Added: 4 years ago
From: hiraisakura
Views: 363,502
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (432)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Good engrish

  • one of the best drama, romance anime i've watched...

  • Love it in english Beast

  • I need to fix my question... lol whats the diff between memories and melodies, ive been a bit of melodies NOT memories. haha

  • @TheKeyboardPiano Memories is melodies' ss 1. But I think melodies is better, i just watch memories cuz of chihiro's story.

  • whtas the difference between memories and melodies? ive seen a bit of memories...

  • People should make this anime into a drama.

  • @katrina0506 if they did i would actually look at dramas

  • which is the first season, Melodies or Memories

  • @ThePowerfulD memories is

  • i cant get the story of this anime can someone explain it to me

  • i believe if i remember correctly if you put the first letter of every episode together, it spells euphoric field :)

  • Comment removed

  • Its getting DUB!!!!!!! DVD will be release earlier next year!!! cant wait

  • uff this animes is the best!!! very original

  • Lol its like the same taste as in Clannad or Air...

  • I haven't seen the whole anime yet, but I really like it so far! I love this opening! Thanks for the upload.

  • this anime was awesome...

    i'm not really sure if i should watch the second season...

    the first was a masterpiece and i don't want to make my memories go bad if the second season isnt good Oo

  • I'm in 5/12

    I don't get some parts.

    Should I continue with it?

  • @lksgman Yes you should

  • @lksgman You should continue. I'm on 8/12, and the stories keep getting more interesting. I like Chihiro's story line the best, but they're all great.

  • es uno de los mejores openings que e escuchado en mi vida

  • wtf happend to the ending in this? episode 11 chihiro threw away the memories of renji.. then episode 12 there both together... waaah da faaark?? anyway the anime was still good despite this :)

  • @Carterbro1 Chihiro wasn't able to forget Renij for some reason, I'm guessing she stayed awake thinking about him or something, or she could have dreamed about him or something. It's kind of confusing because she asked him if they met before earlier in the ep, but I think she was faking.

  • @tH3dIViNeonE

    She just remembered him, not the person but just that he existed. She also said once that she won't reconise him before 3pm.

  • @khoraski because they are the most honest, genuine, significant comments posted :)

  • the best opening

  • It was very good, touching anime, but hell, the ending was too happy, these stories just couldn't end that well. But that's only my opinion.

  • what comes first? Meoldies or Memories?

    i'm confused

  • Comment removed

  • @cool944 In terms of the game Memories has the first three arcs (Miyako, Kei and Chihiro) while Melodies shows you the last two (Mizuki and Yuuko).

    In terms of the timeframe the stories happen, Melodies timeline is both at the start (Yuuko) and the very end (Mizuki) while everything in Memories happens in between the end of Yuuko's and the start of Mizuki's.

  • yea i just just watched this anime it's pretty good very sad but.. i really enjoyed it it uses unique animation techniques to express character emotions ( a very different approach an I really liked it) it has beautiful background music that also set the mood of the scenes it has a lot of genres including romance, Drama, mystery and Seinen the anime is very well made it is a must watch, and i will compare it to Clannad Air Kanon bois rating?  10 ;)

  • @CreativeBoy100 nice i looove air and clannad

  • @buddycute1 make sure u watch memories 1st!!! 

  • on the scale of 1-10 This anime ... 9 

  • How sad is this anime? On a scale of 1-10? Just trying to decide if I should watch before I leave for college soon. Reply soon please!

  • I knew who the guy would choose one the short haired bitch said, "I wont lose to you." It was obvious. the bitches that claim "They'll never lose" in a jealous rage, are the ones who ALWAYS lose in the end. Im glad that bitch never got the guy. after getting her sister in an accident like that, she doesn't deserve any happiness.

  • @miffytea not really. That said, the best stories are evenly divided between them, those being Chihiro's in Memories and Yu's in melodies. I despised Hiro and Kuze was not very interesting imo.

  • On of the best anime i've ever seen :)

  • I just download Ef - A fairy tale of the two game (English). I just started playing now even tho I already have seen both anime.

    I recommend Bakemonotagari for those who haven't seen it. An OVA is to be released this November i think. I can't wait XD XD. I also hope for a 2nd season as well.

