so confused cuz there r so many theories xD i only played 2 kh games i didnt finish bbs but i finished kh 358 2 days so i figured ven and roxas are the same cuz the beginning of kh 3582 the guy asked roxas if he remembers his true name -___________________- but i only played 2 khs so idk but i wish ven/roxas were the same T_T
roxas looks like ventus because ventus loses his heart after his battle with vanitas so sora lets ventus's heart rest in HIS untill it heals and re joins his body and when sora and roxas were separated, ventus might have stayed with roxas, not with sora, that would also explain why roxas has emotions unlike other nobodies
Roxas IS both Sora and Ventus. Roxas's weapons, rebirth and oblivion, are light and dark, combined makes the X (Pronouned keyblade). Mix up Roxas and yoi get Sora and a leftover X. X=Ultimate blade made out of light and dark. Ven's heart combined with Sora's then Ventus was REMADE with his heart (Sora and Himself) created Roxas. Ventus is alive though.
i think ven's heart to over sora's noBODY when sora became a heartless, so that's why his nobody looked like ven/roxas. they are the same people just roxas didn't have his memories.
when roxas entered the castle oblivion he fell weak because his body(the one locked away) was calling out to his heart
if you watch the spoiler video of kh 3d, you will see at the end of the video, braig is standing in front of xehanort, and says "what is this? HAS YOUR HEART RETURNED?" at the end of the final chapter, (kh bbs) xehanort is sent to radiant garden by aqua. he is then asked what his name is and he says "xehanort." it is actually terra who is making a plan of his own. i know this because when aqua defeats xehanort in the final chapter, the darkness is released from him, creating the first heartless.
Thats when he says, "you make a great other." he was talking to ventus that was inside of sora. at the end of kh2, ventus is shown appearing from sora and talking to namine. But why is he called roxas? In kh2 final mix, you see a video of xemnas finding ventus in the mansion on the forest and telling him that his heart and sora's are connected. thus changing him from ventus to roxas. but xemnas is actually terra, who can now control his heart. he has a plan to reunite all three of them
I love all of your theories, but you all are wrong. The nobody is actually vanitas. At the end of aquas story, you fight vanitas, and he looks like roxas. at the end of ven's story, you fight vanitas and they are both destroyed. but vanitas was already created from the darkness of ven and therefor didnt have a heart to begin with. so he was a nobody already. thats why in a cutscene in kh2 you see sora fighting someone that looks like roxas, which is actually vanitas.
I am sorry about those confused people who think roxas is ven but u are all wrong. I am sure of it. It wouldn't make any sense!!! If it was then roxas' keyblade would be same as vens. Plus ven's body is castle oblivion the whole time so it wouldn't make anysense that roxas is ven!!!!!!
@paint2D noooo that isn't right the truth was just said in this vid. Since vens heart is a part of sora's roxas is basically sora's AND ven's nobody. Not much ven but a little. The only thing that changed was roxas' appearance.everything else about him is entirely wat sora would be like.
when sora sacrificed himself vens heart released and went into to roxas, roxas actually does have a heart but its ven's which explains why he can cry and why he looks like ven
i think roxas, ven, and sora are technically the same. ven like we all know went into soras heart then wen sora became a heartless the nobody created was from ven's heart not sora but no one but sora knew ven was in his heart so everyone assumed roxas was sora's nobody but he is actually ven's nobody! an plus roxas also got part of sora's heart... and that is why he has minor feelings as part of orginization XIII
when sora stabbed himself with the dark blade his heart was gone so the only thing left was Ven's and that's why Roxas looks like sora. I like my theory seems possible.
There's one HUGE hole in your theory, Roxas is a Nobody, and nobodies don't have hearts. So if you still stick to your theory, you must also say in your video that you think Roxas isn't an actual nobody (it could be possible, but it isn't probable...)
@Cloudstrife688 your on the right track , but so is cutemax5674 .... what i think is , when sora became a heartless , his nobody was born , and since soras heart and vens heart are one , roxas took the form of ven ... so in a way , roxas and ven are the same , cause they both (in a way) are sora .... if this was a triangle , ven would be on the top of the triangle , and then it leads to sora cause him and ven became one , then sora becomes roxas , and roxas has some of ven's heart
@kj35780 he was talking to aqua's armor, its called room of sleep.room of awkening is still hidden, not even xemnas know where it is. oh and FYI ventus is in room of awakening.
When Ventus lost his heart, it went to Sora. When Sora became a heartless trying to save Kairi his heart went to Roxas. But Sora wasn't dead. So then that caused Roxas to have part of Ven and Soras heart. Soras Keyblade, and Ven's body hair ect.
how can you explain roxas and ventus similar clothes nd how bout when xemnas met roxas he changed the named sora to roxas and the x was the same style xehanort showed they symbol for the x-keyblade
Roxas is Ventus, I think because after the whole Ventus thing, Roxas wakes up in his bed and stuff, when it showed Roxas in KH2 waking up at the beginning he was the same age as Ventus, Kiari and Riku knew Aqua and Terra so why can't Sora know Roxas or Ventus, HUH? Explain that, please.
okay here's how it is...ROXAS is SORA and is a Ventus wannabe. All of Organization XIII's true names are their organization names mixed around without an X. Like, Axel is Lea, ect ect. half of those guys are in Radiant Garden in BBS.
