Added: 5 years ago
From: youngslacker
Views: 94,925
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (149)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I just came

  • Why would someone dislike such an amazing performance....dumbasssssss

  • neil peart kind of looks like tom hanks here

  • ive been playing lots of jazz and i dont think neil peart is as good as i thot he was

    think through this with me,

    1 thing hes credtited for is odd times, but hes not a math rock drummer and there are way better math drummers

    2 like i dont ever hear him play any bebop, breakaway crazy ass buddy rich licks

    but he worships buddy rich

    this solo is really nothing to like the solos max roach and buddy rich play

    what do you think?

    please dont cuss me out

  • @showitormowit /watch?v=34_dTOK_2NY

  • neil peart is the best drummer ever he inspired me to drum

  • Me making childish remarks?? You're the one who told somebody to suck their mother's twat a few comments back. Fucking hypocrite

  • neil is a fucking master and could cook breakfast while drumming and still mop the floor with your skinny ass hero !! and what genre would that be you ignorant ass? punk ? he never was a real punk drummer..tre cool is a way better drummer than he is !! and has been at longer and is more popular and sold more records than skinny puppy there could ever fathom !! so take my adice you fucking waste of teenage skin...go and voice your opinion where it matters..to your mommy !!

  • I'm not a teenager fuckwad. You are the fucking pathetic waste of space my friend. Travis Barker is not my hero, but if he wasn't good he wouldn't have all those sponsors and get all the attention he gets. You are probably some old fuck who gets their rocks off by taking up for your favorite musician. Being a drummer myself I look up to percussion gods like Buddy Rich, Neil Peart, John Bonham, and Keith Moon. But I've seen some very impressive work done by Travis

  • if you like all these great drummers so much , as i do , why would you tell me to go and suck, peart's dick ?hmm?..seems to me you just put your fucking stinking foot in your your dirty mouth !! BARKER'S OVERRATED !!DEAL WITH IT !!! HE STINKS ,, DEAL WITH IT ..WHO CARES IF HE'S SOLD MILLIONS..AT BEST, HE GETS THE JOB DONE, NOTHING MORE..SO YOU CAN STOP WITH THE CHILDISH DICK SUCKING REMARKS..and don't bother responding..i'll just delete ur comment..

  • Travis is okay. He's not a very impressive drummer, he's about as good as all pop drummers today.

  • Travis Barker gets attention because of his looks, his punk hair, his collabos with rappers, and that's exactly what the industry wants, I respect Travis, Bonzo, Peart and all great drummers, but there's no point of comparision between Peart and Barker

  • geez calm down. he's not saying travis is a great drummer he's just saying that you should show him respect. i mean. he is the professional and all. and i'm guessing you aren't? anyways. so once you get sponsored and drum on tracks that sell millions you should take your opinion to where it matters...your mother!

    also don't get me wrong. that tattooed fart comes NOWHERE close to Rich, Peart, Bonham, Moon, and lots others.

  • I remember seeing this concert in

    tour around 87 been rush fan ever

    scince

  • go suck your mother's twat you useless sperm cell !!!!

  • you are nothing short of retarded !!!how old are youanyway ??15-16 yrs old.?? .you obviously have no musical tatse and are far from educated in the genre of percussion..travis barker is an overrated , pathetic excuse for a drummer if i ever seen one..he wishes he could play a fraction of what peart can do with his big toe, you ignorant fathead..go back to school or whatever it is that you do and don't waste peoples' time with your mediocre opinions if you're not professional drummer..

  • Heck anyone can play a drum solo with 65 skins and cymbals at their disposal..anyone!

  • lol

  • fuck you! Travis Barker is a self made drummer popular in a genre that is not known for producing great drummers. He can't touch Neil Peart, but show some fuckin respect

  • listen here you mom twat sucker !!you're probably not even a drummer so shut the fuck up and read on my junior friend..barker is nothing more than a clown who got extremely lucky...and no drummer ,and certainly not me, will ever show some respect to that ridiculous excuse of a drummer !! i've been playing for 30 yrs my ignorant friend , and could sweep the floor with that skinny fucking tattoo clad rat !!

  • @blica1

    um not to but in, but who are we arguing about here

  • i am , ..therefore my opinion matters more than yours does...sorry boy, you're in the wrong environment...run along now !!! and learn how to spell for christ's sake !!even travis barker knows how to spell !!!!

  • tatse also grammer is way off.

  • blica1 i am 16 years old and I do believe you don't know anything about music and above all about drumming! jesus you can't even compare the tecnique of neil peart wiht travis barker... he is a commercial punk and nothing else...

