@clearmusician They've always been technically unstable like that. I suspect lack of vocal training, as Taeyeon and Jessica were the main forces from the start in that aspect.
just to clear things up, this was when taeyeon and yuri were just healing up from the swine flu so they were NOT live. otherwise, they usually sing live unless something like that happens and they can't sing. so they WEREN'T live.
I think Taeyeon wasn't feeling a little better this time that's why her part wasn't live. But who cares really? The girls can also give you a cd-like performances. Geez.
@TheLindavann sync. like synchronize. lip sync. and it's not that big of a deal seeing as she was sick. i doubt one of the biggest groups in korea would have members who were incapable of singing live. just my two cents.
sooyoung can freaking sing. SM never gives her lines but her voice is beautiful, same with yuri. they didn't even let her sing in Mistake and she freaking wrote the song
@LovableLittleRabbit I do. But I think I know how to differentiate live singing to the recorded music. In recorded music, you can hear the breathing too, but you can tell Taeyeon and Yuri's voice did not sound live. I'm not accusing them of not having a good enough voice to sing live, but it's the truth. Listen to the recorded version and this live version and listen closely to Taeyeon & Yuri's voice, they sound EXACTLY the same. Taeyeon & Yuri's part was not live. But the others were.
If ur sayin snsd can't sing then youd better go long.
pizzavortex3000 4 days ago
Hyo's voice is pretty good when she really projects!
hersunshiner 3 weeks ago
SUNNY <3 WOW
hersunshiner 3 weeks ago
넘 죠아 ㅠㅠ 그치만! Tiffany, Hyoyeon, Sunny, and Sooyoung are like 1/16 or 1/8 sharp. Do they not have mic on in ears?
clearmusician 3 weeks ago
@clearmusician They've always been technically unstable like that. I suspect lack of vocal training, as Taeyeon and Jessica were the main forces from the start in that aspect.
blackpkerstr 3 weeks ago
Sunny....your voice.........why is it so underrated! o.O
philosophy75 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love jessica voice so beautiful...oh dead ~~
saranghae19ify 1 month ago
i want to her yuri sing like this more!!!
TheOhJezz 2 months ago
My innocent angels... <3 so beautiful and full of love and kindness.
infinitefreedomx 4 months ago
LO ENCONTRE !!!!!!!!!!! ajakgdjakskjdgaskjdgakjdg SO HAPPY !!!!
OmmyArts 4 months ago
별 별 별 =★ ★ ★
so good!
8510327 5 months ago
Loving Yuri's voice :D in this one :D
I fact always!
SNSD Fighting !
GillpetsSHE 5 months ago 2
taeyeeeeeeeeeeeeeon :* love you
ZodicSuper 5 months ago
Hyoyeon has such a smooth tone to her voice, i just wanna hear more
itsonlyjulian 6 months ago 3
Yuri has such a beautiful voice!! And she's so pretty!
loveblackpearl 6 months ago 2
Sunny has such a beautiful voice <3 :)
mangoesandpeaches87 7 months ago 13
just to clear things up, this was when taeyeon and yuri were just healing up from the swine flu so they were NOT live. otherwise, they usually sing live unless something like that happens and they can't sing. so they WEREN'T live.
love this song <33 snsd hwaiting!!! <333 :DD
cheybug394 7 months ago 3
I think Taeyeon wasn't feeling a little better this time that's why her part wasn't live. But who cares really? The girls can also give you a cd-like performances. Geez.
mharpee 7 months ago
i cant believe yuri lip sing,, i dont know how to spell lip sink
TheLindavann 7 months ago
@TheLindavann sync. like synchronize. lip sync. and it's not that big of a deal seeing as she was sick. i doubt one of the biggest groups in korea would have members who were incapable of singing live. just my two cents.
KalbiKing 7 months ago
@KalbiKing oh she was sick?? thats all i need to hear,, cause well if shes sick ok i get it.
TheLindavann 7 months ago
maknaes at the window!!! xD
camiilove99 7 months ago
Yuri's voice is like angle... <3
polcadotmascara 8 months ago
Why is it SOOOO unfair for Yoona?????!!!! Why can't they just give Yoona at least only 1 line??????? WHY?!?!!!
xuancupcake 8 months ago
SNSD Ranked after how good I think they were in this preformance:
9. Yoona ( sorry, but she had no lines o.o )
8. Tiffany ( she wasnt 100% synced with the music )
7. SooYoung ( Not that she's bad, the other ones were just better )
6. Hyoyeon ( Same here.... and she's my favourite! TTwTT )
5. Yuri ( beautiful )
4. Jessica
3. Seohyun ( powerfull )
2. Sunny ( magical )
1. Taeyeon ( TRUE POWER! )
Vellamina 9 months ago 5
sunny so great!!!!
whuijin 9 months ago
taeyeon good job!!!!!
whuijin 9 months ago
Hey SM! What do you take Yoona for? A statue?! Give her some lines to sing please!