Roxas LOOKS like Ventus for two reasons: A) Sora melded his heart with Ventus and B) Ventus's body is in CO which is prolly why Roxas was all UHHH HEADACHE when he tries to go in there. Also, He's coming back in KH 3 =D Ven, I mean. Cheack out Re:coded for moreinfo
you see i have a theory he might be roxas just at different times you see in bbs
this dude person i think xion or xemnas or who ever idk which but one of then said
" do you remember your true name?" i am thinking ventus's true name is Roxas
becuz you see he couldnt remember anything O.O so maybe his name was changed! is that enough proof of a theory or is it just false O.O you try and figure out lol
alright this is my theory about this crap. SPOILER at the end of birth by sleep aqua creates castle oblivion to seal ventus body armor so mickey can find his heart and place back.now why roxas looks like ventus is because in kh1 sora takes his heart out.well he didnt take his heart out,he took out ventus` half so when that nobody was created it looked like ven> if you think about it makes alot of sense
i think Roxas is ventus reborn, but he doesnt have any memory of his past life. He doesnt remember anything. CAuse his heart and sora's fused right. come on guys you dont need to go so deep. lolololZ:D
@Ural43 Roxas and Ven are not the same person have you not played bbs and kh2?We saw Roxas merge with Sora and he has his memories.Vens heart is in Roxas but Roxas has Soras soul and body he is not Ven.Vens heart went into Roxas not to twilight mansion and even if it did what body does he have?You just said heart.You didnt mention the body or soul he has.Because its Soras.
Ok people let me make this clear.Sora and Vens heart fused together like fusion from dbz.So when Sora destroyed his heart it split back into two his heart and Vens which Soras moved to his heartless and Vens moved to Roxas thats why Roxas looks Ven and has emotions because he has Sora's body and Soul and Vens heart.Ok?
@jayflash522 It really is ten years before actually... Why would Sora, RIku, and Kairi be shown as kids that are barely older than toddlers during Birth by sleep if not for that?
@jayflash522 No it didnt it took place 10 years man.Look at how young they are.They look just a bit older than toddlers.Thats been stated that bbs is 10 years before kh 1.I dunno where your getting your info but its wrong.ALso look at Radiant Garden Leon and the other use to live there.They said 9 years before Kh 1 Radiant was destroyed and turned into Hallow Bastion thast when the heartless attacks.But in bbs it looks likes its old good Radinat Garden place.Meaing it is 10 years before.
major flaw. if that were the case then why was xion able to be made? she wasn't made from a heart. for your theory to be true, xion would have needed to have a heart which is impossible because she was made of memories.
dont you think its kinda cool that terra and ventus are bffs and xemnes and roxas were together in the organization.maybe thats y xemnes smiled down at roxas in the ds version..idk im bored i just beat kh;bbs
yeah, roxas is possibly a nobody, while in kh2 some people say he isn't heartless, it might be like roxas is the heartless of ven, like axel has a nobody and a somebody who really look like eachother
@LoveNoteProjects after defeating SaïX, sora asks riku (ansem form) why all the members of organization XIII call him with Roxas (Xibarg with both names) and then riku (ansem form) tells him, : because sora, roxas is your nobody.
then there is a conversation between riku, sora and namine with the conclusion that roxas is some kind of nobody of sora.
@LoveNoteProjects I thought that nobodies are heartless, (except of ansem/xemnas) because they all say they don't have a heart, like axel at his death:
I think I'll pass, my heart just don't want, haven't got one.........
I wanted to see roxas, he made me feel like I had a heart, you make me feel the same.
saïx: "kingdom hearts, where is my heart?"
sorry if it isn't near my theory but I think you know why I was confused with the connection with a heartless and a nobody
remember when u were fighting against vanitas and he said to ven: if you beat me, you gonna lose your heart. roxas is ven for sure, he just can't remember being him cause he lost his heart. also they got the same voice actors. and vanitas also got the same voice actor like sora. i'm sure they would have created ven different if he wouldn't be roxas, he just exactly looks like him. anyway, its very interessting and confusing, i love kh :)
@SwissChickn6 No thy arent the same person.BBs took place 10 years before Kh1 if that was true how could Roxas merge with Sora?And why didnt he age?Exactly,Its already revealed that Roxas is Soras nobody but has Vens heart.
