why does the The Scottish parliament get a fixed budget and westminster can spend what it wants i would like to see westminster on a fixed budget maybe our debt would drop hmm
I don't necessarily think independance is the best solution. It's better to work with your neighbours than to partition yourselves off. If Scotland (And Northern Ireland/Wales) want these state-funded luxuries they should bear the financial burden themselves.
The US states are largely financially autonomous and are in "a fairer union" as a result...
Thankyou England for your generosity. Long live the UK and all the benefits we gain. You love the idea of britain so much and you only have yourselves to blame for voting the way you all do. As long as we don`t have to work for the money then there is no insentice to do so. Why be independant when we have barnett and all the other benefits kindly given to us by London. We can have England back our banks and not have to worry about them ourselves. Long live the union.
If you want to reconcile the peoples of our nations and fight the evil of the politicians and their bankster masters, you are going to have to be a lot more diplomatic and humble than this display of English arrogance and ignorance. It's what we have come to expect over the past 820 years or so but still, surely the English could have moved on from their snide superiority and overbearing smugness of the past.
@TheHead9999, glad you liked it, hope you take the time to reflect on what I wrote and no, it isn't ironic or indicative of the same failings in me or my fellow Scots so you can forget that. I am not confused but I think you are seriously befuddled.
Well we have to get our money back somehow, after Thatcher closed our docks, steelworks etc. Does this guy in the vid actually think we want to be thieving money off England if that is the case??? Dont flatter yourself pal! We would take independance more than anyone, then hardworking fishermen per say would feel like they can stop lining Belgiums pockets!
Thatcher was an amateur compaired with Blair, Brown and their vicious henchmen.
I think that both of our countries are being deliberately wrecked. We are kept at each others throats (Anyone but England etc) so that they can follow their own agenda whilst we are shouting at each other over the fence. We need to unite and make them pay the appropriate penalty for their crimes. Our ancient constitution had the mechanism to deal with these traitors. We need cooperative independence
@TheHead9999 Thatcher was an amateur 4 u because when she imposed poll tax on us u prob couldnt give a shit! Maybe it wasn't really a big deal 4 u.... I have watched a few of ur vids now and cant agree on whether u have intelligent ideology or u r an underlying racist... Whichever the case, England are suposed to have one of the strongest governments in the world. Tell me, why is it that people like you try 2 blame the rest of Britain because you cant get your own country in order??
Tony Blair is a Papal Knight of Malta--a complete and total Jesuit puppet. When the researching the Jesuits it is important to research the 'Knights of Malta' too.
The Knights of Malta were formed roughly a thousand years ago to launch Crusades for Rome exactly as war criminal Tony Blair did in Iraq.
The Jesuirs are the great nation wreckers and England is top of their list. Of course they are going to place Scots in prominent positions of power as a scapegoat. It's usually Jews that they place in prominent positions of power as a scapegoat.
Scotland has got 20% more oil in the North Sea than Norway, and Norway is one of the richest nations on earth. It is time you directed your ire elsewhere.
The Jesuits of Rome control the entire political process in the UK. Brown, Cameron and Clegg are all Bilderbergers--complete and total Jesuit puppets. You've probably never even heard of the Jesuits, like most Englishmen.
TheHead9999, where/what can I find the total contribution of England into the U.K. economy, I would appreciate it because I have been searching for Months now
I'm Scottish and you have a point,but remember Scotland has also been on the receiving end of English politcians,Thatcher Poll tax etc and people in the south of England could'nt give a shit about the people in the North.
Please get you facts right. In 1999 Blair sent for McLeish (Scottish First Minister) to sit in Westminster to sort out the British sea boundaries, He moved the border from 45 degs to 90 and thus stole 30% of English oil, gas and fisheries. Not a whimper from England because we have no voice. Check it out!! We need more than independence we need to ensure that every penny comes back.
Scotland pays more money than it recieves in tax you complete fucker. Furthermore, Glasgow has more people on benefits than the rest of Scotland combined.
Smear, smear, smear, smear..... lose the little Englander attitude and stop reading the Daily Mail twat.
how can 40 percent of the population be claiming benefits in scotland, if you conside that the population is five million are you suggesting that two million of them claim benefits? when employment levels in the uk as a whole some 60 million have only 2.3 million unemployed, you have cherrypicked and gerrymandered figures and provided lie after lie of ill understood statistics
Do you really think that if England went on its own, the tax man would say "Hey everybody now we have got rid of the ghastly welsh, scottish and Northern Irish, i am very pleased to say i wont tax you hardly anything and your lives will be so much better", give me a break!
