"New age clap trap." So what Science shouldn't progress then? The thing is even if the tests were favourable to Sheldrake and this doc was done unbiasedly, it wouldn't even air. That simple.
Wouldn't the dog's extraordinaire sense of smell explain the phenomena? I think all that happened was the dog smelling his owners coming home. Nevertheless, I do believe that animals do have a different perspective and "see" the world very differently.
Do you want to learn what enlightenment really is?Not satisfied with what you have found?psychic powers, telepathy, precognition, it is all real.Visit THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM where the change will begin.
What is enlightenment?Tired of all the energy and chakra talk with no real results?Unleash your true psychic powers.Search no more, THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM is the end of the road.
I SPECULATE- the problem with trying to observe people having these experiences is that the observation & the consciousness of the observation somehow effects & interferes & blocks the spontaneous occurrence that happens to us when we are in a natural, unexpected state.So when we become self conscious & aware of being tested-our awareness shrinks because our attention is distracted into us & diminishes our openness & receptivity that occurs when we're in an organic, unselfconscious state
@catgumart much like the double split experiment when observation comes into play everthing changes like in tortion physics once everything gets spune up to speed it all changes
Well, the dog experiment should be done differently: In a controlled environment (i.e. lab) to dismiss other variables (e.g. the partner knows that the other person is coming home, and e.g. his/her heart rate changes, what is something that can be sensed by the dog).
Sheldrake came out with that morphic theory, where a morphic field/energy cannot be measured or proven to exist, thus it enters the metaphysics/paranormal/pseudoscience domain.
they should do a multi-part experiment where in one part there are 20/20 instances of not being stared at and the next part 20/20 instances of being stared at. then mix them up for some parts, but only a small percentage of one (2/20 ie.). In closed conditions like these it is way to easy to just guess that you're being stared at....
well a dog relies on a biological clock like humans. if you keep getting up at 7 in the morn for even like a couple weeks you tend to wake up before alarms or right on 7 cuz your body is used to getting up at that time. and if you come home at 5 ish every day or w.e your dog would work the sae way. and be used to u getting home. or the daily walk. or you for a daily , weekly of even monthly phone call or probable event. your minds unconsious thought has a graspe of time. not super powers.
Interesting point, But I guess it would be like when you are at noisy party and yet you are able to note what occrus next to you by excluding most of the background noise. I think telepaty and other mind abilities are exclusive to the human's more developed brain.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
"You were definitely warming up"!
Hopy crap, these people have no idea about statistics. They do the test, it is completely in line with the expectancy that it's all just bullshit and then they OPENLY mine the results.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Complete BS, animals have smaller brains then humans, if humans can't use "tele[ty" then how the hell can a dog? our brain generates about about 14 vot of electricity, and most of that is need to keep you concious how much of that can be channeled into having influence on the real world. Try moving yourself out of the estate with your intellect then talking about moving shit with your mind.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I agree, its sad that some people will buy into anything. By the way its probably smell. Dogs have way better smell than humans, and dogs identify people by smell. So why can't it be that the dog gets excited when the smell of their owner gets stronger. This is a way better explanation than some psuedoscientific morphic fields.
Actually, I heard from my vet that it is a well-known phenomenon that cats seem to disappear just when it is time to take them to the vet for an appointment. I've had my own cat do that on at least four occasions, and I didn't even have the cat basket out.
These experiments are popularized. Come to think of it, these are about the same level as mythbusters or some other TV type experiments are done. Not fully scientific or peer reviewed.
see Journal of Consciousness Studies, volume 12, number 6, 2005. I have the entire issue (comprised of Sheldrake's opening case, following by 14 scientific commentaries, and then Sheldrake's reply). It's fascinating.
I think a few of the experiments were poorly conducted, but I'm not expert in this field. I was actually in one of them. Having said that, I found it genuinely interesting and must remember that the experiments conducted in this film were just an initial starting point.
@nonlocalkaviraj it should be done by a person walking through a park or mall and people set up all around that they dont no stare at them or the person can not even no there in an experiment and ask them what they thought felt while on a night/day out with a friend and the friend there out with can document it because you know a person will tell there friend if they think someone is starring at them
"New age clap trap." So what Science shouldn't progress then? The thing is even if the tests were favourable to Sheldrake and this doc was done unbiasedly, it wouldn't even air. That simple.
LucifersArgument 4 months ago
Wouldn't the dog's extraordinaire sense of smell explain the phenomena? I think all that happened was the dog smelling his owners coming home. Nevertheless, I do believe that animals do have a different perspective and "see" the world very differently.
javierk21 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Do you want to learn what enlightenment really is?Not satisfied with what you have found?psychic powers, telepathy, precognition, it is all real.Visit THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM where the change will begin.
MrJenniferWaggoner 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What is enlightenment?Tired of all the energy and chakra talk with no real results?Unleash your true psychic powers.Search no more, THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM is the end of the road.