when ven was first and went to his station of awkeing it was broken and imcomplete, but his heart found a way to reach sora and sora offered to fix it for him(be aware this is also why Vaintas looks like 15 year old sora) but at the end of vens story his heart was lost and again found sora and stayed with him. When sora realesed his heart he also realesed ven's giving it to roxas. My conclusion any being
i have another theory: so we saw that ventus hearts went inside sora but his body left in the castle oblivion. i think that roxas is ventus body that is been awake but it doesn't have a heart. if you see in the 358/2 in a scene it says than roxas was given that name the day his haw awakened and before that he has like zombie. so i think his body was awakend but his heart is still in sora. and when sora lost his heart ventus heart became roxas. and that is why roxas has no memory being in organ13
I completely agree. Ventus became a part of Soras heart and when Sora became a Heartless that part of his heart that belonged to Ventus became Soras nobody Roxas. This is exactly why Roxas needed to go back to Sora because Sora and Ventus need each other. If Ventus wasn't with Sora, Sora wouldn't be able to use the keyblade. Riku was supposed to be the only keyblade wielder because Terra passed some of his powers down to em but bc Ventus is a part of Soras heart, he can also use the keyblade.
Its kind of like that...but Roxas IS Soras Nobody. He only looks like Ventus and even has some personality traits because most of Ventus was lost when Sora became a Heartless. Most of Ventus went to Roxas. See Ventus and Sora share the same heart basically. This is also why Roxas needed to go back to Sora because without him Sora wouldn't be able to use the Keyblade to his full potential. Their hearts and powers are mixed now so they basically need each other for now.
actually its all wrong, nomura the creator explained it, ven entered soras body so sora holds 1 heart because they merged thier hearts, but when sora released the 7 hearts including his ven's part of the heart got separated and went into the nobody of sora, so roxas is a nobody with a heart which is vens, so sora has 1 heart inside his body and its his heart, i found this on wikipedia under roxas's info. and ven didnt turn into a heartless his body is still in castle oblivion.
@arubaaldoori He's not a nobody his heart remained in Sora's body. A nobody is the body of someone without a heart, but since Ven's heart was in Sora's body he wasn't a nobody. Think of it like possession. Sora never got his body back until kh2. The rest is right but he kinda did turn into a heartless or spirit whatever you wanna call it. You don't even have to use wikipedia all you had to was think about it really hard for couple hours or days. 0-0
@Nexsah just type Roxas on the search and there should be a 12 selections scrool down to the last 1 it should say roxas from KH click on it and look for the reason under the section that says ''Creation and development'' in the last paragraph, plz just do it and u will c the real reason y they look alike plz just read it.
@arubaaldoori Kingdom Hearts II: Final Mix's secret ending features a character named Ventus that bears a striking resemblance to Roxas. Nomura commented that, despite how similar they are, Roxas and Ventus are not the same character. Additionally, he stated that by playing Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep, players will be able to distinguish Roxas from Ventus.[35]
@Nexsah In another interview, Nomura implied both characters are related, specifically to Sora, but he wanted fans to imagine reasons for such connection.[12][36] The Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep Ultimania clarified the connection, stating that Roxas and Ventus look alike because Ventus' heart entered Sora's body and Roxas' birth allowed Ventus' heart to reside in Roxas.[37]
@Nexsah Thats what it says about it. Hmm Ventus' heart resided in Roxas. Which is Sora's heartless body. So basically it was what I said. Ventus took over Sora's body when Sora became a heartless. Thats why he looks like him is because they are one in the same just a different body and no memories of his previous life.
They are the same person. When Ventus lost his heart, his heart didn't just touch Sora's heart it merged with it and when Sora released Kairi's heart in Hollow Bastion, he in turn release Ventus. Ventus's body is in Castle Oblivion and was placed there by Aqua. Castle Oblivion used to be can't remember the world but it was where the the Grandmaster lived and Aqua used his keyblade which he is dead by now and she changes the place into Castle Oblivion. @ the end of KH2 Ven/Rox goes bk insde Sora
@cutemax5674 Sora have the keyblade cuz he have the Ven's heart.
When Roxas/Ventus was released (again *maybe*), Sora was losing the keyblade's control (In the castle oblivion). Then Sora have to sleep...and Ventus/Roxas have to back to Sora's heart.
And...Roxas can cry. A Nobody can't cry or have feelings.
Remember : Ventus' body is in the Castle Oblivion, but...the body dissapeared (When Roxas was released..."When Sora was in the Castle Oblivion")
no memory. in 358/2 someone in the organization also says the castle is where roxas was born. so roxas isnt a nobody, he IS ven, i think this theory also explains y roxas has feelings
@pearl2492 The fact is they are either gonna have to find a way to get Ven's heart back into his body safely or Sora will have to die. Ven never made it to his body, he was controlling Sora's body because Sora's heart left it when he released the 7 princesses of heart. Ven's heart and Sora's were merged and Sora released their hearts hold on each other. Sora's heart went off and became a heartless while Ven's heart stayed and controlled Sora's body. Then in KH2 Sora gained control over his body
actually i think that it might have been ventus the whole time, remember the first day ventus met aqua and terra? he had no memory because of what xehanort did to him. and remember when in the BBS ending when aqua leaves ventus in castle oblivion to go find terra? he was asleep. i think that years later when the organization found castle oblivion they found ventus there, and when sora released the 7 princesses heart in KH he also released vens heart. it came back to ven and he woke up with
@pearl2492 I don't think his heart ever made it back to his body cus if it did he wouldn't have gone back to Sora. Because if you remember in a conversation between Xemnas and Roxas, Xemnas said "I've been to see him, he looks alot like you". I think he was talking about Ven's body I don't think Xemnas wanted Roxas to know the truth. I think Ven's heart was taking over Sora's body because Sora was a heartless ever since he released him in Hollow Bastion and only became whole again in KH2.
