What an amazing song.....amazing voice. It's chilling. Thanks for posting this. I was at the show and it was one of the only times that I have been floored by a song on the first listen.
Rob Dickenson..You Rock...And I would love to spend the last 5 minutes of my life w/you. Great song... Like all your songs.. Genius...U really sing from your soul.. You are a very gifted musician.
I unlike you guys have listened to Rob since ferment. I can play most of his songs on guitar. I do not for the love of god understand how he can fail so much on the studio version. The production is a load of crap. This is the 2nd best version out there. The other live version put chills down my spine like only Tori Amos or Morrisey can do.
Wow! Thanks for turning me on to this sound, merkiron!! But, I must say, the first like 30 seconds or so sound like he's channelling Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah! And, that's just groovy in my book!!! Hear a bit of Floyd in there, too. DIG it in a big big way! Thanks again... and thanks hloveday for posting the vid!!!
That's cool that you pick up on Floyd here, bc his band, Catherine Wheel, strongly referenced them. They covered 'Wish you Where here' as the opener for their B-sides compilation "Like Cats And Dogs". Come to think, this song does resemble that classic! Once you here a few other key tracks, and the hear present hamond organ you'll be really get some Floyd. Glad you dig it!
What an amazing song.....amazing voice. It's chilling. Thanks for posting this. I was at the show and it was one of the only times that I have been floored by a song on the first listen.
BigDaddyBooze 11 months ago
Rob Dickenson..You Rock...And I would love to spend the last 5 minutes of my life w/you. Great song... Like all your songs.. Genius...U really sing from your soul.. You are a very gifted musician.
angelwingzstar 1 year ago
Great song. the person who commented below this is a fucktard.
quinnlefeber 2 years ago
I unlike you guys have listened to Rob since ferment. I can play most of his songs on guitar. I do not for the love of god understand how he can fail so much on the studio version. The production is a load of crap. This is the 2nd best version out there. The other live version put chills down my spine like only Tori Amos or Morrisey can do.
PreacherDeus 2 years ago
He's been working with Steve Perry. Hoping for a comeback Steve!!
vogts2 2 years ago
studio version thats what i ment
doomy08854 2 years ago
no one has this on studio only damn
im going to be the first one =)
he is a good artist and singer
doomy08854 2 years ago
Rob continues to provide us with magical songs a majestic voice never stop
walter19745 2 years ago
Great album, love the remakes!
Thanks for posting this!
irenegade 2 years ago
Comment removed
marisazeke 3 years ago
I've heard this song a million times and it still gives me goosebumps.
I <3 u, robby!
lizberry81 3 years ago
Live is always BEST!
Rob you are my god!
Distilled13 3 years ago
this is better than the CD version. much more haunting & sensitive. love it!
mabeldu 3 years ago
thx for this..I saw him play with The Church in AZ. in July of '06 Brilliant!
excito69 3 years ago
I love Robby and Catherine Wheel... never heard of this song -- VERY pretty! Thank you very much!!
lizberry81 4 years ago
This guy blows me away. I'm speechless......
merkiron 4 years ago
Wow! Thanks for turning me on to this sound, merkiron!! But, I must say, the first like 30 seconds or so sound like he's channelling Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah! And, that's just groovy in my book!!! Hear a bit of Floyd in there, too. DIG it in a big big way! Thanks again... and thanks hloveday for posting the vid!!!
LeonardAndNickFan 4 years ago
That's cool that you pick up on Floyd here, bc his band, Catherine Wheel, strongly referenced them. They covered 'Wish you Where here' as the opener for their B-sides compilation "Like Cats And Dogs". Come to think, this song does resemble that classic! Once you here a few other key tracks, and the hear present hamond organ you'll be really get some Floyd. Glad you dig it!
merkiron 4 years ago
Thanx for this, I went pee when this came on and missed the majority of it!
t.
GO TORONTO FC!
tsnyders 4 years ago
My pleasure Todd! Gotta hate when nature calls & you miss an amazing song - glad I could share with you :)
hloveday 4 years ago
yaaaaay :)
candycane15 4 years ago
Wow! I've never seen him sing this live. Thank You.
TheShadyOne 4 years ago
Beautiful song, brought tears to my eyes when we saw him do it in LA.
MissCrysti 5 years ago
YES! finally! I was hoping this would show up one day. That was a fantastic show and this song was the hilight for me.
dancingmind 5 years ago
You found it, cool, saw your comment over on "Heal"
tooheys1968 5 years ago
Awesome song.
mrpig286 5 years ago
Great tune. Can't wait for a studio version.
919winters 5 years ago
OMG, hloveday, you are a goddess of video ! ! ! What a great story to that song.
tooheys1968 5 years ago