I've got some scots(McDonalds) in me but love Irish music and dance. Wished the Scots had copied these styles from their Irish brethren ..... it's all CELTIC.
Umm...Who's being trolled? Who's trolling? Why is everyone so hyped up about it? How many people are involved? 1? 5? 10? Seriously. If church bells make you want to troll, then skip to like 1:00 or something! 2:13 is a really good place to start. And I'm saying 2:13 because that's my favorite part. And I'm not even Irish of Celtic or whatever! Does anyone else like that part???
Gentlemen, I visited this channel to listen to some amazing music. I visited this channel to listen to some of the best violin playing I've ever heard. I came here to relax after a stressful day and, instead, I found a group of people arguing over who's celtic and who's not.
@MICKYMAVYT Celts don't exist anymore. The Scottish are Scottish. How Celts, however, can, and do make up much of the Scottish ancestry. The Celts as an actual people haven't existed for quite some time. This is not the iron age. This is not the age of the Roman Empire.
@MICKYMAVYT It's good to know you're ignorant about history, and the history of the Celts. Calling the Scottish a Celt now would be like referring to the French, or the Belgium in modern day society as Gauls. Do you understand how retarded that is? The Gauls, and more encompassing, the Celtic society, and languages haven't been practices for centuries. The Celts are a group of tribes that existed in the Iron Age, and during the Roman Empire. Are you going to call Italians Romans? LOL. Retard.
@earth13 "the Celtic languages haven't been practices for centuries" ...Go and teach yourself, about 3 million people speak a celtic language nowadays.
E breizh emaon o chom ha komz a ran un tammig brezhoneg. Kompren a rez ?
@celticbattleaxe More evidence for the link between Welsh and Gaulish language is: The Welsh word for women is "merched" and the celtic French (Breton) word for women is also "merched".
The word "scotus" was originally used in relation to the Irish but there was a great amount of population exchange between Scotland and Ireland and the word eventually applied to Scotland only.
@heliotropezzz333 I think you're a little confused. Bretons and Gauls were two different celtic people with different languages, and Bretons and Welsh were originally one single people : the ancient Britons, that's why Welsh language and Breton language are quite similar...
@29Loubi Uh, Gaulish and Breton are both P Celtic, as is Basque (which is the closest surviving relative of Gaulish). Yes, Breton and Pretan come from the same people, but their language is similar to Gaulish.
@XanonymousFY My dear sir, you are mislead here. The Basque people trace their ancestry to Aquitanian Gauls and Celt-iberians, and their language is one of the most uninfluenced by outsiders. Gaulish and Breton are distantly related, not closely. Both are P Celtic, but Breton is most similar to Welsh and Cornish (Pretan languages). Still don't believe me? Well then, look at the works of TGE Powell and Dr.Ian Barnes, both highly respected and knowledgeable people in the Celtic historical field.
Firstly : Basque people were in Europe LONG BEFORE the Celts arrived there.
Secondly : "their language is one of the most uninfluenced by outsiders"...75 % of Basque vocabulary is of foreign origin ( Celt, Latin, Spanish, French, etc...)
Thirdly : "Gaulish and Breton are distantly related", of course that's true but Breton is however probably nowadays the closest language to Gaulish, concerning synthax, vocabulary, etc...
@celticbattleaxe Finally, if Basque is a celtic language, explain me why all linguist experts all over the world consider it as the unique isolate language of Europe ? Basque has been influenced by Celtic languages, but it is NOT a Celtic language, and surely not the closest language to Gaulish. I know what I'm talking about since I'm Breton with Basque origins.
Do you even know the history of the Basque people? I've given you my evidence, you've given me none except your own thoughts and a deleted comment. If you can't even defend your point, then why are you still arguing?
So then, what is 'closest' to Gaulish in your opinion? You do realize that there was no national language among the Gauls, and that they spoke in many different dialects? Basque is a descendant of Aquitanian Gaulish.
@celticbattleaxe I'm referring to what all good linguists and ethnologists know, except for your swindlers writers, TGE Powell and Dr.Ian Barnes, "both highly respected and knowledgeable people in the Celtic historical field."
Open any books about Basque language or history and you'll see you're totally wrong. Of course there were different gaulish dialects, but they all obeyed to common rules, the same as in insular celtic languages, for example, consonantic mutations.
@XanonymousFY I will admit, there is much controversy in Celtic history, and we do not know nearly as much as we'd like. Oh, and Mr high-and-mighty-bruce-almighty, you spelled "consonant" wrong.
I do my reading, and I thoroughly enjoy it.
Still, Breton is not as related to Gaulish as it is to Cornish and Welsh. After all, the Bretons originally came from the Cornwall area and other parts of southern Albion, crossing the English Channel to settle in what the Romans called Armorica.
@XanonymousFY And I think you mean the similarities in certain words - for example, Gaelige and Scottish are both Q Celtic because their word for 'son of' is "mac" - Manannan mac Lir, for instance.
Cornish, Welsh, and Breton word for 'son of' is "ap" or "map". Gaulish and Basque have similar words to these, and they count as P Celtic
@XanonymousFY And one more thing - where did you supposedly learn Basque and Breton? You clearly don't live in either place, and I know that very few people speak either language.
@celticbattleaxe There are NONE of these rules in modern Basque language, and that's why it isn't recognised as a celtic language by linguists, sorry about that. I studied celtic languages, I speak Breton currently and I know Basque language, even a fool would see there is nothing in common between these two languages family. And please don't tell me about Brittany history or language, I know them better than you thought. ;-)
@XanonymousFY Well duh - there's no noticeable similarity between Gaelige and Breton, now then, is there? Still, you have no given me the names of your sources. I have given you mine, and yes, they are highly respected individuals in the Celtic historical field. I don't make up crap from wiki.
...Or you thought. Basque is related to Aquitanian - Aquitanian is Gaulish, and Gaulish is P Celtic.
Until you give me evidence of your research, I cannot trust your word as valid.
@celticbattleaxe Do you even READ what I write? I just read your first sentence : "there's no noticeable similarity between Gaelige and Breton". These two languages are part of INSULAR CELTIC LANGUAGES, even if Gaelige and Brythhonic languages are two subfamilies of this group. As a result, they share SEVERALS similarities : consonantic mutations, syntaxic order verb-subject-object, and many others I can't traduce cause French is my native language...