I like the theory, but I think it's more likely that Sora's heart was so strongly connected to Kairi's, that the part of Ventus's heart was more easily "detachable" from Sora's, thus giving Roxas the physical side from Ventus and the mental/emotional side Sora.
Comment removed
gabrieltnc12 1 week ago
so confused cuz there r so many theories xD i only played 2 kh games i didnt finish bbs but i finished kh 358 2 days so i figured ven and roxas are the same cuz the beginning of kh 3582 the guy asked roxas if he remembers his true name -___________________- but i only played 2 khs so idk but i wish ven/roxas were the same T_T
laylajoanyachirufan 3 weeks ago
roxas looks like ventus because ventus loses his heart after his battle with vanitas so sora lets ventus's heart rest in HIS untill it heals and re joins his body and when sora and roxas were separated, ventus might have stayed with roxas, not with sora, that would also explain why roxas has emotions unlike other nobodies
msnoahxlukefan 1 month ago 3
@msnoahxlukefan you're right ;P
gabrieltnc12 1 week ago
So basically, martinez is pretty much correct.
Bebee123123123 2 months ago
Roxas IS both Sora and Ventus. Roxas's weapons, rebirth and oblivion, are light and dark, combined makes the X (Pronouned keyblade). Mix up Roxas and yoi get Sora and a leftover X. X=Ultimate blade made out of light and dark. Ven's heart combined with Sora's then Ventus was REMADE with his heart (Sora and Himself) created Roxas. Ventus is alive though.
Bebee123123123 2 months ago
i think ven's heart to over sora's noBODY when sora became a heartless, so that's why his nobody looked like ven/roxas. they are the same people just roxas didn't have his memories.
when roxas entered the castle oblivion he fell weak because his body(the one locked away) was calling out to his heart
XxLightNTheDarknessX 2 months ago
please read from the beginning up : I LOVE ALL OF YOUR THEORIES..... being the first post.
mainez7796 2 months ago
if you watch the spoiler video of kh 3d, you will see at the end of the video, braig is standing in front of xehanort, and says "what is this? HAS YOUR HEART RETURNED?" at the end of the final chapter, (kh bbs) xehanort is sent to radiant garden by aqua. he is then asked what his name is and he says "xehanort." it is actually terra who is making a plan of his own. i know this because when aqua defeats xehanort in the final chapter, the darkness is released from him, creating the first heartless.
mainez7796 2 months ago
Thats when he says, "you make a great other." he was talking to ventus that was inside of sora. at the end of kh2, ventus is shown appearing from sora and talking to namine. But why is he called roxas? In kh2 final mix, you see a video of xemnas finding ventus in the mansion on the forest and telling him that his heart and sora's are connected. thus changing him from ventus to roxas. but xemnas is actually terra, who can now control his heart. he has a plan to reunite all three of them
mainez7796 2 months ago
I love all of your theories, but you all are wrong. The nobody is actually vanitas. At the end of aquas story, you fight vanitas, and he looks like roxas. at the end of ven's story, you fight vanitas and they are both destroyed. but vanitas was already created from the darkness of ven and therefor didnt have a heart to begin with. so he was a nobody already. thats why in a cutscene in kh2 you see sora fighting someone that looks like roxas, which is actually vanitas.
mainez7796 2 months ago
I am sorry about those confused people who think roxas is ven but u are all wrong. I am sure of it. It wouldn't make any sense!!! If it was then roxas' keyblade would be same as vens. Plus ven's body is castle oblivion the whole time so it wouldn't make anysense that roxas is ven!!!!!!
khdayskh1314 3 months ago
@paint2D noooo that isn't right the truth was just said in this vid. Since vens heart is a part of sora's roxas is basically sora's AND ven's nobody. Not much ven but a little. The only thing that changed was roxas' appearance.everything else about him is entirely wat sora would be like.
khdayskh1314 3 months ago
ya forgot to mention that ven's body is still sleeping just....waiting there...for his heart.....which was supposed to heal in sora's heart.
er i remember someone meantion that ven and roxas were the same person
but when roxas was born it was actually ven but without his memories???
idk
this is a trip to solve XD
kittylovemewmew 3 months ago
when sora sacrificed himself vens heart released and went into to roxas, roxas actually does have a heart but its ven's which explains why he can cry and why he looks like ven
technologic98 3 months ago
i think roxas, ven, and sora are technically the same. ven like we all know went into soras heart then wen sora became a heartless the nobody created was from ven's heart not sora but no one but sora knew ven was in his heart so everyone assumed roxas was sora's nobody but he is actually ven's nobody! an plus roxas also got part of sora's heart... and that is why he has minor feelings as part of orginization XIII
dbzpokemon1 4 months ago
when sora stabbed himself with the dark blade his heart was gone so the only thing left was Ven's and that's why Roxas looks like sora. I like my theory seems possible.