  • No ... Just no.

  • How does he handle a basic 4 piece set.,

    because that tests most drummers skills.

    Carl Palmer is better anyway.

    Still ,neither as good as Buddy Rich

  • Peart is the best he's still around right.

  • Agreed, and ya he's still kickin

  • HAHAHAH YOU MADE A FUNNY

  • Shredder is right

  • Which doe mean i donlt like neil peart, because he's amazing, but all these people like travis barker, and joey jordison have nothing on the greats like Rich, Bonham and Peart.

  • John Bonham is by far the best drummer ever, along with Buddy Rich, and then followed by Neil Peart. Anybody wishing to argue over it, save your breath, because it is the absolute truth.

  • Dude Bonham just kicks ass in general, he's so imaginative and uses only the basic stuff to acomplish what he had to say. but you can't count out Keith Moon who interpreted songs instead of imagining his own. he worked with the rest of the band. He was about expressing what the band wanted to do. and of Course Neil Pert is just amazing. He took time to do with drums what jimmy page does with guitar. just absolutley stunning. you can't compare any of them. they all rock.

  • his kit is realy good but his hardware is realy weak

  • Oh, the good young days !! Neil was in excellent shape during this era. He can still kill it, though. I just saw them in Seattle and Portland. WOW !! Not bad for a bunch of old guys !! First and second time seeing them. One more time coming in Newcastle, England. Can't wait !!!

    RUSH - Canada's Greatest Export

  • I hate when people say that statistically, someone is better than Neil Peart. I personally don't think he's the best but don't think Joey Jordison is better - He's Not! Who cares if Jordison has higher stats! He's fast - but not that good!

    Go Peart, and Go Rush!

  • Jordison's real good, so is the rev, but peart kills them by far.

  • And besides, if you want speed, Inferno and George Kollias make Jordison look worthless. Stylistically Peart is just plain awesome.

  • Pearts good, but your right, he is not the best.

  • Pearts good, but your right, he is not the best.

  • Neil Peart is aparently the second best drummer over But to me he is the fukin best!!!!!

  • best drummer that ever lived

  • hes still alive dumbass

  • is it just me or does he look like tom hanks?

  • ha he does

  • t/y dotfan77!

  • Neil should be in the top three best drummers in the world if he already isn't. And we went to see those guys in Camden NJ, and I got a pair of Neil Peart Sticks from snakes and arrows tour!! I am only ten years old! He must really like to make kids happy. NEIL PEART ROCKS THIS WORLD OUT LOUD!!!

  • watch "big thomas" if you like neil. He is another good drummer. Not a neil pert but you decide.

  • No drummer really has rythem, they alway go off tune with the music and for the most part I guess this guys stays on his melody.

  • haha you say no drummer really has rhythm you really have no clue what drumming is then its all about rhythm look up the definition of rhythm before you post something as stupid as you did....

  • great song, great drummer

  • greatest drummer to pick up a pair of sticks

  • Bonham and Neil are the best!

  • Neil, eres una riata pa la bataca...

  • i refuse to believe that neil peart is human

  • Uh, OBVIOUSLY he has super-powers.

  • no drummer ever is or was as good as peart (peeeert, not Pert, you morons) anyone who saw this guy in the 80s knows what im talking about

  • i wonder how many people got seizures from watching this

  • loool macoy... ur philipino... thats bout enuf to explain a lot... neva heard of ur band and trust me... if i was able to see u ill make u regret the day u ever held drum stix bitch

  • yo mama so old she saw passion of christ live.

  • good one

  • duh...im the most greatest drummer of all in the philippines no one can beat me in drum solo... my name is andrew of LAKANDULA the most popular band..

  • shawn spends too much time on youtube

  • You know what?

    Your mama's so fat she has to put on her belt with a boomerang!

  • You guys are infuc_igncredible!! Neil this, joey that, Bonham this, Tommy Lee that! Go check out Carl Palmers work going back to some of the most earth shattering solos from 1969 and on, when he was 19 years old. Even Buddy Rich was quoted as saying "this kid's(Carl) incredible" when refering to Palmer when he was like 22 years old. And he's still going at 55 years old!

  • Bottom line... Neil Peart is the best at what he does.

  • I haven't seen eny thing like that.

  • need more rythm but is reat

  • you laim, unmusical and deaf drummers! Neil is not, by any means, a drummer! He is true percussionist who has feel, taste, rhythm, creativeness and balls! He blows away any of those shitty ass "drummers" people mention on here! Now then, do you comprehend the difference: percussionist vs drummer? If not, you are highly unlikely to ever become a percussionist! Good luck banging the shit out of your pots and pans for the rest of your days, drummer.

