It was really, really good.. intonation and vibrato was perfect. But the song is not that fast! And you're a little to harsh, and watch out on tempo changes, this is a very dramatic and beautiful song <3
You might try using third position instead of open strings more often. This would make the sound much more gentle. I mean, your intonation is pretty good, but to me it sounds a bit too harsh. I kind of miss the soul in it.
When I learn a new song I like to follow your videos to listen to them, other wise my choices are bad vids of whole orchestras and im not a whole orchestra, just one violin ;) but like heartsxteselate mentioned could you do a remake please :) same reasons :)
a little to fast do it with more emotions trust me the begining more giry like and the other part even more girly like so it sounds good then the other part mor rough but expresion emotions and use vibrato more
The first two lines and all of the portions that are similar to it, you should play more at the balance point and then go back to the frog for the second portion, like it says right there in the book.
good attempt, now try it at a broader pace ! also, taste the delight in the final note of each melodic sentence - no need to rush, let the music breathe with you !
is that violin full size?. Remember Romantic....dvorak!!! also try and lower your right arm when on a down bow it wont sound as screetchy good luck and happy playing!!!
a few suggestions, play it a tad slower and with a metronome because you have a tendency to rush. also, practice it slower so you can really hear your intonation because it can still be much better. last one, play it more in a romantic style because dvorak is romantic.
you have a great tone, and i can tell you have confidence. you're a good violinist, keep it up!
Agreed. it's a bit slower than this man, but other than going a bit fast you are an amazing Violinist (of course you probably already know this). I love this piece, it's one of my favorites, not only to listen to but also to play :)
I have to agree with some of these folks. This isn't the best I've seen from you. I'd really like to watch a remake of this, because I know you can play very well!
@violinspieler It's been a year, did you ever do a remake? Lol, sry, not important, was just reading comments and it made me wonder :p Nice song though bro :)
Chromatican- Well that wasn't very nice. You know, if you're going to insult someone, you might want to spell correctly, hm? Or do the rules of the English language not apply to you, your Royal Intonation-ness?
*Sticks nose in the air* D-i-s-g-u-s-t-i-n-g. Please learn to type...
..il violino e' lo strumento piu' bello del mondo..ma la tua musica non ha emozione..e il tempo troppo veloce ti guasta tutta l'esecuzione..alcune note sono troppo veloci..alcune le tieni troppo a lungo...
when you play the 16th notes play it little slower and after the 16th note whre you play the long note, that not is actually a lot longer so hold on. I remember it being about 6-8 beats.
Pues poco a poco se anda el camino. No está mal si corrieras menos sobre todo en la primera parte. Supongo que la coloratura vendrá mas tarde. ¡Animo!
Do you have the music or are you just playing by ear? A lot of notes are slurred that you didn't slur, and some of the notes you didn't hold out long enough. And maybe more dramatic dynamics would be nice. Your intonation and vibrato are very nice, though!
this piece is suppose to skip and tra la la XD so the tempo is slow but it has a fast feeling to it, your tempo is fast and has a fast feeling to it. if you listen to the piano play it (one by golden homes or golden piano one of those has a great track on it) you can hear what i'm talking about
I like using this song for it's 3rd position shifting exercises. I can't wait for the day when I'm good enough to play the real (non-suzuki arranged) version.
Your tempo is too fast and you dont hold some of the notes long and at .41 there is a dramatic change of the tempo so try to make it the same tempo. Overall it was great.
really good overall. Whatch your tempo though, you're rushing in the begining and not holding out the half long enough. Also watch the accidentals. And lastly make sure your fourth finger is in tune with your open strings. Good job!
ViolinSpieler, good job overall and excellent job paying attention to intonation. By the way, you make a good point when you said you really enjoyed practicing it. Although I'm not a fan of the Suzuki Method, I believe it allows students to enjoy making "real music" while they are building technique. Just don't forget about Sevcik and Kreutzer, and you'll be just fine!
i really enjoy this song. i am learning to play the violin and i am going to present my first recital this november 17, i am kind of nervous but your video helps me a lottttt thank youu. i hope i play well as you.
In my book it is written with shifts to 3rd position
holdtheburger 3 days ago
I am playing that song
slowbravo 3 weeks ago
It was really, really good.. intonation and vibrato was perfect. But the song is not that fast! And you're a little to harsh, and watch out on tempo changes, this is a very dramatic and beautiful song <3
bluegirl123321 8 months ago
You might try using third position instead of open strings more often. This would make the sound much more gentle. I mean, your intonation is pretty good, but to me it sounds a bit too harsh. I kind of miss the soul in it.