@celticbattleaxe So you want sources? My grandmother is Basque and she agrees that Basque are NOT Celts and that Basque language is NOT a Celtic language. Where did I learn Breton? I was born and raise in Brittany and I'm still living there. Where did YOU learn to say "I live in Brittany" in Breton? Probably you found it on the Internet. You don't live in a celtic place, I bet you can't even speak a celtic language, and you want to teach others about the Celts? You can't be serious !
@XanonymousFY Oh, I'd doubt that. You are probably lying through your teeth, because your channel says that you live in 'St.Helena'. You are not still living there. I rest my case.
You don't live in a "Celtic place" either. St.Helena was settled by the English, idiot. Stop lying.
Yes, I can speak a little Cymraeg and Gaelige. As I've said before, I am Scottish (clan Gordon), Irish (clan Dempsey and McClain) and Welsh (far back in history).
@XanonymousFY Sorry, but I cannot trust your word, and STILL you have not brought me sources. You said that you get your sources from 'linguists besides Dr.Ian Barnes and TGE Powell (who are legit people, btw)". Well then, who are they, may I ask? If you cannot answer this, your argument is futile and has no place here. Seriously, "Celtic" does not just mean that you have to be of Celtic blood or live in the UK or Brittany. To be a Celt means to be a Celt at heart, soul, spirit and mind.
@XanonymousFY You lied - enough said. For all I know you could be a troll - maybe, maybe not. You don't live in Brittany, you live in St.Helena, or so says your channel.
I hope I'm wrong. Seriously, I do. I have had more $hit from people who BS me about the Celts than anyone else I know. I've had English 'loyalists' troll me (FatallInstinct1), and too many people who lie.
@celticbattleaxe Loooooool my channel says I live in St Helena as it said I was living in Antarctica two weeks ago !!! I don't care about my channel, ok? If you don't trust me I can speak a perfect French, cause French is nowadays (unfortunately) the only official language of Brittany, and I LIVE in Brittany. I'm not a troll and I fuck English loyalists, right?
@XanonymousFY From what I know, your channel indicator for 'location' bases it off of your email.
Still, I hope I am wrong. You must forgive me seeming hostility - too many times have I been the target of moronic fools - people who claim to know Celtic history and really don't, the English loyalist idiots who target ALL people of Scottish/Irish ancestry, and other trolls.
Oh, and when you referred to the 'Celtic Island', I think you left-out Eirinn and Man! :)
@XanonymousFY My 'location' on my channel has always said 'United States'. Still, I know very little of computers and all the software/hardware crap. But who are the linguists you were referring to? I should love to know, and research more about them. Like I said, I don't claim to be expert, and it is always good to hear more than 1 side of the story.
Let us set aside our differences and part without grudges -
@celticbattleaxe Si tu ne me crois toujours pas, je ne vais pas perdre davantage de temps avec toi. De toute évidence tu ne lis pas ce que j'écris et tu restes bêtement campé sur tes positions. Je n'ai jamais dit que les langues gaéliques et brittoniques étaient identiques, j'ai dit qu'elles appartenaient au même groupe : les langues celtiques insulaires. Elles sont de ce fait très proches, du point de vue du vocabulaire, de la syntaxe, de la grammaire, etc...
@XanonymousFY Et je ne suis pas stupide comme vous semblez le penser. Sans sources de recherche, je n'ai pas confiance en ce que les gens disent. Donnez-moi les noms de ces linguistes, et je peux encore la recherche.
Mais je dois demander, pourquoi n'avez-vous pas me donner leurs noms, quand j'ai demandé pour eux à plusieurs reprises? J'ai confiance en mes sources en raison de leur légitimité, et parce qu'ils ont étudié les celtes domaine historique pour un certain temps.
@celticbattleaxe I put back "France" as my country on my channel, are you satisfied now ? :-)
So you speak French? Great ! My sources are principally collective thoughts : in France, everybody knows (or maybe thinks you would say) that Basque aren't Celts. I never met any Basque, but I saw some of their comments on the internet, and they generally don't consider themselves as Celts.
@celticbattleaxe . Moreover, I don't speak Basque but I saw many sentences in this language and I never noticed any similarity with the other celtic languages. My other source is Wikipedia, which can be a good source of information in my opinion. I read french articles concerning Basque country, they probably have been written or at least revised by a Basque (for you surely know that a part of Basque country is located in France) : they all say that Basques were in Europe long before the Celts.
@celticbattleaxe They also say that Basque is the unique "isolat" of Europe; it means that it's the only european language which constitutes a family by itself. And according to them, 75 % of basque vocabulary is of foreign origin ! (celts, latin, spanish, french,...). That's why I was astonished when I saw your comments like " Basque is a celtic language and the closest to Gaulish". Finally, I read articles concerning celtic languages, and to be considered as celtic, a language must respect
@celticbattleaxe ... several rules, the most important of them is called " consonant mutations" and can be found in every insular celtic languages (Irish, Welsh, Breton, Scottish, Cornish and Manx) and probably in Gaulish, but you can't find this characteristic in the Basque language. That's why it's strange to me to admit that Basque is a celtic language...
@celticbattleaxe If you absolutely wish books' sources, I can give you the Wikipedia articles' bibliography concerning Basque language, but all books are in French or Spanish, except for this one : "The History of Basque", Oxford, 1997, by R. L. Trask.
@XanonymousFY No, they don't. Celtic as a set of languages hasn't been spoken for a long, long time. I hate to break this to you, but the linguistic nature of proper Celtic languages has not been used for centuries. That would be like me saying that I can speak Latin with others. It's partially true, but at the same time it is not. The language it's self is still used today, but as a language it's self, it is dead. There is a difference between "Dead" languages, and "Extinct" languages.
@earth13 You mean a proto-celtic language? That diverged thousands of years ago into the various branches of Celtic languages including the ones that survive today, and it itself came from an earlier indo-european language. I don't really get your point? You can hardly argue that today's Celtic languages are not a separate language group. What are they then?