  • @MrMeoow91 Bakemonogatari is going to have OVA? cool.

    and no second season, but they are going to have kizumonogatari made into a movie. (it the prequel just in case you did not know)

  • The people who made this anime made a new anime its called Bakemonotagari

  • i love it so much <3 :D this is the fucking best anime on the world xD!

  • hahahahaha am I the only one who thinks that first person looks like yuki sohma!!!!!

  • Just finished watching Melodies. Truly It has a darker story but both of them are awesome since they are sequel.

  • This is the "MOST" powerful anime I have ever seen.

    I have to put this on par with "Angel Beats" as my most favourite anime EVER.

  • I hate how Himura had to endure the loss of his beloved Yuuko.. That was so SAD! I tried holding back my tears but that was too f**king sad for me. Especially when they barely just re-united and after Yuuko told Himura about her tragic life to him. Then i started crying when Yuuko's death happened and i was like NOOOOOO!!! Stupid drivers i will kill THEE one day! =*(

  • Such a good anime... I cried... and yes i'm a guy

  • Such an amazing anime...

    The characters were so awesome and had so much development...

    THIS IS A TRUE ROMANCE ANIME! And not to mention, a PRO anime!

  • does anyone but me was like "huh?" when they kept switching the ending song in both memories and melodies?

  • Ahh~ This is one of my favorite anime ops!! The song is so pretty and the anime is just beautiful *_* It's been like a year so I don't remember the names but I love the guy in 0:03 - 0:05 <3 Wait, I actually love all of them.. IDK!! :x

  • @EpicMakune Haha Renji is awesome. I love how he and Chihiro ended up.

  • Ahahaha~ I loved the Memories the most.. and I like Hirono's story the most.. I don't know why.. I just love it~ I need to watch Melodies.. lol (:

  • Did she just sing a bunch of English phrases without much meaning?

    Most of what she sang made no sense if put together as a full song story...

  • @lafouboy2 Just like the others Japanise songs in English

  • This anime, along with A Tale of melodies was great, but what it really made it special was the Art and Animation. Unique in every way <3

  • Can sumone upload the all episodes of this anime?  How episodes are there?

  • @Farfeb Please, just download them from bakabt, and use CCCP to play them with, do NOT use VLC it will destroy the file.

  • love this opening.

    Miyako <3

  • ef.tales of memories was better than ef.melodie it was sadder and happy in the same time

  • @cesarrulez65 that's an opinion. I didn't really think ef ~ a tale of memories was anywhere near as good as ef ~ tale of melodies. ef ~ a tale of melodies, in my opinion, was much sadder, more loving, and a lot better.

    why do opinions always get top comment?

  • @cesarrulez65 yea but melodies takes the cake on the pure mind fuck saddnes bit.....and it makes u freakin angry >_<....watching that anime makes u understand how some people could kill others..

  • @deenman23 *spoiler alert* OMG I WANTED TO KILL AMAMIYO SENSEI SO BADLY. WHY'D HE HAVE TO KILL HIMSELF.

  • @loopofpoop WHY DID I READ THIS D: just started watching.........

  • @ValttuzTheChicken FUUUUUUUUUUUUUU Sorry man.  don't know what to tell ya

  • @loopofpoop Right, that's too easy for him. If it was me, I would not have kill him without researching what Gilles de Rais did to his victim.

  • this is a sad anime the 3rd on my list of sad anime 1st would be clannad 2nd would be air tv but all together they are all good

  • uuuugh I should really continue with Melodies

  • @DEIMOSLOL yes!! You should!!! :D

  • @DEIMOSLOL

    well, Sentai picked up the anime

  • I didn't know there was an anime adaptation wah i have to watch this!!!!

  • is ef a tale of memories and melodies the same anime? like season 1 and season 2? or is these two from different anime?

  • @hviskerikke Memories is the first season and Melodies is the second. Although, Melodies follows the relationships of Kuze/Miyako and Yuu/Yuuko. While Melodies might be a sequel, it is also fair to call it a prequel as well considering most of the Yuu/Yuuko relationship is flashbacks. Technically speaking though, yes, they are seasons 1 and 2.

  • i'm probably gonna get a lot of hate for this but am i the only one that paid more attention to the story than the opening btw this a great op though

  • uh wat does the story in the background talk about O.o

  • This anime is soooo kawaii!! love both of the openings n___n <3 but Yuuko, is she an angel or something ? Soo sad that she died, nd muziki has gotten sooo big *w* poor lonely yu... well anyways, loooved it!