PhioIine 9 months ago
love this song!!!!!!
nemynemy123 11 months ago
Comment removed
dunavbalkan 11 months ago
even though its fast its still good i really like this song it has like a good to sad then good feel to it something like that
egoy115 11 months ago
too fast
bobhead71 11 months ago
hey why the begining so fast -_-
trandvinh 1 year ago
When I learn a new song I like to follow your videos to listen to them, other wise my choices are bad vids of whole orchestras and im not a whole orchestra, just one violin ;) but like heartsxteselate mentioned could you do a remake please :) same reasons :)
rowan729 1 year ago
Dude, you're out of tune sometimes
ElPsicoProfeta0993 1 year ago
ya, its way to fast, no feeling, you should here itzhak perlman. you could get a lot of tips. but im sure you didnt have a lot of time to do it.
duranceau951 1 year ago
a little to fast do it with more emotions trust me the begining more giry like and the other part even more girly like so it sounds good then the other part mor rough but expresion emotions and use vibrato more
amandasshorty 1 year ago
The first two lines and all of the portions that are similar to it, you should play more at the balance point and then go back to the frog for the second portion, like it says right there in the book.
MAkAylAxJoRdaN 1 year ago
its a good vid but just a littel earatting with the weird noises in the background
fnufs 1 year ago
The piece isnt folk, play it softer and really hold out those long notes. I would like to see a remake as well.
vitalsuccess 1 year ago
This video has an awesome violin player. Very proffessional. Why doesn't he go on concerts.
pooper228 1 year ago
Play slower but other than that good vibrato!!
listen to Perlman's version to hear a great interpreation
Oiiix3 1 year ago
you do this WAY TOO FAST and then you slow down ??? keep a STEADY PACE....but you sound pretty good
kaitlinmichelleshow 1 year ago
good attempt, now try it at a broader pace ! also, taste the delight in the final note of each melodic sentence - no need to rush, let the music breathe with you !
Tovify 1 year ago
too fast?!?!
RyanSimpson09 2 years ago
is that violin full size?. Remember Romantic....dvorak!!! also try and lower your right arm when on a down bow it wont sound as screetchy good luck and happy playing!!!
localbayboy 2 years ago
a few suggestions, play it a tad slower and with a metronome because you have a tendency to rush. also, practice it slower so you can really hear your intonation because it can still be much better. last one, play it more in a romantic style because dvorak is romantic.
you have a great tone, and i can tell you have confidence. you're a good violinist, keep it up!
mystyksylence 2 years ago 2
I have an Master" Gebhruder Schuster for sale, if anybodys interested... manuf. about 1892 -1920
fiddlnbanjo 2 years ago
Agreed. it's a bit slower than this man, but other than going a bit fast you are an amazing Violinist (of course you probably already know this). I love this piece, it's one of my favorites, not only to listen to but also to play :)
sheila0brckn 2 years ago
please, where can i find the sheet music for this without purchasing the book? i'm trying to write it out by ear and its not exactly easy.
jocelyneskennedy 2 years ago
hey...tune your violin :) please...and play it slower...
vagabonda1982 2 years ago 4
I have to agree with some of these folks. This isn't the best I've seen from you. I'd really like to watch a remake of this, because I know you can play very well!
heartsxtesselate 2 years ago
Thanks, I will try a remake... but it will take it's time ;-)
violinspieler 2 years ago
You should! It will be great.
heartsxtesselate 2 years ago
@violinspieler It's been a year, did you ever do a remake? Lol, sry, not important, was just reading comments and it made me wonder :p Nice song though bro :)
alazaruso117 1 year ago
Try a metronome
thecanadian13 2 years ago
Watch the tempo you tend to change it if you get a little more baroke
ethrisbeam 2 years ago
I played that song when i was 10.... But i still love it!
pinkstuff321 2 years ago
kittycat
watch that tempo : P
jfgelber 2 years ago 2
slow down. hold sum notes out for feeling.
rsluvr123 2 years ago 4
watch ur tempo, intonation and try playing this piece using the 3rd postion as well. check ur phrasing too
spongeprince123 2 years ago
good vibrato :) haha. slow down a bit :)
m2komgr 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Disguisting. Please tune your violin...
Chromatican 2 years ago
Chromatican- Well that wasn't very nice. You know, if you're going to insult someone, you might want to spell correctly, hm? Or do the rules of the English language not apply to you, your Royal Intonation-ness?
*Sticks nose in the air* D-i-s-g-u-s-t-i-n-g. Please learn to type...
RosesSontRouges 2 years ago 6
..il violino e' lo strumento piu' bello del mondo..ma la tua musica non ha emozione..e il tempo troppo veloce ti guasta tutta l'esecuzione..alcune note sono troppo veloci..alcune le tieni troppo a lungo...
vagabonda1982 2 years ago 3
ei. si hai arragione, pero e bene lo steso.
m2komgr 2 years ago
excuse me,
but I got a just a little comment
when you play the 16th notes play it little slower and after the 16th note whre you play the long note, that not is actually a lot longer so hold on. I remember it being about 6-8 beats.
stylecine 2 years ago 2
this sounds so beautiful! check sandimommy's youtube account: she has a 3 year old son, Ethan, playing the exact same song!
ThirdEyeAbility 2 years ago
Please, more slowly. Thanks.