MichelleRundell 1 year ago
I SPECULATE- the problem with trying to observe people having these experiences is that the observation & the consciousness of the observation somehow effects & interferes & blocks the spontaneous occurrence that happens to us when we are in a natural, unexpected state.So when we become self conscious & aware of being tested-our awareness shrinks because our attention is distracted into us & diminishes our openness & receptivity that occurs when we're in an organic, unselfconscious state
catgumart 1 year ago
@catgumart much like the double split experiment when observation comes into play everthing changes like in tortion physics once everything gets spune up to speed it all changes
jemann35645 10 months ago
Well, the dog experiment should be done differently: In a controlled environment (i.e. lab) to dismiss other variables (e.g. the partner knows that the other person is coming home, and e.g. his/her heart rate changes, what is something that can be sensed by the dog).
Sheldrake came out with that morphic theory, where a morphic field/energy cannot be measured or proven to exist, thus it enters the metaphysics/paranormal/pseudoscience domain.
phrack1976 1 year ago
they should do a multi-part experiment where in one part there are 20/20 instances of not being stared at and the next part 20/20 instances of being stared at. then mix them up for some parts, but only a small percentage of one (2/20 ie.). In closed conditions like these it is way to easy to just guess that you're being stared at....
007frogprincess 1 year ago
D to the M to the X
MrJaymacdonald 1 year ago
I love fanny
subbtopp 1 year ago
well a dog relies on a biological clock like humans. if you keep getting up at 7 in the morn for even like a couple weeks you tend to wake up before alarms or right on 7 cuz your body is used to getting up at that time. and if you come home at 5 ish every day or w.e your dog would work the sae way. and be used to u getting home. or the daily walk. or you for a daily , weekly of even monthly phone call or probable event. your minds unconsious thought has a graspe of time. not super powers.
reid300 1 year ago
The Vet is very smart!
amaxamon 2 years ago 3
Telepaty is real, but the dog's test seems dumb. Dogs can hear many things we can't, and smell many things we can't.
14Gott 2 years ago
but smelling from when you get in a taxi cab? That's like they can single out your sounds out of the millions and billions of sounds between them.
Trippy420Hippy 2 years ago 2
Interesting point, But I guess it would be like when you are at noisy party and yet you are able to note what occrus next to you by excluding most of the background noise. I think telepaty and other mind abilities are exclusive to the human's more developed brain.
14Gott 2 years ago
Once you accept that all creatures have energy bodies that are not bound by time or space then all these mysteries go away.
We have just stopped using the ability to function this way. Its there for those who can reopen the channels.
burmanhands 2 years ago 6
@burmanhands Once you accept that all creatures have invisible elves that are not bound by time or space then all these mysteries go away.
alexkidd3d 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"You were definitely warming up"!
Hopy crap, these people have no idea about statistics. They do the test, it is completely in line with the expectancy that it's all just bullshit and then they OPENLY mine the results.
Unbelievable.
DavidMTRutten 2 years ago
I'm not sure he datamined that, he might've just said that as a buddy-buddy thing?
he didn't actually say it showed a convincing result?
Sutskoen 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Complete BS, animals have smaller brains then humans, if humans can't use "tele[ty" then how the hell can a dog? our brain generates about about 14 vot of electricity, and most of that is need to keep you concious how much of that can be channeled into having influence on the real world. Try moving yourself out of the estate with your intellect then talking about moving shit with your mind.
Mind0verM4tter 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree, its sad that some people will buy into anything. By the way its probably smell. Dogs have way better smell than humans, and dogs identify people by smell. So why can't it be that the dog gets excited when the smell of their owner gets stronger. This is a way better explanation than some psuedoscientific morphic fields.
sjb167 2 years ago
just because we're smarter than animals does not mean they are inferior to us
tomsawyersucks 2 years ago
lol @ the n00b at 2:12
supadox 3 years ago
yupp ROFL
sjb167 2 years ago
i believe that if you are expecting to be stared at, you wont get the same results as staring at someone who is not expecting to be stared at.
Drewdoggg1 3 years ago 10
yes
itsAndrogyn 3 years ago
Actually, I heard from my vet that it is a well-known phenomenon that cats seem to disappear just when it is time to take them to the vet for an appointment. I've had my own cat do that on at least four occasions, and I didn't even have the cat basket out.
dreyfalex 3 years ago 4
Thank god for science!
thruthem 3 years ago
LOL
thruthem 3 years ago
These experiments are popularized. Come to think of it, these are about the same level as mythbusters or some other TV type experiments are done. Not fully scientific or peer reviewed.
aikiboy1111111 4 years ago
see Journal of Consciousness Studies, volume 12, number 6, 2005. I have the entire issue (comprised of Sheldrake's opening case, following by 14 scientific commentaries, and then Sheldrake's reply). It's fascinating.
also, the dog experiment was rather poorly done.
nonlocalkaviraj 4 years ago
I think a few of the experiments were poorly conducted, but I'm not expert in this field. I was actually in one of them. Having said that, I found it genuinely interesting and must remember that the experiments conducted in this film were just an initial starting point.
Good stuff.
olioh 4 years ago
@nonlocalkaviraj it should be done by a person walking through a park or mall and people set up all around that they dont no stare at them or the person can not even no there in an experiment and ask them what they thought felt while on a night/day out with a friend and the friend there out with can document it because you know a person will tell there friend if they think someone is starring at them
isisshine 1 year ago