  • @heidyXD mizuki * x.x gomen-ne ..

  • best Drama,Romance Anime in the world !!!

  • 神だなww

  • why doesnt ef a tale of memories has no openin music??I mean the episodes start off w/o this op?

  • i dun understand why is this anime drowned??

    why do clannad is more popular?

    i know clannad is good but this anime is as good as clannad!

  • @Arleran Ef's story was too slow for some people and Clannad was virtually perfect.

  • @twinroaxas2000 I'm sorry but I completely disagree with you. It's the complete opposite. Clannad did not get sad or interesting until the 2nd half of season two. The complete 1st season of Clannad was a waste of my time it was dull and boring. And so was the 1st half of season two. Clannad was the slow one, Ef is only 12 episodes so there is no way in hell ef could possibly be the slow one. But please don't misinterpret what I say I don't hate Clannad but I do think it's very over rated.

  • @TheZalor Woah, woah. I said "some people". "Some people" happens to be a large portion of anime watchers on the internet. I myself like Ef. However, some people thought the plot was too dull contrary to what you think. But I have to commend the series for being impressive with only 12 episodes. However, Clannad was already a huge success BEFORE it got an anime. I also must add the Clannad was successful enough to have a movie, and I think 8 bonus episodes, a side sequel.

  • @twinroaxas2000 I'm not bagging on Ef at all. But then again, you have your opinion and I have mine

  • @twinroaxas2000 It's not you who got me upset. What got me upset is the "some people" who think Clannad was the best series ever when it it's self had many faults. I mean yah it's with out a doubt a great series. Or at least After story was, Season one was not really that interesting and really did feel like a waste of time. But what really upsets me is that Clannad's fame over shadows other great animes like Kanon, Air, and Ef a tale of memories.

  • @TheZalor What I say on behalf of the first season is that it was based off every girl's arc so the plot had to jump all over the place making it wierd for people. But Kanon and Air were made from the same creators of Clannad, you knew that right?

  • @twinroaxas2000 Yah I know that Kanon, Air, and Clannad were made by the same company. In fact I even played and beat the game Kanon 2 times. And I have the game Clannad. I only got up to day 21 in Clannad though, although I do plan on finishing it some day.

  • @TheZalor Although I can't say much for Angel Beats!. That kinda sucked.

  • @twinroaxas2000 Actually I have not gotten to see Angel Beasts yet. But thanks for the warning, lol.

  • @TheZalor I do commend it's Music score. It was very good. ED, OP, and inset songs.

  • @TheZalor I liked this anime, but i didnt love it. It was so gloomy all the way through, that the overall feeling was more numbing and depressing than anything else . It never had the down to earth light hearted feel, which made the characters seem alive, like Clannad. Clannad made me laugh with the characters, and enjoy their triumphs, which made me feel their pain during the sad bits. As did Air and Kanon. I do agree partly though. Clannad series 1 really wasn't great

  • @ishmael1991 wille clannad is a better anime because it combined more elemnts,drama..tragedy...comed­y ,better visuals and a better soundtrack...ef did one thing a bit better....it played with my emotions like a rollercoster...clannad just hits you with 2-3 tragic events,thats all..but i do like it more than ef

  • @deenman23 i definatly agree clannad was the first anime i cried at. although i was a little mad that they made u sgo through so much sad stuff the nfor it to be all happy in one ep again lol thats what made it so damn goodthough!! :D GO CLANNAD

  • @deenman23

    Lol emtionas like a rollercoaster, well said. Never thought of it like that. I always knew this anime series was comparable to Clannad I just couldn't figure out the exact differences. I think what you say is correct.

  • Comment removed

  • i read people's comments, but the original story of ef is a lot sadder than it was in anime (yes i am japanese and i actually played the game ef). the game, which is the original story, is reallllly good, but some might find it disturbing. just putting it out there, cause none of u seem to know this.

  • This reminded me of Persona 3

  • Even though im a guy. i almost cried on episode 11, then i was so fucking happy on episode 12

  • love this song!

