so I don't mean to offend anyone, but he will always just be the other guy from propagandhi to me. and whenever true weakerthan fans speak i just chuckle to myself and go "girls with the greenest eyes".
@nateinkanoya ya but showdown isn't. greenest eyes is his, and preamble is chris'. And based on the music I would assume the Hannah wrote the song. Gifts on the other hand sounds like a sped up weakerthan song... and so this is HIS song. where showdown, is really just a propagandhi song. no matter who's singing.
Doesnt matter what prop album is your fav, but i think everyone should recognize that John did not fit into that band. Todd Kowalski is a much better fit and John has written beautiful music with the Weakerthans
i'm so glad john left propagadhi. i think that this is how his music sounds best. after he left, prop got way better and he started an awesome band with its own sound. seriously could not ask for a gooder outcome!
Is it really a cover though? He wrote it and was in Propagandhi for a good while. That would be like saying Streetlight Manifesto covers Catch 22 songs. Sillypants.
Exactly, it's kind of a partial cover, as although he may have written the song, the rest of the band members who weren't in propagandhi would be covering it.
yeah I just play it with capo on 3. He plays it lower. Yes you can play it in drop D if you want to hear the base note ring, and I'm sure that's what he does. But my way is easier for playing on my shitty acoustic guitar (and yes I know that it's not how he wrote it but in the scheme of things it's the exact same notes minus one)
The line "Spent half the span of some lost culture's rise and fall, but I'm as clueless as a drooling four year old" is one of the best pieces of lyrics ever written.
agreed... the entire song has sweet lyrics but "wrote this selfish sadness on a bathroom wall, spent half the span of some lost cultures rise and fall" is a fucking awesome line
he's playing a Gibson Melody Maker. And no, it isn't acoustic, I've been wondering about that myself. It's also not a Propagandhi cover... he wrote the song himself. I think Propagandhi does own the rights to the song though, I heard he sold the songs to them when he split from the band.
Well, I think Propagandhi give a f*** about the rights - since in the booklet of How To Clean Everything they say "all song are absolutely anti-copyright." Fat Wreck Chords might object, but... well, Fat Mike wouldn't wanna make a complete idiot of himself, too, I guess.
Actually, I saw the Weakerthans a few days ago and got a chance to talk with John Sampson after the show for a few minutes and mentioned that I would have liked to hear him play this song. He said he will probably never play it again because he wrote it when he was 18 and he is now 36 and there are just so many other songs he would rather play. ... Moral being technically, this song has always been his 'crap.' Although I probably wouldn't use that particular adjective.
John k. Samson defines epic
smithdan000 10 months ago
I wish there was a tab for this somewhere.
BobbyBeanBagz 10 months ago
@BobbyBeanBagz There is, youtube it
Pugnacio 10 months ago
@Pugnacio If there is, I can't find it =/
BobbyBeanBagz 10 months ago
@BobbyBeanBagz Youtube search "How to play GIFTS by JOHN K. SAMSON"
Pugnacio 10 months ago
@Pugnacio Thanks!
BobbyBeanBagz 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BobbyBeanBagz
For standard (which is how I play it):
D, G, Bm, A, G, D, A
Then at part: “Still hoping I might find the…” Bm, G, A, (2x)
Then at part: “So here’s the last call for regrets…” D, A, Bm, A, G, G, D, A, start over
Pugnacio
Pugnacio 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BobbyBeanBagz
For standard (which is how I play it):
D, G, Bm, A, G, D, A
Then at part: “Still hoping I might find the…” Bm, G, A, (2x)
Then at part: “So here’s the last call for regrets…” D, A, Bm, A, G, G, D, A, start over
Pugnacio
Pugnacio 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BobbyBeanBagz For standard (which is how I play it):
D, G, Bm, A, G, D, A
Then at part: “Still hoping I might find the…” Bm, G, A, (2x)
Then at part: “So here’s the last call for regrets…” D, A, Bm, A, G, G, D, A, start over
Pugnacio 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BobbyBeanBagz D, G, Bm, A, G, D, A
Then at part: “Still hoping I might find the…” Bm, G, A, (2x)
Then at part: “So here’s the last call for regrets…” D, A, Bm, A, G, G, D, A, start over
Pugnacio 10 months ago
@Pugnacio If you check it, I posted the chords in standard tuning. Cheers!