  • I'd rather be called a drummer than a percussionist anyday.

  • Well aren't you a pompous douche. Drummers and percussionists are the exact same thing pal. The dictionary calls a drummer: "Someone who plays a drum." and a percussionist is: "Someone who plays a percussion instrument." Drums are percussion instruments. Case Closed.

  • You are accurate about the drummer part: "someone who..." However,you are such a benighted and anaesthetized homie that you missed the part that says: "percussionist: A MUSICIAN who plays..." Ask a drum kit palyer about the 26 essential rudiments. Can you properly execute a six-stroke roll?

  • A six stroke roll is painfully easy, that is the basis of all single stroke fills. Can you execute a double drag-paradiddle crescendo? There are 40 essential rudiments, just so you know.

  • Nothing painfull about a six storke or a double drag w/crescendo or decrescendo. Fast ratimacues are dreadfully painful. I gues you do know your sticking.

  • Yep, I do. I find drag-paradiddles slighty harder than ratamacues though. However, triple ratamacues are a bitch.

  • try a triple ratamacue, however, after every drag try a backstick (butt of the stick). Example: X= butt: llX llR llX L R L rrX rrL rrX R L R Start slow and build up. Also, build your chops w/ triple a stroke roll RRR LLL RRR LLL RRR etc. but try it with two 3S's in each hand, on a fricken pillow! Do it for about 5 mins. Then, jump on the snare with your fav. size sticks and watch your self ripp! A real chop builder.

  • A six stroke roll is painfully easy, that is the basis of all single stroke fills. Can you execute a double drag-paradiddle crescendo? There are 40 essential rudiments, just so you know.

  • calm the fuck down dude. "drummer" is easier to spell than percussionist okay?

    lighten the fuck up...

  • every friggin drum solo video i see, i look at the comments and see the exact same arguements, its bullshit.

  • that's because people insist to compare drummers, instead of just watch the video and enjoy it.

  • stop arguing who is the best drummer, how can u tell ?

    and dont talk about mike portnoy on a page with the professor mike is so over rate his sucks compared to neil!! and just so everyone knows the cowbell part at the start is from a solo from working man ages ago.

  • Think musical, fellows. This solo is MUSICAL. If you want a technical solo, watch Thomas Lang, or Virgil Donati.

  • Agreed.

  • jvc, you forgot mike portnoy

    that drummers are all awesome, no question, but mike's the only one who really tries to introduce his fans into the art of drumming. also he knows really to get his whole (really big) kit into his solos and he should be honored for that with more than just "best drum clinican"

  • hes good. but he tries to do to much. he needs to let his solos flow. keith moon is the greatest drummer of all time. he lets it flow. also his drum set is big but not so big he doesnt half the things in it. that is also why peart does not flow cause he tries to get to much in. sry this is so long thanks for reading it.

  • i agree tommy lee sucks balls at drums i rekon he is a good performer but actully shit at holding a beat !

  • danny carey

  • i do agree with deadhawk but we should not forget nicko mcbrian from iron maiden he's up there with those three

  • Why do people fight over who's the best drummer? The fights get real intensive over on The Whos side, because anytime one person sayes "Kieth Moon's the best" someone always comes in with a "Bonham/Peart is the best"

    music is not about who's better, its about the music. these people loved the music and every good musician, in the drumming department, Kieth Moon, John Bonham, Neil Peart, should not be compared, they should all be respected and enjoyed for their own styles.

  • That was awesome!!!

  • For those who follow N Peart's work, you will know he's into various styles (jazz, progressive rock, etc). His musicality and dedication tops everything any other drummers has ever tried. He play drums based in chords, not only as a percussion instrument. If I had to choose one to be my top drummer, I'd have to go with him, because I'm sure he can do whatever any other drummer can and add his sheer quality and style on top to make it sound unique and more elaborate. End of.

  • In no particular order, the 3 best drummers are -

    Neil Peart

    Carter Beauford

    Kenny Aronoff

  • nah

  • This man is quite simply an amazing artist. The fact that he writes most of the lyrics for the band, and also composes solos that are both extremely orchestrated and have a certain flow to them that make them hypnotic. The fact is, he is simply an amazing artist and has increadible talent.

  • It's not that he is robotic. He is focused. He is the Professor because he not only one of the greatest drummers of all time, he is also a great song writer, as well as an Author of several books. Have you seen his clinic drummer videos? Yes he is the Professor and still amazing.

