Added: 5 years ago
From: alwaysbfly
Views: 49,757
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (147)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • sooooo 90s lol love it

  • i dont think its lipped, i think the picture and sound are not playing at the same rate

  • mariah the queen of the micromini dress....and divas dnt dance they glide...

  • I like this song!~

  • my word show me a sexier woman than this . wow she looks AMAZING here. mmmmmmm mmmmm

  • definitely not lip syncing . she is singing, without a doubt. 

  • @MyBoobie11 It's lipped.

  • Ela deveria liberar a versao completa dessa performance ao vivo.. mais ta showw MARIAH COMO SEMPRE A MELHOR

  • this song gives me a feeling that i can't explain and i feel like im about to explode! this is somehow so emotional to me!

  • Hey, I love song, I'll be covering it soon! She looks so pretty here! Check out some of my covers when you have some time. People say I sound similar to Mariah, Leona, Kelly Clarkson, and a few others. I guess it depends which songs I'm singing. I really love Mariah's songs though, so I'll be recording more of them soon. If you have any requests, let me know, I have most of them on karaoke/instrumental now! :)

    Crystal

  • I like the long thick curly hair:P

  • sexiest mariah's song...

  • it doesnt matter if its lipped or not cos i sill love her!

  • it doesnt matter if its lipped or not cos i sill love her!

  • She's very beautiful in this performance ... I love her curly hair!!

  • Everyone always thinks she's lip syncing, but if you know her ability you know she is just that good. It's the honest truth. She was blessed with an amazing talent and she can pull it off live as well as (and sometimes better than) she did on the studio recording.

  • vieo is not synced, but this is live.

  • such a nice video<3

  • ive been a fan since 1990 and this is a lypsync performance...sound like the album version

    fkl

  • I like her, but for fucks sake!! this is fucking lipped!!

    I think it's really unfair for those people who paid a high price for the entrance.

  • Lipped.

  • I´m impressed by her beauty

  • this is live..it'a ALMOST exactly like the rack but not quite..she's just that good

  • Mariah Carey is Rojo Caliente.....HOT!!!

  • i wanna be the dancer

  • the butterfly era was the best cause, her voice was perfect, her body, her face, her songs were amazing, really cool. like honey, besides she has ballads like whenever you call, an amazing song, which songdogs from asia wants to sing but they cant

  • @tian2009 i agree.

  • @tian2009 you're insulting the dogs by calling them songdogs lol.

  • i discovered mariah at the butterfly era, so for me, that was the coolest era ever... of mariah

  • Mariah was so fierce at the Butterfly era

  • wth are yall talking about she's not even dancing ya are a bunch of haterz people just cant be happy for others anymore she is sucessful happily married and accomplish her goal and guess what she dont give a rats behind about you haterz so it's time to migrate bye lmbo

  • and shes still so successful after 2 decades.. legend. she doesnt need to do it like some singers who had to stay relevant by copying pop stars like Britney and Madonna. We know that singer yells a lot in her songs as well lol

  • She's a SINGer therefor her job is to sing and she's doing it more than well!

  • yo mama cn dance like that biatch so shut up mariah is sexy she don't need to listen a poor woman like u

  • i really like this jam.. too bad this is like the only live performance ive ever seen of it

  • i love it. i love this song

  • U guys are haters she is such a gd performance.. and its not lipped!

    So go write ur dumbness elsewhere haters!!

  • i think this is one of her best songs, instead of over obsessing a ballad its simple and goes back to basic styles of rnb

  • No one can. She is a singer first so why bother dance.

  • There was a full version of this performance that was on here but idk what happened to it.

  • ur all stupid !it's live with a strong backing...it's shows ya;'ll dunno shit about music!u cant tell from miles it's live!

  • lipped

  • this performance is live, any true mariah fan would know that, as to those who were arguing that she was better in butterfly/daydream era everyone has their own musical preferences and lets not forget, daydream came out in 95 and butterfly came out in 97. Mariahs voice and musical style changed within that time. my personal favorite is butterfly tho.

  • its lipped lol

  • What is live in this performance,LMAO?

    First of all it does sound too perfect to be real live, it's studio quality.

    After it's exactly the studio version.........

    And yes in live she was wayyyyy better during Daydream.

  • I agree

  • she is singing very the same as the cd version!

    it can't be live

  • Look those legs!!! What a beautiful woman!!! And of course the best voice ever

  • Mariah is the best singer and if she had to lip to take a break who cares....instead of Mariah fans debating on something so STUPID....I would like to point out that alot of Mariah haters say she can't dance and this is one of the many video's that prove she can. Why isn't anyone talking about that???

  • they only say she can't dance because most of the time she doesn't try to. she pulled off a perfectly good routine on her butterfly tour for the fantasy remix!