@Glywysing942 You mean how Proto-Celtic is a reconstructed language based loosely on a dead language, and you don't know what you're talking about? It was reconstructed, and even PhD linguist professors don't call it Celtic. Honestly. People commenting on something they have next to no understanding about boggles my mind. Maybe you should also go take Linguistics when you eventually reach a post-secondary level of intellect.
@earth13 Wow. You're a nice person. No I don't mean that, there obviously existed a proto-celtic language at some point as an ancestor to today's languages. I suggested that that was what you were talking about when you mentioned that "Celtic as a set of languages has not been used for centuries". Mr. Professor, you seem to have avoided actually explaining this and resorted instead to insulting people. There exists a group of languages called Celtic, correct? So what do you mean?
@Glywysing942 No, there doesn't exist a set of languages called Celtic in current use. In fact, the modern languages are precisely called "Proto-Celtic", while the ancient version is referred to as Celtic. Proto-Celtic was reconstructed from what little they could gleam about the structure of Celtic languages. It's a misnomer, as well as slang when one refers to their language as "Celtic". It's retardation, and ignorance on behalf of those people that do speak the language to call it Celtic.
@earth13 What? It's a well accepted fact that there is a living indo-european language group called "Celtic". I have never heard these being called "proto-celtic" (and don't accuse me of ignorance - I have a great interest in celtic culture and language being from Wales myself, I have read extensively around the subject). Proto means an early or original form of something.
@Glywysing942 Don't speak to this troll. He actually knows nothing about celtic languages but he strongly believes he knows everything about them. What a clown !
@Glywysing942 You are ignorant as fuck. This is not a debate. You like to think you understand it, because you're mistaking the 1800's enlightenment movement, where people of Celtic decent called them selves Celtic, with the actual languages. They are properly called 'Proto-celtic", and while that may be hard for you to comprehend, like I said in the past, take Linguistics at your local college, and you'll hopefully get enlightened. People like you annoy me so much.
@earth13 There are TV programmes in celtic languages, radio transmissions, singers who sing in celtic language,theater actors, signposts in the street, etc... Celtic languages are spoken everyday in many schools and in some families. So they 're not dead yet thought. Latin is never spoken anywhere, except for some faculties.
@XanonymousFY This comment was so unbelievably stupid, I'm not even going to give you a response past: Go take Linguistics in University. Maybe you'll be less ignorant.
@earth13 lol ok arrogant prick. However, I speak French, English, Spanish, Latin and Breton. What do YOU speak except for English, before teaching me lessons about linguistics ?
@XanonymousFY First off, you do not "Speak" Latin, as Latin is also a dead language. You "Know" Latin. Which you don't. To humor a lair such as your self; I know French, English, German, Russian. By the by, just because you "Speak", or "Know" a language doesn't mean you fully grasp the linguistic nature of those languages, because learning a language is not even the greater part of study in linguistics. The language is the platform you use as a base to study in linguistics.
@earth13 First off, 'speak' is a verb and hence, not written with a capital S. Secondly, latin is not a dead language as it is worldwide used as the one and only science language. People may not have whole conversations in latin too often, but they do actually know how to.
Bottomline: don't act such a smartass when youn't know shit. Maybe you should get from behind your pc once in a while.
@paddotk Apparently it is you whom doesn't know shit. Latin is classified as a dead language. This isn't even up for debate. In fact, you can use credited sources like JSTOR, or EBSCO to show you that, or even uncredited sources like Wikipedia.
@earth13 'who', not 'whom'. And a language is dead when no person in the world ever speaks it other than for research of the language. Scientists do however. I really don't know what you're trying to pull here but it's stupid. One piece of advice: Don't say stuff like this in the real world or everyone will laugh in your face.
@paddotk I gave you the method, and the places to look it up for your self. I'm not sure what you're trying to pull, but ignorance of volition is incredibly idiotic of you. Good luck with your retardation.
@celticbattleaxe Well, I think we should just put an end to this discussion, cause you have your opinion, I have mine, and we probably can't find a consensus. At least we share a common point : we love celtic culture. Kenavo !
@XanonymousFY I don't claim to be an "expert" on this, but I study more about the Celts than most people - I am a mix of Welsh (far back in history), Scottish (clan Gordon), and Irish (clan Dempsey and McClain).
Still, Breton is not as related to Gaulish as it is to Cornish and Welsh. After all, the Bretons originally came from the Cornwall area and other parts of southern Albion, crossing the English Channel to settle in what the Romans called Armorica.
@GokzTT People often confuse "Pict" and "Scot" too often. The Picts were P Celtic, same as the Welsh, Corns, and Gauls. The Scots, deriving from the Latin word 'Scotti' meaning "to plunder", are Q Celtic, which links them to the Irish. P and Q Celtic are language separations, since the Pretannic/ Welsh (may have been similar to the Gauls) word for "son of" is "ap" or "map", and the Irish/Scottish word for "son of" is "mac".
@padzter Yep - it is a little annoying when people confuse the two, or claim to be "famous historians" and cannot even describe the language similarities. It helps to have a background in linguistics :).
It's due to weather, not that my eyes change colour, I mean nature right? It's the reason why Arabians are dark, Europeans are fair, and Africans are really dark!
Thanks for more detail I did not have, Taranis223. Of course, we may never know for sure, in this life. My speculation, by the way, was offered to the public in the fiction, The Pleistocene Redemption, and you are welcome to enjoy a free PDF copy of it. I'd bet putting the URL in this post, even though there's nothing for sale, would get the post deleted by self-righteous geeks. So, try putting this back together: dan gallagher (.) webs (.) com . Have a nice day.
Say what you will Ireland is where the culture of the ancient Celts has survived in its purest form and that has led to the revivivg of the ancient culture through out Europe and has spread. Where the original tribes originated from is still a sybject of debate and at this point in time is irelevent. The fact that they are an ancient distinct ethnic culture that still survives today is what really matters.
Pathetic that type of shit would normally come from the U.S. plastic Irishman and plastic Celts. Sad fuckers join the real world you idiotic fucking ridiculous people. Tut tut tut you stupid backward fucking cunts.
what a nice emotions came to me when i see the amazing landscapes of ireland/scotland and listen to the great music,i cant imagine the way the celts lived in this world,but allways i listen to his music i feel the magic around and my dream of know ireland and scotland grows and grows and ........ its magic......fucking awesome....and by the web i can see that the celtic womans are really beautifull!!! congratullations celtic people!!!