Pugnacio 10 months ago
so I don't mean to offend anyone, but he will always just be the other guy from propagandhi to me. and whenever true weakerthan fans speak i just chuckle to myself and go "girls with the greenest eyes".
jazzmasterjesus 1 year ago
@jazzmasterjesus
you do realize that greenest eyes was originally his song yeah?
nateinkanoya 7 months ago
@nateinkanoya ya but showdown isn't. greenest eyes is his, and preamble is chris'. And based on the music I would assume the Hannah wrote the song. Gifts on the other hand sounds like a sped up weakerthan song... and so this is HIS song. where showdown, is really just a propagandhi song. no matter who's singing.
jazzmasterjesus 7 months ago
That was the only way he could have made Gifts better
Absolutely perfect melodies conversing with beautiful guitar lines
JoeyMondayRefused 1 year ago
Weakerthans/Propagandhi vinyl available @ chisel records dot com.
chiselrecords 1 year ago
Doesnt matter what prop album is your fav, but i think everyone should recognize that John did not fit into that band. Todd Kowalski is a much better fit and John has written beautiful music with the Weakerthans
SSSMforlife1 1 year ago
Great lyrics, great cover and great band !!!!
PROPAGHANDI19 1 year ago
Capaciteeeeeeeeey!
allnightpancakes 1 year ago 17
I really wish this will someday end up on a Weakerthans album. It's one of my favorite songs.
CynicalSprout70 2 years ago
Love you JKS! Been a big fan for over a decade now... your songs mean a lot.
gardneross 2 years ago
i'm so glad john left propagadhi. i think that this is how his music sounds best. after he left, prop got way better and he started an awesome band with its own sound. seriously could not ask for a gooder outcome!
mysweetgb 2 years ago 24
@mysweetgb Gooder! CAPACITY
muskoxtheband 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
more like WEAKER THAN PROPAGANDHI
futurewolf42o 2 years ago
Two entirely contrasting bands, both equally as good imo. You don't know what you're talking about though mate.
fuckoffwithaname 2 years ago 3
samson is epic. i love his work with propagandhi, it's ashame he left.
the weakerthans are cool too though, albeit very different!
warssuckletsparty 2 years ago
why is this titled as a cover ? its johns song
NearRhyme 2 years ago
'cos it was still a Propagandhi song nonetheless.
yaxxee 2 years ago
because it was still played by the band propagandhi, the collective band owns it i assume because everyone played in it.
hookabot 2 years ago
@NearRhyme
It also says acoustic, even though that's an electric guitar. Perhaps better to just walk away slowly...
Eyedunno 8 months ago
OMG, how amazing, didn't know he ever played that song with the The Weakerthans!
catog 3 years ago
love love it
aaronmitz 3 years ago 2
have I commented on this yet? I forget.
this is a great video and thanks for uploading it! also I really like the smiley in the title.
asemisldkfj 3 years ago
Although, the twat shouting capacity spoils it.
sandihume 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no! i LOVE the twat shouting capacity, its brilliant
riksharma 3 years ago 13
same here!!
stants11 3 years ago
This is another example of one of those songs that give you goosebumps on your back, not many songs can do that!
sandihume 3 years ago
epic song
brajkola 3 years ago 3
*lovvveee this song.
he did a sweet cover of a really good propagandi song.
ohhh what i'd give to see John K. Samson live. <3
kickoutthejamss44 3 years ago 3
Is it really a cover though? He wrote it and was in Propagandhi for a good while. That would be like saying Streetlight Manifesto covers Catch 22 songs. Sillypants.
sexyianpig23 3 years ago
haha true!
i didnt really put much thought into that..
and woo! catch 22 and Streelight are AMAZING!:D
kickoutthejamss44 3 years ago
Exactly, it's kind of a partial cover, as although he may have written the song, the rest of the band members who weren't in propagandhi would be covering it.
sandihume 3 years ago
What an amazing song, John K. Samson is such a great songwriter :)
azpunkazme 3 years ago
I play this once or twice a week
ThingNation 3 years ago
don't suppose you have a tab for this, or can sketch one up? i know what most the chords are but im scratching my head over the picking.
i wish the crazy fool would put this on an album, its pure awesome.
unluckystuntman 3 years ago
You gotta capo the third fret, I believe it's
C (X3201X), G* (32001X), A-(X0221X), E-*(02201X),
F+(13321X), C (X3201X), G* (32001X)
Just put them in the right order after that
He plays around with the C on the b string (first finger on the second last string during G and E chords)
picking is more or less 123 123 13,
with 1 and 2 being the lowest two notes of the chord, and 3 being the highest 2
Anyways I don't have my guitar on me but that's what I think
standintheforestfire 2 years ago 3
it's in drop D - chords are D, A, Bm, Fsharp, D A bla bla,
i know all the bits except the slide from D to A which i'm stumped on.
you can tell its drop D though, listen to the low bass note, has to be.
unluckystuntman 2 years ago
yeah I just play it with capo on 3. He plays it lower. Yes you can play it in drop D if you want to hear the base note ring, and I'm sure that's what he does. But my way is easier for playing on my shitty acoustic guitar (and yes I know that it's not how he wrote it but in the scheme of things it's the exact same notes minus one)
standintheforestfire 2 years ago
Don't you mean the second fret? Either way this is a good alternative method for those without the nous to tune into drop D.
digestives27 2 years ago
Gifts is such a fantastic song.
