Truly outstanding performance. He does play it much more delicately - in the score Haydn marks "forte" for a few more sections than it is apparent in Brendel's version - but it serves a point. Bravo!
Some years ago I heard a phenomenal piano recital by Rudolf Serkin in Los Angeles. Some wonderful elderly ladies behind me tried to pay the ultimate complement " Nicht seit dem Schnabel". That certainly applies to this performance as well.
Haydn's Piano Sonata in C HXVI No 50. 3rd movement - Allegro molto - just in case anyone is interested! This is masterful playing... complete control AND freedom of expression. What a beautiful choice of encore. Very witty too.
Wow, it's amazing how the orchestra won't stand up when he asks them at the end...it's like he's pulling teeth to get them to stand and receive the applause!
you guys have it all wrong. the orchestra is perfectly capable of following instructiions. it s just that they don t think they deserve the applause and that ALL the applause should be for maestro abbado. it is a great sign of respect for abbado.
Ah, good point, I didn't think of that. Different strokes for different folks I guess.... However, wouldn't it have been more respectful to follow his wishes and stand when he (Abbado) asked him to stand, as in most other cultures?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I AM WRITING THIS HERE, BECAUSE i am already blocked in the "100 years aniversary of Carnegie Hall"..
Even "Raphael" an spaniard popular an hysteric singer was invited to sing at Carnegie Hall. Music is a thing . Music busiines is a different thing. In NY where i lived for 6 years are many very goo music connoiseurs, but also a lot of snobs who adore Serkin (Rudolf) and Brendel, So they pay money to go to recitals and concerts. That´s money .....
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Hello "vladvezler" good question...
Well beggining with Sachnabel the maniac of changing tempo every minute... for his subjetive reasons. Cortot was a great musical who belong to the kind of "Labil" or "Low hormonla" playing. It doesn´t mean bad, but is out of my line of "Musical apretiation", Kempff form those trhee is that what i like most of them. He was a begginig of make a kind of parameter for some specific music, especially Beethoven. Of course he had not the dimension ..continune...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
To all people who write comments in you tube: Go to the Cecil Licad links and jut post something against her, and you´ll realized next day you will be blocked , but not only that: The worst : They erased you previous comments. If that is not manipulation, what it is?
Hey Kid, your refering to (Hob.XVI:50), the old numbering system. It is No. 60 in C major if you don't believe me, verify it with John McCabe's complete Haydn Piano Sonatas CD Box Set. I am absolutely sure it is correct.
You're actually both right about the number. "60" comes from the "Wiener Urtext" edition and "50" is the Hoboken number. It simply depends on which numbering system you find more reliable (and it's really inconsequential), but most pianists do, in fact, use the Hoboken number (and it's not considered "old", kid).
Brendel actually plays Chopin for himself. He just doesn't seem to be comfortable or confident performing these composers in front of others. There's a documentary on youtube about him in which he plays a Chopin prelude (No. 4 in E minor)
That was actually a recording of Cortot playing the prelude - I heard from a reliable source that he played the 3rd sonata along with Gaspard de la Nuit at Bridgewater Hall Manchester a few years back
Perhaps he enjoys the music of the Classical era more than the Romantic era. Every pianist has his/her favorites. Some pianists enjoy listening to some composers but would prefer not to play them.
Brendel is famously a Schubert specialist. That's his shtik, and he does it very well. Like Gould played Bach and a zillion people play Chopin almost exclusively. Somebody or other did Scriabin ... What's wrong with being a specialist?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It´s wrong . The word specialist is assigned mostly ..or created by people who managed the musical bussines. Normally it is asigned to a pianists with limitations as Brendel. as an example: People assigned to a Rubintein as a Chopin specialist, but he always rejected it, and he did nice becuase he was abñe to play any music. Of ciourse some better than other, but he is capable. Did you listen Brendel Prokofieff recordings? haha i listened. He just have a very narrow capacity.. to continue..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
continuing... to play music different than his viennese repertoire and so boring (in his way of playing).
The term specialist in most cases is an excuse to justify mediocrity. Regarding "Claps" that´s very relative, here you can realize the claps finally are given to abbado.
gosh, it's abbado afterward. Where did you take this video? It looks like a concert with Mahler Youth Orchestra. the final applauses remind me the concert we played under Eschenbach in Hamburg and Berlin.