Even so I like being British (and English). I spent 5 fantastic years in Wales, I love the Welsh and don't want a divorce! I know less about Scotland, but they seem to have contributed a lot to this land of ours over the centuries. Whatever the accountants think I feel we're better off together.
And whatever happens we all going to be neighbours - FOREVER! So remember: we need to get on.
I'm not english or even british, so my personal opinion is neither way.
However, scotland will go from being a world-leading power to a 3rd-rate european satellite with no voting power in the EU and no say in international politics. That's a fact.
If England went on their own, then I would expect all overseas territories to be split between the Welsh,Scottish and why not the N.Irish too? Perhaps we would need to consider dividing the Falklands evenly, we fought for it too! Perhaps I would want the Welsh border to be revised back to her orignal territories. Perhaps we would charge you alot more for your water usage as Wales provide a hell of alot of water for England?
Scotland gets out LESS than it puts in to to the union. this is FACT, Scotland is a NET CONTRIBUTOR!
You video is a load of nonsense.
our budget is 33Bn and we put in a damned site more. i think britishwatcher(a unionist of big mouth proportions) put Scotland contribution at £50 Bn. so tell me, how is it that Scotland subsidises?
Media, politicians, economists and even your own commentators are recognising that Sctotland is living off it's neighbours.
Banking?
If there was no money going north (Brown of The Scottish Claim of Right) would have you out of the Union faster than you could blink. If Scotland were sending cash south, the 'Claim of Righters' at Westminster are betraying their oath. Some chance of that. You spout the same old bullshit as your history writers.
those figures are from the Westminsters own accounts!
you are blatantly ignorant and anti Scottish , just look at your totally idiotic fantasy videos! you are a genuinely petty propagandist. you might we well work for the british state with he quality of nonsense there. you should realise that it's a GOOD THING to let Scotland go rather that just talk unqualified utter nonsense about it! you would learn a lot from Billy Brag , a real English patriot
What about the MoD contracts subsidies, which are heavily biased in the SE of England. What about the £10bn subsidy for the London Olympics; or the £15bn subsidy for London Crossrail; or the other £15bn subsidy that was for the Channel Tunnel Rail Link?
I'm just sorry that the most recent government figures on expenditure and revenue in Scotland don't back any of your fallacious assertions up, I'm afraid.
Why don't you watch the vid? Those billions you speak of come from England, so how can they be subsidies? Scots contribute nothing you simply get your 10% grant from Britain.
You have just highlighted £4 billion that we English will have to give you for the simple reason that we have spent English money in England. Tell me about Scotlands' subsidies to England. RBS, HBOS, Brown's hundreds of billions pound bail out without even a 'by your leave' to us English. Just go! Please!!
Whilst you rant about unfair distribution of wealth, how do you respond to the fact that all exported Scotch Whisky leaves these shores from Liverpool in order to count as an English export, not Scots, to further reduce Scotland's percentage allocation from Westminster?
Maybe it helps hide the fact that you are doing well and don't need subsidising. I would say that it helps to justify the subsidy rather than reduce it. Why don't you ask Brown, Darling, Reid, Martin etc they run the country and as they have signed the Scottish Claim of Right to look after Scotland before all others I would guess that it is in the interests of Scotland.
Per year. Thus does not include Scottish tax. Scotland has proven to be a worth while investment. Our country is stabilized, we sustain ourselves, we have a dominant Government, over 50% of Scottish student's go onto University once completed secondary school which results in the majority of Scots landing themselves in wealthy, profession careers.
It's not out fault that your country is a Muslim infested shit hole which around 48% of your population unemployed, find someone else to blame!
Blair, Darling, Brown, Reid, Falconer. Irving, Alistair Campbell, Steel, Kennedy, Rifkind, Menzies Campbell, Browne, Cooper, Martin, Davidson,Devine, Duncan Smith, Cooke, Dewar, Fitzpatrick, These are the effluent that turned England into what you describe. It does not stop at Muslims, does it? There are 2 million others that we could do without. How long do you think that the shithole can be contained south of the border once we have paid to turn Scot into such a desirable haven?
You are a narrow minded, idiotic typical English man!
You seem to have forgotten Scotland's multi million pound oil, gas and energy industry. Scotland contributes approximately £52 Billion pounds per year through the oil and gas industry alone which is more than anything England contributes. We also contribute £30 Billion pounds through the energy industry.
Scotland is one of the most visited countries in the World by tourists from all over the World in which we rake in over £50 Billion
It's forensic, it's depressing, it's a bloody disgrace....