  • I agree and she did good with Honey and The So So Def Remix of My All on the Soul Train Awards.

  • Actually after watching this again, it is live.

  • No, u can tell at 0:34-0:36 that it's lipped, when she's singing "youuuu" on the last "you" she starts lipping "last night". But I'm glad theres atleast some footage of this cause The Roof is my favorite song by her.

  • Pay more attention you will notice that bits of it are live. Mariah was at her best vocally at this point. The vocal problems didn't start till like 1999. Some may be lipped but she was definitely singing live regardless of what was on the speakers.

  • U must be deaf. She was better during the Daydream Tour cause she could hit high notes and she brought her own flavor. Her vocal problems started towards the end of 1998 i.e. : Her performance at the Soul Train Awards of The So So Def Remix of My All. She could barely hit the same notes as the recorded version. It's sad cause you look at singers like Coko from SWV and she still can sing notes that she sang in songs earlier in her career.

  • I think there were many out there that must agree. The song "Butterfly" is Mariah's best vocally. Go and listen to Celine you fool. During the Butterfly Mariah could transcend into lower and higher registers so easily. It blended so well together. Her voice simply changed. I have been a Mariah fan all my life so I think I should know a thing or two. You are just some dumb shit. Deaf? is that the best you can come up with. She couldn't get anymore pop during the Daydream era.

  • She also had much more creative control on Butterfly. Many fans agree that Butterfly was her best record lyrically and vocally. So don't slam opinions down just because your opinion is different. Try maturing a bit you fool.

  • You not only deaf your blind. I said she sounded better during the Daydream Era. I don't know why you went on a tangent about things that don't pertain to what I said. I could careless how long you were a Mariah fan, your still an ass. If I feel like saying something you're powerless 2 stop me.

  • Well so will I considering you replied to me in the first place. Hypocrite. Idiot.

  • Yea cause you were wrong she'll always sound better in the Daydream Era then during the Butterfly Era. Get your head out your ass.

  • What is Daydream?

  • her album! lol. the best album in the world!

  • The name of 1 of Mariah's cds. Fantasy, One Sweet Day, and Always Be My Baby are from that album.

  • I thought it was a celine album -_- ....

  • @JamaicanFlava Daydream..That was easy!!

  • I think that overall she was better vocally during Daydream. Her timbre was at its best and she could hit notes with more ease. Her voice became a bit more coarse during Butterfly, although her riffs got better. After 1996, her performances started getting a little less perfect.

  • I agree

  • @Enticingmami0813 You call that dancing!!!...

  • yea if u can do better post a video....otherwise stfu

  • I'm so glad she's done with the micro mini dress phase.....

  • i like mariah..

    but i miss her

    back in the day

    (:

    one of my fav songs

  • How can you call yourself a true mimi fan/ or fans... It was soooo lipped... but we love her all the same! :)

  • as far as i can tell either she was having very good vocals that night or she was singing along to her own track but I can hear she is singing live.

  • the video is off with the music, but she is not lypsinching, the song sounds different in the album, only a true fan knows

  • does it really matter if she lipped it or not? As long as shes singing the freakin song , i doesnt matter ! XD

  • I beleive the VDO CLIP we saw was LIVE

    BUT the SONG we listened is from CDs

    HOPE THIS IS CLEAR

  • It is sooooo lipped, come on now song's exactly like the CD she shouldn't of done that her voice back then was phenomenal, it's kinda lazy of her.

  • not lazy she had 12 other songs to sing this concert and probably performing tomorrow and the day after........her songs are not buit for anyone sing to that many times.....way too much range and high degree of difficult to balance all the registers.....her head voice her chest her mixed voiced and that extremely high register. no one one can sing her songs repetitively. don't even say beyonce cuz her songs don't have that much range

  • You know what, sis? Your right! Don't worry I won't even think about comparing her to Beyonce.

  • THAT WOULD be like comparing Aretha Franklin to Britney Spears

  • lol. beyonce is over-rated! Shaking your ass only gets you far.

  • "It was lipped" THIS WAS 1997, NOT 2008, YOU DORKS!

  • 1998

  • you stupid mariah fans who call themselves mariah fans saying this isn't lipsynched should shut up.

    god. how can you say she's not lipping? idiots. haven't you heard this track on tha cd? jesus.

    one thing i can't stand are other mariah fans who don't know sh*t. stop defending this vid. she's not singing live!

  • uhmm .. im gunna say that im a huge mariah fan. and even though i said before that she wasnt lip synching .. im gunna have to change that and say that she is. im probably just tired of everyone saying thats shes ALWAYS lipping it.

    i wont change the fact that shes a phenomenal singer though ;)

  • Looks to me like its lipped. But so what?! Whats the point about discussing in every Mariah video if its lipped or not? She dont have to proove that she can sing, everbody who isnt deaf knows that she can.

