OXFORD UNION 1

[MaoistLeninistMarx]

“Throughout this whole struggle, we Black students at the school had been ardent supporters of the position of Stalin and the Central Committee. Most certainly we were Stalinists – whose policies we saw as the continuation of Lenin’s. Those today who use the term “Stalinist” as an epithet evade the real question: that is, were Stalin and the Central Committee correct? I believe history has proven that they were correct.” – Harry Haywood

[MaoistLeninistMarx]

Stalinist victory!!!

[yington]

This man is a complete and utter fruitcake.

He has made the CPGB-ML into a mouthpiece for the most totalitarian, unfree nation of North Korea, whereby the population are trapped in a prison from which:

-They have absolutely no freedom of speech

-No free media

-Punishes you if you say anything against the regime

-People cannot leave North Korea for a holiday,or chance to see anywhere else in the world

He has a nice free comfy life in England, and uses it to defend sheer tyranny.

[kotlilohara]

u r great brar saab..

[katalina125]

His comments at the end are so funny because they are so true: we drink something and it's owned by a monopoly, we go to bed and it is produced by a monopoly, we die after serving our whole life to the system and we are buried in a casket produced by a monopoly. Sounds like a good sicence fiction movie or a book but in reality it is for most of the time the lives we live, the lives we are used to living, what we accept as normal, that that we might think it works, it makes an interesting life.

[COMMUNISTGUERRILLA92]

leon trotsky a sexist lying trecherous bastard.

[wblakesx]

MONOPOLY or fief?

[amsterdam78]

Leon Trotsky: Hero, Martyr, husband, father

[wvprogressive1933]

Leon Trotsky: Asshole.

[amsterdam78]

@wvprogressive1933 You can't attack his theory, so you use an Ad Hom attack.

[ourhandsaretied]

@amsterdam78

Oh yeah, and "hero, martyr, husband, father" is so much more detailed and precise.... o_O

[amsterdam78]

@amsterdam78 Stalinist scum, move to Russia, he still has friends there. Outside of a few gits in GB.

[KenTelevision]

What could be contradictory to global unity than lies and selfish hoarding. Capitalism contradicts natural human want and need therefore it's inherently harmful and filled with even more bullshit and lies; example Bosses who refuse to pay a higher wage saying "Without me and my money no one lives." When of coarse people struggle to afford food and/or housing on those wages. And a large portion of the world yes even the USA still live as subsistence farmers ranchers ect.

[2possi]

I find it difficult to understand his Broken English but the bits that i can make out are absolute utter rubbish ther is no ideology as contradictive and floored as communism. I cant believe people are still trying to keep this marxist bullshit alive.

[KenTelevision]

Oh another anti-communist with no logical argument. Do some actual current economic research 2possi. Clearly you have no Idea the hardship and irrational fear and antagonism the majority of people face in all capitalist nations in the labor force now a days. No I don't mean people sitting behind a Desk. I mean Physical laborers! Not to mention the inevitable massive financial collapse the Capital-System is headed toward that you Pro-Bourgeoisie don't even mention and pretend doesn't exist!

[jumpnjza2]

He probably speaks better English than you, moron.

[moronchicken]

He is brilliant. You are a fool. You will be crushed under the heal of the worker.

[2possi]

Bullshit communism is 100% over finished it was tried and tested Russia had over 80 years to prove the ideals of communism they failed and were left playing catch up with the rest of the world FACT

[moronchicken]

No...Bullshit on your behalf. The Soviet Union was almost 150 years behind America after the October Revolution of 1917. YES ALMOST 150 years!!!!!! In just 50 years, they had "caught up" and SURPASSED the west in all aspects of industrial production with SOCIALIST ECONOMICS in the forefront for the vast majority of those years. Look at their space program! You're telling me that America got a 150 year head start?????? They are virtually identical. So much for your "catch up" argument.. Too easy.

[ProletarianCPGBML]

Well - we love it!

Brar's contribution is broad in its scope and unanswerable in its logic - which is why communism's critics avoid logic at all costs!

For, as the capitalist's most frank spokesmen admit: " the greatest enemy of the lie is the truth, and by extension, the greatest enemy of the state is the truth"

Hasta La victoria!

Prol

CPGB-ML

[ivanmakar12]

It is silly to talk about yourself in the third person, Harpal. Your arguments are bizarre and divorced from the daily material experiences of workingmen and women. You are also a wealthy hypocrite who exploits Kashmiri peasants.

[TrueCommunist]

From what I read, what, majority of people are posting, I presume that reading Robert Conquest digests create unified front of facts concerning Soviet Union history. And we all know where those facts originate - Propagandaministerium.

Being confined in totalitarian paradigm, is very sad confinement from the perspective of the progressive people.

For a person of 69 years, comrade Harpal Brar is 'holding his line' flawlessly for his age. We just hope there are many more people like him in UK.

[MarxBakuninMe]

Harpal Brar? Not the most likable person on the left . . .

[simplex555]

Nor the brightest. This mentalist thinks the Holmodovar was all made up and Katyn wasn't the work of Stalin. He's either delusional or a half wit. My money is on the latter.

[MarxBakuninMe]

My moneys on both!

[reabhloiddearg]

Good bit of slander. How about addressing the argument not attacking the person?

[MarxBakuninMe]

Try dabbling in a bit of history. Brar's other group (The Stalin Society) has articles denying Holodomor. But hey, I guess know it was all propaganda created by Trotzkyists (uh . . . I mean fascists).

[reabhloiddearg]

Brilliant. Read dabbling in a bit of history yourself. I admit, the Stalin Society pamplets are not the best but their arugments can be backed by sources - particularly the work on Katyn and the Holdomor.

[MarxBakuninMe]

Oh and I agree that capitalism won't "save the world". But then neither will the CPGB-ML's Stalinist totalitarian nightmare.

[reabhloiddearg]

Good use of vocabulary there. I think we need to address the political line of Harpal Brar and CPGB-ML instead of slapping on labels.

[OxfordUnion2008]

ANd who are YOU?

[MarxBakuninMe]

Who exactly wants to know, Mr. Oxbridge?

[jackmstephens]

I believe Mr. Oxbridge wants to know.

[MarxBakuninMe]

ya ya ya