Added: 3 years ago
From: GetTogetherMe5
Views: 203,643
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (199)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Madonna ist die Größte.

    Besonders süß ist ihre Zahnlücke.

    I Like It.

  • ...per Galileo Galilei era importante saper leggere il libro della Natura....ma spesso saper leggere nel cuore di un solo essere umano è ancora piu' difficile se non impossibile....flavio monterosso.

  • Corny

  • pure jingoistic crap

  • HQ- Hardly Quality...

  • one of the worst video and worst remake ever seen, what she is doing here? does she really understand what she is singing?

  • so like everyone in america are gays? :O

  • bääh ordinory i like madonna but this is real shit, sry -.-

    she spoiled Don McLean´s song with this happy-pappy shit D:

  • madonna did a fine job on this song!

  • I like the Madonnas version better since it's easier to relate to... I can make my own meaning of it, the original is too specific and in "folkish".

  • D:< NO! NO! STOP IT! STOP SINGING THIS SONG RIGHT NOW MADONNA! YOU DON'T DESERVE TO MAKE PROFIT OFF THIS AMAZING SONG!

  • she also killed music with her pop SHIT so she has NO RIGHT to sing this song FUCKING BITCH

    by the way SHITTY COVER

  • @reapermachine Pop shit is still a thousand times better than disco shit... really, anybody who thinks pop killed good music has no clue about music history.

  • Yeah, shes not so orginal after all. Please stop hating on Lady Gaga because Madonna is NOT better.

  • @thatskai

    ah she IS!

    

  • @lordinaire1 Nope ;) 

  • @thatskai

    YES! ;)

  • But Madonna it´s very more beautifull at Don McLean, shout out, and up the women forever...

  • she looks so fit in this video, i want her muscles. =D =D

  • it's a fucking insulte to Don McLean and to Rock music at general...

    Suck Madonna

  • it's a fucking insulte to Don McLean and to Rock musica at general...

    Suck Madonna

  • i like the original

  • i want HQ!

  • This is the single worst cover of all time I almost vomited the first time i heard it. She should stick to dikeing out and leave the music to the actual musicians like Don McLean.....even weird al's cover is a thousand times more engaging.

  • Sometimes it is not all about sex. This is an immortal classic which is least in need for Madonna's body to shake so that it becomes successful!

    She hurt the song more than helping it!!!!!

  • a forbidden song in the usa i heared. only because of the words "the day the music died"... richie valens and another rockn roll stars died by an airplane crash and the media called this day "the day the music died". thats the reason why this song is forbidden.... i dont know if its true but i heared it.

  • @cyreckid It is not a forbidden song It was one of the true classics of the country. Only the Madonna verson was banned by radio stations after people complained on how badly she butchered it. The original Don McLean version is still played on the oldies stations

  • Your underwears are an american flags ? American Retarded pie

  • Why the f*** do you write HQ in the Title if it isn't HQ you idiot??

  • @madeindueren Back when this was posted there wasn't any 480-720p BS, it was just standard or HQ. I guess in the process of converting to resolution-based modes, the HQ factor was lost :P

  • net schlecht^^

  • Does she not realize that she killing music more by making an awful pop cover of an awesome song?

    and her bouncing tits remind me that most modern female pop artists are sluts.

  • AMERICA IS NOT USA!!!! AMERICA IS ALL THE CONTINENT!! WHEN THEY'LL UNDERSTAND THIS???!!!

  • I know it is a cover. Y'all don't have to keep telling me this. I knew from when I heard her sing it that it was a cover by Don McLean.

    You people need to stop telling me things that I already know.

  • @jbarabasz

    Then, stop being assretarded and making unintelligent remarks.

    Oh and you still haven't given any justification for your original comment. If you knew that it was a cover from the beginning, why post what you posted?

  • i like this song, it lets me remember old times :)

  • great boobage

  • Buen tema, buen video, pésima película. No hay alguien que asesore a Madonna para hacer buenas películas????????????'

  • i like when this was on snl. XD

  • Much nicer than Don.

  • She's so hot!!

  • kinda funny how there are no mexicans there

  • But the girl who hugs the man is drew barrymore?

  • look at her arms at 3:08, when she pulls up her pants. she looks like a freakin b-builder :D

  • Madonna is a self-indulgent, politically retarded, talentless hack. If you disagree with me, you are wrong.

  • when Madonna used to make GOOD pop music.... now she just trying to make anything to survive in this new generation. anything after ray of light is a real shambles.

  • @Mature Such a shame :(

  • SONG MURDER!!! oe how Ray would say FAKE AND GAY!!!!

  • All meaning, beauty and intent of the original song has been butchered and raped by this abhorrant atrocity. This cover lacks any meaningful message, it's purpose is singly to inflate Madonna's pride and desperate plea for the attention which seems to be her only comfort in her now empty life. Forgive me, she also does it for money, profiting from the poetry and talent of another, i.e., Don McLean.

  • she never performed live =[

  • I remember hearing this one when I was shopping in Tesco's a couple of years ago!

  • @greenbumho That's what's so great about our country. you can call it a shitty country with out getting arrested, beaten, or killed. unless of course you're physically hurting someone in the process.