Lou77211 2 years ago
Pues poco a poco se anda el camino. No está mal si corrieras menos sobre todo en la primera parte. Supongo que la coloratura vendrá mas tarde. ¡Animo!
Kantari100 2 years ago
PORQ LO HACES TAN RAPIDO!!!
eugegerhardt 2 years ago
pretty good. but slow down it's not the marathon. =0
narutofreakten 2 years ago
dynamics dynamics dynamics..but overall very good xD
sharon4773 2 years ago
Do you have the music or are you just playing by ear? A lot of notes are slurred that you didn't slur, and some of the notes you didn't hold out long enough. And maybe more dramatic dynamics would be nice. Your intonation and vibrato are very nice, though!
evell247 2 years ago 2
plus hes playing too fast...
tenjinnim 2 years ago
the vibrato is really good with his pinky.
MMstir 2 years ago
Esta muy bien, pero hay algo rigido en este metodo, falta expresion.
chosman74 2 years ago
me gusta mas con expression
narutofreakten 2 years ago
this piece is suppose to skip and tra la la XD so the tempo is slow but it has a fast feeling to it, your tempo is fast and has a fast feeling to it. if you listen to the piano play it (one by golden homes or golden piano one of those has a great track on it) you can hear what i'm talking about
iplehguitar 2 years ago 3
O O V
very good
ll19980408 2 years ago
can you play this song a nyssma? what level?
dylan123sassone 2 years ago
I like using this song for it's 3rd position shifting exercises. I can't wait for the day when I'm good enough to play the real (non-suzuki arranged) version.
freeyourcrt 2 years ago
Im almost there! Istn ur b-day coming up. I know becuz like last year ur b-day was like right after mine.
8violin8 2 years ago 4
im 10 yrs old and im gona play this song im just surfing to see what it sounds like xD
YellowLemonJuice 3 years ago 3
Your tempo is too fast and you dont hold some of the notes long and at .41 there is a dramatic change of the tempo so try to make it the same tempo. Overall it was great.
Kritcal 3 years ago 11
really good overall. Whatch your tempo though, you're rushing in the begining and not holding out the half long enough. Also watch the accidentals. And lastly make sure your fourth finger is in tune with your open strings. Good job!
123rock333 3 years ago 2
i am working on thjis piece it is out of tune at spots but great overall
themomo1993 3 years ago 2
i will be playing this piece for my solo. and i am learning from him. but i think he goes 2 fast in the beginnning
norahrocks01 3 years ago 3
Soo schöne Noten KANN man gar nicht verschandeln! Spitze Mann!!! *****
Bierhirn 3 years ago
very nice :D
you can slow down on the opening theme though =]
ethiopianSoul 3 years ago 2
ViolinSpieler, good job overall and excellent job paying attention to intonation. By the way, you make a good point when you said you really enjoyed practicing it. Although I'm not a fan of the Suzuki Method, I believe it allows students to enjoy making "real music" while they are building technique. Just don't forget about Sevcik and Kreutzer, and you'll be just fine!
OnAMushkin73 3 years ago 2
I like how this is one of those pieces where it's a bit different for every person playing it.
;D
whoryhobopowers 3 years ago
:) great job
I'm working on this piece too, and I really appreciate you posting this video, gives me an example to play to ^^
Lavendar770 3 years ago
hey dude!1 play more slow enjoy it.. this song it's amazing..
i play too.. i liked so much!!..
enjoy it..
kaarmaa 3 years ago
i really enjoy this song. i am learning to play the violin and i am going to present my first recital this november 17, i am kind of nervous but your video helps me a lottttt thank youu. i hope i play well as you.
maryix 3 years ago
for me it's played too fast and too mechanic (if such word exists in eng ;p) it's very emotional piece and for me you play it like an etiude...
ladyMandrake 3 years ago
This was always my favorite Book 3 song. So fun and bouncy. :-D
NinjaNutsCheese 3 years ago
gah.
I couldn't play this song if my life depended on it.
SNAILSxROCK 3 years ago
Heel mooi!
suzannetaa 3 years ago
I tried playing this song the cello.
its looks easier on the voilin. To me anyway.
Soulkid3 3 years ago
Terrific performance! The dynamics are spot on. I'm working on this song now so I really appreciate you putting your video up here.
Paisleyxy 3 years ago 7
Thanks, I wish you a lot of fun with this piece. I really enjoyed practicing it and I love to play it. This piece is great :-)
violinspieler 3 years ago
Thanks! Please see my extended comment.
OnAMushkin73 3 years ago 2
Great performance!! you´re very expressive. :)
mikel204z 3 years ago 3
thank you very much and thanks for your video response. nice to hear your version, which is very different from mine.
violinspieler 3 years ago
hey that's great!, but some parts are litle faster. :) but you are great!
michellerua 4 years ago 3
Thanks, I like this parts a little dramatic ;-)
violinspieler 4 years ago
Haha, thought you where gonna start to dance at some point, GREAT!!
PressF5forHelp 4 years ago 2