@shadisoe I think they lived close to nature. There is some poetry, and it features nature very strongly.I think they made good friends (loyal and hospitable and fun) and bad enemies, (proud and warrior like) were creative artists, good story tellers, musical, and passionate and spiritual, but that's just my best guess from what I've read.
SHUT UP ENJOY THE MUSIC PRICKS
@earth13 , @paddotk ,
lorddwan 1 month ago
HERMOSO....
theraphobos 2 months ago in playlist Ronan Hardiman Cry of the Celts
thank you for helping contribute to ethnic diversity's final performance #ethnicD
PS. justin beiber's a fag
nealroxsox 2 months ago
this song is the reason why sometimes i wish i was a celt.
gamatayt 2 months ago
I've got some scots(McDonalds) in me but love Irish music and dance. Wished the Scots had copied these styles from their Irish brethren ..... it's all CELTIC.
fulconer 2 months ago
Comment removed
Celticninja011 2 months ago
Umm...Who's being trolled? Who's trolling? Why is everyone so hyped up about it? How many people are involved? 1? 5? 10? Seriously. If church bells make you want to troll, then skip to like 1:00 or something! 2:13 is a really good place to start. And I'm saying 2:13 because that's my favorite part. And I'm not even Irish of Celtic or whatever! Does anyone else like that part???
technobubbleJump 2 months ago
i have pretty much nothing to do with Ireland, but I love this music!
alx64uchiha 3 months ago
Celts?....cultural marxism and multi-cult-uralism cuppled with die-versity will soon take care of them.
Enjoy your existance, while it lasts.
CelticAngloPress 3 months ago
what kind of flute is it?
Kamilla240 3 months ago
Gentlemen, I visited this channel to listen to some amazing music. I visited this channel to listen to some of the best violin playing I've ever heard. I came here to relax after a stressful day and, instead, I found a group of people arguing over who's celtic and who's not.
JUST LISTEN TO THE GODDAMN MUSIC, YOU FOOLS!
NPBaudelaire 3 months ago 12
why are people arguing over who's celtic or not??? listen to the music n chill the feck out hahaha :)
treeny88 3 months ago
The oldest ( so far ) found Celtic language is extinct Tartessian and these languages were "possibly" brought up from the Caucasus....
Nemeton212 4 months ago
@Nemeton212 Yes indeed! :)
I remember reading about that in TGE Powell's 'The Celts'. Too bad we know so little of Tartessian.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe I found a few interesting links by searching "Tartassian" in the search engine, but mostly about the linguist side..
Nemeton212 4 months ago
we were all celtic in a way. we came from one race a time ago.
Ricky11435 4 months ago
@bubbles98ireland actually, scottish protestants aren't celts.
lugiametagross162 5 months ago 2
@lugiametagross162 Not necessarily true as protestantism is a religion a belief and it does not wholly run along ethnic lines.
heliotropezzz333 4 months ago
Comment removed
MICKYMAVYT 3 months ago
@MICKYMAVYT Celts don't exist anymore. The Scottish are Scottish. How Celts, however, can, and do make up much of the Scottish ancestry. The Celts as an actual people haven't existed for quite some time. This is not the iron age. This is not the age of the Roman Empire.
earth13 3 months ago
Comment removed
MICKYMAVYT 3 months ago
@MICKYMAVYT It's good to know you're ignorant about history, and the history of the Celts. Calling the Scottish a Celt now would be like referring to the French, or the Belgium in modern day society as Gauls. Do you understand how retarded that is? The Gauls, and more encompassing, the Celtic society, and languages haven't been practices for centuries. The Celts are a group of tribes that existed in the Iron Age, and during the Roman Empire. Are you going to call Italians Romans? LOL. Retard.
earth13 3 months ago
Comment removed
MICKYMAVYT 3 months ago
@earth13 "the Celtic languages haven't been practices for centuries" ...Go and teach yourself, about 3 million people speak a celtic language nowadays.
E breizh emaon o chom ha komz a ran un tammig brezhoneg. Kompren a rez ?
XanonymousFY 3 months ago
@earth13 LONG LIVE THE CELTS!!!
SCOTLAND, IRELAND, WALES, ISLE OF MAN, CORNWALL AND BRITTANY
MICKYMAVYT 3 months ago 13
GGGAAAAUUUULLLLLSSSS!!!!!!!!!!
VinlandEinherjar 6 months ago
201 COMMENT! XD
Warriorcats24 6 months ago
@GokzTT what do you mean "a few Scottish"?
mastersverk 6 months ago
@bubbles98ireland You bet we are!
celticbattleaxe 6 months ago
@celticbattleaxe More evidence for the link between Welsh and Gaulish language is: The Welsh word for women is "merched" and the celtic French (Breton) word for women is also "merched".
The word "scotus" was originally used in relation to the Irish but there was a great amount of population exchange between Scotland and Ireland and the word eventually applied to Scotland only.
heliotropezzz333 6 months ago
@heliotropezzz333 Cool!! Makes sense, too since both Breton and Gaulish are P Celtic.
celticbattleaxe 6 months ago
@heliotropezzz333 I think you're a little confused. Bretons and Gauls were two different celtic people with different languages, and Bretons and Welsh were originally one single people : the ancient Britons, that's why Welsh language and Breton language are quite similar...
29Loubi 4 months ago 4
@29Loubi Uh, Gaulish and Breton are both P Celtic, as is Basque (which is the closest surviving relative of Gaulish). Yes, Breton and Pretan come from the same people, but their language is similar to Gaulish.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
Comment removed
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY My dear sir, you are mislead here. The Basque people trace their ancestry to Aquitanian Gauls and Celt-iberians, and their language is one of the most uninfluenced by outsiders. Gaulish and Breton are distantly related, not closely. Both are P Celtic, but Breton is most similar to Welsh and Cornish (Pretan languages). Still don't believe me? Well then, look at the works of TGE Powell and Dr.Ian Barnes, both highly respected and knowledgeable people in the Celtic historical field.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@celticbattleaxe Ok,
Firstly : Basque people were in Europe LONG BEFORE the Celts arrived there.