It's synchronized clapping - the audience wants Brendel to come out. Also you hear "bis!" - they want an encore. But this clearly was an encore - he must have played a concerto with the orchestra before this.
he is sooo greta but what a disservice this nasty recorded sound is. U have to use your imaination just to hear his color! rather not have than to sound so bad. His tempi were interesting about all i could hear of his individ
nice show
delsiemeineke 2 months ago
Truly outstanding performance. He does play it much more delicately - in the score Haydn marks "forte" for a few more sections than it is apparent in Brendel's version - but it serves a point. Bravo!
bontempo01 2 years ago
Oh my god. This is so fantastic. Brendel has a wonderful humour and intelligence to discover Haydn's jokes and present them witch such nonchalance
Refamire30 2 years ago
Some years ago I heard a phenomenal piano recital by Rudolf Serkin in Los Angeles. Some wonderful elderly ladies behind me tried to pay the ultimate complement " Nicht seit dem Schnabel". That certainly applies to this performance as well.
PetervonBelvedere 2 years ago
Comment removed
PetervonBelvedere 2 years ago
I do love how he finishes, so simply.
Great carreer for a great man , BRENDEL .
pichuchika 2 years ago 4
0.48 hehe cuuuute !!!
tchebinai71 2 years ago
the orchestra should have played something else in all that applause.....
pianist12 3 years ago
Haydn's Piano Sonata in C HXVI No 50. 3rd movement - Allegro molto - just in case anyone is interested! This is masterful playing... complete control AND freedom of expression. What a beautiful choice of encore. Very witty too.
rontomcol 3 years ago 15
he's a masterpeace
adolfhitler7 3 years ago 3
indimenticabile maestro Brendel!
Sanrus 3 years ago 6
Wow, it's amazing how the orchestra won't stand up when he asks them at the end...it's like he's pulling teeth to get them to stand and receive the applause!
virtuoso1873 3 years ago 11
your right, the orchestra can't follow a simple instruction like that, you wonder how they follow his conducting... Abaddo's that is
Discerninator 3 years ago 5
you guys have it all wrong. the orchestra is perfectly capable of following instructiions. it s just that they don t think they deserve the applause and that ALL the applause should be for maestro abbado. it is a great sign of respect for abbado.
davecotuit 3 years ago 3
Ah, good point, I didn't think of that. Different strokes for different folks I guess.... However, wouldn't it have been more respectful to follow his wishes and stand when he (Abbado) asked him to stand, as in most other cultures?
Discerninator 3 years ago 4
I meant them to stand, not him to stand.
Discerninator 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I am pretty sure that´s is a German audience
frateramadeus
frateramadeus 3 years ago
Well, I'm going to see this guy in Gateshead, England on the 20th.
He's my favorite. Alfred Brendel.
hellomate639 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I AM WRITING THIS HERE, BECAUSE i am already blocked in the "100 years aniversary of Carnegie Hall"..
Even "Raphael" an spaniard popular an hysteric singer was invited to sing at Carnegie Hall. Music is a thing . Music busiines is a different thing. In NY where i lived for 6 years are many very goo music connoiseurs, but also a lot of snobs who adore Serkin (Rudolf) and Brendel, So they pay money to go to recitals and concerts. That´s money .....
ytpiano7....
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Comment removed
vladvexler 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hello "vladvezler" good question...
Well beggining with Sachnabel the maniac of changing tempo every minute... for his subjetive reasons. Cortot was a great musical who belong to the kind of "Labil" or "Low hormonla" playing. It doesn´t mean bad, but is out of my line of "Musical apretiation", Kempff form those trhee is that what i like most of them. He was a begginig of make a kind of parameter for some specific music, especially Beethoven. Of course he had not the dimension ..continune...
ytpiano7 3 years ago
If you had another brain, it would be lonely.
jakehohsfield 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To all people who write comments in you tube: Go to the Cecil Licad links and jut post something against her, and you´ll realized next day you will be blocked , but not only that: The worst : They erased you previous comments. If that is not manipulation, what it is?
Ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
What sonata's number is it?
Please, answer me
thanks
pianista32 4 years ago
Its-Franz Joseph Haydn's Piano Sonata No. 60 in C major, Finale: Allegro molto...