500 odd traitorous dogs who shamelessly prostitute themselves for the expediency of a cushy job, a gold plated pension and a guaranteed post on a few quangos once they have filled their boots with English taxpayers' cash.
behind why the ruling Cartel of celts & self serving, 'Anti English', english traitors are hell bent on promoting their view of 'Britishness' as a union of nations & regions and denying the rights and even the very existance of England and the English as a nation and people. The wider the exposure this type of information receives the greater the support for an independent England will become.
why does the The Scottish parliament get a fixed budget and westminster can spend what it wants i would like to see westminster on a fixed budget maybe our debt would drop hmm
MrScottishJamie 7 months ago
Almost agree basch2020
But each nation needs to be governed by its own nationals. England and the British Government prove that.
The Scottish Nationalist, supported by the likes of Kinnock would never have got control of an English Parliament.
Think of English nationalists geting control of Holyrood and you will appreciate the need.
Nothing wrong with working together provided you deal on a profit only basis and the others do.
TheHead9999 7 months ago
I don't necessarily think independance is the best solution. It's better to work with your neighbours than to partition yourselves off. If Scotland (And Northern Ireland/Wales) want these state-funded luxuries they should bear the financial burden themselves.
The US states are largely financially autonomous and are in "a fairer union" as a result...
basch2020 7 months ago
You Sir are a comic genius. I salute you. Do you juggle as well?
jimbob1969 9 months ago
Oh dear,
Another amateur phsycologist.
My stress level has just gone through the roof.
Outwitted by another canny Scot.
TheHead9999 1 year ago
Thankyou England for your generosity. Long live the UK and all the benefits we gain. You love the idea of britain so much and you only have yourselves to blame for voting the way you all do. As long as we don`t have to work for the money then there is no insentice to do so. Why be independant when we have barnett and all the other benefits kindly given to us by London. We can have England back our banks and not have to worry about them ourselves. Long live the union.
cjmastablasta 1 year ago
If you want to reconcile the peoples of our nations and fight the evil of the politicians and their bankster masters, you are going to have to be a lot more diplomatic and humble than this display of English arrogance and ignorance. It's what we have come to expect over the past 820 years or so but still, surely the English could have moved on from their snide superiority and overbearing smugness of the past.
arisuta2 1 year ago
@arisuta2
I do like this one!
You say that I am "going to have to be a lot more diplomatic and humble" to achieve reconcilliation.
Then you say "English arrogance and ignorance"
And English "Snide and ,superiority and overbearing smugness"
Now think of that my confused friend.
TheHead9999 1 year ago
@TheHead9999, glad you liked it, hope you take the time to reflect on what I wrote and no, it isn't ironic or indicative of the same failings in me or my fellow Scots so you can forget that. I am not confused but I think you are seriously befuddled.
arisuta2 1 year ago
Well we have to get our money back somehow, after Thatcher closed our docks, steelworks etc. Does this guy in the vid actually think we want to be thieving money off England if that is the case??? Dont flatter yourself pal! We would take independance more than anyone, then hardworking fishermen per say would feel like they can stop lining Belgiums pockets!
scottdj1982 1 year ago
@scottdj1982
Thatcher was an amateur compaired with Blair, Brown and their vicious henchmen.
I think that both of our countries are being deliberately wrecked. We are kept at each others throats (Anyone but England etc) so that they can follow their own agenda whilst we are shouting at each other over the fence. We need to unite and make them pay the appropriate penalty for their crimes. Our ancient constitution had the mechanism to deal with these traitors. We need cooperative independence
TheHead9999 1 year ago
@TheHead9999 Thatcher was an amateur 4 u because when she imposed poll tax on us u prob couldnt give a shit! Maybe it wasn't really a big deal 4 u.... I have watched a few of ur vids now and cant agree on whether u have intelligent ideology or u r an underlying racist... Whichever the case, England are suposed to have one of the strongest governments in the world. Tell me, why is it that people like you try 2 blame the rest of Britain because you cant get your own country in order??
scottdj1982 1 year ago
what about the 13 billion made by the scottish north sea oil fields. 2008 revenue
producersunnyshadows 2 years ago
Tony Blair is a Papal Knight of Malta--a complete and total Jesuit puppet. When the researching the Jesuits it is important to research the 'Knights of Malta' too.
The Knights of Malta were formed roughly a thousand years ago to launch Crusades for Rome exactly as war criminal Tony Blair did in Iraq.
Islandretreat 2 years ago
The Jesuirs are the great nation wreckers and England is top of their list. Of course they are going to place Scots in prominent positions of power as a scapegoat. It's usually Jews that they place in prominent positions of power as a scapegoat.
Islandretreat 2 years ago
Jesuits*
Islandretreat 2 years ago
Dear resentful Sassenach,
Scotland has got 20% more oil in the North Sea than Norway, and Norway is one of the richest nations on earth. It is time you directed your ire elsewhere.