Secondly : "their language is one of the most uninfluenced by outsiders"...75 % of Basque vocabulary is of foreign origin ( Celt, Latin, Spanish, French, etc...)
Thirdly : "Gaulish and Breton are distantly related", of course that's true but Breton is however probably nowadays the closest language to Gaulish, concerning synthax, vocabulary, etc...
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Finally, if Basque is a celtic language, explain me why all linguist experts all over the world consider it as the unique isolate language of Europe ? Basque has been influenced by Celtic languages, but it is NOT a Celtic language, and surely not the closest language to Gaulish. I know what I'm talking about since I'm Breton with Basque origins.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Really? Of whom are you referring?
Do you even know the history of the Basque people? I've given you my evidence, you've given me none except your own thoughts and a deleted comment. If you can't even defend your point, then why are you still arguing?
So then, what is 'closest' to Gaulish in your opinion? You do realize that there was no national language among the Gauls, and that they spoke in many different dialects? Basque is a descendant of Aquitanian Gaulish.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe I'm referring to what all good linguists and ethnologists know, except for your swindlers writers, TGE Powell and Dr.Ian Barnes, "both highly respected and knowledgeable people in the Celtic historical field."
Open any books about Basque language or history and you'll see you're totally wrong. Of course there were different gaulish dialects, but they all obeyed to common rules, the same as in insular celtic languages, for example, consonantic mutations.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@XanonymousFY I will admit, there is much controversy in Celtic history, and we do not know nearly as much as we'd like. Oh, and Mr high-and-mighty-bruce-almighty, you spelled "consonant" wrong.
I do my reading, and I thoroughly enjoy it.
Still, Breton is not as related to Gaulish as it is to Cornish and Welsh. After all, the Bretons originally came from the Cornwall area and other parts of southern Albion, crossing the English Channel to settle in what the Romans called Armorica.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY I kindly suggest you quit the ego-trip and research before you contact me again.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY And I think you mean the similarities in certain words - for example, Gaelige and Scottish are both Q Celtic because their word for 'son of' is "mac" - Manannan mac Lir, for instance.
Cornish, Welsh, and Breton word for 'son of' is "ap" or "map". Gaulish and Basque have similar words to these, and they count as P Celtic
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY And one more thing - where did you supposedly learn Basque and Breton? You clearly don't live in either place, and I know that very few people speak either language.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe There are NONE of these rules in modern Basque language, and that's why it isn't recognised as a celtic language by linguists, sorry about that. I studied celtic languages, I speak Breton currently and I know Basque language, even a fool would see there is nothing in common between these two languages family. And please don't tell me about Brittany history or language, I know them better than you thought. ;-)
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Well duh - there's no noticeable similarity between Gaelige and Breton, now then, is there? Still, you have no given me the names of your sources. I have given you mine, and yes, they are highly respected individuals in the Celtic historical field. I don't make up crap from wiki.
...Or you thought. Basque is related to Aquitanian - Aquitanian is Gaulish, and Gaulish is P Celtic.
Until you give me evidence of your research, I cannot trust your word as valid.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Do you even READ what I write? I just read your first sentence : "there's no noticeable similarity between Gaelige and Breton". These two languages are part of INSULAR CELTIC LANGUAGES, even if Gaelige and Brythhonic languages are two subfamilies of this group. As a result, they share SEVERALS similarities : consonantic mutations, syntaxic order verb-subject-object, and many others I can't traduce cause French is my native language...
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Yes, I read what you write - they are not both P or Q Celtic. THAT is my point.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe So you want sources? My grandmother is Basque and she agrees that Basque are NOT Celts and that Basque language is NOT a Celtic language. Where did I learn Breton? I was born and raise in Brittany and I'm still living there. Where did YOU learn to say "I live in Brittany" in Breton? Probably you found it on the Internet. You don't live in a celtic place, I bet you can't even speak a celtic language, and you want to teach others about the Celts? You can't be serious !
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Oh, I'd doubt that. You are probably lying through your teeth, because your channel says that you live in 'St.Helena'. You are not still living there. I rest my case.
You don't live in a "Celtic place" either. St.Helena was settled by the English, idiot. Stop lying.
Yes, I can speak a little Cymraeg and Gaelige. As I've said before, I am Scottish (clan Gordon), Irish (clan Dempsey and McClain) and Welsh (far back in history).
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Sorry, but I cannot trust your word, and STILL you have not brought me sources. You said that you get your sources from 'linguists besides Dr.Ian Barnes and TGE Powell (who are legit people, btw)". Well then, who are they, may I ask? If you cannot answer this, your argument is futile and has no place here. Seriously, "Celtic" does not just mean that you have to be of Celtic blood or live in the UK or Brittany. To be a Celt means to be a Celt at heart, soul, spirit and mind.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY You lied - enough said. For all I know you could be a troll - maybe, maybe not. You don't live in Brittany, you live in St.Helena, or so says your channel.
I hope I'm wrong. Seriously, I do. I have had more $hit from people who BS me about the Celts than anyone else I know. I've had English 'loyalists' troll me (FatallInstinct1), and too many people who lie.
Still, Celtic history is very controversial.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Loooooool my channel says I live in St Helena as it said I was living in Antarctica two weeks ago !!! I don't care about my channel, ok? If you don't trust me I can speak a perfect French, cause French is nowadays (unfortunately) the only official language of Brittany, and I LIVE in Brittany. I'm not a troll and I fuck English loyalists, right?
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY From what I know, your channel indicator for 'location' bases it off of your email.
Still, I hope I am wrong. You must forgive me seeming hostility - too many times have I been the target of moronic fools - people who claim to know Celtic history and really don't, the English loyalist idiots who target ALL people of Scottish/Irish ancestry, and other trolls.
Oh, and when you referred to the 'Celtic Island', I think you left-out Eirinn and Man! :)
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY My 'location' on my channel has always said 'United States'. Still, I know very little of computers and all the software/hardware crap. But who are the linguists you were referring to? I should love to know, and research more about them. Like I said, I don't claim to be expert, and it is always good to hear more than 1 side of the story.