Buckyman441 4 months ago
There's one HUGE hole in your theory, Roxas is a Nobody, and nobodies don't have hearts. So if you still stick to your theory, you must also say in your video that you think Roxas isn't an actual nobody (it could be possible, but it isn't probable...)
sneurfje 5 months ago
@sneurfje i more think he meant that those parts of ven's and soras hearts went in his look and personality
shadowfan100000 4 months ago
Also, Ven's a wimp. Roxas isn't
Tuth9 6 months ago
Ventus woke up from sora and became roxas but then lost his heart and become a nobody or what ever i freeget
wayl8r 6 months ago
Nice video! That will help everyone who doesn't know. ^^
KingdomHearts1207 6 months ago
hmmmm well my terory is yeah i know ven gave sora his heart BUT what about his nobody well the they must be the samne person
Cloudstrife688 6 months ago
@Cloudstrife688 your on the right track , but so is cutemax5674 .... what i think is , when sora became a heartless , his nobody was born , and since soras heart and vens heart are one , roxas took the form of ven ... so in a way , roxas and ven are the same , cause they both (in a way) are sora .... if this was a triangle , ven would be on the top of the triangle , and then it leads to sora cause him and ven became one , then sora becomes roxas , and roxas has some of ven's heart
MitsakiChan45 6 months ago
Thumbs up if you think Ven stayed in sors's body after going Heartless and became Roxas
MrTgusta 7 months ago
@MrTgusta Ven is memory used to create roxas..dont be a thumbs up whore if you dont know what your talking about.
lyfewithgod17 6 months ago
@lyfewithgod17 a memory?? um, ventus is real, you should play the game or you will epicly fail from your own comment,
animegamesbiggestfan 6 months ago
@animegamesbiggestfan obviously ven is real, but roxas looks like him because of soras memory. same reason xion looks like kiari...
lyfewithgod17 6 months ago
@cutemax5674 at 1:35 ven's heart didnt ovepower sora's, it's because roxas has ven's heart.
AwesomeAznshadow 7 months ago
@cutemax5674 at 1:22 roxas was born WHEN he turned into a heartless not after.
AwesomeAznshadow 7 months ago
@cutemax5674 at 1:14 thats not true, it was because sora released his heart, and let go of ven's too.
AwesomeAznshadow 7 months ago
what would also happen if sora meets ventus?
Spyderhelm 8 months ago
@Spyderhelm Then roxas wouldn't look like he did.
AwesomeAznshadow 7 months ago
what would happen if roxas and ventus were to meet? because ventus is still the castle with yen sid
Spyderhelm 8 months ago
@Spyderhelm no, he's in castle oblivion, you know? Marluxias castle.
AwesomeAznshadow 7 months ago
Comment removed
Bladius9 8 months ago
But in kh 358/2 xemnas and saix were in roxas room (in the castle) and xemnas said
" sleep has taken you yet again"
Or something like that
kj35780 10 months ago
@kj35780 he was talking to aqua's armor, its called room of sleep.room of awkening is still hidden, not even xemnas know where it is. oh and FYI ventus is in room of awakening.
animegamesbiggestfan 9 months ago
When Ventus lost his heart, it went to Sora. When Sora became a heartless trying to save Kairi his heart went to Roxas. But Sora wasn't dead. So then that caused Roxas to have part of Ven and Soras heart. Soras Keyblade, and Ven's body hair ect.
TheCoopasaurus 10 months ago
@xmistyriousx23 oh well you see i jsut realized a few weeks ago i missed typed that and mixed roxas and ven and ven as roxas lol sorry
cloudsmithbro 11 months ago
how can you explain roxas and ventus similar clothes nd how bout when xemnas met roxas he changed the named sora to roxas and the x was the same style xehanort showed they symbol for the x-keyblade
NarutoOfTheRebelion 1 year ago
Roxas is Ventus, I think because after the whole Ventus thing, Roxas wakes up in his bed and stuff, when it showed Roxas in KH2 waking up at the beginning he was the same age as Ventus, Kiari and Riku knew Aqua and Terra so why can't Sora know Roxas or Ventus, HUH? Explain that, please.
poopdroid 1 year ago
okay here's how it is...ROXAS is SORA and is a Ventus wannabe. All of Organization XIII's true names are their organization names mixed around without an X. Like, Axel is Lea, ect ect. half of those guys are in Radiant Garden in BBS.