The Jesuits of Rome control the entire political process in the UK. Brown, Cameron and Clegg are all Bilderbergers--complete and total Jesuit puppets. You've probably never even heard of the Jesuits, like most Englishmen.
Islandretreat 2 years ago
TheHead9999, where/what can I find the total contribution of England into the U.K. economy, I would appreciate it because I have been searching for Months now
CelticBriton 2 years ago
I'm Scottish and you have a point,but remember Scotland has also been on the receiving end of English politcians,Thatcher Poll tax etc and people in the south of England could'nt give a shit about the people in the North.
YARROWS 2 years ago
Where the fuck are you getting your facts form little Englander? Not to mention the fact that the oil is... oh yeah.. Scotland's.
ronMexico121 2 years ago
Please get you facts right. In 1999 Blair sent for McLeish (Scottish First Minister) to sit in Westminster to sort out the British sea boundaries, He moved the border from 45 degs to 90 and thus stole 30% of English oil, gas and fisheries. Not a whimper from England because we have no voice. Check it out!! We need more than independence we need to ensure that every penny comes back.
TheHead9999 2 years ago
Scotland pays more money than it recieves in tax you complete fucker. Furthermore, Glasgow has more people on benefits than the rest of Scotland combined.
Smear, smear, smear, smear..... lose the little Englander attitude and stop reading the Daily Mail twat.
ronMexico121 2 years ago
how can 40 percent of the population be claiming benefits in scotland, if you conside that the population is five million are you suggesting that two million of them claim benefits? when employment levels in the uk as a whole some 60 million have only 2.3 million unemployed, you have cherrypicked and gerrymandered figures and provided lie after lie of ill understood statistics
bhoyracer67 3 years ago
Do you really think that if England went on its own, the tax man would say "Hey everybody now we have got rid of the ghastly welsh, scottish and Northern Irish, i am very pleased to say i wont tax you hardly anything and your lives will be so much better", give me a break!
BritishWarLord 3 years ago 2
Professional video, I didn't know all this.
Even so I like being British (and English). I spent 5 fantastic years in Wales, I love the Welsh and don't want a divorce! I know less about Scotland, but they seem to have contributed a lot to this land of ours over the centuries. Whatever the accountants think I feel we're better off together.
And whatever happens we all going to be neighbours - FOREVER! So remember: we need to get on.
3ballard 3 years ago
if all the states of the union seperated all would suffer..england would just be a 3rd rate power
BritishWarLord 3 years ago
No, because england is 85% of the population of the UK. And more importantly, it would keep all the nukes.
maureenOWW 3 years ago
And? Well you wouldnt be able to faslane then could you?
BritishWarLord 3 years ago
I'm not english or even british, so my personal opinion is neither way.
However, scotland will go from being a world-leading power to a 3rd-rate european satellite with no voting power in the EU and no say in international politics. That's a fact.
maureenOWW 3 years ago
If England went on their own, then I would expect all overseas territories to be split between the Welsh,Scottish and why not the N.Irish too? Perhaps we would need to consider dividing the Falklands evenly, we fought for it too! Perhaps I would want the Welsh border to be revised back to her orignal territories. Perhaps we would charge you alot more for your water usage as Wales provide a hell of alot of water for England?
BritishWarLord 3 years ago 3
Im, Pro-Union, im not going to try to persuade you to change your mind, thats not my intention, but you have to consider the consequences.
BritishWarLord 3 years ago
highest per capita funding list is as follows
london
Northern Ireland
Scotland
so Scotland gets less than london.
Scotland gets out LESS than it puts in to to the union. this is FACT, Scotland is a NET CONTRIBUTOR!
You video is a load of nonsense.
our budget is 33Bn and we put in a damned site more. i think britishwatcher(a unionist of big mouth proportions) put Scotland contribution at £50 Bn. so tell me, how is it that Scotland subsidises?
oh! and btw brown is a BRIT of Scottish origin.
pax681 3 years ago 3
You are in a minority of one old son.
Media, politicians, economists and even your own commentators are recognising that Sctotland is living off it's neighbours.
Banking?
If there was no money going north (Brown of The Scottish Claim of Right) would have you out of the Union faster than you could blink. If Scotland were sending cash south, the 'Claim of Righters' at Westminster are betraying their oath. Some chance of that. You spout the same old bullshit as your history writers.