  • ok look All true mariah fans can instantly tell shes lipping the song yea... for the so called fans who say shes not lipping arent true mariah fans... so the real fans are the ones who know so dont blame us :D

  • you're right, this is lipped.

    I'm not gonna lie to myself about this.

  • It's not lipped. Its an old cassette tape recording and the audio doesn't match the video. That's why it looks off. I'm a Mimi fan and I can tell when she's really singing or not.

  • The song is one of Mariah's masterpieces

  • yes it is

  • Agreed. No other song like it.

  • oh damn yes! I don't even know why it is my fave beside WBT. it's amazing!

  • had it ever occured to you that this part of the song is really easy to sing for mariah , and since she doesnt really use computer stuff to aid her voice on the cds, ESPECIALLY back then , so she isnt lipsynching .. it just sounds the same because she is a phenonmenal singer.

  • As much as I love MC,she is lipping this song,which is my favourite,they just turned up her vocals,and turned down the rest :(

    Nevertheless she is fantastic

  • i very love her hair and her voice she's very beautiful

  • ITS LIVE!!

  • I LOVE MARIAH...and im SO GLAD she has a lil rhythm now cuz her and the dancers lQQked a mess lol...

  • this is lipped but why does it sound diff from the original cd version?

  • for a live effect.

  • Wow.. mariah looks so beautiful here. Yeah I love her curly hair. She also looks gorgeous and very sexy in that dress!! Love this song soooo much

  • I Love u MARIAH!! YOU ARE THE BEST!!!

  • Loooosssseeeerrrrss!!!! that was not lipsynced the words she's singing is live. The ones yous are talking about are the recorded ones off her album as she uses it as backup!

  • It's just the album version vocals.. how anyone could be naive enough to think this is sung live is beyond me.

  • yeah i kno she needs it alwase to be curly.

  • She looks beautiful here...i love her hair curly.

  • Get it!

  • lol why is she smackin her ass?

  • i lovee this songg !!!!

  • ya'll is hella stupid!! she's not lipping it!! the video is just off by like 3seconds!!! Dumb asses!!

  • She is lip-syncing. I have the completely video on my computer. This is the only performance she lipped at that concert.

  • She also lip-synched Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix), Honey and Babydoll (Japan) from this tour. The hip-hop songs.

  • At this same concert or on the tour? I don't remember her doing any more at this concert. I'll have to look at my other videos. BTW I accidently mark your comment as spam.

  • The audio is lagging because it doesn't do that on my video.

  • jamaican you fucking moron , yes she's lipping but you're an idiot for thinking that she was SO bad at it lmao it's the video and audio not being in sync you dumb bastard rofl

  • I never said nothing about it being so bad cause I like this performance. Damn I must care wat somebody I don't kno thinx about me. Next time write without dick in ya brains.

  • this aint sung live at all. not even the background vocals

  • thank you so much!!! and too bad she lyp sanc it =[

  • wow...

  • this is not lipsynched..well at least not the first 30 seconds..cuz those were different..very rare!!do u have breakdown from this tour??

  • you are probably a new mariah fan. You should learn more about her.

  • this aint sung live at all. not even the background vocals

  • I can't STAND LIVE background vocals!!! They sound awful. Mariah always had Melody, Trey, even Kelly Price has sung background for her, her background vocals are too important for anyone to be singing them live so I rather the deathtrack, or Debra Killings=the best background singer.

  • GORGEOUS doesn't begin to describe how good she looks in this video..

  • That wasn't live:p

  • Do you have the entire version?

    It's a lil bit boring that the sound is late from the image...

  • damn rarity!!!

    She is so gracious, and the guy who is dancing with her is so hot... LOL!

    Sensual song, one of my favorites too...

    And HER... THE VOICE... :)

  • damn rarity!!!

    She is so gracious, and the guy who is dancing with her is so hot... LOL!

    Sensual song, one of my favorites too...

    And HER... THE VOICE... :)

  • YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

    thank you so fuckin much!

    really appreciate this song and i never knew she sang it live in butterfly tour.

    thanx a lot

  • THere's another recorder(fan recorded)performance from some other concert from the Tour.Baaaad quality

  • okay...

  • she was killin it..lol

  • This is GREAT and really rare. Where'd you get it and do you have anymore from that concert, I'd love to see Breakdown. If you have anymore, please post, on behalfof all of us.

  • She looks so beautiful here. I wish she could of sung this live though, as this is my very favourite song of hers the lyrics are amazing.

  • this was acctualy during the butterfly tour, but never released or anything, so that makes this very rare!!!

  • thx a lot~ I wish I could see it in taipei~ GREAT! Can i have the video?

  • damn this is rare...great post

  • she`s so cute you kilt it mariah!

  • I love this song. Actually every song off of Butterfly are amazing.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more