Roxas LOOKS like Ventus for two reasons: A) Sora melded his heart with Ventus and B) Ventus's body is in CO which is prolly why Roxas was all UHHH HEADACHE when he tries to go in there. Also, He's coming back in KH 3 =D Ven, I mean. Cheack out Re:coded for moreinfo
Dr4wW1thM3 1 year ago
kool vid totaly awesome i give this 5 stars
MegaRoxasora 1 year ago
you see i have a theory he might be roxas just at different times you see in bbs
this dude person i think xion or xemnas or who ever idk which but one of then said
" do you remember your true name?" i am thinking ventus's true name is Roxas
becuz you see he couldnt remember anything O.O so maybe his name was changed! is that enough proof of a theory or is it just false O.O you try and figure out lol
cloudsmithbro 1 year ago
@cloudsmithbro Wouldn't Roxas' true name be Ventus? Since Ven came first and what not?
xmistyriousx23 1 year ago
alright this is my theory about this crap. SPOILER at the end of birth by sleep aqua creates castle oblivion to seal ventus body armor so mickey can find his heart and place back.now why roxas looks like ventus is because in kh1 sora takes his heart out.well he didnt take his heart out,he took out ventus` half so when that nobody was created it looked like ven> if you think about it makes alot of sense
88magicmariodude88 1 year ago
i think Roxas is ventus reborn, but he doesnt have any memory of his past life. He doesnt remember anything. CAuse his heart and sora's fused right. come on guys you dont need to go so deep. lolololZ:D
bleachlover165460 1 year ago
Left the Org.XII is because Roxas(Ven) really want to meet this person Sora.
After the battle Roxas lost and really remembered whos Sora again.
He said "You did a good other" Because Sora has changed of Vens heart.
Roxas is still alive but who knows where he is now.
Ural43 1 year ago
This is wrong that roxas were born! roxas never have been borned.
When Sora is giving his heart to save Kairi a part of ventus heart has been scatered and gone to the Mansion in Twilight Town.
Ventus Wakes up on the Mansion and xemnas came.
Xemnas messes up with Soras name and put a X on it.
Now Ventus is not Ventus anymore he is Roxas now.
He lost a part of his memories so he really cant remember Sora.
After Roxas(Ven) is leaving the Org.XII He fighted with Sora on Skycrab.
The Reason why he
Ural43 1 year ago
@Ural43 Roxas and Ven are not the same person have you not played bbs and kh2?We saw Roxas merge with Sora and he has his memories.Vens heart is in Roxas but Roxas has Soras soul and body he is not Ven.Vens heart went into Roxas not to twilight mansion and even if it did what body does he have?You just said heart.You didnt mention the body or soul he has.Because its Soras.
4TheLssj 1 year ago
Ok people let me make this clear.Sora and Vens heart fused together like fusion from dbz.So when Sora destroyed his heart it split back into two his heart and Vens which Soras moved to his heartless and Vens moved to Roxas thats why Roxas looks Ven and has emotions because he has Sora's body and Soul and Vens heart.Ok?
4TheLssj 1 year ago
@4TheLssj no t took 4 yearsd before! wat are u talking about???
jayflash522 1 year ago
@jayflash522 It really is ten years before actually... Why would Sora, RIku, and Kairi be shown as kids that are barely older than toddlers during Birth by sleep if not for that?
YumiOfTheFadedTsunam 1 year ago
@jayflash522 No it didnt it took place 10 years man.Look at how young they are.They look just a bit older than toddlers.Thats been stated that bbs is 10 years before kh 1.I dunno where your getting your info but its wrong.ALso look at Radiant Garden Leon and the other use to live there.They said 9 years before Kh 1 Radiant was destroyed and turned into Hallow Bastion thast when the heartless attacks.But in bbs it looks likes its old good Radinat Garden place.Meaing it is 10 years before.
4TheLssj 1 year ago
major flaw. if that were the case then why was xion able to be made? she wasn't made from a heart. for your theory to be true, xion would have needed to have a heart which is impossible because she was made of memories.
LoveNoteProjects 1 year ago
dont you think its kinda cool that terra and ventus are bffs and xemnes and roxas were together in the organization.maybe thats y xemnes smiled down at roxas in the ds version..idk im bored i just beat kh;bbs
Hylianlegion 1 year ago
i get it sora and ventus`s heart is splitted and created a look alike ventus but named roxas (sora plus x scrambbled =roxas)
ROJANE234 1 year ago
yeah, roxas is possibly a nobody, while in kh2 some people say he isn't heartless, it might be like roxas is the heartless of ven, like axel has a nobody and a somebody who really look like eachother
DeUitdager 1 year ago
@DeUitdager impossible because sora would be like riku. a person struggling with darkness if roxas was a heartless.
LoveNoteProjects 1 year ago
@LoveNoteProjects after defeating SaïX, sora asks riku (ansem form) why all the members of organization XIII call him with Roxas (Xibarg with both names) and then riku (ansem form) tells him, : because sora, roxas is your nobody.
then there is a conversation between riku, sora and namine with the conclusion that roxas is some kind of nobody of sora.