Let us set aside our differences and part without grudges -
Merry Part! :)
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Si tu ne me crois toujours pas, je ne vais pas perdre davantage de temps avec toi. De toute évidence tu ne lis pas ce que j'écris et tu restes bêtement campé sur tes positions. Je n'ai jamais dit que les langues gaéliques et brittoniques étaient identiques, j'ai dit qu'elles appartenaient au même groupe : les langues celtiques insulaires. Elles sont de ce fait très proches, du point de vue du vocabulaire, de la syntaxe, de la grammaire, etc...
Bref, j'habite bien en Bretagne.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Et je ne suis pas stupide comme vous semblez le penser. Sans sources de recherche, je n'ai pas confiance en ce que les gens disent. Donnez-moi les noms de ces linguistes, et je peux encore la recherche.
Mais je dois demander, pourquoi n'avez-vous pas me donner leurs noms, quand j'ai demandé pour eux à plusieurs reprises? J'ai confiance en mes sources en raison de leur légitimité, et parce qu'ils ont étudié les celtes domaine historique pour un certain temps.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe I put back "France" as my country on my channel, are you satisfied now ? :-)
So you speak French? Great ! My sources are principally collective thoughts : in France, everybody knows (or maybe thinks you would say) that Basque aren't Celts. I never met any Basque, but I saw some of their comments on the internet, and they generally don't consider themselves as Celts.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe . Moreover, I don't speak Basque but I saw many sentences in this language and I never noticed any similarity with the other celtic languages. My other source is Wikipedia, which can be a good source of information in my opinion. I read french articles concerning Basque country, they probably have been written or at least revised by a Basque (for you surely know that a part of Basque country is located in France) : they all say that Basques were in Europe long before the Celts.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe They also say that Basque is the unique "isolat" of Europe; it means that it's the only european language which constitutes a family by itself. And according to them, 75 % of basque vocabulary is of foreign origin ! (celts, latin, spanish, french,...). That's why I was astonished when I saw your comments like " Basque is a celtic language and the closest to Gaulish". Finally, I read articles concerning celtic languages, and to be considered as celtic, a language must respect
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe ... several rules, the most important of them is called " consonant mutations" and can be found in every insular celtic languages (Irish, Welsh, Breton, Scottish, Cornish and Manx) and probably in Gaulish, but you can't find this characteristic in the Basque language. That's why it's strange to me to admit that Basque is a celtic language...
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe If you absolutely wish books' sources, I can give you the Wikipedia articles' bibliography concerning Basque language, but all books are in French or Spanish, except for this one : "The History of Basque", Oxford, 1997, by R. L. Trask.
Hope it'll help.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Well, I don't exactly trust wiki, but it would be appreciated.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY No, they don't. Celtic as a set of languages hasn't been spoken for a long, long time. I hate to break this to you, but the linguistic nature of proper Celtic languages has not been used for centuries. That would be like me saying that I can speak Latin with others. It's partially true, but at the same time it is not. The language it's self is still used today, but as a language it's self, it is dead. There is a difference between "Dead" languages, and "Extinct" languages.
earth13 3 months ago
@earth13 You mean a proto-celtic language? That diverged thousands of years ago into the various branches of Celtic languages including the ones that survive today, and it itself came from an earlier indo-european language. I don't really get your point? You can hardly argue that today's Celtic languages are not a separate language group. What are they then?
Glywysing942 3 months ago
@Glywysing942 You mean how Proto-Celtic is a reconstructed language based loosely on a dead language, and you don't know what you're talking about? It was reconstructed, and even PhD linguist professors don't call it Celtic. Honestly. People commenting on something they have next to no understanding about boggles my mind. Maybe you should also go take Linguistics when you eventually reach a post-secondary level of intellect.
earth13 3 months ago
@earth13 Wow. You're a nice person. No I don't mean that, there obviously existed a proto-celtic language at some point as an ancestor to today's languages. I suggested that that was what you were talking about when you mentioned that "Celtic as a set of languages has not been used for centuries". Mr. Professor, you seem to have avoided actually explaining this and resorted instead to insulting people. There exists a group of languages called Celtic, correct? So what do you mean?
Glywysing942 3 months ago
@Glywysing942 No, there doesn't exist a set of languages called Celtic in current use. In fact, the modern languages are precisely called "Proto-Celtic", while the ancient version is referred to as Celtic. Proto-Celtic was reconstructed from what little they could gleam about the structure of Celtic languages. It's a misnomer, as well as slang when one refers to their language as "Celtic". It's retardation, and ignorance on behalf of those people that do speak the language to call it Celtic.
earth13 3 months ago
@earth13 What? It's a well accepted fact that there is a living indo-european language group called "Celtic". I have never heard these being called "proto-celtic" (and don't accuse me of ignorance - I have a great interest in celtic culture and language being from Wales myself, I have read extensively around the subject). Proto means an early or original form of something.
Glywysing942 3 months ago
@Glywysing942 Don't speak to this troll. He actually knows nothing about celtic languages but he strongly believes he knows everything about them. What a clown !
XanonymousFY 3 months ago
@Glywysing942 You are ignorant as fuck. This is not a debate. You like to think you understand it, because you're mistaking the 1800's enlightenment movement, where people of Celtic decent called them selves Celtic, with the actual languages. They are properly called 'Proto-celtic", and while that may be hard for you to comprehend, like I said in the past, take Linguistics at your local college, and you'll hopefully get enlightened. People like you annoy me so much.
earth13 2 months ago
@earth13 There are TV programmes in celtic languages, radio transmissions, singers who sing in celtic language,theater actors, signposts in the street, etc... Celtic languages are spoken everyday in many schools and in some families. So they 're not dead yet thought. Latin is never spoken anywhere, except for some faculties.
XanonymousFY 3 months ago
@XanonymousFY This comment was so unbelievably stupid, I'm not even going to give you a response past: Go take Linguistics in University. Maybe you'll be less ignorant.
earth13 3 months ago
@earth13 lol ok arrogant prick. However, I speak French, English, Spanish, Latin and Breton. What do YOU speak except for English, before teaching me lessons about linguistics ?