GeniusHaydn 4 years ago
I regret to inform you, that the sonata, which is played in this video have number 50 :)
mziel53 4 years ago
Hey Kid, your refering to (Hob.XVI:50), the old numbering system. It is No. 60 in C major if you don't believe me, verify it with John McCabe's complete Haydn Piano Sonatas CD Box Set. I am absolutely sure it is correct.
GeniusHaydn 4 years ago
So there are two correct numbering systems.
mziel53 4 years ago
You're actually both right about the number. "60" comes from the "Wiener Urtext" edition and "50" is the Hoboken number. It simply depends on which numbering system you find more reliable (and it's really inconsequential), but most pianists do, in fact, use the Hoboken number (and it's not considered "old", kid).
KennYWooD2 2 years ago 2
Completamente maravilloso. Bravo, Ed.
clasesdepiano 4 years ago
that last part is actually kind of scary. those poor musicians.
tarnashun 4 years ago
Brendel actually plays Chopin for himself. He just doesn't seem to be comfortable or confident performing these composers in front of others. There's a documentary on youtube about him in which he plays a Chopin prelude (No. 4 in E minor)
wol4fram 4 years ago
he played chopin when very young, and decided to drop it then cos he felt he would need to specialize in it
chrish12345 4 years ago
That was actually a recording of Cortot playing the prelude - I heard from a reliable source that he played the 3rd sonata along with Gaspard de la Nuit at Bridgewater Hall Manchester a few years back
lecomptedelalune 4 years ago
I wish Brendel would play some Chopin and Rachmaninov, too. He's so gifted, but he's boxed himself into the German School almost exclusively.
OnGuardForPeace 4 years ago
He played Chopin 30 or 40 years ago. But now he only plays Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert, that´s it. I read he doesn´t like Rachmaninov at all.
zigeunerlieder 4 years ago
Perhaps he enjoys the music of the Classical era more than the Romantic era. Every pianist has his/her favorites. Some pianists enjoy listening to some composers but would prefer not to play them.
cfeeney2 4 years ago
Brendel is famously a Schubert specialist. That's his shtik, and he does it very well. Like Gould played Bach and a zillion people play Chopin almost exclusively. Somebody or other did Scriabin ... What's wrong with being a specialist?
gspaulsson 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It´s wrong . The word specialist is assigned mostly ..or created by people who managed the musical bussines. Normally it is asigned to a pianists with limitations as Brendel. as an example: People assigned to a Rubintein as a Chopin specialist, but he always rejected it, and he did nice becuase he was abñe to play any music. Of ciourse some better than other, but he is capable. Did you listen Brendel Prokofieff recordings? haha i listened. He just have a very narrow capacity.. to continue..
ytpiano7 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
continuing... to play music different than his viennese repertoire and so boring (in his way of playing).
The term specialist in most cases is an excuse to justify mediocrity. Regarding "Claps" that´s very relative, here you can realize the claps finally are given to abbado.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
the only german composers he plays are beethoven and bach - how is that 'boxing himself in'?
chrish12345 4 years ago
the only german composers he plays are beethoven and bach, how is that 'boxing himself in'?
chrish12345 4 years ago
He was having lots of fun; it's great to see.
Which orchestra was that?
The violinist in the middle is cute :-)
Perkeno 5 years ago
gosh, it's abbado afterward. Where did you take this video? It looks like a concert with Mahler Youth Orchestra. the final applauses remind me the concert we played under Eschenbach in Hamburg and Berlin.
mingweicello 5 years ago
I have never heard applause like this before! It's funny. Is it a German thing?
cfeeney2 4 years ago
It's synchronized clapping - the audience wants Brendel to come out. Also you hear "bis!" - they want an encore. But this clearly was an encore - he must have played a concerto with the orchestra before this.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
how come its still so revolutionary to see people smiling
chrish12345 5 years ago
Anyone could post a concerto performance before this encore? :)
chai35 5 years ago
he is sooo greta but what a disservice this nasty recorded sound is. U have to use your imaination just to hear his color! rather not have than to sound so bad. His tempi were interesting about all i could hear of his individ
lovesGenet 5 years ago
he is good, big up
JackYBHV 5 years ago