  • Comment removed

  • madonna is known for being innovative hehe

  • Way to tooootally destroy a beautiful song Madonna. this is disgusting.

  • @greenbumho fuck you

  • Don McLean himself praised this cover, saying it was "a gift from a goddess", and that her version is "mystical and sensual.

    

  • She covered the Wierd All song an changed the Star Wars lyrics!!!! (just kidding! :P)

  • I cant help myself, she is so hot!!!

  • buttcrack

  • she did a really good job on this cover, she got it a great feminine take on the song, always loved the video.

  • it's a beautuful song! ^^

  • schön

    

  • she was molestingthat flag

  • You can't compare this to the original. It's just so different. I've always thought Madonna looked really sexy and hot in this.

  • four and half minutes of american flags and madonna's tits: nothing cynical about that, she' just trying to earn a living

  • She's Old Now.

  • I like it :D

  • I like so much madonna and her version, but the original version is better!!!

  • Nah.... Sorry original is better

  • what the hell is up with this version, i was just cheaking it out and seriously it is SHIT usually madonna is alright but COME ON!!

  • Original is good but this version is better. Plus became much more successful hit (#1 in more than 20 countries). Madonna is the Best!!!

  • I Love this version :)

  • Holy shit... I recently downloaded the original, even though I remember I heard the Madonna version back in 2000, but now I see that Don McLean's version is SO MUCH FUCKING BETTER.

  • madonna is fantastic and so is this song, but she should have never remade this song.....she lowered herself and the song

  • I like the video.

    And I like the film Madonna directed.

    I wish Madonna will keep on doing some controversial activities.

  • it sounds nice but i agree with some people that she ruined the song in a way. This song is supposed to be a tribute to the 3 rock&roll artists that died in a plane crash. And what is with all the strange people??? Rafaelbocorny- It shows the american society and its variety- who gives a shit? LoL "I met a girl who sang the blues" and then you see a fat chick in a wheel chair HaHaHa also madonna the old hag shaking her arse is disrespectful...

  • i like this song better than the original.. but i think its cause i heard this one before the original and just got used to it

  • There are just certain songs you don't remake.

  • @Chazwozel1 i agree .. what an abomination .. don mclean did it best

  • Comment removed

  • I betcha Peggy Sue and Donna Fox would probably care less about this version.

  • her version is sooo better ,,,

  • I like this video. It shows the american society and its variety.

  • Exactly. You dont just have pin up girls, models, and the steriotypical beauty, everyday people are in here, everyone is in here!

  • @rafaelbocorny This is only half of the real song. The real song is 8 mins long.

  • she ruined it

  • beautiful song...

  • well, don mclean let her do the cover fpr a reason, and actually, in an interview, he said, i have received many gifts from god, but this is the first from a goddess, take that bitches...

  • Lots of people say that Madonna ruined this song, and normally i'm the first one to say that the originals are always the best, but I think that her version is ok!

  • how dare she sing this song!

  • ahhaha thats funny random

  • people are stupid you never understand Madonna's and her songs !

  • her songs have clear meaning of what she is trying to say, you just have to listen to what she is trying to say in her lyrics. her music has so much power behind them.

  • @jbarabasz

    This isn't even her song xD

  • @MeshChannel I know I was just referring to her other songs. I wasn't talking about this song in general. I know this song was originally made by Don McLean..

  • @jbarabasz it's actually don mclean's...

  • @jbarabasz dude this songs a cover

  • @Kiinikiti "Dude" I know that this song is cover. I was just trying to get a point across.

  • @jbarabasz too bad she didnt write this song..

  • @jbarabasz lol..u seem to be mistaken that madonna herself wrote this song...this is a very old song dude..madonna is trying to say nothing here..are you one of those guys who think that the singer writes the song thmselves? and give the music too?

  • @veiledvulture...Um excuse me I am not one of those "guys" that thinks that every singer writes their own songs. I do know that she did not write this song I am not an idiot. I know that Don McLean sang it originally. I was just simply stating the fact that she is a great writer and musician. I just posted what i thought about her and her music on this song. Sorry if ya'll are confused, but I didn't know you weren't allowed to say things about an artist I like on a song she made a vid. for.

  • @jbarabasz , well "her songs have aclear meaning of what she wants to say ... listen to what she is trying to say in her lyrics"

    these sentences "somehow make" it seem as if you think that madonna wrote the song and composed the music herself...so try to make your point clearer next time...

  • @veiledvulture So sorry to confuse people with my words. But ya gotta admit that her lyrics in most of her songs are amazing.

  • @jbarabasz Thats NOT HER LYRICS .. Don Mclean is original author!

  • @D3kar You know what I am sick and tired of trying to get it into peoples head that I was not Saying that she made or wrote this song. I do know that she COVERED!! It. I was simply stating that she is a great song writer and she has interesting points she tries to get across to other people through the music she SINGS.( not necessarily always her own songs) Like this COVER!! She did for this song. That SHE DID NOT WRITE!!!!!

  • @jbarabasz It's a cover.