XanonymousFY 3 months ago
@XanonymousFY First off, you do not "Speak" Latin, as Latin is also a dead language. You "Know" Latin. Which you don't. To humor a lair such as your self; I know French, English, German, Russian. By the by, just because you "Speak", or "Know" a language doesn't mean you fully grasp the linguistic nature of those languages, because learning a language is not even the greater part of study in linguistics. The language is the platform you use as a base to study in linguistics.
earth13 3 months ago
@earth13 First off, 'speak' is a verb and hence, not written with a capital S. Secondly, latin is not a dead language as it is worldwide used as the one and only science language. People may not have whole conversations in latin too often, but they do actually know how to.
Bottomline: don't act such a smartass when youn't know shit. Maybe you should get from behind your pc once in a while.
paddotk 2 months ago
@paddotk Apparently it is you whom doesn't know shit. Latin is classified as a dead language. This isn't even up for debate. In fact, you can use credited sources like JSTOR, or EBSCO to show you that, or even uncredited sources like Wikipedia.
You're so fucking retarded, it's not even funny.
earth13 2 months ago
@earth13 'who', not 'whom'. And a language is dead when no person in the world ever speaks it other than for research of the language. Scientists do however. I really don't know what you're trying to pull here but it's stupid. One piece of advice: Don't say stuff like this in the real world or everyone will laugh in your face.
paddotk 1 month ago
@paddotk I gave you the method, and the places to look it up for your self. I'm not sure what you're trying to pull, but ignorance of volition is incredibly idiotic of you. Good luck with your retardation.
earth13 1 month ago
@earth13 Thank you. And please, ask a Latin speaker if you ever meet one. See what he/she says.
paddotk 1 month ago
@celticbattleaxe Komz a rit ur keltiek yezh? Nann, evel-just ! Komz a ran Brezhoneg, e Breizh emaon o chom ha ma mamm-kozh Bask eo.
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Well, I think we should just put an end to this discussion, cause you have your opinion, I have mine, and we probably can't find a consensus. At least we share a common point : we love celtic culture. Kenavo !
XanonymousFY 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY I don't claim to be an "expert" on this, but I study more about the Celts than most people - I am a mix of Welsh (far back in history), Scottish (clan Gordon), and Irish (clan Dempsey and McClain).
Still, Breton is not as related to Gaulish as it is to Cornish and Welsh. After all, the Bretons originally came from the Cornwall area and other parts of southern Albion, crossing the English Channel to settle in what the Romans called Armorica.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@XanonymousFY Sorry, but you can't truthfully say 'E Breizh emaon o chom'.
Give me one good reason why I should trust your word, when you have still given me no sources for your argument.
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
@GokzTT You forgot Cornwall!
celticbattleaxe 6 months ago
@bubbles98ireland
Culturally but not genetically, there are Picts too.
GokzTT 6 months ago
@GokzTT People often confuse "Pict" and "Scot" too often. The Picts were P Celtic, same as the Welsh, Corns, and Gauls. The Scots, deriving from the Latin word 'Scotti' meaning "to plunder", are Q Celtic, which links them to the Irish. P and Q Celtic are language separations, since the Pretannic/ Welsh (may have been similar to the Gauls) word for "son of" is "ap" or "map", and the Irish/Scottish word for "son of" is "mac".
celticbattleaxe 6 months ago
@celticbattleaxe
Oh, thanks for the information.
GokzTT 6 months ago
@GokzTT Anytime :)
celticbattleaxe 6 months ago
@celticbattleaxe Right on the money :)
padzter 4 months ago
@padzter Yep - it is a little annoying when people confuse the two, or claim to be "famous historians" and cannot even describe the language similarities. It helps to have a background in linguistics :).
celticbattleaxe 4 months ago
Celtic music is so awesome
WargoDsssss 6 months ago
che meraviglia!
nehotroppi 6 months ago
oh my gosh this is so awesome!
kellyojedamillaan 6 months ago
@GokzTT and a few scottish...more like thousands...ach co dhiu, le gach deagh dhurachd ...:):)
Angus01ful 6 months ago
@Angus01ful
You're right.
GokzTT 6 months ago
Greetings from the Wallace clan.
Ethaninja 6 months ago
You don't need to watch the photos ! Just listen the music, and u will feel that this music takes you to Scotland, Wales and ireland ;)
crazyanimefear 6 months ago
The photos are amazingly beautiful! I WILL go to Scotland, Wales and Ireland....someday. I will!
Jenovaful 6 months ago
so amazing!!!!!!!!!
nvh137 7 months ago
Comment removed
Claudio36596 7 months ago
Beautiful song !
Claudio36596 7 months ago
Comment removed
Rannek1 7 months ago
ah the auld sheep
SauceBau5 7 months ago
i like the sound!!!!very beautiful!!!!!
melly003 7 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG.
themagieli 8 months ago
the biggest celtic port is in Hampshier. i'm celt,we're the ones who did not run away!!
zeus21ish 8 months ago
i love this music!!! i could listen and dance to it forever!!!
1996nancydrew 8 months ago 2
@1996nancydrew I could toooo!
boomasawrus 7 months ago
@Taranis223
Yup!
GokzTT 8 months ago
@Taranis223
It's due to weather, not that my eyes change colour, I mean nature right? It's the reason why Arabians are dark, Europeans are fair, and Africans are really dark!
GokzTT 8 months ago
@Taranis223
I've got pure green eyes, and I have Celtic heritage, however I must say green eyes are odd, they tend to look blue or grey sometimes.
GokzTT 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is espectacular, it remembers me a lot of my antecesors! irland is the perfect place to race and grow in, it has an enormous cultural feeling!
pauser93 8 months ago
MOTHER OF CHRIST!!!! WHO ATE ALLA ME PASTAAA???
randmnumber 9 months ago
@randmnumber Wrong numba mate.
bjcsupertortoise 8 months ago
I LOVE Ireland and its culture :))
nickasmrdi 9 months ago
@GokzTT Also Cornish and Bretons, and there are Celts in Spain too.
heliotropezzz333 9 months ago
@heliotropezzz333
There are Celts all over Europe, some very less, some much. Italy, France, Turkey, Spain, Greece, and others.
GokzTT 9 months ago
Hey he forgot the swiss flag =(
But the rest is great ^^
TH3P41NT3DC0W 9 months ago
You have a beautiful country over there. And the music. I'm a bit jealous.