KyleLM18 3 years ago 2
i love that background vocal! Best part!
goldenlarry 3 years ago 3
yeh the 'CAPACITY' bit is awesome
tttooommm111222333 3 years ago 2
The line "Spent half the span of some lost culture's rise and fall, but I'm as clueless as a drooling four year old" is one of the best pieces of lyrics ever written.
Salut, John K. Samson!
larsxe 3 years ago 2
agreed... the entire song has sweet lyrics but "wrote this selfish sadness on a bathroom wall, spent half the span of some lost cultures rise and fall" is a fucking awesome line
tttooommm111222333 3 years ago
he's playing a Gibson Melody Maker. And no, it isn't acoustic, I've been wondering about that myself. It's also not a Propagandhi cover... he wrote the song himself. I think Propagandhi does own the rights to the song though, I heard he sold the songs to them when he split from the band.
Sketchward 3 years ago
Well, I think Propagandhi give a f*** about the rights - since in the booklet of How To Clean Everything they say "all song are absolutely anti-copyright." Fat Wreck Chords might object, but... well, Fat Mike wouldn't wanna make a complete idiot of himself, too, I guess.
So, here's the bottom line: Everything is fine.
euronoise 3 years ago
umm yeah anti meaning against.. copywright means they care.. anti means they don't. idiot
NationStates44 3 years ago
it was never about money or owning the songs.. i could release antimanifest right now and i bet chirs H. wouldnt give a f***.
NationStates44 3 years ago
hes not releasing it anyways hes just playing it live, so theres no need for the rights to the song .
albacorepunk 3 years ago
playing electric guitar with clean sound (no distortion) doesn't make it an acoustic song.
Filbunkish 3 years ago
@filbunkish, and what if its a guitar with a piezo pickup, then it would classify as an acoustic song :)
shoottheemokid 3 years ago
wow, a John K. Samson video with sound quality. Good job, awesome song, one of my favourites.
Sketchward 3 years ago 2
great song even in acoustic version..i also like propagandhi's version a lot..
FcBaselFan 3 years ago
hes in the freaking band
nelson3300 3 years ago
douche
Jmulder84 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No. No. No.
goldenlarry 3 years ago
what you mean no no no..... this is pure genius
Jmulder84 3 years ago 3
hahaha..sure.
goldenlarry 3 years ago
douchebag
Jmulder84 3 years ago
Muldy Douchebag.
goldenlarry 3 years ago
just brilliant. love propagandhi, love weakerthans. LOVE CANADIAN INDIE SCENE!!!
gpphx 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
please, no propagandhi acoustic covers, you left the band now stick to your crap
bets86 3 years ago
derp.
EiffelTowerHigh 3 years ago
Comment removed
Jmulder84 3 years ago 7
@Jmulder84 he doesnt need permission to perform a song he wrote
northkato 1 year ago
pfft, and i'll bet you write the most awesome songs!
both versions are awesome! but sadly you fall short of this, and propagandhi hates people like you!
ROH
rohanarchy 3 years ago
Actually, I saw the Weakerthans a few days ago and got a chance to talk with John Sampson after the show for a few minutes and mentioned that I would have liked to hear him play this song. He said he will probably never play it again because he wrote it when he was 18 and he is now 36 and there are just so many other songs he would rather play. ... Moral being technically, this song has always been his 'crap.' Although I probably wouldn't use that particular adjective.
mrhinsliy 3 years ago
thats a blue shirt, retard.
unreal581 3 years ago
thats a electric guitar.
shoottheemokid 4 years ago 4
is that a serious comment or are you trying to point out the extremely obvious?
kylewagoner 4 years ago
nevermind, i see why you said that now.
kylewagoner 4 years ago
hehe oke:P
shoottheemokid 4 years ago
plesa we need tab!!! tab hero help
1
gqunit69 4 years ago
id also love a tab for this, someone should pull their finger out.
cmon john k!
unluckystuntman 4 years ago
I learned how to play it (not quite perfect) by watching his hand in the videos It's in drop D tuning.
... it doesn't sound nearly as good when I play it.
mrhinsliy 4 years ago
i was going to ask the same
abj0405 4 years ago
someone teach me how to play this song?
LllMnr 4 years ago
I'll pay for a video of "letter of resignation" by propaghandi, on an old 7" split w/ FYP. I have the split but need a digital copy
Ryguy1450 4 years ago
I know it's been about a year, but if you still need it I can get it for you.
fonixxxx 3 years ago
I must have had money then b/c I won't pay. But I do appreciate the offer. If you have the split 7" sound pm me.
Ryguy1450 3 years ago
This song is soooo beautiful... It always makes me feel better...
nogakennethcroso 4 years ago
i love him.
greatbigcanadiana 4 years ago
John K. Of Course Will Allways Be Propa. And Propa. Are Also...Weakerthan in most true life respects...
RoaR3000 4 years ago
Awesome Quality
SuperMacguyver 4 years ago