DeUitdager 1 year ago
@DeUitdager you just proved my point. roxas can't be a heartless because he is a nobody of sora-his memories (and ven-his likeness)
LoveNoteProjects 1 year ago
@LoveNoteProjects I thought that nobodies are heartless, (except of ansem/xemnas) because they all say they don't have a heart, like axel at his death:
I think I'll pass, my heart just don't want, haven't got one.........
I wanted to see roxas, he made me feel like I had a heart, you make me feel the same.
saïx: "kingdom hearts, where is my heart?"
sorry if it isn't near my theory but I think you know why I was confused with the connection with a heartless and a nobody
DeUitdager 1 year ago
so is that when sora had gained back his ventus-heart, but then, sora himself lost part of his heart, so Sora became a nobody, then that borns Roxas?
So is that Roxas actualy created from a Sora-Ventus?
O_o?? Im so confusedddddddddddddddddd...
SUPERxXBDFCxXTWF 1 year ago
Comment removed
SUPERxXBDFCxXTWF 1 year ago
that made so much sense its not even funny!
SuperLolom 1 year ago
remember when u were fighting against vanitas and he said to ven: if you beat me, you gonna lose your heart. roxas is ven for sure, he just can't remember being him cause he lost his heart. also they got the same voice actors. and vanitas also got the same voice actor like sora. i'm sure they would have created ven different if he wouldn't be roxas, he just exactly looks like him. anyway, its very interessting and confusing, i love kh :)
SwissChickn6 1 year ago
@SwissChickn6 behind all that connects us to our childhood, there is a very complicated story.
VanitasXblade 1 year ago
@SwissChickn6 No thy arent the same person.BBs took place 10 years before Kh1 if that was true how could Roxas merge with Sora?And why didnt he age?Exactly,Its already revealed that Roxas is Soras nobody but has Vens heart.
4TheLssj 1 year ago
created from one of them will look like the other(be aware this is also why Roxas has feelings he has half of ven's heart inside him)
thefoxfan1 1 year ago
SPOILER ALERT
i know excatly roxas looks like ven
it took me a while to figure it out but
when ven was first and went to his station of awkeing it was broken and imcomplete, but his heart found a way to reach sora and sora offered to fix it for him(be aware this is also why Vaintas looks like 15 year old sora) but at the end of vens story his heart was lost and again found sora and stayed with him. When sora realesed his heart he also realesed ven's giving it to roxas. My conclusion any being
thefoxfan1 1 year ago
i have another theory: so we saw that ventus hearts went inside sora but his body left in the castle oblivion. i think that roxas is ventus body that is been awake but it doesn't have a heart. if you see in the 358/2 in a scene it says than roxas was given that name the day his haw awakened and before that he has like zombie. so i think his body was awakend but his heart is still in sora. and when sora lost his heart ventus heart became roxas. and that is why roxas has no memory being in organ13
nfinalf 1 year ago
THESE GAMES DON'T MAKE SENSE.
Roxas>Ventus>anything>absolute horribleness>Sora. 'Nuff said.
kablay1 1 year ago
I completely agree. Ventus became a part of Soras heart and when Sora became a Heartless that part of his heart that belonged to Ventus became Soras nobody Roxas. This is exactly why Roxas needed to go back to Sora because Sora and Ventus need each other. If Ventus wasn't with Sora, Sora wouldn't be able to use the keyblade. Riku was supposed to be the only keyblade wielder because Terra passed some of his powers down to em but bc Ventus is a part of Soras heart, he can also use the keyblade.
Onizuma13 1 year ago
Thanks for the fuckin spoiler alert
charlie120asc 1 year ago
roxas is ven's reincarnation lol
tigurius555 1 year ago
@tigurius555
Its kind of like that...but Roxas IS Soras Nobody. He only looks like Ventus and even has some personality traits because most of Ventus was lost when Sora became a Heartless. Most of Ventus went to Roxas. See Ventus and Sora share the same heart basically. This is also why Roxas needed to go back to Sora because without him Sora wouldn't be able to use the Keyblade to his full potential. Their hearts and powers are mixed now so they basically need each other for now.
Onizuma13 1 year ago
@tigurius555 "roxass is ventus' reincarnation"... that makes no sense and is probaly the stupidest and most ignorant thing i ever heard..
WarrenKeingGaw 1 year ago
Please, watch my last video. in my video appear more info, and more proofs that Roxas is Ventus ^_^
btw, nice video :D
LinkMan2000 1 year ago
actually its all wrong, nomura the creator explained it, ven entered soras body so sora holds 1 heart because they merged thier hearts, but when sora released the 7 hearts including his ven's part of the heart got separated and went into the nobody of sora, so roxas is a nobody with a heart which is vens, so sora has 1 heart inside his body and its his heart, i found this on wikipedia under roxas's info. and ven didnt turn into a heartless his body is still in castle oblivion.