    

  • The second season was a tad bit under the first but i still think that it was beautiful. I expected it to be a totally different story. You've should've seen my face when i saw Chihiro and Miyako, i went crazy. ^.^ I thought it would simply be the white hair guy and his past and thats it. There was alot of depth in this anime

  • I loved EF it changed my entire view of animes. I thought that there were either the Gintamas (totally out there) NAruto (Fighting based) or Chibi (basically really cute things) After i watched School Days i've gotten a totally different look at romance animes. I've then watched Myself; Yourself (was okay) then Watched Ef. BLOWN AWAY

  • @1yuyuhakushoyusuke myself;youself was like school days (not as good though) where it starts sugar sweet and gets more and more screwed up. Man the end of school days really fucked me up

  • Comment removed

  • The settings in anime was amazing. I wished I lived in it.

  • i love this anime, i just finished watching it, its awesome, i love thins song

  • can anyone tell me where i can find the full text of Chihiro's book?

  • memories was way better =D

  • this was one really good anime..loved it

  • memories was first

  • was memories first or was it melodies?

  • So i havent started watching the show yet im just about to but is Tale of Melodies first or is Tale of Memories???

  • @oXPaperHeartzXo tale of memories first, then melodies.

  • My fav part is . . .

    "I have been. . .looking for my own style!! Don't give up! Here comes the life!!"

    SO BEAUTIFUL!!

    And I cried through this whole series like a BABY!! LOVED IT!!

    It was kinda crazy how realistic it really was when you thought about it. . .

  • What order are you supposed to watch them in? xD It looks awesome..

  • @RikuxDaisukeNiwa13 a tale of memories first, then a tale of melodies.

  • @bashen745 Thanks! I started watching it :D

  • @RikuxDaisukeNiwa13 your welcome! awesome series, i hope you enjoy it. :D

  • does anyone know if there is anywhere where i could find the full text of Chihiro book?

  • Yeah... ;D

  • Shaft rules

  • i cried at the japanese version of this!!!... ephoric field

  • memories is incredible, melodies is meh.. i haven't finished it yet but the characters do not appeal to me

  • I prefer this series ... melodies.. onestly i don't like it and his chater. LoL

    Hiro-hiro X Miya-miya :3

  • Ef is amazing. <3 Though the second series is.. Not so great. But that is just my opinion. :D

  • Comment removed

  • anybody where i can find the whole text in the background please help ^^

  • @gallaros9 The text in the background is Chihiro's story. You can ear it along the anime.

  • Yuko Amamiya is and stays the best character of the whole serie's !!!!! love her

    LOVE THE HOLE DAMN STORY !!

  • @rtsfreak2007 I love Yuko... But I think also Chihiro is one of my favourites characters!! :D I'm agree with you ;) I love alllll the storyyyy! :D

  • OKAY well first off, this is NINJA.....JUST SAYING..... :)

    lol anywayyss, i have a question sooo SUMONE, ANYONE, please answer!:

    i know this is stupid but, what is this anime about? i've heard a lot of ppl say it was good soo i decided to look it up.....well....google was being stupid, soooo SUMONE PLEASE TELL ME WHAT THIS ANIME IS ABOUT!!! ARIGATOU!!

  • @lifesong000000001 it actually consist of three love stories.. one of the story is pretty much like 50 first dates, but instead of a comedic take they did it dramatically. others include the usual love triangle, and unrequited love. the story and the graphic are actually quite good but the sequel, is the better gem tho. i am quite an anime nerd and i've seen my share of character i despise. but, the sequel actually presented me with an antagonist that i really want to kill so much.

  • @yoshi0810 lol heyy, thanx! i appreciate it! i'll give it a try and watch it :D thannkss!!!

  • @lifesong000000001 This anime can be about anything you have not seen yet... The relationships between the characters are amazing... The characters personalities are perfect... The animation is awesome... The only thing that you have to know is that YOU MUST SEE IT! :D ;) There's a first season called "ef a tale of memories" and there's a second one called "ef a tale of melodies".

  • yaa

  • Save me, my knight! - is the theme of this anime.

    very meaningful indeed. The theme of this anime is mature.

  • I love this song and the anime

    one of my fav ^^

  • Que buen anime !! la verdad muy recomendablee!!!

  • The background words arent even grammatical and make no sense.

  • @regulusinmyhand

    Background words are excerpt from the novel that one of the characters was writing on as a metaphorical autobiography of sorts.

    And the words make much more sense than other engrish I've seen.

  • @mirai679 yeah too bad that its kinda hard to read the words XD

  • @cheekobunny

    Yup. I'd read it if it actually came out as a real novel...