Babiezxc 9 months ago 8
Yoona didn't sing at all D:
18Wolfram 9 months ago
0:25
Yoona look sad...
Babiezxc 9 months ago 5
@Babiezxc I think that's because she was suppose to act sad
StrickenWithFear 9 months ago
อินว่ะ
gumkidmaiaok 9 months ago
Jessica I love You♥♥
MatInZaa 9 months ago
sooyoung can freaking sing. SM never gives her lines but her voice is beautiful, same with yuri. they didn't even let her sing in Mistake and she freaking wrote the song
ThePoptartchick 9 months ago 3
jessica!
XDDsnsd4ever 10 months ago
jessica :D hahaha great yuri is the lead dance but she has a powerful voice ! but sunny is the 5th lead singer so yea .. ! :D
mnurterry 10 months ago
Comment removed
Babiezxc 9 months ago
希望能這種抒情歌能多一點
舞曲太多了!!
s966385527441 10 months ago
yuri สุดยอด
ieploii 10 months ago
this song really shows their amazing voices. the other songs can't do that.
edeline18 11 months ago
Didn't Taeyeon lipsync to this because she was sick or something? o.o Heard that from another comment on another vid of this.
stabofhappiness2 11 months ago
@stabofhappiness2 Yes, she lip synced along with Yuri. I heard that from others too, but im not sure. The rest were all singing live though :)
MySungminOppa 10 months ago
@MySungminOppa Do you not clearly hear their breathing?
LovableLittleRabbit 8 months ago
@LovableLittleRabbit I do. But I think I know how to differentiate live singing to the recorded music. In recorded music, you can hear the breathing too, but you can tell Taeyeon and Yuri's voice did not sound live. I'm not accusing them of not having a good enough voice to sing live, but it's the truth. Listen to the recorded version and this live version and listen closely to Taeyeon & Yuri's voice, they sound EXACTLY the same. Taeyeon & Yuri's part was not live. But the others were.
MySungminOppa 8 months ago
@MySungminOppa Sure thing.
LovableLittleRabbit 8 months ago
Seohyun is so pretty
hyunjoong697 1 year ago 6
Seriously, SMent please explain to me why Yuri is not in the 5 main vocalist
21451r 1 year ago 8
Lindas vozes...linda musica....
amo demais SNSD...~
Jessica e Taeyeon formam uma dupla imbativel no vocal....
*o*
Sammy67202 1 year ago
I LOVE SUNNY'S VOICE!! >//<
polkadotkkkk 1 year ago
omfg yuri!!!!!!! amazing voice
slurdas 1 year ago 6
I love them all but Tiffany's, Taeyon's, Jessica's and Sunny's voices are <3. Sunny is really good at the high notes.
Tokboll 1 year ago 13
Love Tiffany's voice!!!!!
fairywinx11 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
SweetStrawberry16 1 year ago
I <3 TAEYON, YURI AND SUNNY'S VOICE!!!
pOpMuZiK4EvEr 1 year ago 11
OMG yoona...her emotions are so real.
patwong228 1 year ago 3
I love snsd and i really like thi song. I dont know what they're saying, but i'll look it up lol.
KiaraRawks 1 year ago 5
I love Taeyeon's voice! so powerful :)
Love Yuri. <3
Hananfye 1 year ago 7
is this live?
konjo93 1 year ago
TaeYoen, Jessica, and Yuri was best singers!!! and Seohyeon is training to be the next vocal!!
<3 <3 and sunny's high voice is very nice.
i REALLY love this song. it's so pretty.
happikoala 1 year ago 5
@happikoala what do you mean??? Seohyun is the 3rd lead vocalist in group
kyuuutquh777 1 year ago
such a good song it kind of made me cry
musiclovesu23 1 year ago
why didn't yoona sing?
lilkrnprncs9 1 year ago
@lilkrnprncs9 she looked she was about to cry maybe thats way
musiclovesu23 1 year ago
@musiclovesu23 but, they most likely planned for her not to sing so ..who knows.
lilkrnprncs9 1 year ago
Taengoo is adorable. ^_^ I love her voice. :))
FashonBayBheeXD 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
HYOYEON EW.
chezeez 1 year ago
Yuriahhhhhhhhhh
prettyeang 1 year ago
允兒有唱嗎?
catherine0716 1 year ago 3
Why can't let have yoona have some singing lines ? She had a pretty good voice too .
starrycrystle 1 year ago 53
crying nowT_T
aikopikkwan 1 year ago
OMG>.
totally feel this song...!!!
i really want them to perform agaaaain..!!
SNSD ....
love Tiffany's voice...
n not to forget..
all of theem..!!!! =)
fadz05 1 year ago 72
nice tnx for upload
nightsqual 2 years ago
does anybody know about what is the lyric?
letamy 2 years ago