Huzi5 9 months ago
Thanks for uploading this beautiful piece :-)
sford605 10 months ago
Was the first picture from Inis Mór/Inish More?
demonicblessings 10 months ago
im from scotland but i realy like irish dancing and music ! (: xx
VictoriaFraserxxx 10 months ago
What are these Kimmeri? I can't find anything about them on google -.-
monkey0in0a0cage 10 months ago
i like the music for Ronan Hardiman
laci480 10 months ago
no wonder the celts stopped travling if sights like these were what they saw ;-)
sorenmarkable 10 months ago
Lovely music great slides, thanks for a great upload
wafrom 10 months ago
Gorgeous pictures, Sarris! Love how you put them to this brilliant piece. Well done, indeed!
clubnqueendiva 10 months ago
Umm why is there a french flag in this video? shouldn't it be a breton flag? and where's the rest of the celtic flags? Cornwall? Isle of Mann?...
branz93 11 months ago
Proud to be a Celt :) diolch am y fideo!/ thanks for the video!
branz93 11 months ago
hermosas tierras
Taiko1982 11 months ago
love this track.... brilliant!!!
hcsurman 11 months ago
Thanks for more detail I did not have, Taranis223. Of course, we may never know for sure, in this life. My speculation, by the way, was offered to the public in the fiction, The Pleistocene Redemption, and you are welcome to enjoy a free PDF copy of it. I'd bet putting the URL in this post, even though there's nothing for sale, would get the post deleted by self-righteous geeks. So, try putting this back together: dan gallagher (.) webs (.) com . Have a nice day.
1dgalla 11 months ago
Say what you will Ireland is where the culture of the ancient Celts has survived in its purest form and that has led to the revivivg of the ancient culture through out Europe and has spread. Where the original tribes originated from is still a sybject of debate and at this point in time is irelevent. The fact that they are an ancient distinct ethnic culture that still survives today is what really matters.
MrDec202 11 months ago
Pathetic that type of shit would normally come from the U.S. plastic Irishman and plastic Celts. Sad fuckers join the real world you idiotic fucking ridiculous people. Tut tut tut you stupid backward fucking cunts.
Crime1234management 11 months ago
so glad to be part slavic, irish and english! :)
16Muslimah 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I bang my head to this shit and hope not to break anything around the house!!!!!
LordHannigan 11 months ago
I bang my head to this shit and home not to break anything around the house!!!!!
LordHannigan 11 months ago
Don't pay attention what this homo gayreek says my Celt friends. French is helenic Celt is helenic ha? Hahaha get a life dumbass!
SimplyTurk 11 months ago
Anything with bells, flutes, and/or a celtic tune has me hooked!
sparrowgirl25 11 months ago
I'm not Celtic by parents, since I'm Australian, but I have Celtic heritage and have their genes both by blood and features.
GokzTT 1 year ago
oh my god i love this music! i also love Ireland. i don't have a whole lot of Irish blood, but i take pride in my first name, Erin :)
crimsonclover87 1 year ago
The first photo is Moher!!!!
The clifts of Moher!!!!
I've benn there is WONDERFUL!!!
Ephira19 1 year ago
I love you Ireland!!
hi from Hungary!:))
dnorbert16 1 year ago 2
BOSTIN!!!!!111
Buddy375 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OOPS i fell asleep xD
dkdanny30 1 year ago
2:10 starts epic part
0:00 - 4:26 starts epic music
UnBreadCZ 1 year ago
born in dublin =)
jririshbmxr97 1 year ago
greeks and celts have the same rush in their blood.
anoustouras 1 year ago
Oh, beautiful song !
misseli123 1 year ago
we live in a beautiful world.
SVV1985 1 year ago
This makes me want to go back in time and tavel all over in scotland and ireland. I LOVE HIS SONGS! I just want to listen these and start to dance
joku02 1 year ago 2
what a nice emotions came to me when i see the amazing landscapes of ireland/scotland and listen to the great music,i cant imagine the way the celts lived in this world,but allways i listen to his music i feel the magic around and my dream of know ireland and scotland grows and grows and ........ its magic......fucking awesome....and by the web i can see that the celtic womans are really beautifull!!! congratullations celtic people!!!
shadisoe 1 year ago
@shadisoe I think they lived close to nature. There is some poetry, and it features nature very strongly.I think they made good friends (loyal and hospitable and fun) and bad enemies, (proud and warrior like) were creative artists, good story tellers, musical, and passionate and spiritual, but that's just my best guess from what I've read.
heliotropezzz333 1 year ago
what does one do when one likes Ronan Hardiman, but doesnt like Micheal Flatley? =/
VoughtF4U1A 1 year ago
makes me think of Michael Flatley and the rest dancing ... :)
uuaaaXD 1 year ago
oane of the best celtic songs i ever heard
diedrachan 1 year ago
Aaaahhh.... this song... so beautiful...
Napolismark 1 year ago
me: I gona kill 5 people
mom:why? your sick littel man!!
me:becouse 5 people dislike this song
mom oke that its okey
MrAZ09AZ 1 year ago
Sorry guys, but I think I just broke the replay button.. :$
MartijnGlas 1 year ago
Fajna muzyczka :)
Byku1Kcz 1 year ago
Even though I look nothing like a celt because i'm eurasian, when I listen to this it's clear that the celtic blood outshines the rest. :P
Thanks stacks for uploading this Sarris12
:D
omgsomanynamestaken 1 year ago
I wanna bone Robin Tunney on a bed of white doves with this music on as loud as possible. oh, merciful Goddess of Wind, don't fail me now
Alphabex8 1 year ago
Awesomeeee
sabigabbi 1 year ago
no one master the Celtic music like ronan hardiman
im not Irish but i love Irish music and Celtic music
Xiluin 1 year ago
would you say the beginning was done by a irish tin whistle or an irish flute?
MetalShewolf93 1 year ago
@MetalShewolf93 Tin Whistle i think
bobfari 1 year ago
@MetalShewolf93 It sounds to me like tin whistle first, followed by flute
heliotropezzz333 1 year ago
It just doesn't sound right without the taps. D:
Still a wondefully song. <3
batmanplusjoker 1 year ago