arubaaldoori 1 year ago
@arubaaldoori He's not a nobody his heart remained in Sora's body. A nobody is the body of someone without a heart, but since Ven's heart was in Sora's body he wasn't a nobody. Think of it like possession. Sora never got his body back until kh2. The rest is right but he kinda did turn into a heartless or spirit whatever you wanna call it. You don't even have to use wikipedia all you had to was think about it really hard for couple hours or days. 0-0
Nexsah 1 year ago
@Nexsah just type Roxas on the search and there should be a 12 selections scrool down to the last 1 it should say roxas from KH click on it and look for the reason under the section that says ''Creation and development'' in the last paragraph, plz just do it and u will c the real reason y they look alike plz just read it.
arubaaldoori 1 year ago
on the wikipedia search
arubaaldoori 1 year ago
@arubaaldoori Kingdom Hearts II: Final Mix's secret ending features a character named Ventus that bears a striking resemblance to Roxas. Nomura commented that, despite how similar they are, Roxas and Ventus are not the same character. Additionally, he stated that by playing Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep, players will be able to distinguish Roxas from Ventus.[35]
Nexsah 1 year ago
@Nexsah In another interview, Nomura implied both characters are related, specifically to Sora, but he wanted fans to imagine reasons for such connection.[12][36] The Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep Ultimania clarified the connection, stating that Roxas and Ventus look alike because Ventus' heart entered Sora's body and Roxas' birth allowed Ventus' heart to reside in Roxas.[37]
Nexsah 1 year ago
@Nexsah Thats what it says about it. Hmm Ventus' heart resided in Roxas. Which is Sora's heartless body. So basically it was what I said. Ventus took over Sora's body when Sora became a heartless. Thats why he looks like him is because they are one in the same just a different body and no memories of his previous life.
Nexsah 1 year ago
@Nexsah And Sora didn't have a body until KH2 he was a heartless until that point
Nexsah 1 year ago
They are the same person. When Ventus lost his heart, his heart didn't just touch Sora's heart it merged with it and when Sora released Kairi's heart in Hollow Bastion, he in turn release Ventus. Ventus's body is in Castle Oblivion and was placed there by Aqua. Castle Oblivion used to be can't remember the world but it was where the the Grandmaster lived and Aqua used his keyblade which he is dead by now and she changes the place into Castle Oblivion. @ the end of KH2 Ven/Rox goes bk insde Sora
Nexsah 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cutemax5674 Sora have the keyblade cuz he have the Ven's heart.
When Roxas/Ventus was released (again *maybe*), Sora was losing the keyblade's control (In the castle oblivion). Then Sora have to sleep...and Ventus/Roxas have to back to Sora's heart.
And...Roxas can cry. A Nobody can't cry or have feelings.
Remember : Ventus' body is in the Castle Oblivion, but...the body dissapeared (When Roxas was released..."When Sora was in the Castle Oblivion")
Then :
Roxas = Ventus
PrincessPeachR 1 year ago
But in kh 358/2 days, when Roxas was going to Castle Oblivion, he was remembering something.
Roxas: All these...pictures...rushing into my head
Roxas : Wait...there's something...I can almost...
And Ventus is in the Castle Oblivion. Roxas was remembering that...he was Ventus (Roxas have the Ven's heart, cuz Roxas can feel emotions)
PrincessPeachR 1 year ago
@cutemax5674 oh yea, which game is that?
pearl2492 1 year ago
@pearl2492 kingdom hearts 358/2 days and chain of memories
cutemax5674 1 year ago
no memory. in 358/2 someone in the organization also says the castle is where roxas was born. so roxas isnt a nobody, he IS ven, i think this theory also explains y roxas has feelings
pearl2492 1 year ago
@pearl2492 The fact is they are either gonna have to find a way to get Ven's heart back into his body safely or Sora will have to die. Ven never made it to his body, he was controlling Sora's body because Sora's heart left it when he released the 7 princesses of heart. Ven's heart and Sora's were merged and Sora released their hearts hold on each other. Sora's heart went off and became a heartless while Ven's heart stayed and controlled Sora's body. Then in KH2 Sora gained control over his body
Nexsah 1 year ago
actually i think that it might have been ventus the whole time, remember the first day ventus met aqua and terra? he had no memory because of what xehanort did to him. and remember when in the BBS ending when aqua leaves ventus in castle oblivion to go find terra? he was asleep. i think that years later when the organization found castle oblivion they found ventus there, and when sora released the 7 princesses heart in KH he also released vens heart. it came back to ven and he woke up with
pearl2492 1 year ago
@pearl2492 I don't think his heart ever made it back to his body cus if it did he wouldn't have gone back to Sora. Because if you remember in a conversation between Xemnas and Roxas, Xemnas said "I've been to see him, he looks alot like you". I think he was talking about Ven's body I don't think Xemnas wanted Roxas to know the truth. I think Ven's heart was taking over Sora's body because Sora was a heartless ever since he released him in Hollow Bastion and only became whole again in KH2.
Nexsah 1 year ago
I like the theory, but I think it's more likely that Sora's heart was so strongly connected to Kairi's, that the part of Ventus's heart was more easily "detachable" from Sora's, thus giving Roxas the physical side from Ventus and the mental/emotional side Sora.
xmikeyxlikesitx 1 year ago