the lyrics wrongly-__-..However, the girl sings much better than him but she can't sing more trebly.
leung20082008 3 years ago
I love his singing......its comedy
timothyngim 3 years ago
the phantom of the opera is originaly french so I don't mind accents sounded strange though( i meant the book, ok?)
wanbo626 4 years ago
I was loving it until the guy opened his mouth.
minadrake 4 years ago
I personally like the accent.
xStilleNachtx 4 years ago 3
his accent is better than most of those korean pop singers and also really good for someone who grew up in korea and learned enlgish as a second language. See how you sound if you were to sing in a different language. I really love his voice!
nejiismylover 4 years ago 3
he puts in like different words to the song... lol... nasty
pm0834 4 years ago
No need to nit-pick every single thing. All of the actors act the way they want. Maybe he wants to smile while other actors don't. It's all a matter of preference.
yumichan89 4 years ago 8
I don't think he can help the accent. The girl might have just gotten a better english education, or possibly lived in the UK or US awhile. And I think in this song, the phantom is alowed to smile derangely.
happilyinsane13 4 years ago 2