Added: 4 years ago
From: phenroid
Views: 36,771
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (82)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Is this version available anywhere? Really like this version, but the quality is a bit lackin on this vid.

  • Shannon Noll is better than Guy Sebastian and i'll tell you why, when Guy sings, he uses a voice synthesiser, when Shannon sings, its just him singing. You be the judge.

  • I have to be honest. I like both Shannon Noll and Guy Sebastian. Both of them do this song well. But with Shannon singing this song, I can actually connect with him. He sings with emotion. You can also hear that when he does What About Me. I like both versions of the song. Don't get me wrong. But I can connect with Shannon's version more than I can with Guy's.

  • Shannon Noll I think did this way better than Guy. Bust more emotion in the vocals. In saying that though What About Me was a 10x better first single for him.

  • shannon sucks at this song

  • you could tell Guy would win this competition for a while BUT i wish shannon won Shannon has a real aussie voice

    *not that they both don't i just mean he could sing the classic aussie hits better than guy in that retrespect*

  • first season of idol was so good, a lot of people made good careers out of it, no less the top 2 who are massive stars in aussie music industry

  • i think the song itself didnt favour shannon as much as it did for guy. having said that, shannon did an awesome job to make it work for him. so unlucky he didnt win the contest that year. nevermind though, he's still churning it out after all this time - definitely a great aussie talent!

  • BITCH THIS IS GAY SEBASTIANS SONG XO

  • I actually think this version's better. Sounds more natural & genuine.

  • This one reminds me of Bryan Adams

  • Shannon's voice brought a sense of sincerity and realism to the song. Guy's version was great, but I felt that I connected better with Shannon's version.

  • trololol

  • SHANNON IS SO CUTE. IVE NEVER SEEN THIS CLIP. SHANNON BRINGS A COUNTRY SOUND TO THIS SONG. ITS A REALLY NICE SONG.

  • Shannon Noll still going strong, he is becoming very big over in the UK also

  • nah bullcrap...shannon does it better..and at least he was born ere in oz to be our aussie idol lol (not bein rude,but shannon rocks) and it will be his version playing at our wedding not guys sorry to the g-seb fans

  • Makes me teary this one but i love it,well done Shannon.

  • @schneke1 I was reading your comment, and I had to double read it because I thought you said "Guy sounds like he's singing to a man" hahahahaha

  • I do like Guy's rendition better - it suits him well. Though shannon's one was good, too.

  • did this soooooo much better than guy

  • This was the best version by far, its sung from the heart, Guys is to perfect almost sterile.

  • Shannon Noll

  • I like shannon but this song was guys for sure. I like them both, very different singers

  • make an idiot out of himself?? wtf is your problem champ... shannon is heaps good.... he actually prefers to stay in australia and stick to his roots.. but guy had to sell out and ditch to america.. okay so guy is not bad im not dissing him... but shannon is much better

  • he is a angel singer i would really like 2 hve a pics with him lol thats toattly funny sumone lol

  • Wow I didn't know they made the videos before the winner was announced. This was really good, but still...you close your eyes and the voice that really leaves an impression is Guy's. Still I have a lot of respect for Shannon.

  • shannon knoll has a great voice, but technically and professionally speaking, compared to guys voice, it is merely average. guy sebastian has such a unique voice that i have never heard before. i have heard a million shannon knolls. i dont live in australia so i dont know but the only reason guy would have done nothing after idol if this is the case is down to bad management because that guy is something special, his talent is beyond belief. come to england, show up the shower of shite we have !

  • Can I like both versions, both singers and not have to diss either one?

  • this is way better than GUYS!

  • I like this version better than Guy's.

  • There are few Aussie singers who have never gone global and have lead very famous,rich and successful aussie music careers. (e.g john Farnham)

  • For a singer that does rock, he does a good job. But I agree it doesn't suit him.

  • shannon noll should've won, guy sebastian did nothing after he won aus idol, he has like 1 song and then nothing, shannon noll was making hits for a couple years after aus idol

  • @DarkFlaze true, but guy went over seas to expand his carrer and reach further than our boarders, where as shannon hasnt done anything other than sing in random pubs and make an idiot out of himself.. Guy has had numerous hits since winning, i think the Australian public made the right decision :)

  • @DarkFlaze are you serious? Guy sebastian has make heaps o hits and has released plenty of albums!! Guy Sebastian has gone so far in the last couple of years

  • Shannon Noll did a very good job in here

  • it's far to pussy for shannon.. A gorgeous rock voice like that... I am glad he didn't win only because he didn't have to go on and release that shit song.. He is soo much better then guy and HOT

  • Amen to that. Proves Australian Idol means nothing, you dont need to win it to become successful. He's 100000 x better than Guy

  • liammolloy123 I think you must be on some drug because that is the only part I could understand in your post. Maybe you should proof read before posting and spell check.