  • @jbarabasz HER song?! you do know this is a cover for Don McLean's "American Pie"

  • @jbarabasz It is Don McLeans song and I think that this is an insult to Rock music . -.-''

  • This song isn't ruined, this is a beautiful song and it has soul, a lot more than the new artists. This was back when music wasn't about the money!

  • This is Madonna's best song. Honestly!

  • My Niece looks like Madonna

  • Don MrBean please take your redneck ASS fans out of here, commenting on the Queen Of POP. They stink

  • FUCK YOU REDNECK COW SUCKING REDNECK

    MADONNA is THE BEST

  • god wtf i hate her sooooo much cause of this song cause she killed my favorite song by making a stupid hey cover....ugh

  • jess

  • Some things in life should be left alone and this song is one of them..She sucks doing this song and no one can ever do it better than Don!

  • tram pam pam))

  • Madonna is simply super, she spent almost 30 years in the light of world music!

  • Stupid haters. Why do so many low-IQ'd individuals not SEE how friggen epic Madonna is??

    PS: I never actually *liked* this song until I heard her do it... so there.

  • cunt fucking raped this song.

    and don't think for a split second she makes up the little side tunes either, she hires people like william orbit for that.

  • unhappy?

  • U GOT SOME SERIOUS ISSUES!!!!

  • Why?

    I think you have more serious issues. First of all you type with all upper case characters, and you did not spell the word "you" correctly. What the hell is "u"? It's not an English word because it is not in the dictionary. And "You got"? It should be "You have".

    I've seen worse, so I'll give you an "E" for effort.

  • Awsome Song im loving it

    And a1mint also known as Mr Perfect English

    We Write These Kind Of Words When We Dont feel like writing The Whole Letters

    and it saves alot of time to do so

    Besides It doesnt matter as long as the words complete Concept is clear when You read any words like brb (be right back) lol laughing out loud) or where r u from or thats just gr8 is normal as long as your not writing in a test

  • You're actually defending those snots. Pathetic.

    They write like that because they don't pay much attention to anything, they don't know how to write, and instead of accidentally making mistakes because they are so bad at it, they purposely use cell phone lingo to avoid looking stupid.

    Things that are not ok is "u", "ur". It makes it sound like the person has to pause between the words to speak.

    "brb" doesn't do that, so that's not as bad.

    It's high time that the youth get with it.

  • Okay Whatever You Say

    i think i will agree with you if i find someone else who feels the same way as you

    But i Have No Problem With u

    but if people dont really know how to type You due to the spelling confusion

    than its a shame

  • I can't believe this slimy whore covered this song...Fuckin scank hates America...

  • I like this song very much...

    Madonna is the best sing in the world...

    Kisses

  • OMFG

  • I think that you have a bigger problem with yourself. Madonna would rather shit on your face than let you "stick your tongue into her anus" But it's quite possible that you would enjoy this shit on your face, wouldn't you?

  • NO, THIS ONE'S BETTER!

  • i cant seem to find this song in itune can anyone help me please!!!!

  • OMG I LOVE MADONNA! i love both versions of this song.but i hope she NEVER dies.I want her to BE 4-EVA

  • Is that rupert everett sitting on the chair and dancing with madonna at the end?

  • I don't think so. But he's backing up the vocals at the end. If you listen good enough, you can hear a guy singing.

  • yeah, its him

  • yes

  • elle est magnifique

    Madonna respect !!!

  • one of madonnas best songs ever! ;D

  • ugh!!she isnt dead yet.

  • she is really not getting younger [and the video shows that dramatically] but I like her more since she grew up

  • Oh, BTW, I hate the way she dances in this video.

    She's just got her hands on her hips leaning back and forth obnoxiously.

  • Yeah I know...but shes so sexy anyway I don't think she wanted to over do it on this kind of song. The imagery is poignant....sexy dancing would not have worked.A lot of people think her Beautiful stranger video is a lot sexier but actually there is something about this one...and as you say...shes not really even dancing.

  • haha I love the kids it shows when she sings

    "can music save your mortal soul?".

    They're all...terrifying.

  • amo esta canción!

  • Man, this takes me back a few years.

    Remember the days when images of pro-America patriotism could feel lighthearted and inoffensive?

  • My fave Madonna song. :D

    DON MCLEAN FTL (for the lose)

  • One of the best cover ever,she is simply amazing,great video and everything,rock on Her Majesty!

  • like this song :) one of her best !

  • The images of people in this video are very powerful. It shows people from all walks of life with amazing expressions. awesome video.

  • im ok with sarry about that

  • only other vushin then the origenil

  • what's you're explanation the universe? when i hear you're anti-religion people's explanation i say you guys have much more faith than we do.

    a rock hit another rock and somehow created a land with grass and living beings from something that's anything but living is the real bullshit. also evolution is another one that i hear about...almost all scientists how study evolution say it's also bullshit. why do these theories stay around?...cause they are political issues.

  • cool. I like lyrics

  • if any other pop star had done this song, i'd probably be offended (jessica simpson's 'these boots were made for walking,' anyone?) but i'm totally ok w/ this version- it sounds crisp and is very catchy.