Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (41)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The newer ones way better! Well, I don't like either of them, but the woman thing singing in this looks so fake, but the newer CGI one looks great./ But in all fareness I've growen up watching the Speciel Edition.

  • I can't believe I forgot how much more fitting this version of the scene was compared to the 1997 version. Thanks for uploading this.

  • Lucas gets butt hurt because he cant take criticism. We made him rich and now he doesnt even respect the fans.

  • I just watched a white power skinhead band on you tube before coming here, and I have to say that Max Rebo blows them out of the water, everyone start to leave video responses on racial videos on you tube with star wars music clips. That's what I plan on doing.

  • Wait a second. The door opening with the Rancor in it. That scene could have worked if Oola hadn't already been screaming in a way that she was frantically trying to escape from something. Also the Rancor has already seen her by the roar yet the gate isn't open enough for him to actually see her. Inconsistances I tell you!

  • Every time I watch the film I have to go find this portion of the scene and mute the DVD version of the scene...can't stand that new crap!!

    

  • I agree, a large portion of the CGI additions to the Trilogy are epic FAILS. The removal of the original song from this scene and the addition of the other creatures is utterly LAME. This song is way more catchy and a huge part of my memories from films is tied into the soundtrack. Even in the 2001 DVD release (where Lucas did the meddling with CGI) you can see Max Rebo is still jamming to THE ORIGINAL BEAT! How retarded is that? Just leave the music alone

  • Greedo never got off a shot, Han didn't telekinetically hover superfast out the way of a blast from his gun. Blue lightsabers don't turn green on the Millenium Falcon (that 1, like Greedo, was totally unforgivable, much as I love George). This musical number is better. Much CGI of the S.E.'s LOOKS like CGI which RUINS them. We don't & never did want additions George, IMPROVEMENTS yes. Additions NO. The transition of the Jedi Choral piece into TROTJ credits music WORKS BETTER. Give us the O.E.'s!

  • this version is the original and alot better than the version you get on cd or record ! can´t find this version on cd :( it is only for the movie !

  • Lyrics at 0:44..."That's a big one." And hey, she is.

  • I like the full song and not the movie version better.

  • Does anyone prefer this to the "Jedi Rocks" song? I like both of them actually.

  • @sgauden02 I hope you're just joking.

  • @xXSparky117Xx Look I know many people hate "Jedi Rocks", but the song itself wasn't bad, it was just out of place.

  • Since you've worked this much and came this far already, you should buy the full frame laserdisc and then rotoscope the main subjects of interest like Sny Snoodles into the widescreen picture. The reason being because the GOUT only uses half of the vertical resolution, contributing to such a soft picture maybe? But the full frame uses all of the resolution. Perhaps a combination of the two would result in the best image? Not too different from what you have already been doing. Thoughts?

  • fuck off remasterings

  • I like George Lucas

  • The original band review(I saw it first in this video today):I think the original long-mouth singer looked completely unrealistic and cheesy and I am glad Lucas fixed it. Since I grew up with the Special versions, the music feels out of place, but it's understandable and actually great. Now I can see that most of the band was in the Special. The only thing that needs fixing there is the long-mouth at the camera.

  • 1.) This Jabba is INFINITELY more life-like and intimidating than the CGI versions. That's NOT an 'opinion'... it's a plain-as-day FACT.

    2.) This Soundtrack is SO much better than the Special Edition.

    3.) Obviously the last few seconds are from the RESTORED footage.

    Its a reminder of how badly it SUCKS that Lucas refuses to restore the ORIGINALS and only cleans-up the crappy altered version.

    CONCLUSION:

    99% of the changes Lucas has made are FAILS!

  • @PabloJalan Hey asshole: most of us agree with you about some of the changes, but don't get a superiority complex over it. Let's keep things in perspective: It most certainly is an opinion, get over yourself. And let's get something straight: You prefer the original because that's what you grew up with. I agree that a lot of the changes were unnecessary (Han should have shot first) but I personally think the original song sucked hard. I'm not crazy about the new one, but I'd say it's better.

  • @EinsteinEMP826

    Shut your fucking face asshole!

  • @PabloJalan sorry, I realized I've violated the sanctity of the Holy Film Trilogy. I will go cleanse myself of my heinous deed. Much apologies.

  • @PabloJalan I would cut that down to 89 percent. (proof? compare the scene from Empire where Leia is watching Boba Fett take off in the OOT to the same scene in the SE's, the music has been "restored" in the SE.

  • At 0:54, 0:58 did jabber said a Japanese word??

  • This tune is sooooo much more funky AND memorable than the special edition version. Why tamper with perfection?

  • I want her as a sex slave

  • @Destroyer12revenge Which one? 0_0

  • The way it was MEANT to be!

  • this band scene was like a milestone in the movie . they totally fucked it!

  • I'd do Oola. 

  • @TheJd3000 She's nasty....

  • @TheJd3000 I agree but only if she consented. The poor girl went through so much pain and suffering.

  • 0:43 is that a guy?

  • LOL 1:20 to 1:27 oola is screaming because thats when the rancor is about to put her in his mouth to eat. and yet youve shown the gate opening up for when the rancor is about to come out to get her. lol the rancer was already eating her at 1:20 to 1:27. so you made a mistake at the end of the video.

  • This worked much better for the scene, the movie, and the series. It has that ~music from another world~ feel to it. The new song huttesse [I think that's the title?] sounded kinda disney-like or something. Besides, if it works why fix it?

  • WHAT THE FCK I just saw the remake on TV and it looked like a comedy movie for little children! Shame on you, soulless movie companies!

  • Great, it looks darker then the original.

  • Send this to LucasFilm and get it in the blu-ray!

  • @toajaller5544 Since this is the Original Cut on DVD from 06 im sure they have it. they just didnt give us the Original Trilogy in Anamorphic so it was kind of like lucas saying yeah here ya go fanboys now fuck off.

  • wow just wow! very clever editing. Nice!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more