TheHead9999 3 years ago
ROFL!!!!!
man you are a total fantasist!
those figures are from the Westminsters own accounts!
you are blatantly ignorant and anti Scottish , just look at your totally idiotic fantasy videos! you are a genuinely petty propagandist. you might we well work for the british state with he quality of nonsense there. you should realise that it's a GOOD THING to let Scotland go rather that just talk unqualified utter nonsense about it! you would learn a lot from Billy Brag , a real English patriot
pax681 3 years ago 2
RODFL.. i think you will find that with an SNP govt i am hardly in a minority of one at all.
also go to bbc iplayer and then go to Scotland and look for a program called Diomhair. fear not it has subtitles so you can understand.
this program will show you the dirty tricks lies and deceit by westminster and the truth about Scotland not being a drain on the so called UK.
you my man are in a minority of one and live in cloud cuckoo land
pax681 3 years ago
What about the MoD contracts subsidies, which are heavily biased in the SE of England. What about the £10bn subsidy for the London Olympics; or the £15bn subsidy for London Crossrail; or the other £15bn subsidy that was for the Channel Tunnel Rail Link?
I'm just sorry that the most recent government figures on expenditure and revenue in Scotland don't back any of your fallacious assertions up, I'm afraid.
globaltraveller 3 years ago
Why don't you watch the vid? Those billions you speak of come from England, so how can they be subsidies? Scots contribute nothing you simply get your 10% grant from Britain.
You have just highlighted £4 billion that we English will have to give you for the simple reason that we have spent English money in England. Tell me about Scotlands' subsidies to England. RBS, HBOS, Brown's hundreds of billions pound bail out without even a 'by your leave' to us English. Just go! Please!!
TheHead9999 3 years ago
Whilst you rant about unfair distribution of wealth, how do you respond to the fact that all exported Scotch Whisky leaves these shores from Liverpool in order to count as an English export, not Scots, to further reduce Scotland's percentage allocation from Westminster?
Monster1910 3 years ago 2
Maybe it helps hide the fact that you are doing well and don't need subsidising. I would say that it helps to justify the subsidy rather than reduce it. Why don't you ask Brown, Darling, Reid, Martin etc they run the country and as they have signed the Scottish Claim of Right to look after Scotland before all others I would guess that it is in the interests of Scotland.
TheHead9999 3 years ago
Per year. Thus does not include Scottish tax. Scotland has proven to be a worth while investment. Our country is stabilized, we sustain ourselves, we have a dominant Government, over 50% of Scottish student's go onto University once completed secondary school which results in the majority of Scots landing themselves in wealthy, profession careers.
It's not out fault that your country is a Muslim infested shit hole which around 48% of your population unemployed, find someone else to blame!
chadstur1991 3 years ago
Blair, Darling, Brown, Reid, Falconer. Irving, Alistair Campbell, Steel, Kennedy, Rifkind, Menzies Campbell, Browne, Cooper, Martin, Davidson,Devine, Duncan Smith, Cooke, Dewar, Fitzpatrick, These are the effluent that turned England into what you describe. It does not stop at Muslims, does it? There are 2 million others that we could do without. How long do you think that the shithole can be contained south of the border once we have paid to turn Scot into such a desirable haven?
TheHead9999 3 years ago
You are a narrow minded, idiotic typical English man!
You seem to have forgotten Scotland's multi million pound oil, gas and energy industry. Scotland contributes approximately £52 Billion pounds per year through the oil and gas industry alone which is more than anything England contributes. We also contribute £30 Billion pounds through the energy industry.
Scotland is one of the most visited countries in the World by tourists from all over the World in which we rake in over £50 Billion
chadstur1991 3 years ago 2
fuck england. freedom for ireland scotland and wales
LorcanDMeath 3 years ago
It's forensic, it's depressing, it's a bloody disgrace....
500 odd traitorous dogs who shamelessly prostitute themselves for the expediency of a cushy job, a gold plated pension and a guaranteed post on a few quangos once they have filled their boots with English taxpayers' cash.
AlfredtheOK 3 years ago
Brilliant - 5 stars.
I am absolutely sick of the way the Union treats England.
I was born British and once I was proud of that. Now I am English and only English.
It's about time the English Democrats dropped their unionist angle and came out for independence.
Home rule for England.
Wyrdtimes 3 years ago
One step at a time WT...our day will come.
EnglishCult 3 years ago
Time for that step imo.
Wyrdtimes 3 years ago
once again great work exposing another truth
behind why the ruling Cartel of celts & self serving, 'Anti English', english traitors are hell bent on promoting their view of 'Britishness' as a union of nations & regions and denying the rights and even the very existance of England and the English as a nation and people. The wider the exposure this type of information receives the greater the support for an independent England will become.
The20words 3 years ago
well said, it's our fault we let them get away with it.
no1ancientbriton 3 years ago