  • I on the othet hand love the whole xylophone call and response, reminds me of a song i did a while back, call and response with the bassist.

  • A classic!

  • Definitely the greatest drummer ever IMO....but he sits there like a robot.

  • Neil is crazy good. One of the best ever. His only weakness is that he lacks soul. He's TOO technically sound. Almost robotic.

    If you've never heard of Jojo Mayer, look him up. Truly awesome.

  • the whole solo is ruined at 2:15, with the xylophone parts, although they're cool the transitioning is terrible

  • Mike Portnoy is still my favourite to watch, but that by no way means he's the best.

  • then why do they call peart The Professor?

  • I dunno...

    Because he professes to be the best? :D

    Buddy....Rich...Man

  • I have to agree with Escape. The best drummer ever is Buddy Rich, but I would have to say the drummer to beat now adays is Mike Portnoy from Dream Theater.

  • You are ALL wrong about everything. Best Metal Drummer is Gene Hoglan and Best Drummer EVER is Buddy Rich.

  • nah, all you who say Jordison sucks are wrong hes amazingly technical, but not that interesting, Travis Barker on the other hand is awsome, and yes, Bonham is awsome... but ive been hearing so many good things about this guy, i was expecting somthing incredibly amazing. this is awsome, but its just OK.... hes still ungodly amazing though.
  • i only agree with bonham

  • Travis Barker is SO boring and overrated , he trys far too hard and just doesnt succeed , he just has to eat some food!! Pearts out of this world

  • and hes canadian !

    more proof that canadians kick fucking ass

  • anyone ever hear of Dennis chambers ?

  • Bonham was very good...Peart is much better IMO.

  • we'll kinda bonham is better than peart cause he was influenced by him

  • Just because one influenced the other does not make him better.

  • Peart is the best ever...no one comes close.

  • excuse me.... ever heard of john bonham from a band called LED ZEPPELIN. his drum set wasnt nearly as big as neil pearts...and he could anything neil did but better.

  • IMO, I like Neil better, JB was fantastic also but Neil is more musical than JB was

  • yeah jordison sucks

    so so so bad.

    sooooooo bad.

    what a fag

  • yeah, in behalve of the music dumbie, his solos are not ''exactly the same'' watch clearly what he does.

  • Jordison does suck. All he has is speed. Adler sucks too, everything he plays is exactly the same.

  • Yea for real its no real good sound its just hiting one drum after another

  • BADOOM CHI!

  • Jordison sucks. Neil reigns over all.

  • jordison doesn't suck

    hes not better than neil though

  • joey jordison?? best metal drummmer??? have U ever heard about a guy called Dave Lombardo????

  • hes a god.

  • bdunmm dum CRAASH BLAKCAKAKAKA dakakakakkakak rumrumrurmrururmrmrmrr GASH!! GASH GASH!! blickle da dickle dle paradiddle diddle didle diddle thwap thwap thwap

    yay

  • u shd record a video of yourself actually doing that, verbally and post it on youtube... lol, it'll attract so many comments...

  • agree i want to see a video of this done verbally hha

  • lmao

  • joey jordison and chris adler i think r the 2 best METAL drummers. but neil is the best durmmer period. he mastered pretty much every style their is 2 drumming.

  • joey jordison?? best metal drummmer??? have U ever heard about a guy called Dave Lombardo????

  • correction on last comment, i didnt mean to end it at rock and roll, i meant to say "best drummer period" after, but i forgot

  • jordison and neil are two different styles, joey is an amazing metal drummer, i will give him that, but in his category, chris adler of lamb of god blows him out of the water. but as for rock and roll drummers, neil peart is the best, no question

  • you are so totally right. the slipskot drummer is amazingly talented- in skill. but he sounds like banging and he doesnt not have his own style he has the generic heavy metal style. chris adler is my fav drummer and extremely technical and amazing. he also has his own unmistakable style.

  • Please get some vids so we can judge for ourselves.

  • or hes just a faggot and cant play drums

  • jordison is creative but neil is classic two different leagues

  • sometimes i hate drum solos

  • jordison has LOTS of speed and endurance, but neil has grrove and style

  • Neil is the best rock drummer out there.

  • Neil is the best. Period. and if you try to compare him with joey jordison i'll kill you. honestly i'll track you down and kill you :)

  • him, tommy lee, jeff porcaro(rest his soul), & lars but definately Neil is tops.

  • are you kidding? Tommy Lee is a hack.  He can't even read music.

  • I'm convinced that he is the best drummer in the world.

  • Insane!!!!!!!

  • Fun =)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more