  • oi bekayelle guy is way better than shannon noll omg y did guy win u never hear off shannon any more but guy like it like that is been top 1 in 5 months so yeea i dnt no what drugs ur on but phhhh GUYS AWSOME

  • @liammolloy123 well said, i agree :)

  • Whoa, crap! I've never seen this...

  • Guy sang this song better live than shannon at finals...shannon struggled with the high notes.

    Guy is a more versatile singer.

  • i lve shannon noll .. great singer .. i like this song .. its so beautiful .. xx

  • such a better version

  • pretty much the same video with guy???? huh???

  • i like shannon. Guy is no wherre as talented as shannon (=

  • I was voting for Shannon that year....but I must admit that Guy Sebastian sings this better!! Not really suited for Shannon! But his songs afterwards on the charts were awesome!! Shannon rocks!!

  • i like his voice better then guys and i like anthony then kate then jessica then matt then chrislyn other people i liked where guy casey natalie ricke lee carl jacob brooke and mark da costa

  • i love this song and his voice. i love his version.

  • he makes me hard

  • who started this song him or guy sebastian?

  • it was the final song for the first Australian idol.. So both of them performed it..

  • dang - this is awful.

  • woah, never heard this smooth side of his voice, except in the album version of shine, love it

  • I definitely like Guy's version better.

  • Kinda disappointed. His voice is good, and there were good parts to the performance, but it wasn't a good song for him.

    Also, I'm a little disappointed with the video concept. Its the exact same as Guy's. I mean, seriously, be creative people!

  • there was only ever going to be the one video with the one guy. so why bother creating two separate videos?

  • sparkleandshine there has been no cancellations to any shows, don't know where you got that wrong info from and he has added more next year in Queensland and Victoria so no problems there. Oh and why are you trying to slander him so much did he run over your dog or something?

  • this song doesn't suit him...

    go shannon!!

  • THIS song DOESN"T SUIT HIM HUH!!! Where the

    f ****** hell are you proposing  HE GO???.. Some dirtbags have bno idea of real talent!!!

  • wtf ur problem man? i didnt say it was bad. i said it didnt suit him.

  • I agree with you sunclose..its very bad and as for record and ticket sales..they are doing very badly for him..ive read some place he had to cancell a show coz he didnt enough to do a show. I say hasbeen...

  • Sparklieandshine is a guy fan. Why do so many guy fans leave such nasty comments on Shan's videos?

  • this version's like of the 80's. i mean his voice sounds like that. LOL

  • ok. im sorry. he sang in a hi register on the second part.

  • the song's really not for him.

    his register for the second verse went lower.

    u can notice also by comparing it to Guy's part by part.

    I just don't know why he sang it higher on the first part.

    :]

  • like he's singing in a higher register than Guy. u can hear it in the short interlude.

  • goosebumps!!!!! aw!!!

  • I really like this version, I like Guys version as well but I preferred this one at the time... Vocal Gymnastics dont always impress me. I preferred Guy as a singer, damn we spent enuf money voting for him, lol, I just like what Shannon did with this...I think Carrie Underwood would have been better off trying to sing this version, its more her style and range....

  • I guess both singles have their ups and downs, he has the sort of rock, barnsey sort of voice and it it great. On the other hand, guy sebastian did it alot more smoother and more vocal gymnastics. :D

  • This is one of his best songs ever and me & Susan are using this song as our wedding song we will marry to a great song by a great singer and if i could have him there on the day to sing it i would and i would not have any one else sing it but him, To my beautiful Susan i love you sweet heart forever yours my love xoxoxooxoxoxooxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo­xoxoxoxox

  • That is a very bad version of a great song. Shannon does not have the vocal skills to pull off a song like this. The actual released one by Guy Sebastian is soooooooooooooooooo much better.

  • There you go again!!!

  • Shannon IS better! Just ask Australia! He's kicked his backside in record sales and concert tickets! Go to guys videos and comment on how great you think he is there!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more