  • Comment removed

  • LOL! I'm such a retard, I thought the words floating by were the english lyrics! XD

  • Too bad melodies was shit compared to this.

  • @bashen745 agreed, probly didnt hate it as much as you do but melodies seemed more like.... they just wanted to profit some more off the success of memories

  • @TheFreedom1696 I see where you're going at, they probably did want more profit.

  • @bashen745 its not uncommon, the best example i think would be gundam seed and gundam seed destiny (destiny is season 2 incase you dont know those) and the storyline for both is almost identical, just some other characters

    i wont say destiny was bad but... how cheap can you get, using hte same storyline for both seasons

  • @bashen745 Mmm i think that melodies was the sad part of this story... I like both of them.

  • @hiraisakura you're probably right on the mark with it being the sad part, but it was definitely not as interesting as what memories was.

  • @bashen745 agreed

  • @bashen745 Melodies was the Sadder version of Ef. Memories showed triumph and happiness. Yet Melodies showed that even through despair you shouldn't let it hold you down.

    But i still think that Memories was so much betta simply because of the unique character selection of Chihiro. :D Chihiro was absolutly was the best part of the show.

  • @bashen745

    Felt like they rushed through Kei and Kyousuke.

  • There are a few small errors in the way she phrases, but otherwise this is pretty good english. Also, I like how they make subtle (sometimes not so subtle) changes to the op to reflect the tone of the episode

  • @Evnyofdeath agreed, this is very good english, especially since they got another letter system then us, and compared to most english from japanese.

    especially in the episodes themselves, when they make a character who is supposed to be from america and speaks english sometimes, its like.... the japanese is easier to understand than whatever he says in english

  • if you listen closely at 1:03 you can hear fishes

  • es una de mis series favoritas

    al igual que el opening  :3

  • i cried at the ending of the series T.T

  • @purplerosesxX Me tooo!!! Did you finish melodies?

  • @hiraisakura Yes I just did :D I thought that memories was a bit better but I loved them Both ^.^

  • @purplerosesxX ^^ Me too!!! I saw the message that you left me on my channel... I answered there... XD I told you that I already watched 5cm/s.... It's amazing! Did you watch "Voice of a Star" / Hoshi no Koe?

  • @hiraisakura Yesh I love them. :D

    :D :D :D lol. I love how we like the same anime's :D

  • @hiraisakura omg those are my fav series and makoto shinkai's movies are also de best for me <3

  • @hiraisakura i love to join you guys.may i? i did watch 5cm/s.it is pretty good but it did not make me cry.ef did.when i finished the game,i cried.also,finished the anime.cried again and hit me twice.the other like CLANNAD did make me cry a lot. Key's game did really well in this area

  • @hiraisakura wow i am amazed...after watching over 200 animes...i dint think anything could surprise me...i dint think anything could come close to Clannad in terms of drama and tragedy,but ef was a good surprise,it wasnt tragic like clannad was,but it played with my feelings very hard...still havent finished second season,so i may be wrong on it not being as tragic as clannad until i finish it

  • Why does the song remind me SOOO much of Nightwish?

    Soo soothing...soo good... too bad I just can't find a working torrent for the anime before I decide if I should buy it...

  • can some 1 help me please? ive only seen 1 ep.. it says memories so it put's stuff in my head. is the place where it was snowing an train station are those same 2? just differnt age's? or what? im confused

  • @subzero2039 There are two different places that look almost if not exactly alike. Ones in Japan I think and the other in Australia.

    I hope that's what you were talking about it's been a while since I watched the series.

  • @HarvestMoonAngel THX im still gonna be confused with some.. -it make's me sad with just watching it idk.. i mean not cause sad stuff its just the show gives off a sad feeling

    but thx im sure that will help

  • it looks like school days art.....that is the only thing that bugs me

  • @JKlolita Like School Days?!

    Oh hell no, Ef's art is one of a kind, so unique!

  • @MonyXChan no..it looks like school days to me...XD but i think its a lot more artistic....i actually liked school days art until the characters went crazy and started slaughtering one another o_o

  • I love it when you get a Japanese artist who sings in English. It feels so weird the way they pronounce the worlds but it sounds good :)

  • I really liked the ending, I though the right people ended up together . will I be disappointed if I watch the sequel?

  • @disrepdog you might be, but you probably won't in my opinion i loved the sequel but i liked the first season